Transcripts For MSNBCW MTP Daily 20170502

Kardashians. Can you name all five of the girls and maybe put them in order . Are you kidding me . This is mtp daily and it starts now. Welcome to mtp daily the white house backed Health Care Bill is teetering on the brink of collapse again. The house backed government bill is facing resistance from inside the republican party, making matters worse, President Trump is seemingly all over the map on both issues. Now he is advocating to shut down the government to change the rules so his party can consolidate power. Heres how the day began. President trump slammed the deal, the reason for the plan negotiated between the republicans and democrats is we need 60 votes in the senate which are not there. We elect more republican senators in 2o 18 or change the rules now to 51 . Our country needs a good shut down in september to fix mess. The white house doubled down on the president s statements. The senate is requiring 60 votes on every appropriations bill that is forcing this discussion about continuing resolutions that are a bad way to run the government and shutdowns are not productive. Its not a goal and a associating tool. But to the extend the president vocated for one. Thats one that fixes the town. All of this stems from a funding deal that the president criticized and then touted as a massive victory for him. This bill is a clear win for the American People. We brought lawmakers together from both sides of the aisle to deliver a budget that funds the rebuilding of the United States military makes historic investments in Border Security and provides health care for our miners and School Choice for our disadvantaged children. This is what winning looks like. Are there is a noticeable decide on the deal. I feel very good about the wins we got with the administration in the bill. I dont know if im going to vote for the bill they will present to the senate. Why . The democrats cleaned our clock. There are things that i just dont understand. This was not winning from the Republican Point of view. To make matters worse, they threaten to derail the second attempt at a Health Care Deal in the house. 21 House Republicans have stated their opposition to it. At least 18 are undecided. If just two of them oppose the deal, it is dead. The president s position on this is all over the map. Yesterday he seemed to tell Bloomberg News it wasnt ready for prime time. He wanted it to be good for sick people. It is not in the final form right now. The comments came as President Trump was phoning hold outs to get them on board. Today the white house dispatched mike pence to twist arms. The president s conflicting stances are likely not making life easier for gop leadership, but Speaker Paul Ryan insisted that President Trump is not hindering the effort. The president has been nothing but helpful. He is helping for a lot of the members. We are making Good Progress and the president has been instrumental in that. Joe man chin from West Virginia joins us. You are from trump country. If this Health Care Plan does in fact make it through the house, is it something that you will be able to support in the senate . No, i cant. I have been very honest with everybody. You talk about repeal, 172,000 West Virginians who got health care for the first time are working people. They are working in a situation where they dont have health care provided. They got it this time. Thats something you will take away from them. That doesnt work. If we can get everyone to say we can repair that. There is not a democrat i know of that doesnt think it can be improve and repaired. If you repeal it, cant start it over. Thats not going to work. It doesnt work. Describe a bill that you could support. If you sit down and work with it, 20 Million People got health care for the first time and never paid for it. They didnt get one word of instructions about how they should use responsibilities they have. There is a tremendous amount of efficiency and savings. In the priflt markvate market, joe, im working and doing fairly well. I have to buy my own insurance and pay a 7 or 8 or 10,000 a year and a 5,000 deductible. Its the same as having no experience that they are paying 15,000 out of pocket before they get assistance. Thats the market we can. We have to work on that and we cant get an honest discussion because the repeal part about it is setting down as a pathway foard. I can get 10 or 12 democrats to sit down with my republican friends. If we can look on repairing it before you throw it out . After all, this repeal discussion and debate is taking place in the house. You are in the senate and why not sit down with the colleagues and craft your own version. Im trying. We have been trying and have spoken back and forth. Can you say im going to try to fix this before we throw it out. I dont know if thats a political promise and they are all weighted to that. I dont know. He said i dont think i can get anybody to go along with with. If you can get me republican senators who say lets work through this how we move on the private market and how we move on the risk and how we get Preventive Care and how we are able to keep the things we agree on because there is no guarantee any of that can be kept. There is no guarantee. Whats the hold up . Why wont they talk about it . You have to ask them. I dont know. If you have been chanting repeal, repeal and getting elected because you said you would do away with obamacare, i said this to President Trump. We spoke about a month or two ago. I said mr. President , in West Virginia there is i lot of people that got helped by this legislation in the Affordable Care act. They dont know how they got it and they dont know that the democrats or president obama might be the reason they got it. They have no idea, but they will know who took it away. I will assure you they will know that. Before you go down that way of repealing everything, lets sit down. You are supposed to be the mr. Fix it president. Lets fix it and repair it. That can be done. Lets talk about government funding. There is a deal in place. The white house is trying to spin it in their favor by saying its a down payment and forhe border wall and a bigin for republicans. There is no money specifically going towards the border wall in this bill. If it does come to the senate and you are presented with that deal for a vote, is that something that you will support . The bottom line is that we have a piece of legislation which our immigration bill was bipartisan. Democrats and republicans working and voting together to secure our borders. They need to be secured. And we had an awful lot of attention and money put towards that. And a pathway forward. Get rid of the people that committed crimes and came for the wrong reason or came here and committed a crime. They should be sent out. We kbrea on that. Basically you cant say you are going to be making or building a wall and i said this. If thats the priorities you have, thats okay. Let mexico pay for it. I cant go home to virginia and the people that are basically just fundamental functions that are needed saying that we will spend money on and they will pay us back. Thats a hard sell. I want to ask about the russian investigation. Members of the Intelligence Committee took the bus to langley to get intelligence briefing. We checked in on the bus. You were not on that bus. First of all, did you end up going to the meeting with different transportation . I had a conflict today, but i will be getting that briefing tomorrow. Can you give us an idea of what that encompasses . That are that are poots revealing more information has been turned over to show the full committee, the brought base of this and how much there is and what different actions and what different direction or continue down the same direction we are going now. Bringing people in and building the case and trying to find out what we have before you bri in some of the top players. Some of those people. I think the Senate Intelligence is methodically going about their business the same as it should be to get the facts in place. They are not sensationalizing it and its not a show horse. They are trying to get the work done that they can lay out a pathway for. The president questioned whether russia was behind the medaling and said it could have been china. Is there any doubt that russia was behind this . No doubt in my mind. Everything we have been able to see and you reported that we can talk about that russia definitely was involved. Russia was involved more intensely this past election cycle than ever before. We see no evidence that any of the votes were changed or the out come would have been different. With that being said, we are seeing him involved in paris and germany and could they have done more harm to us and are they waiting to do harm at a later date, we cant let that happen. Appreciate your time. Thanks for having me. Amid the debate, the Health Care Debate went viral after this emotional monologue from jimmy kimmel about his newborn son battling heart problems. Before 2014, if you were born with Heart Disease like my son was, there was a good chance you could never get Health Insurance because you had a preexisting condition. If your baby is going to die and doesnt have to, it shouldnt matter how much money you make. Thats something whether you are a republican or democrat or something else, we all agree on that, right . We do. Im joined by Republican Congressman jim jordan of ohio who is a member of the House Freedom caucus. What is your reaction to that monologue . We do all agree on that and the legislation makes sure we have a safety net provision called a high risk pool and allocate 125 billion to make sure they can take care of the situation that mr. Kimmel was describing with his young son. We all agree that should be the case, but we also want to bring down premiums for middle class families. What the waiver option does is allow those states to get rid of the regulations that are driving up the cost for middle class families. The cost that the senator was talking about. 7,000 they are paying for a deductible in a years time. They cant afford the deductible and they want that to come down as well as protect the situation that they were talking about. The senator will not support the bill as it is now if it makes it to the senate. We should note that. On the high risk pools notion and on preexisting conditions, there is a lot of serious concern that your bill waters down protections for preexisting conditions and it comes from a lot of different places. Your conservative colleagues are saying this. This is coming from representative bill long of missouri. The American Medical Association said its worried as well. Saying although the amendment states the ban remains intact, this assurance may be illouisry as underwriting could make coverage unaffordable to people with preexisting conditions. The Kaiser Foundation said the same thing. How can you say you are right and they are wrong. Read the bill. They said that specific line. Preexisting conditions are covered. We have 125 billion in the bill to help with this situation. We set up high risk pools and the safety net provisions. You cant be kicked off and changed at a higher rate when a serious illness happenso you or your family. Whats in the bill is the yet that we have on repeal obamacare. Thats what we ran on and what the election was about. We have to get at the key regulations that are driving up the cost for everybody in the insurance market. Driving up for working class families. We are trying to do both of these. It is not full repeal. This is not what we were elected to do, but its a step in the right direction when it gets to the senate and we will do more to make sure it gets to full repeal. I think the numbers show 17 of voters say they are confident in your plan . What we left with the voters said we would repeal obamacare. We had three big elections where this was a central issue. I think thats what we have to do. This bill doesnt get there. We are giving states the waiver option. Its a huge step in the right direction. Can you guarantee their health care will not be more expensive, period . For ohio is the state that gets the waiver, i believe that Health Care Policy experts believe premiums will come down. Thats why we need the waiver. I would like to do it here, but we dont have the votes for that. We are trying to get the votes that give this waiver option. The white house said you have the votes, but we show you are two votes short of losing this bill. Are you confident you will get the two votes . There are a lot of undecideds out there. With the Freedom Caucus, we brought 20 something new votes to the yes column. We are working with our colleagues to encourage them to support it. Its a good step in the right direction. Did they help or hurt the cause and the Health Care Plan was not in the final form and it has to be good for sick people. I think the president is stating the facts that we like you and i he said it was not in the final form. Is it being negotiated . Not in the house. There is some negotiation, but maybe until it winds up on his desk. You concerned they are taking this bill so far to the right it will be completely unwinnable for the senate. Is it going to make it much more moderate. Why not do do it before it gets to the senate . We told the American People. Is it just about fulfilling a promise or making Health Care Better . Its about doing what we said. We are supposed to do what we said. Never forget what obamacare brought us. All the misinformation. Like your doctor, keep your doctors. Premiums will decline and website is going to work. Website is secure. The coops will be wonderful. All the false information. Thats the context we are in. We very to get rid of this. This doesnt fully do that. Its a step in the right direction. Does it concern you that the majority of americans want to keep obamacare . What are concerns me is what the voters elected us to do in 2010, 2014, and 2016 where this was a central issue of the campaign. Certainly the foters in the Fourth District know where i stand and thats what i am trying to accomplish. Thank you for joining me. Thank you. President trumps conversations today with another authoritarian leader. Keep it here. Still be pain. It comes when your Insurance Company says theyll only pay threequarters of what it takes to replace it. What are you supposed to do . Drive threequarters of a car . Now if you had Liberty Mutual new car replacement™, youd get your whole car back. I guess they dont want you driving around on three wheels. Smart. With Liberty Mutual new car replacement™, well replace the full value of your car. Liberty stands with you™. Liberty mutual insurance. Wheres jack . Hes on holiday. What do you need . I need the temperature for pipe five. Ask the new guy. The new guy . Jack trained him. Jacks guidance would be to maintain the temperature at negative 160 degrees celsius. That doesnt sound like jack. Actually, jack would say, hey mate, just cool it to minus 160 and were set. Good on ya. Oh yeah. Thats jack. To have been a fly on the wall in the white house this afternoon. They called the conversation a very good and said the topics included syria to north korea to mideast terrorism. According to the white house. They talked about setting up a meeting in germany in july though nothing has been solidified. This was President Trumps first conversation since the u. S. Launched cruise missiles by the syrian period on his own people. That caused a rift with moscow that supports assad and just last month, Rex Tillerson described the relationship between the two countries at a low point. No word if they discussed the multiple investigations in russias multiple attempts to interfere with the election. Well be right back. When it comes to heartburn. Trust the brand doctors trust. Nexium 24hr is the 1 choice of doctors and pharmacists for their own frequent heartburn. For all day and all night protection. Banish the burn. With nexium 24hr. Start your day with the number one choice of dentists. Philips sonicare removes significantly more plaque versus oralb 7000. Experience this amazing feel of clean. Innovation and you. Philips sonicare. Save now when you buy philips sonicare. Ozzy, react to congressman jordan. They want to get rid of the regulations and that will drive down cost. What he did not discuss was the fact that some of those regulations he wanted to get rid of would require essential Health Benefits like a cancer patient getting health care, but not having chemotherapy be part of the that coverage. Whats the point . The other part is he includes a guarantee that the people get charged the statement amount. If you get rid of those two p provisions, you might have health care being more experience. They will not remember who gave them insurance, but who took it away. Is this about passing something and not necessarily passing something that the people want or that will be good for the country . I think at this point its looking like political theater because even in this makes it through the house and thats a huge if. I dont think they will get the votes to pass the bill. It has to make it through the senate. The senator said it would not make it through the senate in the current form. There has to be a compromise. I asked about that. If its going to get more moderate in the senate, why not do it now . Thats a good question. The problem is they have seen that you cant get the Freedom Caucus votes you need. The problem with this bill from the beginning is they dont have enough policy experts giving them provisions that will help people. This is all about politics and saying we ran on repealing obamacare. They have the big l with the first version of trump care and they are trying to save face. Its more about ego. And a really important point is President Trumps point in all of this. He doesnt know what the policy is that he is supposed to be pushing. That wasritica to the failure in round one. The same applies in round two when we dont know what is going on. Do you think the president was misleading people or did he not know what was in the bill . I think he doesnt know what he is putting out there . Which is worse . Katie, these questions. Im sorry. Good thing you want a new president. If the house doesnt pass it and they cant get it through, is the repealing and replacing dead . For now. They didnt go about it the right way. It took a long time to pass obamacare. You have to make the case to the American People and get enough approval to get the senators and the house folks on board so they didnt feel like they were taking a risky vote. They havent done any of the ground work. It doesnt mean trump will stop talking about it. This could fail and he will see Chuck Schumer did this and obamacare this. Of course. The democrats are doing a victory lap over it saying they got a lot of what they wanted and Lindsay Graham agrees with it and the president agrees and disagrees. He said the system needs to be reformed and 60 and also this was wonderful and i got everything i wanted and its a down payment on the wall. Mixed messaging. Does that work now that he is president. I think it works with the core supporters. Maybe 40 of people who are not going to move and are sticking by President Trump. They have invested so much in him that they do want to see him succeed. Its a tenuous question of bringing in other supporters. You look at is this the blueprint and the New York Times had a great story on how this came together. It wasnt because of the white house. Democrats and republicans had bypassed the white house. This deal, is it going to look a lot different come september 30th . You saw trumps tweets and he is reacting to the fact that the democrats are responsible here and we worked with republicans across the aisle to come to a consensus and President Trump wants to be the center of attention and wants to seem like he is the grand negotiator that is coming to the table and getting everyone to come to the table and come to a deal and he was not part of this. If he feels some kind of way. Is the government shut down good . For trump, yes. He needs drama and attention. Its good . For trumps purposes and talking points. He needs too identify an opponent whether its congress or democrats or media. Congress is a great opponent for him because more of the country dislikes congress as a unified body. If he attacks them and makes Congress Look incompetent, thats not good for him. Congress is run by republicans differently than when obama was period. Republicans are in charge. They have to make it happen. How is it good if the Republican Congress cant get the republican agenda done. It shows they are dysfunctional. Place is bad. How do you say im the deal maker and im the best and i can do something nobody has and i could stop the civil war from happening if you cant get a deal done. Hes like a parent in a car getting arrest and the only way to get to the next exit is to speed up. If there is a good spending deal that doesnt include him, he will call it bad. Get attention and speed up to the next exit and say i got us someplace better even if its off the map. It feels like im in a speeding car. Without a atbelt. You should always wear a seatbelt. Stay with us. We will come back to you later. Democrats doing House Flipping in 2018. Is there a path to victory for them. We will look at the best shots to gain ground, ahead. David. Whats going on . Oh hey thats it . Yeah. Everybody two seconds dear sebastian, after careful consideration of your application, it is with great pleasure that we offer our congratulations on your acceptance. Through the Tuition Assistance program, every day mcdonalds helps more people go to college. Its part of our commitment to being americas best first job. Theres nothing more than my vacation. Me so when i need to book a hotel room, i want someone that makes it easy to find what i want. Booking. Com gets it. They offer free cancellation if my plans change. Visit booking. Com. Booking. Yeah. If you have moderate to severe Rheumatoid Arthritis like me, and youre talking to your rheumatologist about a medication. This is humira. This is humira helping to relieve my pain. And protect my joints from further damage. Humira has been clinically studied for over 18 years. Humira works by targeting and helping to. Block a specific source. Of inflammation that contributes to ra symptoms. Its proven to help relieve pain and. Stop further joint damage in many adults. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. Serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened, as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Before treatment, get tested for tb. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas. Where certain fungal infections are common and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Talk to your doctor and visit humira. Com this is humira at work. Lets[ whimpers ] dog. Find pingpong. Okay, lets go. Find your awesome with the xfinity x1 voice remote. Thats amazing it is my mission to provide the customers the highest level of service. Reliability and also a deeper sense of respect and trust and dignity. That was United Airlines Ceo Oscar Munoz in front of the house transportation committee. He is along with scott kishy and executives testified at an oversight hearing to look at Customer Service with airlines. It comes in the wake of incidents including the violent removal of a customer from a united flight last month. They told the executives that congress will not hesitate to act if meaningful results are not enacted to improve the flying experience for passengers. Up next, will republican retirements win back the house in 2018 . Heres Hampton Pearson with market wrap. Stocks closing slightly higher with apple leading to another record close and finishing up by 36 points and the s p gaining two and nasdaq closing higher. Cash reserve swelling to 256. 84 billion. Shares falling however 1 after earnings beat expectations, but fell short on revenue as the company sold fewer iphone. Automakers posting weak sales. Ford gave up 4. 4 . Investors watching for comments on the economic slow down as the fed wraps up the twoday policy meeting tomorrow. Thats it from cnbc first in business worldwide. I realize that ah, that 100k is not exactly a fortune. Well, a 103 yeah, 103. Well, let me ask you guys. How long did it take you two to save that . A long time. Then its a fortune. Well, im sure you talk to people all the time who think 100k is just pocket change. Right now were just talking to you. I told you we had a fortune. Yes, you did. Getting closer to your investment goals starts with a conversation. Schedule a complimentary goal Planning Session today. Start your day with the number one choice of dentists. Philips sonicare removes significantly more plaque versus oralb 7000. Experience this amazing feel of clean. Innovation and you. Philips sonicare. Save now when you buy philips sonicare. Welcome back. We have a saying you might have heard. If its tuesday, someone is voting somewhere. That is south carolina. Republican and democratic primers to fill the seat when mull vaina director. Its likely the republicans will hold on to the seat in this deep red district, but can democrats win back the seats . They lost house in the 50 midterm every time except 2002. Democrats are trying to take back the house in several special elections, but could get the biggest boost by republicans or republican retirements in democratic leaning districts. They got a major opportunity to pick up a seat when florida Republican Congresswoman announced she will not be seeking another term. In 2016, she defended her democratic challenger by 10 points while Hillary Clinton won by almost 20 points. The political report is categorizing that district as lean democratic. Joining me now is the house editor. David, how big of i deal is it for retirement to open up 103 days into the new administration. If democrats can pick one republican, it would have been ross. They are moving towards the Democratic Party at a blistering piece and its in miami. You have younger cubans and upscale whites. All of whom are moving away from the National Republican brand. Heres a dramatic shift and the question is whether its the start of something or whether we will see more republicans in marginal districts or whether its a one off. Do you think it could be because there are a lot of moderate republicans that are worried about potential challengers and wont stand up to them . When democrats lost the house, we saw the start of the wave with democratic retirements in republicanleaning seats. A lot of blue dogs retiring and that was the beginning of an exodus of conservative democrats that left open a lot of seats. To really build a wave where democrats mht be able to take back control of the house,hey have a favorable environment. The Democratic Base is fired up. Republicans are having trouble building accomplish ams to sell to their own base. They need two things. The first is retirements of republicans like ross and if democrats can gets en similar members to retire, that would be good news for them. And the election is a year away, democrats will have more candidates than they know what to do with. What are the chances that they will be able to retake the house . They thi have 23 republicans in districts that voted for Hillary Clinton. They need to reach into trump country. I would put the odds somewhere between 40 and 50 because in these kinds of situations when you have a president that is this unpopular and Republican Base that is this demoralized, but not only that, a lot of trump voters dont hold the republicans in high hard. Will they show up in 2018 even if they showed up in 2016. Thats a question that is making a lot of republicans nervous. What are you keeping an eye on . We are looking at upscale districts that trump only won by narrow margins or lost narrowly. Republicans who ordinarily have races in illinois and these are all going to be targets in november. Talk about georgia. We have j o sof and that vote is coming up in june. They are neck and neck. 30 million was the last tally in terms of ad spending down there. What are o sofs chances some. A lot of democrats would wish they had his money, but democrats are not going to be able to fund every candidate to this extent. He has a very good chance in the run off. Its a tie ball game for the june 20th run off. Im not going to put too much stock on the out come if its close. What we know is if this race is close in a district that went republican for house by over 20 points in 2016, even if it went narrowly for trump, we know the house will be in play. If trumps Approval Rating persists in the low 40s, that is typically the kind of place that spells trouble where you have alarm bells for the control of the house in a midterm. Never too early to watch out for an election year. Appreciate your time. Elizabeth warren discusses the path forward and how would Hillary Clinton handle kim jung un . After the break. Stay with me, mr. Parker. When a critical patient is far from the hospital, the hospital must come to the patient. Stay with me, mr. Parker. The at t network is helping First Responders connect with medical teams in near real time. Stay with me, mr. Parker. Saving time when it matters most. Stay with me, mrs. Parker. Thats the power of and. Theres nothing more than my vacation. Me so when i need to book a hotel room, i want someone that makes it easy to find what i want. Booking. Com gets it. They offer free cancellation if my plans change. Visit booking. Com. Booking. Yeah. Itthe power of nexium 24hr protection from frequent heartburn. All day, and all night. Now packed into a pill so small, we call it mini. New clearminis from nexium 24hr. See heartburn differently. Hillary clinton made comments about losing the 2016 president ial elections. Speaking in new york city, the former secretary of state didnt shy away from commenting on President Trumps Foreign Policy decisions. She said she supported the strike on syrian air fields last month, she slammed the president s dealings with north kor korea. Negotiations are critical, but they have to be part of a broader strategy and not thrown out in a tweet some morning saying lets getting to sp see if we cant get along and maybe we can come up with some sort of a deal. That doesnt work. [ applause ] more on what Hillary Clinton said about the election after the break. What if technology gave us the power to turn this enemy into an al microsoft and its partners are using smart traps to capture mosquitoes and sequence their dna to fight disease. There are over 100 million pieces of dna in every sample. With the microsoft cloud, fast. If we can detect new viruses before they spread, we may someday prevent outbreaks before they begin. Usaa gives me the and the security just like the marines did. The process through usaa is so effortless, that you feel like youre a part of the family. I love that i can pass the membership to my children. Were the williams family, and were usaa members for life. Ii need my blood osugar to stay iin control. I need to cut my a1c. Weekends are my time. I need an insulin that fits my schedule. Tresiba® ready announcer tresiba® is used to control high blood sugar in adults with diabetes. Dont use tresiba® to treat diabetic ketoacidosis, during episodes of low blood sugar, or if you are allergic to any of its ingredients. Dont share needles or insulin pens. Dont reuse needles. The most common side effect is low blood sugar, which may cause dizziness, sweating, confusion, and headache. Check your blood sugar. Low blood sugar can be serious and may be lifethreatening. Injection site reactions may occur. Tell your prescriber about all medicines you take and all your medical conditions. Taking tzds with insulins like tresiba® may cause serious side effects like heart failure. Your insulin dose shouldnt be changed without asking your prescriber. Get medical help right away if you have trouble breathing, fast heartbeat, extreme drowsiness, swelling of your face, tongue, or throat, dizziness, or confusion. Ask your Health Care Provider if youre tresiba® ready. Covered by most insurance and medicare plans. Tresiba® ready i was on the way to winning until a combination of jim comeys letter on october 28th and russian wikileaks raised doubts in the minds of people who were inclined to vote for me, but got scared off. That was Hillary Clinton today prey much acknowledging that she thinks 2016 election s taken away from her. That brings us to this. I have mixed feelings whether or not the comey letter was what ultimately did her in. I saw the enthusiasm from the Trump Supporters. Its fair to argue she took a polling. I dont know. She didnt go to michigan. She didnt go to wisconsin. I think he outcampaigned her in so many states. He did so many more visits than she did. Is it fair to say that the comey letter was ultimately what sunk her . Yes. You can look at the data. If you are being looking at the trajectory of the polling before the comey letter, there is a drop off and it came out in the middle of early vote voting. If you are trying to exercise your strategy and get to the polls and that letter comes out and they were alluding to the possible indictment and she going to be in jail. That of course is going to have an impact. I would say she is right to target misogyny as a reason why she lost the election, but i want to say that the russian hack was a big factor. In terms of the timing of the release of the emails. It wasnt just the hack itself. Its the fact that right after the comes out the next day is the first batch of podesta emails. The first day of the dnc, another batch of podesta emails. The last month before the election, podesta emails, 2000 of them, came out every single Maria Sharapo morning. Do you maybe go back and campaign differently . None of it mattered, that they wouldnt go to michigan more, they wouldnt go to wisconsin . Im not saying that. Im saying there were certain calculations made based on internal polling which turned out to be incorrect. If youee intnal polling that says youre up in michigan and youre making that call where to allocate resources youll go to a state where its closer, like north carolina, pennsylvania. I think people want do overs, but i dont think we can say its all on her personal failings or its all this one reason. We have to remember she won 3 million more votes. A lot of the analysis is going to be a little bit off. I want to get to ozzie. I think i want to do it with the ladies. Please. Do you think misogyny played a role in Hillary Clintons loss . Absolutely. I went to Battle Ground states prior to the election and it really was shocking to me that in this day and age so much blame was put on Hillary Clinton for being a strong woman who had clear ideas about what she wanted and also how much blame she continues to get from voters because of bill clintons transgressions. She is blamed for the Affairs Trump tried to paint her as an enabler. His supporters totally bought into that. Its incredibly sad in 2016 that still was an issue and women are still seen as the cause of a strained husband when bill clinton was the one who originally wronged her. And i will say this. We saw unmentionable tshirts at the rallies. Not only prison gear, hillary sucks. Just these things that were incredibly out there. Yes. That being said, trump had a lot of momentum. He had a lot of enthusiasm. He was derailed during the access Hollywood Tape certainly. Right. This gave him new life. Are you convinced that Hillary Clinton would have won had there not be the reemergence of the comey letter . She had a much better chance before the comey letter came out. Obviously then afterwards. With respect to whether or not misogyny played a role and what role, the fact that it even gets asked, the fact shes the first candidate, the fact she was there on the National Stage for a quarter of a century. Right. This is the first person and we have to sit around ask wonder about it. The fact there were not more than one female candidate vying for this. You really get to wonder, you know, the fact that we all celebrate the first person that sort of crosses the line. And whats sad is that that first person has to be celebrated, that there is not more of a challenge of five or six people who are competing in this kind of arena, that people dont say, look, we have a catholic thats running. Look, we have a mormon thats running. The idea you have to celebrate and wave the flag, a National Moment weve never had Something Like this before, Hillary Clintons campaign is going to lead to many more women stepping forward and running for Higher Office who didnt think they could. Now, the fact that some of her supporters, like you said, were saying, bill clinton did something and she was a part of it, is head scratching. Donald Trump Supporters believe him irrespective of everything else. Hassan said it correctly at the white house correspondents dinner, they trust him more than they trust t truth. I dont think i disagree with that. She also talked about russian interference and i want to play a byte from that. Lets take a listen. Well, he certainly [ laughter ] interfered in our election. And it was clear he interfered to hurt me and help my opponent. If you chart my opponent and his campaigns statements, they quite coordinated with the goals that that leader who shall remain nameless had. So, when shes saying he shes talking about Vladimir Putin and claiming that the Trump Campaign did coordinate. Thats kind of a big deal. I think there is some evidence to show that thats true. In terms of the timing of the email releases, it wasnt it wasnt just that theyre hacking and its like were going to dump all the emails. They released the bernie emails. Where were the Martin Omalley emails . There was some benefit to trump. I dont think it was to elicit, it was discord ant. Last word . I really dont think there is some farreaching plot. I doubt that the Trump Campaign was that capable of anything that complicated. But we need an investigation to find out and just figure out what happened. Ozzie, they drowned you out. It was worth it. It was about misogyny. Even this. Thank you guys very much. After the break, chuck todd on politics and pop culture. Stay tuned. [ dog whimpers ] man lets go man 2 were not coming out man 1 [ sighs ] flo [ amplified ] i got this. Guys, i know being a firsttime homeowner is scary, but you dont have to do this. Man 2 what if a tree falls on our garage . Woman what if a tornado rips off our roof . Flo youre covered. And youve bundled your home and auto insurance, so youre saving a ton. Come on. You dont want to start your new life in a dirty old truck. Man 3 hey. Man 1 whoa, whoa. Flo sorry. Woman oh. Flo youre safe. Youre safe now. Woman i think im gonna pass out. Can you stop using the bullhorn . Flo i dont make the rules. Start your day with the number one choice of dentists. Philips sonicare removes significantly more plaque versus oralb 7000. Experience this amazing feel of clean. Innovation and you. Philips sonicare. Save now when you buy philips sonicare. Philips sonicare. Take on the mainstream. Introducing nissans new midnight edition. In case you missed it, chuck has gone hollywood, or at least access hollywood. Take a look. You grilled the president. The answer is always trump. Its time for us to grill you. Lets start with the kardashians. Can you name all five of the girls, and maybe put them in order, Kardashian Jenner . Are you kidding me . It begins with a k. Thats all i got. Let me get kim out of the way. Yes. Thats pretty much as far as he got. Turns out chuck does not know his kardashian trivia. Can you really blame him . He was a little more in his element last night when the k word was korea. Look, on north korea, its not as if what bush and obama did worked. Right. So, and, you know, if somehow in five years he somehow can we get to a point where north korea is letting people in and inspecting the nukes, well, all right, it was a different strategy, but it might have worked. Right. Or Thermo Nuclear war. One or the other. Always end on a laugh. [ laughter ] we will take that safe advice and end on a laugh as well. Chuck will be back in the mtp daily anchor chair tomorrow where i think we can safely predict there will not be any kardashian questions. Thats all for tonight. For the record with greta starts right now. I hear there is a government shut down thats being threatened, greta. There is, katey, but im not sure id cut ought the kardashian questions tomorrow night. There is a chance, there is a chance. Thank you, kate yes. Thank you, greta. Tonight washington turned upside down. Does trump want a government shut down or not . The president saying things on fire when he took to twitter and tweeted about the Government Spending bill. Quote, the reason for the plan negotiated between the republicans and democrats is we need 60 votes in the senate which are not there. We either elect more republican senators in 2018 or change the rules, allowing 51 . Our country