Controversies, a surging pandemic. Over 7,000 people will be at this event. No social distancing, masks are optional. There are protest sites by native american groups. They have their views, their free speech on this american holiday heading into the weekend about what it means and what they think of this president. Meanwhile, the nation struggling with of course what we have been living through for months, the reckoning, the legacy of slavery, our history, jim crow, and the symbols that accompany all of that. There has been news on that just today. But donald trump choosing to speak in front of a monument that will dig into a racial cultural war. Well obviously keep an eye on that. We have the right guests to fact check of it. We wont be showing all of it, but we have guests to give you content for the excerpts we will hear tonight. This will be the first fireworks display at the site in over a decade because of serious concerns over wild fires. Reverend al sharpton, dr. Patel and many more. As you can see, we mean it when we say live special coverage. And we begin with two very special experts. First tramaine lee, most of the into the america podcast and we will be joined by cal perry who has been keeping an eye on this all day. The context that you see tonight . Think about this is perhaps one of the most donald trump things to do. We saw him go from tulsa, oklahoma, the scene of one of the most bloody massacres in history. Here we are in the native american tribe. This flouting of not only the health and safety, you think about the ongoing pandemic. But were in the midst of, as you described, a reckoning, where one side wants to grapple with who we are, right, and strive to be our better selves. And there is side that harkens back to where native americans were slaughtered. While were having this conversation about confederate monuments and what it means acid sevens to walk in the shadow of that reminder of that ugly american past, here we are at Mount Rushmore, two of the four president s, two en slavers. Lets not forget about the fugitive slave act. Lets not forget about how he shifted his enslaved people around to make sure they were never free. So the backdrop is tremendous. Coming off the death of george floyd and the protests and the reconciling of who we actually are, here we are in this moment. It will be interesting to see exactly the tone and how donald trump positions this moment. You lay out so many things for us to chew on. I should mention tremendous main lee will be staying with us throughout the hour. Cal perry is on the ground there, and you have been reporting throughout the day on this. Im curious what you are seeing in your journalism on the ground and given you are there, your thoughts about the way we are encouraged to think aboutre we n reflect on pat tre patriotism a positivity or the other aspect about what kind of country do we want to be. Cal, take it away on all the above. Yeah. And this is the summer in which america is doing exactly that. So the question is is the Trump Administration ignorance of all of these things or are they choosing to be ignorant of it and make all these stops across the country. When you look at the black hills, the history is a dark one. But it is an important one because it is instructive of where we are as a country. The u. S. Government promised this land to the people. It was a way of ending years and years of conflict. And less than a decade later, people were starved and raped and pushed out of this land. In 1980, the Supreme Court said that was wrong. The Supreme Court was wrong in doing that. This should be native land. Unfortunately, it hasnt panned out that way. The people who live here, this is their heritage. This is their history. Today there was an incredibly ugly scene just about a mile up the road where i am where police were arresting protesters in a completely peaceful manner. But you had Donald Trumps supporters yelling and mocking these protesters in sometimes racial ways, and you had this lack of understanding on both sides, both sides, both with the native american protesters and trump supporters. For people here, that is a serious thing. Add to that the every day concerns about coronavirus. The community here on reservations that is not able and doesnt have the equipment and have the tools to handle the virus because there is no running water. There is no access to health care. There is no access to hospitals. And, so, you have these reservations closing themselves off to the rest of the state. You have the governor of the state saying the reservations cannot do that when legally they absolutely can. So you have this clash of cultures happening in 2020. All the while, the president continues to make these stops. First in tulsa right around juneteenth on purpose, upsetting that city. People felt like they had to go out during the pandemic to change the narrative. And then today, the name narration playing out where the president is going to come and speak at a place where people here view as a flagrant violation of their rights. As a president who is celebrating their down fall. They view the timing as very purposeful, and they will view this speech as purposeful as well. I think we will hear the president talk about American History and about holding up the icons in American History. And to his narrow audience, i think that speech will make sense. To everybody who lives in this area of the country, i think they will be a little lost. You know, when you think about the intent here and you go across the country and there is some folks who may, quite frankly, be ignorant of the history. Lets not forget the ideals of White Supremacy, the shadow in history to lionize certain individuals. But there are other folks that this moment is not lost on them the very least bit, right . It is very intentional. So we call it a dog whistle or it is a whistle whistle that everyone can clearly here. Were in the midst of this progress. My concern has always been what happens when the pendulum swings back . When great progress and Great Strides are made, we see that pendulum swing back. Four months away from the election and we know for a fact how donald trump will hunker down. His supporters will hunker down. The scarey part in this moment, what does that hunkering down actually look like . What will we hear not just in tone and rhetoric but as emotions flair. These grand pronouncements of equality signals like the fall of something, right . The loss of something. With the blackening of america, but also the recentering of the narrative of who we actually are and who we actually see ourselves as. Lets think about that in the context of part of the thread moving away from donald trump. The ways that he kicked off, for example, the charlottesville statue fight. Whatever the ethics were of that, which we could speak to and you have reported on. You have won awards on your reporting of these kinds of issues, the statistical facts was that was far more divided at the time than where we meet tonight going into this holiday, where states like mississippi, which remain maga red in their voting pattern are taking down the confederate symbols, where Corporate America is adjusting. People may say late, overdue, but the socalled redskins, a profitable franchise, being pulled down and rebranded. Im curious what you think about the environment. If he does, as his advisers have previewed tonight, try to kick off another fight about these symbols, whether he is at a practical level on weaker ground than he was just two years ago in public opinion. Well, certainly. When you think about those early fights, as long as it was a Smaller Group or just black folks or black folks and a group of allies, folks had the cover of, well, it is history. People are being drawn from the sidelines. So the environment most certainly is different. Think about what we have seen in certain weeks in terms of the makeup of the crowd, cross racial, Cross Cultural where white folks are getting a taste of police violence. Were seeing young white kids and older whites being beaten with batons. There was a peaceful protest and they were literally playing violins, and here come the troopers coming in, right . So now i think the ground has shifted in terms of the actual outcry. Also, the corporate culture. Corporations have some cover now. Now they can say black lives matter without fear of any kind of repercussions. I think the tone has shifted. The silent now maybe not so silent majority of folks who are hunkering down and bracing for the white, lets not forget, some of the white supremacist violence was always edging towards a race war. Im not saying thats where we are now, but the tone of america is in this great contention of who we are in this reckoning. I dont know. But public opinion, think about those that support black lives matter. You mentioned two years ago. Think about in the wake of Michael Browns killing. Where now, you know, im not sure if it is a majority yet, but its shifted dramatically in terms of folks that actually support this idea of equality and pushing america to be more equal. Yeah. All really important context as we head into the holiday. I think this is on americas minds and with people who are spending times with their family or distancing, these are the conversations to have and to do it forthrightly. Im thrilled to tell viewers, tremendous main lee, who has lead so much of our coverage on this and cal perry are with us for the hour. You have set up a lot of the conversation, and we appreciate that. We turn now to other experts as promised. The reverend al sharpton, the host of politics nation here. He has worked on these issues, including advocates for families of police brutality. And the dr. Partel, also an msnc contribut contributor. Good evening to both of you. Good evening. Doctor, im going to start with you because we talked about some of the big issues, and ill come back to that with rev. But we also have the reporting. You look at that crowd. What do you see medically . Number one, ari, it just makes me cringe. There was a part of me hoping that this would not be as packed as it was. There was just some wish i had that i would see people spacing themselves out in those seats. But this is to the point absolutely against every single one of the president s science and Health Advisers own recommendations for the entire country. It is classified by its own nature. Those pictures, that appearance is a highest risk event. And im looking at the crowd, and im pretty sure there are probably people that are high risk themselves because of age or chronic conditions, obesity. It feels like this speaks of someone who has the makings or consciousness of an authoritarian regime where he is consciously leading his own people against their health and wellbeing. Right. And i can only honestly, i can only hope that people have some sense to avoid the crowd based on these pictures and move away. Thats all i can say scientifically and ethically as a doctor. Appreciate that. And viewers can see as were reporting these live events and the doctor is living us the analysis, the president and the first lady have stepped out neither in a mask. They are going through what look to be the warmups that we see here in many of these patriotic events and saluting. Well keep an eye on that. Were not going to go to the speech when it begins. We will monitor it. We will also give context and Fact Checking as we endeavor to do. What is your on your mind given what tramaine lee and others have spoke about, the work i emphasized you have been doing for so long as we have a president that has pledged to use tonights speech to dig in and double down on a history and culture war he wants to have. I think its clear that this president wants to draw a line in the sand because hes taking a day that we will all acknowledge and say, no, im going to even put it in your face. Im going to land that native americans it was owed. It was theirs. Im going to celebrate president s, some who advocated slavery and some who owned slaves themselves and im going to do it at the risk of the health of those supporting me. So im drawing a line in the sand. This will be a cultural war election, and im on the side of White Supremacy. Im on the side of holding up the statues and relics of those that represent the dehumanization of people of color, particularly black people. And either you are on my side or the other side. I dont think you could have a more graphic example. He in his mind is saying im holding up the greatness of america and those of us with an increasing amount of americans, some folks saying majority is saying, no, those are the disgraceful days that we need to eliminate out of the continuing american story. And i think that it is a line in the sand that many of us on the other side are going to resist. And, rev, if you could build on that point, in our business, in the media and political sphere as probably as well as life in general, things can be taken for granted or normalized. Whatever you think of the Police Executive order that the president released, and we have heard from many experts that walked through it, i think you and i would certainly agree that a year ago donald trump was not planning on kicking off the general election july 4th by being dragged to say or do anything about alleged police brutality. That he now pivots through this speech away from what he may have been pushed or dragged to do. Whether people think it was genuine or for optics or not, which is try to respond in some way to the protests. Im curious what you think about that. You have been around this man, you know, in new york for a long time. I think clearly the protests, i think the movements that many of us have been engaged in, not only for decades but just a few weeks ago. I mean, the rallies that i have spoken at. I did the eulogy at two of floyds funerals. I dont think that any of that can be in any way dismissed from the fact that the president had to respond because the nation responded. Let us not forget, ari that had there not been this massive response by the american public, he would not have done anything. He did it because he began seeing mainstream america respond. Mainstream america that had been sheltered down that couldnt have the distractions of watching sports, no basketball, no football and all that was saying, wait a minute, this is really happening. And when they responded, he tried to in many ways deal with it by distorting it, giving some really ineffective executive order but acting as if i am responding when it was no response at all. To say that were going to deal with criminal acts and thats what now these policemen have been charged with in the floyd case and the arbery case, to say im going to deal with criminal acts by giving you incentives to do better. You be nice guys, now, and ill give you a lollipop shows how out of touch he is. You are actually saying something we heard earlier here on msnbc from congressman jeffries who you know and have worked with about the fact that more americans than usual were forced in this particular environment that you just illuminated to face it. When actually faced with it, we found more people ended up supporting black lives matter and saying, gosh, maybe i ignored that. Theyre telling pollstersthis some of this has got to change. How do you rootize that . I have a lighter point. I realize i earlier credited ali for all of his hard work as the james brown of the news, hardest working man. But now i realize i should have gotten your clearance and blessing for that reference first as james brown former manager. Well, i was James Brown Like a surrogate son that i had to do different roles. But i could say as one who was mentored by james brown, im properly the james brown of activism that i will cosign you giving ali the james brown of news because he is a hard working man. Id just tell him, make sure he has somebody to throw the cape on him at the end of the night. Hey, i love that. Im happy. Im relieved to get your cosign. When james would do it, it always meant, when it looks like im gone, im really just recharging. Ill be right back. Amen. You were close to him. I got to see him when he was performing in his late 60s, early 70s and he looked like he was 40. The energy was incredible. Reverend, on a night of history, reverend al sharpton has been a part of many different aspects of history. Dr. Patel, were happy to have you for your medical expertise. Ill keep you out of politics. Thank you both. God bless. Amen. Thank you both. We have special coverage continuing. We will be joined by, this is important, the first native american member of the u. S. Congress. Shes here tonight as part of our special coverage and others that were really excited to reflect with. Stay with us. Up at 2 00am again . Tonight, try pure zzzs all night. Unlike other sleep aids, our extended release melatonin helps you sleep longer. And longer. Zzzquil pure zzzs all night. Fall asleep. Stay asleep. Theyre going to be paying for this for a long time. They will, but with accident forgiveness allstate wont raise your rates just because of an accident, even if its your fault. Cut sonny. Was that good . Line the desert never lies. Isnt that what i said . No you were talking about allstate and insurance. I just. When i. Lets try again. Everybody back to one. Accident forgiveness from allstate. Click or call for a quote today. Accident forgiveness saturpain happens. Aleve it. Aleve is proven stronger and longer on pain than tylenol. When pain happens, aleve it. All day strong. You think it smells fine, s in your car. But your passengers smell this. Eliminate odors youve gone noseblind to for up to 30 days with the febreze car vent clip. Wow, it smells good in here. So you and your passengers can breathe happy. You say that customers maklets talk data. S. Only Xfinity Mobile lets you switch up your wireless data whenever. I accept 5g everybodys talking about it. How do i get it . Everyone gets 5g with our new data options at no extra cost. Thats good. Next item corner offices for everyone. Just have to make more corners in this building. Chad . Your wireless your rules. Only with Xfinity Mobile. Now thats simple easy awesome. Switch and save up to 400 a year on your wireless bill. Plus get 200 off a new Samsung Galaxy s20 ultra. Welcome back. Were checking several stories including the donald trump rally, which is slated to include fireworks tonight, something many different parts of the country scaled back on to discourage large gatherings, but it is especially dicey in south dakota. Fireworks responsible for 27 different wild fires around Mount Rushmore. I said you cant have fireworks because of the environment . I said, what can burn . Its stone. So nobody knew why. They just said environmental reasons. So i called up our people and within about 15 minutes, we got it approved. What a great story. Meanwhile, the park service did not announce it was looking into this for another month. It was actually three months before the fireworks were approved. Donald trump was obviously, though, looking forward to getting his fireworks. Joined now on this and a lot more, we have the White House Correspondent for pbs news hour and the new yorkers gilani cobb. We could talk fireworks or everything else, your pick. Does it really matter at this point, ari . Does anything matter . I hope so. Given where we are, i mean, its the 4th of july. The president of the United States wants fireworks at a place that may well go up in flames as a result of it. It is the perfect encapsulation of everything we have seen during his presidency. I think what were seeing is a president who is determined to fly in the face of the experts and his own health officials, environmental experts as well as people that are saying there is a myth of america that this idea that america treated people well, that they treated men and women equally, that we founded this country just by our own wits, that that is a lie and were seeing a celebration of americas independence on land stolen by native americans and being seen and overlooked by two president s. Theyre figures that own slaves and a third president , voos vrot who oversaw the desecration of native land. I know were in the middle of a pandem pandemic, but im going to show you. This is a big Political Risk on his part. The president , according to reporters who are there, the event that hes at, people are sitting shoulder to shoulder. There is no attempt of social distancing. And the vast majority of people sitting there right now are not wearing masks. Yeah. Thats something our medical experts and others have highlighted. Widening out to the history, there are always extremes. Someone could be so judgment of their own neighborhood, country, people. But they could be overly harsh when we all have room to grow and there is positives and negatives. On the flip side, much of american political propaganda over the course of our history has tried to completely erase, ignore, lie about the ugly parts of our history, that we would be better to simply address and move forward. Whats more patriotic than obviously improving ourselves . Im curious what you think about that long running prism for a big holiday with the president obviously not engaging on most of those things forthrightly. You know, ari, there is an interesting book that touches on some of this, not directly, but a historian did a book years ago called american violence, a documentary history in america. What they discovered was contrary to the perception, america was not particularly violent, not comparatively when you kind of shook everything out. And said what was atypical . What was unusual . Was that the United States had a significant level of violence while maintaining a perception of themselves as the most nonviolent people in the world. And you can exploit that out to everything else, that the fragility of the american sense of itself, this nations sense of itself has never allowed it to actually account what its history is. While it would be easy to interpret the act of holding a 4th of July Celebration on per loined land, just as you could talk about the insensitivity and the objectionable nature of holding a rally in tulsa on juneneenth, that is really facilitated by the fact that people arent even aware of just how brutal and unfair the history of this country has been. And the only way you can be truly exceptional as a country is in confronting that. Thats the road of exceptionality. We have confronted the weaknesses of human nature and said that through that we will transcend and create a community that is embracing. But you cant do that based on what were seeing right now. Well, youre inspiring me to want to get into it. Are we going to get into it here . Lets get into it. Im going to take the issues. Lets get into the fact that when we talk about stealing, donald trump stole words, plagiarism from Ronald Reagan who literally ran on make america again in the quest against civil rights. That stolen language and southern strategy goes all the way back from nixon to jim crow to the roots of this country. And, so, we are literally watching this president here approach this holiday trying to hit the same buttons that he has before where it is a direct indication of a type of nostalgia that everyone knows whats being said when you say things were way better back then. Thats why you saw so many people in this country, especially people of color look really, really disturbed when the president and then candidate trump started saying make America Great again. The question was what part of america and what period are you talking about . Is it when women couldnt vote . Is it when native American People were literally run off their land . The people i talk to, voters and experts, they all believe President Trump is sitting somewhere in history between George Wallace and Ronald Reagan and fitting in this history that is some ways a republican history about the idea theyre looking at white resentment and giving people worried about the future of america but also angry at the idea of America Browning and saying, you are the victim. This country owes you more instead of looking forward the future and saying, lets have an america where people understand the history of america. President trump wants to be on the side of the myth of america. And the myth that the pandemic is over when we know for a fact that those things are not true. Im running over on him, but i will give you the final thought. I think you are absolutely correct. And i think the final point about this is that if you really look at this, it almost has a kind of undercurrent of desperation to it. One of the things that we saw with donald trump in 2016 was that he had this standup kind of thing. He did comedy and he was playing on peoples resentments and fusing that with the populus politics. Now you look at this, and it appears like an old performer whose greatest hits just dont move the crowd the way they once did. So you are looking for bigger and bigger things to get the same sort of effect you once had. Which artist are you thinking of . I think the relevant comparison has been elvis. Right. Like the older, harder years elvis. The karate kicking elvis. I dont want to offend anyone, but sometimes you go to jimmy buffet and not every hit lands the way it did in the earlier days. But shout out to jimmy buffet. Hes also talented. Thanks to both of you. Thanks. Were in special live coverage tonight because there is a lot of news. Breaking news on a new positive covid test in Donald Trumps inner circle when were back in 30 seconds. Liberty mutual customizes your car insurance, so you only pay for what you need. I wish i could shake your hand. Granted. Only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Nbc news confirming a Senior Trump Campaign official who is the girlfriend of donald trump jr. Now tonight for the first time has tested positive for covid19. This is of course ahead of the president s event at mount rush mor. The sourcing here is according to a person familiar with the situation. The same source telling nbc News Donald Trump jr. Tested negative. They did not travel on air force one with the president today. It is a brandnew piece of news. We bring in dr. Patel. Dr. Patel, there are extra precautions taken of course around the president. But this is someone who is in the inner circle and despite the caveats i mentioned could be very close to several people who are physically close in the inner circle around the president. Your interpretation of this news. Yeah. I mean thr, this is incredibly concerning. It is not the first one. There are people in the president and Vice President s inner circle creating a National Security risk by the proximity to the president of a deadly virus. I think, by the way, the fact that she was there with donald trump jr. In advance from out of town illustrates why this entire spectacle just doesnt need to happen. Were actually bringing in the virus just like the Vice President and the president S Secret Service details did in other states. And there is no reason for it. And i do think that two days ago the president said that this virus will just go away and this is living proof that this is not going to go away. You mentioned it as literally living proof. As with every case we report, we wish everyone well on it. When you look at the exposure risk, a personal valet for the president tested positive and did the secretary or Vice President pence. It comes at a time where anyone watching the news knows this event included, the president has been doing more, getting out there more, interacting with more people. When you look at Something Like this, if you take out all of the ideology or politics or whatever you want to call it, would you as a doctor advise a person in the situation to close the circle to be less exposed or not . Yeah. Just medically speaking, ari, the fact that you have someone in your own inner circle in your family who has any positive case immediately puts you at high risk. While i understand the president of the United States may not want to completely selfisolate, its practically not feasible, you certainly would want to mitigate the risks by doing Everything Possible to ensure that you do not get infected or anyone else in your close circle get infected. The Doctors Orders in this case would absolutely be to stay at home and as much as possible practice physical distancing in order to decrease the risk and wear a mask, wash your hands and i dont see any evidence of any of those things happening. All very interesting and very clear. Dr. Patel, thank you as always. Thank you. This maga style independence rally has drawn protesters from native american leaders, some angered at the president s use of this monument that some call a desecration of land. To get a perspective on this as part of our special coverage, were joined by deb holland of new mexico. The first native American Woman serving in among. How are you . How are you . Good to see you. Im all right. Walk us through your perspective on all this. Sure. Well, first of all, yes, there is a fire risk right now because of a beetle infestation. So fireworks that have been banned in that area for ten years could easily start a fire that would not only and right now as your previous guest tensioned, there is a lot of people that are not wearing masks, not social distancing. The governor of the state made it very clear that they were not going to require people to worry about the pandemic while theyre at that event. But he could also put firefighters lives at risks. Now yes . Go on. So, yes, this is land that, you know, you see in the headlines, stolen land. I saw president bear runner on this station last night saying that he had requested President Trump to meet with him to have a conversation with him before coming to Mount Rushmore for this event. President trump has had an extremely neglectful relationship with Indian Tribes in this country since hes been in office. You remember that he had the navaho code talkers and had a port tr portrait of Andrew Jackson behind them in the office. He tried to cut coronavirus funding for tribes. He hasnt cared that we have spikes in our communities. There is some real issues that are happening in this country right now that cant be, you know, pasted over with a 4th of July Fireworks presentation. All well put. Food for thought. How do you think we, as were going through a reckoning, and we have been discussing with people are rethinking and trying to open their minds. That can be constructive. How do you think big picture americans should meditate on and learn about the native american aspect of our long ago history on holidays like this. Yes. Well, yes, 4th of july, the birth of our country, right. What better way to celebrate it than at a sacred place sacred to the indigenous cultures of that area and not to even acknowledge tribes, not live up to their wishes that they would like to have consultation before these types of things happen. Ari, im the vis chair of the Natural Resources committee and the chair of the subcommittee on National Parks forest and public lines. We get a lot of these issues in front of our committees. Not too long ago we had a hearing in our committee on the blasting of sacred burial grounds on the border of arizona and mexico with a tribe. The Trump Administration is blasting sacred burial grounds so they can build his wall on the southern border. That is outright disrespect. Here at Mount Rushmore, which is not its a sacred mountain. I posted a photograph on my twitter account today, and it showed it before the carvings of these president s faces have gone into it. It is a sacred mountain. Tribes were not at the table when the exterior boundaries to their tribes were drawn. And just because sacred sites are not included in their exterior boundaries doesnt mean that tribes cease to acknowledge them as sacred sites or care for them as sacred sites or even go to pray and hold ceremonies in these places just because it is not on their land. And i think that in this reckoning thats happening in our country right now, to say that, yes, our history is everyones history, native American History, its American History in all of us have to care about that. We have to respect it. I dont think it was too much to ask for President Trump to consult with tribes before he even thought about doing this. Hes like a bull in a china shop. He just decides to do something and nothing stands in his way. And in the process, hes going to make people sick from the coronavirus, a super spreader event. Hes going to inflict a fire danger on this fragile environment. And to top it off, folks, you know, i saw some of the video throwing smoke bombs and arresting people and that was we just went through this in Lafayette Park not too long ago. Peaceful protesters using their Constitutional Rights to make their voices heard, you know, having chemical smoke bombs thrown at them and arresting them to shut them up, i think its par for the course with this administration. All important points, and you stitched it all together. Thank you very much for giving us that perspective. Thank you. Appreciate it. Were going to fit in a break. As i told you, we have a lot of folks lined up, including some new ones which we havent heard from yet, and some new controversies on a big weekend. People used to care. Heck, theyd come all the way out here just for a blurry photo of me. Oh, thats a good one. Wait, whats that . Thats just the lowbattery warning. Oh, alright. Now its all, check out my rv, and, lets go fourwheeling. Maybe theres a little part of me that wanted to be seen. Well, progressive helps people save when they bundle their home with their outdoor vehicles. So theyve got other things to do now, bigfoot. Wait, whatd you just call me . Bigfoot . My name is daryl. We are back following our special live coverage here. Donald trump, you can see, getting ready to take the stage at this big and controversial decision to go to Mount Rushmore, south dakota and hold a packed rally. Donald trump is leading this high profile event. Hes modeling the conduct that all experts and his own task force say would make these infections worse. Hes also been reengaging a culture war in demanding fireworks that officials thought could cause an actual wild fire. In other words, this is Independence Day in the year 2020. We are joined by cal perry and tremendo tramaine lee. There are a number of people in the town behind me waiting for the fire work display. They were hoping the president would drive down the road. They are sitting down watching that fire work display. K he was here in town the last couple of days. Part of that group are some high profile republican donors, people that raised money in the west, wyoming, montana, south dakota. He was at a the last 48 hours with some very senior people. It will interesting to see the knockon effect of who has to get tested and when they get tested, ari. Tremaine . Jelani cobb talked about this event being staged on purloined land. I actually had to look that up. Its an amazing word. It means stolen. Its not just the land that had been stolen. Its the theft of history, the theft of the narrative, and places like Mount Rushmore or spots in communities all across this country where confederate monuments have been erected. It was to steal the history and steal the truth, to always reflect back on those ideas of White Supremacy and power and domination. And we see that again. So as folks are gathering at risk of their great health, we see the pandemic continuing to spread, we think about this moment of reconciliation, of who we are and who weve been and who we could possibly be. And to stage this moment, Independence Day, and you think about Frederick Douglass said what to the slave is the fourth of july, right . Its a terrible day, but also a day of deep reckoning and trying to understand the great insults of america at odds with its greatness. On its best day we know what america can be. On its worst days weve seen that play out through history. Its not just native American History. Its not just black history. This is all part and parcel of American History. As we grapple to understand it, we are most certainly, without question, at an inflection point. Trymaine lee making several important observations and like the reporter you are, quoting from several of the other experts. We want to bring in New York Times columnist michelle goldberg, msnbcs joshua johnston, and errin haines. Good evening, everyone. Hi there. Hi. Michelle goldberg, you have helped us and our viewers through many different story lines. I come to you first on something that was not true the last time i spoke with you earlier in the evening on the beat, but the news breaking that the son of the president s girlfriend has tested positive for covid. And i will repeat what i said earlier. As with any case, we wish everyone well, and yet it also does seem to undercut Donald Trumps approach, which he is living and foisting on many others, with regard to managing the risk. Your thoughts . I think that i called him just a few hours ago. I said that donald trump is a mobile covid hot spot, right . He is bringing this disease with him wherever he goes. Wherever he goes offers evidence of the recklessness of these rallies. Again and again he does these rallies against all Public Health guidance, including guidance from his own government. And again and again people who work for him pay the price. I mean people who follow him pay the price. People who related to them pay the price. The communities he holds these spectacles pay the price. Hes not even willing to take precautions to protect his own secret service agents, his own staff, and now basically somebody who is a member of his own family. One of the things that i think is happening in what, lets pray, is the last months of the Trump Presidency is the increasingly wide and kind of desperate disconnect between what the president says and the obvious reality on the ground and the reality in most americans lives. Joshua . [ inaudible ]. Can you all hear him . I cant hear him. All right. Joshua, were going to work on that. How about now . Try now. Yes, sir. There we go. Like i said, 16 years in radio. Youd thinkize kn id know to u myself. Well, as the saying goes, microphone check. Microphone check. One, two. One, two. Is this on . I have been listening to some of the events before the president began speaking just a few minutes ago. He just mentioned that these monuments, referring to Mount Rushmore, will never be desecrated. One the big themes thats already come out of this event from governor kristi noem speaking, who is the governor of south dakota, has had to do with the way that weve been engaging in these cultural conversations about the imagery that we have and about the way that we view our own history. Tremaine was just referring to this in terms of the land being purchaloined from indigenous peoples. Governor noem said, quote, this is being done to discredit americas principals so that america can be remade in a different political image. She also said, quote, to attempt to cancel the founding generation is an attempt to cancel our own freedoms. Let us not destroy history. Let us learn from it by preserving and imitating what is good about it, end quote. Thats one of the early themes of this event thats just come up in the last few minutes and the president began his remarks with that theme as well. Appreciate your reporting and it reflects what i told you we were going to do with his speech, which is keep an eye on it and report it out and also factcheck and analyze it. Its not a free cspan broadcast for this or any other politician. In that spirit, to you, joshua, and then errin, im just jotting down what you said and weve been monitoring the speech. There is a debate over socalled cancel culture. As a free speech person myself, i tend to err on the side of listening and reckoning with ideas, and if theyre bad, debating rather than canceling them. However, im curious if you would edify us a little bit on the attempt to treat the lawful amends aing and improving the founding documents as, quote, canceling because it strikes me as a misnomer. The founders themselves created the mechanism whereby we could amend the constitution. Having studied it in law school, thank goodness we did. In fact, theres an ongoing debate about improving other parts of it. Im curious how you might contrast that to socalled canceling or censorship because amending is different. Well, thats part of what i think the governor was trying to get at in her remarks. The kr she actually mentioned cancel culture. She said, to attempt to cancel the founding generation is an attempt to cancel our own freedoms, unquote. Thats part of the debate. How do we view america now in the context of 2020, covid19, George Floyds homicide, in terms of the country that we want to become . The issue of what we do with these monuments and with our legal structure is really not just the question of the day. Its the question of the nation. Thats what weve always been. We declared independence from a government which did not allow us to amend our own laws and did not even allow us to have agency over them. Thats one of the long list of usurpations that the founders mention way up at the top of the declaration of independence that caused them to start a revolution, to throw off their old government. The issue, i think, is in what we define as that more Perfect Union that we refer to in the preamble of the constitution. This argument now is over what we do with the values of the founders, with the legacy as opposed to with their flaws and with their foibles. I mean right. Teddy roosevelt is one of the four people on Mount Rushmore. He was one of the great conservationists of the let me bring in errin, who writes for the 19th. Picking up the theme of amending, the 19th amendment didnt cancel mens right to vote. It amended so women would have the right to vote. Take it away. Youre absolutely right about that, ari. But i would have to point out that it did certainly cancel the right for all women to participate in the franchise during you know, at the passage of the 19th amendment, which we are supposed to be celebrating in the midst of, you know, this pandemic. So, you know, what i would say is cancel culture a couple of things on cancel culture. One, theres a difference between cancel culture and telling the truth, right . Im based here in philadelphia, you know, home of the constitution, cradle of our democracy as seen by many americans. And yet, you know, we know that this is a country that was founded on protests, right . That was founded on dissent. And we are in the midst of, i think, this National Reckoning that is really asking who gets to dissent . Who gets to be part of protests . And really the fundamental question that were asking there is who gets to be american . And i think the other part of this is there are some parts of our culture that have been canceled. Like we dont celebrate slavery. We dont question, you know, the motives of the start of the civil war as a country although, you know, this president has certainly done that. You know, we are not honoring, you know, confederates. You see every single day brick by brick the walls of racism seem to be coming down in this country and the momentum of progress really seems to be sustained by a pandemic that has really laid bare a lot of the truth about america that make us want to cancel some of the myths we have been telling about ourselves as a country. So, you know, i think, you know, the pushback against cancel culture, i think, is a resistance to want to tell the full truth about america, and you have the president now here at another culturally relevant site in our country, saying that he is there to do truthtelling. And while theres been a lot of truthtelling by a lot of people on the show tonight, i dont know how much truthtelling were going to hear at this fourth of July Celebration here in south dakota. Fair and an important conversation here. I want to remind viewers we have tremaine and cal perry, who have been basically quarterbacking a lot of coverage. We have our expert panel here, which well continue to factcheck. We are as promised going to dip into the speech and add context and reporting. Lets listen to a little bit of the president s big address tonight. [ applause ] true. Thats very true actually. That is why i am deploying federal Law Enforcement to protect our monuments, arrest the