Transcripts For MSNBCW The Rachel Maddow Show 20140903

Military wing of a radical religious fundamentalist Political Movement called the islamic courts union. And as essentially the militia for the islamic courts union, al shabaab starting in about 2006, they were doing all the things that we associate with this group and with their ilk. They were stoning people to death, they were cutting off hands and limbs. Doing mass executions. Basically ruling by terror. Declaring a fundamentalist terror state in the parts of somalia where they had control. And it was not long before they got aspirations beyond somalia. In 2010, al shabaab launched all those attacks in uganda against people who had committed the grave sin of getting together to watch world cup soccer matches. Those attacks killed more than 70 people. In 2012, al shabaab formally declared they were an affiliate of al qaeda central. Declared allegiance. Though they claimed credit for bombings and killings and mutilations and grenade attacks over and over and over again throughout this whole time, it was this time last year, was september 2013, when an al shabaab attack made frontpage headlines around the world and shocked the whole international community. That attack happened not in somalia, but in kenya in the cosmopolitan capital kenyan city of nairobi. Al shabaab militants over a period of three days mounted a coordinated military assault on a purely civilian target. They attacked the west gate Shopping Mall in nairobi. More than 170 people were wounded in that attack. At least 67 people were killed. And an integral part of how terrorizing that attack was was not just the mayhem that it caused. Not just the softness and civilianness of the target they chose for that attack, but a big part of the terror that it caused was how long it went on. I mean, it was like mumbai, right . The authorities were not able to bring this siege to a close in the first day or in the second day and all through the third day. It just went on and on and on. These poor people at the mercy of these terrorist attackers. And before that point, its not as if the United States government had been ignoring al shabaab. There had been numerous u. S. Air strikes against the group in somalia including an air strike that killed the groups top leader back in 2008. But in 2012, excuse me, sorry, in 2013, it was just something about that attack in kenya, just the emotional force of that terrifying attack on this very knowable, very cosmopolitan, frankly, very western Shopping Mall in nairobi. When that news broke internationally, it was enough to not just horrify the world, it was enough specifically to make u. S. Decisionmakers scale up what they were willing to have the u. S. Government and the u. S. Military do against this group, al shabaab. Less than two weeks after that attack on that mall in nairobi, the u. S. Launched its first direct boots on the ground commando raid inside somalia against al shabaab. Navy s. E. A. L. S launched from ships off the somali coast. They came ashore to attack a shabaab leadership compound in a seaside strong hold that had effectively functioned as al shabaabs capital city in somalia. And, yes, as i said, the u. S. Had targeted al shabaab leadership before, but never like this. And the difference was that that mall attack was less than who weeks before. That had apparently been enough to make u. S. Decision makers think differently about how much they were willing to do against that group. In the words of the new york times, that attack broke a deadlock among officials in washington over whether to conduct the commando raid against al shabaab. Thats why we decided to do it apparently. The horror over what they did in that Shopping Mall. The problem is that raid did not work. The navy s. E. A. L. S ended up getting turned back by heavy gunfire when al shabaab guards realized the s. E. A. L. S were coming ashore and were coming for them. After the failed attack al shabaab held a News Conference in that town that they controlled bracically bragging about their invince blt, bragging about how they not only pulled off a threeday siege of the West Gate Mall killing civilians in a neighboring country, but also their Senior Leadership had been protected by their own guards against an attack by the best of the best military in the world. By the best of the u. S. Military. At the News Conference, they put on display this u. S. Military gear left behind by the s. E. A. L. S including bullets and a gps device and what appears to be a stun grenade. There was nothing about that terrible and spectacular assault on that westernized Shopping Mall in kenya that made it more likely that a u. S. Commando raid against al shabaab would be successful. But there is something about that terrible and spectacular assault on that Shopping Mall in kenya that made it more likely that we, our government, the u. S. Government, would try to do something as aggressive and risky as that commando raid. That ultimately did not work. We were so horrified we were willing to do something wed never done before. That doesnt mean that what we were willing to do was more likely to be effective. Terrorism is provocation. It is designed to provoke action by those who are terrorized so that a fight can then happen between the terrorist group and the opponent of their own choosing on the terrorist groups own terms and on their own timeframe. And the United States is still taking action against al shabaab. The pent fwon announced today a new set of air strikes again targeting Senior Leadership of that group in somalia. In fact, targeting them in the exact same town that the navy s. E. A. L. S raided last year in that raid that was approved because there had been a terrorist attack but did not succeed when it was tried. We know from our own history that terrorist provocations make us more likely to act. They to not make our actions more likely to succeed. Thats the beauty of terrorism, right . Thats the strategic beauty of it. Thats what they want. Today for the second time in two weeks, the terrorist group isis has released a videotape showing the execution of an american journalist. In the first tape two weeks ago, two weekends ago, an isis militant with a distinct london accent is seen killing an american journalist named jim foley then at the end of the tape the same man is seen threatening to kill another american journalist named Steven Sotloff. Today the group posted a similar video apparently showing the murder of Steven Sotloff and threatening to kill another hostage that the group has in captivity who is reportedly a british citizen. U. S. Government officials are not confirming the authenticity of the video and neither is nbc news. But the family of Steven Sotloff did release a Statement Today saying they know of this horrific strategy and are grieving privately. There will be no Public Comment from family during this difficult time. So for the second time in two weeks, the u. S. Government is in the position of deciding not just how it wants to respond to this terrorist group that keeps killing americans on videotape, but also what the u. S. Government thinks will be the most effective approach to targeting this group. Because what we want to do, and what would be most effective against them, are not necessarily the same things. Right . The group that just killed jim foley and Steven Sotloff and has taken over big swaths of iraq and also syria, they were borne out of the u. S. Invasion of iraq in 2003. There was no al qaeda presence in iraq when we invaded in 2003. In 2004, al qaeda in iraq was formed by this jordanian militant named al za carry. He made his group very high profile, not only by choosing to become an affiliate of the great terror franchise of them all, al qaeda, right, but also by virtue of spectacular attacks and a penchant for brutality that could, in particular, be filmed. He was the one who started dressing prisoners in guantanamostyle orange jumps t jumpsuits then cutting their heads off on camera. Hes the one who started doing that. That was how he put al qaeda in iraq on the map. A u. S. Air strike killed zarqawi in 2006 and was seen as a great victory by u. S. Forces. They wanted to get him more than anybody else. That victory eliminated the one leader from the group but did not stop it from going. Al qaeda in iraq survived and eventually morphed into the Islamic State in iraq. Same group. They continued to be known for their highprofile provocative brutality, mass kidnappings, high profile political assassinations. They bombed the iraqi parliament. In 2007, they abducted and tortured and murdered three serving u. S. Soldiers. By 2009, their leader was replacing zarkawi was a new mysterious figure who called himself al baghdadi. Nobody knows anything about him. It just means he claims to be from baghdad. Al qaeda had always been strongest in the sunni part of iraq. The sunni western part of iraq in al Anbar Province. At one point they had declared the city of ramadi in al anbar to be the capital of the Islamic State of iraq. Geographically speaking if youre in western iraq, in al Anbar Province, if you go further west from there, where you are after you cross a desert border is in eastern syria. When syrias civil war started simmering and boiling over in 2011, leader of the Islamic State in iraq, this guy al baghdadi was very happy to send his fighters a little further west. Send his fighters out of al Anbar Province in western iraq across the border so theyre operating not only in western iraq but also in eastern syria. That is the thumbnail history of this group. They first split from al qaeda central in what is essentially a middle management style turf dispute. But where they come from is the same longterm strategic terrorist mindset that is designed to so outrage us, to so provoke us by their brutality and frankly by their evil that they cause us in anger to do somethings that ultimately in the long run hurt us and help them. Yes, we killed the leader of al shabaab in 2008. Today, literally today, were still waiting on word about whether we killed the new leader of al shabaab. Any doubts whether there will be a new leader after him . An air strike killed al zarqawi in 2006 in iraq. Were debating whether bombing syria would be the way to kill al baghdadi. 2010, targeted killing, osama bin laden, himself. The man in osama bin ladens office is ayman alzakari. Air strikes are not magic. President obama left today for a european trip in part to try and shore up International Support for his strategy to try to contain and isolate an increasingly aggressive Vladimir Putin in russia. Hell also be working on the nato side of an International Coalition to try and stop isis. To try to stop this Islamic State group. Across not just nato and not just the western world, but across the whole world including the muslim world, even across the more radicalfriendly muslim state governments around the world, isis has united the world if revulsion with their tactics and their goals. To them, thats a feature. Thats part of what theyre trying to do. Have we learned enough in past fights, have we learned enough in fighting groups with those goals who use those kinds of tan tactics to get at those goals, have we learned enough to fight them now in a way that will work this time that isnt giving them exactly what they want . Nbcs Richard Engel joins us live from the turkish Syrian Border in just a moment. Stay with us. Im on expert on softball. And tea parties. Ill have more awkward conversations than im equipped for, because im raising two girls on my own. Ill worry about the economy more than a few times before theyre grown. But its for them, so ive found a way. Who matters most to you says the most about you. At massmutual were owned by our policyowners, and they matter most to us. Ready to plan for your future . Well help you get there. Walgreens knows that heartburn sufferers can sometimes find themselves at the corner of mmm, home cooking and umm, i think thats enough. Thats why walgreens offers new nexium 24 hour, protection Strong Enough for whatever your day dishes out. Walgreens makes it easy to treat frequent heartburn. With new nexium 24 hour, now get nexium level protection without a prescription. At the corner of happy and healthy. Nbcs chief Foreign Correspondent Richard Engel is going to be joining us live from the turkish Syrian Border in just a moment. Well be right back. Stay with us. My motheits delicious. Toffee in the world. So now weve turned her toffee into a business. My goal was to take an idea and make it happen. Im janet long and i formed my Toffee Company through legalzoom. I never really thought i would make money doing what i love. We created legalzoom to help people start their business and launch their dreams. Go to legalzoom. Com today and make your business dream a reality. At legalzoom. Com we put the law on your side. So were trying to do a constructive thing here. Constitutionally speaking, its congress that is supposed to decide if we are going to war or not. A president can deploy u. S. Troops into hostilities for 60 days on his own say so without congress weighing, bullet undt troops are supposed to be brought back in 60 days if the congress does not authorize them. Will congress do that . In an effort to keep track whether congress will or will not do their constitutional duty, vote, debate the issue of military force in iraq and maybe in syria, we have started a public whip count of all the members of congress who have publicly expressed the need for a vote on military authorization of the use of force against isis. Last week we had five u. S. Senators and over 80 members of the house from both parties. Today were adding three more members of the house. Democratic congressman elliot engel of new york, republican congressman tom cole of oklahoma, and California Republican congressman ed royce. We can add one more u. S. Senator, democrat from florida, senator bill nelson who says hes going to be introducing to authorize air strikes in syria if president obama decides that is what he wants to do. In breaking news, late this evening we got word from the white house president obama has ordered an additional 350 military personnel to iraq. The white house specified that those 350 people will not be serving in a combat role but will be deployed to baghdad to protect u. S. Diplomatic outposts there. Joining us now from turkey on the Syrian Border, nbc chief correspondent, chief Foreign Correspondent, Richard Engel. Richard, thanks very much for being there. I have to ask you about how you see the overall u. S. Approach to this problem right now. We were just talking in new york last week, you said you didnt see what the overall rationale and design was from a u. S. Government prospective. Reporter well, ive been struggling to figure out what our Foreign Policy is as we have so many conflicts around the world, so many conflicts in the muslim world. Libya is falling apart. Is going back into civil war. The capital no longer in control of any reasonable force. You have syria and iraq in a state of collapse. And im not exactly sure what our objectives are. I was listening, as i always do, to your introduction just a few minutes ago, and you pointed out a couple of very important issues. There is this terrorist dilemma. You dont want to fall into the terrorist trap. Terrorists want to do atrocious, horrible things in order to provoke an emotional response. And you talked about a few examples. Think about osama bin laden. Thats perhaps the greatest example. He launched 9 11 in order to draw the United States into a war in afghanistan. He watched. He participated in the conflict when the soviet union was pulled into a war in afghanistan. And it was pivotal to collapsing the soviet empire. He said in repeated statements that the goal of 9 11 in part was to draw the United States into a land war in afghanistan which he thought would be the end of the american empire. It proved not to be the end of the United States, but it was, in fact, very costly. You dont want to allow the terrorists by doing something heinous to pull you into a conflict where they choose at a timing of their own choosing. But now you have a situation with isis on the move, with the state where you cant ignore it. You cant close the door and forget about this because things have advanced so far that its not going to resolve itself without any kind of intervention. So you have to split the difference. You cant get sucked in, but you cant do nothing. And i think this problem, finding a middle ground, has left the United States in paralysis. Richard, join look at the history of not just groups like this, but fighting groups like this, not just militias, not just wouldbe sort of prodo states around the world but really terrorist groups using terrorist strategy to get us to fight on their terms, to pick their own enemies and pick their own turf and pick their own tactics of battle, are there examples where these groups have been effectively either defeated or sidelined or neutralized that we should see as models for ways to defeat them in the long run rather than just sort of playing this game where every once in a while youre able to use an air strike or commando raid to take out their leadership, but they just regrow . Reporter there are quite a few historic examples. It usually takes a long time. Seven to ten years. But the most effective way, it seems, is to carry out Occasional Air strikes when necessary, but really to have a local indigenous force that does it for you. Isis, the best thing about isis if there could be any good thing about isis is it is to brutal that almost everywhere it goes within a matter of months, it is hated by the people where it is governing. So, there are plenty of people in syria, in iraq, who are very happy to rise up and stand against isis. It just takes a great amount of diplomatic skill. Takes a lot of coalition building. It takes determination. Risk to engage these groups. To try and get them empowered enough. Financed enough. To get them the right kind of intelligence so that they can get rid of isis, themselves, with the occasional help from above. Richard, were just learning tonight that the president is deploying another 350 u. S. Troops to iraq. Hes not saying that these troops are for a combat role but rather that theyll be protecting u. S. Diplomatic facilities inside iraq. I dont i cant do the math in my head right now, but from what i remember, i think that means were up over 1,000 troops deployed doing air strikes, fighting isis, advising troops fighting isis and protecting u. S. Facilities there. Are enough troops there in meaningful numbers that we should see this as a start of a largescale u. S. Operation or do you see this as sort of equivalent to the sort of things we dont think of as war in the kind of places around the world where we have people deployed all the time but doesnt rise to the level of something we ought to be debating as a war back at home . Reporter i think we are now at the level and it is over 1,000 right now of the residual force. You remember there was so much talk, and the democrats, republicans, were beating themselves up whether there would be a residual force left in iraq after the u. S. Pullout. Well, that residual force is now there. It has been put there piecemeal. Not with the combat mission, but with an advising combat mission. And theres a lot more than 1,000 people involved in this. There are many aircraft flying over iraq right now. There are drones flying over aircraft. This means that u. S. Command centers, mostly special Operations Forces command centers, are watching the terrain, advising the Iraqi Government, aiding and supplying Kurdish Peshmerga fighters who are in northern iraq. So we are involved in this conflict, were just trying to do it by remote control. And 1,000 is not an insignificant number. There is a chance that some of them could get caught up in the fighting, but the idea is that they are the staybehind force that was never left behind in order to prevent the iraqi army from collapsing as it did collapse in mosul. I think something to watch right now is will this force be enough to allow the iraqi army to take back the city of mosul . The Iraqi Government is now making a lot of noises that it is going to launch an offensive against mosul and drive isis out of the Flagship City that it took where it seized all the american humvees and the american weapons from the iraqi army, where the iraqi army suffered a humiliation when two divisions dropped their weapons and ran. If the iraqi army can take over mosul and hold it, then i think it would be an achievement for this strategy of putting american advisers back on the ground to help the iraqi army reconstitute itself and reclaim some of its territory including a major city. But its not at all clear that the iraqi forces are at a stage yet where they can take mosul. If they could, of course, it would be a huge psychological shift in at least the perceived momentum there. Nbc chief Foreign Correspondent Richard Engel staying up until the dead of night to be with us from turkey on the Syrian Border. Richard, thank you so much. All right. The jury is out on former Virginia Governor Bob Mcdonnell. Literally and metaphorically. Well have the latest straight ahead on that. And also a trip to debunktion junction. Theres lots to come tonight. Stay with us. First, one more thing about our running tally of members of congress who have publicly said that congress ought to take a vote on military authorization for the u. S. Of force in the middle east. There are still hundreds of members of the house and dozens of senators who might weigh in one way or the other. The list as it stands right now is up at maddowblog. Com right now. You can be part of this. If you notice your hometown lawmaker calling for a vote or saying that Congress Needs a vote, drop a link in the comments at maddowblog. Com and we will keep adding to that list as we learn more. Well be right back. Stay with us. Take them on the way you always have. Live healthy and take one a day 50 . Complete multivitamins. With 7 antioxidants to support cell health. Research suggests cell health plays a key role throughout our lives. One a day 50 for men. And for women. Age . Who cares. One a day 50 [ shutter clicks ] hi there [ laughs ] im flo i know im going to get you your rental car. This is so ridiculous. Were going to manage your entire repair process from paperwork to pickup, okay, little tiny baby . Your car is ready, and your repairs are guaranteed for as long as you own it. The Progressive Service center a real place, where we really manage your claim from start to finish. Really. Easy as easy can be bye i am so noh my gosh. Now, its not even funny. Driver 1 you ready . Yeah go [sfx] roaring altima engine woah ahhhha we told people they were riding nissans most advanced altima race car. We lied. About the race car part. Altima, with 270 horsepower and active understeer control. How did you . What i dont even, im speechless. Innovation that excites. Dont have allergies every night. Just on allergy nights. [ sneezes ] [ male announcer ] thats why theres new vicks qlearquil for night. The powerfully effective, take it only when you need it, so you can have a good night allergy medicine. Sometimes truth is stranger than fiction. In a hardfought governors race this year in the great state of alaska, alaska democrats have decided to win that race by quitting that race. And if you think Alaska Governor and quitting, youre probably thinking about this person who quit halfway through her first term as governor after coming in second in the race for Vice President of the United States, but thats not who im talking about. Because after she quit, her Lieutenant Governor, sean parnell, he got the top job in alaska and republican Alaska Governor sean parnell this year is up for reelection. Sean parnell does not have great approval ratings. Before today, though, he did have an a advantage of running in a split field, running against not one opponent, but two. In this race against a popular independent and also a democratic candidate, sean parnell probably by virtue of the split field was going to hold on to his seat. Now, though, alaska democrats have decided to kibosh their own candidate for governor and have him run instead as the Lieutenant Governor running mate with the independent guy. Whos going to be running for governor. They formed a Fusion Campaign. The independents and the democrats have teamed up in a Fusion Campaign that is much more likely to actually unseat the republican incumbent. Now this whole scheme obviously involved lots of negotiations about how theyre going to describe themselves and what their platform is and how they get their existing Lieutenant Governor running mates to drop out. Kindly. But alaska democrats really have decided now that the best chance of winning their partisan fight against republicans is to blow up the twoparty system that created that partisan fight in the first place. Its not bunk. That really did happen today in alaska. Its true. And that doesnt mean there isnt a lot of bunk you may have heard masqueradining as news abt other stories today. Because of that, right at the end of the show today, theres a debunktion junction. Thats coming up. Stay with us. Kid hey dad, who was that man . Dad hes our broker. He helps looks after all our money. Kid do you pay him . Dad of course. Kid how much . Dad i dont know exactly. Kid what if youre not happy . Does he have to pay you back . Dad nope. Kid why not . Dad it doesnt work that way. Kid why not . Vo are you asking enough questions about the way your wealth is managed . Wealth management at Charles Schwab so factors like diet can negatively impact good bacteria . Even if youre healthy and active. Phillips Digestive Health support is a duoprobiotic that helps supplement good bacteria found in two parts of your digestive tract. Im doubly impressed phillips Digestive Health. A daily probiotic. Who would have thought masterthree cheese lasagna would go with chocolate cake and ceviche . The same guy who thought that small caps and bond funds would go with a merging markets. Its a masterpiece. Thanks. Clearly you are type e. You made it phil. Welcome home. Now whats our strategy with the fondue . Diversifying your portfolio . E trade gives you the tools and resources to get it right. Are you type e . Yeah . Om. We got allstate, right . Uhhuh. Yes well, i found this new thing. Called Allstate Quickfoto claim. Its an app. You understand that . Just take photos of the damage with your phone and upload them to allstate. Really . So you get a quicker estimate, quicker payment, quicker back to normal. I just did it. But maybe you can find an app that will help you explain this to your father. Introducing quickfoto claim. Just another way allstate is changing Car Insurance for good. Wouldnt it be great if hiring plumbers, carpenters shopping online is as easy as it gets. And even piano tuners were just as simple . Thanks to angies list, now it is. Weve made hiring anyone from a handyman to a dog walker as simple as a few clicks. Buy their services directly at angieslist. Com no more calling around. No more hassles. Start shopping from a list of toprated providers today. Angies list is revolutionizing local service again. Visit angieslist. Com today. Take a look at this. Its called he said he said. Its a chart the Washington Post put together comparing on the one hand things that were said by former Virginia Governor Bob Mcdonnell and on the other hand things that were said by the man whos accused of bribing mcdonnell when he was governing to the tune of more than 160,000. Take, for example, the rolex, engraved rolex purchased by businessman Jonnie Williams then given to the governor by his wife. Governor mcdonnell says when his wife gave him that rolex on Christmas Eve he assumed that his wife had bought the watch to give to him. Jonnie williams, though, he says the governor texted him a photo of himself wearing the watch which led Jonnie Williams to leave that Bob Mcdonnell knew where the watch was actually from. Take the allexpensespaid trip to a resort on cape cod which Jonnie Williams also paid for. Governor mcdonnell says that was very little business discussed on that trip, it was just a chance for him to have some time with his family. While another guy was paying for some strange reason. Jonnie williams, however, billed that trip as an expense to his company and said the whole point of the trip was to get governor mcdonnell on board promoting his company. He told the jury, i was working the entire weekend. Mr. Williams says that he had discussed with the governor a 50,000 loan. Mr. Williams planned to make to first lady maureen mcdonnell. He says the governor even thanked him for that loan. Governor mcdonnell on the other hand contends he knew nothing of the 50,000 loan until after his wife received it and then he was horrified to find out what she had done. Not horrified enough, though, that he didnt then personally move to arrange himself 70,000 more in loans from the same guy. The discrepancies between the he said he said worlds here, right, the discrepancies between the world of lavish gifts and cash as told by bob and world of lavish gifts and cash as told by jonnie, decembiscrepancies is w the jury is weighing in the trial of governor Bob Mcdonnell in virginia. Today the jury finally got the case. The judge spent two hours going through nearly 90 pages of jury instructions with them in the morning. Judge James Spencer told the jurors they should examine and weigh with greater care than usual any testimony from witnesses who have been granted immunity in exchange for their testimony like, say, Jonnie Williams, the star witness of the prosecution case. Judge spencer also told the jury that governor mcdonnells wife, maureen, cant be on the hook for the public corruption charges shes facing unless her husband, bob, is convicted of them, too. If he hasnt committed a public corruption crime, then she cannot have conspired with him to commit that crime and so shell be off the hook, too, basically by definition. Well, after these jury instructions today, after jury instructions so long and complicated that they actually required a 15minute intermission halfway through, the jury did start deliberating today. They ruminated on this case for roughly 5 1 2 hours today, but at the end of the day, they still had no verdict. Theyre due to be back at it first thing tomorrow morning. Tomorrow is day two of jury deliberations. Joining us now, ryan novels, political reporter covering the story for nbc 10 in richmond. Mr. Nobles, thanks very much for being here. My pleasure, rachel. Thank you for having me. 85 to 90 pages of instructions for the jury. They had to take an intermission in getting the instructions from the judge. Did it seem the jurors were okay with the instructions they received or just such an overwhelming amount of information you think they might have trouble . Rachel, i think thats a question you could ask about the entire trial. Weve had five weeks of testimony and and arguments from the attorneys from both sides and a lot has been knee deep in legalese and these are average folks sitting on the jury and a lot of us in the press corps wonder at certain points if they seem overwhelmed by everything happening. Judge spencer has taken care to make sure each and every one are prepared for what theyre facing in this deliberation and that is a big question as we go into it, and i cant imagine that any of them understand the very specificity of this law that theyre dealing with and then when you pile on top of it all of these indepth instructions, it certainly is a mementos task that they have in front of them and i think thats why most of us think its going to be quite a while before they come back with a verdict. Specifically in terms of how hard it might be for them to understand their remit, what theyre being asked to decide, do they have option in terms of getting more guidance on these instructions now that they started deliberation . Can they actually ask the judge for help if they need it . Yes, they can ask the judge questions about the instructions, but judge spencer was very specific with him that the rules of the courtroom allow him very little latitude in providing guidance. They basically have to take all of these instructions and that is their bible. That is what they have to use to make this ultimate decision. He can clarify. He can kind of emphasize certain points that stay within the bounds of the law. But for the most part, all they have is their recollection, what they heard over these past five weeks, and then that lengthy set of instructions to come up a final decision. Ryan, in terms of the broader view here, im wondering if you as a reporter can give us your sense of the effect that this trial is having on the political atmosphere in virginia. Obviously hes a former governor. Hes the first Virginia Governor indicted for acts while in office ever in virginia history. He was indicted just a few days after he left office. Hes a legend in the state in terms of his political profile. Is this trial being seen as a very big deal in the state . How is it being viewed in virginia . Well, i dont think theres any question that most political observers have never seen anything like the spectacle that weve seen over the past five we weeks. All the television cameras, all the excitement and interest every time the former governor and his wife come in the courtroom separately every year every morning. Theres no real indication theres been any sort of movement or impetus on behalf of the General Assembly to make any changes as related to virginias really lax gift laws. They put forth some real meager legislation in this past General Assembly session, but yet even though the eyes of the world and the eyes of the United States are focused on virginia, theres been no calls for stricter gift laws. Theres been no legislators that have put forward plans to make something happen. They do have a special session coming up in the next month where theyre going to deal with medicaid expansion, but theres been no one whos taken a strong stand about increasing the gift laws. Of course, the current governor, terry mcauliffe, imposed a gift ban on himself but hes a multimillionaire and nothing in this sense he would necessarily be someone who could become a victim of a situation like this. So, yes, everybody agrees this is a historic month that we faced here in virginia, but whether or not it turns into something substantive over the long term so that these politicians could make preb protect themselves from themselves, at this point we havent seen anything like that. Ryan nobles, political reporter for nbc 12 in richmond. Thank you for being here. Thank you, rachel. On the last point ryan was making, its amazing, 160,000 in cash and prizes, much to get the attention of federal prosecutors. Nobody ever contended it might have broken virginia law. That kind of thing doesnt look that illegal under state law. Maybe thats a problem for state law. Well be right back. Way to plus our Accounting Firms mobile plan. And minus our expenses. Perfect timing. Were offering our bestever pricing on mobile plans for business. Run the numbers on that. Well, unlimited talk and text, and ten gigs of data for the five of you would be. Oneseventyfive a month. Good calculating kyle. Good job kyle. You just made partner. Our bestever pricing on mobile share value plans for business. Now with a 100 bill credit for every business line you add. If energy could come from anything . Or if power could go anywhere . Or if light could seek out the dark . What would happen if that happens . Anything. This is kathleen. Setting up the perfect wedding day begins with arthritis pain and two pills. Afternoon arrives and feeling good, but her knee pain returns. Thats two more pills. The evenings event brings laughter, joy, and more pain. When jamie says. Whats that like six pills today . Yeah. I can take 2 aleve for all day relief. Really, and. And thats it. This is kathleen. For my arthritis pain, i now choose aleve. Get all day arthritis pain relief with an easyopen cap. Car Insurance Companies say theyll save you by switching, youd have, like, a ton of dollars. But how are they saving you those dollars . A lot of Companies Might answer um or no comment. Then theres esurance. Born online, raised by technology and majors in efficiency. So whatever they save, you save. Hassle, time, paperwork, hairtearing out, and, yes, especially dollars. Esurance. Insurance for the modern world. Now backed by allstate. Click or call. Esurance. Insurance for the modern world. I got this. [thinking] is it that time . The son picks up the check . [thinking] im still working. Hes retired. I hope hes saving. I hope he saved enough. Who matters most to you says the most about you. At massmutual were owned by our policyowners, and they matter most to us. Whether youre just starting your 401 k or you are ready for retirement, well help you get there. Cardinal rule of political crisis management. If you have some kind of bad news to put out, the only thing better than putting it out 6 00 on a friday night is putting it out 6 00 on a friday night before a long holiday weekend. And so it was this past friday night, right as the Labor Day Weekend was upon us, that news really did break out of kentucky. News tonight of a huge shakeup in kentuckys senate race. Mitch mcconnells Campaign Manager resigns as questions swirl. Bad news right before a long holiday weekend. Jesse benton will resign effective saturday, what he knew in an endorsement for pay scandal involving a 2012 campaign he was in charge of. The patented friday night right before the Labor Day Weekend late night news dump. Tada last week on this show we reported extensively on the chickens coming home to roost from a bribery scandal involving the ron paul for President Campaign back in 2012. A former republican state senator from iowa pled guilty in federal Court Last Week on two counts related to a secret deal that hed worked out with the Ron Paul Campaign in which theyd given more than 70,000 for him to endorse ron paul. The guy who was running the Ron Paul Campaign back then, when they were bribing a guy for his endorsement, was a longtime paul family political aide named jesse benton. Jesse benton then went on to become the Campaign Manager for the Top Republican in the u. S. Senate. Hes the Campaign Manager for Mitch Mcconnell of kentucky now that mcconnell is running for reelection. Last week, as that bribe ry scandal was resulting in the plea in iowa, sealed documents and word the guy pleading guilty was cooperating with prosecutors, last week as that news was breaking, the Mitch Mcconnell campaign refused to respond to our phone calls and emails about their Campaign Managers role in that bribery scandal. Day refused comment for two days. And then, bam, right before the holiday weekend, jesse benton quit. Stepped down as Mitch Mcconnells Campaign Manager after close of business on the friday before a holiday weekend. And incidentally, two months before election day. That, in itself, is big political news, but theres also a criminal investigation here thats still under way. The Washington Post reporting late last week that the federal investigation into that Ron Paul Campaign bribery scheme is ongoing and that the focus of federal prosecutors at this point is on the people who were running the ron paul call pain back then. The criminal part of it may not be over yet. Stick a pin in that for now. Right . In terms of the Political Part of this scandal, though, there is also this. This is jesse benton standing alongside kentuckys other republican senator, rand paul. The thing that jesse benton did right before running the ron paul president ial campaign in 2012, bribery and all, was that he ran the 2010 campaign that got rand paul elected to the United States senate. So he did son rands Senate Campaign in 2010, then he did dad, rons, president ial campaign in 2012, and yes, jesse benton was believed to run rands president ial campaign in 2016. Was being the operative word. If rand paul is going to run for president , why else would he be spending all his time these days in iowa, new hampshire, and south carolina, if hes going to run for president , rand paul has had an awful few days. On friday, his president ial Campaign Manager in waiting was forced to quit his current job and is still mired in what is reportedly an ongoing federal criminal investigation into bribery. And then today, this was the front page of rand page of ran state newspaper, the lexington herald leader. Voters offer mixed signals for rand paul in 2016. The headline refers to a new poll that shows 22 of kentucky voters want rand paul to run for president. Look at the subheadline there. They dont want season law changed to allow senate and white house bids. Oh, right. Its the law of the land in kentucky that you cant run for two federal offices on the same ballot. In 2016, hes contemplating a president ial run and up for reelection in the senate. Under kentucky law, you cant do both at once. So this is sort of one of those moments in politics. Is rand paul a real candidate and a real republican or whether, like his dad, hes a perennial protest candidate, a candidate running not the win, but running to run, because running is good for the cause and good for the family business. The ron paul protest candidacies for decades now have been the paul family business. Nobody is under any illusion youre going to be the last man standing but your running can build an idealogical movement at which youre the center. Lu thats what the ron paul backwards erevolution has been about, protest candidacy as family business. Rand pauls claim for why he should have been elected to the senate in 2010 is that he was ron pauls son, and therefore, a junior level icon of the movement. He ran and he won on being the younger, maybe Second Coming of ron paul the movement. So now heres the question. Is rand paul just a protest candidate as the pauls have been for a very long time . Or is he an actual republican candidate trying to win the presidency . And in a really specific way, that question is now being called. Because that new poll in kentucky on the front page of his newspaper shows that 66 of kentucky voters dont want to change that state law in kentucky that would allow rand paul to run for president and run for his seat in the senate at the same time. 2 3 of the state agrees that if rand paul wants to run for president , he would have to give up the senate seat in order to do that. If youre just running because youre looking forward to running. So this calls the question, right . If kentucky calls the question for rand paul, will he give up his senate seat and run for president because he thinks he can win . Ill believe it when i see it. But watch this. [ female announcer ] we help make secure financial tomorrows a reality for over 19 million people. [ mom ] with life insurance, were not just insuring our lives. Were helping protect his. [ female announcer ] everyone has a moment when tomorrow becomes real. Transamerica. Transform tomorrow. Snever miss a chance to dance. Just because you happen to sprinkle a little tinkle. Introducing a revolution in bladder leak protection, from the experts in feminine protection. New always discreet, for sensitive bladders. Up to 40 thinner, for superior comfort. Absorbs 2x more than you may need. For danceallyouwant protection. New always discreet. Now bladder leaks can feel like no big deal. Because hey, pee happens. Visit alwaysdicreet. Com for coupons and your free sample. Virtually all your important legal matters in just minutes. Now its quicker and easier for you to start your business, protect your family, and launch your dreams. At legalzoom. Com we put the law on your side. How can i ease this pain . man when i cant go, its like rocks piling up. I wish i could find some relief. announcer ask your doctor about linzess a oncedaily capsule for adults with ibs with constipation or chronic idiopathic constipation. Linzess is thought to help calm painsensing nerves and accelerate bowel movements. It helps you proactively manage your symptoms. Do not give linzess to children under 6, and it should not be given to children 6 to 17. It may harm them. Dont take linzess if you have a bowel blockage. Get immediate help if you develop unusual or severe stomach pain especially with bloody or black stools. The most common side effect is diarrhea, sometimes severe. If its severe, stop taking linzess and call your doctor right away. Other side effects include, gas, stomacharea pain and swelling. Bottom line, ask your doctor about linzess today. For over 19 million people. [ alex ] transamerica helped provide a lifetime of retirement income. So i can focus on what matters most. [ female announcer ] everyone has a moment when tomorrow becomes real. Transamerica. [ train whistle ] putin of russia is none too pleased about the west and the u. S. Pressuring him about the war hes waging against eastern ukraine. But today in president obamas trip to estonia, there are reports that president putin has increased the belligerence of his stance toward ukraine. Did vladamir putin really just say if i wanted to, i could cake kiev in two weeks . Vladamir putin now says i could take the capital of ukraine, i could take all of ukraine in two week it is i wanted to. Did that really happen . Is that true or false . True. It was first reported by the italian paper after the president of the European Commission told the paper thats what putin said to him. If i wanted to, i could take that whole country in two weeks. Confusion about this might have come when the kremlin tried to muddy the waters saying it was unprofessional and unserious for this european diplomat to tell newspapers what vladamir putin said to him. Is the kremlin denying that putin said this thing . No. They are not denying that he said it. So its true that on the eve of president obama arriving on russias border in parts of prussiarussia to back off its war in ukraine, russian president vladamir putin is bragging that if he wants to, he can take that whole huge country in two weeks. That ones true. Next up, the last time a u. S. President visited the balkans is when george w. Bush visited albania in 2007. The thing that most people remember about that last trip is it resulted in this 9 1 2 foot statue being elected to honor president bush. It shows president bush over nine feet tall with pleated pants and a tiny little head. But beyond the giant statue, is it true or false that the last trip by a u. S. Trip to the balkans by a president resulted in his watch being stolen. Heres the video. President bush shaking hands in an albanian crowd in seven. Heres basically when the moment the watch disappears. About ten seconds left, no watch strap visible. In one shows before, hold on, we have before. See the watch . You can see the watch there at the bottom center. This is during, here he is shaking hands. People grabbing his wrists. And then after, same event. Heres the president. Wait, look at his left wrist. No watch. Is that true or false, that the last time a u. S. President went to the balkans, the president had the watch stolen off his wrist in a crowd of albanians, true or false . [ buzzer ] false. Although he did start that hand shaking with a watch and finished with no watch on his left watch, the white house clarified that president bush didnt lose the watch, he took it off himself and maybe stuffed it in his own pocket or gave it to a bodyguard to hold. Any way, they say he didnt get it stolen. It is basically the only thing you will find if you try to google about the last time a u. S. President went to the balkans. The president will be in estonia very shortly. In part to remind russia that the full force of nato is really on their doorstep thats scheduled for tomorrow at 10 00 a. M. Eastern. Now time for the last word with lawrence odonnell. Thanks for being with us tonight. Good evening. Rachel, you drove me crazy with that watch story. Im up here in boston doing the show tonight and i dont have a monitor that can show me what youre doing or what youre showing with all those watch pictures. I will text you the pictures