Allegiance of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Commissioner president loftus id like to call roll at this time. Commissioner president loftus commissioner Vice President turman commissioner marshall commissioner dejesus commissioner mazzuco commissioner hwang commissioner melara commissioner president loftus we have quorum also with us is deputy chief for intern chief tony chance lane good evening and welcome to the Police Commission. Item one discussion one a chiefs report to allow the chief of police to report on Police Activities and make announcements. Good evening and welcome. Good evening commissioner president loftus and director hicks on behalf of tony chaplain hes in washington, d. C. With offense Joanne Walker awarded by the attorney general a police award a good reason not to be here commissioners this thing weekend youve heard in the news San Francisco experiences a pike in gun violence which resulted in multiple homicides ill roughly summarize those on thursday the 29 there was a shooting multiple victims on ellis one of the victims died the gunshot wounds and the second homicide the following day in the tenderloin on elvis no arrests were made that was a homicide with a gun the third homicide occurred other than esl worth in the ingleside approximately 15 in the evening the fourth homicide occurred on bird street in the ingleside that was a homicide with a gun that was approximately 4 00 p. M. In the afternoon and on sunday another homicide on 4446th street in the southern that was a homicide with a gun no arrests and on sunday again, a homicide with a sharp object on california street an arrest warrant was made in that case we also reported a homicide in weekend that occurred in june was in the hospital and unfortunately didnt survive the george bush wounds an arrest warrant was made in this case there were 10 shootings around the city from the Police Department investigated the task force go unit station investigation there investigating those crimes to determine if their gangrelated and were utilizing the Central Station to saturate the areas to preventive future violence moving on we have additional staff id like to make the commission aware of our homicides are up 3 percent compared to 2017 our shootings with up 5 percent so except this weekend overall our Violent Crime is down 14 percent and burglaries are down im sorry were down Violent Crime. 14 percent and robberies down chief do you have the raw numbers of date from 20152016. 40 2014 by xash envelope 52 at this time and the low was 201428 at this time. I get it thank you. Move on to events a lot of events coming up this weekend in the city we have fleet week be events that start on friday the 7 and create shifts multiple military events throughout the city including the blue angels on saturday and sunday a dream force held throughout the weekend and on sunday the italian heritage parade also and that concludes my report. All right. Any questions for the chief colleagues commissioner hwang an interest any trend or explanation for the increase in gun violence. Thats one of the things were trying to determine if their gang or drug relayed what type of forum that they involve in one of them was a night club were there were rival gangs were trying to determine. Other questions okay. Thank you deputy chief thank you for sitting in. Item b occ directors report to report on recent occ. Good evening director joyce hicks. Deputy chief and members of the public last week members of the office of citizens complaints staff and i attended the oversight of Law Enforcement annual training conference in mexico the scene was confronting systematic injustice from President Obama Task force policing was front and center and a as an example a police chief indicated the Task Force Report was for reading for his police force the task force implementations guide materials the Conference Panel included the civilian oversight and you Law Enforcement and several pooechz and activists some Key Takeaways were with the Body Worn Camera and the Data Collection and analysis and of us by creating time distance and proportionality. That sounds familiar. Yes. Indeed and the policing next year conference september 10th through 14 next year ill be happy to propose a panel for next years conferee in San Francisco story and implementing change it come in next week and will present the statistic report president s report. Thank you director joyce hicks thank you for that report thats a great why do to have San Francisco present next year and inspector, next item. Item one c Commission Report commissioners president and commissioners report. The only thing i have to report colleagues, i did send a letter to the representatives of the Blue Ribbon Panel an accountability in Law Enforcement they 36 there was a hearing before the board of supervisors regarding the implementation of those recommendations my letter indicated what we indicated before were grateful for the amount of time and certainly all the volunteer hours well have Successful Partnership with the use of force sub group and to the remaining recommendations those are not just going on shelf those have been passed on the United States department of defense and other civil grudging reports the president and the ocii recommendations they made as you all know colleagues from the meeting he missed i reviewed the presentations they indicated all the reports are in a magical and once the doj report is final the department will present a Strategic Plan aon the next steps implementation is critical and not done in a peace meals fashion and thank you. The Blue Ribbon Panel and others for the work weve passed that on i understand i was not present but understand the board was ongoing engage on the standoffs of those recommendations on a future date and seller move forward well engage with them and let them this the process other reports colleagues. Okay. No all right. Inspector, next item. Item one d commissions announcements and consideration for future meetings action. With an item id like to schedule sergeant for us to have Joanne Walker to give her a Police Accommodation one in washington we should know about that and give our own accommodation schedule that to make sure of the policing work shes been doing thats one thing to add commissioner dejesus. Id like to add a presentation from the homicide detail go to a scene how they process and the scene and question the secretary but what do they do to secure. What are the protocol between the departments and the da and the medical examiners officer their scheduled in the District Attorneys Office are they responsible and who is responsible inform remove the body from the scene and other questions we have a list of questions id like to give it to you and have a presentation on that. Okay anything else colleagues. Commissioner president loftus this microphone didnt work for me anyway, im still hoping to discuss a safe place at some point you know obviously were going to agendize all the priorities and hope we can add. Thats on our ongoing list. Commissioner mazzuco i know we checked on it i noticed the Mayors Office announced we are were in partnering with the Health Crisis and hopefully can get to a point we have a 60 percent of calls for our officers are for people in crisis if we can followup hopefully the goal to have Mental Health folks to follow up and appropriated what they deal with address that issue next month that will be appreciated. Yeah. We should add that and this commission need to have a presentation to flag that in february especially the ois there is a Public HealthDepartment Response and partnering with the department of health well schedule that thank you commissioner mazzuco and i neglected to do one of the things i need to do on any report that is fantastic news i get to introduce ron in a in the back you if you can wave if youre one of the people that follow the work you can weve tried to get independent resources directly for this commissioner mazzuco has indicated a need and we were successful have a core fellow we want to share and her goal toe accelerate the reform so the policing practices we continue to restore public trust prior a unit at price water house and consolidated International Government agencies executive and holds a masters in Foreign Service from george town and from the university of wales will be doing outreach to both commissioners and members of the Police Department and members of the public to help us and the large amount of policy work a number of issues flagged around giving us more resources 0 welcome and thank you very much. We have her for a year we promise to use your time well. inaudible . I hired or heard this is tough inspector, next item. No for members of the public to make the announcement that our next meeting a wednesday october 12th in room 4 hundred at 5 30 the next item it Public Comment oh, exemplary is there any Public Comment on item one a through d. Yes. At this time well take Public Comment on items one a through d hearing none, inspector, next item. Item two Public Comment public is welcome to address the commission on items not on tonights agenda but within the jurisdiction of the commission. The commission as a whole and not to individual commissioners or departments or occi personnel. Department, occi or commissioners are to respond to questions but may provide a brief response. The commissioners, occi, nor the Police Commission should enter into debates and please limit your comments to 3 minutes, please. Two minutes. Thank you. Good evening and. Good evening and welcome. Good evening, commissioners the camera people can put that up if you could get the whole thing ill appreciate ill pass this out to you guys from the camera buy can get the whole thing on the screen if that is possible. Thats fine. Sure. Go ahead. So i came here to address you about the board of supervisors hearing yesterday it was a very interesting hearing and i made comments and the document ill be passing out to you guys one of the things that came up the board of supervisors may request or ask the commission to come and speak before them there was no representatives of the commission yesterday at the hearing on the Blue Ribbon Panel which i think that something that somebody really should have been there i understand that commissioner president loftus was not there but none of you there i think was a huge omission im hoping that you guys will weigh in on the Blue Ribbon Panel and i think there is going to be some followup on it im sure followup and hope you guys are engaged but i really want to talk about the Sunshine Task force hearing that will be happening in a month your clerk sergeant killshaw as you probably know was there earlier at the 4 oclock and the matter was continued for a month because it will go on the full agenda of the sunshine that task force the complaint by Magic Johnson is that the use of force policy was not properly noticed as far as the documents and you know thats a serious charge and well pursue also with regards to the use of force i know you guys will go dark well not find out what goes on the use of force is not impacted the intern chief passed out a memo that was not sufficient as far as the 80 percent of the use of force policy being active i want to put you on notice and pass 24 this to the commissioners, thank you. Good evening clyde and welcome. Commissioners oneill and commissioner bratton the lowest homicide in new york i saw the numbers unbelievable but back to San Francisco okay. The Blue Ribbon Commission hey he was here when chief of Police George gascon the the elephant in the room is the poa thats the elephant in the room people the poa a resisting change we know that detailing it come on people the poa didnt want to change they dont want it ive fought with them for days honestly the poa can make the changes Going Forward chief chaplin good guy one of the best but without the poas changing nothing will happen can you control the poa probably not probably not probably not but we have to make some changes and that poa will come along well say h see the use of force and all the issues before the city that poa will join the party at the resist which was they hate George Gascon i had a poa member told me hes nothing thats environmental thats environmental thats the attitude of that Police Officers association thank you. Next speaker good evening and welcome. Back. Welcome back yourself tom gilberty it is bad leaving the meeting all the Police Officers left they should have been finishing out the issue there ought to be a law against meetings during a playoff games a racism that exists tony chaplain knows more than i will every and yet there are departments across the country black pooechz are shooting people black people so i believe there is a training issue here that more important especially the position where the officers have their gun out and their Public Health it and wheres the deesclation we need not to pull that gun out before it was 40 percent our mentally challenged and now 60s percent mentally challenged people that are walking in the street when traffic is not going to be responsive to any logical sense the Training Needs to be challenged the video is not going to work were going to sekwefrt and let someone one twentyfour hour of the officers seeing the video should go to public i know were holding up on something but not going to work across the country were seeing videos and the public needs to see the videos that will be i think a major realty check for the department and the trust of society again, thank you. While ms. Brown im reminded shaukt consider the changes have been presented to this commission during a power point weve added tabs to the website so people can have that assessable and adding training and all the things the changes youve spoken to some of them completes followup. Good evening and welcome. Theres not a lot of people the length of the agenda is one of the factors ms. Brown. Well, i want to bring up the fact that you guys were talking about the homicides that are happening i dont know from the form of racism or this they call the homicide their Gang Violence you know you know and he remember getting a call concerning any son was my son in a gang but it was two phones his girlfriends phone the naming of that that our childrens are in gangs or possible gaping violence is point of privilege that words needs to change i dont know how but that needs to change a stigma on people of color i want to say that but im here concerning my son Aubrey Abrakasa murdered august 14, 2006 and im still waiting for justice on my child and i come with the same thing all the time that is something ill continue to have to do until justice paralyze and happens for any child i bring this up that again gavin newsom former gavin newsom said he knows the police know who killed my son they have names they can name addresses of perpetrators that killed any son when my son was murdered i was down at homicide and got those names and those are the names that are thomas han building and perris moving at the time and james and anthony these guys are walking the streets except one is deceased we have a new investigator but are they looking 9 perpetrators that killed my son what is being done i got a phone call but not wanting to hear the same thing oh, ms. Brown were trying oh, ms. Brown thank you ms. Brown. If you or anyone you know has information to the murder of Aubrey Abrakasa there is an anonymous tipline 415 5754444 and if you have any questions ms. Brown about this specification of that investigation ive asked someone from the department to make sure your questions are getting answered. Its the same thing. I want to make sure their following up with you and someone in the department can do that, please deputy chief any further Public Comment . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. Inspector, next item. Item 3 Public Comment on all matters pertaining to closed session including Public Comment only to vote whether to hold item 5 in closed session. Any Public Comment on whether to hold item 5 in closed session and the society votes hearing none, Public Comment is closed. Inspector, next item. Item 4 vote on whether to hold item 5 in closed session did code action. Do i have a motion to hold item 5 in closed session. All in favor, say i. I. Opposed . That item passes were in closed session thank you ladies and gentlemen, commissioner president loftus were back on record in open session and vote to disclose any or all items administrative code action do i have a motion not to disclose. Any Public Comment on that. All in favor, say i. I. Opposed . That item passes inspector, next item. Adjournment action. All in favor, say i. I. Were adjourned thank you ladies and gentlemen, [ gavel ] good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the regular meeting of the San FranciscoEthics Commission for september 26, 2016. Before i turn to the agenda, i want to take the pleasure of introducing our newest commissioner, a man who i think is known to many of us in San Francisco who has lived here for a long time. The man who has devoted his life to public