and that simply has to be recognized now as a mainstream threat into this republican party. this entire conversation is core at understanding 2024 as i was also reminded earlier this was part of the court reason that president biden decided to commit himself to a presidential run the last time around. what happened in charlottesville this burgeoning of white supremacy that we have seen in this country so there is that piece i m also intrigued though by the dynamic juanita that you have republicans in disarray and you are seeing democrats are very much leaning to coalesce around biden the fact you have gavin newsom declaring yet again that he does not plan to run against president biden i wonder if you think that dynamic sticks? absolutely it sticks. consider the proposition in 20 21st 2022 midterms. on 2020, biden ran on a