Theres more than a few who will have real knowledge about how to question the attorney general about the inner workings of the department on Something Like you know what do you do when you get a special prosecutors report. Right, exactly. He was very, very, very he slippery on the subject when he was at his confirmation hearing. Kept talking about everything as a hypothetical. Now theyre asking about a specific matter that is no longer the hypothetical. Hopefully skilled questionsers from either house of congress over these next two days of hearings will get some explanation. His behavior has been very freelance. Hes been sort of making it up as he goes long. Hopefully hell explain what hes been doing. Yes, america awaits the Mueller Report and the attorney general testifies twice this week. This is going to be interesting. Thanks, lawrence. Thank you, rachel. Well, i thought i knew everything there was to know about the law that makes it absolutely mandatory for the irs to hand over anyones tax returns to the chairman of the house ways and Means Committee or the chairman of the Senate Finance committee. Ive been reading you that law for the last couple of nights ever since chairman. Rich neal delivered his depend to the irs for those tax returns. But i learned something tonight. I learned something tonight about that law and i learned it from a former treasury secretary who is in a position to know these things. And that is former treasury secretary larry somers, the har harvard economics professor who was bill clintons secretary, he served in the Obama Administration also. And he has identified an element of precedent in the treasury that makes this a much more interesting situation than even i thought. And he has words of advice including legal advice for the current treasury secretary about how to handle himself in this situation. Because it is much electric year than even i realized until he wrote about it. He will be joining us tonight. At the end of the hour, what did barack obama do when he was being audited by the irs . What did he do with his tax returns . Because barack obama was repeatedly audited by the irs. And you never heard him talk about it, but he was. And ill tell you, at the end of this hour exactly the way barack obama handled his tax returns when he was being audited and, of course, we all remember that the big trump reason for never releasing his tax returns is that he was being audited. We never knew if that was true during the campaign. But we do nope exactly whats happening to Donald Trumps tax returns right now. But the lesson of how barack obama handled his tax returns when they were being audited is what were going to save for the end of this hour. Its an important lesson to consider this week. Deadline week for the trump tax returns. Measuring the chaos level in the Trump White House has never been an exact science but it seems that each successive white house chief of staff has made matters worse, much worse. John kelly was brought in as white house chief of staff to control the chaos that exploded under the First White House chief of staff Reince Priebus and now Mick Mulvaneys as the third is reaching new levels of chaos tonight. President trump is now on the attack against his own administration. Especially anyone involved in the job of controlling the southern border. The president got rid of his Homeland Security secretary Kristin Nielsen last night. So far the president is allowing her to publicly claim that she resigned, but we will surely be seeing the i fired her tweets probably by the end of this week because President Trump never lets any of his failed cabinet members leave without some kind of nasty i can kick as theyre on their bay out the door. Her last day is supposed to be wednesday of this week. Well see if she lasts that long. Today the president fired the secret Service Director. And while he was at it, he fired the immigration and Customs Enforcement director. The surprise firing of Kristin Nielsen last night came after the president told fox news on friday when he visited the border in california, the country is full. The New York Times is reporting that the president repeatedly called ms. Nielsen at home early in the mornings to depend that she take action to stop migrants from entering the country including doing things that were clearly illegal such as blocking all migrants from seeking asylum, according to nbc news, President Donald Trump has for months urged his administration to reinstate large scale separation of migrant families crossing the border according to three u. S. Officials with knowledge of meetings an the white house. Nbc news also reports nielsen told trump that federal court orders prohibited the department of Homeland Security from reinstating the policy and that he would be reversing his own executive order from june that ended family separation. Senior Administration Officials say that President Trump ordered Kristin Nielsen and secretary of state mike pompeo to shut down the port of el paso march 22nd at 12 00 noon. The plan was that in subsequent days the Trump Administration would then shut down other ports, Kristin Nielsen then told the president that that would be a bad and even dangerous ideas and proposes an alternative plan that would slow down entries at legal ports. According to two people in the room, the president said, i dont care. It the trump chaos comes while congress and the country await attorney general William Barrs redacted verse of the Mueller Report this week. This week he will be forced to testify to the House Appropriations committee on tuesday and the senate Appropriations Committee on wednesday. Those hearings are supposed to be about the justice departments budget but you can expect questioning about the Mueller Report. Joining us now is, joyce vance, former federal prosecutor and professor at the university of Alabama School of law, maria traerz ca mar, veto latino and peter baker, chief White House Correspondent for the New York Times, all msnbc contributors and necessary to the moving parts of this discussion. Peter baker, let me start with you. Youre part of the reporting team thats delivering us what we think is happening inside this white house. But this is weve said this before but with each successive white house chief of starks this feels like a new layer level of chaos with these multiple firings. What youre seeing is a president frustrated after two years in office he hasnt been able to have the impact on the border he thought he would be able to have. He hasnt gotten the wall built. Although he went down last week to claim that its now under construction. He hasnt gotten the numbers you know, down to zero obviously in fact theyve been coming up the last couple months. He blamed Kristin Nielsen for this. Thats not the only one who is going to leave as a result. A number of top people at the department of Homeland Security will leave in the coming days probably because hes trying to clean house and find a new team of people. I tell you something that two years in he hasnt found a team he thinks can carry out the wishes he has for this. Sometimes for those reasons you decide it officials like secretary nielsen felt that the things he was asking them to do were not perfectly legal, not appropriate, not effective even. But rather than accept that, hes going to find a new team until he finds one that he thinks is going to be more effective at stopping people from coming over the boarder. Peter what, do we know about the firing of the head of the secret service . Yeah, that one is not directly related to immigration but its part of the overall dissatisfaction with the department. Its really a sign that a lot of these departures are connected it seems like to john kelly. Kelly, of course, had been the first secretary of Homeland Security before being white house chief of staff and tex alles has been his choice, a former marine general for secret Service Director. The administration will say he didnt fit in. He was the first secret Service Director who hadnt been from the agency more than a century and therefore, didnt really suit the job. You hear from his allies in secret service. No, he was well liked in there. But in any case, clearly he was associated with general kelly. That was a black mark against him with the president. Maria kumar, the shakeup of Homeland Security goes to one your areas of expertise. The current immigration situation and all the reporting seems to indicate that the hand of Steven Miller is in all of this. I think its become very clear the one running the show inside the white house is Steven Miller. Hes the last person standing. He is the one that puts out policy and all of a sudden the people charged to deploy that policy doesnt quite figure out how to do it so he backs up and points the finger back at them and hes become teflon. It would be curious if we could do more digging in the influence he has with the president because its clear that he is the person. Pull willing the strings, that he has become the puppet master and the more we can better understand his intentions i think that the more that people could actually do not only better reporting but have better negotiations with the president himself. This idea that the reason that theyre reshuffling Homeland Security at a time the president claims we are under attack that our border is incredibly weak shout give us all pause. Im going to redo all the folks that are missing right now at Homeland Security, not only do we not have a cabinet member with secretary nielsen resigning but we dont have the secret service, we dont have head of fema, head of i. C. E. , we dontive specter general, someone leading Public Policy on behalf of the department and now dont have a custom control commissioner. Basically as the president claims that there is a Huge National security issue, all those people that could advise him and actually direct policy and prevent anything from happening are missing. I want to read a report from the Washington Post indicating one way that Kristin Nielsen apparently saved her job according to this reporting. Earlier in her tenure. It says she appeared to regain her footing after u. S. Border patrol agents used tear gas to repel a large crowd attempting to break through a border fence, the kind of tough action trump said he wanted in a dhs secretary. And so maria teresa, yet another possible reason we saw that tear gassing. Unfortunately, i think secretary nielsen right now is trying to basically wipe herself off and say i couldnt do anymore for this president. But the fact she under her supervision resaul thousands of children being separated from their families we are now learning from the Trump Administration and from judges that many of these children that are still lost in the system may not be reunited with their families for the next two years. Dem mon strays a lot of these decisions is lie squarely on her. And that is i think one of the things we have to insure that there actually are at the end of the day certain types of repercussions when people decide to basically stand by a president doing things morally wrong and in many cases it seems like that are legally ambiguous. Joyce no, legal ambiguity in some of the background reporting about what was going on in the oval office. We just read reporting that the president when he would hear things like the family separation trying to do that again vi lays your own executive order and also violates a court order you cant do that, the president says i dont care. Thats his reaction to everything here. We see that playing out in this massacre at dhs. These are people who didnt hesitate to carry out the president s agenda. They separated kids from their parents. They made it virtually impossible for people lawfully trying to seek asylum to do that. They did everything he wanted them to do. Apparently the only line was when he tried to push them over into outright il legality. And the only thing we conclude from that is the president now seeks new leadership that is willing to violate the law. Otherwise, why get rid of this team that did so much for him to carry his water forward. Peter, youve done so much reporting about the inside of the Trump White House and about the various outbreaks of chaos that we get to see publicly. The books that cop out about inside the white house seem to add to that with revelations of day to day chaos that never quite make it into the news cycle. What is your judgment about where we sit tonight in the chaos rhythms of the Trump White House. Is this worse than it has been in the past . Yeah, thats a good question. The one thing youll hear if you talk to white house officials is this resentment that we say they are in chaos. They say everything is running perfectly smoolthly and Mick Mulvaney the new acting at least chief of staff has tried to stabilize things and feels like things are going better. And yet, this is a presidency that lives on what the outside world anyway would consider to be a certain degree of chaos or a certain degree of unpredictability at the very least. Thats just the way they roll an its not going to change. Theyre not looking for a different way. In fact, i think theyve come to understand that the president is the president. Hes not going to change. Hes 672 years old. This is how he operated in business, thats how he operated in entertainment. Hes not going to suddenly become a different person. It works for him in the way he wants it to work. So were not going to try to stop him anymore. It the people around him are going to try to manage it and keep it from falling off the rails, bus in the end, theres going to be a certain degree of volatility in this white house till the day its done. And maria teresa, the spinoff is they have created chaos in thousands of families that were separated at that border, some remain separated. Estimates saying it might take two years to be able to put some families back together. Because the approach they brought to this never included even a plan for putting families back together. They had absolutely no plan when they did family separations that they were going to track the children and the parents for reunification. That speaks to the a morality of this the fact that they were basically going doing deterrence at an all costs. Its cruel and a reminder for those who cross the bodder and seek asylum, thats legal. The fact the president is trying to prevent people from even crossing over to mexico and trying to put the burden on mexico, a judge today basically said thats illegal. Thats where we have to make sure were doing due diligence. Right now had the facility that turned a ot of these unaccompanied minors have shut down and theyve opened up homestead in florida and housing over 3200 children as we speak. We have to make sure we are diligent and have the staple same level of outrage as we had before to ensure that the facilities are closes down and the families are reunited. Joyce vance, its another week in which Robert Mueller will be in the headlines but in the person of attorney general barr testifying two days in a row to a House Committee and then a Senate Committee about the budget of the justice department. Its that time of year when the heads of departments have to do that. But obviously, the attorney general is going to get some real questions about the Mueller Report. Will he be able to in these appropriations hearings dodge those questions do you think or will he have to add something to our public understanding of where we are . You know, you know this so much better than i do, but no attorney general looks forward to going up to capitol hill to talk about the budget, right . Its never a good day. This is so much worse. And really the smart thing for barr to do would be to release at least the summaries that we know the mueller team prepared to put those out there as a show of good faith to try to reestablish some of the credibility that he has lost so much of ever since this report came out. Weve seen no indication at this late date that thats going to come. Apparently this attorney general will go up on capitol hill and spend the next two days trying to duck the only quell that at least the democrats care about, whats really in the Mueller Report. The countrys entitled to know. And i think that there are some folks who know what theyre doing, some former prosecutors, people who are unafraid to speak truth to power and i think that the attorney general will there will at least be an effort to hold him accountable. How hell respond is still up in the air. Just the people we needed to start us off tonight on those subjects, joyce vance, maria, and peter baker thank you all. Really appreciate it. When we come back, former roeschry secretary larry somers has taught me something tonight about the law that governs the mandatory handover of tax returns to the chairs of the tax writing committees by the irs. Larry some mers will join us next. Youre going to want to be taking notes. At the end of this hour, we will consider how barack obama handles himself and his tax returns when his tax returns were being audited. Returns when his tax returns were beingud aited to be nobody but yourself in a world which is doing its best to make you everybody else. Means to fight the hardest battle, which any human being can fight and never stop. Does this sound dismal . It isnt. Its the most wonderful life on earth. You wouldnt accept an incomplete job from any one else. Why accept it from your allergy pills . Flonase sensimist relieves all your worst symptoms, including nasal congestion, which most pills dont. And all from a gentle mist you can barely feel. Flonase sensimist. You can barely feel. Applebees bigger, bolder grill combos. Now thats eatin good in the neighborhood. You know reliable support when you have it, and that dependability is what we want to give our customers. At comcast, its my job to constantly monitor our network. Prevent problems, and to help provide the most Reliable Service possible. My name is tanya, i work in the Network Operations center for comcast. We are working to make things simple, easy and awesome. The president s lawyers have one mother full day to try to figure out how to defy a very clear and simple law that no one has ever defied. It is the law that empowers the chairs of the house and senate tax writing committees to doomed, not request demand from the irs any tax return that they want to see. The law does not put any limitations on that power. Ive known about that law since i worked on the staff of the Senate Finance committee in the 1990s and thoughts i knew everything about that law until professor lawrence some mers new piece in the Washington Post just put online tonight. Professor some mers was the heads of the National Economic council for president obama and he served as treasury secretary under president clinton. And he has something very important to teach us about this law and as ive mentioned before, the law was written in 1924 and it says when the chairman of the house ways and Means Committee or the Senate Finance committee demands a tax return from the irs the secretary shall furnish such committee with any return or return information specified in such request. The law was written to apply to the treasury secretary since the Internal Revenue service is part of the Treasury Department. But in his oped piece, former treasury secretary larry somers says the treasury secretary should have absolutely nothing to do with chairman richie neals demand for the trump tax returns because the treasury secretary years ago specifically delegated this responsibility directly to the commissioner of the irs. Larry somers writes the an appropriate response of the treasury secretary is very clear. Under a longstanding delegation order, the secretary does not get involved in taxpayer specific matters and has del guyed to the irs commissioners as follows, the commissioner of Internal Revenue shall be responsible for the administration and enforcement of the Internal Revenue laws. Moreover, this is not a delegation that is readily revokable. Federal law provides that if the secretary determines not to delegate a power such determination may not take effect until 30 days after the secretary notifies the tax writing and other specified committees. So the, so far the secretary to seek to decide whether to pass on the president s tax return to congress would surely be inappropriate pan probably illegal. Probably illegal. I would truly not have done it. Rather i would have indicated to the irs commissioner i expected the irs to comply with the law as always. And joining us now for an exclusive interview, lawrence somers, the former treasury secretary under president bill clinton and former director of the National Economic counsel under obama. He is an economics professor at harnd university. Thank you for joining us tonight. Have you taught me something once again. Im used to taking notes when you speak. But i did not know that the delegation from the treasury secretary to the irs commissioner on matters of tax issues like this was actually in writing and that its a formal delegation and theres a formal process for revoking that delegation. Thats right. You know, its the first one of the first things my general counsel told me when i became treasury secretary was any individual tax matter affecting any individual taxpayer you are under no circumstances going to be anywhere near. And that applies to a request of this kind and for good reason. Its the essence of the integrity of the tax system that politically appointed officials not be involved in these matters and thats why there is a delegation to the head of the irs and it wouldnt have ever occurred to me and wouldnt have occurred to the treasury secretaries who i served under or the treasury secretary i served with to become involved in an individual taxpayer matter, much less an individual taxpayer matter involving the president of the united states. And so and the part that i didnt realize is that this is actually written and in effect codified within the Treasury Department and so what youre telling us is, if secretary mnuchin does want to be the one who decide what to do about the trump tax returns, he has to file a notice with the Senate Finance committee and with the house ways emins committee right now saying that 30 days from now, he will revoke he will resume or take back the power away from the irs commissioner to deal with these tax returns. That is the understanding that i have of the law confirmed by legal officials who have served in the relevant tax positions in the past. And i do not think it would be appropriate for a secretary of the treasury to become involved in the resolution of a matter of this kind. And knowing the way the Treasury Department works, theres a council but there already also some people working as i understand it kind of in the mid level of an office like that who have been there for years through different administrations who really have institutional expertise about this. Would you expect what youre telling us now has already foundity way to secretary mnuchin, that he should have been made aware of what you know about this even before your oped piece came out . I cant know that for sure. I imagine different secretaries operate differently. Certainly on matters of this kind, we would always have been very careful to seek the guidance of and presumptively 0 follow the guidance of career officials. And an certainly career officials are familiar with the long history of the concept of independence of main treasury from individual taxpayer matters. And you make the point that while you were treasury secretary, you never had to worry about or think about Something Like this. And you explain in your piece why. Could you remind the audience why you as bill clintons treasury secretary never had to think about it. Sure, president clinton made all his tax returns publicly available. All the president s for the last 50 years have made all their tax returns publicly available. So this kind of issue would have been couldnt possibly have arisen. Its only arisen because this president has chosen not to make his tax returns publicly available. Which was his prerogative. But it is also the prerogative of the congress as part of their oversight function and one of their oversight functions is making sure that president ial tax returns are adequately monitored and audited especially in light of the fact that there were failures in that area during the nixon administration, for which reason they have requested access to the president s tax return. By the way, this is this is something thats been considered extensively. This isnt something new. The relevant statute 6103 dates from 1924, congress during the time i was in the Treasury Department in the 90s, passed the irs restructuring act and as part of that irs restuk touring act they made clear that any employee of the irs who failed to comply with this law it was what was control questionally referred to as the ten deadly sibs, would be subject to being immediately fired. So this is not something that congress has failed to consider carefully. This is not something, these are not provisions that have never been used before, for example, they were used in the investigations of bias against what was felt to be biases against conservative groups during the Obama Administration by the then republican ways and Means Committee. So these are long established provisions. Lawrence somers, thank you very much for joining us tonight. Really appreciate it. Thank you. And when we come back, so what will steve na mnuchin do about chairman neals demand for the tax returnses . We will consider that next with two authors that portrays Steve Mnuchin as the class clown of tax policy in the Trump Administration. Lass clown of tax policy in the Trump Administration so theyre using Dell Technologies with the power of vmware to bring their idea to life. Together, were powering ai that analyzes satellite imagery to follow the spread of pathogens like malaria so we can stop them in their tracks. And that kind of technology. Can make the world a healthier place. Vmware, a part of Dell Technologies. Im missing out on our family outings because i cant find a bladder leakage product that fits. Everything was too loose. But depend® fitflex feels tailored to me. With a range of sizes for all body types. Depend® fitflex underwear is guaranteed to be your best fit. Depend® fitflex underwear itso chantix can help you quit slow turkey. Along with support, chantix is proven to help you quit. With chantix you can keep smoking at first and ease into quitting so when the day arrives, youll be more ready to kiss cigarettes goodbye. When you try to quit smoking, with or without chantix. You may have nicotine withdrawal symptoms. Stop chantix and get help right away if you have changes in behavior or thinking, aggression, hostility, depressed mood, suicidal thoughts or actions, seizures, new or worse heart or blood vessel problems, sleepwalking, or life threatening allergic and skin reactions. Decrease alcohol use. Use caution driving or operating machinery. Tell your doctor if youve had Mental Health problems. The most common side effect is nausea. Talk to your doctor about chantix. Theres a new book out tonight with more inside reporting from inside the Trump Administration. And insights about how the Trump Administration operates including its a book that might be able to help us with the question of will Donald Trumps treasury secretary Steve Mnuchin, what will he do on wednesday when the deadline arrives for the irs to turn over trumps tax returns to chairman richard neal of the house ways and Means Committee. We dont know the but in a new book, mnuchin is portrayed as the class clouchb tax policy in the Trump Administration. The book is called the hill to die on. It chronicles the first two years of trumps struggles with congress and contains this report of how congressional leaders and everyone else involved regarding mnuchins input when they were trying to pass the trump tax cuts . Most everyone discounted him much like trump, he seemed to latch onto the last concept he heard. For example, he wanted to craft rules that would in effect allow earnings up to 1 million to be taxed at 20 . This could allow a lobbyist making 900,000 to pay a lower effective tax rate than a teacher. Some involved in the negotiation preferred that mnuchin stay far away. One day in november, he was at an event in los angeles and a white house aide joked that he was going to find more events thousands of miles away from washington for mnuchin to attend. We dont know how Steve Mnuchin will handle neals demand for the trump tax returns by wednesday but it seems very clear that the Trump Administration is not going to leave that decision up to Steve Mnuchin. Jake sherman and anna palmer will join us next with their insights on how the Trump Administration will rely to chairman kneels demands for the trump tax returns and what their reporting tells them about the new levels of chaos were seeing in the Trump White House tonight and well review the books description of one of those rare moments when President Trump surprised everyone in the room by studiously taking notes. Well, they thought he was taking notes. Until they saw what was really on that piece of paper. Thats next. Was really on that piece pofaper thats next. So, youre open all day, thats what 24 7 means, sugar. Kind of like how you get 24 7 access to licensed agents with geico. Hmm . Yeah, you just go online, or give them a call anytime. You dont say. Yep. Now what will it take to get 24 7 access to that lemon meringue pie . Pie pies coming thats what it takes, baby. Geico®. Great service from licensed agents, 24 7. Do you want ready to Wear Clothing without all the hassle . You can, with bounce dryer sheets. We dried one shirt without bounce, and an identical shirt using bounce. The bounce shirt has fewer wrinkles, less static, and more softness and freshness. Bounce out wrinkles, bounce out static. When it comes to type 2 diabetes, are you thinking about your heart . Well, im managing my a1c, so i should be all set. Actually, youre still at risk for a fatal heart attack or stroke. Thats where jardiance comes in. It reduces the risk of dying from a cardiovascular event for adults who have type 2 diabetes and known heart diseas. Thats why the American Diabetes association recommends the active ingredient in jardiance. And it lowers a1c . With diet and exercise. Jardiance can cause serious side effects including dehydration, genital yeast or urinary tract infections, and sudden kidney problems. Ketoacidosis is a serious side effect that may be fatal. A rare, but lifethreatening, bacterial infection in the skin of the perineum could occur. Stop taking jardiance and call your doctor right away if you have symptoms of this bacterial infection, ketoacidosis, or an allergic reaction. Do not take jardiance if you are on dialysis or have severe kidney problems. Taking jardiance with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. So, what do you think . Now i feel i can do more to go beyond lowering a1c. Ask your doctor about jardiance today. Now i feel i can do more to go beyond lowering a1c. Straight from the worlds best plant scientists comes miraclegro performance organics. Its miraclegros next big thing. Organic plant food and soil that finally work. And work. And work. And yes we did say organic. For twice the bounty, guaranteed. Miraclegro performance organics. Organics finally grow up. And up, and up. You get the price match guarantee. So if you find your room at a lower rate, hilton is like. Were gonna match that rate and give you an extra 25 off. What would travel sites do if you found a different price . Thats not my problem, its your problem. Book at hilton. Com and get the hilton price match guarantee. Take notes in meetings according to all accounts, the president barely listens to what people are talking about at meetings. So there was real surprise one day at camp david when the president was busily taking notes. Here was the scene as reported by jake sherman and anna palmer in their new book. Trump was nodding his hid taking what happened to be furious notes on a note card in front of him. People in the room were impressed that trump cement to be so engaged in gary cohns proposal. Notes hts nothing to do with infrastructure. Sloppy steve, trump had scrawled on the top of the card in black marker. As cohen had detailed his plans to rebuild americas roads, the president was writing do you know how he wanted to trash steve bannon the next time someone asked him about it. Joining our discussion now anna palmer and jake sherman, coauthors of the new book the hill to die on, the battle for congress and the future of trumps america. Coauthors of the politico playbook. Really appreciate this in your first primetime interview about the book. Well sell as many as we can. So so many things about the furious taking of notes and it turns out to be sloppy steve. He does rehearse the nicknames. He doesnt just rehearse them. He writes them, he sits down and thinks about them really hard. I think the president is something that came up time and time again in this book and in multiple instances throughout the book, the president really does have a vision for hollywood flair. Right . Another incident in the book talked about how a meet eg got he told paul ryan a meeting got good ratings. Paul ryan turned to him and said what ratings are you talking about . He said everything has ratings. This is why i was so good at the governance. Thats the way he thinks about governing which is through the lens of a hollywood flair which is something we havent seen in the context of donald trump. Anna, the way we read these books is the books are always about something thats happened. You try to get them to press as fast as possible. But you are always dealing with something a minimum of 90 days old and sometimes a year or two old. Were always reading them in todays news environment. We are reading about this chaos in the Trump Administration and basically cleaning out the Homeland Security department in 24 hours. And what did you find in your reporting that gives you a way of looking at todays chaos news. Yeah, i mean i think what you see today happened in the last 1 months. Its kinds of stunning you. Forget theres so much news happening, a luge of people being fired, people coming in as acting different sks that you kind of look back from election day and look at the political novices who came into washington, Jared Kushner thinking he was going to up end the entire wait government operated and you see them still having a lot of the same mistakes which is pretty surprising. And you mentioned that there is a passage in the book that includes senator mccain. Hes talking to the president and Jared Kushner weighs in and Jared Kushner says were going to change the way the entire government works. Kushner said without a hint of irony in the book, mccain says good luck with that, son. It seems to me that good luck with that son is actually too subtle for the Jared Kushner who is portrayed in this book. He would think mccain is wishing me luck. I can get this done. I think the entire Trump Administration came to washington which is a town as you know well is not really into change, is not into up ending structures around for 100 years and Jared Kushner is body somebody who fancies himself a dealmaker somebody who could tear part the government and rebid it in his liking. It does get to the point frankly what you were talking about before about cleaning out the department of Homeland Security. The president likes that. The president likes people who are going to try to complete his missions, try to do things in his image. I think kushner was trying to do that in front of the president say were going to remake this whole government. Donald trump got elected. Theres so many things in here that stun me. During the president ial campaign when i didnt think donald trump was going to win, i would sometimes think, if he ever was president , he would discover that speaker of the house is way more powerful than he is on most things not involving foreign policy. Turns out i was completely wrong. Paul ryan turned out to be the weakest speaker of the house ive ever seen in my lifetime. I have never been able to be explain how paul ryan and these republicans who sounded like they meant half of what they were saying at least which is kind of the normal political level of washington, they gave up on all of that on any concern for the deficit, any concern for the debt, when trump came in and seemed to him know tise them. I think what you saw is stunning when you look at paul ryan for 20 years, deficit hawk. You look where he was on immigration trying to cut deals with republicans, almost seeming like a dob on that issue. And when the president came into office, he really fell in line behind all of his. Why . I think he would say now in the book we talk about this is that he felt like the bigger things that they were able to get in done in particular tax reform for him which was his hill to die on as a member of congress was able to get done. But jake, they did what they call tax reform. This was not tax reform. It was a cut. Under Ronald Reagan they did do both tax cuts and tax reform and didnt sacrifice republican principles along way. What happened in 1986 was very different from what happened in 2017 or 18 whenever that happened. The donald trump tax reform, donald trump and republicans were dishonest about this. They said that democrats they tried to get democrats involved and couldnt get them solved. That was not true. They designed this process to go around democrats and on the paul ryan point, i want to add one thing. We get into a paul of ryan in this book. I think a lot of people close to him would say his take away was he trashed donald trump throughout the entire 2016 campaign. He didnt endorse him. He was very fervently against trump. We have a chapter called not a trump guy about paul ryan. But then donald trump won and paul ryan felt like he had two choices. There was a fork in the road. He could either concede he lost the argument and stay in government and what he thought was keep the government on the rails. He said he didnt want to the just never trump and take his toys home or he could leave. He chose to stay in government. But ended up driving the republicans into a defeat in the house of representativeses. We could go on and on about this. Thank you very much, jake sherman, anna palmer. The book is the hill to die on. When we come back, donald trump says he cant release his tax returns. Hes always said he cant release them because theyre under audit. So what did barack obama do when he was being audited by the irs repeatedly as he was . When we come back, well tell you all about it. When we come back, well tell you all about it the worst. Especially when your easily distracted teenager has the car. At subaru, were taking on distracted driving [ping] with sensors that alert you when your eyes are off the road. The allnew subaru forester. The safest forester ever. Steven could only imaginem 24hr to trenjoying a spicy taco. Burn, now, his world explodes with flavor. Nexium 24hr stops acid before it starts for allday allnight protection. Can you imagine 24hours without heartburn . Or psoriatic arthritis, Little Things can be a big deal. Thats why theres otezla. Otezla is not an injection or a cream. Its a pill that treats differently. For psoriasis, 75 clearer skin is achievable, with reduced redness, thickness, and scaliness of plaques. For psoriatic arthritis, otezla is proven to reduce joint swelling, tenderness, and pain. And the otezla prescribing information has no requirement for routine lab monitoring. Dont use if youre allergic to otezla. It may cause severe diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting. Otezla is associated with an increased risk of depression. Tell your doctor if you have a history of depression or suicidal thoughts or if these feelings develop. Some people taking otezla reported weight loss. Your doctor should monitor your weight and may stop treatment. Upper respiratory tract infection and headache may occur. Tell your doctor about your medicines and if youre pregnant or planning to be. Ready to treat differently with a pill . Otezla. Show more of you. It is the standing policy of the irs to routinely audit tax returns filed by the president of the united states. Theres no law that requires the president s tax returns to be audited, but that is something that the house ways and Means Committee chairman richard neal and actually considering, passing a law that would require the irs to audit president ial tax returns. That is one of the reasons that chairman neal has demanded President Trumps tax returns from the irs as the law allows him to do. The reason this has never come up before, the chairman of the house ways and Means Committee demanding to see the president s tax returns is because all past president s since Richard Nixon have publicly voluntarily released their tax returns. But not donald trump. And so here we are facing a deadline, the day after tomorrow. The deadline that chairman neal gave the commissioner of the irs to turn over the trump tax returns. Well show you how barack obama and other pres and Vice President s handled their tax returns after this final break, and well remind you of the story which some of you might remember of the time the Vice President s tax returns showed v very little Charitable Giving which created headlines in some newspapers calling him the cheap veep. Who was the cheap veep, the answer is next. O was the cheap answer is next we dont follow t. Ensure max protein. To give you the protein you need with less of the sugar you dont. straining ill take that. cheers 30 grams of protein and 1 gram of sugar. Ensure max protein. In two great flavors. What do all these people have in common, limu . Oug [ paper rustling ] exactly, nothing. Theyre completely different people, thats why they need customized Car Insurance from liberty mutual. Theyll only pay for what they need [ gargling ] [ coins hitting the desk ] yes, and they could save a ton. Youve done it again, limu. Only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Conventional wisdom says you cant make a 400 horsepower sedan, thats also environmentally conscious. We dont follow conventional wisdom. When barack obama was president he publicly released his tax returns every year by april 15th. As soon as president obama filed his tax returns, and he always filed them on time, he released them publicly. And that wasnt Barack Obamas idea. President s and Vice President s had been doing that for decades. President bush and dick cheney publicly released tax returns every year they were in office. Bill clinton and al gore releashed their tax returns every year they were in office. And since bill clinton filed jointly with Hillary Clinton, that means Hillary Clinton was also releasing her tax returns every year she was first lady. None of the president ial tax returns that were reheleased we particularly confidential. It was a routine news story right around april 15th. And the only tax release i for one can remember even being slightly controversial was one very peculiar year where Vice President al gore gave only about 350 to charity. This looked like one of those slipups when people miss the deadline by december. But that got al gore the headline cheap veep, and that is the only thing i can remember from president ial and Vice President ial publicly released tax returns that was confidential. He was probable horrified when he discovered hed only given 350 to charity that year, but there was nothing he could do about it. It was out of the question for him to decide not footo release his tax returns because it contain aden embarrassing item like that. The next year the charitable donations were 15,091. Here are the dates in which president obama and Vice President biden publicly released their tax returns after filing with the irs. Four times the president did it on the last day, april 15th. The earliest he did it was april 10th. And most president s use the filing of their tax returns to make a Public Statement about their next policy. In his last year as president when he released his taxes on april 15th to proval to the country he was doing his part in paying his taxes on time president obama said while weve made progress toward ensuring that the wealthiest americans pay their fair share, there is more work to do. We need to close special tax loopholes for millionaires and billionaires and invest in the middle class. That was a typical statement from a democratic president on april 15th when he was filing and releasing his tax returns. Donald trump has no message for the american taxpayer on april 15th. Donald trump makes no attempt to show them that that he is paying his fair share and paying it on time. Donald trump simply tells the lee that he cannot publicly release his tax returns because theyre being audited. Well, that is finally true. The tax returns that donald trump has filed while he is president have been ozted automatically because it is the irs policy to automatically audit president ial tax returns unless President Trump has ordered them to stop that policy. But that also means that all of Donald Trumps predecessors since Richard Nixon have been publicly releasing their tax returns while their tax returns are being audited by the irs. Every single time president obama publicly released a tax return, that tax return on that very same day was under audit by the irs, and we know that because its irs policy to audit president ial tax returns. And not one president has thought thats a reason not to release tax returns. Not one. President bush, president clinton, president reagan, president carter. None of them said i cant release my tax returns because im being audited. They all released their tax returns and they were all being audited at the same time. What message for taxpayers will President Trump have on april 15th . I hope you get away with as much in your tax returns as i get away with in mine . Chairman richard neal is going to get Donald Trumps tax returns. The law is very clear about that. It might take several months in court to enforce that law, but that law will be enforced. But as we approach april 15th donald trump continues to undermine tax law in america by defying the president ial tradition of publicly releasing tax returns and in effect encouraging taxpayers to try to get away with whatever they can on their tax returns. The trump method. That is tonights last word. The 11th hour with Brian Williams starts now. Tonight more departures than arrivals as a number of big names have been shown the door and a Trump Administration with a lot of vacancies now in some big permanent jobs. The kind of jobs that affect the safety of the american people. Plus tough questions are awaiting attorney general bill barr when he appears before Congress Just hours from now. And most folks have the same questions. Wheres the Mueller Report, whats in it, when do we get to see it . And the rare political speech that broke through and might just echo for some time. Tonight the words of a 37yearold mayor of a small midwestern city as the 11th hour gets under way on a monday night. Well, good evening once again from our nbc news headquarters here in new york. Day 809 of this Trump Administration. The president is shaking up the top ranks of the nations immigration and security