Examples of people he wrongly convicted for murder spending 18 years in prison, 18 years and 20,000 for payment a year as a result. They spend other than their arraignment hour or two no time in jail, no time in prison and they got 20 million. Several life events to tell you about tomorrow. In 2004 utah voters passed an amendment to the states constitution recognizing marriage as only between a man and a woman effectively banning samesex marriages. Last december the eighth federal judge ruled it unconstitutional. The tenth Circuit Court of appeals took up the cake case last week when many around the country challenging samesex marriage bans. This is a little more than an hour. We are here this morning for one case, her team 41. Council you may proceed. Good morning. Im gene cher and im honored to appear on behalf of the state of utah as governor attorney general here with us today and its people and just for the courts information on going to try to reserve seven minutes for rebuttal.