Myself with her comments on this matter, this is not just about rates today, lets be realistic, its not, if we were to approve these rates today, we are approving the program because if we approve these rates, that would essentially authorize the general manager to sign a contract with shell and move forward, so its not just about the rates, its about the whole program and thats why weve raised many of these concerns. Commissioner vietor, do you have anything else to add . Alright. The motion is before us. Would you restate the motion, please. Or does counsel want to restate it . Im hoping she has or does ms. Vietor want to restate it . Sure i will restate. Today is a historic moment not the entire speech. Of the public ewe tult commission, it shows dedication to a decent Greenhouse Gas emission and is become a leader in combating climate change. I, therefore, i understand the Current Program proposal is not final, todays vote is simply a not to exceed rate vote, can i get confirmation from the deputy City Attorney on that, thats the resolved in the rez lawing as i read it, i know theres other language but thats what were voting on . Thats correct, thats the resolve. I know we cannot determine the Program Details until we set the rate, so it is with a great sense of urgency, responsibility and on noer that i make the motion to approve the not to exceed rates at 11. 5 cents without further delay. Alright, the motion was seconded by commissioner moran, is that still the case . Yes. Inger all those in favor, signify by saying aye . Aye. All those opposed . Nee. The motion fails. Were are going to go to closed session, we need a motion to do so. So moved and seconded by commissioner moran to move to closed session. Are there any Public Comments on matters to be discussed in closed session . Are there matters closed session item number 14, conference with legal counsel, existing claim with the proposed settlement agreement, item 15, conference with legal counsel, proposed settlement agreement, item 16 alright, were back in order, is there a motion . Whether to disclose the discussion . Motion not to disclose. Moved. Second. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Other new business . The one that we wanted to put on the record, the settlement, 14 and 15 were approved. Alright. Thank you for making that statement. Any other new business . Alright. This meeting is adjourned. Thank you all very much