now on how russia responds and if they co-wrote choose to cooperate with the u.k. and ask all across that they sanctions that you mentioned before clinton and the muckle not so long ago i was seeking to have those left at from russia but we did have from the defense minister on the lion just yesterday she said that there would be consequences that russia would have to deal with if they refused to cooperate and so it was this there is a lot of pressure on germany right now to take this responsibility as it s growing role in europe a lot of pressure on all these leaders of the moment thank you all these only sure when in moscow clinton peel from chatham house with us here in the studio and of course kate bret your political correspondent thanks thank you all in a must say stick around we re going to be talking a little more about chancellor merkel s visit to paris because today under michael is heading to france for talks with president amount of well calling the two