Transcripts For MSNBCW MTP Daily 20160404

Chuck todd. Welcome to mtp daily. We are now just 15 hours until the polls open in wisconsin. This is a state that could dramatically change the course of the races on both sides. It also means that we are now just under 24 hours until chuck kicks off our live primary night coverage of the wisconsin, thats going to start at 5 00 p. M. Eastern tuesday. So lets get that countdown clock ticking. You you can see on the lower righthand side of your screen, we begin tonights take with a badger state battle royal, as donald trump and ted cruz unite in a massive effort to force john kasich out of the race before a possible contested convention. There are only two candidates whose names will appear on the ballot. Donald trump and myself. Under the rules, you have to have won eight states. There are only two candidates under that threshold. Hes 1 in 30. He ought to get the hell out, honestly. Its very, very unfair to have a stubborn guy like that to be campaigning. And as our own ari melber reports, trump and cruz are leading a big effort behind the scenes that would block kasich from availability at this summers convention. Were going to get the inside scoop from ari on that in just a moment. Kasich, meanwhile, is firing back against both trump and cruz today. At a rally today in new york state and in a News Conference with reporters, kasich bristled at the criticisms from trump and cruz, that he should get out. Donald trump said that i need to get out of the race, because im getting his voters. Ive got news for him. Im going to get a heck of a lot of his voters, thats whats going to happen. Im not getting out. Why would i get out . Particularly when trumps worried im going to get his votes . Ive spent 1 million including smearing me, senator ted, im not going to be a pin cushion or a marshmallow. And kasich insists he has no intention of going anywhere, regardless of the outcome in wisconsin tomorrow night. But the antitrump forces are looking to notch a big win. A turning point for the stoptrump movement. Cruz has held sizable leads in wisconsin. Theres a new one that shows cruz up five points, so trump still very much within striking distance there. What makes this race so intriguing are the wild spins in delicate allocation that we could see depending on the results. It is possible that donald trump could get shut out completely in wisconsin. Its also possible that even if he loses to ted cruz, he could cobble together a number of delegates, anyway. Lets explain, because in this tight race, every delegate is going to matter. Now, overall, there are 42 delegates up for grabs tomorrow night on the republican side in wisconsin. If you win the statewide vote, you get 18 of those 42. 18 to the statewide winner. The other 24, that gets a little more complicated. Each of wisconsins eight Congressional Districts will also award delegates in a winnertakeall contest by district. For every Congressional District you win, you get three delegates to the National Convention. Now, if you look at the map, wisconsins Congressional Districts are not all created equally. But right now, most of them appear to be favoring cruz. Ewe know this because in that Emerson College poll, i was just mentioning, they crunched the numbers, they broke it down by Congressional District and found cruz leading in most of those districts right now. They did show, though, trump having a slight lead in the second district. Thats around madison. Also, a big lead in the third district. Thats in la crosse, in that area. Thats about it. So under those under that breakdown, trump right now would have six delegates in the state. 6 of the 42. If cruz wins the state and wins most of the Congressional Districts, that means trump could get blown out. And that is what makes wisconsin such a wild card here. But weve also been here before. It is also possible that trump loses wisconsin tomorrow, that the headlines are really bad for him, but then on april 19th, he rebounds with a huge win and then a week later on the 26th throughout the northeast, when a bunch of northeast states hold primaries. We just dont know what is going to happen in this race, but there are cracks in trumps towering campaign. At least there appear to be. While trump has dominated the national narrative, his campaign has struggled at the local level. He appears to have been outmaneuvered in north dakotas state convention, where they picked 25 National Convention delegates. It looks like cruzs preferred delegates won a vast majority of the slots there. Although, a key asterisk here, north dakotas delegates are all officially unbound. So it remains to be seen who they will ultimately support when they get to the National Convention this summer. In tennessee, meanwhile, thats the state where donald trump won big in the primary. His Campaign Says that the States Republican Party chose some of its Convention Delegates unfairly in an attempt to steal support away from trump. At a rally just a few hours ago, trump ripped into the partys nominating process. Lets watch. Were dealing with a corrupt system. Were dealing with a system thats not fair. And i say to people, i dont care what it said. Any won, i should get more delegates. Like, i dont care. And im going to be joined momentarily by the Trump Campaigns Senior Adviser, Barry Bennett, who is leading their delegate strategy. And im going to be joined by the Washington Post dan balz who thinks wisconsin should reshape the republican contest mathematically and psychologically. Well begin this hour with msnbcs chief legal correspondent, ari melber. Hes been all over this war for delegates playing out on the republican side. Ari, take us through it. It looks line trump and cruz have both decided, its in their interests not to have kasich around at that convention. Thats right, steve. And as you know from following this, that could change. But right now we have word from both those aides, thats what i determined in this story, that thats going to be their approach. Now, the arguments for that either, weve done it this way before, or we want to do it, we have the power, were going to do it. And im sure you could talk to Barry Bennett about that. Heres what ted cruz said about that second argument, we have the power, today. If theres a contested convention, 80 of the delegates will be cruz delegates or trump delegates. Both donald and i have been very clear that we shouldnt be changing the rules because washington is unhappy with how the people are voting. What hes saying there, to be precise, is that they are going to have the majority of delegates, both on likely the rules committee, the rights of first draft, and tonight floor, so they can decide on who goes on the ballot. I also spoke to north blackwell, who is a really interesting guy whos been on the past seven Convention Rules committee and was a critic and wanted to change the very rule that limits the ballot. Hes a cruz supporter and said there was a time to change it and that time is passed. Heres what he told me. Under the rules, it appears kasich cant meet the eightstate threshold. They were established for people who largely all for kasich right now, the establishment, and changing the rules in the middle of the game is quite generally understood as unfair, steve. But if we get to june and the Cruz Campaign determines or the Trump Campaign, for that matter, hey, its now in our best interests to open this thing up as wide as possible, all bets are off. And thats what makes this so interesting and so much like a game of thrones or house of cards scenario. No one is thinking these rules are some sacrosanct thing. You would expect the convention to pursue the rules that help them. The cruz team has had a very focused approach here. And because they are second, its pretty obvious they want anything to narrow this and make them the alternative. The trump calculations, i know youre going to explore in this broadcast, could change more over time. Ari melber with the start of probably months of wrangling. Im joined by Barry Bennett, the Trump Campaign Senior Adviser. I want to start with a piece of sound. This was donald trump today talking about what we were just talking about here, this idea of john kasich and his role or lack thereof of the convention. Here was trump today, sending a different message, saying, hey, he wants john kasich to be placed in nomination. At least thats what it sounded like. Let me play that. Let minimum go to the convention. Hes the governor, you know, governor, were talking about cleveland. Let him put his name in contention and if things dont work out, let him be. So barry, do you want kasich to be nominated at the convention or do you want him out of the race . Weve had these rules now for three years and three months. And the rules state that you have to win a majority of the delegates in eight states. John kasich is not going to achieve that. And now in the ninth inning, he wants to change the rules to allow more outs. Its not going to happen. Barry, the clip we just played, your own candidate says let him go there and put his name in nomination. Your candidate is saying, he wants his name on the ballot in cleveland. What hes saying is, let him try. Hes not going to be able to get i done. In order to be nominated, you have to get the majority of delegates from eight states to sign a piece of paper to take to the secretary to get on the nomination process. Hes not going to be able to accomplish that. Let me ask you this, though, if we get to june, if we get to the end of this primary process here. Do you have any doubt that if ted cruz and his campaign determine then for whatever reason that its in their best interests to open this thing up to kasich or somebody else, that they would change their tune from where they are right now . Oh, probably, but they wont, because as soon as the establishment has someone else to choose other than ted cruz, they will. It will be ted who . So hes never going to let him do that. What about the where we stand right now in terms of wisconsin. The stoptrump movement, the nevertrump movement, whatever you want to call it, they are looking at wisconsin tomorrow and they are saying, this is going to be the start of a domino effect. Donald trump, they say, is going to lose wisconsin, a state that he should win. That is going to make him look week. Thats going to be the story, and then hell start losing other places hes supposed to win. What do you say to that . Well, they havent been right about anything so far. Well start with that. Two weeks ago, we were probably down about 15 points in wisconsin. Today, were down probably within the margin of error of the polls, its getting very tight. Its an open primary, that changes the dynamics. We could equal it out tomorrow. If we do, then this race is over. Frankly, if we win any delegates tomorrow, i think this race is over. Because ted cruz just cant afford to lose anymore delegates. Donald trump also gave that interview over the weekend. It appeared over the weekend, at least, maureen dowd in the New York Times, and he actually had a couple of lines in there that i think people were surprised to hear. One thing he said was that he thought that it actually had been a mistake on his part to send that retweet out, that picture of heidi, of heidi cruz, that unflattering pictuue of heidi cruz. Weve been asking for a while, but are we going to see a different tone at all from donald trump Going Forward . I think, especially once we get the primary process behind us, right now were battling in 56 states and territories, over delegates, rule committees, primaries, you name it. Weve got a lot going on. But once we get past this primary and get back to focusing on the issues, why druonald tru decided to run. The safety of our border, the security of our border, keeping drugs and Illegal Immigrants out of our country, those kind of things we need to get back to and i know that well do really well once we get back to talking about those issues. Barry bennett with the Trump Campaign, thanks for the time. Thank you. Well turn now to dan balz, the chief Political Correspondent with the Washington Post. Dan, thanks for taking a few minutes. Let me ask you the same a variation of the same question i just asked Barry Bennett there. He says he doesnt think wisconsin is any kind of a turning point. He says, actually, if you look at his polling, had them down a few weeks ago, he said they made up ground. But you asked that question today, could wisconsin be a turning point for this republican race nationally . How do you look at it . I think if ted cruz has a very good night on tuesday night, it could be a turning point. A very good night would be to sweep all the delegates and to shut out donald trump. Its not at all clear thats going to happen the late polls show that this is a closer race than the polls last week. Its anybodys guess. I think, what its going to end up as, cruz is clearly the favorite at this point. If trump brings a surprise, barrys probably right, that that is a feather in trumps cap and away he goes. But, theres still a ways you know, weve still got a number of events to take place. Clearly, the calendar after wisconsin, the immediate calendar favors trump. But if he doesnt do well tomorrow night in wisconsin, its not likely that he can get to 1,237 before california and even with california. So theres so much yet to play out. I think what were dealing with is that hes come off of two difficult weeks, with a variety of selfinflicted wounds. And i think if he takes a lumping in wisconsin, people are going to equate part of the result to the problems hes created for himself. Thats the other question, too. That the events of the last two weeks may not just be jeopardizing his position in wisconsin, but when we talk about all of these scenarios at the convention this summer where republicans could deny him the nomination, all of these delegate maneuverings we see in all of these places, do you think this has added a sense of urgency . Has strengthened the resolve of the republican establishment to take advantage of any loophole they can find to deny trump the nomination this summer . Theres two realities. One is that the convention can write its own rules. When barry says the rules have been in effect, theyre not actually in effect for this convention. Theyre the carryover from 2012. But as both the cruz and Trump Campaigns have been saying, if they have the overwhelming majority of the delegates, they will probably be able to write rules that are more favorable to them. Thats what mitt romney and his folks were able to do in 2012, to keep ron paul from having his name put in nomination. So but, you know, the other thing, steve, is, you know, just think of weve been through february and march. Were now in early april. We have to go through april, may, early june primaries, and then maneuvering before the convention. There is so much time, it is impossible to predict what the circumstances are going to look like, by the time we get to the eve of cleveland. And it also seems, we are talking with ari, talking to barry, too, just a minute ago, about this idea of trump and cruz, at least for now. And like you say, theres a lot that can change between now and convention, but at least for now, calculating that not having kasich on that ballot, not having kasich up for a nomination would benefit both of them. Im trying to think about that from the cruz standpoint, and maybe one of the things theyre worried about there, is the idea of the dark horse candidate, the white knight. The candidate whos not currently out there. Paul ryans name gets mentioned a lot. If you put kasich on the ballot, if the thing extends for a few ballots, that possibility enters into the mix more, doesnt it . It certainly does. Its always been the Cruz Campaigns position that they would like john kasich and everybody else out of this race. They have wanted to have a headtohead contest with donald trump for many, many weeks. So we know that thats in their interests. Given what the audio you played from donald trump, and from what he said versus what barry said, its impossible, at this point, to know what the Trump Campaign really thinks about that. Thats right. Dan balz from the Washington Post, thanks for the time. Appreciate it. Thank you. All right. And coming up, recesssive traits. Could Donald Trumps predictions of an economy on the brink send his campaign over the edge . Plus, the evolution of the sanders revolution. Campaign insiders look backward to give a new take on their candidates path forward. Stay tuned. There are two billion people who dont have access to basic banking, but that is changing. At temenos, with the microsoft cloud, we can enable a banker to travel to the most remote locations with nothing but a phone and a tablet. Everywhere where theres a phone, you have a bank. Now a person is able to start a business, and employ somebody for the first time. The microsoft cloud helped us to bring banking to ten Million People in just two years. Its transforming our world. Whewhat does it look like . Ss, is it becoming a better professor by being a more adventurous student . Is it one day giving your daughter the opportunity she deserves . Is it finally witnessing all the artistic wonders of the Natural World . Whatever your definition of success is, helping you pursue it, is ours. Tiaa. Welcome back. All eyes will be on americas dairy land tomorrow. 86 democratic delegates going to be up for grabs in the primary there. And 42 on the republican side. And here are some key areas to watch as the votes srt coming in tomorrow night. Well start with the wow counties. These are the suburban areas densely populated suburban areas, just outside milwaukee. This is where ted cruz is getting his strength from right now, in this state. These areas th s that propellet walker to victory in 2010, in his recall, in his 2014 reelection bid. They are the heart of conservatism in wisconsin. At least scott walker conservatism. Next is Milwaukee County. In theory, this should be good for donald trump. Hes been successful in areas where white voters live near more diverse communities. But, wisconsins racial divides are much more stark than in other parts of the country. In the milwaukee journal senathnell broke down marquette polling data from inside Milwaukee County and found this. They found that trump has a negative 28 favorableility sco there. Thats terrible. The third, seventh, and eighth Congressional Districts, those could be more fertile territory for donald trump tomorrow. These are the types of rural, working class whites that boosted trump in ohio. And in michigan, these tended to be lower education levels. Thats been the formula for trump so far. Finally, there is dane county. This has the state capitol, the university of wisconsin, madison. If john kasich can do anything in wisconsin tomorrow, this is where hes going to find his support. Right in and around madison. Now, polls in wisconsin are going to close at nine oclock p. M. Eastern tomorrow night and you can see the votes come in with our allstar team right here on msnbc. Well have all the numbers and all the analysis. Make sure to tune in tomorrow night, so well be right back next more mtp daily. For your retirement, you want to celebrate the little things, because theyre big to you. And that is why you invest. The best returns arent just measured in dollars. Td ameritrade®. Wrely on the Us Postal Service . Because when they ship with us, their business becomes our business. Thats why we make more ecommerce deliveries to homes than anyone else in the country. Here, there, everywhere. United states Postal Service priority you between you and me, i dont want to get Hillary Clinton more nervous than she already is. Shes already under a lot of pressure. So dont tell her this, but i think we win here, we win in new york city, were on our way to the white house. That was Bernie Sanders earlier today in wisconsin, sounding very confident about his prospects in that states primary tomorrow. It would launch another round of stufftories for Hillary Clinton and her campaign. But it wont really change the delegate math in the democratic race. Sanders would have to beat her in new york in two week for clinton to really be in trouble. He would have to do more than that down the road. Thats the bare minimum. In todays New York Times, it seems like the Sanders Campaign is all but admitting defeat. Quote, allies and advisers of mr. Sanders say they missed opportunities to run an aggressive political operation in 2015 that would have presented more of a challenge to mrs. Clinton. That is the tone of an autopsy report. Tad devine, a Senior Adviser for the Sanders Campaign responded to the article today on msnbc. He says the campaign is far from throwing in the towel. I think they determined if Bernie Sanders had run a tough, personal, negative campaign, he could have defeated Hillary Clinton. But he was never going to run that campaign. Thats not who he is. Kasie hunt is following the Sanders Campaign and joins us from milwaukee, wisconsin. Kristen welker joins us from albany, new york. Lets start with this New York Times article. I thought the framing of this article, i found it a little odd, to be honest. To me, when i look at Bernie Sanders, this is a guy whos won more than a dozen states. He could wind up with more than 1,800 delegates. This is a selfdeclared socialist running against a former secretary of state, a former first lady. To me the story of his campaign is that hes overachieved, not that hes underachieved . Reporter steve, i think thats right. And if you look at it from the flip side, Hillary Clinton is pretty lucky that thats what shes up against this time around. Because he really has challenged her in ways we didnt expect. And i will say many of these quotes in this story have been given to me and to many other reporters over the past couple of months, very close to what is printed in this story. Theyve always said, all the way long, and i asked Bernie Sanders himself this back in iowa, when it was looking like he had a good shot to win and maybe if she had gone negative, maybe if he had done things a little bit differently, he was going to be at the point to push it over the top. The secondguessing on that has always been there and its also always been true that Bernie Sanders himself is the one who is reluctant to go negative on Hillary Clinton. There have been plenty of people around him, advising him, telling him, hey, you really should do this. If you want to win, this is the way to go aide ahead and do it. Tad devine has worked with Bernie Sanders for a long time. Many of his other aids around him know that that is not. He does not believe that that is a part of his brand. Thats what he told me in iowa. He told me that again in vermont, when we were going into some of those other states. I think the question is, how much has Bernie Sanders changed from feeling as though his campaign was a cause to really actually believing that he could become the nominee. The one major turning point for him is nevada, where they really misset the expectations and that changed the trajectory. It is interesting. I guess we have the tendency, when things dont seem to be working out for a campaign, we go back and say, they must have made a million mistakes. I think theres a sports analogy here. Its possible to play a really good game and still lose. Its possible to rub a Good Campaign and still lose, depending on what kind of campaign youre up against. Kristen, whats your sense when they look at the Sanders Campaign . Do they look back and say, wow, we dodged a bullet . How do they look at it . I dont think. If you talk to the Clinton Campaign, they would say, hes been pretty critical of her as of late. Thats been a big point of contention. One of the arguments the Clinton Campaign has made, they have been so negative, they initially werent sure they wanteded to debate him. That was a political tactic. It underscores you have seen this significant shift in senator sanders and in his strategy in terms of how hard hes been going after secretary clinton. Still, there is a reality about all of this, which you talked about at the top, which is that, look, senator sanders is leading by a slim margin in wisconsin, even if he wins that state by that very narrow margin hes not going to get a whole lot of delegates. He will gain some momentum heading into new york. In order for him to really start making a significant play for the nomination he has to start winning by large margins, not only gaining momentums, but cutting into her delegate lead and he has yet to do that. They still feel fairly confident. But they would argue, he has run a robust campaign, and i think secretary clinton has felt more challenged than she thought she would. Steve . Thats my takeaway. When i think back to a year ago, i dont think anyone thought they would be here now. I think its a little funny, look at all the mistakes they made. Thanks for the time. Appreciate that. Up next, Donald Trumps bubble trouble. How his economic doomsday prophesies are playing out on the trail. Stay with us. Take on the unexpected. The new 2016 nissan altima. Built to stand out. People are taking charge of their type 2 diabetes with noninsulin victoza®. For a while, i took a pill to lower my blood sugar. But it dnt get me to my goal. So i asked my doctor abt victoza®. He said victoza® wor differently than pills. And comes in a pen. Victoza® is proven to lower blood sugar and a1c. Its taken once a day, any time. Victoza® is not for weight loss, but it may help you lose some weight. Victoza® works with your body to lower blood sugar in 3 ways in the stomach, the liver, and the pancreas. Vo victoza® is an injectable prescription medicine that may improve blood sugar in adults with type 2 diabetes when used with diet and exercise. It is not recommended as the first medication to treat diabetes and should not be used in people with type 1 diabetes or diabetic ketoacidosis. Victoza® has not been studied with mealtime insulin. Victoza® is not insulin. Do not take victoza® if you have a personal or fami history of medullary thyroid cancer, multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2, or if you are allergic to victoza® or any of its ingredients. Symptoms of a serious allergic reaction may include itching, rash, or difficulty breathing. Tell youdoctorf you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Serious side effects may happen in people who take victoza®, including inflammation of the pancreas pancreatitis . Stop taking victoza® and call your doctor right away if you have signs of pancreatitis such as severe pain that will not go away in your abdomen or from your abdomen to your back, with or without vomiting. Tell your doctor about all the medicines you take and if you have any medical conditions. Taking victoza® with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. The most common side effects are headache, nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting. Side effects can lead to dehydration, which may cause kidney problems. If your pill isnt giving you the control you need ask your doctor about noninsulin victoza®. Its covered by most health plans. Still ahead, trumpanomics 101. The republican frontrunner now says the country is sitting on a financial bubble. But do his talking points really add up . We are going to dive headlong into that, next. But first, Hampton Pearson has todays cnbc market wrap. Hi, steve. Yeah, we had stocks ending the day lower. The dow sinking by 55 points. The s p was off by 6. The nasdaq following by 22 points. Alaska airlines is buying Virgin America for 2. 6 billion, creating the nations fifth largest airline. The company outed by jetblue in that contest. Factory orders slid 1. 7 in february. Theyve fallen in 14 of the last 19 months. And crude oil prices sank nearly 3 today, falling to a onemonth lull after iran reportedly said it would raise output to presanction levels. Thats it from cnbc, first in business, worldwide. M terrible. He is. People say im getting better. No ones ever said that. But id like to keep being terrible at golf for as long as i can. Hes just happier when hes playing. But hes terrible. For the strength and energy to keep doing what you love, try new ensure enlive. Only patented ensure enlive has hmb, plus 20 grams of protein to help rebuild muscle. And its clinically proven formula helps you stay you. Oh. Nice shot. New ensure enlive. Always be you. Wyou could just forget frthe beach wedding. And the beach booty. You could just book a different resort. Like in alaska. Theyve got igloos. When a moment turns romantic why pause to take a pill . Or stop to find a bathroom . Cialis for daily use is approved to treat both erectile dysfunction and the urinary symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently, day or night. Tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex. Do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, or adempas for pulmonary hypertension, as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. Do not drink alcohol in excess. Side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. To avoid longterm injury, get medical help right away for an erection lasting more than four hours. You have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, or any symptoms of an allergic reaction, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. Ask your doctor about cialis and a 200 savings card. Atand that horrible smellstee are really good at hiding. Vice, oh, boy. There it is. Ohh. Ooh. [ gags ] so when you need a house cleaner or an exterminator, we can help you get the job done right, guaranteed. Get started today at angies list, because your home is where our heart is. Republican president ial frontrunner donald trump says the country is on the verge of a, quote, very massive recession, speaking to the Washington Post, trump gave what reporters bob woodward and robert costa described as a gloomy view of the economy. Trump says its a, quote, terrible time right now to invest in the stock market, and that the Unemployment Rate is, quote, probably into the 20s if you look at the real number. End quote, i think were sitting on an economic bubble, a financial bubble. Trump says hes the only one who could steer the country in the right direction and he repeated those comments on the trail in wisconsin today. I was interviewed by bob woodward and bob costa at the Washington Post, two great reporters and they did a story and it was i thought it was a pretty good story. It was pretty accurate. And what i said is that were going to go into a massive recession, but i also say, if im president , thats not going to happen. Because im going to straighten things out before it happens. Now, even some prominent rightleaning economists are calling trumps predictions irresponsible and wrong. And were going to talk to one of them in just a moment. First, nbcs Gabe Gutierrez joins me now from superior, wisconsin, where trump just wrapped up an event a short while ago. Gabe, that kind of talk, that kind of doom and gloom economic talk, did you hear that again this afternoon . Reporter yeah within we did, steve. Certainly, the crowd here, more than 2,000 strong, was very receptive to trumps comments on the economy. And once again, donald trump really went after ted cruz, something he has continued to do. He also called for john kasich, as youve been mentioning, to drop out of the race. We also had some harsh words for the rnc, saying that he will continue to keep his eyes wide open. Basically lying that trial balloon just in case he does walk into that vnconvention wita plurality of the delegates. Of course, that sweet talking about louisiana, him winning the popular vote, but ted cruz getting more delegates. Expect to see that more from donald trump over the next coming days. Here in wisconsin, of course, he faces an uphill climb. The polls have him down potentially by double digits. But he is downplaying the endorsement of scott walker, saying that thats similar to governor nikki haleys endorsement, down in south carolina. She endorsed marco rubio, of course, and yet trump still won. So his Campaign Thinking he could pull out a victory here and get a bunch of those 42 delegates. Steve . All right. Thanks, gabe, for that. Joining me now, economist doug holtzeakin who said this about trumps economic predictions. Quote, its irresponsible and baffling he would do this and also substantively wrong. There is no recession in site. Doug is president of the American Action forum. He was the top economic adviser to john mccains 2008 campaign and hes a former member of the noncongressional budget office. Let me start with this. Donald trump said the real employment rate somewhere in the in the 20s. He says were sitting on a financial bubble and a recession is in sight. Thats his take on the economy. How would you describe the state of the American Economy right now . Well, i think everyone know its not as strong as we would like it to be. Theres been a lot of pain in the labor market during the recovery. But, look, you cant get a recession without having household spending, which is twothirds of the economy, actually falling. And right now the combination of wage growth, job growth, and hours growth adds up to something that looks like almost 6 percentage point of growth per year in payrolls. Thats the kind of Income Growth that will support household spending. Youre not going to get a recession with that kind of an outlook. Let me you ask about this claim about the Unemployment Rate. This kind of looks at the Employment Level going back, really to the start of the obama this is the current one, in the most recent report, more than 200,000 jobs added in march. The Unemployment Rate sitting at 5 . Six years ago, it was up near 10 . Now half of that at 5 . Ive heard others throw numbers like this around. Im curious as an economist, when trump makes that claim, the real Unemployment Rate is in the 20s. Do you have any idea what kind of math hes using to get that kind of where hes getting that from . I dont know where hes getting his number s. I know you can adjust the typical Unemployment Rate for the kind of workers that are marginally attached in the labor force, working less than they would like to, parttime work, a variety of measures that actually are put out by the Labor Department and the broadest measures known as the u u6 employment rate. Thats at 9. Its hard to get to 20. We know that unemployment has come down and the combination of those two things just gets you to a point where you cant be saying that 20 of americans who want to have a job dont have a job. So he is tapping into something, though, clearly. And when you look at the raw statistics, an Unemployment Rate being cut in half over the last five to six years, down to 5 , what is it, though . You say the economy is not as strong as we think. What are the things you think hes specifically tapping into . Are there economic indicators, numbers, pieces of data you would look at and say, this is where trump resonates when he says things like this . I think the key is very simple. If 5 is the Unemployment Rate, that means 95 of those who want to work are at work, but they havent had a raise. They havent had a raise since before the great recession. Theyve lived through their house prices collapsing, really bad wage growth, the median Family Income declining during the recovery. And that has generated some real economic distress out there. Hes tapping into that. And, you know, people dont know what the numbers are. I promise you, i live by the numbers and people find that the least interesting thing you can talk about. They know theyre not doing well. They hear donald trump say, hey, we have a big recession coming. Weve got big problems in the stock market and 20 of people are out of employment. That resonates with them. And finally, theres also this subject of the national debt. It sits near 20 trillion right now, 19 trillion. And donald trump promising in this article, he says he can get rid of that, he can wipe that away in eight years. When you look at the numbers, this is a guy, he says he does not want to touch entitlement spending or Social Security or medicare. He says he does favor a tax cut. So he would reduce revenue coming in, he would not be cutting a big source of expenditures, entitlement programs. What would it take with those parameters, what would it take to accomplish what hes talking about . Look, this is pretty simple. He will inherit 6 trillion of deficits on, you know, baked into the budget from this administration. So first, hes going to take care of that. Then theres another 14 trillion in debt in the hands of the public. Thats 20 trillion hes got to somehow get his arms around in eight years. 2. 5 trillion a year. Well, right now we spend, for entitlements, about 2. 5 trillion a year. He could wipe out all the entitlements and get there. But as you pointed out, hes promised not to touch Social Security or medicare. There isnt enough defense and nondefense annual spending to cover that. We cant go there. So he would have to raise taxes, but hes already promised to cut taxes. The bottom line is it doesnt add up and its not going to happen. Doug holtzeakin, thanks for the time. Sure. Still ahead, who counts as a person . The Supreme Court takes a stand on the oneperson, onevote argument. The story ahead on mtp daily. Sure, we could have stacked these tires. Or put them on a rack. But the specialists at ford like to show off their strengths 13 name brands. All backed by our low price tire guarantee. Yeah, were strong when it comes to tires. Right now during the big tire event, get a 120 rebate by mail on four select tires. When your ford needs service, these are the specialists. At ford. I am a lot of things. I am his sunshine. I am his advocate. So i asked about adding oncedaily namenda xr to his Current Treatment for moderate to severe alzheimers. It works differently. When added to another alzheimers treatment, it may improve overall function and cognition. And may slow the worsening of symptoms for a while. Vo namenda xr doesnt change how the disease progresses. It shouldnt be taken by anyone allergic to memantine, or whos had a bad reaction to namenda xr or its ingrients. Before starting treatment, tell their doctor if ty have, or ever had, a seizure disorder, difficty passing urine, liver, kidney or bladder problems, and about medications theyre taking. Certain medications, changes in diet, or medical conditions may affect the amount of namenda xr in the body and may increase side effects. The most common side effects are headache, diarrhea, and dizziness. Hes always been my everything. Now i am giving back. Ask their doctor about oncedaily namenda xr and learn about a free trial offer at namendaxr. Com. Time now for the ws. Starting with the who. Its melania trump, joining her husband on the campaign trail tonight in wisconsin. This is her first appearance at a rally in over a month. Todays what . Bernie sanders wants to shut down new yorks controversial Indian Point Nuclear facility. Sanders is the only candidate who wants to end all Nuclear Energy production. Hillary clinton, whose new york home is about 15 miles from indian point, has called to improve operations at the plant, which experienced a leak in february. Now to the where. It is new york and california. Governors in both states signing bills today, putting their respective states on the path to a 15 hour minimum wage. Both Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton celebrated the move. The when . Well, it is tonight and tomorrow. The ncaa mens and Womens Basketball championship games, villanova and North Carolina and the mens game tonight. Syracuse and uconn tomorrow in the womens final. New york and connecticut all have president ial primaries happening in the next month, so there are plenty of pandering opportunities available. Im not pandering when i say, go villanova, tonight. Now to the why. New hampshire senator kelly ayotte will be meeting with a Supreme Court nominee, merrick garland, on april 13th. According to our count, there are 13 republican senators who are at least open to meeting with garland. And heres why that matters. While 13 are open to meetings, only two republican senators, mark kirk of illinois and Maines Susan Collins actually support having hearings on garlands nominations. Back with more mtp daily after this. I love to take pictures that engage people and to connect us with the wonderment of nature with the tiger image, the saliva coming off and you got this turning. Thats why i need this kind of resolution and computing power. Bon the screen directly with the image, it just gives me a different relationship to it and i cant do that on my mac. This is brilliant for me. Whewhat does it look ke . Cess, is it becoming a better professor by being a more adventurous student . Is it one day giving your daughter the opportunity she deserves . Is it finally witnessing all the artistic wonders of the Natural World . Whatever your definition of success is, helping you puue it, is ours. Tiaa. All right, big voting news on capitol hill today, not in congress, though. But across the street from congress, as the eight justices who currently sit on the Supreme Court unanimously reject an attempt by conservative republicans to reduce the voting power of hispanics and other minority groups. The justices agreed that states cannot be required to draw their electoral districts based on just the eligible voting population. But the court didnt say that states must use total population to determine districts. Nbcs justice correspondent, pete williams, joins me with more. Pete, play translator here. Voting eligible population, total population, what exactly are we talking about here and what happened today . Well, this was a challenge brought by two residents of texas, who live in areas with large minority populations, that include many people who arent eligible to vote, by drawing the boundaries for state legislative districts, based on total population, they said their vote was diluted compared to people in districts where the total and the voter populations are closer to equal. They wanted the Supreme Court to rule that the states have to draw their boundaries, based on voter population, meaning eligible or registered voters. Texas opposed that. It asked the court to rule that at least that it could do it, but today the court ruled unanimously that when a state draws the boundary based on total population, that is constitutional. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote the opinion. She said, adopting votereligible apportionment as constitutional command would upset a wellfunctioning approach to districting that all 50 states and countless local jurisdictions have followed for decades, even centuries. She said the challengescenturie. The challengers have found no reason for the court to do that. In essence, the court says it requires using the total population report, so how it can be unconstitutional for states to do the same with their legislative districts. The court did not say whether a state may draw boundaries based on the voter and not the total population. Thats a question for another day. Pete williams, justin krauntd in washington. Thanks for that. A lot to talk about from the president ial campaign trail, and our roundtable is going to join us next for the lid, so keep it right here. G great burgers, or building the best houses in town. Or becoming the next highlyunlikely dotcom superstar. And us, well be right there with you, helpinwith the questions you need answered to get your brand new business started. Were legalzoom and weve already partned with over a million new Business Owners to do just that. Check us out today to see how you can become one of them. Legalzoom. Legal help is here. A 401 k is the most sound way to go. Lets talk asset allocation. Sure. You seem knowledgeable, professional. Im actually a dj. [ dance music plays ] woman [laughs] no way that really is you . If theyre not a cfp pro, you just dont know. Cfp work with the highest standard. But ive managed. E Crohns Disease is tough, except that managing my symptoms was ali was doing. And when i finally told my doctor, he said humira is for adults like me who have tried other medications but still experience the symptoms of moderate to severe Crohns Disease. And that in clinical studies, the majority of patients on humira saw significant symptom relief. And many achieved remission. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. Serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Before treatment, get tested for tb tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Ask your gastroenterologist about humira. With humira, remission is possible. R. On every plate and were about to keep it going. Yeah, youve got three more weeks to try the largest variety of lobster dishes of the year. Like lobster lovers dream. And new dueling lobster tails. This party cant last so hurry in. It was always just a hobby. Something you did for fun. Until the day it became something much more. And that is why you invest. E best returns arent just measured in dollars. Td ameritrade. Youto get the help yourefar looking for. Thats why at xfinity were opening up more stores closer to you. Where you can use all of our latest products and technology. And find out how to get the most out of your service. So when you get home, all you have to do is enjoy it. Were doing everything we can to give you the best experience possible. Because we should fit into your life. Not the other way around. All right, welcome to the lid. A lot to talk about today. We have with us elise jordan, an msnbc political analyst, former rand paul adviser and Bush White House official. Kai wright, and ozzy is a senior reported for politico. Lets start on the republican side. Looking ahead to wisconsin. Talking about this. Donald trump, maybe hell pull a rabbit out of the hat. Lets say the polls are right and donald trump loses. The question is, is this going to change anything nationally in the republican race or is this just an only in wisconsin win . I think his momentum has shifted. I know everyone has made this prediction thousands of times. I think this narrative has set in with women that he is against them and he is antiwomen. Imagine why women would think that after all of the really disturbing incidents from the Trump Campaign over the past year, but also the past week especially. Assaulting a reporter, and then trumps comments on abortion and women deserving punishment if they get an abortion. I think its the start of a trend where women are completely writing donald off and theres no way he can be successful in a general. Maybe hell be able to eke out a few more delegates. Okay, so elise is saying hes not going to be able to get there. We have new york after wisconsin. Donald trumps home state. Can he turn it back around here two weeks later . Hes expected to do well in new york. Remember the expectations game. Everyone has tried to write off donald trump, and even if he comes out losing and gives a speech that night that is not crazy, he looks like an adult. Therefore, people will can look at him as someone who is matured as a candidate. This is youre setting the bar a little low. Youre basically saying i think donald trump has set his bar low. Some people in the media have helped him, but the expectations game. The bar is low. Hell either low and thump his chest or lose and if he reacts calmly, people will look at him favorerably and hell get past this and do something outrageous to get our attention the next day. Kai, let me ask what you think of what elise said. She said this is baked in. And heres the question, and probably other voters too, but this is a guy who has reinvented himself an awful lot of times. If he gets the republican nomnails, hes going to turn around and try to do it again. Do you think he can pull it off . It would be very difficult to reinvent himself in the general, but the idea hes on a downward slide is wishful thinking. We have been in this conversation several times already in the course of this primary. You think hes still going to be the republican nominee when all is said and done . Anybody who tells you they know whats going to happen is lying to themselves or you. But theres no reason why he couldnt be the republican nominee and no reason why he wouldnt continue to run. You know the numbers so well. How difficult is it for donald trump to retach 1237 delegates f he doesnt win wisconsin. Gles, it makes it tougher, but does it spill over . If he goes to new york and dominates, does it mean he loses indiana . He does a lot less in california. Then he cant get there. My question is it is only a wisconsin state, or is it a bigger national thing. I want to get to the democratic race. We were talking about this earlier. Theres this New York Times story today, all these sanders people basically, its framed at least, the article is framed and the Sanders Campaign is arguing with the framing, but it makes sound like if only Bernie Sanders had done x, why he could have beaten lik hik. To me, i think they got that all wrong. To me the stories of the Sanders Campaign is hes overachieved, not underachieved. Thats exactly right. First off, to ding the guy for being a senator doesnt seem right. But more to the point, if youre looking back, if were looking at history, it is shocking to remember how far off conventional wisdom was from accurate about the Sanders Campaign, and what that says about what we know, what we think we understand about what voters want, particularly democratic voters. If were looking back, the main thing to do is what are the lessons we learned from this . Theres a strong, real democratic constituency for the kinds of message Bernie Sanders has for whoever is going to lead the party. I can remember when this started last year, when sanders was first getting in, the conventional wisdom was he going to finish behind martin omalley. New york, by the way, could be one of the states. Theres polling that shows sanders wib striking distant. This is the home of not only wall street, but occupy, the movement that helped bake in the conversation what Bernie Sanders is talking about. The New York Times has dup a lot of excellent coverage, but one of the things they have been criticized for is not taking Bernie Sanders seriously early on. They did not put on the front page his campaign announcement. Now, i think theres a lot of room for outlets to look back and think what campaigns and reporters should have done differently to understand better what was happening this year. It essentially was a postmortem, hes not dead yet, hasnt dropped. I really felt that it was unfair in the sense that it hit him up for being there in the senate, for actually showing up to his day job, and then it also hit him for not attacking hillary hard which is part of his appeal, he really has been a issues message candidate that really is going to rise above all that. I felt that part of what it was hitting was whats propelled him so far. The subtext really was, why didnt you go negative sooner than you did. We forget, how much did he raise off the i dont care about your emails line at the debate. Thank you for joining us. Chuck is going to be back tomorrow with more mtp daily, and with all due respect starts right now. The donald is calling himself the lone ranger. I am who i am. Im a problem solver. I know how to solve problems. Im killing everybody. I have been tough. Takes gutsz, believe me, folks. It takes guts. I have very powerful hands and large hands. If hes the lone ranger, whos tanto. No more orange. Hiho, halperin, on this, the eve of the wisconsin primary election