Transcripts For MSNBCW The Rachel Maddow Show 20190316

Critically ill. Initially there had been four people in custody in conjunction with these killings. One of those in custody is believed to be the gunman. Hes already showed up in court in new zealand today. Interestingly, new zealand authorities announced that his Court Proceedings today and presumably his future Court Proceedings as well will be closed. They will not be open to the public. Nobody will be allowed to observe them. Theyre describing that as a security decision. That may also have implications in terms of how much this guy wants to continue to try to be a propagandist for his terrorististic ideas that led him to do this as hes done in his online writings as well. Of the other people who were arrested besides him, police had said originally that it was two men and one woman who were arrested in addition to the guy who is believed to be the gunman. Police initially said they were picked up because at least some, if not all of them, had firearms near the scene of the crime. Authorities are now no longer characterizing those three people in any way, except to say that one of those people has since been released from Police Custody after it became clear that that person was actually trying to help police in stopping the event and he was not part of committing it. But these other two people who were arrested besides the guy who is believed to be the gunman, those other two people as of right now remain in custody. Now we know nothing about them and we know nothing about their potential complicity in this act. We also really dont have a clear timeline as yet. The vast majority of those killed, 41 people were killed at the alnur mosque in christchurch, but seven other people were also killed at a different mosque, the linwood mosque, about three miles away. Another person later died at the hospital. We do know from what Law Enforcement has described that happened, the man in custody, the gunman, the man who is in court today, he drove to the alnur mosque first and killed those 41 people there and then we know from the way police have described what happened that after the killings at the alnur mochk, mosque, he got back into his vehicle and drove away. It is possible when he drove away, he drove to the other mosque three miles away and committed the other killings there. It has not been explicitly laid out that way by police. They havent given us that level of detail. So that sort of hole in the timeline thus far. That in combination with the fact that other people are still in custody without police saying what their potential involvement in this might have been just means that some of the basics here remain unsaid and we still have a lot to learn about what happened. But as of tonight, a lot of people are still being treated for injuries. As i said, Christchurch Hospital just said that as many as a dozen people are viewed as critically ill, which means, you know, the death toll may yet rise above the almost unbelievably high number of 49 people already known to have died. So we will have more ahead on this still unfolding story tonight. This in part is going to be the subject of the interview that were going to do here on set tonight. But before we get to that, were actually going to start tonight with an exclusive. With a bit of a scoop. At the beginning of the Trump Administration, there were a lot of somewhat strange personnel choices made by the incoming president. I mean, even in the cabinet. Rick perry for energy secretary, right . Rick perry had not only proposed abolishing the Energy Department, he also appeared to believe that the Energy Department was the oil and gas part of the government and not the part that deals with, like, nuclear weapons. He didnt even appear to understand that once he had been named the secretary of energy. So that was a weird choice. Also remember the Party Planner for eric trumps wedding was put in charge of housing in the northeastern United States. That was a weird choice. Also, the president s personal bankruptcy lawyer, his bankruptcy lawyer was named ambassador to israel for the United States. Also, the president really did make an effort to try to make his personal pilot the head of the faa. So there were some weird choices right off the bat. One less high profile but equally weird choice came when President Trump picked a man named scott loyd to be the director of the office of Refugee Resettlement. That was a weird choice, too, because scott lloyd had never worked with refugees ever. He had never worked with resettling anyone, so the idea that he would be in charge of resettling refugees was odd. What scott lloyd had done in his life is he had been a conservative activist lawyer from a Catholic Group called the knights of columbus. He basically was an activist antiabortion guy. His body of public writings included stuff like this. Quote, facts about abortion, why you cant be prolife and procontraception. This was all about how Birth Control is the same thing as abortion and women shouldnt be allowed access to either in this country. All abortions should be illegal for american women and Birth Control should be illegal for american women, too. So that was his public profile before he got put in charge of the office of Refugee Resettlement. If you want to know what happens when you put somebody with that pedigree and that experience in charge of randomly Refugee Resettlement in this country, well, now weve done that as a country. So now we know how that works out. Here is a headline from the l. A. Times, december 2017, trump official sought to block abortion for 17yearold rape victim. Scott lloyd is the trump official in question. Part of this scandal was him writing a memo outlining his reasoning for blocking a teenage rape victim from accessing abortion. Quote, im convinced that assisting with an abortion in this case is not in her best interest. I am mindful that abortion is offered by some as a solution to a rape. I disagree. And then he tried to block her from getting an abortion, using his status as a federal official in charge of this Refugee Resettlement agency in order to do it. The 17yearold in that case, the 17yearold girl who had been raped, she was one of many kids who arrived in the u. S. Applying for refugee status. She was sent alone to a shelter operated by the Trump Administration. At some point along the way she found out that she was pregnant as a result of that rape. In america, it does not matter whether you are an immigrant or not. It doesnt matter your age. It doesnt matter where youre from. In america, you have a constitutionally protected right to get an abortion if you want one. The government is not allowed to stop you from getting one if you want one. That is a decision that you are allowed to make for yourself. It is protected by the constitution. But when scott lloyd took over the office of Refugee Resettlement, he became the guy who was in charge of all of those kids. And he decided he would make it his First Priority in that job to block any girl who came into the clutches of that agency he was running, he would block any girl under his purview at that agency from getting an abortion. The only reason that 17yearold rape victim from that 2017 case, the only reason she eventually was allowed to get an abortion, and the only reason we know about her plight is because she found her way to lawyers at the aclu who took her case, who sued the government on her behalf and won. She was the first jane doe in the case. She decided she wanted an abortion. Its interesting, in her case, she had raised the funds needed to pay for it herself. She had gotten a judge in texas to explicitly grant her permission to get the abortion, despite the fact that she had no way of getting parental consent for it. She had arranged for travel at her own expense to and from her doctors appointments necessary for her to get the abortion. But still, scott lloyds agency, the federal Government Agency he was running wouldnt let her leave the shelter to go to the doctor. That is what ultimately became a Class Action Lawsuit led by that pregnant teenage girl who has literally being forced to continue this pregnancy against her will by the u. S. Government until the aclu intervened to take her case and won it. Bridget amiri is the aclu attorney who sued on her behalf and we talked to her about it at the time. They were literally holding her hostage, blocking the door, preventing her from obtaining an abortion. And i do believe that that was their goal, to hold her hostage until she carried this pregnancy to term against her will. Bridget amiri talking about her client who had the name in court of jane doe. As that case made its way through the courts, the aclu kept turning up more janes, more girls who were being held in shelters overseen by this guy, scott lloyd, who were being blocked from getting an abortion. And it soon became very clear why. This was not just some fluke thing where somebody, like, wasnt properly trained or something, this was an official policy of this agency under this Trump Administration official, scott lloyd. Bridget amiri, the aclu attorney, got to depose scott lloyd as part of that aclu lawsuit. Heres how part of that went. Youre personally opposed to abortion, correct . Yes. Youve written on the subject . Yes. Youre personally opposed to contraception, correct . Um, depends. You wrote an article that said not to be prolife you needed to be anticontraception . Um, that was the title of the article. Something along those lines. Something along those lines. Something like the title of the article why you cant be prolife and procontraception. Something along those lines. So those are his views. Bridget amiri from the aclu goes on to ask him about how it is when hes running this agency that essentially controls the fate and controls the physical movement of all of these girls who are in this country because theyre asking for asylum, how it is that all of these girls in that agency that hes running keep getting blocked from accessing abortions. And watch what she gets him to admit. Have you ever approved an abortion request in your time as orr director . No. Are there any circumstances under which you would approve an abortion request . Objection. Calls for speculation. Im not going to answer that. You can still answer it even though i dont know. Youve denied abortion requests, correct . Yes. Youve denied abortion requests even in the context where the pregnancy is a result of rape, right . Um, yes. So the way the system was working under the Trump Administration is that scott lloyd was in charge of this agency. When a teenage girl who was a rape victim made her way to the United States seeking help in this country, she has to get permission from scott lloyd personally to get an abortion. Because hes weighing in on all of these cases, blocking these girls from getting it. And so scott lloyd has appointed himself the gatekeeper about whether or not the girls are allowed to access the thing theyre supposed to have a constitutional right to get. Hes appointed himself a gate keeper and it turns out hes never granted that permission any time someone has come to that gate. So this was starting to look like a de facto u. S. Government Trump Administration policy. That deposition with scott lloyd was released in february of last year as the lawsuit was still ongoing. Then in april, the New York Times reported something that began to shed a little bit of light on how that policy was carried out. The New York Times reported that scott lloyd, quote, has instructed his staff to give him a spreadsheet each week that tells him about any unaccompanied minors who have asked for an abortion and how far along they are in their pregnancy. In at least one case, he directed staff to read to one girl a discrimination of what happens during an abortion. And when there is a need for counselling, mr. Lloyds office calls on someone from its list of preferred life affirming pregnancy resource centers. So he was keeping a spreadsheet with details that amount to a record of pregnant teens menstrual cycles and he was using that information individualized to these individualized girls, teenagers, and some of them younger, to block them from accessing abortions that they wanted to get. After the New York Times reported that that spreadsheet existed somewhere inside the federal government, a progressive super pac called american bridge filed a freedom of information act request asking the government to hand over that spreadsheet, since thats apparently federal Government Property and federal Government Employees are doing that, tracking these individual girls menstrual cycles and how far along they are in their pregnancies as federal employees, as people who are working at a federal agency for the purpose of controlling what happens to those girls pregnancies. Well, this week, much to the surprise of the people at american bridge, as far as we can tell, the Trump Administration did hand that spreadsheet over, and tonight we have obtained it. And its it is a it is a remarkable thing to look at. Here it is. It is 28 pages long. Let me just show you what were looking at here, as best as we can tell. When the government released this document because of the freedom of information request, they sent it as a pdf document. So they didnt send it as a spreadsheet you could look at as a spreadsheet. That just means the titles of the columns are collapsed in some cases, but we think we know what each of these things means. The first column is the date where the pregnancy was reported. Second column is we think how the pregnancy was reported. How Government Officials found out about it. The next column contains an alien identification number, which is a unique identifying number for each of these kids who has come over to ask for asylum. The government has redacted those here because that would identify these specific girls in this document. But scott lloyd had access to that unique identifying information for each girl. Next is each girls age on this document, the girls ages range from 12 to 17. Next is the name of the shelter where each girl is being held. Then we think this next column is the day each girl was admitted to the shelter. Weve partially redacted this column ourselves because it seems like this kind of information could be used in some bank shot if somebody was trying to identify some of these women so weve redacted some of that ourselves. And then you have in this u. S. Government document the results of their pregnancy tests. They all say positive, positive, positive. Then you have the u. S. Governments calculation of the estimated gestation age, how far along these pregnancies are, tracking them for each of these girls. Then the next line is whether the pregnancy is believed to be the result of consensual sex or not. U. S. Government keeping track of that for each of these girls on this federal government employeeprovided spreadsheet. Then whether or not it was reported as a sexual assault, all those column lines, either reported, not reported. Reported, not reported. Then the second to lamb column is t. O. P. Requested. T. O. P. In this context we think means termination of pregnancy. So the question of whether or not this girl has asked for an abortion. Theyre keeping track of that with each of these girls, including their age, how far along they are in their pregnancy, the gestational age of the fetus as believed by the federal government. The circumstances under which the girl may have become impregnated. Whether or not it was reported as a sexual assault. Is she asking for an abortion . The federal government is tracking all of this for each individual girls, down to age 12. Finally the last column is reserved to notes on each case. You can zoom in on that notes case. In one case theyre talking specifically about the timeline of the girls last menstrual cycle as being tracked by the Trump Administration, except they spell menstrual wrong. This is literally the federal government tracking a 15yearolds period because of what the federal government plans to do about it. Lets look at one entry and detail here. One at random. Just so you can see the kind of data they were collecting. This is a case from march of last year, march of 2018. A 14yearold girl being held in a shelter in illinois. Shes believed to be about one month pregnant from nonconsensual sex. 14yearold girl. As you can see in the notes column, it says assaulted by unknown assailant in coo, which we believes country of origin here. So this is the federal government with your tax dollars keeping an individualized record of pregnant teenage girls menstrual cycles, whether theyve had a positive pregnancy test, what the government knows about how they believe the girls got pregnant, how they believe this individual girl got pregnant and whether this girl has requested an abortion and then the last column, the last column supports what the federal government is doing about it. And this record was being kept for the express purpose of subverting any of these girls ability to get an abortion. This was essentially a spreadsheet designed to facilitate federal Government Action to block these girls from getting any abortion they might want. Cant imagine why any of them would want that given the circumstances described in the cold, hard spreadsheet cells. When you look through this 28page document, i mean, its full of teenagers, in some cases girls who arent yet teenagers who report being raped and being pregnant as a result. And here is scott lloyd, Trump Administration appointee, compiling this information about these girls and using it so he can intervene as a Government Official to block each after these girls individually from being able to get the abortion they have asked for. All the while he was tracking in an ongoing way how far along each girl in her pregnancy was. How long he could delay it until it was illegal, right . How much he had to keep blocking her from leaving the shelter that he controlled until shed be legally forced to give birth thanks to the u. S. Federal government. So this document has never been seen before. This is not the sort of thing were used to seeing. This is not the sort of thing we expect our government to be keeping tabs on in the modern era. But there is one other element of this that i think is, for me, part of this that made me want to sort of close the door and yell at this story a little bit. The part, to me, that is actually the most shocking part of it, because, remember, the aclu had sued to stop scott lloyd from blocking these girls access to abortion, right . They did very well in that suit. On march 30th of last year, they won a major victory in that case. Not only had the original jane doe been allowed finally to get the abortion that she had been seeking, on march 30th, a federal judge granted class action status to that case and ordered scott lloyd and anybody else in charge at the Trump Administrations office of Refugee Resettlement that they needed to by court order stop interfering with or obstructing any class members access to a judicial bypass, to a medical appointment related to pregnancy dating, nonbiased counselling, abortion counselling or any pregnancyrelated care. As of march 30th last year, the courts have stepped in and stopped this. The court march 30th tells scott lloyd, this Trump Administration appointee, that as a federal official he needs to stop interfering with these girls decisions about whether or not theyre going to get an abortion. March 30th was that order from the court. So we called up Bridget Amiri today when we obtained access to this document, this aclu lawyer who had fought this case, and one of the things she told us is that among the things that was most shocking about this document, which she had never previously seen, was that the dates on the spreadsheet show that scott lloyd kept tracking all the girls pregnancies and their menstrual cycles for months after that court ruling. That court ruling ordering him to stop interfering with access to abortion. I mean, all of these dates on the first page are from june of last year. He was supposed to stop this stuff in march. He just kept doing it. And we dont know if scott lloyd continued to physically block girls from access to Abortion Services the way he was before the court ruling after he was ordered not to by a federal judge, but we do know thanks to this document uncovered this week, which we are making public for the first time, we do know he kept on tracking them regardless of what the court told him. Why would he want to keep a detailed record of individual girls menstrual cycles and the pregnancy status of girls and the means by which they became pregnant and the desires whether or not they wanted to have an abortion . Week by week for all of these girls if he had pledged that he wasnt going to do anything else to block them from getting what they wanted . I mean, we dont know. We put in a request to hhs to speak to mr. Lloyd or get a response from the department tonight. An hhs spokesperson told us, quote, we cant comment because of ongoing litigation on the matter. But the fact that this spreadsheet is being produced on your dime, this is what the federal government does now with individual girls in this circumstance, well, thats where we are. Joining us now is Bridget Amiri. Shes Deputy Director of the aclus reproductive freedom project. Shes the lawyer fighting this case in court. Bridget, thank you for being here. I appreciate you helping to validate this document. Thanks for having me. Im right you had not seen this document before we obtained it today. I had not. There had been reporting that the Trump Administration was tracking girls at this level of detail in this one agency. Seeing the document, to me, first of all, has a visceral effect. But its also it struck me when i read that earlier reporting, i had no idea it was going to be this detailed. Did you know that this was the level of information the government was tracking . I had a sense it was. I asked scott lloyd at his deposition in february about what kind of reports he was getting. We knew at that point through emails we had obtained that he was getting weekly reports. I had a sense it was at least this level of detail. Youre right, seeing it together and all of these young women and their specific requests for abortion was really quite surprising. As you told us today when we called you to get your take on this and before we asked you to come on the air tonight, you said that it seems shocking or it at least surprising that this level of tracking information about all of these individual girls continued, even after the court order in your case, which blocked lloyd from intervening, blocked the Trump Administration from intervening to stop these girls from getting abortions. Is there any reason that you know of or that hhs might have put forward in your litigation that would explain why theyd need to track this information about these girls, up to and including the date of their last menstrual period . There is no legitimate government reason to track this information at all. We dont know that there has been any attempt to block any of these young women, but its curious and i would say creepy that scott lloyd was continuing to get this level of information about these young women and their pregnancies, even after we got the court order, and i think youre right, for what purpose . We are not aware of any obstruction attempts, but it is concerning and kind of bizarre. Mmmhmm. Yeah, i mean, seeing this seeing the other thing, to me, that i think was visceral. You first look at it, it takes awhile to figure out what youre looking at. Then you realize the level of personal information that theyre getting here and then you realize youre looking at 28 pages of it. Right. Part of it is also the volume that there was this many girls that they were tracking at this level of detail. Did you know that it was this many girls who they sort of had their eyes on in this way. I didnt know it was this level of girls they had information on. We knew there were hundreds of young women who were pregnant in custody. A number of them, some subset of them were seeking access to abortion, but i did not know there was this level of detail for this many women. Bridget, as i mention, the hhs spokesperson late tonight contacted us, returned our call when we had asked for comment and they just said they cant comment because of ongoing litigation. What is the status of the litigation here . So our injunction is still in place and the government appealed it. Were wait for a decision from the court of appeals, but in the meantime, the government is prohibited from obstructing or interfering with access to abortion for all unaccompanied pregnant minors in their custody. And if anyone has any issues, any concerns, any witness to any problems they should give the aclu a call. Do you anticipate on privacy grounds or on any other ground i dont think you can sue for creepiness, maybe Margaret Atwood can sue for copyright infringement. Do you anticipate there will be further legal action simply on the basis of the fact that the federal government has been tracking this level of personal information on uniquely identified girls at such to such an extent and for so long. Might this be a cause for additional action on its own . Its a good question. I just saw the document a little bit ago. Certainly ill be talking to my team and well discuss it further. All right. Bridget amiri, again, thank you for helping us today. Thank you. All right. Yeah, as i mentioned, that is an exclusive here you wont have heard that story anywhere else. That document was not obtained by my staff, it was obtained by this super pac american bridge. We are being transparent about that sourcing. They provided it to us so that we could make it public but, again, we expect because it was handed over by hhs as a result of a foia request that this is now fair game for reporting by any other news organization. All right. Much more to get to tonight. Stay with us. L right. Much more to get to tonight. Stay with us im not calling him dad. Oh, nno. Look, [sighs] i get it. Some new guy comes in helping your mom bundle and save with progressive, but hey, were all in this together. Right, champ . Im getting more nuggets. How about some carrots . You dont want to ruin your dinner. Youre not my dad thats fair. Overstepped. Thats fair. Mthat im 19 native american,d specifically from the chihuahua people. The level of details it gives you its, its incredible. 20 million members have connected to a deeper family story. Order your kit at ancestry. Com. I can choose from all their Different Hotel brands. Like a doubletree for my cousins. A homewood suites for my uncle. A hampton for my sister and her kids. And the waldorf astoria Beverly Hills for me. Can i get a. . Thank you. Book at hilton. Com and get the hilton price match guarantee. Book at hilton. Com whooo want to take your next vacation to new heights . Tripadvisor now lets you book over a hundred thousand tours, attractions, and experiences in destinations around the world like new york from bus tours, to breathtaking adventures, tripadvisor makes it easy to find and book Amazing Things to do. And you can cancel most bookings up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. So you can make your next trip. Monumental read reviews check hotel prices book things to do tripadvisor makes you feel like a king king for a day well, maybe not the whole day. Our 19. 99 or 49. 99 oil change includes a tire rotation. Ahhh, ha. Oh yeah, baby. Like a fool i went and stayed too long. Now im wondering if your loves still strong. Ooo baby, here i am, signed, sealed, delivered, im yours applebees 3 course meal starting at 11. 99. Now thats eatin good in the neighborhood. Today at the white house, the president expressed condolences for the people who were killed and injured in the horrific terror attack in new zealand, where at least 49 people worshipping at two mosques in christchurch, new zealand were shot dead by a man who appears at this point to be a white supremacist antiimmigrant gunman who apparently proclaimed his intentions and his motives in a rambling online manifesto where he ranted about how immigrants were a terrible invasion and how someone needed to stop these invaders, and how he was going to be the one to do it. So President Trump expressed condolences for that attack today. When he chose his setting for expressing those condolences, he chose to make those remarks at the white house photoop where he was set to make a big show of vetoing the bill just passed by congress that would stop him from using an Emergency Declaration as a way to try to build a wall between the United States and mexico. So he is using the veto photoop to talk about new zealand. The way this goes in order is that he starts off by expressing his upset over the new zealand massacre carried out by the antiimmigrant zealot who wrote his manifesto about stopping his invasion. Then the president immediately went on to his next thought which was saying about his border wall, quote, it is definitely a national emergency. Rarely have we had such a national emergency. Quote, it is a tremendous national emergency. It is a tremendous crisis. We are on track for a million illegal aliens to rush our borders. Quote, people hate the word invasion, but that is what it is. Its an invasion. These immigrants. Its an emergency. We have to stop them. The president says today. Moments after expressing his condolences for what happened in new zealand less than 24 hours ago. Right now, the largest state in the country, the largest state in our country is pretty much openly confronting the president on his position on the border and on immigration. California governor gavin newsom has already announced the withdrawal of some California National guard troops from the southern border. He said that troop withdrawal was intended to, quote, refocus on the real threats facing the state. To prepare for the upcoming fire season in california. I should tell you, california is also one of the 16 states suing the president over his Emergency Declaration to try to build his wall. Joining us now for the interview here in studio is california governor gavin newsom. Governor, thanks very much for being here. Its great to be here. Thank you, rachel. So when i asked you to come in and be on the show tonight, i didnt exactly know what was going on in the news. Yeah, tough. I have to ask you in the wake of what we believe has happened in new zealand. I mean, we know about the extent of the violence and the terrorist attack that was committed. We are learning more about what the gunman may have intended. Whats your reaction . Its interesting. I mean, the way you just set this up, invaders. Its just an interesting fact last week when we opened an Asylum Center for people that are coming through the border legally, coming through the border, san ysidro border, the busiest border in the western hemisphere, legalliy surrounded during my announcement were all these Trump Supporters with signs saying invaders. Wow. That language is real. Its out there. Its part of the body politic. It is intentional. To hear him say that tonight in light of what happened in new zealand is an outrage and people should be, i think, more, well, more intense about that than pretty much anything else that they heard today. Let me ask you about i have interviewed you a few times. Youve had different jobs in public service. As mayor of San Francisco and as Lieutenant Governor in california. Now as governor of california, and california is such an important state in terms of size of its population, the size of its economy, its influence in the country and around the world. Yeah. You obviously have a totally different take on the issue of immigration. Yeah. And asylum and the border than the president. Yep. But there is a question about governing differently when it comes to those issues that is different than how you win the argument, how you win the fight with somebody who is using those issues for the kinds of ways the president this president is using it. Do you see those as two Different Things . Is it the same challenge . No. I think theyre very distinctive challenges. I love what you just said. Look, let me sort of set this up. California is the most diverse state in the worlds most diverse democracy. We are actively engaged in diversity. Meaning we are celebrating not just tolerating our diversity. Were a universal state also in this respect, we brought in 112,000 refugees just in the last 15 years. Where the federal government walks away, we step up and step in. As i said, we were dumping people out on the streets and sidewalks. 60 to 180 families every single night legally coming through our border were being dumped off in the bus stations. Dumped off on the streets and sidewalks. The federal government doing nothing for them. The state of california put 25 million up to create a first of its kind migrant shelter. And we did it because of our Human Capacity to empathize and also because were a welcoming people and we believe in the American Dream and we believe it should be afforded to anyone who seeks it legally. The Trump Administration does not feel the same. They are making this a national emergency. Legal migrants seeking asylum. Last year, here are the facts, last year we had the fifth lowest illegal border crossings since 1973 in 46 years. The fifth lowest in 46 years. The crisis is nothing more than legal Asylum Seekers coming through the border. A crisis that is not just manufactured in the context of the larger issue, but is substantively manufactured with intentionality by the Trump Administration that is metering those crossings, doing nothing to help support these people and actually creating the conditions that theyre condemning. This is a farce. Its political theater. And the fact is california is not going to play part of that. Now, how do i make that an argument that can attach itself leading by example in a different way is one thing. Confronting them, defeating them in argument, winning the battle, winning the war of ideas around this stuff is harder. Something in addition to that. Thats it. Look, so thats the separate question. Its a more challenging question. You can intelectize it. Then youve got a guy who uses emotion. He knows the vulnerabilities of his base and he exploits them every single day. And the politics is, you know, its pretty its not particularly novel. Its about fear, anger, fear, anger. Its a golden oldie. Mmmhmm. And its an old saw and he plays it very, very well. Weve got to push back with facts, but we also have to push back with positive alternatives and id like to think our states that. Governor, i have a bunch of other stuff to ask you about, will you stay there . Lets do it. California governor Gavin Newsome is our guest. Stay with us. Newsome is our guest stay with us but what if your psoriasis symptoms didnt follow you around . Thats why theres ilumya. With just 2 doses, a majority of people were clear or almost clear. And over time, even more people were clear or almost clear. All with dosing 4 times a year. After 2 initial doses. Plus, ilumya was shown to have similar risks of infections compared to placebo. Dont use if you are allergic to ilumya or any of its ingredients. Before starting treatment, your doctor should check for tuberculosis and infections. After checking there is no need for routine Lab Monitoring unless your doctor advises it. Ilumya may increase your risk of infections and lower your ability to fight them. Tell your doctor if you have an infection or have symptoms, or if you plan to or have recently received a vaccine. This could be your chance to leave your psoriasis symptoms behind. Ask your doctor for ilumya today, for a clearer tomorrow. Back with us in studio for the interview tonight is governor gavin newsom. Democrat of california. Governor, thanks for being with us. You made National News within the last few days by making an executive decision in your authority as government to basically stop the implementation of the Death Penalty in your state. Yep. You have made executive decisions in other leadership roles in the past. You made a very controversial decision around gay marriage within your powers as mayor in San Francisco. In this one, though, im struck by the fact that california voters have been asked if they want to get rid of the Death Penalty and theyve said no, as recently as 2016. You nevertheless decided that this was the right thing to do, not just for yourself, but for your state. Prop 22 in california said marriage is between a man and a woman as well. And that passed in 2008. So there is right and wrong and there are the whims of the majority. With respect, weve had 164 people in this country since 1973 that have been exonerated from death row. Five in california. One since the voters approved a measure to fasttrack the Death Penalty. We have the largest Death Penalty, interestingly, again, in the western hemisphere, not just in the United States. 737 people. California has 700 more than 700 people 737 human beings on death row. The largest in the United States. 120 have died on death row. Without being executed. Without being executed. Suicides or natural causes, including someone just a week or so ago. Whats remarkable, we spend 5 billion. Weve executed 13 people. Spent 5 billion. And yet were still in a debate, for good reason, because we know that were putting people death that are innocent. We dont think that. We know that. We estimate by conservative estimates 4 of people on death row today or innocent. Do the math on the 737 in california. That means im being tasked to literally exercise my authority to execute someone every single day for two years knowing that its likely 30 of them are innocent. And with respect, thats not an intellectual exercise, thats an exercise the governor has the power to execute or reprieve. I chose reprieve. I choose not to do this for another reason. The racial skew is overwhelming. 2 3 on death row are people of color. 1 3 have severe mental illness. Many of them are there for crimes that are more modest, as horrendous as they are, than folks that are out on parole in california, based upon as a judge said, lightning, it strikes some defendants, the Death Penalty and others it does not. But it strikes those people of color and those that commit crimes against whites more than others, and those without wealth are more likely to end up on death row. I cannot support that system. I was surprised this year when you went out early with an endorsement in the democratic president ial primary. I tell you i was surprised for a couple of reasons. One is because i think a lot of people looking at this race and the way its going to shape up think that youre a potential Vice President ial choice even if you choose not to run yourself. And so somebody who is in that i know youre not hot for it. Nobody ever says they do. As somebody who wasnt talking to you about it and was thinking about you in the abstract. Sweet. I thought youre somebody somebody might consider. Given that active possibility, i wouldnt expect you to endorse. Two, california is going to be very, very important in terms of picking a nominee. Yeah. Its going to put the spotlight on you and on democrats in your state in a way that is going to burn hot in the national perspective. For you early on to come out and say that you support senator harris was not a not expected bold choice. Why did you choose to do that . Because i think shes the right person at the right time. Ive had an upclose opportunity to get to know her over the course of decades. I saw her firsthand as District Attorney in San Francisco. I saw her stand up weeks after we both were elected on principle against the Death Penalty and against the overwhelming majority of people that wanted an individual executed. And she said i cannot in good conscience do that. That was a profile in courage early on. I saw her as attorney general when i was Lieutenant Governor first hand doing work on mortgage settlements. On issues of implicit bias. On the issue of overt bias. On issues of independent police investigations. I saw the work she did when she got into the senate and aggressively engaging in some of the national debate. I think shes impressive. I think she can take on not only those that are in the primary but she is the right person to take on oneonone donald trump. I have great confidence in her and i could not be more enthusiastic and supportive. Are you going to campaign for her around the country . I am. I think im doing it right here. You did. Govern gavin newsom of california. Nice to see you. Great to be with you. All right. More ahead tonight. Stay with us. Stay with us sometimes, bipolar i disorder can really get you going. But mania, such as unusual changes in your mood, activity or energy levels, can leave you on. Shaky ground. Help take control by asking your Healthcare Provider about vraylar. Vraylar treats acute mania of bipolar i disorder. Vraylar significantly reduces overall manic symptoms, and was proven in adults with mixed episodes who have both mania and depression. Vraylar should not be used in elderly patients with dementia, due to increased risk of death or stroke. Call your doctor about fever, stiff muscles, or confusion, which may mean a lifethreatening reaction or uncontrollable muscle movements, which may be permanent. Side effects may not appear for several weeks. High cholesterol and weight gain; high blood sugar, which can lead to coma or death; decreased white blood cells, which can be fatal; dizziness upon standing; falls; seizures; impaired judgement; heat sensitivity; and trouble swallowing may occur. Youre more than just your bipolar i. Ask about vraylar. coughing need a change of scenery . Kayak searches hundreds of travel sites and filters by cabin class, wifi and more. So you can be confident youre getting the right flight at the best price. Kayak. Search one and done. I swibecause they let metual, customize my insurance. And as a fitness junkie, i customize everything, like my bike, and my calves. Liberty mutual customizes your car insurance, so you only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. When the president s Campaign Chairman Paul Manafort was sentenced to federal prison for the second time this week, that led to a lot of expectations that maybe everything related to the special counsels office was wrapping up now, too. I will say i hope that by now everybodys learned to be at least a little bit humble about predicting whats going on with the special counsels office, since youve all been wrong, weve all been wrong, right . But when manaforts federal criminal cases came to a close this week, it at least, even if you were being humble, it at least seemed safe to guess that, okay, at least we now know the rick gates case will come to an end now, too, right . I mean, these were linked. Gates was the Deputy Campaign chair when manafort was the campaign chair. Gates was initially charged alongside manafort in the first indictments that were handed down by mueller after initially pleading not guilty alongside manafort, gates was the one who first took the plunge, changed his mind, pled guilty, became a cooperating witness. That included a couple of awkward weeks with him serving as the star witness against Paul Manafort in manaforts trial in the Eastern District of virginia. Now over the Long Duration of manaforts trials, gates sentencing has been delayed again and again and again. And that made sense. He was being used as a cooperator and a prosecution witness against manafort in the manafort trial as long as the manafort case was still alive, it made sense that prosecutors might want to keep their claws in rick gates. Keep him from cooperating. Stop him from going through with this sentencing and moving on with the rest of his life. When the manafort case finally came to a close in court with the sentencing on wednesday, it seemed like, okay, gates will now finally wrap up, too. Gates case scheduled for a status update in federal court today. And i think its fair to say it was widely assumed that everybody thought today that wed learn that gates was finally coming to the end of the line. Theyd finally be ready to move forward with sentencing him, too. Nope. Nope. Nope. Wrong again. Prosecutors today asked for another delay in rick gates sentencing. They asked for four separate delays in gates sentencing over the course of the manafort trials. Now that the manafort trials are over, today they just asked for an extension in gates sentencing for a fifth time. Mr. Gates, quote, continues to cooperate with respect to several ongoing investigations, says the special counsels office. And so at least another 60 days, at least until midmay now before gates case will be back in court after yet another extension. Gates is still an actively cooperating witness in several ongoing investigations. No, we still dont know what those investigations are, but, again, trying to stay humble here, given everybodys record on predicting stuff in these cases. We might surmise it has something to do with gates was number two in the trump inaugural. Trump inaugural didnt appear to be under Law Enforcement scrutiny at the outset of the case against manafort and gates, but its clearly under scrutiny now. Trump inaugural was a subject of subpoena from the Southern District of new york recently. And by the d. C. Attorney general. Its also the subject of extensive document requests from the Judiciary Committee in congress and rick gates was the number two guy number two guy in the trump inaugural committee. So its possible that thats some of what he is still cooperating on and why they cant move forward with his sentencing. But given how good everybodys been at predicting things from here on out and guessing how things are going with mueller, its also possible it has something to do with the moon and green cheese, and dont hold me to it. Well see when we see. Watch this space. Mini was born to do the only thing we ever wanted to do. Drive. To hit start and just go. Fast and far. Around town and around hairpins. To leave everyone in the dust, and leave rubber on the road. Because mini was born to drive. Drive for yourself at the mini born to drive sales event. Special offers at your local mini dealer. Even our pets know to go because its the easiest way to save 30 on all the medications we carry. So skip the search and go directly to petmeds. Com now. Makes you feel like a king king for a day well, maybe not the whole day. Our 19. 99 or 49. 99 oil change includes a tire rotation. Woman ahh need a change of scenery . Kayak searches hundreds of travel sites and lets you see how your baggage will affect the cost of your flight, so you can be confident youre getting the right flight at the best price. Kayak. Search one and done. boy got it. Youre getting the right flight at the best price. Nooooooo. dad nooooooo. vo quick, the quicker picker upper bounty picks up messes quicker and is two times more absorbent. Bounty, the quicker picker upper. It is not uncommon for kids to cut class, especially on fridays, but it is uncommon for them to do it on this kind of a scale. Today, kids and teenagers in over 100 countries and 1,700 cities skipped out of school to demand that adults finally do something about climate change. This was in london. I bet the dinosaurs thought they had time, too. This was lisbon, portugal. You are killing your mother. In berlin, germany, our house is on fire. Children marched in bogota, in seoul and dublin with signs that say there is no planet b, as in no plan b. In italy, kids painted their hands to say our future is in your hands. In cape town, south africa, school kids chanted outside the parliament, we need change, we need change, we need change. There were crowds in new zealand. Yes, even today in new zealand. In prague, ukraine, uganda, also here at home in washington, d. C. This was paris. You are never too small to make a difference. More ahead tonight. Stay with us. The matters. Ar. Introducing the allnew 2019 ford ranger, its the right gear. With a terrain Management System for. This. A bash plate for. That. An electronic locking Rear Differential for. Yeah. This. Heading to the supermarket . Get any truck. Heading out here . Get the ford ranger. The only adventure gear built ford tough. Of nondrowsy claritin. And relief from symptoms caused by over. 200 outdoor and indoor allergens. Like those from pollen, pets and dust. Because new memories start with dusting off old ones. Feel the clarity and live claritin clear. Sarahs last tuition payment, sent off. Feeling good . Oh yeah. Now im ready to focus on my project. This is why we plan. You never cease to amaze me, maya. See how investing with a j. P. Morgan advisor can help you. Visit your local chase branch. Uh uh, i deliver the news around here. Sources say Liberty Mutual customizes your car insurance, so you only pay for what you need. Over to you, logo. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Whooo want to take your next vacation to new heights . Tripadvisor now lets you book over a hundred thousand tours, attractions, and experiences in destinations around the world like new york from bus tours, to breathtaking adventures, tripadvisor makes it easy to find and book Amazing Things to do. And you can cancel most bookings up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. So you can make your next trip. Monumental read reviews check hotel prices book things to do tripadvisor the bad news is deadline approacheth. The good news is they still do have the weekend. 81 different people and the entities got document requests from the Judiciary Committees a couple of weeks ago. They are all, all 81 of them, facing the same deadline this monday for getting those records up to capitol hill. Judiciary chairman Jerrold Nadler is asking these 81 people and entities for information issues, everything from the president s hush money payments to the trump tower meeting with the russians to details about the inaugural committee. Its a ton of stuff. Some people who were targeted with these document requests have apparently said theyre not going to comply, but nadlers office tells us they actually think theyre getting a good response so far. They say theyve also been working with people who might need a little bit more time, if not potentially a friendly subpoena. But, again, deadline for all of them is on monday. We shall see as of monday what they get. Have a good weekend. That does it for us now. We will see you again monday night. Now its time for the last word with ali velshi sitting in for lawrence tonight. Im alley velshi in for lawrence odonnell. The president is condemning the horrific terrorist attack in new zealand, where a white