Jurors had to consider in their verdict was whether Pretty On Top killed Chaney under mitigating circumstances, specifically while under extreme duress.
U.S. Marshals vehicles pinned the SUV that Dovel was driving in place, but Dovel allegedly tried to escape by ramming the federal cruisers several times.
Drew Kinnin was working at a youth home operated by the non-profit Youth Dynamics at the time of the allegations, which were reported by other staff members at the residence.