there but that decision, we certainly welcome him to join us if you are so inclined. a lot of folks ask is manchin going to become a republican? i hope it does. i have asked him to. a lot of questions and a lot to talk about. manchin has not indicated if he would join the gop. dc fun. thank you very much. there is this notion on the left that if you beat, chain, cancel people into submission they will do what you want them to do but look at what joe manchin did over the last 48 hours and you look at what people have been doing in society in general over the course of the last year, fighting back against this cancel culture notion, you see it happening more and more, that s a great sign going forward, joe manchin will not be been into submission and when you look at what the american people ultimately once joe