Indices were down 2 . Right now the dow is down. 9 . Before some tech earnings, the nasdaq up a quarter percent. A lot of movement in oil. We will be speaking to paul sankey about that. The 10year yield down to 55 basis points. Just to show you that it is Consumer Companies like procter and gamble that are helping the market recover a little bit today, that index up 1. 9 . People cannot do without their necessities, as long as they have the money to buy them. U. S. Economic data showing gdp shrinking at a record pace. 17plus million americans applying for ongoing benefits, which necessitates the need for more to be done. Lets bring in narayana kocherlakota, former president of the minneapolis fed. He joins us from rochester, new york. Talk about the dire Economic Data this morning and what it tells you about whether even the minimal reopening that we are doing is helping the markets more broadly. Narayana thank you for having me on. The numbers were certainly eyeopening. 10 fall transl