two tantalizing clues, a handprint. the subject had blood on their hand. and a trail on twitter. incredibly powerful. you can almost see this happening in realtime. could she help solve her own mystery? she s fighting him off. it was so emotional. i wanted to jump out of my seat. never in a million years would you expect something like that. on long island, about 10 miles down the shoreline from the mansions, the fancy cars and the elites of the hamptons, is a blue collar beach town some call the poor man s paradise. but life was rich for these brothers and sisters in mastic, new york, filled with the love of a large tight-knit family. all that was taken away one warm evening when evil rolled in with the summer tide. their youngest sister was missing. we just want you to come home safely. reporter: and for better or worse, this family would go to extraordinary lengths to find her. we re going to scour those woods right now. we were our own investigators.
jason flores and was part of the group sarah was hanging out with that friday night. his name wasn t familiar to her, but alluara s boyfriend had heard of him. my boyfriend was like, oh, i think that s the kid up the block. so that s when we realized that that was the neighbor. did your boyfriend s family want to keep an eye on dante? i guess we were looking out for him. looking out for everyone, you know. it s just like, when you re in a situation like that, every little thing that happens, you re paying extra attention to at this point. her boyfriend s mother, dehlia mckernan, heard about sarah s connection to dante, so she decided to pay extra attention to him. he lived with his mom, a few houses away. what kind of things were you seeing? anything suspicious? you know, at the time, i wouldn t know if it was suspicious. like when she says she thought she saw dante cleaning out his car.
were you getting when you woul call last we seen her was at th party. that s about it. nobod knew anything. as allaura scrolled through sarah s call log, there was on number that caught her attention. it was a number that kept reoccurring. so we wanted to figure out who it was, you know. so we called and then who answered? dante. just the sam response as everyone else. i don t know where she is. haven t seen her dante taylor was a friend o jason flores and was part of the group sarah was hanging ou with that friday night. hi name wasn t familiar to her, but alluara s boyfriend ha heard of him my boyfriend was like, oh, i think that s the kid up th block. so that s when w realized that that was the neighbor did your boyfriend s family want to keep an eye on dante i guess we were looking out for him. looking out for everyone, you know. it s jus like, when you re in a situation like that, every little thing that happens, you re paying extra attentio to at this poin
don t know where she is. haven t seen her. dante taylor was a friend of jason flores and was part of the group sarah was hanging out with that friday night. his name wasn t familiar to her, but alluara s boyfriend had heard of him. my boyfriend was like, oh, i think that s the kid up the block. so that s when we realized that that was the neighbor. did your boyfriend s family want to keep an eye on dante? i guess we were looking out for him. looking out for everyone, you know. it s just like, when you re in a situation like that, every
dante taylor was a friend of jason flores and was part of the group sarah was hanging out with that friday night. his name wasn t familiar to her, but alluara s boyfriend had heard of him. my boyfriend was like, oh, i think that s the kid up the block. so that s when we realized that that was the neighbor. did your boyfriend s family want to keep an eye on dante? i guess we were looking out for him. looking out for everyone, you know. it s just like, when you re in a situation like that, every little thing that happens, you re paying extra attention to at this point. her boyfriend s mother, dehlia mckernan, heard about sarah s connection to dante, so she decided to pay extra attention to him. he lived with his mom, a few houses away. what kind of things were you seeing? anything suspicious? you know, at the time, i wouldn t know if it was suspicious. like when she says she thought she saw dante cleaning out his car. yeah, on two different occasions i noticed that he