Transcripts For SFGTV Entertainment Commission 20240707

i worked on the it for 16+ years and i workeded an endless cycle of people going to the emergency room. i wanted to address those unmet needs. i have a satisfaction when we make a real difference in our clients' lives. we were getting people housed, connecting them to treatment, and seeing them through sobriety. don't be afraid of failure. i have failed at things in my career and they are opportunities to continue on. it's important for women and women and people of color to see representation matters. when i first started my career 25 years ago, there were not that many other women. so it is amazing to respond to meetings and go to meetings and see other female leaders and learn from each other. this career is my dream job from working on [ indiscernible ] to being the chief and overseeing a division. it's been challenging and rewarding and inspiring. >> good afternoon and welcome to the july 12, 2022 regular boarded meeting of the san francisco board of supervisors. madam clerk call the roll. >> thank you, mr. president. supervisor chan. >> present. >> supervisor dorsey. >> present. >> supervisor mandelman. >> present. >> supervisor mar. >> not present. >> supervisor melgar. >> present. >> supervisor peskin. >> present. >> supervisor precinct. >> present. >> supervisor ronen. >> present. >> supervisor safai. >> present >> stefani. >> present. >> walton, present. >> mr. president you have a quorum all members are present. >> thank you. the san francisco board of supervisors acknowledge we are on then cest ral home land. ramaytush ohlone who are the original inhabitants of the san francisco peninsula. as the stursd of this land, and in accordance with traditions, the ramaytush ohlone have never seed, lost nor forgotten their responsibilities as care takers of this place. as well as for all peoples who reside in there territory. as guests, we recognize that we benefit from living and working on their traditional home land. we wish to pay respects acknowledging the elders and relatives of the recommend ram community and by affirming their rights as first peoples. colleagues, please stand for the pledge of. [pledge of allegiance] on behalf of the board of supervisor i would like on acknowledge the staff of sfgovtv we have calistena mendoza and janet who record each of our meetings and make the transcripts available to the public online. madam clerk. go to our 2 p.m. special yard mayoral appearance. >> special order 2 p.m. is the appearance today's meeting bite honorable mayor london breed to engage in a policy discussion with board members prior, the mayor may address the board for up to 5 minutes. >> thank you we have the mayor online. madam mayor, do you have remarks? >> thank you, president walton and good afternoon as we continue our road to recovery a component is ensuring san francisco am feel safe going to school. open businesses and move about without fear. this is not just an issue for the present addressing public safety concerns is essential for the future of our city. ensuring streeters safe is critical to the recovery of our tourism industry. people want to come to san francisco from all over the world to enjoy the sites and scenes that make our city so special. when we have high rates of property damage. open air drug dealing, gun violence, people leave with a different picture of the city we all know and love. i want to thank members of the budget and appropriation's committee especially our chair of that committee hilary ronen for working through funding departments and initiatives. after speaking with community leaders, business owners and every day people in san francisco it is clear the majority of residents want accountament for those who commit crimes and justice reform efforts. we can absolutely do both. last week we welcomed our new da to the team of people who were ensure our communities across san francisco are safe. enforce policies to hold account okay those violating the law and work with long-term sustained justice refurthermore efforts look like. i said last week brook has experience as a prosecutor with sex crimes and homicides the inequity is not theoretical it is her livid experience like mine. and addressing that inequity we dedication to victims and commitment to justice is why she does this work. that's why i appointed her to serve as our da and look forward to working with you to make sure our da and other public safety agencyers set up for success and delivering on the key nieced of our city. which has to be safety first. thank you for the opportunity to share with you today. >> thank you, mayor. and madam clerk do we have topics submitted for today? >> no mr. president, we do not. >> thank you, and madam mayor we appreciate you this concludes or 2 p.m. special order. thank you for joining us today. >> thank you >> do we have communications >> yes, mr. president the board of supervisors away the general public to the board's chamber in room 250 to listen or to advise the board with testimony or public comments. when your item is call third degree is airing live on channel 26 or live stream at sfgov.org alternateively you may participate remotely utilizing the remote call in system. best practices are to enable the board to hear you clearly you will call prosecute a quiet location, you make sure your television or radio is turned down the board am priority hearing from those currently in the chamber and then they will turn to the remote call in system. note, once remote call in system the queue has been exhausted tell not be reopened a second time. throughout the meeting the phone number is streaming it is 415-655-0001. when you hear the system prompt enter the id24832806900. and then press pound twice. you have joined because you will heart discussion but your line will be muted. once you are ready to put yourself in the queue, that is when you should press star 3. and you will listen for the prompt that you have been unmuted and begin speaking your comments. i will tell you a bit about the agenda content that is eligible for your testimony today. it includes there are 2, 3 p.m. special orders item 45 is the public hearing for finings and recommendations regarding law enforcement practice. you note if you are looking at the agenda well is a note that the president may entertain a motion to continue this hearing to the board meeting ever september 20th, 22. public comment today will be taken on the continuance. at the september 20th rescheduled public hearing. you may speak to the merits of the progress made of the findings and recommendations for that public hearing. there items 46 and 47. another public hearing expected to be held today. this is for the order of the street vacation and the interdepartmental department transfer for 9 huh human enis avenue park development and puc easement vacation order for india basin the mixed use project on 7 huh human 700 enis off. item 52 you may speak to the mayor's appearance. approval of the board minutes the president will review in a moment. you may speak to items 53-57 the items the back of the agenda for consideration without calendar as general matters that are not on today's agenda but went board's jurisdiction. all other content will have had a proper hearing and had been reported out to the board by an appropriate committee the public comment requirement had been full filled. you may community by sending written comments use the address 1 carlton b. goodlet place. or sends an e mail using the bos @sfgov.org. with office of civic engagement andim grant affairs we'll have interpreters at 3 p.m. i will invite them to intruns themselves then if you mean are experiencing trouble accessing this meeting remote or have general questions, the clerk's office in room 244 we have a live person for walk ins or assist if you are using the phone. that concludes my communication, mr. president. >> thank you madam clerk and colleagues before we get started, remember to mute your microphones when you are not speak. we are now at an approval of meeting minutes. today we are approving the minutes from the june 7, and june 8 appropriation's committee. instituted a quorum of the board of supervisors. >> don't see anyone on the roster for changes i will entertain a motion for approval. made by supervisor ronen and seconded by supervisor peskin. on the motion? >> on the motion to arc prove minutes as presented supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> and supervisor precinct. >> aye. >> there are 11 ayes the minutes will be approved after public comment. call items 1-3 together. >> items 1-3 comprise settlements. item 1 authorizes a settlement of 35,000 lawsuit by martin collins a personal injury from dangerous condition of public property. item 2, 860 thousand dollars settlement tessa lieu a person injury on a city sidewalk and item 3 is an authorization to settle 375 thousand dollars lawsuit by arthur higgins till and bell will plaintiff it is civil right's violated following a traffic stop. >> thank you, madam clerk. call the role. >> 1 through 3 supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. and supervisor preston. >> there are 11 aye's >> thank you without objection these are passed unanimously. madam clerk call item 4 >> item 4 is ordinance to authorize grant agreements for 20 years after project completion for the puc commission green infrastructure grant program. >> thank you, madam clerk. call the roll on item 4. >> supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye >> supervisor preston >> aye >> there are 11 ayey >> this ordinance is finally passed unanimously. >> call item 5. >> item 5 ordinance which amends the planning code to create the group housing special use district. >> thank you, madam clerk. call the roll for item 5. >> supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor steph any. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> air. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's >> without objection this is finally passed unanimously. >> call item 6. >> them amends the planning code to per mitt the hohcd mayor's office of housing and community development to collect fines and penalties violations ever planning code provisions governing affordable housing and the hohcd to use the proceeds in the afford okay housing fubldz for all planning activities relating to to affordable housing. >>. item 6, supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye >> stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor woman ogon. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> and supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's. >> without objection this is finally passed unanimously. madam clerk call item 7. jeechl an ordinance to amend the planning administrative subdivision codes issue zoning map to provide and the density exception in residential districts. and to affirm the ceqa determination and findings. >> thank you, so much. madam clerk. can you call the roll on item 7. >> supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> no. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> no. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 9 aye's and 2 nos supervisors safai and dorsey in the decent. >> thank you, madam clerk. this ordinance passes but go ahead move to resin the vote. >> second. >> thank you, it has been a motion to reas i understand the vote by stefan and he safai. fa madam clerk on the motion. >> mr. president can you do that without objection. >> thank you. and the vote is rescinded and we will call for the roll. >> all right. on item upon 7. supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> no. >> supervisor stefani. >> no. >> walton. >> no. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> approximate supervisor dorsey. >> no. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 7 aye avenue and 4 no's with supervisors safai, stefani, walton and dorsey in decent. >> by a vote of 7-4 this ordinance passes. >> would you call item 8? >> item 8 an upon orbs to amend the business and tax revving lagzs code to permit the tax collector to make public certain information regarding vacancy tax. >> thank you, madam clerk. call the role on item 8. >> on item 8. supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's. >> thank you, without objection this is finally passed unanimously. call item 9. >> a motion to approve the president of the board of supervisors walton's nomination for the appointment of alex lackbird to the burden of appeals for the portion of a 4 year term ending july first, 2024. >> thank you, would you call the roll. supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> no. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 10 aye's and one no with supervisor stefani in decent. >> 10 to 1 this motion is approved. >> police call item 10. >> item 10 is an ordinance to approve a new 2022 transportation plan for the county transportation authority and submit to the voters at an election to be held on november 8, 2022. >> thank you, so much. supervisor mandelman. >> thank you. and a pol joes to supervisor ronen had to hear this speech about 12 times as budget chair and mfbt mtc board. but this item is an ordinance as you know this is an ordinance to place initiative on the 22 ballot renew san francisco transportation sales tax this half cent tax as prop k with 75% voter approval. prop circumstance bring in 100 million dollars a year and primary on going source of local funding for transportation planning, transit infrastructure, road repairs, street safety and paratransit service. in march the county transportation authority board we outputly approved an updated plan that will guide the next generation of transportation investment in san francisco. as with the prior plan, managed bite transportation authority in 2003 the 2022 plan would not raise the tax rate but allow for the extension of the current sales tax level upon prove by 2 thirds of san francisco voters the investments called for in this plan support agencies recovery from the pan dem and i can delivery of reliable service for ride and advance goals around street safety and vision introverto. transportation sector the leading source of green house gas irk missions in san francisco. and closing equity gaps. increases the share of sales tax dollars available for downtown cal train extension. mount and he bart projects and street safety investments and nksz funding for you paratransits service essential life line support for seniors and people with disabilities during the pandemic through the trip card program. we will also have an opportunity to leverage billions in new federal and state infrastructure funds and this spending plan sets us up to maximize those opportunity. this revenue will be the more critical following the narrow defeat of prop a in the election last mont. >> this mont or last mont. >> fortunately the measure before us stands on a solid foundationing thanks to the community members who spent over sick months the plan advisory committee that included representatives from every district, neighborhood and equity advocates and business interests. desired use funds delinquented and with ta staff and arrived a fair balance of many pressing transportation priorities. i want to thank whoefrn served especially the chair and vice chair chung for their hard work and again thank mariah lombardo and executive director chang of the ta for guiding that process. following our action in march the plan was approved in april bite mtc. thank you surprise ronen andom june 29 this was recommended by the budget and finance committee, thank you budget chair ronen. and so -- here we are colleagues i want to thank you for your cosponsor should. i hope we can approve today and stay on track for the november election and we will need all of your help to get this overnight finish line. so. thanks, everyone. >> thank you, so much. supervisor mandelman. no one else on the roster can we get a roll call for item 10. supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> and supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 ayes. this is pass the unanimously. of madam clerk please call items 11 and-28 together. >> yes. 11 is the budget and appropriation ordinance to appropriate all estimated receipts and expenditures for departments of the city as of june first of 22 and the fiscal yearsening june 30, 23 and 24. item 12 the salary ordinance the positions in the budget and appropriation ordinance. for the fiscal years june 30 of 23 and june 30 of 24. item 13, the office of community investment and infrastructure operating as the successor agency to the san francisco redevelopment budget 2-23 and upon issuance not to exceed 99.700 million. the police code to update the fix the place out door amplified permit sound filing fee. and license fee. to current amounts. item 12 is the ordinance to amend the administrative code to authorize the chief of the fire chief to appoint 3 rart than 2 deputy chiefs one of the an emergency medical services or paramedicine member of the department. 16 amends the code to increase the surcharge on vehicles registered to a san francisco address in accordance with california state law. 17, amends the code to increase the fees imposed by the department of @administrative service notary services provide to public. 18, ordinance adopts the beautification and graffiti clean up fund tax designation seating for year twoochl ordinance to authorize the execution and delivery of certificates of participation evidencing and representing an amount not to exceed 140 million to finance capitol improve am projects. 20 issue ordinance to amend the business and tax regulation code to update emergency medical service fees to reflect amounts authorized under adjustments and require fees for stroke centers and amending the health code to include definition of stroke centers. item 21, this rescinds the 50 dollars surcharge on probate filings in san francisco superior court the city collected support the acquisition and rehab, construction and financing of courtrooms or courtroom buildings. item 22 ordinance to amend the health code to set patient rates for other service provided by the department of public health 22-24. item 23 an ordinance to amend the park code impose a surcharge and license fees for birthing at the marina west harbor to fund the cost dredging at the west harbor and affirm the ceqa determination to make the findings. item 24, a resolution to authorize the acceptance of state grant funds bite san francisco department of public hasn't for years 2020, 22-23. item 25, a retroactive resolution to authorize the human right's commission to accept and extend 11.8 million dollars grant from the state of california to support and expand youth programming under the opportunity for all initiative through may first 24. item 26, a resolution to approve the fiscal 22-24 plan for department of homelessness and spicht housing. item 27, resolution to concur with the kroerls consumer price index and adjust the access line tax by the same rate. >> item 28. resolution to concur with the controller certification that department services approved can be performed by private contractor for a lower cost than similar work programmed by city and county employees for various services. >> thank you, so much. and colleagues. pursuant to charter section 9.100 b the board of supervisors shall adopt the budget not earlier than july 15th. but not later than august first. i will entertain a motion to continue items 11-28. to our july 19th 2022 board of supervisors meeting. >> motion made by melgar and seconded by budget chair ronen >> mr. president. i believe the date is july 19th. >> correct. >> motion to continue items 11-28 to july 19th supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there were 11 aye's. >> thank you without objection the motion to continue 11-28 to our july 19th, 2022 board of supervisor's meeting is approved unanimously. >> go to our 2:30 p.m. special order. request >> the 2:30 special order is the recognition of merit service to the city and county of san francisco. president walton. >> thank you very much. colleagues, this afternoon i have the honor to honor mrs. tucker known as nurse kim on her well deserved retirement. >> mr. tucker if you could come up to the podium, please. [applause] nurse kim began nurgs in 1992 work nothing a family health care clinic in berkeley, california. filling a pool to return to her home town of san francisco, she landed a job with san francisco city and county jail health services as a staff nurse. since then, she has been able to work in various communities and special in nursing within the san francisco department of public health. including being a nurse manager at sf county jail, surgical nurse at zuckerberg and chpy at balboa high school. also her al madder and finishing in nursing at maxine hall healing center as a primary care nurse. nurse kim also lead initiatives to decrease disparities in african-american health care with the san francisco health network. some initiatives that remain close to the heart of her are the following:hypertension leadership committee. aimed helping to decrease all healing disparities among african americans. racial equity group, focusing on african-americans in the health care system specifically equity. participated with gar. government alliance on race and equity. works to advance racial equity and he increased opportunity for all communities. held the only african-american hypertension clinic in d ph primary care at maxine hall health center focused on closing the gap with patients with high blood pressure, educating and addressing their physical and social needs. >> the importance of this clinic helped address the greatest diseased plaguing the african-american community and creating better health out come. nurse kim had a clinical, hospital and community base experience in nursing and has left a legacy in the public health community with her arc mazing work and served the city through the department of public health for 26 years. taking care of patients and mentoring nurses and other health care professionals. today, we commend you for your care and for your service. congratulations and thank you. [applause] of [applause]. wow. thank you so much. so good afternoon, everyone. first i want to say thank you to the city and county of san francisco. i have to stay close to my paper. thank you to the city and county of san pran and the department of public health employing me for 25 and a half years thank you to the board of supervisors for the honor and a thank you to president of the supervisors committee -- walton for his hard work and leadership. thank you. >> also another special thanks to anna director of opinion health primary care and director of nursing. i want to give a thank you to my family for always standing behind me since the beginning of my nursing career in 1992. my husband kevin for pep talks when i was ready to give up. you are my rock. i love you my daughter and my son who are always there for me unselfishly. i love you. and thank you to the rest of my family and friends for being here today. i appreciate and love you as well thank you to my maxine hall health center family. thank you for being here. for the last 9 years of awesomeness my murs manager for lead everybodiship, friendship and transparency. my retire medical director katherine james. and susan oshg bada who has been great roll models for me. someone said to me it is hard to work with dhp system but there are so many good people and i agree. i have truly been blessed the last 25 and a half years of serving my communities. i must say, as i thought about what i was going to talk about my journey as a nurse i realized it was meant to be. since a girl i loved helping people because it made me feel better. and if you feel burden of proof i feel better. so00 eye was born and raised in san francisco and grew up in housing projects in potrero hill. attended star king and potrero high school and balboa high school. my mother took us to san francisco general hospital and the dentist in the old brick buildings in the 60s and 70s. the memories were good. so i believe it was fitting for me to return and give back to what was goin me. good health care. i love being a nurse and what i did as a nurse and would not trade it for anything. i did my best at being a good nurse and roll model for my colleagues and new nursing coming in the profession. my favorite lines i would say to new nurse or students was, don't get in the profession if you don't like helping people or for the money because tell be a disservice to you and the parents who trust you to take care of them. they don't deserve that. and as a nurse, i got to serve people who physical or mental health in any capacity was compromised whether minor, arc acute or chronic i helped them get to their optimum quality of health by giving care and showing empathy. i tried different develops work nothing jail health services, surgical, health care and my first love, primary care. >> i was able to build relationships with staff and patients by way of team based care. i got to be part of something so important like equity. we address the the inequities we see in our network with african-americans and hypertension but must improve on what has been set in motion. there are such awesome people taken equity tow another level and appreciate their leadership. now look we have an [inaudible] in equity and he health. being a nurse come with responsibility from all aspects. so, let me tell you what nurses are. servances with a heart to serve and heel. they are empathetic and good listeners. gate keepers between doctors and patient and gate people00ers of nurses and doctors. nurses are troubleshoot irs. great advocates. nurses are compassionate, skillful and protectors. fearless when necessary. and will get the job done. i would like to ends with a quote from mya angelo it goes, i learned that people will forget hayou said. forget what you said. people will never forget how you made them feel. it has been an honor to work in this capacity as a nurse for the city of san francisco. i say, thank you again for letting me take this ride and journey with you. thank you so much. [applause] [applause] congratulations again. madam clerk. let's go to item 29. >> a resolution to designate newspapers to be the out reach community periodical of the city. world journal. bar media ink. sf bay view. san francisco times. noe valley voice. street media llc, action latina and nguyen newspaper. and tsing spay tao >> thank you. based on an inquiry received by the office of contract administration the department is further reviewing the recommendation for award of the contract for the section regarding chinese community newspaper. until final determination as to the award the newspaper contract i'm making a motion to sever the question which is to separate that section from the rest of the resolution and that's specific low lines 5-7 in line 16. and -- we will account to approve the newspapers upon sept that section. and send the bvenlts ordinance become to committee which is the budget and finance committee. since budget and appropriations will not meet. seconded by supervisor chan. did you -- madam clerk. >> and we will sever that portion of it and sends that to the budget and finance committee. call the roll. >> supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> and supervisor safai. aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye >> supervisor walton. >> aye >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> mandelman. >> aye. mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston >> aye. >> this is adopted with the exception of the line item that is moved to continue. >> madam clerk call item 30 >> resolution to designate clinton rhymey dob at the san francisco examiner to be the official paper of san francisco for all advertising fiscal 22-23. >> thank you very much. supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. why supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. eleven ayes. this is adopted unanimously. >> item 31. >> 31 is a resolution to approve the 2021-22 dignity fund community need's assessment. >> thank you. questions of law the roll. >> item 31, supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> walton. >> aye >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> can you add me as a coexperience. >> aye. >> noted. >> melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> and supervisor preston. >> aye. n is adopted unanimously. call enemy 32. >> item 32 this is a motion to authorization everauthorize the clerk of the board to take all steps to amend the budget and legislative analyst services contract with harvey m rose llc for additional work under the scope of services to extent that funds are appropriated for that purpose. >> on item 32, supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's >> thank you without objection this is approved unanimously. >> please call item 33. >> item 3 a charter amendment third draft to amend the charttory create the homelessness oversight commission over see the department in supportive housing. >> thank you, please call the roll on 33. >> item 3, supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> and supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's >> thank you and just to let everyone note we are voting on charter amendment to be continued. >> which is -- i didn't state it that way but it is in the record >> it is listed in the question. >> if thank you. >> so -- without objection this charter amendment is continued to july 19th. unanimously. >> please call item 34 >> this is a charter ma'am second draft amend the charter extend the library preservation funds for additional 25 years. through june 2048 to set arc side funds provide services and materials. and operate library facilities at the main library in branch libraries it's an election to be held on november 8, 2022. thank you, madam clerk roll call to continue. to continue to the july 19th meeting supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye >> supervisor stefani. >> ayech >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> and supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's >> thank you without objection this amendment is continued to july 19th 2022 board of supervisor's meeting, unanimously. >> call item 35. >> y. 35 this is a charter amendment third draft to amend the charter provide for review and approval eligible 100% affordable housing projects, educator housing and market rate projects provide significant afford attant and planning department view in lieu of approvals or appeals to city boards and commissions to make the amendments to the planning code in the business and tax regulation code among other provisions. >> thank you. supervisor chan. >> thank you, colleagues, some of you having conversation about the affordable housing production act put before the ballot this november. california environmental equality act protects our environmental health and safety n. san francisco process including the discretionary review is to protect the history of our city. and our community from displacement and gentification. this is why exemption for the reviews enough deliver affordable housing that address san francisco's housing crisis. let's make sure we build housing that working families can afford i introduce the affordable housing production act to accelerate the process to build real affordable housing san francisco working families can afford. a safe guard against any attempt to mislead voters about market rate housing as affordable and further displace working people in san francisco. this measure will will accelerate production for low income and middle income housing. middle income in this legislation is defined as 160 thousand dollars annual income for a family of 4. provides more family housing. by requiring for the additional affordable housing units to sites that produce 2 and 3 bedroom housing. more housing by increased affordable housing requirement percentage. and -- it supports our workforce developmentment requiring skilled and trained employ am and require worker to be paid a wage so those who build housing can afford to live in it. and brings a greater trance transparency requiring a report throughout budget process. i want to thank supervisor peskin and preston and walton as your for your early cosponsorship i'm proud to have the san francisco building trade, labor council and educators of san francisco standing with us. our workers are essential to san francisco and needs to be able to afford living here. and thank you to council of community housing organizations were for some ofs known -- and helped tenants and working families against displacement for a long time. but -- colleagues, i think that while we have been in good faith working toward this legislation and making sure that not only that we mean what we say by delivering affordable housing we do want to make sure that it it is feasible. and sometime its does requirer conversation with those who do build housing in the city. and with that conversation i want to point out that you know colleagues, some of you have been involved in this conversations. and working with our office with advocates and working with you know -- trades. members to making sure this measure is workable. it is meaningful. and i want to supervisor safai for his participation in the conversations as well. as a result, i will be making 2 amendments today. and those 2 amendments are -- amending the definition of multifamily housing as it is defined 2 units and more with exception single family home. with the amendment is going to increase that unit number to 10 units and more. and the second amendment is to amend the increase inclusionary percentage from as they stands at 15% to 8%. colleagues i want to clarify that this decrease of percentage still is in addition to the existing inclusionary percentage. which varies between 21.5 to 33% and in an inclusionary upon standard for housing percentage requirement on site. so -- this still is 8% in addition to the existing standard. that is a thoughtful compromise in a sense where how can we make sure we still get what wheelwe need in affordable housing. we need more affordable housing but how can we reach a place where we can get everyone on board be it market rate developers or nonprofits to build more affordable housing faster. in accelerated pace. that is the goal of this legislation. so i urge for your support today to for this 2 amendments to be more specific the amendments you see has been circulated electronically by my office and on page 8 line 12 and that's replacing 15% to 8 percent and on page 9 line 1 to replace 2 with 10. very simple but critical ma'ams and look forward to your support with this amendments, colleagues, it will sends us with your support to continue and amend then tell then emsend to yous next week for continuing discussion and if you support this we will have a commit eye of the whole to continue this conversation -- hopeful low it have your final support on tuesday july 26. so thank you so much for this time to speak on this and i look forward to havingior support and i will be making that motion to amend >> thank you. why thank you a second. >> seconded by supervisor ronen. >> supervisor ronen. >> yes. supervisor chan, i wanted to thank you for your thoughtfulness in putting this together. i could in the agree more with you. that it is is important that we are moving the production of housing faster. that'ds fordable housing to the stock the reason i have not put my name on this legislation thus far i was worried about that inclusionary number but you have been thoughtful and listened and -- made compromises and so would like to now be added as a cosponsor and appreciate your hard work >> thank you. >> thank you supervisor ronen. >> on the motion to amend. >> on the motion to amend item 35 supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> and supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's >> motion to amend passes unanimously. call the roll on the motion to forward this to continue this amended charttory the july 19, 2022 board of supervisor. >> in the setting as a committee of the whole? >> correct. >> all right. on the motion to continue item 35 to july 19 in the setting as a committee of the whole supervisor ronen. >> that will be as amended. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor steph afternoony. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey >> aye >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston >> aye. >> there are lefrn aye's >> thank you. motion carries unanimously. would you call item 36. >> item 36 a charter amendment second deteriorate it amend the charter to e eliminate the department of sanitation and transfer responsibility to the department public works to remove qualifications for members of the san station and public works commission and for the director of public ws to limit the duties of san station to hold hearing reviewing data and setting policies for the department of public works regarding sanitation and maintenance of the public right-of-way and provide the commission shall over see all other aspects of the department of public works at an election on november 8, 2022. >> thank you, madam clerk. can we get a roll call it then and there charter amendment to july 19th. twenty 22. >> on that motion supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai >> aye >> stefani? >> aye >> supervisor walton jofrmg aye >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor mefwar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> and supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's >> thank you this amendment is continued to the july 19 issue 2022 board of supervisors meeting um unanimously call the 3 p.m. special order of business upon the first one. >> all right. special order 3 p.m. this is item 45. this is the board of supervisors to convene a committee for a public hearing to hear and receive updates on the progress and implementation status of the united states department of justice recommendations. regarding reforms within the police department. scheduled approveod september 15 in 2020 and continues from a 5-24-22. >> thank you, colleagues i would like to make a motion to continue this hear to our september 27th, 2022 board of supervisors meeting, is there a second. >> seconded by supervisor peskin. on the motion to continue after public comment. >> mr. president. i double check the date we think is september 26 for the board meeting. we are absolutely. no, no. we'll double check our date. that take public comment. >> we'll call for public comment at this time the board away testimony specific to the continuance of the update on findings and recommendations regarding law enforcement practices. we will hear first testimony from anyone present in the chamber and then from those joining remotely. if you are present, like you to lineup on your right hand side and i will return to you after i provide the best practices for the remote system to proviolet testimony remote connect to the system. the number is on your screen 415-655-0001. huhear the prompt enter 24832806900. press pound twice. you will hear the discussion and muted. once connected press story 3 and the system will indicate you raised your hand. continue to wait listen carefully when the system indicates you have been unmuted that is queue to speak your comments. we are joined by our partners at office of civic engagement andim grant affairs we'll ask each to introduce themming. agnus lee? assisting those who are speaking chinese and tarsita for filipino and arturo for spanish. [instruction in cantonese] are you there? tarasita, are you there? >> arturo can you go next while tarasita figures out if she is connected. >> sure thing. [remote comment instructions in spanish] >> thank you, and tarasita were you able to connect? all right. well, i do appreciate the interpreters here with us. go to those in person. is there anyone who would like to address the board on this issue? all right. seeing no one in the chamber we will go to the remote system. we have from the clerk's office mr. author coo. do we have anyone in the queue? we have one caller in the queue >> let's welcome the caller. >> welcome, caller. setting the timer for 2 minutes. of are you with us? we can hear you -- all right perhaps this is an unattended line. is there anyone else in the queue? >> that completes the queue. why thank you mr. coo >> mr. president. >> thank you, seeing no one here for public comment. and no one on call line public comment is closed. >> madam clerk call the role on the motion to continue item 45 to our september 27, 2022 board of supervisor's meeting. >> yes, mr. president and confirm this is the correct date. thank you. on the motion to condition item 45 to september 27, 2022 supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's. >> thank you without objection motion carries unanimously. madam check please call our other special order at 3 p.m. >> item am 46. this is a public hearing of the board of supervisors to convene in the setting as a committee of the whole to hold a hearing on an ordinance to order the street vacation of portions of grift igstreet and hudson avenue as part of 900 enis avenue and the puc easements 700 enis avenue which happen to be the subject matter of the n item which is item 47. >> thank you, can you go ahead and call 47 as well. >> was referred without recommend agsz from land use and transportation committee. this is an ordinance to order a street vacation and property transfer for 900 enis park development easement vacation order for india basin project 700 enis and adopt ceqa and make findings. >> thank you. colleagues we have before us a hearing on the street vacation order and interdepartmental property transfer for 900 enis avenue park development. puc easement vacation for india basin mixed use project at 700 enis avenue. i would like to invite david from rec and park to present on this ordinance and he is accompanied by other representatives from rpd, dpw, department of environment and city attorney's office if there are questions >> thank you. >> good afternoon supervisors i'm david a project manager worry rec and park capitol planning. can i get permission to present on the teams? >> certainly. of >> thank you. hang on a moment. >> okay. i see it. thank you. >> >> upons good afternoon i'm david and i am a project manager at rec and park to the planning division. and i'm here to provide a brief over view on the waterfront park project relating to street and puc easement vacation before you. india basin endeavour to build a park that is -- meaningful -- equitable and essential to the health of sudden fran community historically under served. the vision for the site has been to create a larger interconnected water front park and trail network in the bay through community. with this, in 2015 property owners and key bay view stake holders embarked on the india basin water front study it understand the opportunity created and all waterfront parks look, feel and operated as an integrated park system. out of this process, and from many meeting goals about inclusion were centers in the equitable development plan was created the edp. >> the edp ensure this is park will benefit bay view residentses and preserving the culture and identity of the historic neighborhood. provides a blueprint for delivering a park designed by and for the community. while improving economic opportunity and varmental health for residents. it is a culmination of 2 year community driven process to preserve the culture, identity and pride in the community and ensure this multimillion dollars investment to transform the waterfront uplifts the community beyond washing boundaries. >> areas of focus include culture identity, economic workforce development, transportation and access, health, community and eastboundingology, youth opportunity and housing security. force force the india basin project is aimed prosecute violeting healthy community investment and environmental restoration and 3 priorities. the first, address decades of environmental contamination from boat and repair activities in the remediation phase now of the project. the second is to create amenity rich parks build community capacity and reflective of the community. and the third is to credit a resilient, healthy shore line community. the india base i believing include several pak cites shown on this map the future park development is shown that's the same side as remediation and 9 huh human enis park construction hope to start construction this sum or the park. the seconded the renovation of the existing india basin shore line park to the west/northwest and third the renovation and expansion of the existing open space and new big green which are constructed by build inc. part of the 700 enics project. the open space will provide public amenities and will linked by connected pedestrian and poik path way commyself. of the puc vacations will accommodate the important improvements proposed by rec and park as analyze in the the india basin mixed use eri certified in july of 2018 the development inclusive of the street vacation and with the hunter's point shore line herrins head, bay trail and future development is important to the needed revictim in the bay view neighborhood and consistent with the general and bay view hunter's point area planning and rec and park strategic plan and support recreational open space equity goal unless a high need's area. >> here say project map showing the various parcel ownerships across the site. ownership is confidential coded such that the port streets and tide lanes are in blue. rescue park owned in green. public works paper streets in purple. the builted inc. 700 enis in orange. and private parcel in gray. you see the park property and master under. you seat street vacation footprint buffer associated with the rec park project is in darker blue occupying a portion of griffith and hudson avenue and bounded by enis and gaffys. the vacation footprint over laps western edges of the proposed park developments. jury rooms rec and park plans to return to the board later for a future second vacation boundary which is depict in the orange/yellow that comprises edge of the park development site. because survey work will take longer and given time sensitivity of our current construction efforts. the department elected to separate out and seek that at a later date. this presentation was developed with public works and than i support this vacation. >> and now i can answer question, that concludes my presentation. >> thank you very much mr. frolic. i don't see questions or anything from colleagues. madam clerk can we go to public comment on this item? thank you, at this time the board welcomes testimony on the public hearing regarding a street vacation order interdepartmental property transfer 9 huh enis we will hear from any members of the public who were present in the chamber. i we appreciate if you lineup on your right side near curtains and i will provide the best practices on remote call in system. you must dial 415-655-0001. id24832806900 >> press pound twice and then press star 3. . the somes indicate you have raisedior hand. continue to wait until you are hear u you have been unmuted that is your queue to begin speak. we are joined by interpretors. of cant niece, filipino and spanish. welcome. [remote public comment instructions in cantonese] thank you. >> hi. [remote public comment instructions in filipino]. >> thank you. remote public comment instructions in spanish] thank you. >> you are great thank you for being with us. let's start with member of the public here in the chamber i don't see anyone lining up on the right side. last call. we gallon to the remote system. mr. cue we have 6 listening and one in the queue? let's welcome that person. >> setting the timer for 2 minutes. welcome, caller. >> all right. that men an unattended line. is there anyone else in the queue? . all right. >> hello. >> hello. welcome, caller. >> um -- hello i'm jill fox. i live on enis avenue. very much support development of the park and the project. one thing that is not shown in all the pretty pictures is the utility lines that the poles and lines that run on enis avenue. we have been promised that these would be put under ground. but there seems to back peddling on that. and -- they are unsafe lines and basically all of the development at the ship yard is running on the old poles. and as will all of the power cable, et cetera for the build inc. project and the park. i would very much like some honesty from rec and park and the developer about what will help about under grounding our utilities so that these developments will they get under grounded everything is running in front of our hopes and businesses on poles that were install in the 1941. they are the oldest utility pole in thes city and they just should not we should not have to pay the price in terms of safety and aesthetics for all of this new pretty development for new people. thank you for taking my call. jill fox and i live on enis avenue. thank you. >> thank you for yu testimony, to the board. now we have 6 callers listening and one more in the queue. if you want to make comments on this matter you need to press star 3 otherwise we will take this last caller. welcome, caller you have 2 minutes. have you joined us? >> now my line is unmuted. welcome mr. decosta. >> thank you very much. so let me say that -- way back in 2004, there were supposedly a lan mark cottage on 900 enis. and -- this property is very close to the shore line. and i studied this area because they used to be a lot of contamination. now i believe that ruby and i know rubicon very well are doing the arc baitment and mitigation. my concern it is simple. it is too close to the shore line and i want to know like the san francisco sea wall how is park and rec going to address -- a tsunami or 50 foot waves? park and rec likes to get involved with some issue without doing the right thing. you heard from i caller -- that the public utility the lines have to be put under ground. and there is no clarity on this. board of supervisors, you like to rubber stamp you are not educated on issues. somebody whispers sweet nothing in your ear and you go forward. this land is prison to flooding. >> thank you francisco decosta for your comments to the burden. arthur do we have other callers in the queue, welcome, caller. have you joined us. that individual. >> great. welcome. >> yes, welcome. >> hi. i'm i apologize i have to run to work and wanted to comment on the items reported housing if i am permitted. no, ma'am. unfortunately this is are if you street vacation order at 9 huh human 900inns avenue. innes not yet, mr. worryfields. press star 3. >> all right. >> okay. >> thank you. >> thank you. >> do we have other callers in the queue, please. that completes the queue. >> thank you. are there other members who are here to address the board on this matter. all right. mr. president. >> thank you, seeing no others public comment is closed. supervisor melgar. thank you, president walton i wanted to clarify because a couple of colleagues asked the question, this on the agenda it says sent out to land use without committee recommendation. that is just a technical thing. we all hear it. and you know we will vote on it. but there was no controversy at the land use committee. thank you. >> thank you for clarifying that, chair melgar. >> and i don't see anyone else on the roster. en thank you, mr. frog frolic. this is something the community is excite body and can't wait to see how the design turns out this park is something that has been long awaited we want to protect our environment through the process. i'm excite body this. this is one piece of what needs to be done for us to move the land over to rpd to get this park built along with other components of the development. thank you very much. and this committee of the whole item 46 has been heard and filed. >> and madam clerk. can you call the roll for item 47 j. on item 47 supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> thank you without objection this is passed on first reading unanimously. and madam clerk this concludes or 3 p.m. special orders. let's go back to item 37. >> item 37, this is a charter amendment second draft to amend the charter of the city to change the election cycle for the offices of mayor, sheriff, da, city attorney and the treasurer so that the office will be elected in even numbered years and provide that the current term for the offices will end on january 8, twin 25. rather than january 8, 24. 2 amend the definition of general municipal election so that such elections occur in even numbered years approximate change the signature threshold for initiative ordinances to 2% of the number of registered voter in san francisco at an election to be held on november 8, 22. >> thank you. madam clerk. can you call the roll on continuance of this item to our july 19th 2022 board of supervisors meeting the motion to condition item 37 supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are upon 11 aye's. >> thank you this charter amendment is continued to july 19, 2022 board of supervisors meeting unanimously. >> police call item 38. >> this is a charter amendment for first draft to amend the charter of the city to eliminate the full funding requirement for supplement cost of living benefit payments to the san francisco. ployee resierment system retired before november 6, 96 subject to amongly cap and their survivors and beneficiary in years that the retirement system is not fully funded to adjust the base retirement or their survivors and beneficiaries to accounts for supplemental cost of living adjustments noreceived in 2013, fraern, 17, 18 and 19 and enter in an individual contract with any retirement system executive director hired on or after january 21 of 23 an election on november 8, 202. >> supervisor ronen can be added as a cosponsor and thank you supervisor safai for your leadership. >> thank you very much. >> thank you supervisor ronen. madam clerk, call the roll on continuing this item to our july 17, 2022. >> president. >> supervisor melgar. >> i'm sorry. okay. >> i wanted say thank you to supervisor safai for his work on this. i was involved only in the backgrounds texting him every day are we there yet. get this done. i did in the do work on it. just cheerleading but i gotta say this was a heavy lift and it you know involved a lot of negotiation. and we have some of our community folks here who have been pounding the pave am working really hard to take care of our vulner annual retirees. i want to acthanking supervisor safai you did it with patience and love which i appreciate. thank you. why thank you supervisor melgar. can we get a roll call on the continuance of this item to july 19, 22 board of supervisor's meeting. on the motion to condition item 38 ronen >> aye >> supervisor safai >> aye. >> supervisor stefani >> aye >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> spriergs melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's y. thank you without objection this charter amendment is continued to july 19, 2022 board of supervisor's meeting unanimously. >> madam clerk please call item 39. >> item 39 appointments to the shell are monitor committee joaquin ramorea ending 23. chris plunginget. diana residency requirement waived and tracie watson ending july 21. 2 to the shell are monitor committee. >> thank you madam clerk. call the roll on item 39. supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> and supervisor preston. >> aye. >> is there are upon 11 aye's. >> thank you, without objection this motion is approved unanimously. call item 40. >> a motion to approve the mayor's nomination for appointment of steven lee to the port commission term ending may first of 26. >> thank you. call the roll on item 40 >> supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. there are 11 aye's >> thank you without objection this is approved unanimously. >> madam clerk call item 41. item 41 and i do apologize if i incorrect low pronounce anyone's name. a motion to appoint morgan [inaudible] residency requirement raises. pamela nayingel. mike sullivan and edcar florez term ending november 18 of 22. to the urban forestry council. >> thank you, madam clerk. call the roll on item 41 >> item 41. supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. ja supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> is there are upon 11 aye's >> thank you this motion is approved umly. call item 42. >> item 42 a motion to approve the mayor's nomination for the appointment of mar >> mologyannam to sanitation and street. >> supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> and supervisor preston. >> aye. >> without objection this motion is approved unanimously. madak clerk call item 43. a motion to appoint >>hannah liu to the san francisco health authority. >> call the role on item 43. >> supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston >> aye. there are 11 aye's >> thank you without objection this is approved. >> call item 44. >> was referred without recommendation from rules committee this is a motion to approve the mayor's nomination for the appointment of deborah walker. to the police commission term ending april 30 of 24. >> thank you, supervisor chan. >> thank you president walton i want to say that misdeborah walker has been a great art's commissioner and also have served as our department and building inspection commissioner as well. and has been a long time add kro vocate in the city. and that -- today, though. regrettablely i will not support her appointment to the police commission simple low only because not -- this is not really about miss walker but much more about when wheelwe need at this motion on police commission. i do believe we are at a critical place of reform. progress, i think that while we thank you is a lot progress has been made. i think that so much more needs to be done i'm looking for someone that and previous appointments both from the board and also the mayor's appointments they are either you know, attorney that worked with immigration law or that they have strong community advocate that have worked with unions and specifically also to the ap i community. there are different expertise that brings to the table and so for some of the commission appointees working in police reform work democracieds long. i will not support the commission appointment on this specific commission for mrs. walker i look forward to seeing the possibility of having her serving in other commissions. that is perhaps more fitting. with her expertise and her leadership. thank you. >> thank you supervisor chan and supervisor ronen we have supervisor dorsey on remote i will call supervisor dorsey first. >> supervisor dorsey? >> thank you, president walton. colleagues i have a decade's long relationship with deborah walkir included political activism and out of caution i sought the city attorney's guidance and add vised there is no basis to recues but i want to disclose that for public record. >> thank you supervisor dorsey. supervisor mandelman. >> i'm strongly supporting this appointment. this body needs queer rep centation. does not currently have it and has not premesis petra left, i believe. and i think that mrs. walker has been involved in police reform going back to harvey mill club president and i think brings valuable perspective from many communities that will be important top have on this commission. i think she demonstrated she is harvard working, independent and open to hearing from lots of different folk and she should be confirmed. >> thank you supervisor mandelman. supervisor ronen >> i want to back -- echo nightmy colleague supervisor chan while i also believe that there should be queer rep centation on the police commission i believe it should be an individual that has a history or connection to policing, police reform issues and i think mrs. walker explained during the rules hearing herself that she did not have that background or experience but would do her best am as supervisor chan explained, this is not a personal issue about mrs. walker i agreed to her appointmentos many other commissions in the past. this is the wrong commission at the wrong time and i will vote, no. >> thank you supervisor ronen. supervisor preston? >> thank you president walton and i want to agree with my colleagues supervisors chan and ronen. with their observations and you know i think that like them, i think you know i applaud deborah wanger's service to the city both on arts commission and building inspection and political activism but i do think especially in this moment that the police commission plays a really key role around a lot of extremely important issues in our city and around oversight of police and policing. and that we need commissioners on this body that are that can really hit the ground running and have the experience to -- to really from day one engage in that policy making role and frankly, the recent appointees have been that including from the mayor that you know we supportd and an expert in this area. i want to echo that i understand that often times people you know look to folks they know through club when chosing but we have an increditedicly rich range of advocate in san francisco with all perspectives and real expertise around police and public safety and in nile my 99 this moment that's who we should choose for the commission. in the event she is confirmed i look forward to working with mrs. walker i known her for years and have respect but will not vote to support her for this position today. thank you. >> thank you. supervisor preston. i don't see anyone else on the roster. would you call the role for item 44. >> supervisor ronen. >> no. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> no. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. sdwr aye. >> supervisor preston. >> no >> there are 8 aye's and 3 nos with supervisors ronen, chan and preston in decent. thank you and 8 to 3 this is approved. i believe we are on item 48. >> yes. i will state that items 48 and 49 were considered by the gentleman audit and oversight committee on thursday july 9 guilty of 22 and recommended as committee reports. item 48 this is a resolution to authorize the office of contract administration to enter in a people soft contract between the city and [inaudible] limited for the provision of a class a biosolid service with contract not to exceed 16.4 million for 5 scombreers 6.4 million for 2 optional extensions and duration of 7 years to commence on july first of 22. >> thank you. call the roll on 48. >> supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar >> >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's >> without objection this resolution is adopted unanimously. item 49. this is a resolution to authorize the office of contract administration a third ma'am to the agreement with the city and sunset company doing business recology sunset golden gate disposal and recycling as recology golden gate the contractor. for refuse collection service at city facilities increase the amount 24 million for total of 39.sick million and extend the term 2 years for a total duration of 3 years and 7 months through june 30 of 24. >> supervisor preston. >> thank you. >> and colleagues, i will move nonsubstantive amendment we circulated to reflect our approval of the contract amendment would be retroactive apologies we did not catch this in committee. thank you for catching this. the item was heard and know amended before. july first but because the amendment was conditioned to after july first render the approval retroactive here. we circulated the amendment it is to add the word. retroactive on page 1 line 3 in the long title and page 3 line 8. thank you. >> thank you. i have a second. >> supervisors safai. i don't know if supervisor, thank you, if peskin will speak on his resolution later in the item but i want to take this opportunity to highlight something that has been a source of frustration for me. with recology. there has been many and appreciate the amendment done by supervisor peskin this contract is about services municipal buildings. and there will be further conversations. we will have those at the budget committee. one source of frustration recology has the requirement and the duty to service our public trash cans and often time in my district, they are not serviced properly. they are not continuous low hit. often times tell take multiple conversations with the agency to have people exactly out. it is to the ridiculousness of one person will service the can but another person can't service the treasure that is around the can. and i just feel like -- we need to have better service, better relationship. and over all better effort from an agency that we have a strong contractual relationship with. so i wanted get this on the record today. been in office for 5 and a half years. and i cannot count how many times hi to call recology to tell them remind them and ask them to service our public trash cans. that either over flowing or have people using that as a site for illegal dumping. i will support this today. i know ultimately tell go out to bid in the coming months we had that conversation but i want to say that i'm not clear hot current representative is from that agency and have not had a lot of communication in the last 10 months from or year from recology. wanted to get on the record happy to support this today but definitely want to see a better level of service and engagement from this company. >> thank you mr. president. why thank you supervisor safai. supervisor peskin. >> at long last the city services contract for collection is going out to a competitive bid. i encourage any qualified company to bid. and this extension, which we need and i think the city add administrator negotiated at a fair and appropriate price, can be terminated at any time for convenience when the rfp roesz everpress is concluded should there be another winner other than recology. thank you city add administrator and her staff and as to the related but different item on the boopgz dpoopgz calendar i will speak to that later in the day but i think supervisor safai does have a good point which is, the rubber hits the road when our trash caners emptied and done so in a clean fashion by the trash collector recology. and i hear constant complaints and see it with my own ice some of that is a function of people behaving badly and some is a function of trash not picked up well. but -- i think recology should have gotten the message with the passage of prop f. and they should get the message when we unanimously adopt item 54 on today's calendar. >> thank you supervisor peskin and thank you supervisor safai. i want to echo supervisor safai around the support that we don't receive from recology when it come to public housing cites. especially in my districtism think the thing that is worse in supervisor safai eludeed this is that in terms of communication and responsiveness this has gone down the toilet to supervisor safai's point i don't even have the right contact or representative in terms of how to address the issues and occurrence, which is a major problem. so -- i want recology to be on notice that most certainly their transparency and the way they community with the leadership of the city is very problematic. i will be supporting this as we do know one that there are a lot of workers who are living in our communities and in the city and of course i want to make sure that we do everything we can to keep people employ exclude because we will be putting this services out to bid. most certainly, recology will have to step and up do things a lot better. and i don't see anyone else on the roster so madam clerk call the roll for 49. >> on the amendment to item 49 mr. president, >> on the motion to amend made by supervisor preston and seconded by supervisor chan. >>you want to take that without objection it is a simple amendment. as long as we can supervisor dorsey on the phone i would love to which we will roll call on the amendment to item 49. supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> and supervisor preston. >> motion to amend the passed unanimously. call the roll on the amended item number 49. >> as amended supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> air. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> and supervisor preston. >> aye. >> tr are upon 11 aye's >> this amended resolution is adopted unanimously. >> please call item 50. >> item 50 was considered by rules committee on monday, july 11th. the chair kept it in committee and not sent as a committee report. thank you. . would you call the role on the continuance of this item. >> mr. president this item is not before the board. >> it is still in committee >> thank you. my apologies. to the public. >> next week. >> we are at roll call for introductions. to introduce new business supervisor ronen. >> thank you, colleague in thes beginning of the year the body passed an ordinance to dress sale of stolen goods on streets and create a permit system for people making money selling goods obtained legally. built in was a requirement that the public works do community out reach and education to ensure all venders had the opportunity to learn about the new laugh sxhchlt built in the requirement that public works received board approval for the ruleless and regulations developed. last week the clerk's office received the regulations from public work and ares distributed them after the review the regulations my office determined them to be appropriate and believe they will be effective in eliminating the large scale sale of stolen goodz and opportunity for legitimate ventzors i am introduce a resolution to allow enforcement of the ordinance and bring needed relief to streets. i want to thank public works to develop the regulations and inspectors working with the community to keep ore our streets clean and susanna and the quat row staff for the work on the project and my legislative aid santiago for being on this problem come coming up with effective solutions and to supervisor safai for cosponseship. >> supervisor safai >> submit >> stefani >> submit >> chan. >> submit. >> supervisor dorsey. >> thank you, colleagues hold on. okay. i'm intrubss legislation the first of 4 part pack knowledge move us forward on the trance bay block 4 project this project is on a site bounded by howard, main and beall and provide 681 units of residential housing 45% of those affordable. like much of what has been developed under the trance bay plan other block 4 is high resource access to jobs and transit and bike lanes and inviting public realm i was in the city attorney's office in 05 kwht original transbay plan was passed by chris daly and earned support. most of the parcels that plan developed and block 4 is the last ones. reflects a great partnership. for transbay partners and construction is slated start a year from now. the ordinance i'm proposing am commends the zoning map. follow shortly and my office is working with the city attorney office on those. i thank you it is among many steps we need to continue taking as san francisco makes good on requirement to build 82,000 units of housing by 2030. >> second there was a store in the. stan fran chronicling on a practice in other cities worldwide to appoint night mayors role is to advocate and groat city's night life scene. in general that very muches working with residents, clubs, business owners and others to remove barriers to a thriving after our sector the supervisor representatives the night life scene i'm call figure air hearing to explore impelementing a nightmare model shows promise amsterdam was the example. and my purpose in calling for this is not to fault anything because i being we super great leadership in san francisco with the entertainment commissioner come night life business community if anything explore what city hall can to to support our night life scene and help it thrive as we e merge from the covid-19 downturn, we are aware it is slow going with daytime economy getting employers get employees back downtown now it is time to support our night time economy 2016 accounted sick billion dollars in economic activity in 60,000 jobs. upon i'm convinced night life is i big support to our tourism industry. i'm looking forward. with that i submit. >> thank you supervisor dorsey. and i will backtrack to supervisor and president walton. thank you, madam clerk. no worries. colleagues in 2021 i introduced a residence luge 395-21 urging the federal government to cancel student loan debts and passed at this board. for.9 million in the united states are federal student lone borrowers with outstanding debt totalling 1 penalty sick trillion and the bay area the student borrower protection center estimated 735,000 student lone borrowers owing 26 billing canceling student loan dent and eliminating death reports an opportunities for san francisco to create better jobs. to jurisdiction spending and local communes and support individuals in movingum and social mobility. today in partnership with the city treasurer i'm introducing a follow up resolution to commemorate san francisco joining as an anchor member of the public service lone forgiveness plsf challenge. created bite campaign for california baroars rights. an estimated 825,000 california qualify to have dents cancelled through psflf since the program's creation in 0710, 290 received cancellation. and only 14% are on track to receive upon cancellation. we need more out reach on the pslf program to public sector workers so they miapply to get students loans forgiven this also urges that the board will continue to urge the federal government to commit to cancel all student debt and "government enact a plan to cancel student debt and begin the transition to education as a public good. i have one more resolution which it is to commemorate the sf build and construction trade councils 125th anniversary. the san francisco building and construction trade council is one of the oldest councils in the united states. and it was foundod february 6, 1896 and lead bite late ph mccarthy president of the carpenter's union local 22. one. their first organizing campaigns secure an 8 hour workday 1896 part of on going efforts to improve working conditions for laborerers and craftsman in 1897 the building trades working cart was neighborhood with at this time union craftsman not working on jobs with 9 union workers from another craft. and 1900, the building trade founds a weekly newspaper, organized labor. which remains as the oldest labor paper in country and still published today. union labor instrumental in rebuilding san francisco after both the earthquakes and fires of 1906 and 1989 and the construction boom in san francisco after world war ii. union labor constructed every iconic project in san francisco from the golden gate bridge in the 30's to the present day sales forth. the building trades supports apprenticeship programs offering career opportunity for all communities and people of color. they have conditioned fight for labor and prosecute mote job training. family wages and retirement security and health care. congratulations to the san francisco building and construction trades council on your 125th year anniversary the rest i submit >> thank you, mr. president. >> going become at this times order. supervisor mandelman. thank you. today i am introducing a resolution calling on the cdc and the department of health to lead an aggressive monkey pock vaccination cam pavenl guy and bisexual men are once again failed by public health institutions the cdc and nhs the federal government vaccinated 40 million people for covid-193 monthsast first shots is only planning vaccinate to fully vaccinate 2 million per monkey pox and this by the send of 2023. that's a low goal considering we have sick million men have sex in men within the united states and other xhounlts impacted by the spread. this should be a health cries unlike covid-19 we did not have to wait for vaccines and unlike covid-19 monkey pox does not spread through droplets. here we are with case rising and vaccines parse and action by our federal public health institutions absent. officials and heck providers community activists and every day folks impacted communities are left to beg for a response and that in turn begs the question would monkey pox have received a better responsibles in the united states if it was not primarily affecting queer people? the kinds of response monkey pox received in other nations such as the united kingdom and germany vaccines are offered to everyone at risk. so this is embarrassing and it is shameful. and yes, a resolution is only a resolution but an opportunity for this board to call out the federal government for its monkey pock failure and to amplify the voices of those demanding the cdc and hhs confront the virus with the urgency it demands i want to thifrng supervisors dorsey, melgar, safai, preston and stefani and the rest i have submitted or will submit. >> thank you supervisor mandelman. supervisor mar. >> submit. >> thank you. >> supervisor melgar. >> thank you, colleagues, today i am cosponsoring the mayor's introduction of an ordinance merging the office first 5 and the office of early care and education. creating a department of early care. i -- have been working on this all year. i am the board's representative on the first 5 commission for the past year, we have gone through a comprehensive commune planning process. we have identified the challenges to making what the voters approve what they pass prospect c the vision. to have universal childcare. in san francisco for all families who need it regardless of their ability to pay. i'm proud of our efforts. i have been working and i want to thank my chief of staff jed low who has been working with the early care advocates the childcare provide and also the family resource center folks to come up with language in this ordinance and introduced by the mayor that is inclusive of everyone in the community. that centers racial justice in equity as the goal for achieving out come in our early education efforts. and that it provides the foundation and the capacity building that we need to get to universal childcare in san francisco for everyone. it is my commitment to you that i will follow this very thoroughly. it is something this my predecessor norman yee was championed his office's priorities and will remain mine. supporting families but also sets the foundation for later achievement in k-12 silence. so, i thank you and look forward to having this go through the process. the second thing i'm introducing, colleagues, is i hearing request and i am calling up the hearing request that was introduced by my colleague supervisor peskin. he will be cosponsoring. and we are requesting to have the hearing request go to gao. by the end of this month. to hear get an update an early update to the laguna honda closure plan. this is not about the recertification plan this is about the closure plan. because we have been hearing discrepancy from families and parents about what is going on, how they are transferred. what they are told. what we have heard from the department of public health and seen in writing. when we want to do at gao is get some agreements, commitments, clarity and transparency about the relocation plan. what is our bottom line? what is going on there? thank you so much and the rest i submit >> thank you supervisor melgar. >> supervisor peskin. >> submit. >> supervisor preston. >> thank you, colleagues today i'm introducing a resolution to support star bucks workers in san francisco attempting to form unions and urge star bucks to refrain from intrefrns in worker organizing efforts. star bucks workers are unionizing across the counts real in a campaign for the service industry with workers demanding better health and safety conscience protections from unfair firings, seniority rights. leaves of absence. benefits and fair wages. since december of 2021 over 300 star bucks stores filed for union elections. with over 180 victories for the coffee chain workers. the campaign is over seen by star bucks workers united affiliate of worker's united. i want to thank supervisor mandelman for his early cosponsorship and want to thank star bucks works united local 1021 for support. and also thank the star bucks workers all over san francisco and the bay your for their courageous organizing efforts. the first star bucks store in san francisco filed for recognition in june of this year. in the castro. and supervisor mandelman's district and this was only a month after the first star bucks location in california voted unionize. i'm concerned as i'm sure others are reading media coverage and hearing reports of star bucks under mining workers, closing stores and firing organizers around the country. i think the city of san francisco needs to condemn any forms of union busting and my hope a resolution from the board can in support of workers and fight for better working conscience will prevents union busting activity hear in san francisco and beyond. we are as often stated a union dpoun it is critical we build on the successes of this historic national campaign to unionize star buck locations and build a worker lead approach ensure a fair contract and respect for workers. the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor preston. seeings no other names mr. president that concludes the ungz introduction of new business. >> thank you colleagues and madam clerk go to public comment. >> at it time the board of supervisors away general public comment first those present and take those who joined us remote. if would lineup on your right hand side and i will provide best practices and begin with you. if you would like to proviolet p.m. stomach remost the number is on your screen 415-655-0001. and when you hear the prompt enter the id24832806900 press pound twice. you will hear the discussion but you will be in listening queue muted. that's when you press star 3 and the system will indicate that you raised your hand. if you continue it wait upon lynch for the system to indicate you have been unmuted and that is your queue to speak your comments. this is you are able to speak on the approval of the board meeting minutes for june 7 and 8 where a quorum appeared. speak to the mayoral appearance today and items 53-57 those were consideration on the adoption without committee reference calendar and speak to other general matters not on the agenda today but this are within the jurisdiction of the board. all other content reported out by an appropriate committee. we still will accept your written comment if you use the u.s. mail. . of or send an e mail bos @sfgov.org we were joined byim fremantle affairs i ask them to introduce themselves and the information on how to connect to remote. welcome. [instructions for remote comment in cantonese.welcome. [instructions for remote comment in cantonese. instructions for public comment in filipino... [instructions for remote comment in spanish] thank you. thank you for being with us this afternoon. all right. can you prop the podium. you notice on that lect urn we have a timer for 2 minutes. >> thank you. i'm patrick wolf i'm speaking to item 53. i'm a residents of the sunset i live 6 houses away from the project at 2 if i have 0 irving. i support the construction of this housing. i want this housing to be baptist. i'm wholehearted low in favor. however i want what i suspect each you would want which is to have any poisonous material safely and effectively removed in the construction of this so i'm not harmed my family is not harm exclude neighbors are not harmed. i have been frustrate with the ways in which this project has been handle thered is not enough coordination with the city to invest in the neighborhood. ir do support this project so long as it is done safely. neighbors have done on their own time a lot of analysis and work to put to call attention to the problem and to put forward solutions. i commends supervisor mar for bringing for your consideration that the agencies should coordinate together. this statute min numb exit can't imagine a reason why you object. if you do object to this done sxafl economically in the construction of new affordable housing i appreciate an explanation y. i hope you am unanimously approve the proposal by supervisor mar. thank you. thank you for sharing your comments next speaker, please >> i'm john a 40 year residents in the sunset. i'm here as a board member of the mid sunset neighborhood association. and echoing mr. wolf i recommend the board unanimously adopts the supervisor mar's resolution. specifically, we are in favor of affordable house and i want it clarify that. that has been a myth this we have been criticized for. it is a matter of it safe for neighbors and also on a reasonable size and scale. we support the compromised proposal for a somewhat less massive and large building but toxins and with the suppliers resolution the consotidation of the sites to be one for consideration. that the d. public health hold mohcd and tenderloin corporation responsible. and the safety of neighbors and the new residents of building when constructed will be able to live safely and not fear toxics affecting the questions of law of our life i urge you to report the resolution, thank you. thank you for sharing your comments next speaker, please. good upon afternoon supervisor dan calmuchy a district one renter and the senior researcher for carpenter's local 22 we are rise nothing support of the fordable homes now charter amendment and urging the board to join us in support. affordable homes now the strongest labor provisions proposed for the construction industry. wage. family health care and enforcement to tackle the economy. and arc prenticeship standards earnsugar all have an opportunity to enter the industry regardless of their last name or zip code. we are urning the board to join us and the over 52,000 san francisco residents who support affordable hopes now. >> thank you. >> thank you for sharing your comments next speaker, please >> good afternoon i'm sean mc gary the senior field report or for carp fer's cloel 22 and district one residents since 2011. i'm here to ask to you support are affordable homes now on behalf our 4,000 members and the 4,000 yet to come. it has prevailing wage. local hire and compliance. all the things put people to work and on other then and there that a catch phrase and i hope you can support affordable homes now. thank you. >> thank you thanks next speaker, please >> good afternoon supervisor i'm don and i'm here to speak to behalf of the thousands of brothers and sisters from the nor cal carpenter's union that live and work in san francisco and come from the greater bay area to work in san francisco. i'm a third jenning raise pile driver built most of the foundations in the city. i worked most low in mission bay area driving the piles bang them in for you guys to make sure they have safe foundations and work and live in. but i'm here to speak on fordable homes now act that will get units built out there. it will get apprentice chances to work in the yours they live in and build a career to support families. it is also going to make sure they have health care we got through the pandemic we have seen what it is like without health care. you see people that don't get teit is a tragedy i can't believe people don't have it we have to make sure they have health care and will be enforced. these are things we need to make sure they get the wageless we know the price its costs to live in the bay area today. i support all of you guys and to i'm asking you support this. affordable housing act and we can join forces and get units built in san francisco. thank you for your support. >> thank you for sharing your comments. next speaker, please. >> thank you the board for your time. i'm robert ho i'm an owner of a property that is a block away from the fwif00 block of irving street. this for item 53 the resolution that calls for a coordinated clean up of the toxic contamination under ground the 2550 block irving. we will have known about the corn tame nation since january of 21. many of us lived there for over 20 years not knowing we were exposed to beingic vapors. this is a source of anxiety for all of us. because this gas has been prune to cause cancer and parkinson's. it is a great source of frustration because we than the people and government have known about this problem since 2019. nothing has been done about temperature no one has stood up if the residents or taken step its have the problem cleaned up. that's when we want. we have a resolution by supervisor mar and thank you supervisor mar for your working with our group. it calls for a coordinated clean up of the contamination. using the technology soil vapor ectraction. we urge the board to approve the resolution the clean up needs to be completed before the construction activity. for the health and safety of current and future residentses and also for the health and safety of construction personnel kwhol workament the site. thank you. >> thank you for sharing your comments are there other members of public like to provide general comment to the board of supervisors? seeing none. let's go to the remote system we have 9 listening and there are 4 members red to speak. will if you are one of the 9 press star 3 now otherwise we may take this group to the very end. hear from our first speaker. welcome, caller. have you joined us. speak in your phone and perhaps its you. all right. let's go to the next caller we will circle back to that caller. >> hello. i'm [inaudible] and i am a resident of the district 4 a block away with my young family from the irving project. there has been my neighbors echoed a source of frustration with the city of san francisco and the administration for approving 14 million dollars of funding for a project without ensuring that the safety and toxicity that might be create friday the project or the [inaudible] before the project site was selected was cleaned up. so, i -- urge all of the board supervisors to vote in favor of the resolution as presented today to ensure the safety and health of the neighborhood. and i implore the board take a look at future housing projects or any project to ensure that the health and safety of the neighborhoods is a priority and an important consideration. we have been fighting for tw years to be heard about making sure that we have a safe neighborhood this . should be the minimum requirement of any project approved bite city of san francisco. and yet that has not been doneful today is the day to change that. i hope the supervisors will agree outside of reason to make sure the neighborhood and the toxicity is cloned up prior to moving ahead with the construction of the project. thank you for your time. thank you for sharing your comments next speaker, please. >> thank you this is peter warfield. executive director of [inaudible] users 2004. and today's hearing on the evans of january 6 in our capitol there was testimony from a former twitter employee voice was altered protect privacy. he testified the people at twitter were worried about ecpresident trump's tweets and alarmed. nothing happened until 2 days arch january 6 when twitter removed trump. a question asked was, of him was, would you if not the president would you have deleted the account earlier and answered, yes. i'm talking about this the library continues to taught social media platforms like twit and facebook both of which we heard in ways have various very negative issues for the users and which there is no reason the library should be taughting at all. and the larger issue we have is where the is aability spending monteis in the spending money a way that is not discriminatory, providing remote programs and then notteen telling people they can approach with a phone. >> and there are other things the hours have been reduced on the branchs that have reopened. and the openings have been slow. there needs to be something you can insist on and supervisor that is accountability and a mechanism. thank you for sharing your comments. next speaker, please we have 3 callers in the queue ready to make comments. welcome, caller. will >> hello. i would like to provide public comment in favor of the resolution by supervisor mar regarding plan remediation of the contamination of the 2500 block. irving street in the sunset. my family and i are among the impacted residents when is live close to this contamination. we live with our 2 young children and elderly parents. oir indoor air was tested and the results are alarming. we know that there is vapor under and around our neighbor's homes above california state screening levels. our family lived here for scombreers all exposed the cancer causing chemicals most neighbors lived here longer. we are concerned for the health of our family and asking it support supervisor mar's resolution to ensure that the contamination is remediated. this will ensure all homes new and old are safe for current and future residents. there is a window of opportunity now to get it done right and in a cost effective way before new project begins. and you know, asking them to support this resolution for the sake ever all of the neighborhood existing and future. >> thank you for sharing your comments. next speaker, please. welcome. >> were with sunset park side education and action committee, speak. speaking on agenda item 53. in strong support for the item regarding pc e's on the irving street corridor. following up on speak's written comments. first, thanking supervisor mar for this resolution. the 2500 block of irving has a leg easy of pc by dwo dry cleaners that pc e now broken down in a vapor. pc e vapor plumes spread through sangd than through soil. and sense the sunset neighborhoods are built on sand dunes these pc vapor plumes are a major more were are a problem that is why speak is joining with the sunset neighborhood association to advocate for remediation. and urging the board of supervisors to advocate the california department of to beingic substances control responds accordingly. this reports to count epa. since 2019 the secretary of cal epa has been jefferade bloomenfeld previously director of department of the environment from 2001 to 09. urging the board of supervisors reach out to him regarding this issue. thank you. >> thank you for sharing your comments. next speaker, please. the board of supervisors all over san francisco that are over 2, 500 hot spot. you heard from the previous caller time to contact sacramento the department of toxic control or of department of toxic control and substances. or bloomfield, too. i'm calling you supervisors, because you need to read this article regarding the san francisco port authority. where the planning to build a sea wall and it will cost them 20 billion dollars. much like the [inaudible] at the bay view that started 6 billion now 12 billion and will cost 25 billion when it it is completed. you board of supervisors you still have a grand time allowing the sanning fran public utility commission to puff [inaudible] room 250. and now -- because of the fbi we know. the city attorney the public city attorney accident not do anything the controller could not one supervisor tried to 90% of the do you means were redacted. so, this department should be audited regularly. thank you very much. >> thank you front cisco decosta for your comments. do we have other callers in the queue? that completes the queue. >> thank you. mr. president. >> thank you madam clerk no more callers in the chamber or on the phone, public comment is now closed. would you call for adoption without committee reference 53-57. >> 53-57 were introduced for adoption without reference to committee a unanimous vote is required for first reading today. a member may river a resolution to go to committee. would you like to sever items? >> supervisor mar. >> 53. please. >> thank you. supervisor peskin. >> 54. >> thank you. no one else on the roster madam clerk call the role for 55, 56 and 57. >> on item 55, 56 and 57 supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani j. aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye a >> thank you without objection this resolution and these motions are adopted and approved unanimously. madam clerk call item 53. >>. item will 53 a resolution to urge the california department of toxic substances control san francisco department of public healing and other agencies to provide a coordinated response to the tetra~ pc e contamination in the 2500 inching street block protections of homes and establishments. >> thank you, madam clerk. supervisor mar. >> thank you, president walton. colleagues i want to acknowledge and thank the mid sunset neighborhood association for wing on in resolution and for their advocacy for full clean up of the pc e contamination in this i didn't remember in the sunset district. i noted in my remarks 2 weeks ago and some of the speakers noted the pc e contamination in the soil was uncovered as a result of the needed affordable housing at 2550 irving. and the scope has expanded to the entire block of 2500 irving. and to the surrounding homes as well. and this legacy contamination is in the uncommon in our city the commune has a right to know to understand what the healing impacts are and to have confidence this our public oversight agencies are doing their jobs and protecting opinion health and the environment. upon infederal evereverthis is not case with regards to oversight of the 2500 irving area analysis and clean up. which includes source of kong tammyination and lead by the california department of toxic substances control because sfd ph seeded oversight authority to the state we are frustrated how oversight process has been with 5 separate agreements with separate parties all motivated limit liability and all but one agreements are voluntary and the first party the police credit union a former own of 2550 irving walked away from the valtear agreement that the need for this resolution call on temtht oversight rowel for coordinated assess am of health risks around 2500 irving. this holds all parties accountability and prioritizes remediation. and this resolution is in support of efforts by msna in my on whiches to hold them accountable and ensure the remediation. i did want to close lie says this 2550 was stream lined because it is 100% fooshd affordable. we work to accelerate and stroll line housing and affordable housing production we need to ensthur new development addresses other important need in our communities such as identifying and cleaning up legacy koon contamination like on irving. thank you to the community for and colleagues i urge your support. why thank you supervisor mar. and seeing no one else on the roster call the role on item 53. >> 53 supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's >> without objection this is adopted unanimously. i did not want to confuse you. thank you supervisor. madam clerk, item 54. >> resolution to urge recology to appoint 1 or more represents to the board in collaboration with teamster's 350 of the june 2022 refuse collection and dispose at ordinance prop footwork. >> thank you. supervisor peskin. >> i think the kreshg summed it up. section 290.4d. not to long ago we certified the june like where prop f got the highest percentage of initiative or item with over 70%. and section 290.4d that all of us voted to put on the ballot, has a provision that requires recology to demonstrate ability to arc void service disruptions with a number of options including appointing representatives to the governing board. i note that there is a position open on their board rather they admitted to -- over 900 thousand dollars in bribes. and enter in the a deferred prosecution agreement with the united states d. justice and paid the feds twine million dollars in the city 7 million dollars in refunded 94 and a half to over charge rate payers they got a new board and in april of last year a new chair of that board james lamb who barely made it a year now that is vacant and this resolution, colleagues, would urge recology to appoint one or more representatives in collaboration with their number one labor force teamster local 350 i pause it to and recology had they had employeeos that board they might have had the sense not to engage in the practices that got them in trouble. and in the future if they have members of the teamsters on that board they may be able to make the adjustments this will have us, colleagues like the words that supervisor safai and president walton uttered earlier, more satisfied relative to service. i think it is time for recology to heed this section 290.4d that was overwhelmingly a part of prop f and overwhelmingly adopted by votereds. thank you, >> thank you supervisor peskin. supervisor safai. >> thank you, i have a question. if oui were to add one sentence to the reds lugz would it be pass okay. depends what is it says. >> what i was hoping to add was in the last resolve a paragraph that the board urges recology to immediately appoint one or more representatives to the governing board collaboration, bla, bla, bla add they respond. the rest of the all the way to the end we can add the sentence and respond to the board of supervisor within 30 days of passage of this resolution. >> would this be -- urges them to responded western 30 days. would not be a substantive amendment. i ask i know that supervisor peskin did this. the reason to get on the record they have have ignored the will of the voters and not responded to this body. we talked about not lack of communication. i think good to put on the record asking them within 30-days to give us a time line of what they plan to appoint one or more representatives. >> through the president, cosponsor safai. language that affect is fine with this supervisor. >> that a notion to amend with that language. as long as the city attorney is okay with that. that's is fine to he and act on >> great >> that is a motion. >> thank you seconded by supervisor peskin. >> we have a motion on the floor. madam clerk. supervisor chan. i want a second for the motion. >> yes , i have safai and peskin. >> supervisor chan. gi want to clarify the language the 30 days upon the passage of the resolution? >> okay. >> thank you. thank you supervisor chan. thank you supervisor safai and peskin. did we get the language. >> yes recology report within 30 days upon passage of the resolution. >> thank you very much. on the motion to amend. >> on the motion to amend -- item 54, supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's >> thank you motion to amend passes unanimously. would you please call the roll for the amended item 54 >> supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walon. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor mar. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye >> and preston. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's >> without objection this resolution is adopted unanimously. madam clerk do we have agenda items. none to report. >> in memories for this afternoon >> none to report. thank you colleagues that brings now we are in the city by the bay. we are getting ready for the big parade. the warriors have a lot of fans. you see her at all of the games. the blue and gold for the last few months. welcome the mayor london reed. who does it mean to have the first parade in san francisco. how much are you looking forward to this one? >> let me tell you. i'm so excited the streets are lined in blue and gold which will give a homecoming like no other welcome home warriors what has the center and drive city and the whole vibe. what has it meant to the city. >> it meant so much. we are talking about a team and amazing cost that are not just wonderful on the court but off the court. they brought a vibe and energy that's carrying us in the city after two hardiers. it's time to celebrate give me a final thought. how much you looking forward to riding in your own car in this championship team. >> i'll be smiling and waving so hard my face will hurt. which dezer this. i would like you to show so much love to the team and the people on the stage. let's give them some love warriors. >> give it up for lon ton. [ applause ] >> all right, now we have the hot seat part of the he think delve sorry. the pingient difficult parade questions. the things where they say what they want to say this is great for the fourth parade. the last broadcasting job that hassen been taken by green. let's hear from steve kerr. >> you say this surprised you? >> we stunk the last two years. i don't know if you noticed that. to be back to where we were is incredible and testament to these guys. amazing mentoring from our older to younger guys. a beautiful mix. >> talk about coaching a humble super star stephen curry. he decided to miss free throws the be one of the guys. was it his idea? >> he missed one and you will say he missed free throws. >> he fits in with the group that you elevate above. when you are leaders and so much apart of the mix it's tough to beat. >> with stef it's the combination of talent and he makes everybody want to win for him and with him. one guy was an gray. because of what he meant to our guys to our younger guys and older guys it's not easy. andre helped us get through it all. it was a great mix and good mix of vets and young guys it'd was truly an organize nal success this year it's beautiful to work with everybody. >> four championships as a coach and one for the other thumb. >> absolutely. >> give it up for steve kerr. [ applause ] >> fans know this and on tv we look for this. there is nothing better than a wiggens smile. we started to see that more often. let's have andrew and green come up here. first year all-star first championship and best basketball you played on the biggest stage. how rewarding for you. >> it was great. now we celebrate. >> whatever you have to say go ahead and do it. let me get out-of-the-way. [ applause ] everyone is nervous right now. >> i'm trying to think of the most controversial thing i could say. this is great. i don't know what do you want me to tell you we are better than everybody. [ beeps] that. this has been an amazing year. i told y'all not to let us win a championship. i warned y'all. i'll continue to destroy people on twitter i have been. and instagram stories. i love this group and when i say the group the entire group. there were times we won a championship and everything didn't have to be aligned. for this to work every single person up here had to be aligned. it's so special and you talk about which championship means more. the reality is every single one has it's own journey. i was numb because of the ger any this was. what you appreciate for the journey is the peole

Related Keywords

Berkeley ,California ,United States ,Philippines ,Santiago ,Regióetropolitana ,Chile ,India ,United Kingdom ,China ,Bay View ,Carlton ,North Yorkshire ,Spain ,London ,City Of ,San Francisco ,India Basin ,Filipino ,Spanish ,Chinese ,Steven Lee ,Mike Sullivan ,Norman Yee ,Chris Daly ,Jill Fox ,Arthur Higgins ,Steve Kerr ,Francisco Sea ,Tracie Watson ,Sean Mcgary ,