Transcripts For SFGTV BOS Land Use Committee 42417 20170427

School it can be a huge impact on their lives and, yes it is a sex crime and the involve the da and as parents were thinking oh, your kids can go on the social months and posts things that their friends might be sending them and like i said again, it is a lack of awareness and i just want to be the one to let parents and the panel know that somewhere in the policy should be stated that kids should not do that because when it comes up or if it is worded differently in the policy we dont know kids can post anything and be jailed you know it can affect their whole entire lives i want to thank you for just hearing me out and unfortunately my son he goes to kidnap sf academy and is up for expulsion so i want to give him a chance to speak with that because he was not being treated fairly it was like a number of other children maybe 8 or 9 kids were involved in it and you know my son got as an africanamerican male he got you know the wrong end of the stick got treat the worst like he made the video that was a video and my son he is in trouble. Thank you. Thank you. I want to give him a chance. Thank you. Not treated fairly so. clapping. good evening commissioner, i want to look past this and get my education so clapping. hi, im on track a parent of two sons an third and Marshall High School at the high school were having problems are transparency and the rule of the San Francisco Unified School District i need our help to establish what those rules are with the staff at Marshall High School ive been told by the principal of the High School Im not allowed to talk to with black students or parents restraint is needed i volunteer everyday at the school i work in the cafe and do various activity but want to be a support for the school i joined e lack and pac as a parent San Francisco San Francisco Unified School District told me to step up to the plate to be informed im not informed today, i got a phone call from the assistant principal telling me my sons teacher refuses to meet with me and showed racism towards him he cant be here hes doing homework ive not had a professor or teacher give a student 80 percent out of a 100 percent because they forgot to indent my son get a scholarship and that letter got him into that letter he received a c for it im going having problems and need help with transparent i have principals and assistant principals who are showing me nothing but opposition and haiti want to be part of third grade marshall and want to evaluate the africanamerican we have a 0. Zero math and reading proficiency we need help it is the only high school in the bayview im reaching outside to reach out to the school im not the enemy but the parent thank you. clapping. hello commissioners my name is Alison Collins im here to speak about that same issues im here with my friend from the middle school i had a great experience with the Public Schools until i come back to francisco and an educate 20 years plus in the San Francisco Unified School District and in the bayview a strong persistent advocate and helping to help with the black Advisory Council i help 10 to 20 hours in an effort to support families at my school that dont have the time to daenth to their psychology what im understanding is the policies that i 86 in you get assess to the district policies monthly determined by the leadership are the social capital that you have im agriculture to talk i know how to write emails and have the time to come to meetings i know how to write an email chain that includes people to respond i know how to tweet those things have gotten me responsiveness and yet tearing down when my daughter recorded kids teasing a boy go back to mexico she is like me didnt look black doesnt mean shes not hurt im a black parent but i was upset i know how to report i was thorough and professional we look forward to my daughter include in the restore practice and the principal met with teachers two separate groups of teachers and encouraged them to file deprives he know this i have a relationship with other educators okay. Thank you. This is going on with parents throughout the district some educators with learning and dont know but educators are arbitrator parent and theyre doing it at wallenberg and sounds like at marshall my question what happens when a parent is targeted by an administrator no place for us to go when we report it im told the assistant principal is to tell them their sport to meet in a room we already know didnt have our interests at heart and potentially trying to align other teachers area parents against us. Thank you. Im College Educated and have great relationship with you on board and in Central Office i cant imagine to be a marginalized parent doesnt speak english and have to cabinet the frustration after 8 months. Can he hear me hello superintendent and superintendant guerrero im sheila he apartment with the San Francisco middle school and want to thank you jerry for supporting families like anything like that with the uniform you have no idea i have 3 kids id like to talk about the boys bathroom at San Francisco schools are locked if theyre open only during class break if the kids need a bathroom break you have to wait for the security guards to unlock the bathrooms i have pictures to prove that my child feels like he shouldnt description or eat meaning from the California Law that is also to have the facilities open clean and staffed with supplies that situation effecting my childs physical and Mental Health unfortunately, when i have tried to help my son administrators at school cant be transfused they say one thing were imitated by the they bull the children and parent the different treatment with minority nobody that speaks spanish concurring the meeting no translators i translate the school feels unwelcomed to all i feel that way and see the ways that will be handed like my third child thank you very much for your attention and looking forward in work to resolve those matters with the San Francisco Unified School District thank you very much. clapping. good evening, sir the rest of board i dont know if youll call me on the separate issue but do you want me to continue with this . I have a copy of book if you allow me to speak a little bit about this and speak about the issues why im here this is my second night you talked about do soda i thought i had an opportunity to San Francisco Public Utilities commission but a different issue i went home after 9 oclock but the student and family handbook let me say that i authored this chapter ten on the uniform i authored this and now it bathrooms letter of the law but im saying if you have a problem with the school go to the school and ask for a copy of williams complaint former write our complaint and put it in the box that school as thirty days to come fly if at the dont by law theyll lose money not a school in the San Francisco Unified School District that likes to allows funds they have to be in compliance and that will keep you home not 4 oclock now 10 oclock but put that on paper anyway ladies and gentlemen, my being here is weve been talking about students i have 7 children and have two more left in school right now, im saying our kid is our investment let us not. clapping. not invest and forgot we have cops, watching our money but no cops in the school so im here thank you im here to speak on behalf of the children please put cops in the psychological to be protected to San Bernardino will not happen again. Thank you very much. clapping. were here to talk about an issue that is of use in San Francisco it is about the dramatic of flavored tobacco and an issue that last week 7 days supervisor cohen introduced an ordinance that will prohibit the sale of flavored tobacco in San Francisco that is a topic if id like to get the board of education interested in because it is really an issue to the health and social justice we know that the tobacco borrow communitybased organizations after everybody to try to get the kids to be replacement smokers with candy and fruit favored Tobacco Products and africanamerican youth asianamerican youth and youth in the lgbt communities so we have in the last month or so come up with a petition weve got waterproofs people that wanted a policy about that and want to pass that on to you and look forward to talk with you soon about it thank you. clapping. hi, i crystal weve been talg about the men thalamus citizens Advisory Board cigarette that effects the High School Students just the smoking because the prices you can get two cigarettes for 0. 99 really packaging like candy you know like end of flavors like candy and children waffles things that our kids like and thinks that our kids are interested in so we been working with use of force with a lot of tools ymca a lot of you know afterschool programs to get parents interested and learning more about favored tobacco and sell the flavored tobacco in San Francisco berkley a lot of the counties have done similar things to restrict the flavored tobacco in the Communities United States Post Office why San Francisco which is one the number one, cities we not done anything to support the community especially, when it comes to kids and the disadvantaged communities ive emailed a couple of you guys to meet and ask im asking we all i know you guys have different schedule my schedule a flexibility im ready to meet at our date and time we want to meet with you guys to talk about an issue to see if you guys were asking that to get that solution to support supervisor cohen and other organizations that have been working ending the favored tobacco thank you thank you. Thank you sorry well not be getting to the safe and Supportive School resolution it is late in the hour and make sure this report gets the full attention it deserves well be pushing this to another meeting, however, Public Comment on safe schools feel free to come up and speak weve been here all night we want to honor that. By the way, section g no special order of business were on section h discussion of other educational issues. Susan educators of San Francisco when looking at the report from weve got a lot more work to do united educator of San Francisco wants to stand with the district to fully implement that policy and like to let you know when we looked at the disproportionality for so many areas for africanamerican students in particularly i dont know men that is a crisis we want to be part of the solution to this problem we had the California Federation path course that come out with our report last month you can find that on the first page the website and we focus the task force specifically open africanamerican men and youth in terms of education, and how to help the young men get sustainable jobs were interested in making sure that we didnt create just an interesting report but were we can implement some of the solutions and recommends if that report within the purview of safe and Supportive Schools we hope we Work Together to change the dynamics so we can continue to see thank you. Seeing no more Public Comment items removed at the previous meetings section j introduction of proposals and assignments to committee there are two items one 7424 f p2 and board policy one to budget and next to in support of ab 424 a bill to fill the 11 oclock of civilians to bring guns into school im defer those to the rules committee may i have a motion and second. So moved. Section k proposals for spectrums the rules there is one item item and in support of mayday 2017 and labor immigrant and civil rights introduced by consultant scomplaen and can i hear a suspension of the rules for this proposal to be heard tonight thank you there is a motion that has been seconded roll call vote on suspension the rule. Mr. Cook plane mr. Haney ms. Mendozamcdonnell dr. Murase ms. Norton mr. Sanchez and mr. Walton of is. Thank you now may i have a motion and second for this reduces and well now read thol bargaining rights and. Okay i dont know if we got there the right wing agenda included breaking the unions privatizing public education. And whereas history has shown. The direct action in the streets and strikes have been the most effective weapon ars nol the may day the International Worker holiday have passed throughout the United States and throughout the world. Therefore be it resolved that the board of education of San Francisco Unified School District support the movement and take our message to the street on may first 2017 and be it further resolved that the direction action will be stop ataxes on muslims immigrants and refugees equality for fight discrimination for people of color and womens equality by demanding equal pay for equal work. Jobs for rebuilding infrastructure and public jobs program defeat attempt to destroy the soeshl social safety lynette with healthcare and further be it resolved in order to build widespread result for may day actions. There are no public speakers here signed up for this resolution. Do want to hear from our superintendent. Thank you president walton and commissioners i wanted to comment about the resolution and the guidance prosided to staff and families we agree with many of the value articulated in the resolution. Highlighted in the title are the principles of defending labor rights immigrant and civil rights certainly stand with the authors on all of those values i want to say for clarification we have communicated as we have done in previous unexcused absences in terms of guidance to staff we with respect the rights of staff to take personal time off to participate in this action at the same time we also are concerned about adequate and safe coverage of our classroom andish youd guidance to our school sites with both of those interests in mind. We do have some reports several of our sites are expecting high absences that does give us some concern. We want and will take every step to provide adequate coverage deploying our staff as needed. Depending on the extent of the planned absences we are somewhat concerned about our ability to do that and we ask all of our staff to register their intentions, to be absent and request substitutes i just want to remind our community about those fundamental interests of protecting or school and student safety in voicing the personal beliefs that people have. Thank you. Thank you. Superintendent lee. Any comments from colleagues . Commissioner haney. I want to thank commissioners walton and sanchez for bringing this forward. I respect superintendent lees points on the impact in some of our schools sol of the schools have done with Large National demonstrations is organize teaching and ways to engage students ways around participating in different ways and learning and supporting the general cause. At least learning about it. Notten couraging Political Action in any type of way that is inappropriate. But using it as a teaching moment and having ways that our School Communities to engage we should encourage that and with their rights however they can with your guidance but think about ways our teacher and students and community can participate if they so choose where appropriate. I want to encourage that as well. Vice president mendozamcdonnell. I wanted to thank you my colleagues for bringing this resolution of support. Its very troubling time and we need to do all we can to protect our students, our families and so many of those who make up our beautiful city. I respectfully to have all of our names put on this resolution its an important resolution that speaks to our School District wholeheartedly and would make sense for us to be able to all demonstrate our support. Add the commissioners the immigrant and labor families and everybody under attack in this administration and put our best foot forward to show solidarity in this fight against solidarity with that said, in comments from colleagues or superintendent roll call. Commissioner cook. Yes. Commissioner haney. Yes. Vice president mendozamcdonnell. Yes. Dr. Morasi. Commissioner norton. Yes. Commissioner sanchez. Aye. Thank you mrs. Casco. [applause]. Budget services any reporting from the april 5th. Committee meeting . Anything . No report we did discuss a little bit, what happened at the last Meeting Program from april 6th. Commissioner haney. All of the things we discussed. Whoever said these new agendas are hard to navigate i agree with them. We have three items which were all informational items one we had report on Special Olympics in our district and all of the activities happening programming and very impressive and positive partnership we have with Special Olympics. And representatives from Special Olympics at the committee. We did a curriculum an update on the curriculum of gotc its on going and nothing to report at this point. We should hear more about that. Theyre sort of waiting for some information they need to move forward so there is nothing in particular thats happened with that so far. We had what is notice of preliminary discussions on black history radiowe got the broader picture of what is happening in our School District with respect to africanamerican history in the various courses and new developments new courses and we discussed some potential ways we might expand our support for and teaching of black history eye in our School District there is more to come on there. There was no big developments but it was a preliminary discussion. Thank you commissioner. Vice president mendozamcdonnell committee as a whole. Our committee on the whole on 18th. Of april had two presentations one on the planning of the art Center Located at 135 van ness. It was much more detailed and informative with regards to the art Center Including the Art Institute and the rula saul school of the arts and the second presentation on the planning for proposed school on mission bay and candle stick point david golden gave us an overview of the time frame and the steps needed in order for us to move forward with both mission bay and update on candle stick and the conversations on going with ecii all great conversations with the new centers and cools we have in the works and we also had a great upda update meeting between the joint ad hoc commits, and the u. S. D i want to thank [inaudible] for putting that together. It was good around the partnership strands so we have ladely have had a standing update on bridge to success, the California Career Pathways trust the Career Education block grant and the drul College Enrollment we were expecting to have an update on city college but we did not have that. I want to thank my colleague and trustees over at city college they hosted the Ad Hoc Committee at their chinatown campus. Thank you. Thank u any other updates board delegates or other reports. Commissioner rosay . Im happy to report panel csba will include kevin truit the head of the Child Abuse Center and joyce derado of ucsf approaches its elevated from small workshop to Critical Issues panel. Really looking forward to that in december. The Ad Hoc Committee on Student Assignment will be meeting on monday may 15th. It will be the culmination of an entire school years worth of study where the pain points in our Student Assignment process. I hope folks will come out to that. A few of our events everybody is invited to the sf u. S. D cell bracing friday may 4th. At eight at the asian center. The grand opening on may 6th. 14. May is Asian Pacific heritage month and association of chinese teachers has partnered with other organizations to present angel island immigrant voices on sunday may 7th. From 123. And the first 50 children age 12 and under get a goody bag. So be there early kevin tuit is coordinating a 50 50 day on wednesday may 10th. I want to thank Vice President mendozamcdonnell for bringing this to my attention. It is a global celebration of gender equity including a 20 minute film and 24 hour global live cast the organization is planning the clearinghouse for 8,000 events in 42 states in 36 country im pleased to see a set of sf u. S. D schools to participate sunny side taylor cis diaboli cis and burton i want to encourage all of our schools to participate involves a 20 minute film and discussion. There is ready to go class curriculum available on the website let it ripple. Org. You can find it by going to 50 50 day. Finally, bay view Hunters Point music and art show case is happening thursday may 11th. At 5 30 to 6 30 at the willy brown Junior Middle School thank you. Thank you commissioner rasi. Commissioner sanchez . Rules committee may first. 7 00 p. M. Commissioner . Committee meeting at monday may 8th. 6 00 p. M. Vice president mendozamcdonnell . Thank you. There was not a building and Grounds Committee meeting this month we will have the next one on may the 22 and i have a couple of announcements as well. Or thank yous i want to thank you comcast that came out with 300 plus volunteers to help work on the cool this past saturday i want to thank the puc for the urban eco fair. They have on college park a garden that is used heavily by both fermont and jennifer sarah, thank you. Which say beautiful site and they use heavily. I want to congratulate harvey millm on the festival we had fun out there the academy of science hosting their gala thursday may 27th. They have been incredible partners the funds theyre raising will be to have more elementary School Students to come to the academy for free. I want to remind everyone that spark sf is hosting their gala on may the 12th. At the Fairmont Hotel we encourage you to buy your tickets come on out with our new superintendent Vince Mathews and well as princeal and teacher of the year award recipients and the superintendent will be honoring six of his Scholarship Award recipients buy your tickets join us. We will have dancing this year i dont want to miss that. Thank you. The exciting, only one adjective tonight. The committing meeting will be this thursday april 27th. 4 00 pm instead of 6 00 p. M. With that said, section m other informational items posted in agenda. Is informational reports posted gifts for the month of 2017. Section n adjournment this meeting is dead dated to january ono. We will go into close i resume the regular Board Meeting the closed session items from tonight and closed session action items from april 18th. The read out tonight the board vote of 5ayes two absent. Approve the will not renew notices for one principle the vote by five ayes two absent. Approve the with not renew notices for Program Administrator vote by five ayes two absent. Hand commissioner haney commissioner norton for assistant principle. The board by the vote of five ayes two ablent. Approve the may not notices from one supervisor report out of closed action items from tuesday april 18th. 2017 the board by the vote of 4ays three nays expulsion of one student. The board by a vote of seven ayes approved the contract one assistant problem. Board by the vote of seven ayes approve the contract for one administrator. The vote by the board of seven ayes may not noticed for one princeal in one case of anticipated litigation the board by the vote of seven ayes given to count and the vote of jd versus u. S. D six ayes one absent cook. To settle for the stipulated amount, this meeting is adjourned week. The San Francisco. The reporter has many opportunities to get out and placing play a 4 thousand acres of play rec and park has a place win the high sincerely the place to remove user from the upper life and transform into one of mother nachdz place go into the rec and park camp mather located one hundred and 80 square miles from the bay bridge past the oakland bridge and on and on camp mather the city owned Sierra Nevada camping facility is outings outside the gate of Yosemite Park it dates back before the area became is a popular vacation it i sites it was home to indians who made the camp where the coral now stands up and artifacts are found sometimes arrest this was the tree that the native people calm for the ac accordions that had a high food value the acorns were fatally off the trees in september but they would come up prosecute the foothills and were recipe the same as the people that came to camp camp is celebrating its 90th year and the indians were up here for 4 thousand we see every day of them in the grinding rocks around the camp we have about 15 grinding sites in came so it was a major summer report area for the 92 hawks. Through there are signs that prosperity were in the area it was not until the early part of the century with the 76 began the construction of damn in helpfully a say mill was billed open the left hand of the math for the construction by which lake was used to float logs needed for the project at the same time the Yosemite Park and company used the other side of the camp to house tourists interesting in seeing the National Park and the constructions of damn when the u son damn was completed many of the facilities were not needed then the city of San Francisco donated the property it was named camp mather the first director it was named after him Tuesday Morning away amongst the pine the giant sequoia is the giants inventories first name if our title is camp means theres going to be dirt and bugs and so long as you can get past that part this place it pretty awesome i see i see. With a little taste of freedom from the city life you can soak up the country life with swimming and volley ball and swimming and horseback riding there you go buddy. We do offer and really good amount of programming and give a sample p of San Francisco rec and Park Department has to offer hopefully weve been here 90 years my camp name is falcon im a recession he leader ive been leading the bill clinton and anarchy and have had sometimes arts and crafts a lot of our guests have been coming for many years and have almost glutin up, up here he activity or Children Activity or parent activity here at camp mather you are experiencing as a family without having to get into a car and drive somewhere fill your day with with what can to back fun at the majestic life the essence of camp mather one thing a thats been interesting i think as it evolves theres no representation here oh, theres no representation so all the adults are engine i you know disconnected so theres more connection the adults and parents are really friendly but i think in our modern culture i you know everyones is used to be on their phones and people are eager to engagement and talk they dont have their social media so here they are at camp mather how are i doing. How are you doing it has over one hundred hundred cabins those rustic structures gives camp mather the old atmosphere that enhances the total wilderness experience and old woolen dressers and poaches and rug i do lay out people want to decorate the front of thaifr their cabins and front poefrnz their living room is outside in this awesome environment theyre not inviting their guests inside where the berms are people get creative with the latinamerican and the bull frogs start the trees grow and camp mather is seen in a different light were approaching dinner time in the construction of the hetch hetchy damn the Yosemite Park built Jackson Diane hauling hall to serve the guests it does was it dbe does best service s serve the food. Im the executive chef i served over 15 hundred meals a day for the camp mather folks breakfasts are pancakes and french toast and skranld eggs and hash browns our meal formulate is we have roost lion its reflecting of the audience we have people love our meals and love the idea they can pick up a meal and do worry about doing the dishes can have a great time at camp mather after camp people indulge themselves everyone racks go in a place thats crisis that i air after the crackinging of a campfire a campfire. The evening is kept up with a tenant show a longed tradition it features music i tried this trick and this talent show is famous for traditional things but we have new things the first 7, 8, 9 being on stage and being embarrassed and doing random things unlike my anothers twinkling stars are an unforcible memory admission to camp mather is through a lottery it includes meals and camp programs remember all applicant registration on line into a lottery and have a rec and Park Department family account to register registration typically begins the first week of january and ends the first week in february this hey sierra oasis is a great place to enjoy lifeiest outside of the hustle and bustle and kickback and enjoy and a half everything is so huge and beautiful. The children grew up her playing around and riding their bites e bicycles its a great place to let the children see whats outside of the city common experience is a this unique camp when you get lost in the high sierra Wilderness Camp mather is waiting and we look forward to City Managers Office you here soon here are these amendments. All right. Good afternoon, everybody welcome to the board of supervisors language for that monday, april 17, 2017, my name is mark farrell ill be chairing and joined by supervisor peskin Community Member supervisor tang and with us is supervisor Hillary Ronen thank ms. Alicia and others from sfgovtv for covering this mooring and madam clerk, any announcements . Electronic devices. Completed speaker cards and documents to be included should be submitted to the clerk. Items acted upon today will appear on the april 25th board of supervisors agenda unless otherwise stated. Okay. Thank you very much madam clerk temperature item no. 1 Green Building and environment codes requirements for installation of electric vehicle electrical vehicle chargers undergoing major alterations and making appropriate findings. Thank you this was sponsored by supervisor katie tang so im going to turn it over to you. Very much were here to make a simple amendment to the ev readiness we heard at land use and hearing concerns from various associations the indictment has met with organization as much as as Sf Apartment Association and well have a proposed change on page 7 starting listen 6 through 8 essentially we are exempting projects that are undertaken specifically to meet the you may have a seat. Schematic retrofit program from the ev readiness ordinance as you recall from last week the be argument made was that the city has a mandatory program and another ev ordinance on top that so there is a desire to exempt the you may have a seat. Schematic retrofit buildings from the ev readiness ordinance so i dont know if you have any questions sf environment staff are here otherwise ill make a motion avenue public commissioners comments, and questions. On number one. To supervisor tang i appreciate the fact the department of the environment undertook those meetings and appreciate this amendment i spoke a little bit based on correspondence that we received there was another point raised with regard to also exempting accessary dwelling units in the same regard not that i think will be many in the 25 thousand square feet buildings but i was wondering if there are any conversations with the department of the environment or i know those issues were raised and correspondence we received. Sure maybe ill have dbe month from the department of the environment who is part of the conversation. Good afternoon, supervisors for the record geremo department of the environment as supervisor tang mentioned at the last meeting we heard broadbased support for the ordinance but the department and the department of housing raised concerns we may be seated with them a good meeting walk through the ordinance in great detail about the drafts and the many types of buildings undergoing market octavia retrofit and some of the adus questions i think we came to a good agreement on the amendments that is before you today where arent to the schematic retrofit program looked at the projects that are call the roll. At the dbi and looked at it the definitions and the projects to see if theyll trigger the retrofits and require this out of abundance of caution we decided to go with the amendments before you where were is the accessary dwelling units again, we building that the ordinance has strong provisions in place to address many of those types of projects again, the 25 thousand square feet definition of a planned area really is extremely large as well as to have to pull you know of significant electrical Plumbing Mechanical structure we feel those provisions are Strong Enough in the existing ordinance to deal with the adus and if it does become an issue to identify the projects that trigger well send it back to the board and address those concerns thank you. So chair peskin and supervisor tang i mean based on what mr. Recordings said and as far as as we dont want to discourage them ill offer a amendment number 5 to insert after accepting Public Comment where a project is under construction of the c of planning code. Supervisor tang thank you. I do appreciate that thought but i have to stand by what mr. Rodriguez said when it comes to major renovations i forgot what page but clarified the dbi 3 out on im sorry on page 43, 3 out of 4 structural and mechanical, electrical and or Plumbing Systems so again page 4 on the bottom as mr. Rodriguez mentioned those are significant amounts where in most cases probably you wouldnt trigger an adu alteration and okay. Colleagues any further discussion okay open up for Public Comment anyone from the public wish to comment on item number one, please come forward and line up against the far wall two minutes. Good afternoon, supervisors San Francisco Apartment Association thank you very much to all of you and thanks to the department of the environment for working on this legislation with us our initial requests was to exempt seismic a exempt adus from this program we believe that getting more adus on the market is a really important policy goal of this board of supervisors and we want to make that as easy as possible so if we could exempt those that would be our preference but dont want to say that is department of the environment has not reached out to us and done their best we kind of reached this policy impasse so whatever you decide today, our policy goal to get as much schematic work done and as many adus on the market as possible thank you. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Good afternoon, supervisors corey smith on behalf of the housing coalition. Actually agree with the previous speakers comments between one familyfriendly equipment and at the same time want housing with the adu protective forward with our support. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Good afternoon, supervisors laura on behalf of spur and to support the proposed legislation for the environment code for the vehicle charges and undergoing major alteration im not prepared to comment on the proposed thing but spur has thought we, of course, need to solve the housing but little climatic change and in the 2016 policy in the bay area we find that personal cars are the largest Green House Gas emissions in the bay area and hope by 0100 percent of cars needs to be zero Mission Vehicles and meet the goals by 2050 we need to add more charging capacity that legislation is directly in line with the spur represents that requires all residential and commercial dont know how many in the future but ev ready and at the capacity and as sf shows reducing the costs of retrofits i would prefer an earlier version of this provision like oakland 10 percent be added we offer our support including with the seismic with one request for we and others building the electrical cars should grow as cars in the future we acknowledge that is other technologies may and eclipse the electrification and the ownership could decline as shared vehicles and wireless would be available suggest a review in 4 or 5 years to see how the implementation is going and the scaling up of electrification is relevant to the adu. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Hi, my name is spencer represent the charge point and thank you for the opportunity in support of this legislation i want to expand our network the latter in the country the ev chasing stations in San Francisco county. The north bay have over one and thirty are corporate customers n judah the city of San Francisco im working with Property Managers and tenant that point the benefit of those charges and have high tech employers and nonprofit schools hospitals and misrepresent housing across the Diverse Group of stakeholder where retrofits how to keep down the costs and this proposed legislation is an important step and charge that it in is in support that have this wellthoughtout legislation whether we need to plan ahead should be up one in 5 vehicles are sold in the bay area u. S. Ev sales has grown every year and looking at 35 percent more than last year for easy so how to best support those electrical vehicles to do that is cost elective this legislation is welldesigned in support of that. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Good afternoon members of the board thank you for thank you for your time im bill on behalf of tesla to over our support of proposed ordinance for make ready charging infrastructure in order to meet the state goals over the coming years that is necessary to increase access to ev charges infrastructure both with that lafrp and more affordable long term vehicles with the model 3 well have more ev drivers detrimentally in dense urban arrests with charging infrastructure may be difficult for high cost and may put an ev out of someones reach this is a low cost solution given the analysis by pg e that demonstrate up front costs versus retrofit with the ev infrastructure thank you very much thank you. Next speaker, please. Hello chair peskin and supervisors my name is jeff the cocorridor local 350 climate nonprofit want to support in legislation and thank you to the department for working on that we do a lot of work in the bay area quality and tomorrow theyll be approving their clean air plan for 2050 to be follows free and this is a crystal piece of that and ultimately you know we civilization will end if we dont substantially river our climate issue it is penny wise and pound foolish to be quickly over one we know well need 100 percent electrification and support the comments there is a place for Technology Review at a time to make sure were not spending money on most that ineffective we are keeping up with the new itself trend but ultimately make sure that every parking space in the city eventually can priority 40 provide for nonprofit transportation that needs to startle now, when industry will be more expensive want to flag that i mentioned the bay area of Quality Management theyll be looking at providing funding best practices, etc. On ev charging and could spread legislation like this around the region lastly sfaep sonoma has instituted a program for the adoption if cleanpowersf didnt meet those charges. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Hello supervisors my name is stacey im the ceo of the power we are a charging Service Providers to permeate dwellers i think the points that were made by the prior commenters are on point ill highlight as well that there is a social balance social justice for charging for apartment dwellers currently according to the cc m it that administrators the Ev Rebate Program 95 percent of all vehicles that are influencing in have been sold to singlefamily homeowners yet San Francisco has 2 3rds of the population that rents ios renters would like to have charges and electrical vehicles have been denied federal rebates and state rebates and to the salesforce that electrical vehicles what provide to the ownership and as a result that is impoverishing the community by denying the access of those savings so keep in mind as much as possible providing assess for renters a significant benefit on multiple levels thank you. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Anyone else wish to speak on number one, feel free to line up on the screen side of the room. Im here representing ever charge were also in support of this legislation i would like to point out that current a 10 to one ev charges to electrical vehicles stations in the city this needs to change for the electrical vehicles to ton to grow and 90 percent of ev drivers peace officer to charge at work or home or both are available this legislation absolutely meets that goal and i very much hope you put it forward thank you. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Hi laura clark action i wanted that remind everyone this is maybe okay legislation but the most powerful thing to do to make sure that we are buildings Green Community to build dense urban refill that is building more housing this may increase the costs of building housing thank you. Thank you anyone from the public wish to comment in Public Comment okay seeing none, Public Comment is closed. For number one supervisor tang. Thank you very much thank you for your comments i will work with it sf environment in terms of reevaluating whatever technology is on the market absolutely that is crucial and so you have my commitment to continue to do and sf environment and i will say, i would proposes the amendment to exempt the Seismic Retrofit Program in selfill not include adus we already have quite a high threshold that triggers a major alteration and on top that we want to currently many people to be able to drive ev as possible and capturing the window of time less expensive to be able to install the infrastructure rather than going back to Old Buildings to install the charges i would like to make a motion to adopt the motion on page 7 lines 7 and 8. Supervisor tang made a motion and supervisor peskin on that motion without objection. So were clear first of all, thank you to the department of the environment and supervisor tang and the mayor for putting this forward it is very good legislation i think that the amendment that we are i think all in agreement is about balancing competing needs to very important Public Policy about seismic safeties and climatic change i think that number 5 fails in the same vein not used much but take advantage in new construction in most case but to the extended we have a priority of building adus id like to have a vote on that one sentence amended i offered number 5 under the number 4, ill prepared to take without objection. First of all, supervisor tang emotion and supervisor peskin seconded by without objection and supervisor peskin you want to make a motion. Yeah. I made the motion i dont think in committee we need to second but vote on that. Okay roll call vote on supervisor peskin motion. On the amendment by supervisor peskin supervisor tang no supervisor peskin supervisor farrell nope. There are 2 one i and one no im sure that is part of discussion in a few minutes and i want to thank commissioner tang and the dipt for working on this issue it is awesome legislation about a year since electrical vehicles and an awesome experience but feel it is for the right reasons so the more we deal with legislation i want to thank and supervisor tang for this issue so with that, the underlying item a roll call vote. Supervisor peskin a roll call vote. Okay motion by supervisor tang. Through the chair with a positive recommendation as amended and a committee report. Without objection. All right. Item no. 2 urging the evaluation and allocation of properties for urban agriculture. The properties fushlg. It was sponsored by supervisor ronen and supervisor tang so supervisor ronen. Thank you colleagues today im proud to assume the officeship of a resolution together with supervisor tang on urban Agriculture Supervisor avalos the former district 11 supervisor introduced this on the feed of the closure of the city garden in district 11 last december that was a beloved neighborhood gardener for urban agriculture this resolution reaffirms San Franciscos commitment to allocate properties for urban agriculture so that hopefully in the misfortune we can recreate the magic of little city garden without shutting down in 2009 San Francisco made a commitment to prioritize un and local Food Productions from mayor gavin newsom the healthy and Sustainable Food for San Francisco in 2011, the city demonstrated further commitment by administrative review the planning code to allow United States umg in all zones throughout the city as recently as 2014 our city created the first urban agriculture incentive zone by implementing the Assembly Bill that loud the city to evaluate sites including surplus city sites thats been 3 years and not yet secured the land for the if you will indulge me projects that what provide Educational Opportunity for children and families and adults and the chance to grow fruits and vegetables here within the city i understand that there are questions about competing priorities for land use given our huge affordability and hicks housing crisis in the city certainly building housing is a top priority housing is a top priority we have to balance our Housing Development in this city where some agricultural space for heath fresh foods for the residents and connection and for the unification in neighborhoods that resolution calls the assessment of a limited number of suitable sites for the Development Challenges have been rendered vacate and underused foresight from flooding and limited egress that have a history of aulgz usage and sites identified by the Community Groups to be desirable for architectural i made in the portal neighborhood which is known and has been declared the Garden District of San Francisco ways in the past century that was a place for new immigrants to establish themselves by growing flowers and other things geographically and hiv that has perfect weather for the city for the implementations of a urban agriculture project as a contribute to the neighborhood groups i hope this resolution is a step to accomplishing that goal and the urban agriculture projects are valuable assets they help to galvanize the neighborhood and provide hands on education about produce and preservation and understanding the larger agricultural system long use tenure has proven an important thing as addressed by the Assembly Bill in 2014 if we want want this to be a permanent fixer for San Francisco Educational Opportunities we need to forge a pathway for urban agriculture projects to assess outside of temporary land use spaces before i open up to commissioner tang and my colleagues in Public Comment i wanted to give a huge thanks from supervisor avalos for beginning this to kate from the little city gardens youll hear from shortly and angelian from the urban Agriculture Alliance and others that or the cofounder the project and eli from spur and karen from the sf cause for working with former Supervisor John Avalos and my office to form a resolution i hope that gives us more momentum to we can secure the goals of gaining space where we can have permanent urban agriculture in San Francisco thank you very much. Supervisor tang did you have any comments if none have comments open up for Public Comment and im oh, im sorry. calling names from rec and park and has a brief presentation thank you so much for being here. Thank you, supervisors im the brand new urban and Community Gardens Program Manager for the rec and park i recently moved to rec and park from the department of the environment where i worked for 10 years on a variety of things with the urban agriculture and worked on those policies that you mentioned in our introductions im delighted to be part of rec and park and providing more direct service and happy to talk about the urban agriculture and Community Gardens so overall i wanted to give some overall of what rec and park does to support the Community Service in our San Francisco and take questions. So we have two major goals for spotting Community Gardens one is to provide a direct support for garden and provide leadership within our Community Garden network anhiand have a lead role of our sister agencies on the ushlg policies for the first point rec and park oversee and provide support of 39 Community Gardens with the Community Gardeners have over one thousand plots available for purchase in San Francisco and have alamany farm the largest and longest urban farm in San Francisco that farm has has approximately 7 thousand hours of volunteer hours dedicated were proud of that site we also acknowledge there is a high unmet need for Community Garden space in general in San Francisco we have more than 35 hundred people sign up to an a wait list to get a Community Garden that demonstrates we have 11 hundred plots and 35 hundred people waiting for the second role rec and park supports an un citywide were reessentially the Ad Working Group and working to reestablish the open garden days we give away resources to Community Gardens and their gardens whenever their gardening and were also looking to identify stakeholders additional stormwater that will fascinate the workshops that will balance the budget all our City Resident im available to answer any questions if you have any. Great. I think im going to open up for Public Comment if in my colleagues dont have any questions okay. Thank you very much. With that, i will actually open up for Public Comment. All right. Anyone from the public wish to comment on item number 2, feel free to line up on the screen side of the room. Everyone will have two minutes. My name is karen im here on behalf of bee cause in support of resolution our organization was founded in 2010 and sponsored by the Parks Alliance and 3 olympics to educate resident no need to be afraid of bees native or honey bees and what kind of bees in San Francisco and what we can do to help them and why are honey bees and native bees are important in their environment their pollination helps the argue more successful and maintain the bio diversity from 2010 to 12 we were on the farm on the part that is developed for housing in 2012, we have a charitable use of half an acre on san bruno on the edge of the Visitacion Valley neighborhood sins then turned the neighborhood eyesore into eye candy were the bee farm and conducted 3 projects first, we won a two year bee keeping Apprenticeship Program and began the fifth program and for demonstration we grow bee pollination and other plants managed by volunteers this we conduct bee surveys 2017 will be the third year nothing like the bee farm no where in the United States there simply isnt and unique were entirely selfsupporting the honey produced and managed by the bee keeping Apprenticeship Program the new owner will develop housing that is great but we also want to continue and we are looking for a site thank you. Thank you very much. Next speaker, please. Supervisors thank you very much for having this hearing on this important topic im the president of urban resources the home of just one tree projects and other green promotions we have been advocating for greater urban Health Alliance for thirty years our city does a great job in setting the goals for religiously the Carbon Footprint but the food areas is hit hard i think that most of us know the majority of our food comes if 2000 will miles away at every mail 5 ingredients from another country we must focus on Food Production in the city i think many people thought we couldnt do it here not having the land we have some land and other production sites that are important we can go vertical that is the nature of our demonstration project our goal is to show that any city even the densest city in america like San Francisco, california selfalign we pick lemon trees only 11 thousand to be sufficient this is what weve been trying to do this legislation is important because public land is where a lot of the Food Production can take place many of the agencies that have land does not think about it in terms of Food Production id like to suggest this legislation add to the list maybe include owl city agencies our biggest lemon orchid site theyll not normally be thinking about Food Production but have a good leader ill expand all the legislation to include all city agencies reporting about what land they have thank you. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Good afternoon, supervisors todd to support this we think that the community farms and the commercial automatic is important part of livable city if you look at studies from philadelphia having the access to Community Gardens and farms and people growing food for improvement of innovation is helping the pocketbooks and helping to save money and build communities and a huge number of gardens reports that are connections with neighborhood improve Mental Health physical health there are a myriad of benefits and competition for land this is important as we move forward we hope you will think about equality we had a map if you look at the general plan with the playgrounds and the radius around playground you realize this is a desert their low income Communities Community with recipients that dont have garden in their communities so the key piece to find the land as your assessing think about mapping and another standard for accesstolysis another stunt here we find food on rooftops we have an issuance a lot of that is habitat like the community of science but it can be urban architectural look at the 25 percent of the citys in the public rightofway about 13 blocks unaccessible and not maintained that is a huge land use you can find the skweeflz i skwieflz and green space by taking 10 percent of public rightofway so a lot of opportunities and hopefully that is the beginning the conversation thank you. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Good morning supervisors im kate less than and the cofounder of the farms until our closing 2, 3, 4 december we were the only farm grew food and flowers and offered tech programs we worked onsite close to seven years and when we were there the gate was open for food im here to spotlight this it is conducting liz cotter was a narrow property that flooded only assessable on one side and owners failed to get permits for the Housing Development before he we exited the site the properties is notable here particularly challenging site for decades and particularly well suited for neighborhoods funds and unfortunately despite our efforts for pretty much weve been in conversation with folks and it went on the market in 2014 and purposed quickly that past fall despite hundreds of members the Planning Commission felt their hands were tied and approved the plans for the development the loss of this site where the policy came to fruition so today as the land farmer with incredible experience he look to the resolution to help us figure out how to move forward and i think there is a lot of Untapped Potential and the availability of farm is dwindling we need the citys support we hope weve got our vote in favor. Next speaker good afternoon. My name is marion a cocoordinator as the Alliance Works to help to pass a. D. 551 and San Francisco was the first to implement urban zones we believe that this resolution will be a way for the city to show the continued resolve for supporting european e that ushlg the first coordinator for rec and park showed Public Interest in urban agriculture people want to get involved and know the benefits and as you may know we have high Property Values and not enough housing so the city is responsible to try to prioritize in the places where it is it can happen we believe this resolution can help to show that resident and other cities that the government of San Francisco is dedicated to making sure we dont lose those more spaces that are possible for urban agriculture obviously not as high of a monetary value but other value so, please vote yes on this resolution thank you. Good afternoon. My name is patricia a unite whaler in the bayview and a farm in alamed it provides employment for homeless and im here to support the resolution that we believe will be a step in the right direction there are a few institutions that has the impacts on a community and makes that for myself ill not be here without little city garden and has been in the city on a regular basis the trainees at the farm talks about hallway u how this helps their families wellness and this work has become valuable spaces that art and health and food ecology and cultural and blight and sustainability politics and so many issues come together and unique in some ways those desire direct attention and engagement should not be close to the margin in the city to keep it assessable and connected to the community their part of the farmable lands will be missed once it is turned into condo how can those recovered the city is hard fought made hard steps towards this in the past and this resolution is another incredibly value step in the right direction and continuing to cultivate a city for progress thank you. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Good afternoon, supervisors my name is eli on behalf of spur im here to support the resolution thank you, supervisor ronen and supervisor tang for bringing it forward first, the support of this for a variety of reasons one of the biggest is education connecting people in the city to a sense of what fresh food is and 2012 report called the public harvest we recommended the city continue to identify the public land and sites for acquisition we can expand urban agriculture i want to note on the 2009 executive director inventory that look at this and may i less than pulled this together but the puc is developed this an education there is a good chance well find additional spots i understand the concern of competition with housing working with spur we understand this and want to see more housing and 3 things we want a mix of open space not all sites are suitable for housing and not for if you will indulge me but this should say a be a case by case and more importantly that doesnt dictate where this will happen it only calls for the city to examine this and identify the sites at that point the evaluation we can do the balancing for other uses i hope youll supported this and thank you for your time. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Good afternoon, supervisors i volunteered at the this city garners for a year and a half for the support of farms a unique place especially in a city environment of most i got involved the more i learned about urban agriculture and place like austin and brooklyn and others this is why i found shopping with the San Francisco a place usually at the forefront of proving changes cant protect its own viable farms there was a ton of support to keep this operational neighbors came out and you cant august that with the real estate value and pollution and noise reductions i myself was inspired to start my openly own Small Business i sold ice cream in my own backyard in order to grow the business i need a plot in the future with the Farm Movement now growing being the normal i imagine im not the only one please port this this is beneficial to our neighborhoods and environment thank you. Thank you. Next speaker. Hi good afternoon. My name is Richard Chung a volunteer at the little city garden for the past 5 years im grateful to have state your full name for the record on them and in support nephew resolution he went to school at marshall and in the district i see this concrete concrete concrete and im grateful to have moved off and nurturing that aspect thank you. Thank you. Next speaker, please. Good morning supervisors thank you, supervisor ronen for introducing this legislation my name is lou which i im here on behalf of the greenhouse were with the portal district and our current Central Project is 777 an entire block were working as a urban farm for the benefit of Portal Community in San Francisco largely first, i want to echo everyones sentiments about the robust benefits of urban agriculture the city environment and the health and wellness and how critical for the residents of San Francisco this legislation address an obstacle when we interviewed people how difficult to secure the access to and continue using land for automatic in American City and counties cities it is true in San Francisco where undeveloped planned lapd is harder and harder to find given San Franciscos longstanding commitment to sustainability and resilience and its recent investment in urban agriculture the city want wait to preserve the parcels for farming as a pro tem site that makes auto the contrary and so forth in the resolution 770 will serve there the robust and john Training Program and part of next chapter of urban agriculture speaking on behalf of the Portal Community we give me our support and develop the urban agriculture in the city over one hundred Community Members gathered to celebrate the neighborhood recognized as the district and lord to an agricultural as the portal addition once again the Portal Community urges the committee and the committee of the whole to pass this legislation thank you. Thank you. Next speaker. Hi, im keri a san franciscan and live in the Mission Neighborhood i actually little city garden is around the corner from my house this resolution could be one of those things with the last commercial farm in we lost that battle and really want to be part of a city that has this resolution can be one of the things that could have saved that farm maybe you can safe other farms and have spaces for them so, please consider it thank you. Thank you. Next speaker. Hi laura clark action i wanted to remind everyone were less dense than we have a lot of space we can building more housing especially on the west side to actually take a real bite out of our you know climate goal but additionally im concerned that kind of resolution can be used to fight against shadows maybe cast on a Community Garden which building 2013 housing it is most useful thing to do with the dismays this can be used to fight housing obviously thats the only thing i care about. Thank you. Is there any additional Public Comment on item number 2 . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. Supervisor ronen i have one question sure. First of all, thank you for bringing up this forward i grew up where my mom was a member of the action on federal land it is different but awesome growing up in San Francisco and a lot of the comments having diversities of spaces and not just a concrete jungle i agree that only question i go supervisor ronen through the City Attorney how will this effect our surface land and heirs ordinance and how will we justify kind of or reconcile the two, if you will. Sure i mean would you like me to answer i think we Just Creative a catalog of possible things to look at it and to consider when looking at pieces of land whether surface or properties perhaps the city can acquire to create urban agriculture not a you know prison thing weo show evaluate the for land use one piece of pulse is that appropriate for the Housing Development near and dear to my Heart Properties ordinance but not all of those pieces of properties some are too small and some inappropriate when that is the case another aspect to look at when deciding whether or not the particular piece of land will be appropriate for urban agriculture. Well done okay you thank you very much. Sorry supervisor ronen. I want to really thank everyone for coming out today and say that we learned unfortunately, the heartbreaking loss of little city garden and fight to preserve it and during that fight learning about how much that garden brought to the neighborhood and brought to San Francisco as a whole was you know a very sad way as a city to be educated by the benefits ever urban agriculture and sad to say were not able to safe that farm but hold that loss in the memory we no longer have in that farm together with the resolution to continue the many years of the citys focus on urban agriculture well renew the sense of urgency around the need to create a new space and i really want to echo some of the Public Comment around equality and especially in areas of city that are predesert that we particularly looking at those areas for potentially to acquire the surplus this is a resolution recommitting ourselves to this project but committed to continuing to work on this issue and partner with rec and park, cca our Real Estate Division and any city agency that shares the goals to realize a permanent space to have additional ushlg space and hopefully another commercial farm here in our city so with that, colleagues, i will ask for your support colleagues any commissioners comments, and questions. Okay motion by supervisor ronen. All right. I dont think i can. Ill make a motion. Thank you very much sorry. Make that motion to. Send it to the full board with a positive recommendation. Motion by supervisor tang colleagues, can we take that without objection . Objection so moved. Number 3. Item no. 2 planning code construction of accessory dwelling units. Into conformity with the state law mandate and michael appropriate findings. Okay. This item was supported by supervisor peskin so im going to turn it over to to him. Must chair peskin and supervisor tang as you may know over the last decade and maybe dozen years thinking around secondary units we call them accessary dwellings has evolved i think in 2002 actually introduced an ordinance to try to look at the development of more and more o more of the inlaw units but in those days, the third rail the politics in San Francisco and i was i think i fella vote shy fast forward a decade my successor david chiu passed a similar ordinance and after that ms. Turner or Supervisor Scott Wiener did a Pilot Program and my predecessor pioneered a similar albeit it adu legislation for district 3 and in as far as great minds think liquor the chair and i had similar legislation that came down to a coin toss with the b anthony dollars to interesting enough and our two pieces of legislation laterally end up condo to one another and the subject of ongoing conversations and amendment that will be discussing in the week ahead the state Legislature Passed a law that become effective on january 1st, i was informed by the deputy City Attorney that typically our law was out of compliance so what is before us today is what the City Attorney recommends to bring this back into compliance that was heard by the Planning Commission on february 23rd and again briefly on a thorough procedural matters last thursday and some of the most important suggestions that planning made i have gotten the zoo to incorporate and they are ready to speak to and i will hand to you colleagues there is one and here is another actually. That one is for the City Attorney theyre the same. And so we have representative from the Planning Department here today what i indicated to the Planning Commission ill do duplicate the file today and would like to in the interest of time send the first part with a few amendments and well hear from the City Attorney about a couple of the missing details actually typos that we will need to amend in the whole and the duplicate file will be continued to presumably the land use and Transportation Committee after may figure that out is may 8 i believe if im doing the math right and entertain the trailing amendments on that day and with that, im happy to hear from the Planning Department staff and colleagues and members of the public sorry just to be clear i think that is sounds like are you going to speak to those or the Planning Department. The major amendment is the amendment that was appointed by Planning Department staff and that is to have this legislation include singlefamily homes in misrepresent family Zoning Districts that was necessary and was an oust to conform with state law and that the minor technical amendments john gibner, deputy City Attorney. And speak to actually maybe in our version of with my mark ups there is a sub one that actually is supposed to be sub 3 on one moment if i gave you the one i marked up mr. Gibner you want to speak to those. Hold on no, no we should step back and as opposed to flipping throw things and going through different amendments talk about one by one what is contained in here. Planning or to supervisor peskin. Good afternoon Planning Department staff i would like to first thank you supervisor peskin and appreciate his efforts for keeping the adu program in compliance to state law and in a timely manner the state law finds that the programs are not in compliance with the state law theyll be demonstrated null and avoid this item was before the Planning Commission on february 23rd and strongly supported the ordinance that the following modifications the first is about adus and rh1 district the proposed ordinance maintains the language in the code that makes the general reference to the stating for adus in rh1 d districts at the same time the ordinance creates the detailed new set of standards for the adus and singlefamily homes in rh1 and rh1 h from the planning code is required the commission represents accepting the rh3 for the same set of standards without the recommendation the department will need to issue a Zoning Administrator bulletin to implement the state law for rh1 b district to develop this the department will duplicate the work of the ordinance interpreting the state law the state law that informed the new controls in this ordinance the second recommendation is about the types of spaces eligible for conversion of adus the proposed ordinance that allows 0 the space from an existing unit but not from the garage the staff the Planning Commission recommends including the garages as an eligible space to be converted to adus that is consistent with the citys policy with adu in the past couple of years that allowed for the garages converted to adus the 3rd. Maam, sorry to interrupt just to be clear what lines are we are talking about here. The line in the ordinance. Uhhuh. The second part