Cut the American People. This is a time for solutions and they need to be based upon fairness for all. Somebody in the House Republican caucus has to grab the wheel and hit the brakes. There are two deals circulating, first the senate, to reopen the government through january 15th, the exact date the next round of sequester cuts kicks in. Extend the debt ceiling until february 7th and create a budget negotiation framework by mid december. Obama care could be involved with a delay to the reinsurance fees employers pay and efforts to strengthen laws if your income level qualifies you for a subsidy. Then theres the house gop plan, the same dates on the debt ceiling and short term budget but would stop future efforts by the treasury to extend the debt limit. House republicans want a twoyear delay to the medical device tax and to eliminate all obama care protections for labor unions and subsidies for elected officials in washington. No matter which door we choose, looks like well be back in needless crisis plan by the new year. We start with Peter Alexander at the white house and luke russert on the hill. They are about to bring the House Democratic leaders into the oval office. What do you think the message will be . Reporter i hope you give me points for the cliches lets see how many i can hit. Working they are on the same page that their ducks are in the row and another one, that they are trying to shore up support. Thats a very they could walk it back, its unlikely. Its all about lining it up. This is all about maintaining that sort of unified efforts the democrats have had throughout the shutdown and debt ceiling crisis. Obviously the republicans have struggled with that internal battle between the tea party bloc and more moderate republicans. This is what the white house is hoping to make sure that whenever anything does come out of the senator potentially out of the house later that everybody as we noted on the same page with that. Were heading toward this deadline. In fact jay carney during the press briefing said we have already passed the deadline in terms of uncertainty saying the time is of the essence. Im speaking to an economist a short time ago who put this in good terms as people try to get a better grasp of the date. Kind of like driving a car on empty into the desert where you pass the last gas station. Your car is not going to explode immediately. But you dont know when the next gas station may exist and wherever youre going isnt a very good thing. Ill turn this car right around. Ill turn this car right around. I counted eight, peter. Lets see if luke can do better. We did hear a lot from House Republicans on fairness for all. Wouldnt it be easier if the bill originates in the house . Reporter its easier in it originates in the house because then it stops one of the parliamentary procedures that ted cruz could use to delay it. Its a good vehicle. Lets take a step back and tell you where we are today. So the senate deal that we had been talking about between mcconnell, which has never filed, details were leaked out, that was overwhelmingly rejected by the house gop in their conference. One member said to me it was a ka ka sandwich, you know the real terminology there. After that happened and forward their own bill, which was also dismissed because real ultraconservatives within the house gop conference did not december lidislike the fact it took away the employer payins and subsidies for president and vmt and cabinet, they wanted it to extend to staff. After that meeting, boehner had to go out and say, we dont know what were going to do precisely, we have to put something on the floor tonight. We dont know what its going to look like. They are behind closed doors right now trying to make this bill more conservative to try to attract the amount of republicans they would need to get out of the house. While thats happening, Mitch Mcconnell has said to harry reid, were not going to negotiate, i want to see whats coming out of the house of representatives. What boehner has done in the house gop conference has done, delayed the talks that were seemingly going very well between reid and mcconnell to see what the house can produce. From conversations ive had with members, its really, real tough sledding to use a cliche for them to get to 218 on this bill, whatever it might look like. The more conservative it gets, the more it will be dismissed by reid. On your point, it makes it easier in the sense that boehner and the house gop can pass this bill over to the senate, reid in theory could amend it, striking out things he doesnt like and keeping things they could agree on, on which there is some in there and move it forward. As we get towards the october 17th deadline, this creates a huge issue if the markets react negativively and on top of that, there are folks in the house gop that dont think october 17th is that bad. If the markets react negativively, theyll yank this and pass something out really quickly. If the markets are kind of like, we think youre going to do something, then youll see this battle gone on through thursday and its anyones idea as to how this ends up, guys. Theres a lot that i dont understand about whats going on in the Republican Caucus right now, but the session with stripping their own staffers of health care is particularly bizarre to me. People who make 29,000 a year answering phones and for whatever reason people that work for them. Political pawns, thats what it is. They are political pawns now. On the step of a default and government being shut down for over two weeks. Only in america, folks. Peter and luke, thank you both. I want to bring in howard fineman. I would love for you to weigh in on the reporting weve heard from luke. It sounds like the senate deal is not at all acceptable to the House Republicans, even the plan from the House Republicans is not acceptable to the far reaches of the House Republicans. How do you see this all coming together . Well, actually they are not very far apart. They are agonizingly close. But the problem is, the sort of psychological dynamics almost of this. Just as nothing that barack obama, the president of the United States would propose could possibly be acceptable to the Tea Party Wing in the house, so too anything that the senate comes up with, even including anything the senate comes up where Mitch Mcconnell is in concert with harry reid. That by definition is unacceptable to House Republicans, many of them. What they are looking for now and trying to throw the Staff Members under the bus and labor Union Language and language about you cant try any tricks at the Treasury Department in the future, all of that stuff is designed to prevent them agreeing when in fact the two sides in many respects are very close. The republicans basically the tea party has already lost essentially on obama care. The whole game here was to try to seriously delay or defund obama care. It was a wrong headed and disastrous strategy on their part. Theyve lost that. So they are still looking and still down on basement meeting in the basement trying to figure some way to reject whatever comes out of the senate. That is sort of the dangerous and unfortunate psychology were in the middle of here. Howard, you mentioned throwing staffers under the bus. I hope they dont get hurt in that bus clash because they would need health care. I wanted to try to add to the sum total of cliches. You did. We bring it hard with cliches, you know that about that. I want to ask beyond the details of these bills that we are looking at closely as you get down to the wire, if you take a step back and you put aside the fact that in my opinion theres been an unethical type of government leadership here from some members of the house, if they do get a deal, that tweaks federal law and only wounds the debt ceiling a couple of months away, doesnt that risk rewarding blackmail and at a certain point rewarding irresponsible behavior is irresponsible behavior . Everybody keeps talking about this as though it were a lesson in kind garten or parenting. I agree with that theory up to a point. But when does it become a victory that you drive the republicans approval numbers down to the Single Digits and at the same time you have to witness a default of the u. S. Government and a potential worldwide economic crisis . I mean i dont know what lessons the republicans are going to learn. From what i can tell, the republicans have already the tea party has already decided and in many ways our government here in washington has already become a series of socalled manufactured crises. I dont see that changing. I think this is the new normal. This is the cliche alert, its i think its the way things are going to operate now. And i know were over at the house, i heard them say, were going to break their will, meaning the republicans, the break the will of the tea party. They are not going to break the will of the tea party. The tea party believes in rejecting and gumming up the works as much as possible. Thats part of their whole ethic. Rather than look at this as some sort of teaching moment, its time to look at it as a moment to get a deal. Its frightening. Thats right, that they have shut the government down. They have very little to show for it. Certainly nothing substantive. Nothing substantive to take home and say look what we got for shutting the government down. But their folks are happy with what they have done and want them to go further. All of these talk about gop numbers and sinking super low, their folks are happy with what theyve done. Most of these folks who oppose this led this thing will return to congress after their next election. So it makes me say they are going to do this again. As you talk about, this is the new normal. This era of brinksmanship. How do we get beyond this into something more substantive, governing that is worth while . The tea party can have their opposition, but this way of doing it is completely ineffective, not just for america but the entire globe. Right and especially as you were pointing out, even if they reach an agreement now, this is going to happen again right after the new year. I think part of the impetus is that the Business Community which doesnt have the effect it had, but common sense says you dont want this situation going on during the holiday season. You dont want it going on entering thanksgiving and christmas when many businesses make a lot of money for the whole year. Were going to kind of put it on hold until after the first of the year. Toure, i dont know the answer to your question. Ive been thinking about it a lot and writing about it a fair amount at the huffington post. I think the nature of our society has become more confrontational and dramatic and thats where we are. I dont know if these socalled regular order of the congress will ever return. I just dont know how. I wish i had an answer for you. Its so sad for the upcoming generation. But howard, i find harry reid and Mitch Mcconnells relationship pretty fascinating. Here they are yesterday complimenting each other. Lets listen. Im very optimistic we will reach an agreement thats reasonable in nature this week. I share his optimism that were going to get a result that will be acceptable to both sides. As we know, at any sort of crisis situation, when every other option has fallen to pieces, unlikely duos come together and find Common Ground in order to fix things. We saw that with president obama and Chris Christie after sandy hit much to the chagrin of many rpz. Now were seeing this with reid and mcconnell. Despite what many described as a bitter and distant relationship, i want your thoughts on the relationship and do you think it will be up to these two in terms of coming down with what can pull us out of this mess . Abby, its all well and good to see harry reid and Mitch Mcconnell as much as they dislike each other to work out a deal in the senate. That doesnt count in the house. As a matter of fact, every time the Tea Party People see Mitch Mcconnell going into a room with harry reid, it stiffens the tea partys resolve to oppose it. Dont forget Mitch Mcconnell has a Tea Party Challenger down in kentucky. Dont forget ted cruz who doesnt view himself as bound by one chamber of the congress, let alone the whole country, is busy making trouble with the House Republicans, meeting with them in a restaurant telling them to resist. And thats the situation were in right now. And we dont have much time to do much about it. Not a lot of optimism. Depressed me thoroughly, howard because youre exactly right. Thank you so much for a great analysis. Dems are continuing to arrive at the white house for the meeting with the president. You got to admit they have looked pretty united through this whole thing. Republicans on the other hand, thats another story. Well spin as the cycle rolls on. For a store near you go to benjaminmoore. Com bayarea. For a store near you go to benjaminmoore. Com bayarea. Hit me with your best shot in the spin, apparently the republicans best shot wasnt good enough to take down obama care. Now with nearly 3 4 of americans disapproving of the way the gop is handling the debt fight, you have to wonder, when do they throw in the towel . And when they do and the deal is settled between senate leaders, will the speaker of the house be able to sell it to the rauk us caucus . He might not even get the chance because senator ted cruz let it slip hes still debating an attempt to delay any such deal. Who exactly is he debating with . Probably nobody but that never stopped him before. The focus has shifted almost fully to the debt limit. Instead of the issue republicans started this entire thing over, obama care. Let me ask you a question and you can be honest and frank with me. How many of you are only here because you had some trouble signing up for obama care and instead you got tickets to the show . How many of you see for republicans that should be the headline, the obama carrollout has been a mess. The numbers are shockingly low and the white house doesnt have a solution at this point. Instead all were talking about is the craziness of tea party republicans. This is a real blown opportunity and i would argue they deserve every bit of backlash. All they had to do is nothing at all for the American People to see the glitchy, problematic rollout of obama care so far. I tried to put myself in speaker boehners shoes to be honest, i would rather walk over my feet every day walking home from work to have that happen, to be in his position. But if i were him i would tell my caucus its in your best interest to end the Government Shutdown as soon as possible so the headlines will shift from the gop holding the government hostage to obama care is a complete disaster. I dont even have to tell you guys, 5,000 enroll ees in 36 states are using the federal exchange program. Yet were barely talking about this because its been completely overshadowed by the narrative of the shutdown. It reminds me of one of my favorite movies, how to lose a guy in ten days, she does everything she possibly can love that movie. So charming. She is winning. She is good in that one. The title i would give it, how to lose all credibility and embarrass the party in 21 takes. Its been 21 days when cruz had his marathon speech against obama care. All of this nonsense is overshad lowing. In the end they want absolutely nothing and shoot themselves in the foot. The reason why boehner cant easily advocate, the reason why it doesnt completely ruin the Republican Party, they are not doing this alone. Theyve been demagoguing against obama care for three solid years and they cant just step aside at the last second and then let obama care fall on its own face. Even still, even now, the folks at home are calling and saying, this is what we want, good job. Good further. Dont give up. This is not far enough for them. So as long as you have that sort of alternate universe for folks getting fake news and pushing lawmakers to do things and giving ted cruz their straw poll by a large margin, theres another alternate universe that looks at this in an entirely different way. I think we have to stopped deluding ourselves to think we with reason or rationalize you mean me or members of everybody in the country needs to give up on these folks. They do not respond to normal logic. They were sent there to be come kaz zis, no poll number is going to change that. From the beginning, this has been within John Boehners control, to short circuit the xris sis, i hear this thing he cant pass anything with democratic support then hes afraid of losing his speakers gavel. First of all, i dont believe that. Second of all, heres an idea. Ness this is kinds of outside of historical numbers, theres no reason democrats cannot pledge support to john boehner for speaker if republicans keep control of the house in 2014. If you save the country and dont allow us to default, we will support over whatever tea party idiot runs against you for speaker if thats really the problem for them, lets short circuit it. Thats a novel idea. People need to understand this is not just a Government Shutdown, it is a democracy shutdown. You tune in now as krystal just i will lus dated, there are votes on the house floor. Theres a majority in both houses of congress to avoid the selfinflicted political default. The only reason were not doing it because the house does not function as a democracy. A lot of people around the country are tuning into it. The other number i want to leave people with, is 66. Thats the number of republicans quh who opposed the last debt ceiling hike. Theres 66 republicans who are already lost, they voted against this last time even when they got a huge compromise offer from the president , that was the time he said im not doing that again, not negotiating with you with an economic gun to my head. Some of these people are gone. When we have this final vote, a bunch of them arent going to be with you. What kind of deal do you make where you give people things and they still vote against you . Thats the point weve been discussing, theres a democracy problem and irresponsibility when you encourage these people. This vote in the end whether we get it thursday or in the tenth inning, its going to have republicans voting against it. We shouldnt give them anything. Youre talking about individuals who have total control. Its frightening and the conversation sadly will continue. Up next, polling i wish had been around when my dad was running in the primary, rational conservative is actually popular now. Ted cruz, thank you for that one. Has its ups and downs. Seasonal. Doesnt begin to describe it. My cashflow can literally change with the weather. Anything that gives me some breathing room makes a big difference. The plum card from American Express gives your business flexibility. Get 1. 5 discount for paying early, or up to 60 days to pay without interest, or both each month. Im Nelson Gutierrez and im a member of the smarter money. This is what membership is. This is what membership does. To find you a great deal, even if its not with us. [ ding ] oh, thats helpful well, our company does that, too. Actually, we invented that. Its like a sauna in here. Helping you save, even if its not with us now, thats progressive call or click today. No mas pantalones . That 1972 classic holds true today, apparently you have to leave the beltway to recognize it, ari. A brandnew nbc news esquire survey, half of americans describe themselves as being in the middle, being moderate. Our survey identified eight different groups ranging from far left to far right. The mini van moderates and right out right to name a view. This is almost evenly split between republicans and democrats and independence and they are pessimistic about both the economy and state of american politics. Lets bring a man who never had a pessimistic thought ever, even when hes dreaming, mark murray. Interesting stuff here, this center group you identify, they are pro gay marriage, pro marijuana and pro minimum wage hike and antiaffirmative action and pro death penalty. Interesting amall gamation of views there. I want to push back on the whole idea theres a robust model deciding elections. Steve cornacki, there are no swing voters we are more hyper partisan than ever. Elections are increasingly won by turning out folks on the edges, not pandering or sliding towards the middle. If there is a middle, they are not deciding elections anymore. What am i missing . Its how you define the middle and how you define the different polls. This breaks it up into eight different groups gives a good routine. There isnt the myth cal swing voter were hoping for in illinois or in wisconsin. But what was really instructive here is when somebody like me who followed the president obamas campaign and followed the mitt romney campaign, when you look at the eight different groups and realize you end up having partisans on both sides, righteous right versus the gospel left and bleeding heart versus talk radio heads and then you have the mini van moderates and people like in mba middle. It was interesting how the Obama Campaign talked to these different groups. For example, president obamas pitch when he was talking about contraception, talking about abortion rights, he was speaking to mini van moderates, a group that he ended up winning a 6633 margin. When he was talking about fairness and economic fairness, he was really hitting at these pickup populists in the middle. People who are kind of sometimes from more rural areas and people who might evenly have a high school education. When he was talking about the need for talking about being liberal on social issues but then, hey, still need fairness when it comes to the economy, that was the mba middle. What was fascinating, that should have been an area that mitt romney should have cleaned up in the 2012 election. It split 49 49 between obama and romney. So president obama either won on tied in all of these middle groups and thats explains who won in 2012 sfwl thats a great point, really interesting change weve seen. I disagree with toure on this because i argue that this group is so relevant that you look at the gop that has lost the popular vote since 1988 other than one time because they have not attracted enough of these people. There were two things i took away from this, you said this, the group wants fairness and two, that this irrational litmus test tone coming out of the Republican Party is not appealing at all to these folks. Shouldnt this be pretty concerning for the Republican Party as they look forward in terms of their prospects . Shouldnt they say, we need to attract these folks if we want to win again . I think so. You can use this survey to look and say that the righteous right and talk radio heads are the base and driving almost all of the actions the Republican Party right now and making it sometimes harder talking about issues like gay marriage we were talking about earlier, you make it harder to win over people in the mini van moderates or even the mba middle, this is liberal on social issues than economic ones. Sometimes catering to one of those to that base makes it harder. One of the problems the Republican Party has, they dont have a leader to set the tone. Its much easier when you control the white house to be able to explain to your base, heres what were for and heres what were against, right now it does seem that the talk radio folks, as well as the righteous right are driving the Republican Party and making it harder to hit the middle groups. To that point, one of the things you asked people in the middle was, who is the person they most admire . And 18 named democratic figures, only 13 named republican political figures. And within those numbers, there was only one republican leader current leader who got more than one percent and that was Chris Christie. That shows you how hard it is when you are out of the white house and dont have a leader that everyone looks to and all of a sudden you have competing voices. If the republicans today held the white house, you would not be hearing as much about ted cruz as youre hearing today. Theres a big vacuum and it allows people to fill that. I think that leadership, the next time the republicans win the white house, 2016 or 2020, it will be easier to say, heres what were for and heres what were against. Thats one of the reasons why theres so much Democratic Unity than republican unity. Mark, i dont want to make you nervous pointing out one small error in the piece on tv, but you had the category as mini van moderate. You were missing one, liberation front groups like toure. I dont know the numbers but he exists. I think hes perfect in the bleeding heart category. I took the he esquire, im bleeding heart but that means i care. Mark murray, you will always be in the center of our heart. Thank you. A test of leadership, the president is meeting with democrats as we speak, what can all involved learn from president grant ulysses . Take a look at these negotiating skills. Youre playing lets make a deal. Door number one me getting in front of the press corps and telling them you or chess traited a coverup, becausal i wanted to do is tell the truth. Behind door number two, me giving you what you want and telling the press corps im sorry to sleep with janine lock. Sir, i told you, theres no way we can make them do anything. Its a simple choice, door number one, i tell the truth and both of us get kicked out of the white house. Number two, i admit to the geneva fair and jake gets released. How president ial are my balls now [ male announcer ] if youre a rinse user, you may have heard theres a new rinse that talks about protecting, even after eating and drinking. Crest prohealth has always done that. Its clinically proven to fight plaque and gingivitis. Rinsing with prohealth after brushing can take your oral health to a new level. Now thats the new you need. Right from the beginning i could really feel it changing something for the better. I know theres been an improvement. My pearly whites, they feel really good. [ male announcer ] go pro. With the brand you can trust, crest prohealth. [ male announcer ] go pro. With the brand you can trust, if youve got it, you know how hard it can be to breathe and man, you know how that feels. Copd includes emphysema and chronic bronchitis. Spiriva is a oncedaily inhaled copd maintenance treatment that helps open my obstructed airways for a full 24 hours. You know, spiriva helps me breathe easier. Spiriva handihaler tiotropium bromide inhalation powder does not replace fastacting inhalers for sudden symptoms. Tell your doctor if you have kidney problems, glaucoma, trouble urinating, or an enlarged prostate. These may worsen with spiriva. Discuss all medicines you take, even eye drops. Stop taking spiriva and seek immediate medical help if your breathing suddenly worsens, your throat or tongue swells, you get hives, vision changes or eye pain, or problems passing urine. Other side effects include dry mouth and constipation. Nothing can reverse copd. Spiriva helps me breathe better. Does breathing with copd weigh you down . Dont wait to ask your doctor about spiriva. First day of my life by bright eyes youre not just looking for a house. Youre looking for a place for your life to happen. Earlier today, matt had a crazy idea, and a crazy idea can either make you kind of famous or kind of fired. His bosses told him to pack up his things and go. To an office. With a door. See, matt works at esurance, where crazy ideas make Car Insurance faster, friendlier, and fit for life in the modern world, which isnt all that crazy when you think about it. Esurance. Insurance for the modern world. Now backed by allstate. Click or call. Why would i take one pepcid® when i could take tums® throughout the day when my heartburn comes back . cause you only have to take one. [ male announcer ] dont be like the burns. Just one pepcid® complete works fast and lasts. New video just in on top House Democrats inside the oval office where they are discussing the shutdown and debt ceiling with president obama. Less than half the nation in the recent survey says the president has been a strong leader on this. Obama has 42 predecessors who he can look to for negotiation role models, Ulysses S Grant maybe a good place to start. Long before he had a starring role on the 50 bill and before two terms as president , grant polished his negotiation skills by managing the end of the civil war as president lincoln and general in chief. We think shutdown passions are intense. Here to put it in historical context, author of ulysses s. Grant, michael is also the former editor and chief of simon and shuster and joins us at the table. Lets start with that. Any lessons that we should take from ulysses s. Grant skill as a negotiator for todays crisis . I think so. Ulysses s. Grant pursued the path directly, he never veered from it. When he was a child he was remarkable because he would never retrace his steps. So if he was going in one direction, he would never back up. He would always go forward. And as a negotiator, he was very much the same kind of personality. In a very polite but firm way he stuck to what he believed. We could probably use him today. It would be nice if we more applicatio politicians like that. You talk about the action on the battle field helped and crippled him in the white house. You would think they would help each other, if youre a good commander in field, you would be a good commander in chief. I dont think thats necessarily true. Battlefield success is not necessary a guarantee for true success as a president. Actually i think grant is a better president than hes given credit for. He kept us out of two wars that everybody was keen to fight, both with great britain, because he believed very firmly, like most experienced generals that peace is better and wore is terrible. But above all, grants underlying personality was to patiently move forward day by day towards the goal that you want to achieve. He was an enormously interesting man. I dont know what he would have made of todays financial crisis because he was terrible with money himself. Mark twain said when it came to financial matters he was as naive as a baby. How much do you think he was defined by his age . Because we hear about president s only be able to excel within the context of their time and contrast that to the gridlock today. We probably think of him as old because the portrait of him on the 50 bill. He was quite a young man when he entered the white house and one of the few to have done two terms successfully. I think grants energy was phenomenal at war, not so great in the white house. Michael, interesting insights, thank you for your time. Thank you for having me. Up next, one of the most critical people in the criminal Justice System has been furloughed and youve never heard of him likely. Ari explains next. Before they sat down, one more time, just for themselves. Before the last grandchild. Before the first grandchild. Smile. Before katie, debbie, kevin and brad. There was a connection that started it all and made the future the wonderful thing it turned out to be. At bank of america, we know were not the center of your life, but well do our best to help you connect to what is. It guides you to a number that will change it guides you to a number your life your sleep number setting. It even knows you by name. Now its easier than ever to experience deep, restful sleep with the sleep number beds dualair technology. At the touch of a button, the sleep number bed adjusts to each persons ideal comfort and support. And youll only find it at a sleep number store. Where right now our newest innovations are available with 36month financing. Sleep number. Comfort individualized. Medicare open enrollment. Of year again. Time to compare plans and costs. You dont have to make changes. But it never hurts to see if you can find better coverage, save money, or both. And check out the preventive benefits you get after the health care law. Open enrollment ends december 7th. So nows the time. Visit medicare. Gov or call 1800medicare [ unr ass [ female announcer ] e people like to pretend a flood could never happen to them. And that their Homeowners Insurance protects them. [ thunder crashes ] it doesnt. Stop pretending. Only Flood Insurance covers floods. Visit floodsmart. Gov pretend to learn your risk. Life with Crohns Disease ois a daily game of what ifs. What if my abdominal pain and cramps end our night before it even starts . What if i eat the wrong thing . What if . What if i suddenly have to go . What if . But what if the most important question is the one youre not asking . What if the underlying cause of your symptoms is damaging inflammation . For help getting the answers you need, talk to your doctor and visit crohnsandcolitisadvocates. Com to connect with a patient advocate from abbvie for onetoone support and education. The new cycle begins with an accused terrorist on u. S. Soil, anas al libi is back in new york facing arraignment for the u. S. Bombings in kenya and tanzania. Hes back on dry land and apparently suffering from a terrible case of hepatitis c and needed medical attention. At least 200 people were killed in the embassy attacks. A poignant ceremony at the white house for the newest medal of honor recipient, army captain william swenson. Five americans were killed in the fight where swenson risked his life to recover the fallen and save others from death. Will swenson was there for his brothers. He was there for their families. As a nation we thank god that patriots like him are there for us all. The u. S. Supreme court is hearing arguments today in a case whether michigans voters have the right the outcome could impact similar antiaffirmative action bans passed by arizona and washington state. That news from the high courts leads to the special series presumed guilty as the Government Shutdown continues, one of the most pivotal officials is on furlough, the pardon this president is the most micingly partner of any modern president. The numbers back that up, barack obama has the lowest clem entcy rate in modern history. Bill clinton had pardoned one in every eight applicants and george w. Bush, 1 in every 33 and president obama just one in every 50. Why does the pardon power matter . The constitution empowers the president to decide when the interest of justice are served by overturning a conviction or shortening an unfair prison sentence. Beyond individual mistakes in the courtroom, one of the most compelling reasons to use the pardon power is to release americans serving prison terms for activities that the law would punish differently today. A prime example, the shifting approach to the war on drugs. The Justice Department is no longer seeking harsh penalties for some nonviolent drug users. It has yet to apply the same logic to inmates serving time right now for those same offenses. The other end, the executive himself has discretion under the pardon power and i think theres a correlating imperative to use it at both ends. Mark osler at Saint Thomas University in minnesota. We have people serving time, over 5,000 people serving time under harsh crack laws that have now been undone by congress. Back with us to explore the moral question michael xol scolnik and president of global grime. Com. Thank you for being here. You supported the president and reelection, what do you make of the moral character on this issue . Weve been big supporters of the president but the president is still on the gate on this issue. In the first term of his administration he has been focused as we see here on much bigger pieces of policy. I think he let this one go. I think weve seen a major shift in the president , not just his talk but action in the last six months. We wrote a letter urging him not just ending the war on drugs but first the pardoning. Not just for more pardons but the 5,000 people still locked up under the crack powder disparties. Were talking about the war on drugs and what we do with nonviolent drug offenders. But they have moved to war on drug reform. How do we get to substantive reform for millions of individuals locked up for nonviolent crimes . I think toure, the one thing to remember, the pardoning office, we cant fix 35 years of horrible drug policy. What it can do, it to those ind have served far too long sentences and no threat to society. If we are to break this war on drugs, to me, the domino that must fall is mandatory minimum sentencing. And certainly the attorney general has hinted that he wants to end this, and folks in the senate, senator durbin and rand, have shown they want to end this, as well. That is the piece of the tool that the Law Enforcement and that the courts have used to pack the prisons, is by threatening these young men with these horrible sentences, and they plea out. 93 of drug offenses in this country plea out. And now we have 2. 2 million folks in prison. Republicans like mike lee and rand paul are on the right side of this issue. Interesting. A big fear, though, you let someone out and then they go and they commit a heinous crime. You have the backlash of i told you so. What did you expect . And obviously, here were talking about nonviolent drug offenders. And, you know, the idea that you let 5,000 people go, the odds are that at least one of them will commit a crime. So talk to us about how this this plays into this conversation. I think, actually possibly obamas greater fear than that is the politicalization of the pardoning office in the past. I think if you look at whats happened with mark rich, scooter libby, even richard nixon. I think this administration has shown their white house is not for sale. And theyre afraid that if they are to not just let out someone who might have committed another crime, but let someone out for a political reason or because of privilege. Most people who get out who are pardoned or get commuteded are white. Michael, you mentioned that issue of being pardoned and the disparity. Youre almost four times more likely to get pardoned historically as a white inmate than as an africanamerican inmate. Incredible disparity. On top of that, you mentioned the louis libby pardon. And the New York Times was reporting this weekend about how in the limo ride to the inauguration, bush was advising obama, youve got to fix this, youve got to get a good program up and yet the president has held on to the same pardon attorney. He hasnt even put in his own person to take a different stand. Ronald rodgers was appointed by bush at the end of the bushs term. I believe he should be replaced. I think thats part of the issue. What is becoming before the president s desk, what is he seeing, how many applications is he seeing for pardons. We have to not just address this one issue of pardons, but the war on drugs has to be a central part of the president s second term. Part of the problem, prison itself makes people be better criminals. So we have to stop sending so many people to prison. Right. I think thats also where it hits on the recidivism. A good concern. But you have to figure out how to harm onnize this so youre not locking away people forever. Were out of time. For my republican friends, a lot of republican friends support this across the country. Some rand paul is leading this movement. So this a bipartisan issue and we can get this done. Michael skolnick, thank you. Action on the issue will require a lot more public engagement, including republicans. So come to our facebook page, whatever your party, to learn more and you can post comments, well answer questions. You can also engage on twitter at the hash tag, presumed guilty. Up next, krystal has an inspiring pep talk for john boehner. Well, sort. [ male announcer ] this is pam. Her busy saturday begins with back pain, when. Hey pam, you should take advil. Why . You can take four advil for all day relief. So i should give up my two aleve for more pills with advil . Youre joking right . For my back pain, i want my aleve. Youre joking right . I have obligations. Cute tobligations, but obligations. G. I need to rethink the core of my portfolio. What i really need is sleep. Introducing the ishares core, Building Blocks for the heart of your portfolio. Find out why 9 out of 10 large professional investors choose ishares for their etfs. Ishares by blackrock. Call 1800ishares for a prospectus which includes investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. Read and consider it carefully before investing. Risk includes possible loss of principal. Hey, john boehner. How is your day going . Not so great . Oh, really. Mine isnt going so great either. Now that i think of it, a lot of people across the country arent having the best week like government workerers not getting paid, retirees terrified their Social Security checks arent going out next week, the mom who dont have formula for their babies. But i get it, this is a tough final for you. John, ive heard this line before about ted cruz and justin and the Tea Party Caucus and how your hands are tied. Its time to take personal responsibility. After all, you use the tea partiers to win the speakership. You enabled them, gave them power, told them their cause was just, noble, patriotic. What did you expect . Theyre behaving in exactly the renegade and destructive way they promised voters they would. You cant be surprised they were promised a pound of flesh and now they have come for it. Really, thats all water under the bridge, john. Lets deal with the present. You could have passed a clean, continuing resolution at sequester levels, a major win for republicans, but you didnt want to upset the tea partiers. They wanted their government shut down and so you gave it to them. Thank you that, john. Thinking i suppose that maybe once they saw the gop numbers tank and felt the wrath of constituents, they would come to their senses and you could write in, saving both your caucus and the country from the tea partiers you enabled. Did you think that would work . You were dealing with zealots, kamikazes in a sign that the hour of their political martyrdom is close at hand. They want the confrontation. They want to go out in a blaze of glory. Andner never going to love you, john. So now the president and the senate have agreed on a deal. Its not a great deal for the country. But at least averts the current crisis. And once again, it all comes down to you. You, john, not the tea party, not ted cruz, you. Just like it always has. You wanted power and boy, do you have it. You could end this crisis today. Just as you could have ended it from the beginning, just as you could have averted it before it even started. Some say that youre terrified of losing your speakership. After all, you only won the gavel this time by six votes. Well, you nooet need to think long and hard about what youre doing to the country in order to keep your grip on a gavel that has brought you attention, sure, but it seems like a lot more misery, let alone what its doing to the country. This is your moment, john. It is time to decide who you want to be when you grow up. Will you choose to be a great man . You have that chance. Or will you choose to be the pawn of the tea party destroying the country that you love so deeply, it makes you weep. You wanted the power, you won the power, now figure out what you want to do with it. And remember, theres no crying in politics, right . Aww. All right. That does it for the cycle. Martin bashir, its all yours. Thank you so much. Its tuesday, october the 15th. And as america stands on the brink of default, will the house gop push the Global Economy into fullblown meltdown . Hit it. If we dont start making some real progress, we stand a good chance of defaulting. Our leaders met with our members today trying to find a way forward in a bipartisan way. Bipartisan way. I dont know who hes talking to. There are a lot of opinions about what direction to go. What you saw here was a speaker who did not have the votes. Speaker boehner decides to light a match and throw it on the gasoline. There have been no decisions about what exactly we will do. Extremist republicans are attempting to torpedo bipartisan progress. Its been very clear what we as republicans have wanted. Why are they wasting the publics time . We are cognizant of the calendar. The house Tea Party Caucus. After we talked to ted cruz