Transcripts For MSNBCW The Rachel Maddow Show 20170713

Reported today. But i want to start with something that came out in midmay. Time magazine published a big story about one prong of the russian attack on the u. S. Election last year. As weve been talking about that, it had three different components. First there was the straight up hacking effort by russia to try to penetrate local and state election systems all over the country. Mostly targeting Voter Registration rolls. We still dont have a clear sense of why they did that, what they did with the access that they gained through that attack. What they were trying to do, whether that might have been laying the groundwork for something in the future. Ill say just personally, i find it mildly distressing that under rt Trump Administration, the department of Homeland Security doesnt seem interested in investigating what the consequences were of that hacking attack and whether u. S. Election systems might be compromised in a way because of that attack that we may not learn about until that effect is sort of actuated sometime in the future. But that pure hacking effort going after state and local elections software, and elections infrastructure, that was the first part of the russian attack. Second prong of the attack was their attack on political institutions. Specifically the Democratic National committee, the clinton campaign. This is where Russian Hackers stole information off of american servers, and unlike a normal spying operation, where the russians would, you know, keep those documents, keep those secrets for themselves, so the russian government could use that information to inform its own actions, instead they took that information, they repackaged it, and then they fed it back to us, they fed it back to the American Public in a way designed to do maximum damage to one president ial candidate Hillary Clinton and maximum benefit to donald trump. That was the second prong. First was the attack on the election infrastructure, the other was stealing stuff and sending that stuff they stole back at the American Public. The third prong of their threepronged attack is what they did on social media, and in media media. The manipulation of news and online discussion of news and the interrupting and spearing of social media traffic to, again, hurt one candidate in the president ial election, Hillary Clinton, and to help their preferred candidate, donald trump. In midmay, Time Magazine did a big deep dive into that last prong of the russian attack. The social media part of it. Fascinating report. Really good article. The report was written by a very good reporter, very well written. You might remember that was the issue of Time Magazine where they put this image on the cover where the white house was slowly morphing into the kremlin. Well, deep into that story, they had this great new detail that didnt get a ton of attention you when that story came out. Looking back now, its clear he should have. He reported in mid may in Time Magazine that there had been an intelligence intercept, a u. S. Intelligence intercept that happened last spring, in may of 2016, where u. S. Intelligence overheard a conversation that took place in russia between two russian officials. And they were talking about a russian plan to, quote, cause chaos in last years president ial election. What they were talking about was a russian plan to try to hurt Hillary Clinton in the president ial election last year, by using russian assets, russian resources directed by the kremlin to manipulate the American Publics view of Hillary Clinton. By spreading damaging information about Hillary Clinton through the resources of the Russian Military intelligence service, through the gru. So that was that intelligence intercept about that conversation overheard between russian officials in may 2016, that was initially reported in may 2017, may 27th, this year, by Time Magazine. That report about that u. S. Intelligence intercept overhearing the two russian officials talking to each other, that was reupped today by gordon reporting at mcclatchy. Quote, as donald trump was locking up the president ial nomination in may 2016, a u. S. Intelligence intercept picked up russians discussing ways to spread news damaging to Hillary Clinton. Mcclatchy citing two people familiar with the matter. So that may 2016 intelligence intercept, now reported by Time Magazine and by mcclatchy, where the russians are talking about how to manipulate American News about Hillary Clinton, the importance of that is now way more recognizable than we first learned about it. Its way more recognizably important because of its timing. Right . If that discussion between those russian officials happened in may 2016, we now know what happened next. Right . In june 2016, in early june 2016, was that previously undisclosed meeting between donald trump jr. , Paul Manafort and Jared Kushner, their meeting with an emissary from the russian government, a lawyer who was russian speaking who got that meeting in the trump tower, because she apparently was seen by them as the delivery agent to the Trump Campaign of official russian documents and information that would somehow incriminate Hillary Clinton and that the trump folks could use in the campaign against her. Now, since the email setting up that meeting were disclosed by donald trump jr. Yesterday morning, a lot of people have noted that mr. Trump didnt seem surprised. He didnt seem taken aback at all when he was told bluntly in this email asking for this meeting that this, quote, obviously very high level and Sensitive Information is part of russia, and its Government Support for mr. Trump. We have the whole email chain, at least what donald trump jr. Said is the whole email chain. And he doesnt respond to that by saying, wait, russia and its government are supporting mr. Trump . He doesnt seem shocked. Right . He doesnt say, this is part of how russia and its government are supporting mr. Trump . What are the other parts . What are the other ways in which theyre helping, right . He doesnt react with surprise. He doesnt seem at all taken aback. To hear about this promised delivery of Hillary Clinton dirt from this emissary from the russian government, he doesnt seem surprised to hear that this is part of the russian Government Supporting his father in the election. So didnt surprise donald trump jr. , nor does this apparent involvement of the russian government in our election apparently surprise or bother Paul Manafort or Jared Kushner, it doesnt bother them enough to keep them from taking the meeting, even though they were informed about what it was. Looking back on that, for context now, we know that russian attack was well under way by that time, right . This wasnt the start of it. This was about Hillary Clinton in order to help trumps prospects in the campaign. So that discussion was in may. That meeting was in june. Since we learned about the scale and the impact of the russian attack to try to manipulate social media and the news media in this country, there has been a lot of i think there have been a lot of serious questions raised as to whether or not the russians could have pulled off that attack as well as they did, without any domestic help. Without somebody in america helping them do it most effectively. There have been serious questions raised as to whether somebody in the u. S. Might have had to help them in terms of the groups of American Voters to target, what messages were expected to work, how they might be able to dovetail their media manipulation with what the Trump Campaign was doing at that time to try to hurt Hillary Clinton on their own terms. There have been a lot of questions about that when we realized the scope of what russia did with its social media targeting, right . Mcclatchy reports today that investigators in both the House Intelligence Committee and the senate Intelligence Committee as well as investigators at the department of justice, theyre now looking at that. Theyre now looking specifically at whether or not the digital operation of the Trump Campaign itself might have been the entity that helped the russians in that part of their attack. The digital aspect of the Trump Campaign, whether its part of what helped the russians target their news media manipulation. And the stuff they did via social media. Greg gordon is one of the two mcclatchy reporters on that story today. Well talk to him live in a few minutes tonight. I should also tell you that for that story, mcclatchy spoke with a former pentagon official, an official that just left the Defense Department in january after serving there as the Deputy Assistant secretary of defense for russia. And ukraine and eurasia. That Senior Pentagon official responsible for russia now says about that part of the russia attack last year, quote, there appears to have been significant cooperation between russias online Propaganda Machine and individuals in the United States who were knowledgeable about where to target the disinformation. Again, that coming from the person who was in charge of russia at the pentagon, at the time the russian attack was happening. Were going to be speaking with that former official. That former pentagon official tomorrow night on this program for the interview. So you should cancel your thursday night plans for right now. All that is stacked up. That headline from mcclatchy today is presumably harrowing to the trump white house, trumprussia investigators investigators probe Jared Kushnerrun digital operation. Even after that, late this evening, that particular story became even worse news for the trump white house. Because later this evening, Charlie Savage from the New York Times reported on a new lawsuit that has just been filed, down to the wire, just inside the statute of limitations. Its a lawsuit filed by donors to the Democratic Party and one dnc staffer. What theyre doing is theyre suing the Trump Campaign. This is a lawsuit that is has been filed by an organization that was formed very recently by former Obama Administration lawyers, called protect democracy. Sort of watching them to see what they would do. Now they have filed this lawsuit against the Trump Campaign alleging that while it might have been russian government hackers that broke into the dnc and stole dnc information in the first place, this lawsuit alleges that it was actually the Trump Campaign that conspired to release the information back to the American Public. This is actually an invasion of privacy lawsuit. Because the personal information of those donors and dnc staffers was released to the public along with all that other stuff, and that targeted data dump of dnc stuff. Again, this lawsuit says was not just a russian operation, it was a russian operation in which the Trump Campaign conspired. So we have posted a link to the complaint that has been filed in this lawsuit in Federal District court in d. C. If only because if youve been trying to keep track of the known universe and facts and data and documents that have been produced in the trumprussia investigation so far, this lawsuit may be a whole new source of emails, texts, phone records, other primary source documents. Through this discovery process, and this lawsuit, they want to depose witnesses, they want campaign documents. Again, this is specifically looking at whether there was Trump Campaign involvement, and what has otherwise been seen as a russian operation. So and i should mention that the lawyers involved in this, the people who are suing the Trump Campaign here are freaking highfalutin highpowered people. So theres that. Think about this from the perspective of the trump white house. Think about the perspective from their lawyers, their legal team, the people who are trying to defend the president , and defend Trump Campaign people on the trumprussia affair just on that issue. Theyre now dealing with the special Counsel Robert Mueller investigation. Theyre dealing with the Senate Judiciary committee looking at possible obstruction of justice. Theyre looking at the senate Intelligence Committee and House Intelligence Committee, broadly looking at the russian attack and potential Trump Campaign collusion in that attack. In addition to that, theyre looking at what may be a very high powered offensive of the court system through the federal courts. All tied to that second prong of the russian attack, that hack of the dnc where they stole that information. And turned it back on the american people. Imagine trying to manage the defense on all of those fronts. The guy who is supposedly the captain of that team, managing the defense, is Mark Kasowitz who is the new york lawyer who had previously represented donald trump and his business interests and his divorces and stuff. Thats who trump brought on, brought to washington to run his russia defense. Mark kasowitz is not the only lawyer involved in that defense but hes supposed to be in charge of that team. Today, the New York Times reports that Mark Kasowitz is considering resigning. Propublica has published an enormous haircurling story about Mark Kasowitz today, which is part personal profile, but also part cliffhanger in terms of whether Mark Kasowitz is going to be able to continue in his role leading the trump defense. Even if he does stay on and he doesnt resign, theyre raising the question whether he can continue to effectively run this defense. We have posted this propublica story on our website tonight. Its long. Its fascinating if youre interested in this side of the story. I should tell you, though, its got a lot of disparaging personal information about mr. Kasowitz, including stuff like about his lifestyle, and even medical issues for him, its got a lot of details about, i kid you not, his behavior at Office Christmas parties. Its an unusual thing. There are some unnamed sources in the piece, but there are a lot of named sources as well, including named sources who are people close to the president. So i dont have that much appetite for like learning about the palace intrigue in terms of who likes who and whos on the outs. And whats happening among the people who work for the president on personal terms. But between this New York Times reporting that the president s top russia lawyer might resign, and this incredibly well reported litany of negative personal information that was just published in this big story of him at propublica with this very damning sourcing, thats just whether or not you care about the personalities involved here. That is starting to become a factor that we ought to Pay Attention to in terms of whether or not the president really is getting an adequate defense as this scandal gets more intense. He picked a weird defense team anyway when it comes to defending a washington scandal. But the guy in charge of it, if hes about to quit and now facing this barrage, thats a factor. And its not just the president s legal team thats starting to look a little wobbly, there are also signs of stress among very high ranking white house officials including Vice President mike pence whose spokesman today had a very hard time refusing to answer questions about mike pences own contacts with russian officials during the campaign. We will be talking about that a little later on today. As for Jared Kushner, the only currently serving white house official who was at that june meeting last year with the russian lawyer at trump tower, Jared Kushner is facing pointed questions today from chris murphy of connecticut, asking why for months now, Jared Kushner has allowed the white house, including white house spokespeople, and Vice President mike pence, and Senior Advisers like kellyann conway, why hes allowed all of these people around him to insist publicly for months that there were definitely no meetings with russian officials during the campaign, when Jared Kushner knew there had been, because in at least one case he was at that meeting. Allowing other white house officials, including Vice President mike pence, to make false statements about whether or not they were contacts with russians . Isnt that what mike flynn was ostensibly fired for . So Jared Kushner is facing serious questions tonight about why he stood by and allowed the white house and senior white house officials to repeatedly lie about something he had firsthand information about. Hes also facing serious questions about whether he should lose his security clearance which would allow him to operate in his job as white house Senior Adviser. Among the president s defenders in congress, things there are also starting to get a little shaky, although in this case i think the shaking might be just an egg thats about to hatch. It might just be a predicate to what we are about to see that i expect to be a largescale political counteroffensive by republicans and the conservative media, to try to turn this scandal into Something Else that is not about president trump. Today was the Senate Confirmation hearing for christopher wray, the nominee to be the next head of the fbi. The chairman of the committee that conducted that hearing, Chuck Grassley of iowa, strangely, although i said to watch for this last night, somewhat strangely today, senator grassley spent a good portion of his Opening Statement in the confirmation hearing today going after the current acting director of the fbi. Going after Andrew Mccabe, and saying he wants Andrew Mccabe off of any investigation involving mike flynn. Hmm . The chairman proceeded todays very important hearing for the fbi director by also going on fox friends and entertaining their questions about whether the russian lawyer meeting with don junior and trump tower was all a Democratic Party setup. And he bragged to them about how that dossier of alleged russian dirt on donald trump needs to be investigated. Not investigated to figure out whether or not its true, and based in reality, but its existence needs to be investigated, because maybe the existence of that dossier is the real scandal here, and the russia lawyer was maybe a setup, and fusion gps who paid for that dossier, maybe theyre the super villain here and they did it and russia didnt. In trump world, things are a little wobbly right now. The Trump Legal Team has some significant personnel wobbles to it. Trump Administration Senior officials up to and including the Vice President are having their own troubles with this story. Because nepotism is apparently normal now. The troubles at the upper echelons of the Trump Administration also cause problems for the trump family, for trumps soninlaw and trumps eldest son, who may both be facing serious legal questions about their behavior thats been reported over the last couple of days. Also among trumps supporting republicans in congress, i continue to stick a flag there. The flag i stuck there last night is still waving in terms of an expected counterattack trying to turn this into a democratic scandal. That effort to try to turn this into a democratic scandal, it is happening already, almost full scale in the conservative media. The president started tweeting some of those articles from the conservative media today. Republican members of congress, including senior republican senators like Chuck Grassley are starting to use those talking points and point in that direction. It is coming. And to all of that, to all of those different places where we can see the panic button getting hit, from all of that comes a big new scoop today from the wall street journal. From National Security reporter shane harris. And that story is next. Steve was born to move. Over the course of 9 days he walks 26. 2 miles. Thats a marathon. Because he chooses to walk whenever he can. And he does it with support from dr. Scholls. Only dr. Scholls has massaging gel insoles that provide allday comfort to keep him feeling more energized. So he even has the energy to take the long way home. Keep it up, steve dr. Scholls. Born to move. Did you know slow internet can actually hold your business back . Say goodbye to slow downloads, slow backups, slow everything. Comcast business offers blazing fast and reliable internet thats up to 16 times faster than slow internet from the phone company. Say hello to faster downloads with internet speeds up to 250 megabits per second. Get fast internet and add phone and tv now for only 34. 90 more per month. Call today. Comcast business. Built for business. Shane harris is the National Security reporter at the wall street journal who broke the first story that documented american collusion with the russian attack on our election. It was shane harris of the wall street journal that reported almost two weeks ago now about a republican political operative who has since died who late last summer put together a team to contact russian government hackers to try to get antiHillary Clinton oppo from them to use in the u. S. Election to help donald trump. The still lingering unanswered question about that reporting is whether or not that project was embarked upon in conjunction with then Trump Campaign Senior Adviser mike flynn. That remains an outstanding question there. But now, shane harris at the wall street journal has a new scoop with important new details. Can we put that headline up on the screen, please . Well have shane harris here in just a moment to talk about the importance of what he has just reported here, what hes found. But it seems to me, looking at this new story he has posted, that there are two very important new things here. The first is whats in the headline, russian officials overheard discussing Trump Associates before campaign began. In the spring of 2015, before trump ever announced he was running for president , u. S. Intelligence agencies detected conversations in which russian government officials discussed associates of donald trump. In some cases, the russians in the overheard conversations talked about meetings held outside the u. S. Involving russian government officials and trump business associates. Now, as i said, were going to hear from shane harris himself in just a minute about what he can tell us about the circumstances of those meetings, and the surveillance that led to those intelligence reports. He does say in the wall street journal in this wall street journal piece, though, quote, the reports in and of themselves meaning the reports of these meetings in and of themselves were not alarming, but the volume of the mentions of Trump Associates by the russians did have officials asking each other, whats going on . So thats one. Again, thats about 2015, before trump ever announced he was running. The other thing shane harris is reporting is this. In the spring of 2016, european intelligence officials warned u. S. Intelligence officials that russian money might be flowing into the u. S. President ial election. Hmm. It remains unknown if or whether those funds were funneled to a particular campaign, or to others to spend it on behalf of candidates. So as early as 2015, russians are talking about all their meetings with Trump Associates. A lot of them. Sometime in the spring of 2016, european intelligence agencies warn the u. S. That russian money is being funneled into our president ial election. Nobody knows why or how. At least not yet. But at least not yet. And then in may of 2016, would that be considered spring, late spring, early summer . Nye upon the solstice. In may of 2016, thats when russian officials, as first reported in Time Magazine a few weeks ago, russian officials are talking about a russian government effort to spread disparaging news about Hillary Clinton. So spring of 2015, all these meetings with Trump Associates and russian government officials, whats that all about . Spring of 2016 theyre talking about spreading disparaging news about Hillary Clinton. May of 2016. Immediately thereafter, time for a trip to trump tower, right . Jared, paul, junior, this woman is here from the russian government. All of those things are now stacking up in the chronology. There is a lot going on. Theres a lot of new reporting coming out now. Really, i will tell you it is starting to feel very orderly. Its starting to feel like i finally get how this thing stacked up. Im less confused than i have been in a long time. But this is a time when the news is moving fast. Shane harris from the wall street journal is going to join us next. And weve got greg gordon joining us from mcclatchy tonight as well. If you havent heard of mike pences onair discussion of his problems, youll want to stay around for that. Whoa youre not taking these. Hey, hey, hey youre not taking those. Whoa, whoa youre not taking that. Come with me. Youre not taking that. Youre not taking that. Youre not taking that. Mom, im taking the subaru. Dont be late. Even when were not there to keep them safe, our Subaru Outback will be. vo love. Its what makes a subaru, a subaru. I enjoy the fresher things in life. Fresh oooo. Fresh soaps. And of course, tripadvisors freshest, lowest prices. So if youre anything like me. Youll want to check tripadvisor. We now instantly compare prices from over 200 booking sites. To find you the lowest price. On the hotel you want. Go on, try something fresh. Tripadvisor. The latest reviews. The lowest prices. Shane harris is a senior National Security writer for the wall street journal. He wrote tonights news that russian officials were overheard by u. S. Intelligence agencies discussing their meetings with associates of the president as far back as 2015. Before he had officially entered the president ial race. Shane harris, thank you for being with us tonight. Appreciate your time. Thanks for having me, rachel. What can you tell us about these 2015 conversations that you reported on today . Obviously the thing that jumps out is the date that this preceded mr. Trump declaring that he was going to run for president. But it seems like youre indicating in your reporting that the volume of these meetings, the number of these meetings, the number of these intercepts was itself alarming to the u. S. Agencies that became aware of them. Thats right. If you transport yourself back in time to the spring of 2015 before donald trump was running when he was still a television personality, intelligence officials are picking up reports of the russians that theyre routinely monitoring, and talk about donald trump, and meetings with Trump Associates is popping up. Its puzzling. Its not unheard of u. S. Business people or famous people might be mentioned by russians in conversations. But the volume of it is coming across seemed odd to officials at the time. As it was described to me, it becomes this water cooler conversation of whats going on here . Why are they talking about these associates . Its not until time progresses and really, frankly, even in recent weeks that weve seen more revelations coming out, that you go back to that kind of initial dot in the narrative and it starts to make a lot of sense, or look like maybe this was part of the narrative that was building. And i think what were seeing here is like a photograph developing. Its becoming clearer as more and more information gets layered on to it. This piece is particularly important now, because investigators can go back, relook at those reports from 2015, and say, is there something in there that we didnt recognize as significant at the time . But now we see maybe why that matters or why it marries up to information thats come out since then . Is there anything controversial about this surveillance . Obviously if this is surveillance of surveillance of russian persons, not particularly controversial in terms of u. S. Law, but people who are associated with donald trump, mr. Trumps name itself turning up in these intelligence reports, is that controversial . Is that likely to be something that the Trump Campaign or republicans or other people who are concerned about privacy issues here might be concerned about . It could be controversial insofar as there has been this issue of unmasking and names of u. S. Persons showing up in reports. Its important to remember as well that those names are only ever unmasked if investigators believe there mighbpkru. opzdy to do that to understand the context of the intelligence. So its not entirely clear which associates maybe mentioned here or even if some cases russians were alluding to meetings with people around trump. As were now going back and looking at this again, it might be something thats appropriate for officials to dig into those names even more, now that were past this april 2015 time frame, when officials are routinely monitoring people in russia, and sort of wondering why this business about trump coming up. Back then it would not have seemed as significant as it might now. Okay. Along with that portion of your reporting today, what jumped out to me was your reporting that intelligence officials were warned in u. S. Intelligence officials were warned in the spring of 2016 by their european counterparts that russian money might be flowing into the u. S. For the president ial election. What can you tell us about that . This is important in the narrative. It sort of falls after the before donald trump clinched the nomination, but the first signals as described to us where Intelligence Services are thinking, wait a minute, theres some kind of russian interference potentially going on. Its still not clear to people who are close to the investigation that ive talked to, exactly what the nature of this was. Was it russian government money somehow funneled into a campaign, was it being laundered. These are questions that investigators are struggling with right now. It was enough the european Intelligence Services flagged this to the u. S. Intelligence community, and said, we think theres reason to believe that russian funds are finding their way into your elections process. And it seems like this is one of those moments where the signals really start to increase and intelligence officials become more alarmed at that point at what theyre seeing, that ultimately starts to build later into that summer, into what we know now is the hack of the dnc that was revealed in june. By the time you hit that time frame in june of 2016, it is really kind of an open secret at this point that the russians are meddling in the elections. And some months later the intelligence community, of course, would confirm that publicly on the record. Shane harris, Senior Writer on National Security for the wall street journal. Shane, thank you very much. Thanks, rachel. Thanks for having me. That last point, i dont want that its not in the headline but it may end up being the most important thing about this story, reports in the spring of 2016 european intelligence agencies were warning u. S. Intelligence agencies about russian money making its way into the u. S. President ial election. Spring of 2016, the sort of wrapping up of the primary process. We know who the general election candidates are going to be. I dont know what well fimpb fimpbld find out about that. That detail reported for the first time tonight in the wall street journal by shane harris, that, if nothing else, probably explains why there have been so many people signed up as lawyers on the bob mueller probe, whose background is in International Money laundering. All right. Much more to come here tonight, including another excellent Investigative Reporter joining us live. Stay with us. More kinds of crab than ever, new dishes, and all your favorites. Only while crabfest lasts. Red lobster. Now this is seafood. Theres nothing more than my vacation. Me so when i need to book a hotel room, i want someone that makes it easy to find what i want. Booking. Com gets it. And with their price match, i know im getting the best price every time. Now i can start relaxing even before the vacation begins. Your vacation is very important. Thats why booking. Com makes finding the right hotel for the right price easy. Visit booking. Com now to find out why were booking. Yeah in march, mcclatchy had a scoop. This was the scoop. Operatives for russia appear to have strategically timed the computer commands known as bots to blitz social media with links to protrump stories at tiles when trump was on the defensive in his race against Hillary Clinton. The bots and products were largely millions of twitter and facebook posts on internet sites like breitbart and infowars as well as on kremlinbacked rt news and sputnik news. That was the scoop that mcclatchy had in march. Importantly, in march, mcclatchy noted that those bot attacks, those were now the subject of federal investigation being led by the fbi counterintelligence. The fbi was looking into whether conservative websites in the United States, sites like Breitbart News and infowars, whether they might have knowingly helped russian operatives who were carrying out this attack. That was in march. Investigative reporter peter stone and greg gordon, theyve done a lot of stellar reporting on the Cyber Attacks by russia last year against us. And now those same reporters are out with a brandnew piece today. Congressional investigators are looking into whether russian attackers had help not just from conservative media sites in this country, but maybe from within the Trump Campaign itself. Whether the Trump Campaigns digital arm helped russians target their bot attacks and their fake news attacks to specific states, specific districts, in order to boost trump support in those states and districts. Congressional investigators, of course, are not focusing entirely on this. It doesnt appear to be the central focus of their investigations. But we have confirmed separately tonight that they are in fact examining this angle. Mcclatchy also reports tonight that u. S. Intelligence intercepts last may, last year, captured russian officials talking to each other about the russian effort to spread disparaging news about Hillary Clinton. The question being bored in on here is whether those documented and consequential russian efforts had american help. And if so, whodunit. Joining us now is greg gordon Investigative Reporter for mcclatchy, nice to have you back. Hi, rachel. Thanks for having me back. In your reporting, i want to ask you about a specific quote that really stuck out to me in part because of who it was from. You oh quote a former Senior Pentagon official dealing with russia who says, who tells you there appears to have been significant cooperation between russias online Propaganda Machine, and individuals in the United States who are knowledgeable about where to target the disinformation. That seems incredibly important to me. I wanted to ask you, if that former pentagon official would be in a position to know, from his previous role in the department of defense, and do you know who hes talking about in terms of americans who coordinated . We do not. And its important to say what we dont know, we dont know, first of all, that what theyre investigating actually is going to prove out to be, you know, the possible russian attack finetuned to local jurisdictions that had swung away from Hillary Clinton, or even local precincts. But what we do know is that the trail is getting a lot warmer, and this particular angle, because of the way in which bots and fake news and the bombardment of social media messages may have affected the outcome of this race, its important to see that the investigators are going to try to get to the bottom of this. It will be very difficult. But they may run into some brick walls unless they can get some help from humans. Let me ask you about, from your reporting on this, and obviously youve been looking at this angle on this story for a while from a few different angles. Whats your understanding of what kind of evidence they need to look at . What kind of evidence might exist in the world . What kind of trails and leads they might follow in order to prove this out, if theres anything there . This is the most intriguing part of it for me as far as the cyber end of it. And that is that really, from what my understanding tells me, the National Security agency is really where it starts and stops. The nsa collects little data packets of communications that enter and leave the country. And if the russians were attempting to do this sort of thing, from overseas, the nsa might be able to reconstruct this. Although, trying to reconstruct millions of bots and where they went and so forth would be to say the least a huge piece of research. But at least you would have that possibility. Now, russians did this and used a computer that was based in the United States from what im told, it would be pretty tough to reconstruct it. So then it comes do you know to who knew what, and whos going to talk about it. I see. So human intelligence, human evidence about what may have happened in the cyber environment. Fascinating stuff. Greg gordon, Investigative Reporter for mcclatchy news, thank you for helping us understand this tonight, sir. Great to have you here. My pleasure, rachel. Still ahead the Vice President having trouble explaining how the Russian Investigation relates to him, or does it . Thats next, including some pretty incredible tape. Stay with us. Whoooo. Finding the best hotel price is now a safe bet. Because tripadvisor searches over 200 booking sites so you save up to 30 on the hotel you want. Lock it in. Tripadvisor. Whuuuuuat . Rtgage offer from the bank today. You never just get one offer. Go to lendingtree. Com and shop multiple loan offers for free free . Yeah. Could save thousands. You should probably buy me dinner. No. Go to lendingtree. Com for a new home loan or refinance. Receive up to five free offers and choose the loan thats right for you. Our average customer could lower their monthly bills by over three hundred dollars. Go to lendingtree. Com right now. How to win at business. Step one. Point decisively with your glasses. Abracadabra the stage is yours. Step two. Choose laquinta. Where youll feel like the king of the road. Check out our summer rates now at lq. Com. Ain i hafor my belly painking overand constipation. Ucts ive had it up to here its been month after month of fiber. Weeks taking probiotics days and nights of laxatives, only to have my symptoms return. vo if youve had enough, tell your doctor what youve tried and how long youve been at it. Linzess works differently from laxatives. Linzess treats adults with ibs with constipation or chronic constipation. It can help relieve your belly pain, and lets you have more frequent and complete bowel movements that are easier to pass. Do not give linzess to children less than six, and it should not be given to children six to less than 18. It may harm them. Dont take linzess if you have a bowel blockage. Get immediate help if you develop unusual or severe stomach pain, especially with bloody or black stools. The most common side effect is diarrhea, sometimes severe. If its severe, stop taking linzess and call your doctor right away. Other side effects include gas, stomacharea pain, and swelling. Talk to your doctor about managing your symptoms proactively with linzess. Anyone who calls it a hobby doesnt understand. We know that a persons passion is what drives them. [ clapping ] and thats why every memorial we create is a true reflection of the individual. Only a dignity memorial professional can celebrate a life like no other. Find out how at sanfranciscodignity. Com. Fair warning, im about to play you some tape from fox news. Im playing it not to make fun of fox news, not to play cable news wars, but i think theres legit news making stuff that happened on fox that you should see. Ready . Okay. In january this year, Vice President mike pence was asked if there had been any contact between the Trump Campaign and russia during the campaign. A person who believed that there hadnt been any contact like that might have just said no. But that was not mike pences first instinct. He did eventually get around to no, but he had to run around the block a few times and dodge it first. Im asking you a direct question. Was there any contact in any way between trump or his associates and the kremlin or cutouts they had . I joined this campaign in the summer, and i can tell you that all the contact by the Trump Campaign and associates was with the american people. Im just trying to get an answer. Yeah. Of course not. Why would there be any contacts . So hes got a different story to tell. He doesnt really want to answer it but Chris Wallace presses him and eventually he gets there. By later that same morning, mike pence got better at getting right to that answer. Did any adviser or anybody in the Trump Campaign have any contact with the russians who were trying to meddle in the election . Of course not. Go right to of course not. Now, the problem, of course, is that there were contacts between the Trump Campaign and russian officials during the campaign. There were multiple contacts up to and including the meeting we learned about this week where the president s son and soninlaw and Campaign Chair all sought out damaging information on clinton from a kremlinconnected lawyer at trump tower after they were told explicitly that she represented the russian government. No, there were no contacts. Yes, there were contacts. Mike pence has also insisted that mike flynn did not talk to any russian officials about sanctions. Even though with you know now he did. Mike pences explanation for that is that he was lied to. Mike pence has also insisted honestly, looking right into the camera, that he had no idea until after mike flynn was fired as National Security adviser that flynn had been on the payroll of a foreign country. That denial was very hard to believe because mike pence was head of the transition, and the transition was notified multiple times including in writing, multiple times in multiple ways. They were told by multiple people about mike flynn taking Foreign Government paychecks. But now, today, more from the mike pence side of this scandal. Fox newss bill hemmer asked the Vice President s spokesman today, spokesman for mike pence, if pence himself ever met with russian officials. Now, this again is a yes or no question. Somebody whose boss definitely didnt meet with russian officials could just say no, and they would move on. But thats not how it went. Did the Vice President ever meet with representatives from russia . The Vice President is is not focused on the areas where, you know, on this campaign, especially things that happened before he was even on the ticket. Just come back to this question. If it wasnt a private citizen from russia, did he ever meet with representatives from the russian government during the campaign . Thats stuff that the special prosecutor and the counsels are all looking at. Just to nail this down so were clear, is that a yes or a no . Did he or did he not, and was it relevant in fact . I im not aware of anything that i have seen. His spokesman will not say no. Did Vice President mike pence meet with representatives of the russian government . We dont know if the answer is yes or no, but we know his spokesman will not say no. Mike pence is often regarded as less caught up in the unfolding russia saga. I think its because of the way he looks so meaningfully at the camera when he talks about it. But he really has made a number of blatantly false statements about the trump russia connection thus far, and especially given what happened today on fox news of all places. Credit to them. He should not be discounted in this scandal. Watch this space. Senate republicans say they will release version 2. 0 of their spectacularly unpopular bill to repeal the Affordable Care act. Nbc news reports tonight that while the new version of the bill does have some changes from the old version they couldnt pass quite recently, the deep, drastic cuts to medicaid in particular are still in there, and the new version of the bill is still likely to take millions and millions of americans who have Health Insurance right now and make them not have Health Insurance of any kind because of the republicans new bill. Now, i should say in terms of the electoral and the political math here, there is no indication that republicans can actually pass even this new version of the bill. Kentucky senator rand paul already came out against it this afternoon. Moderate senator Susan Collins and dean heller are also expected to say no to this new version. And if thats it, even if just the three of them vote no, its toast. Mitch mcconnell can only afford to lose two republican senators and get this thing passed. It already looks like he doesnt have those numbers. That is expected to be the reason why he is delaying the senates beloved all of august recess, making the senate stick around in d. C. Two extra weeks at least, so their arms are close by for some extra twisting. Despite that uncertainty, we are good evening, rachel. On the health care bill, we notice that ted cruz actually missed the entire Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing today for the new fbi director because he was working on the health care bill, which i have to believe is good news for people who dont want the bill to pass. The bigger ted cruz fingerprints there are on it. No one has more enemies in the senate, in the republican party, than ted cruz. Thats why he has such a long list of legislative victories, why theres been so many bills hes passed. Yeah, thank you, my friend. We will be watching. Thanks, rachel. Cheers, lawrence