Sitting. Be seated, please. Case number 195331 committee on the judiciary of the United States house of representatives versus Donald F Mcgahn 2nd appellate. And at the appellate. Good morning. Good morning, your honor. May it please the court. The House Judiciary Committee seeks to assert an implied cause of action to enforce the subpoena to compel mr. Mcgahn to testify regarding his duties as white House Counsel over the objection of the president of the United States. This interbridge dispute over institutional prerogatives bears no resemblance to be controversies under article 3 and moreover, while congress has purported to authorize senate commutes to enforce certain subpoenas against nonfederal officials, congress itself has expressly carved out the authority of the senate to enforce subpoenas against federal executive officials asserting executive prerogative objections and what gives the senate statute. How does that help us think about the constitutional issue and stability is
Investigation. All persons having business before the Honorable United States Court of appeals for the District Of Columbia circuit. Draw near and give their attention so the court is now sitting. Be seated, please. Case number 195331 committee on the judiciary of the United States house of representatives versus Donald F Mcgahn 2nd appellate. Good morning, your honor. May it please the court. The House Judiciary Committee seeks to assert an implied cause of action to enforce the subpoena to compel mr. Mcgahn to testify regarding his duties as white House Counsel over the objection of the president of the United States. This interbridge dispute over institutional prerogatives bears no resemblance to be controversies under article 3 and moreover, while congress has purported to authorize senate commutes to enforce certain subpoenas against nonfederal officials, congress itself has expressly carved out the authority of the senate to enforce subpoenas against federal executive officials a
Note a quorum is present. We we will hear testimony from e department of education implementation of borrowed eventual. Pursuant to commingle 7c statements are limited to the chair and Ranking Member. I want to thank secretary devos of being with us today and thank her for a green to hold enough time in the schedule all of the members present to have amendments confinements of questions pursuant to house rules. Especially thankful because this cheer im exercise my prerogative to go last in question order so it she were to leave early i wouldnt get to ask questions. I want to thank you for agreeing to stay with us for the fulltime. I recognize myself enough for the purpose of making an opening statement. We are here to examine the department of educations implementation of the borrower defense rule. I want to thank you, madam secretary, for appearing before the committee to discuss this important issue. Borrower defense is a rule grounded in basic fairness. Student borrowers who are def
And his very presidency e. President trump today contending with the preposterous Speaker Pelosi who headlong rushes to the wrong side of history seeking still to overthrow this historic president who maddens already deranged dems who know hes unbeatable at the polls in november, and they have the little left with which to flog their better. The hapless dems are still demanding the Supreme Court consider his fight over the radical lefts attempts to subpoena his financial records, his taxes. The speaker and her callow cohorts in the house still hell bent on frustrating the will of the people. The facts and the constitution give us no choice but to move forward with impeachment of the president. [inaudible] i dont hate anybody. I pray for the president all the time, so dont mess with me when it comes to words like that. Lou dont mess with her. Well, President Trump also returning to take on the chinese communists and their hefty helpers on wall street, contending with american billionair
And his very presidency e. President trump today contending with the preposterous Speaker Pelosi who headlong rushes to the wrong side of history seeking still to overthrow this historic president who maddens already deranged dems who know hes unbeatable at the polls in november, and they have the little left with which to flog their better. The hapless dems are still demanding the Supreme Court consider his fight over the radical lefts attempts to subpoena his financial records, his taxes. The speaker and her callow cohorts in the house still hell bent on frustrating the will of the people. The facts and the constitution give us no choice but to move forward with impeachment of the president. [inaudible] i dont hate anybody. I pray for the president all the time, so dont mess with me when it comes to words like that. Lou dont mess with her. Well, President Trump also returning to take on the chinese communists and their hefty helpers on wall street, contending with american billionair