Transcripts For MSNBCW MTP Daily 20170308

Right now. Good evening. Im chuck todd here in new york city. And welcome to mtp daily. Folks the Republican Health care plan already has an identity crisis because the Republican Party still has an identity crisis, at least when it comes to ideology. The health care fight is exposed the growing divide between the partys Old Fashioned Movement Conservative base and its new nationalist president. Right now the white house and gop leaders are aggressively trying to unite those two warring factions and in fact in just a few minutes at the white house, President Trump is scheduled to meet with conservative groups who are bashing the current plan to repeal and replace obamacare. Some on the right are slamming as trumpcare, others are slamming it as ryancare. No matter what theyre calling it, others call it obamacarelite. They dont like it. It seems as if the Republican Party isnt quite sure what the bill is supposed to do. Why . Because the party isnt quite sure what its supposed to be in this new era of trumpism. Their political goal is clear, keep the promise to repeal and replace. The policy goal, unclear. Is the goal to cover more people in the mold of a nationalist or to lower cost in the mold of a conservative . There are some Health Care Experts who say this plan wont do either. Or, is the goal merely to keep mr. Trumps Campaign Promise to do something . That seems to be House Speaker paul ryans argument today. Heres the problem, right now the conservative opposition to this Health Care Plan appears to be hardening. The bill is written is not going to pass the senate. This is smoke and mirrors when we suggest that were going to dupe the American People. This is just obamacare with a different label. Is this proposal dead . Yes. Its dead on arrival. This is not what conservatives want. Appears to be the largest Welfare Program ever proposed by republicans in the history of our country. And if you recall brooks began that answer by telling me he was undecided on the bill. When House Speaker paul ryan held his press conference today, he was insistent that republicans will get on board, but his argument didnt seem to be rooted in policy, instead his message boiled down to one word, promises. I have no doubt well pass this because were going to keep our promises. Every house republican, every i think every republican in congress, including the president of the United States, made a promise to the American People. And the promise we made to the American People is were going to repeal and replace obamacare. Because we made that promise, i am confident were going to make good on that promise. There you go. Heres the other big question right now amid the conservative backlash, who owns this bill . When House Speaker paul ryan met behind closed doors with his caucus today, his message was clear, according to to the source who spoke to nbc news, the message was this, this is the president s plan. But yesterday at the white house, President Trump was clear, this is the house plan. According to to the associated press, Vice President pence just said, the house proposal can be improved. And there is disagreement inside the white house about how willing they are to stamp this as certified trump when it comes to this plan. How does the white house and you feel about the label trumpcare . Oh, ill let others provide a description for it. I prefer to call it patientcare. Trumpcare if you want to, but i didnt hear President Trump say to any of us, hey, i want my name on that. Heres the big problem. The party doesnt have the luxury of time to figure this out. Theyve created urgency on the issue of health care. So its either now or never. Im joined by John Barrasso of wyoming. Who is a member of the Republican Leadership on the senate side. Serves as the Republican Policy Committee chair. Also a medical doctor, senator barrasso, see, i had a lot of introductory titles for you there, so my apologies. Thanks, chuck. Good to be with you. Senator, i know you are you came out yesterday supportive of this plan. You are well aware of where many conservatives whom you share a lot of views with many of these conservative senators, but not on this issue. What do you say to rand paul who says, this plan is dead on arrival in the United States senate . Rand has a lot of good ideas. All of these members have a lot of good ideas that were considering and working through and chuck, i will tell you, the reason theres a sense of urgency is obamacare is collapsing. In my home state of wyoming, theyre basically down to one choice for buying insurance under the exchange, and it continues to go up over 25 last year, the year before, the huge double digit increases with huge copays and by next year, theres going to be places all around the country where nobody is selling on the exchange. Obamacare is collapsing, we need to do something. Thats the sense of the urgency. Well, some would argue, senator, that its a chicken and egg thing, if you believe its collapsing, its because many insurers hear that you guys are going to repeal and replace it. So lets set that chicken and egg you guys have made it, you have to do this first. Youve made is statutorily that you have to deal with this first. So i guess walk me through how youre going to get these factions together at this point. Especially since i think you have to do this without a single democratic vote. Well, first of all, this was collapsing way before the president ial election. So either whether Hillary Clinton or donald trump was elected president , we would be having to do this right now, no matter who won the president ial election because Insurance Companies had sold out, young people were not buying, and half of the people that were thought to have been ready to sign up by last year, only half of them actually did sign up. So this has been an ongoing problem with obamacare. So we believe we have a responsibility, and i have a commitment to try to provide Affordable Health care for the American People, and thats what this is aimed at doing. I think this is a monumental shift away from obamacare. Its a significant improvement over obamacare, is it perfect . No. Are they going to have debate, discussion, amendments . Absolutely. You know, one of the critiques on the right has been this is an obamacarelite. And the argument is this, senator, i understand theres many parts of it that change, but that the architecture is essentially very similar to obamacare because frankly, if youre going to have this mix of a Public Private partnership, its going to be structured, at least, you know, from 30,000 feet, somewhat like this. Do you accept that one might say critiques, others might say a compliment, that z this is a form of obamacarelite . This is lights out on obamacare. The opportunity to actually reform, update, modernize, medicaid, and entitlement program, that is dysfunctional, but has been what basically obamacare man all about because over half of the additional people covered under obamacare got that way by being on medicaid. This is our opportunity the first time in 50 years to do fundamental entitlement reform, and i want to embrace that opportunity and get the job done. Is the goal of this bill, is what . Is the primary goal to lower costs, is the primary goal more coverage . Its affordability, so that more people can actually get coverage. Many people have been priced out of the market under obamacare, even with the subsidies, people werent signing up because they felt it was a bad deal. So many people that had obamacare coverage, the copay was so high, they said, i have coverage, but i cant go and actually see a doctor. It was coverage without care. The networks were so narrow. So my goal is to provide access to affordable insurance so they can have affordable care, and that that way you want more people to be able to have it. You say access to it, but it may come with less dollars to buy it. Well, if you actually are successful in lowering the cost of care, no one would need as many dollars to buy it. Senator, thats a promise that seemed to be a reach when president obama made it, and frankly when has any prediction that somehow the cost of health care is going to go down, based on some intervention by the government, when has that prediction ever come true . Thats why im trying to get the decisions chuck, out of washington and to the states. Get this out of government control and into patient control. Make let people at home make the decisions thats best for them, and part of that is letting them buy what works for them and they can afford. You know, under obamacare, people have had to fwhie socalled essential Health Benefits chafs huge basket of insurance for many people. And certainly i hear about it every weekend in wyoming, i heard about it at a health fair in buffalo, wyoming, this past weekend, they said look, it was insurance, i didnt want it, couldnt afford, didnt need, it was too much, it wasnt right for me. The president said i had to buy it, but, it wasnt right for me and my family. And we to want have people have that choice. Let me close with this, the bill in a you pass through the senate, are you going to be able to promise the American People that it means you can get more insurance for a lower cost . Well, you could get insurance thats better for you at a lower cost. Thats the goal, but weve got to see what comes out of the house, comes to the senate, get passed the senate and put on President Trumps desk. But i am committed to longterm solutions for affordable care. Thats what i want to work on as a doctor, as well as a senator. Senator John Barrasso, member of the leadership and the senate side. From wyoming, always a pleasure, sir, thanks for coming on. Thanks chuck. Let me bring in tonights panel. Katie tur, of course has been covering the trump now white house and campaign throughout the last couple of years, and joel benson was a senior strategist to Hillary Clintons president ial campaign and now an analysis. Welcome all. Charlie, this is your party. And so, we looked at this health care that it feels as if its exposing the identity crisis look, both parties have identity crisis, ones in charge, its the republicans, and this is exposing it. Yeah, you didnt know better, youd think that after eight years in opposition, they dont have a governing philosophy that being in charge is harder than being in opposition. But yeah, you are seeing that. And i think youre going see this push pull come, you can call this ryancare, call this trumpcare, and i would suggest keep your eye on all of that because were in early days now. A lot of what the senator had toe say 12 true about obamacare. The problem is its unclear, does the republican plan, does the trump ryan plan, will it fix it or make it better . Nobodys knows whats in the plans. Theyre going to be trying to ram it through in three weeks. At a time when people are going looking over their shoulder and going, okay, this is real stuff. This is real life. This is, you know there are real winners and losers in all of this. This is going to be a real test of political clout and whether theres any principle left in the Republican Party. Joel, let me go get on the partisan side before i bring katie in which is, i go back to, i hear the promises that the republicans are making about health care. And im sorry, i heard the same promises from the Obama Administration. You know, theres this belief and i have to say, there were a lot of cynics going really, you think youre going to cover more people and bring the cost of health care down and all of this. Yes, i saw, oh you bend the cost curve over time and wed hear all that. And now i hear reasonables now in leadership trying to twist themselves into a pretzel, making the same claims. That are probably not true. Look, wung thing we do know obamacare did, it reduced the number of uninsured by millions of people, 11 to 12 million more people got coverage under obamacare. Bending criticism, mostly medicaid. Okay. But then lets take medicaid, you can see the difficulty that senator barrasso has. Giving states block grants in medicaid doesnt expand health care coverage. What it does, it expands emergency room use in all of these states which are going to drive up the costs even more. No one would sit here, i certainly wont, and say obamacare did everything it needed to do in six years on bending the cost curve, we didnt. The cost is still too high. This was a bill, it was difficult to pass, took 14 months. I love when i hear republicans say it was jammed down peoples throats and now have committees voting and heres what you know about the weakness of this plan is. They want people to voten to before the cbo scores this on how much itll cost and how many people will lose coverage. Katie, i want to get at a topic that you know well which is trumps level of patience for all of this. And this is patience, not the patients thats the doctor, but other patience. First i want to play a montage of all the promises that candidate trump made about health care. Universal health care. I am going to take care of everybody. I dont care if it costs me votes or not. Everybodys going to be taken care of. Much more than now. Heres where im different. I dont want people dying on the streets. I they all the time. If somebody is sick and really sick and they dont housing and they dont have becant let them die. All americans will get health care. Were going to take care of them. We have take care of them. Katie, he is not where the house conservatives are philosophically. That is clear. The question is when does that when does that clash . When does that clash . That is unclear. If you watched the White House Briefing today, sean spicer said this, we shouldnt be talking about how many people are covered, we should be talking about the quality of the coverage that is being offered, which seems to say, were going to realize that lose in a numbers game. Were going lose in a numbers game. Were not going to cover as many people. And the talk about not letting people die on the streets and he was certainly more on the i guess you could say liberal end of the spectrum when he was talking about health care on that regard on the campaign trail, with their taking away certain a. Coverage and if youre theres no mandate for requiring you to pay in if youre not going to get health care, but if you suddenly need health care, the money that youre going to need to pay if there is some sort of lapse is astronomical which will be completely prohibited. People will end up going to those emergency rooms, they will end up not being able to afford those bills, and that will end up being put on the backs of everybody else. And what does he do when the cbo score does come and showing what 10 to 15 Million People are going to Lose Health Care . The white house discredits it. Yes. That would be which is what they did today. Also, this is something that you have to watch, and this is why i would suggest keeping a close eye on the conservative media, with the breitbarts and the drudges to the extend to which they try to separate trump to give him an escape hatch. He is clearly not id logically committed to this plan because hes not id logically committed to anything. Breitbart has been referring to it has it as ryancare. Thats a tell. That is very much a tell. But interesting here, joel, at some point, i feel as if i could picture joe manchin and rob and portman and cher record brown going to him and saying with dont block grant medicaid. My states that voted for you are not going to like that. And i think that can have an effect on trump. The question is, is when does that moment happen . Well, and i dont know if that moment ever happens. I think theyre hearing that loudly and clearly from a lot of folks who are in medicaid states where they expanded it and its helped coverage. But i think its going to be difficult for trump to separate himself from this at some point, only because hes the president of the United States. Theres this guy named Harry Trueman who had a sign on his desk that says the bus stops here. Didnt president obama try to blame there was a moment they were like oh its congress is holding this up. The congress Health Care Plan, no, no, no, buddy, it ends up on the president s desk. Im going to disagree. We havent seen a circumstance where he has been blamed for something that did not work, among his supporters. And among those who want to see him succeed. He also campaigned on congress not being able to do anything. So if hes having a bill, katie, he has to take ownership and put something out there. He said in all of those clips, were going to cover everybody but he if he wins, he owns it. Shoots this down and i havent seen political gravity apply to donald trump yet and i will be surprised the day it does. She makes a fair point. Approval rating sink well after first term President Campaign were certainly high then. I understand, but now youre comparing him to previous president s. I understand. Health care is different. Its personal. There are winners and losers. It affects peoples lives. Its not like a debate about the border tax or about infrastructure which is intellectual. This goes right to the heart of his constituents. And youre right, we havent seen it yet. What happens when you have people in rural ohio begin to realize, okay, this is my health care. This is the uncertainty and theres a reason why everybodys been destroyed when they touch health care. And i have to tell you, im going to stop it here, wait until phase two and phase three, youre like, i heard that from the obamacare world. Once you dhang, its yours. Charlie, you are here for the hour. Its no secret the russians were thrilled to see donald trump elected. They wanted him to win afterall. But what does Vladimir Putin now want . Ill ask russian chess grand master when become back. My business was built with passion. But i keep it growing by making every dollar count. Thats why i have the spark cash card from capital one. With it, i earn unlimited 2 cash back on all of my purchasing. And that unlimited 2 cash back from spark means thousands of dollars each year going back into my business. Which adds fuel to my bottom line. Whats in your wallet . Deartheres no other way to say this. Its over. Ive found a permanent escape from monotony. Together, we are perfectly balanced. Our senses awake. Our hearts racing as one. I know this is sudden, but they say. If you love something set it free. See you around, giulia well, yeah. If youre one youre looking live at what we expected to be a Bipartisan Group of senators making a coordinated foush condemn rooub for meddling in the election, but its been going for about an hour or so. And weve only so far heard from democrats. No republicans yet. Russia attacked the United States of america. And our free election system. Thats not something to any dispute today. They attacked america. They interfered with our internal affairs. They tried to influence our election. Just yesterday, house intel chair devin nunes announced the first public hearing will be march 20th. Theyve invited james comey to testify. Comey told a Cyber Security conference at Boston College today, quote, youre stuck with me, unquote, pointing out he has another six and a half years on the job. That first public house intel hearing by the way will happen the same day as the first confirmation hearing for President Trumps nominee to be the u. S. Supreme Court Justice to replace antonin scalia, neil gorsuch. I wonder if that timing was coordinated. Its worth considering whether it is an attempt to bury the russia stoiry a little bit. What Vladimir Putins end game may be. One of the most outspoken critics when we come back. In july of 98. I did active duty 11 years. And two in the reserves. Our 18 year old was in an accident. When i call usaa it was that voice asking me, is your daughter ok . Thats where i felt relief. It actually helped to know that somebody else cared and wanted make sure that i was okay. That was really great. Were the rivera family, and we will be with usaa for life. Usaa. We know what it means to serve. Call today to talk about your insurance needs. Bp engineered a fleet of 32 brand new ships with advanced technology, so we can make sure oil and gas get where they need to go safely. Because safety is never being satisfied. And always working to be better. Welcome back to mtp daily. Before the break, the cloud of russia continues to hang over President Trumps first month and a half in office. Though in russia, his election was mostly met with fanfare, at least in kremlinrun media. Recent lay it honeymoon appears to be coming to an end. Whether or not Vladimir Putin could turn on President Trump and what happens if he does that . Joining me now is gary casperoff. A russian prodemocracy leader and a former world chess champion. Hes run for the presidency in russia. Hes also author of the book winter is coming why Vladimir Putin and the enemies of the free world must be stopped. Always a pleasure, sir. Thank you. Lets start with that. Weve all determined it seems like the large motivation of Vladimir Putin to mess with western elections is simply to destabilize the west. Fair . Absolutely. What is and america is not, you know, an exception. So he has been doing it and still doing it in europe because he wants the undermine the council of democracy. Those for people in russia and outside. So now that hes watching the first month and a half of this new President Trump, and on one hand, he thought, this is great. Because Foreign Policy wise, hes a nationalist, im a nationalist. But now word is, hes turning on him. Why would he be . No, hes not turning on him. Russian propaganda, its Russian Media they call under total control of Vladimir Putin is viciously antiamerican. Despite being antiamerican, they do not criticize donald trump personally. They separate him. Exactly. They go after obama, obamas loyalists, they harshly criticize the deep state, fbi, cia, i mean, all the forces in the United States who are according to them, conspireing against donald trump, preventing donald trump to make bargains with Vladimir Putin. Coincidentally, this is the same line taken by breitbart and eventually, you know, its used by trump and his supporters. Theres always been this other concern that i think that that perhaps folks close to the President Trump have never accepted which is this idea that, look, putin was going to destabilize any presidency that happened. His goal was to destabilize our democracy regardless of who won. Absolutely. So in that respect, if he is this a case where if trump gets too stable in the job, hell try to undermine him . Well, look if trump wanted and still wants relations with putin, why to lie about all russian contacts . Because its always russia and all the news about ties between russia and trump and his staff met with counterattacks with lies and denials. Its always russia, not saudi arabia, not china, not brazil, its always russia and lies and denials. Now trump is blaming obama. For everything that went wrong. And i meet him half way. That i believe obama. Reporter you were a tough critic. You thought he was way too weak on putin. He may think that now. Maybe, i think this is obamas weak policies, one of the main reasons why u. S. Elections has been hacked and we have an American Administration with more russian connections than ever. And, you know, if you like this consistently, it means you have something to hide and trump lied about him not being involved in changing over support of ukraine. Michael flynn lied about speaking about Russian Ambassador about sanctions. Jeff sessions lied about meeting russians, page doesnt remember his own name. So, why lie all the time . I think, you know, we have to insist, you know, on a full investigation of these ties. Because otherwise, you know, well never find whether there was something, you know, much more sinister than simple, you know, emu which will admiration of two leaders. We were showing earlier, and there is bipartisan criticism of Vladimir Putin in the United States congress. And there is a good chunk of the Republican Party that was with you for the longest time. In fact, would champion your criticism of barack obama being too weak on putin. Has this oddly backfired was putin too successful in some cases and now the reaction to trump, the fear of being seen as too close to russia, that its actually is now going to make it harder for putin ever to find allies in the United States . You know, it will have temporary success. As always, you know, dictators, they do much better tactically, it was a tactical success for putin. Strategically its his loss. Now bipartisan correlation and sooner or later, well see the United States changing its policy quite dramatically and, you know, countering putins efforts to destabilize the world. What youre seeing in europe right now with what hes doing in france. What is happening in germany, what is next for him . Is this going to continue to be this strategy . No, actually the whats next for putin depends on what happens here. Because, right now, people in the baltic states, in ukraine, eastern europe, western europe, they all, you know they all contemplated what u. S. Foreign policy is. Is it what serious guys like general mattis are saying to eu, European Union and nato on the weekday . Or is what Donald Trump Tweets with four exclamation marks at 6 00 a. M. On saturday . I want to get your expertise on something here. Over the last few months, there have been a ton of mysterious deaths of highranking russian officials. Some of whom may is this a coincidence . There have been heart attacks, Natural Causes but it all seems to be inside this time connected to the United States. Yes. What do you read, the whole list theres no direct connection, is this a coincidence or are you suspicious . I always say, i do believe in coincidences, but i believe in kgb. Were dealing with Vladimir Putin and his ruthless organization that is willing to do anything to protect their lead percent. The total cynic would look at that, look at this list of mysterious deaths in the last and say huh, i wonder if this is them getting ribd of anybody that was involved in this operation. You know, again, if were in a court of law of course, you know, you can disregard everything as big conspiracy. But theres too much circumstantial evidence. You look at the conflicts between trump and his people and russian authorities. Then look at all of these dossiers, and as you mention now, talking about this mysterious death and russian officials. So when you start adding it up, you know, its a very, you know, disturbing picture. And again, you know, United States congress, United States must start a full scale investigation. But its American National interest. Its a fate of democracy, not only in this country, but worldwide. And unless we go to the bottom of that, you know, we all, you know, be there. We have heard the ambassador that russias ambassador be described as a spy master. Is that overdoing it . I dont know. It doesnt matter. Definitely he has been reporting to back to moscow and if he has another spy master in embassy doesnt change the equation. And is that Vladimir Putin and by the foreign minister. Wanted to punish the United States. Which is normal diplomatic practice. You said of 35 guys from washington would do the same for moscow. Putin didnt do it which is highly unusual for a strong man because he cannot show weakness. Thats against putins nature. Putins dictators rule, he did it which means to me, theres only one thing. He trusted michael flynn. Michael flynn spoke on behalf of donald trump and he expected to trump to do something, lifting sanctions and improving relations. Its clear, you know a lot more about whats going on than many people in this country. Never ending story. For sure. Always a pleasure. Thank you. Stay with msnbc. By the way, special edition of the Rachel Maddow show, taking a closer look at russias influence in american politics. Its titled the russia connection. And it airs tonight at 9 00 p. M. Eastern. Still ahead here, consider these two facts, fact one, Donald Trump Campaign promising clean air and clean water. Fact two, called for the largest cuts ever in the epa. How do you square fact one with fact two . Im going to ask a former administration, Kristen Todd Whitman when we come back. Special edition . Because, actually theres five. Ooohh aaaahh uh hooooly mackerel. Wow. Nice. Strength and style. Its truck month. Get 0 financing for 60 months plus find your tag and get 5500 on select Chevy Silverado pickups when you finance with gm financial. Find new roads at your local chevy dealer. Theres nothing more than my vacation. Me so when i need to book a hotel room, i want someone that makes it easy to find what i want. Booking. Com gets it. They offer free cancellation if my plans change. Visit booking. Com. Booking. Yeah. it just feels like anything is possible here in upstate new york. at corning, i test smart glass that goes all over the world. But theres no place like home. Theres always Something Different to do like skiing in the winter, jet skiing in the summer. We can do everything. New york state is filled with bright minds like samanthas. To find the companies and talent of tomorrow, search for our page, jobsinnewyorkstate on linkedin. And her new mobile wedding sebusiness. Tte page, at first, getting paid was tough. Until she got quickbooks. Now she sends invoices, sees when theyve been viewed andtadahpaid twice as fast for free. Visit quickbooksdotcom. I wanti did my ancestrydna and where i came from. And i couldnt wait to get my pie chart. The most shocking result was that im 26 native american. I had no idea. Just to know this is what im made of, this is where my ancestors came from. And i absolutely want to know more about my native american heritage. Its opened up a whole new world for me. Discover the story only your dna can tell. Order your kit now at ancestrydna. Com. This this this is my body of proof. Proof of less joint pain and clearer skin. This is my body of proof that i can take on Psoriatic Arthritis with humira. Humira works by targeting and helping to block a specific source of inflammation that contributes to both joint and skin symptoms. Its proven to help relieve pain, stop further joint damage, and clear skin in many adults. Humira is the 1 prescribed biologic for Psoriatic Arthritis. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. Serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Before treatment, get tested for tb. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Want more proof . Ask your rheumatologist about humira. Whats your body of proof . Welcome back. If you havent been on social media. Then you probably dont realize this, but today is International Womens day with Events Worldwide calling for equal rights and attention to womens issues and you are looking live right now at the day without women march in new york city. It is part of a nationwide strike of sorts. Organized by the same people who put together the massive womens marches the day after President Trumps inauguration. Still ahead, where President Trumps Campaign Promises on the environment nothing but hot air . But first, heres Hampton Pearson with the cnbc market wrap. Thanks chuck. We had stocks closing mostly lower. Oil posting its biggest decline in more than a year. Dow down by 69 points. S p off by five, the nasdaq up by just three points. A win for chipotle with a judge dismissing a lawsuit claiming the chain defrauded shareholders during outbreaks of e doe lie. Starbucks decision to hire thousands of refugees may be hurting the brand according to credit analysts who decided customerbacklash and giving the company a hold rating. Thats it from cnbc, first in business worldwide. Healthy, free, the world before me, the long brown path before me leading wherever i choose. The east and the west are mine. The north and the south are mine. All seems beautiful to me. Im raph. My name is anne. Im one of the real live attorneys you can talk to through legalzoom. Dont let unanswered legal questions hold you up, because were here, were here, and weve got your back. Legalzoom. Legal help is here. Legal help is here. Whattwo servings of veggies . V8 or a powdered drink . Ready, go. Ahhhhhhhh shake shake shake shake shake done you gotta shake it i shake it glad i had a v8. The original way to fuel your day. Welcome back, President Trumps budget blueprint plans to cut a lot from domestic programs. Washington post reports today that the white house is planning double digit cuts to the coast guard, the tsa, and fema to pay for his proposed border wall. And thats just a fraction of what President Trump may have in store for the Environmental Protection agency. According to reports from ap and reuters, epa could soon see a 25 budget cut including removing 3,000 staffers. The budget for the Chesapeake Bay cleanup project would go to 5 million. The great lakes cleanup project would lose 97 of funding. Also on the chopping block, funding to cut Greenhouse Gases and 30 of the budget for giving grants to state governments to better air quality. Now, President Trump says he wants clean air and clean water but wants to dismantle the regulations that help clean some of the air and clean some of that water. Take a listen. We want clean air. And we want clean water. And other things, but its gotten to a point, people are making a fortune off of this stuff. And our businesses are being hurt, our manufacturers cant compete, china is over there right now laughing like hell at barack obama because were stopping our plants from functioning and making it so expensive and not any better pollution wise. Well, joining me now is a former epa administrator under former president george w. Bush, governor whitman, nice to see you. Always a pleasure. Good to see you well, i dont see you fair enough. Good stare at you in a camera. Let me start with responding to the president s critiques there. Forget before we get into the details of the epa budget, did you generally agree with that critique that the epa was too bloated, to big, too much and Environmental Protection was too much of a priority in the Obama Administration. Do you accept that . No, not the whole ball of wax as he said. I mean, we have seen over time that we can grow our economy, grow our energy demand, see our population increase and still double our gdp. I mean, we see that, we have facts that show that. So its not Environmental Protection or a clean, green environment or a healthy growing economy. We can do both. And weve got to do both because quite frankly you cant have a healthy economy if you dont have a clean and green environment. If people dont have clean air to breathe and clean water to drink. You need to have all of those things. And while you can see the Obama Administration certainly used the executive power more than in the past, thats true. And you need to take a look at that. Thats okay. Theres nothing wrong with that, but to go in and say i want clean air and clean water, but im not going to give the agency any money to do that, and im not going give the states any money to do that, when i want to send power back to the states and do more, but im going to give them a lot less. Just doesnt compute. You know, its interesting when looking at the proposed budget cuts of epa, it feels like it was a political strategist that made the budget, right, and say okay, you know, youll never be youll never make a conservative mad by just whacking at the epa, and it also feels as if its not serious. That it was such a whack at epas budget that its almost designed they know that its never going to be accepted, but they really want 20 or 30 cuts, so theyre going to ask for some extreme number like 97 . Do you think thats what this documents about . Um, i dont think entirely. Certainly theyre sending a message to the base. This is one of the easiest places to go because everybody hates regulation. Causing them to spend money or change behavior they hate regulation until theres lead in the water they like the outcome. Exactly. They like the outcome of regulation. So its one or the other. But they do know that a lot of programs will be restored. Congress will not let it go through this way. Its their home district. You talked the Chesapeake Bay, the great lakes clean up, those are things that are important to a whole bunch of constituents of a number of those who are in the congress today. And so, theyre going to push back. They will restore, let the magnitude of the cuts that theyre putting in with this budget means its still going to be a largely crippled agency, and it sends you a bit of an understanding of what theyre going to do even with what they have left. Which is to draw back on reinforcement, probably no new regulations, and they are still going to go after the clean power plan. Have you met with the new epa administrator, scott pruitt . No. No. Im not exactly on the list. Well, i guess as a former epa administrator and he doesnt have any experience, as much experience as you had doing it, and you know, here hes got in your opinion a Republican Administration and some at the time thought you werent probusiness enough because of what you were advocating at the epa. What would you tell scott pruitt to say you know what, this is what youre going learn what the epa really is. You may think its x, but its really y. What is that y that you would tell scott pruitt . Well, the y is its really about Public Health and the environment. And what he needs to do as ive said repeatedly is just take a deep breath, get to know the agency, get to understand how much the agency is controlled, what it does by the laws that established it. That congress wrote. I mean, the epa has to consider certain things relative to clean air within certain time frames. They dont have a choice. And on the clean power plan, as far as carbon goes, thats been adjudicated in the Supreme Court. And the Supreme Court found in fact its called a finding of endangerment, they found this was bad for human health which triggers a responsibility on the epas part to do something about it to set a regulation. So, he has to understand, truly understand, that the people there are not all wild tree huggers who cant stand, isnt enough regulation for them fir. There are people who want to do their job. They want to protect Public Health. They want to protect the environment. Theyll do it the way you want them to do is as long as theyre convinced youre trying to make things better. They understand budget cuts. Theyve been through it before. They understand the challenges we face, but when they seem so broadbased that theres no thought behind them, thats when youre going to get real pressure. What do you hear moral wise in the agency . Its pretty low. Its pretty low. Theyre scared, theyre not entirely sure what to expect. And theyre not particularly happy with where they find themselves now. All right. Kristene todd whitman, former epa administrate. Nice to see you through a camera lens. Appreciate you coming on. Up next, why i think some of our friends at the nations biggest colleges need a geography lesson. Then next tuesday, austin, who doesnt want to be in austin . Some days of the week, right . Were going to south by southwest because nobody does that anymore. Ill be hosting a discussion on whether big data is destroying the u. S. Political system. If youre in austin, wed love to see you there. Stop by, well be right back. Why do so many businesses rely on the u. S. Postal service . Because when they ship with us, their business becomes our business. Thats why we make more ecommerce deliveries to homes than anyone else in the country. Here, there, everywhere. United States Postal Service priority you youthats why you drink ensure. Sidelined. With 9 grams of protein and 26 vitamins and minerals. For the strength and energy to get back to doing. What you love. Ensure. Always be you. So we know how to cover almost alanything. Ything, even a truckcicle. [second man] how you doing . [ice cracking] [second man] ah,ah, ah. Oh no [first man] saves us some drilling. [burke] and we covered it, february fourteenth, twentyfifteen. Talk to farmers. We know a thing or two because weve seen a thing or two. We are farmers. Bumpadum, bumbumbumbum welcome back tonight im obsessed with geography or the integrity of geography when it comes to college athletics. Its of course conference tournament week in college basketball. A solid appetizer for the upcoming feast of march madness. And the Atlantic Coast conference, the acc, king. College sbaubl holding its tournament subway ride away from here at the Barkley Center in brooklyn. You probably are assuming thats why im here today. My feelings about new york city are well known, but ill concede that it is a great basketball town. Hard stop. Lets be real, brooklyn has absolutely nothing to do with the acc. Were in brooklyn do you find tobacco road . Is Cameron Indoor the name of a warehouse bar . None of the colleges that play basketball in the acc are within 200 miles of new york city. The closest one is not even in new york state. Its Boston College. And that is at least a four and a half hour drive without traffic. Look, we already sacrifice a lot when it comes to geographic integrity in college sports. Colleges in three states that dont border the Atlantic Ocean and only one of the three touch salt water, pennsylvania. Big east, college in nebraska, and the big ten, four members and big 12 has ten. And play in a city with maybe the tiniest bit of connection to your colleges. Or at the very least, somewhere relatively nearby. May even gate few more people in the seats for the weekday afternoon games. That said, acc, theres acc tournament and theres everybody else. Well be right back. Way to say this. Its over. Ive found a permanent escape from monotony. Together, we are perfectly balanced. Our senses awake. Our hearts racing as one. I know this is sudden, but they say. If you love something set it free. See you around, giulia time for the lid. Panel is back. Charl charlie sykes, katy tur, joel benenson. Let me wrap up, you enjoyed a little time off camera, heard what he said, look, katy, hes pretty sure exactly how putin operates and more definitive about what happened in his mind probably because hes witnessed russia doing these things, oh by the way, hes had his own life threatened by putin over the years. There isnt that definitiveness in the United States on this yet. No. There is a lot to glean from him. Theres not that definitiveness. A lot of smoke, so far no fire. One group of people say, listen, with all this smoke, by now you should have found a fire. You cant keep saying is and saying and saying it. The best spin the trump people have right now. Theres a whole other group that says, listen, you cant have all this smoke without something going on and if there is all this smoke, why would the Trump Campaign not go above and beyond to be as clear about their connections to russia as they possibly can . And there are others who say but a thebecause there is so much confusion, people like fbi director james comey, need to come out publicly and say we are doing an investigation, we are not doing an investigation. Here is what we know, here what we dont know. Trust has been degraded across the board. Lindsey graham almost spoke to that very point earlier today. Take a listen. I want to find out was a warrant issued against the Trump Campaign for illegal legal activity . Thats not too much to ask. The answer is either yes or no. If the answer is no, then i think we can move on and say that there was no surveillance by the Obama Administration through the warrant process, then the question is did they do something illegally . I highly doubt that. Now, joel, jim clapper on sunday on meet the press said, made it about trump tower. Said nothing that was associated with trump tower. Some people have said is he drawing a distinction there or not . And it seems as if Lindsey Graham thinks theres a distinction there. That i find i think thats worth noting, some people read what clapper said to me as a total, theres no warrants, there was nothing, no surveillance. Lindsey graham is hinting he still thinks there may be some surveillance of something or someone. I think the issue was about trump tower. Thats what donald trump raised himself. Correct. I think mr. Clapper, jim clapper, was being very careful. He was addressing only what was put out there. And you know if youre in any kind of enforcement, intelligence agency, you dont go beyond what you have to deal with in that moment. I think he was very very careful. As for the point about whether theres so much smoke, you already know fire, i think thats baloney. We are at the tip of the iceberg of something unprecedented whether its true or not here. There are enough things out there this will take time, it will take an investigation, someone with subpoena power to get to the bottom. You know, charlie, there was a republican operative quoted if the axios mike allen, i think last week, i love this quote, he says you dont know the smoke is the fire, the way theyre handling it, they actually created a fire with all the smoke. None of it makes sense if theres nothing there. Why did they lie about their contacts . Why has nobody come forward and say, yes, we did meet with the russians, told them, stop hacking. What is going to be going on here . Also, why does the president escalate this is a constitutional crisis level by accusing the previous president of committing a felony . So if he wants this to go away, theyre doing it in the worst possible way. Katy, whos spinning the president up on this . Somebody intentionally wanted him to see the Levin Breitbart stuff. They could have kept that from him. I had a conversation with somebody who spoke to donald trump over the weekend about exactly where he got this information. And the person said it was it was the breitbart article and he brought up levin and asked what do you think of this, is donald trump was barack obama wiretapping me . I dont think its anybody. I think he woke up on that morning and did his google search, found that breitbart article. All right. Voila. There it is. One way to govern. Joel, charlie, katy, thank you very much. After the break, love, hate and a dinner date, all at the white house. Usaa gives me the peace of mind and the security just like the marines did. The process through usaa is so effortless, that you feel like youre a part of the family. I love that i can pass the membership to my children. Were the williams family, and were usaa members for life. Heres to the wildcats this i gotta try. Bendy. Spendy weekenders. Whatever kind of weekender you are, theres a hilton for you. Book your weekend break direct at hilton. Com and join the weekenders. Safety isnt a list of boxes to check. Its taking the best technologies out there and adapting them to work for you. The ultrasound that can see inside patients, can also detect early signs of corrosion at our refineries. Hightech military cameras that see through walls, can inspect our pipelines to prevent leaks. Remotecontrolled aircraft, can help us identify potential problems and stop them in their tracks. At bp, safety is never being satisfied. And always working to be better. I love to see businesses that just started from ground up grow into further success. It just feels good to know that im helping someone else. My first goal is to learn about their business, what theyre currently doing in their advertising. Pull some research, create a great story. Trying to figure out some way of building some kind of trust in a very quick moment. You have to love to work with people. Our goal, without a doubt, is that all customers are satisfied before they leave. Welcome back. In case you missed it, during the campaign, senator ted cruz had unkind things to say about mr. Trump after mr. Trump criticized senator cruzs wife, heidi. I dont get angry often, but you mess with my wife, you mess with my kids, that will do it s coward, leave heidi alone. Guess whos come to dinner . Ted cruz and wife, heidi, will dine with donald trump and first lady melania trump, the latest in a string of meetings between the president and his rivals, not just as he called him lyin ted, on friday, little marco hopping on air force one as they sf flew from d. C. To florida. Just yesterday, 1 Lindsey Graham had lunch with the president and it was so good, Lindsey Graham gave him his new cell phone number. How about that . Well see, though, how heidi and ted handle tonight. Thats all for tonight. For the record, though, with greta starts right now. Demanding answers. Now its both parties calling for proof from the fbi about President Trumps explosive claim that president Obama Wiretapped him. Will the fbi talk . Well, they might have to and sooner than you think. Also, he rolled his eyes. Not reporting on president obamas reaction to trumps twitter accusations. Well tell you what the former president is reportedly really worried about. Also the right hits back. Kpr conservatives defy gop lde