judge arthur schwab. it s federal judge in pittsburgh. had an ordinary routine deportation case before him. he said i don t want to be deported even though i pleaded guilty to entering the country illegally, under the president s new rules and because i fathered a child and my child is an american citizen, i can stay. that forced this federal judge to review the constitutionality of the president s new rules and he ruled in a lengthy detailed and well-reasoned opinion that the president cannot rewrite federal immigration through which is effectively what he did. bill: does his decision hold much weight? it depend what happens. if the government appeals it to the third circuit court of appeals and loses it will cascade against the president. bill: the number of executive