Transcripts For MSNBCW MSNBC Live 20140510

Lifestyle is questionable. You remember those comments, allegedly from the mayor of latta, South Carolina. This afternoon a new effort to curb his authority after firing that towns openly gay police chief. Meanwhile here in new york city, some families of 9 11 victims are angry over the decision to move unidentified remains to the site of the attacks. Ill talk to one fdny lieutenant whose brotherinlaw died that day. What about this idea, pot for schools . Well, not pot exactly but tax dollars from pot sales to support schools. Its an idea thats seriously being floated. Well talk to the woman behind that proposal. Good saturday afternoon to you, im craig melvin. Youre watching msnbc. All of that, plus a big idea about how to get farm fresh food to americas biggest city. So much to get to, but lets start here. That developing story out of virginia. Take a look at these dramatic pictures right there showing a hot air balloon in flames. Three people were on board, including a pilot. We just learned about an hour ago that a second body has been found. No names have been released so far. More than 100 people are part of that continuing search effort right now. Theyre looking for the other person who was aboard. The basket and balloon at this point still have not been found. Investigators from the National Transportation safety board and the faa are on the scene just north of richmond, were told. They gave us an update just a few moments ago. Its a very rural area, its very dense, wooded, a lot of undergrowth and it just takes time. Its a very meticulous process when youre doing a grid search. We will stay here until the third occupant is located and of course as we continue to hopefully find the wreckage of the basket and the balloon too. The balloon was one of more than a dozen that took off friday night as part of an event there in virginia. Witnesses say they heard an explosion, then they saw the balloon simply fall out of sight. Well have a live report from the scene in just minutes. Also today, grieving families in nigeria continue to wait for news about the nearly 300 girls abducted from their school. Those girls were kidnapped nearly three weeks ago now. First Lady Michelle obama today joined the course of worldwide disgust. Mrs. Obama devoted her firstever white house weekly address, her firstever solo address, she devoted it to the abduction. This unconscionable act was committed by a terrorist group determined to keep these girls from getting an education. Grown men attempting to snuff out the aspirations of young girls. Outraged nigerians also demonstrated today, and u. S. Military advisers and International Aid workers have arrived to help Nigerian Forces find the girls. Nbcs Stephanie Gosk is live for us in neighboring cameroons capital city. Stephanie, what are we hearing about what the Nigerian Government is doing right now . Hey, craig. It seems some of that pressure, both domestic and international, is having an effect on the Nigerian Government. They announced theyre going to be moving two military divisions up to the north in that region where they believe the girls may be held at this moment. We also know that they have asked for international help. One group of u. S. Military personnel arrived on friday. Another will be traveling over the weekend. They have asked for help also from the u. K. , france, china, all contributing in the search for the girls. Still no word on where they are or how they are doing. Amidst all of that, the violence continues. This group, boko haram, struck again today. They hit a bridge on the border between nigeria and chad, very similar to an attack here in cameroon earlier in the week that killed as many as 30 people. Theres also the abduction of family members of a Police Official in the northern part of this country. A part of this country that has essentially become lawless in recent months. Stephanie, how is it that boko haram has been able to continue moving essentially at will with so much attention on them from all over the world now . Reporter it is pretty remarkable, but you have to know a little bit about the history of Northern Nigeria in recent years to understand it. This group started in the 90s and has entrenched itself in an area that has for the most part been kind of forgotten by the rest of nigeria. The economy is bad, there are no jobs. They have gained force in this region, and now have struck this insurgency, which is about four years old, and has really started in earnest in the last four months. This has been a string of violence. Kidnappings, bombings, they have attacked groups of doctors that have been trying to vaccinate kids against polio. They have attacked a number of schools. And the government has been criticized regularly for not putting the kind of military presence that is needed to control them, and now you see theyre trying to correct that course, sending up these divisions but there will certainly be a lot of people wondering why it took nearly a month to move them up there. Stephanie gosk, thank you. Retired u. S. Army general carter hamm, the general commanded the u. S. Africa command from 2011 to 2013. General, thanks for being with me this afternoon. Thanks, craig. First of all, i dont even know how to phrase this. Ill just ask you, how likely is it at this point that these girls are going to be found alive and brought back home . How likely is it that they have not already been shipped off to neighboring countries . Well, craig, i think it is likely that many have probably been moved outside of the country. Almost certainly they have been dispersed into small groups, perhaps even as individuals. But the key thing is, there is hope and there must remain hope. And until such time as all the girls are accounted for, i think nigeria has a significant responsibility to pursue all possible options to bring them safely home. Im glad that the United States and others have offered and are helping the Nigerian Government. Your former command is going to be part of that american effort to help find these girls. Specifically, what can they do . I think first and foremost, the nigerians probably are asking for intelligence support. The nigerians and the nations neighboring nigeria all have very good and sophisticated human intelligence networks, and im certain that those have been activated and theyre seeking to get all the information they can. But technical intelligence. Overhead surveillance, persistent collection, signals intelligence and the analysis of that all Source Information is something that the United States and others are quite good at and i suspect were probably helping them in that regard. I want to pivot here and talk to you about benghazi. Im sure youre aware of the new panel that was convened this week to dig deeper into what happened the night in 2012 when you were in charge there in africa. I know youve testified. What questions are left to be answered that have not been that have not been answered yet or are there any . I think first and foremost, we should remember that night that four brave americans were killed. For them and for their families, the nation should remain eternally grateful. With regard to the military aspect of the events in benghazi, i think the chairman of the House Armed Services committee probably summarized it best. After many hearings both open and closed, classified and unclassified, a parade of witnesses to include myself and many others, the chairman has concluded that the United States military, given how fast the attack occurred and how quickly it subsided, the time distance that is involved, that the military acted properly. And i think that has been completely investigated and answered. So why another panel . Why another investigation . I cant answer that. You know, obviously coming from a military background and that was the aspect of it that my testimony and meetings with members of congress focused on. Are you optimistic that another investigation is going to shed any new light on the thing . Im optimistic because thats hour form of government. That sounds like a very diplomatic way of saying youre not optimistic that theyre going to find anything new. But its more than that, craig. The oath the oath that each military person takes begins with support and defend the constitution of the United States. This is our process. And whether our personal views agree or disagree, it is the process and thats got to have to move forward. You testified that it was fairly clear from the outset that it was in fact a terror attack. Did you get the support that you needed from washington . Absolutely. Every capability that i asked of through general dempsey, who was the chairman of the joint chiefs of staff and secretary panetta, then secretary of defense, every capability i asked for was provided. Was a military strike by the United States, by our forces, was it possible at that time . It was not, partly because of the time distances involved and partly because of how quickly the attack occurred and then largely subsided. Looking back really quickly, is there anything different that you would have done that night . Two things. I think one of which has occurred. I would have i should have put more effort into expediting the movement of the people from benghazi back to tripoli once the surviving americans were all consolidated and relatively safe havened at a second u. S. Facility in benghazi. The second and more important and longer lasting is that the department of defense has since benghazi stationed more capable Response Forces in the region. Do you think that the issue itself has been politicized since . Thats not for an old soldier to comment upon. I knew that was going to be your answer but i had to ask anyway. General, thank you. Thanks, craig. More whistleblowers are now coming forward as the scandal surrounding wait times at the va as that scandal continues to grow. All of this comes after allegations this week that administrators in phoenix, arizona, kept an offthebooks list to conceal long wait times as some 40 veterans died waiting to get an appointment. But its not just confined to phoenix. Clerks in wyoming and texas have revealed information about problems there as well. Arizona senator john mccain held a town hall meeting with veterans and fair families in phoenix friday, and those folks demanded answers and accountability. It took months. They wouldnt call us back. Finally when they did, the appointments were set out two months in advance. Look, if these allegations are true, if these allegations are true, they are a violation of law, and its not a matter of resignations, its a matter of whether somebody goes to jail or not. Lets head to Jennifer Bjorklund for us. Jennifer, what more do we know about precisely why these clerks were allegedly told to change these waiting times . Reporter craig, its a difficult question but the answer seems to be in the law. The va mandate is a veteran seeking care must be seen within two weeks. They have a 14day window. And an impossible list of waiting. So in this case in cheyenne, wyoming, the whistleblower there said they were instructed to actually change the dates on some of the appointment lists to make everything line up and have no backlog. Here in phoenix, they went as far as to allegedly open up a screen, set an appointment, put all the information in, printout a screen shot of the screen and then delete all the information in those lines. So youre coming for a followup appointment and say, okay, my 14 days are here. Theres no record you were ever here, its gone. You just have the paper in your hand which, you know, isnt worth anything unless its in the system, craig. Jennifer bjorklund from phoenix. Thank you for that update. Russian separatists in Eastern Ukraine are preparing for tomorrows referendum which some leaders in kiev say could be a catastrophe. More from ukraine ahead. Well go live there. Also ahead, funding education by the sale of something that used to be illegal in most places. This is msnbc. E a question, how much money do you think youll need when you retire . Then we gave each person a ribbon to show how many years that amount might last. I was trying to, like, pull it a little further. [ woman ] got me to 70 years old. Im going to have to rethink this thing. Its hard to imagine how much well need for a retirement that could last 30 years or more. So maybe we need to approach things differently, if we want to be ready for a longer retirement. Can help your kids school get extra stuff. Theyre the only cereals with box tops for education. You can raise money for your kids school. Look for this logo. Only on big g cereals. You can make a difference. Every cereal box counts. Improving everything from booking to baggage claim. Were raising the bar on flying and tomorrow well raise it yet again. We cannot let the fans down. Dont worry the United States Postal Service will get it there on time with Priority Mail flat rate shipping. Our priority has always been saving the day. Because our priority. Amazing . Is you the amazing spiderman 2 delivered by the United States Postal Service. Female narrator the mattress price wars are on the mattress price wars are on at sleep train. We challenged the manufacturers to offer even lower prices. Now its posturepedic versus beautyrest with big savings of up to 400 off. Serta icomfort and tempurpedic go headtohead with three years interestfree financing. Plus, free sameday delivery, setup, and removal of your old set. When brands compete, you save. Mattress price wars are on now at sleep train. Your ticket to a better nights sleep welcome back. Lets get you caught up on some of the top headlines this saturday afternoon. We start with this developing story from arkansas which right now is becoming the first state in the south to issue samesex marriage licenses. You are seeing the first couple right there. Friday a judge in arkansas struck down that states voterapproved ban on the unions. The ruling was issued without a stay, but the legality of todays marriages will most surely be in some sort of legal limbo. The Arkansas Attorney general says he plans to appeal fridays ruling, despite, despite his personal support for Marriage Equality. Meanwhile, it is commencement weekend across the country. Louisiana governor bobby jindal made his way to Liberty University today. That Religious School is a wellknown essential stop for any republican even thinking about a run for president. Jindal talked openly about his christian faith. He also criticized socalled elites for waging war on religious liberty. Our religious freedom was won over the course of centuries of persecution and blood, and we should not surrender them without a fight. Make no mistake, the war over religious liberty is the war over free speech. Without the first, theres no such thing as the second. And theres a new man in charge of the l. A. Clippers today. His name is dick parsons. Hes been named the interim ceo. He takes over that embattled team as scandal continues to surround owner Donald Sterling. Parsons is the former chairman of time warner and citigroup. Earlier today here in new york, evidence that the investigation into the september 11th attacks is not over. All of the nearly 8,000 unidentified remains of 9 11 victims were moved from a temporary facility. They are now in a specially built repository at the World Trade Center site in lower manhattan. This plan is not new, but nonetheless its now mired in controversy. The Mayors Office tells us this is not a final resting place and the work to identify the remains will continue on a daily basis, but some families are quite upset that the remains are being housed in the same building as the National September 11th memorial and museum, a museum that charges admission when it opens. Joining me now, his brotherinlaw was in the south to your and his remains have never been found. Lets start with this morning. I know you were there. How did things go . It was just kind of opening up an old wound, one that never really heals. We want to go down and pay our respects to our loved ones as well, but the fact that they are putting them in the basement 70 feet below ground in what is essentially presented as an exhibit of a museum we find very distasteful, extremely offensive and equally disgraceful in the fact that during this whole process, 9 11 family members, the loved ones of those killed on 9 11 have had virtually no input as to the decisionmaking process as to where the human remains will be interred. We called new york mayor bill de blasios office and they gave us a statement. Our administration has engaged the community and 9 11 families continuously since entering office four months ago. This includes talking with and listening to families who have questions about this plan as well as many families who are supportive and comfortable with this plan. Whats your response to that . I have heard that quote and that is just completely untrue. They havent reached out to the families . Not that the groups and families i am associated with. Maybe the ones in support of this plan. But the ones in opposition, which i am part of, none of us have heard from the Mayors Office. We have reached out and would like to meet with the mayor, but we havent had any discussion. Weve had virtually no discussion. When did you first hear about the plan . To house them in the basement . Right. And to actually do it today, the day before mothers day. I did hear house them in the basement, or what we call the basement, 70 feet below ground in a museum and weve been fighting this plan all that time. The fact that they were going to move them today was only revealed about a week ago. Many family members that i spoke to still do not know that it happened today. Still dont know. The notification process was abominable. Whats the next move going to be for you and your groups . Part of the Memorial Museum and the city talking points is that we are averse and against bringing the remains back to ground zero. We are not. We are just against them being 70 what we call disgraceful feet below ground. We want something more akin to a tomb of the unknowns on plaza level, at ground zero level. To me or to us, the remains of the victims are the essential element of 9 11. If trees and water falls can have a place of prominence on the plaza level, surely we believe that the remains should have such a place of prominence as well. All right. Im going to leave it there. Keep us up to date on whats happened, okay . I appreciate it. Lieutenant jim mccaffrey. A note now on a story we found. While it is still true that sticks and stones may break your bones, it is also true that words can in fact hurt you apparently. Theres a new study out and it finds that adolescent girls who are called fat by family and Close Friends are more likely to become overweight or obese as teenagers and young adults. Those findings are part of a decadeslong study on the word fat and its impact on the human psyche. Its being called the other f word. The full story is on our website, msnbc. Com craigmelvin. And this is my son, chris. Im a messy person. I dont like cleaning. I love my son, but he never cleans up. Always leaves a trail of crumbs behind. Youre gonna have a problem with getting a wife. Uh. Yeah, i guess. [ laughs ] this is ridiculous. Christopher glenn [ doorbell rings ] what is that . Swiffer sweep trap. I think i could use this. It picks up everything. I like this. Thats a lot of dirt. Just that easy. Good job, chris. I think a woman will probably come your way. [ both laugh ] afghanistan, in 2009. Orbiting the moon in 1971. [ male announcer ] once its earned, usaa Auto Insurance is often handed down from generation to generation. Because it offers a superior level of protection. And because usaas commitment to serve current and former military members and their families is without equal. Begin your legacy. Get an Auto Insurance quote. Usaa. We know what it means to serve. That would be my daughter hi dad. Shes a dietitian. And back when i wasnt eating right, she got me drinking boost. Its got a great taste, and it helps give me the nutrition i was missing. Helping me stay more like me. [ female announcer ] boost complete nutritional drink has 26 essential vitamins and minerals, including calcium and vitamin d to support strong bones and 10 grams of protein to help maintain muscle. All with a delicious taste. Grandpa [ female announcer ] stay strong, stay active with boost. Lets get to an update on an exclusive interview we first shared with you here last month. It has to do with crystal moore. Youll remember she was the police chief of latta, South Carolina. That was until she was abruptly fired by that towns new mayor. Moore and her supporters say she was let go because she was openly gay. The mayor says this is a personnel issue and has nothing to do with sexual orientation. The story gained traction when a story was on television with him making comments. The town councilman said he recorded it without the mayors permission. Take a listen. I would much rather have, and i will say this to anybodys face, i would much rather have somebody who drank and drank too much taking care of my child than i had somebody whose lifestyle is questionable around children, because that aint the damn way that its supposed to be. Mayor bullard has told us that he does not know if thats actually his voice on the tape. Weve invited the mayor to appear several times and hes declined. Emailing us this week, quote, if miss moore will give the town a release for us to speak of her situation, i will be glad to discuss the matter with you. If miss moore has nothing to hide, she should be willing to sign such a release. Crystal moore says the mayor is free to talk. Meanwhile, people in latta are set to vote next month on whether to take away some of the mayors power. Crystal moore joins me from columbia, South Carolina, along with the latta town councilman who made the recording you just heard. Crystal, when we last spoke you had just been fired and were trying to figure out your next move. Where does your situation stand right now . I am still waiting to hear. We did ask for a public hearing through my attorney, so just like he says, i have nothing to hide. There is no such release, as he keeps telling people, so i decided to ask for a public hearing. That will be up to him. Hopefully he will grand me that open and public hearing and its going to be may 19th at 1 00. So this release stuff is just bull, is that what youre saying . Yes. There is no such paperwork to be released. He gave me the seven bogus reprimands the day that i was fired. All i did was ask to speak to my attorney, and on the third time when i told him i needed to speak to the attorney, he told me i was no longer needed, to turn in my badge, gun and keys. Jared, i want to talk to you a minute here about this recording. Set the scene for us. Weve heard the tapes now a number of times. When was this . Where were you . What were you talking about . And why did you record the conversation . Yes, sir. We had had a conversation earlier in the day too much mayor bullard had been less than forthcoming and truthful to myself and another councilman. And after being told pretty much a story as to what actually transpired. I decided any time i had runins with the mayor to protect myself i would record him. That way if he ever came back and said i didnt say anything, i can always come back and say, yes, this is what i said or this isnt what i said and heres the proof. That particular conversation was made after a Council Meeting in which we were discussing another employees driving history, and it happened to involve alcohol and that particular comment was made in reference to the alcohol situation. So youve been recording the mayor youve been recording him for a while, just all of your interactions with him . Yes, sir. To this day i still record all my interactions with the mayor. So you have other recordings as well . Yes, sir. Other recordings where the mayor says things like this . Not quite as blatant. He does make a comment in one conversation when hes talking about the Recreation Department of latta. He says that the rednecks of latta are upset with him because he hired a young, educated black male and he goes on to say that the problem in latta is so evident that even helen keller and ray charles could see the problem. I think that just further goes to show that he has issues with people of difference than he is. Crystal, again, the mayor has said that you were fired because of seven demerits that you got in one day. Walk us through again what those demerits were and why you insist theyre bogus. Just for several of them, ive done nothing but my job. One of them was that i did a background check illegally. Being in the supervisor side of it, i actually have to run background checks for the Police Department when im hiring for the Police Department. Thats covered by our town policy. He has accused me of running a background check on the young man, the recreation director, but that was by my officer at the time after he was arrested, after the rec director was arrested its protocol for a background history to be ran for the judge to set his bond. But hes accusing me of running his criminal history. Have you whats the end game for you here, crystal . Do you want your job back in latta or are you over that now . No, sir, i want my job back. Ive done nothing wrong. All ive done is what the law tells me. I have policies and procedures and i also have recordings, because we have been having this problem with the mayor telling different untruths basically. You have recordings of what . What do you have recordings of . Just five days and seven days before he fired me, i have him stating that ive done a wonderful job. That the rumors behind me, theres no way hes going to fire me, he stands behind me for the job ive done, and then all of a sudden why dont you release these tapes . Thats why we want a public hearing so everybody will see those tapes on the 19th at my public hearing. Really quickly, jarett, we understand the Council Voted on a move to ban the mayor from appointing another chief for 60 days. What more does the council hope to do . Actually hes actually questioning whether that emergency ordinance is even valid. He doesnt understand the fact that his decision to hire another chief in such a short time, if the referendum does in fact pass june 24th, the council has voted and given chief moore their confidence and she will get her job back if Everything Else is as it is today and we dont want him to hastily hire someone else and put someone else in a position where were going to have to terminate their employment. So hes actually questioning the emergency ordinance, but to date it still stands. And so until the referendum takes place june 24th, theres not too much more that the council can do under our Mayor Council form of government. Crystal moore, councilman taylor, thanks for your time. Again, we should note that we have invited mayor bullard to come on this show. We hope that he accepts our invitation soon. Coming up, heres an idea being floated in South Carolina. Legalizing pot to fund schools. Well talk to the local official there who is pushing that plan. Stay with us. [ female announcer ] crest presents crest 3d White Whitestrips vs. A whitening pen. I feel like im going to miss a spot. I think you actually might have. I feel like my lips are going to, like, wash it off. These fit nicely. Wait, it says to use up to four times a day . Oh, gosh. Im not going to do that. [ female announcer ] crest 3d White Whitestrips adhere to your teeth evenly and safely remove stains below the enamel surface for professional level results that last up to 12 months. This says it removes 14 years of stains. It doesnt tell me how many stains it removes. [ female announcer ] crest 3d White Whitestrips. The way to whiten. So, whatd you think of the house . Did you see the School Rating . Oh, youre right. Hey, babe, i got to go. Bye, daddy. Have a good day at school, okay . [ man ] but what about when my parents visit . Okay. Just love this one. Its next to a park. [ man ] i love it. I love it, too. Heres your new house. Daddy [ male announcer ] youre not just looking for a house. Youre looking for a place for your life to happen. Zillow. An update on that developing story in virginia. We now know that two of the three people on board a hot air balloon were killed when it caught fire and crashed. The difficult search continues right now for the third person who was on board. Nbcs luke russert joins me live now from virginia just north of richmond. Luke, at this point what do we know about where those search efforts stand . Reporter well, the search efforts are ongoing as we speak, craig, and its a massive search operation. Theres over 100 personnel involved as well as over 20 state troopers and the civil air patrol. They also have canine units theyre deploying a sort of grid method where a lot of people walk and they hope to come upon the remains of the last individual or perhaps some debris of the wreckage. It started last night. They were not able to have air support last night because of the weather. That cleared up this morning and the daylight has been really helpful. They found two out of the three victims over the last 12 hours, but interestingly enough, craig, were starting to get varying reports about who the victims may have been. Nothing has been confirmed as of yet, but the community now has sort of shifted from the search to undergoing a mourning period, if you will. Luke, what more do we know . I know this hot air balloon was part of a larger display last night. What else do we know about what happened last night . So right behind me at this meadow farm it was to be a sort of hot air balloon festival. It was a threeday event. There was over 20 hot balloons, a lot of enthusiasts were coming here to practice their hobby. Last night about 13 balloons went up for a little happy hour sale and three of them were supposed to come down. Two of them landed okay. Upon landing, this one that ended up exploding actually ruptured a 4 lipower line. That started a fire on board. That fire caused an explosion. Horrific things played out. One person on board the basket shouted oh, my god, im going to die. When that happened, the balloon separated from the basket. The balloon went flying one way, the basket fell. Theyre trying to find both of those right now. And they could have incinerated because the fire was so strong after hitting that electrical wire. All right. Nbcs luke russert for us. Keep us posted. Reporter will do. Take care. Lets pivot to the crisis in ukraine n a matter of hours, people in ukraines Eastern Region will head to the polls to vote on whether to declare its sovereignty. The vote by prorussian separatists would make the Eastern Region independent from the government in kiev. The referendum follows deadly violence friday. At least seven people were killed in clashes in maripol. Richard engel is monitoring all of this for us from donetsk, ukraine. Do we know what effect yesterdays violence will have on tomorrows vote . Reporter i think its also important to understand, craig, this is not a normal vote. The Ukrainian Government does not recognize this vote. The u. S. Doesnt recognize it. Europe doesnt recognize it. The only people who will actually accept the legitimacy of this referendum will be certain separatists here in Eastern Ukraine and very likely moscow. So this is not a normal election. There are no international monitors here. There are no official polling stations. It is an ad hoc referendum that is being held by a fairly large number of separatists here in order to move their case that the government in kiev no longer represents them. That is a hostile government and in their opinion it is a fascist, nazi government. The violence that has been continuing here against these russian separatists from the government in kiev only reinforces their case. Yesterday in mariopol, a city just south of here, the government in kiev launched a series of military operations to drive out russian separatists. They had taken over a police station. The soldiers, the ukrainian soldiers, were ultimately successful in dislodging these russian separatists. But in the process of this military operation, they killed, the estimates are anywhere between 7 and 20 people, turned the downtown into a war zone and alienated a lot of people. So in this climate of fear and tension, the separatists are holding this referendum tomorrow. And we know at this point that russias president , Vladimir Putin, that he pushed these prorussian separatists to postpone the vote and they decided not to do that. What are russias calculations here, what are putins calculations . Reporter i wish i knew what putins calculations were. Ive spoken with some u. S. Government officials and they are saying the same thing. Because Vladimir Putin did call on the separatists who are prorussian separatists here to postpone the referendureferendu. The separatists thought about it for about 12 hours and said, no, were going to go ahead and hold the referendum. Then yesterday when putin visited crimea, he seemed to encourage the referendum, calling out all those who love russia to rejoin with the motherland. What putins calculations seem to be is he wants to revive the glory of the soviet union. Hes already annexed crimea and seems to be putting down a lot of markers and winning a lot of influence here in Eastern Ukraine. Nbcs Richard Engel for us, live on the ground in donetsk, ukraine. Richard, thank you, as always. Up next, farming in the city and feeding the needy in the process. It is todays big idea. Thoutful combinations, artfully prepared. Fancy feast elegant medleys. Inspired dishes like primavera, florentine and tuscany. Fancy feast. A medley of love, served daily. Fame, makes a man take things over fame, lets him loose, hard to swallow fame, puts you there where things are hollow the evolution of luxury continues. The next generation 2015 escalade. Fame i got more advice than i knew what to do with. What i needed was information i could trust on how to take care of me and my baby. Luckily, unitedhealthcare has a Simple Program that helps moms stay on track with their doctors and get the right care and guidancebefore and after the baby is born. Simple is good right now. anncr vo innovations that work for you. Thats health in numbers. Unitedhealthcare. When you didnt dread when youbedtime becausenner with anticipaof heartburn. Itation. When damage to your esophagus caused by acid reflux disease wasnt always on your mind. Thats when you knew nexium was the Prescription Medication for you. Because for over a decade nexium has provided many just like you with 24hour relief from heartburn and helped heal acidrelated erosions in the lining of the esophagus. And now the prescription nexium you know can be delivered directly to your door with nexium direct. Talk to your doctor to see if nexium is right for you. There is risk of bone fracture and low magnesium levels. Side effects may include headache, abdominal pain, and diarrhea. If you have persistent diarrhea, contact your doctor right away. Other serious stomach conditions may exist. Avoid if you take clopidogrel. For 24 hour support, automatic refills, and free home delivery, enroll at purplepill. Com. Its the nexium you know, now delivered. [ male announcer ] its one of the most Amazing Things we build and it doesnt even fly. We build it in classrooms and exhibit halls, mentoring tomorrows innovators. We build it raising roofs, preserving habitats and serving americas veterans. Every day, thousands of boeing volunteers help make their communities the best they can be. Building Something Better for all of us. Check in out, a food pantry that grows its own food with no sunlight or soil. Its todays big idea. A nonprofit in brooklyn, new york, runs it and provides healthy food for those who need it with its own hydroponic farm. Its helped them grow spinach, lettuce, all within four walls. Caitlin brazil is the president of strategic partnerships. Why this technique . Why did you decide to try this . Thanks for having us. You know, weve been working 37 years to figure out ways to alleviate poverty. It turns out hydro ponic is an efficient way to grow it. We are growing 4,000 heads of lettuce with staff and volunteers, many of whom have never set foot on a traditional farm. And whats the advantage to this method . Well, its cheap, its clean, its easy to do year round, its something that can really engage our community. So we have High School Students who are managing the farm, they built the farm themselves. Theyre in there every day checking water levels, making sure the ph is okay. These 18, 19yearold kids are looking at vegetables like they are their very own babies. I would imagine its also for a food pantry, probably a lot easier to grow your own food instead of relying on others to donate. Absolutely. I mean be do both. We get generous donations and we couldnt possibly support everything we need. We reach 5,000 people a month, so our garden is not hitting it all. And of course at first our customers were a little skeptical on what they were calling science food. But now people embrace it. Theyre getting the freshest produce in brooklyn. Is this something that you think can go natural or have you seen it start to happen nationally . Absolutely. Were not even the only hydroponic farm in brookbrookly but youre the only hydroponin food pantry. We are. And were talking about the size of a large walkin closet that produces 4,000 heads of lettuce every year. Its a terrific way to use the space weve got and the incredible talent and enthusiasm of our community. We sent our producer over there and he was quite impressed at the operation. Good for you guys. Thanks for stopping by to tell us a little more about it. Its todays big idea. Thank you so much. And do you have a big idea thats making a difference . You can let us know on twitter. You can use the whatsthebigidea. Obvious transition here, legalizing pot to pay for school books. Im kidding, im kidding. Thats the idea of one local official in South Carolina. Well go back to the palmetto state on the other side of this break. Shes going to join us live. Of s can help your kids school get extra stuff. Theyre the only cereals with box tops for education. You can raise money for your kids school. Look for this logo. Only on big g cereals. You can make a difference. Every cereal box counts. Improving everything from booking to baggage claim. Were raising the bar on flying and tomorrow well raise it yet again. So, whatd you think of the house . Did you see the School Rating . Oh, youre right. Hey, babe, i got to go. Bye, daddy. Have a good day at school, okay . [ man ] but what about when my parents visit . Okay. Just love this one. Its next to a park. [ man ] i love it. I love it, too. Heres your new house. Daddy [ male announcer ] youre not just looking for a house. Youre looking for a place for your life to happen. Zillow. Youre lookin for a place for your life to happen. No matter what kind of business you own, at t Business Experts can help keep it running. Seamlessly. So you can get back to what you love. When everyone and everything works together, business just sings. There is a blunt new proposal by one leader in South Carolina for how to pay for education. Sheila gallagher is a former president of the state education association. She is now running for state superintendent of education and she wants to get more green in the classrooms by legalizing green. It isnt about getting high, its good investing 188 million every year until we have the best schools in the nation. As you might imagine, this is creating quite the buzz in the palmetto state of t. Here now from South Carolina, sheila gallagher. As we mentioned, candidate for state superintendent of education. Sheila, good to see you. Quite simply, how did you come up with this idea . It started when we noticed how much money colorado and the state of washington was making once they legalized it. Do you and of course i go ahead. Our state house then again underfunded the public schools, so the state teachers union, which you used to head, applauded your creativity but said, quote, the scea remains confident that additional Revenue Streams for education can be identified perhaps through policies to reduce unnecessary Tax Exemptions to businesses locating here or to increase the quantity of taxable property. Whats your response to that . Well, weve had that idea out there. You know, we had the house of representatives and the senate pass the whole Tax Exemption with act 388 and weve been trying to get rid of that when they swapped property tax and sales tax. So weve been trying these ideas and they havent worked. So it would be good to just legalize marijuana, decriminalize it, add some money that way, and lets go ahead and put money into our public schools. Governor nikki haley, governor of South Carolina, has proposed roughly 175 in new education spending. The state legislature is working on a budget right now. Are there problems in education in that state and others . Are they really something you can throw money at or do we really need to take a good, hard look at whats going on inside our classrooms and take a look at our per pupil spending right now and how that money is being allocated . I think its important to look at whats going on in school. I i think the public would be surprised the bang theyre getting for their buck. But the whole issue does come around to resources. Youve got to make smaller class sizes, especially in prek through third grade. And you need our educational support persons more to be in the classroom with our teachers. And so when youre talking about better compensation for our teachers and our educational support persons, putting in more resourc resources, expanding our broadband here in South Carolina, you are talking about muchneeded resources. State funding for the antiprogram dare ended in 2003. Theres an interesting juxtaposition. On one hand youve got kids who are taught starting at a very early age that pot is dangerous. How do you justify that while telling them its dangerous but good enough to pay for your education. Its not just fiction. We know drugs are out there. One of the things you want to do is stop putting kids in jail just because they were smoking pot. And i dont mean kids, i mean young people. So you teach them exactly what dare is supposed to be teaching them, that drugs are wrong, what happens to their bodies physically, emotionally. We continue with that program but know that it still happens, just like with alcohol. Your basis is the same. If you abuse it, youre in trouble. Sheila gallagher, well leave it there. Running for South Carolina superintendent of education. Sheila, thank you. Thank you, craig. Good to see you. Good to see you. Up next, the uproar over alleged mismanagement at va hospitals all over this country. Well hear from the person who blew the whistle on the scandal. Plus theres a new man taking the top spot of the l. A. Clippers. What will that mean for embattled Donald Sterling . This is msnbc. Awesome, amazing, thats epic, bro. Whatever happened to good . Good is choosing not to overshoot the moon, but to land right on it. Good is maxwell house. Good to the last drop constipated . Yea dulcolax tablets can cause cramps but not phillips. It has magnesium and works more naturally than stimulant laxatives. For gentle cramp free relief of occasional constipation that works mmm mmm live the regular life. Well be here at lifelock doing our thing you do your connect to public wifi thing protecting you in ways your Credit Card Company alone cant. Get lifelock protection and live life free. Woman welcome to learning. Spanish in the car. C on. Passenger youve got to be kidding me. Driver this is good. Woman vamanos. Driver passenger vamanos. Woman gracias. Driver passenger gracias. Passenger trece horas en el carro sin parar y no traes musica. Driver mira entra y comprame unas papitas. Vo get up to 795 miles per tank in the tdi clean diesel. The volkswagen passat. Recipient of the j. D. Power appeal award, two years in a row. In these girls, barack and i see our own daughters. We see their hopes and their dreams, and we can only imagine the anguish their parents are feeling right now. The first lady joins the millions calling for the release of nearly 300 school girls kidnapped in nigeria. Meanwhile in ukraine, high tension as a top official Warns Russian separatists in the eastern half of his country they would be courting catastrophe if they voted yes in tomorrows referendum. People do think that we are the anomaly and that, you know, every shooter in the United States is a 50yearold white guy. Women shouldnt have a gun, they dont know how to use it, theyre just going to hurt somebody. Its not true at all. Women are a big force in the antigun movement now, but the nra and others are banking that they may be the key to their cause. This is about judgment. Should we, should we as a country have a commander in chief who didnt provide Adequate Security in libya. My opinion is that Hillary Clinton has precluded herself from ever being considered for that position. So how much of a liability will the benghazi controversy be for Hillary Clinton and will she be subpoenaed by that newly formed house committee. The man who signs marriage licenses in North Carolina says he will be signing them for samesex couples. Ill talk to him ahead. And king of pop has a new album out nearly five years after his death. Well get a debut days before its release. Im craig melvin. You are watching msnbc. We start with more outrage coming from veterans and their families over those wait times at va hospitals and big claims of a coverup. Allegations surfaced earlier this week about secret efforts to falsely make va patient waiting times appear shorter. Now more whistle blowers are coming forward. Kelly odonnell starts us off with the very latest. Are you going to do whats right for the veterans, sir . Reporter veterans and their families are demanding answers and accountability. It took months for them to see him. They wouldnt call us back. Reporter this widening scandal first surfaced at the Phoenix Veterans Administration hospital. With allegations that records were secretly altered to show shorter waiting times for patient appointments to meet va standards. We were betrayed. Myself, other veterans. Reporter senator john mccain, who held a town hall meeting on the controversy friday, said this could lead to criminal charges. This is the first time ive ever seen an outright what apparently, allegedly is an outright coverup. Reporter going beyond arizona, a texas va medical clerk, brian turner, tells nbc news that clerks in the san antonio and austin offices were coached to change numbers and dates to erase wait times of weeks or months. If you had a longer time frame than the 14day window, you would receive a report and they would tell you, you need to change this. Reporter va officials said turners claims were not substantiated. Turning to wyoming. Nbc news obtained an email where a va staffer described the practice of altering dates, writing, yes, it is gaming the system a bit, but you have to know the rules of the game you are playing. Adding, the front office gets very upset when wait times go past 14 days. Veterans Affairs Secretary Eric Shinseki ordered an investigation of the wyoming office and put an employee on leave. Im very disappointed in the evidence that we have so far. Its tragic and its unacceptable. That was Kelly Odonnell reporting there. We are also watching new developments this afternoon in nigeria. Overwhelming emotions have gripped the families of the nearly 300 girls who were abducted from a school in the northern part of that country three weeks ago now. Back here, first Lady Michelle obama spoke today on behalf of the global concern for the missing victims as she took her husbands place to deliver the white house weekly address. This was her first solo address. Listen. Like millions of people across the globe, my husband and i are outraged and heart broken over the kidnapping of more than 200 nigerian girls from their School Dormitory in the middle of the night. The first lady is also among the hundreds of thousands who have taken to twitter with the hash tag bringbackourgirls to bring global pressure to bear on the kidnappers. Also ukraines acting president is warning against selfdestruction on the eve of a referendum in two eastern cities to declare that regions sovereignty. Tomorrows vote by prorussian separatists would make the Eastern Region independent from the central Ukrainian Government in kiev. But only prorussian separatists in moscow will accept the results of that, quote, referendum. The separatists have attacked and seized government buildings and clashed with ukrainian troops. It comes after violence grips the region. I want to bring in reuters investigative journalist david rhode, also a contributing editor to the atlantic. We heard from Richard Engel just a few moments ago in donetsk and his contention is basically tomorrows vote, its a sham. How much of a sham is it . No one even knows what this vote means. Its similar to the referendum in crimea. The ballot says do you support Self Determination for donetsk. Does that mean independence, does that mean youre joining ukraine, does that mean youre joining russia . Theres a lot of frightened residents that are stuck between the Ukrainian Army and the prorussian militia and it sounds chaotic. The vote is largely symbolic . Yes. Its essentially an effort to show they do have support in these two regions, the separatists. The big question is what happens in two weeks. Thats when theres supposed to be this ukrainian president ial election. Given the fighting, its a very dangerous situation. Earlier this week russias president , Vladimir Putin, called on these prorussian separatists to postpone tomorrows vote. Apparently they thought about it shortly and decided, no, were not going to do that. Is putin losing control now over the separatists . Its unclear. Some people say he just said that to try to stop germany and stop harsher economic sanctions. If he hasnt already, hes going to lose control of these militias. When you have these situations, it reminds me of yugoslavia. Each side is calling the other terrorists and fascists. This is not good, this is approaching civil war. Putin needs to be careful about what forces hes unleashed here. How do you think tomorrows vote will play out . No one will know what the vote is and the people organizing it says its 100 for selfdetermination and who knows what that means. Thank you for your insight, sir. Shifting now to los angeles where its the first full day of a muchneeded new direction for the embattled los angeles clippers. Former citigroup and time warner chief executive dick parsons is taking over the team as interim ceo amid the scandal of owner Donald Sterling. Earlier this week the celebrity website radaronline published what it says is a new audio recording of sterling. Nbc has not independently authenticated this recording. Heres a little bit of it, though. Im talking to a girl. Im trying to have sex with her. Im trying to play with her. What you know, if you were trying to have sex with a girl and youre talking to her privately and you dont think anybodys there, you may saying in the world. I know im wrong, what i said was wrong, but i never thought the private conversation would go anywhere. Out to the public. I didnt want her to bring anybody to my games because i was jealous. I mean, im being honest. And the news gets worse for the clippers. They lost their playoff game last night to oklahoma city. Theyre down 21 right now in that series. Rob from nbc Sports Radio Network is here. Aultz good to see you, thanks for stopping by. First of all, lets start with dick parsons. What does this appointment of parsons as ceo mean . Well, it just gives the clippers a chance to turn the page. There was really no one in l. A. Running that Organization Day to day. The previous ceo, a guy named andy rosier took a leave of absence after sterling was banned for life because he was very closely tied to sterling. He had said some things defending sterling so he was obviously not the guy. The nba needed someone with great credentials. Im sure they wanted someone who was africanamerican. Thats certainly a plus as well. They certainly have a great person to see the organization through whats going to be i think a long period of instability while this ownership situation gets sorted out. There are some who are already saying heres parsons, a guy whos no stranger to some scandal himself. Former chairman of time warner and citigroup. He was one of the guys hauled in to testify before congress back in 2008 along with other execs to defend his big wall street salary during the height of the mortgage crisis. Is he the best choice . I think hes an impeccable choice, to be honest. Yes, he was a banking executive during a period of time when banking executives were not very popular in this country. That arguably continues to this day. But, you know, hes got experience as a ceo of a major media organization. That company, by the way, time warner, owned the Atlanta Braves Baseball Club during the time, part of the time that he was ceo so he has some background with sports but most importantly hes just a guy with a great deal of credibility around this country as a manager, as a ceo, and also a good thing for the nba, not someone whos going to want that job for the long term. Hes not looking to be sports executive long term, so hell take this. When the job is done, hell leave. Lets get back to Donald Sterling for a moment and this new audio. A man identified as sterling basically says that hes not a racist and hes just a jealous lover. Is there any amount of damage control at this point that can save Donald Sterling . Wouldnt you just stop talking on the phone if you were him at this point . You should always assume youre being taped. Unless youve got the place completely, you know, shaken down to know theres no recording, just keep your mouth shut if youre Donald Sterling. But listen, theres nothing he can say at this point thats going to fix anything or change anything. The damage is done. The pr damage to the nba, the loss of sponsors, the general nightmare that this has been for the Clippers Organization and the nba cant be put back in the bottle. Now the question is only about his legal position as owner and how hard he and his wife, shelly, are going to fight to try to keep control of that team. Real quickly before i let you go, the nfl draft in its third and final day now. A lot of folks looking to see if michael sam gets drafted. If he does, he becomes the first openly gay player in the league. At last check that had not happened. It would seem as if the nfl is in a tough spot here. If michael sam doesnt get drafted, here youve got an allamerican defensive player, if that doesnt happen, there are going to be a lot of folks who dont follow sports closely who will say, well, he wasnt picked because hes gay. Listen, im sure that Roger Goodell would like to see michael sam drafted this weekend. Theres still plenty of time for that to happen. It it doesnt happen, he can still catch on as a free agent. You see a lot of guys undrafted go on to sign with teams and be successful. His stock dropped a little bit after the nfl combine. He did not have a great performance at the combine, but theres still lots of opportunity for him to catch on with an nfl team. Sounds like youre certain that hes going to play for an nfl team . I think hell at least get a good shot at playing, either as a drafted player or free agent. Someone will give him a shot, i think so. Rob, always good to see you, sir. Thank you. Pleasure. See you later. Earlier today, first Lady Michelle obama gave the commencement address at dillard university, one of americas historically black colleges and universities. Some of those schools are having trouble with funding and some of the problems are tied directly to the government. Dillards president will talk to me about that straight ahead. First, the National Rifle association and others are encouraging women to take up arms as a way to protect their kids. Ill talk to one prominent gun rights activist and well also talk about why she got my twitter feed blown up today. Next. Whats a powerful way to cut through everyday greasy messes . [ male announcer ] sponges take your mark. [ female announcer ] one drop of ultra dawn has twice the everyday grease cleaning ingredients of one drop of the leading nonconcentrated brand. [ crowd cheering ]. To clean 2x more greasy dishes. Dawn does more. So its not a chore. So, whatd you think of the house . Did you see the School Rating . Oh, youre right. Hey, babe, i got to go. Bye, daddy. Have a good day at school, okay . [ man ] but what about when my parents visit . Okay. Just love this one. Its next to a park. [ man ] i love it. I love it, too. Heres your new house. Daddy [ male announcer ] youre not just looking for a house. Youre looking for a place for your life to happen. Zillow. Youre look ng for a place for your life to happen. vo oh. My. Tongue. Finally. announcer allnew friskies saucesations. A taste experience like no other. In cheesy, creamy, homestyle, or garden sauce. Friskies. Feed the senses. Female narrator the mattress price wars are on the mattress price wars are on at sleep train. We challenged the manufacturers to offer even lower prices. Now its posturepedic versus beautyrest with big savings of up to 400 off. Serta icomfort and tempurpedic go headtohead with three years interestfree financing. Plus, free sameday delivery, setup, and removal of your old set. When brands compete, you save. Mattress price wars are on now at sleep train. Your ticket to a better nights sleep we are getting a live update now from the National Transportation safety board on that deadly hot air balloon accident in virginia. Lets listen in. Again, the aircraft went down last night in rural virginia. So far two of the three bodies have been recovered. The search for the third person continues. At the ntsb website which is www. Ntsb. Gov. That report will be released within ten days. Then within a year, a factual report will be released and after that the fivemember safety board will determine a probable cause that will be released a few months later. At this time i have a few minutes for questions, so lets start with anybody. Is there any indication [ inaudible ] thats part of the environment section that well be investigating. Well be looking into that. I pulled the data but didnt get a chance to examine it but i am looking into it. Do we know when this balloon was last inspected and also have you looked into the pilots record . Thats a great question. The maintenance records of the balloon have not been recovered yet but we are looking for them. We will try and obtain that evidence and, again, we will examine it. As for the pilot records, the same thing. Have not been obtained yet but well look into them once we get them. Any other questions . Can you repeat that number again. The Registration Number . It is november 30 we are going to monitor this news conference. Well continue to listen in and pass along any new developments if we get an update on the investigation into precisely what happened to that hot air balloon that went down last night in rural virginia just north of richmond. It sounds like the search is going to continue for the third person. Turning now, advocates for stronger gun regulations have long focused on women to help make their point on gun safety. Well funded groups like moms demand action and every town for gun safety have held demonstrations for gun law reform across the country, but nra is fighting back to win the hearts of women gun owners and to convince a new generation of women that its okay to own a firearm. Linda elliott is the National Spokesperson for one million moms against gun control. She joins me live now. You founded the group, i understand, linda, you founded it shortly after the antigun Violence Group moms demand action was formed. How did a gun Regulation Group inspire you to start your regulation . Im just a board member, but im very proud to be friends with the founder. Her name is heather. She founded the group, organization because she was upset that moms demand action was speaking to every mother. Not for her. Its okay to be a mom and own a gun and we just want to have the voice and the opportunity to say so and encourage other women as well. So the group itself was created in direct response to moms demand action . Yes, sir. Women gun owners are still fairly a distinct minority in this country. Just about 12 of gun owners are women, according to a 2013 pew study. Why do you think there are so few gun owners in this country . You know, with what i do, ive been all over colorado with the work that i do for the organization, and a lot of it is intimidation. Theres the fact that there are so many women that believe that you cant be a mom and own a firearm because that automatically makes you a bad mom, and then theres also the fact that were so new. We dont want to embarrass ourselves. We dont want to feel uncomfortable and to take the step to get out to the range and actually fire a firearm if you havent been around them. Its a big task to undertake and that is what keeps so many women from having the courage to do so. Advocates of stronger gun regulations point to some sobering statistics. The centers for Disease Control finds that firearm homicides and firearm suicides are the second and fourth leading causes of death among young people between the ages of 15 and 24. Firearm violence ninth leading cause of death for infants between 1 and 4. The Childrens Defense Fund found more than half of young people who committed suicide in this country with a gun got it from their house and it was usually a parents gun. How do you answer critics who say that the home is a safer place without guns . It needs to start with firearm safety, it is paramount. And i believe it always gets compared to cars, even though cars have nothing to do with your amendments. But everyone should know how to drive a stick shift even if you have an automatic car. Even if you dont want to have a gun or own a gun or be around a gun, everybody should know how to safely handle a firearm without harming yourself or anyone else around you. But the difference is the difference is i dont know how to drive stick. That doesnt mean im going to necessarily go out and kill myself. If someone doesnt know how to operate a firearm properly or keep it locked up safely, then theres a child in the house that could get ahold of the gun and accidentally kill himself or someone else. It seems like that might be not a good comparison. I have a 3yearold son and he knows not to touch any firearms. He knows its for mom and dad and hes not to touch them. If a 3yearold can learn, id think anyone can learn. Moms demand action have objected to some tweets that you sent. Im sure youre familiar with this. One, during the murder trial over the death of 17yearold jordan davis where you tweeted a response to moms and to lucy mcbeth, the victims mother in the case, saying stand your ground laws save lives. Then you tweeted to the coalition to stop gun violence calling them idiots. Is it appropriate to confront victims and victims groups with rhetoric like that . Is that helpful . Probably not the most. Since then we have been a little stricter on how we represent ourselves and that was back when we were first founded, first figuring this out. You know, were grassroots. We dont have a millionaire funding us, so were im a housewife. Im a stayathome mom and were learning. So, no, it probably wasnt the best way to handle it, but at the same time it comes to a point where you have to stand up for what you believe in. That sounded almost like an apology. Just about. Really quickly before i let you get out of here, my friend and colleague, chris hayes, did some reporting this week on smart guns. A maryland Gun Store Owner last week was forced to drop plans to sell these socalled smart guns after he got Death Threats from gun rights advocates. Smart guns, these are the guns that contain electronics that prevent them from being fired by someone whos not authorized to fire the gun. Why so much opposition to smart guns . For me its just anything can malfunction. A firearm is a tool, just like anything else. And it already has enough instances where it can make it malfunction. Why add in the possibility of an electronic malfunction. Thats how i personally feel about it. To me its you cant legislate morality, why does a firearm owner need to have a smart gun to own a gun. Linda elliott, one million moms against gun control. Linda, thank you for your time. Thank you. Still to come, how an uncontested election could effectively make samesex marriage legal in North Carolina. Its a crazy story. Well bring it to you right after this. Rely good chocolate shakes. growls man thats a good look for you. woman that was fun. man yeah. man let me help you out with the. woman . Oh no, i got it. man you sure . woman just pop the trunk. man vo i may not know where the road will lead, but. Im sure my subaru will get me there. announcer love. Its what makes a subaru, a subaru. How did i know . Well, i didnt really. See, i figured low testosterone would decrease my sex drive. But when i started losing energy and became moody. Thats when i had an honest conversation with my doctor. We discussed all the symptoms. Then he gave me some blood tests. Showed it was low t. Thats it. It was a number not just me. [ male announcer ] today, men with low t have androgel 1. 62 testosterone gel. The 1 prescribed topical testosterone replacement therapy, increases testosterone when used daily. Women and children should avoid contact with application sites. Discontinue androgel and call your doctor if you see unexpected signs of early puberty in a child, or signs in a woman, which may include changes in body hair or a large increase in acne, possibly due to accidental exposure. Men with Breast Cancer or who have or might have prostate cancer, and women who are or may become pregnant or are breastfeeding, should not use androgel. Serious side effects include worsening of an enlarged prostate, possible increased risk of prostate cancer, lower sperm count, swelling of ankles, feet, or body, enlarged or painful breasts, problems breathing during sleep, and blood clots in the legs. Tell your doctor about your medical conditions and medications, especially insulin, corticosteroids, or medicines to decrease blood clotting. So. What do men do when a numbers too low . Turn it up [ male announcer ] in a clinical study, over 80 of treated men had their t levels restored to normal. Talk to your doctor about all your symptoms. Get the blood tests. Change your number. Turn it up. Androgel 1. 62 . We just got an update on that developing story in virginia. The ntsb says they are still searching for the third person who was onboard a hot air balloon that went down in virginia last night. Two bodies have been recovered so far. The basket and the balloon itself have not been found just yet. Were going to keep you updated on any new developments there in virginia. Up next, though, well talk to the president of the historically black university where the first lady spoke today. Later, the king of pop is back with some new songs, never heard before. The inside scoop from Rolling Stone later. mother vo when i was pregnant. I got more advice than i knew what to do with. What i needed was information i could trust on how to take care of me and my baby. Luckily, unitedhealthcare has a Simple Program that helps moms stay on track with their doctors and get the right care and guidancebefore and after the baby is born. Simple is good right now. anncr vo innovations that work for you. Thats health in numbers. Unitedhealthcare. Welcome back. History is being made today in the south. Samesex marriages started earlier today in arkansas. Friday a judge there struck down that states voterapproved ban on the unions. The ruling was put into effect immediately, but couples are not claiming an allout victory. Arkansas attorney general Dustin Mcdaniel says that he plans to appeal the ruling. Mcdaniel says that he personally supports Marriage Equality but promised to defend the law in court. Well keep you posted on whats happening in arkansas. Meanwhile, in North Carolina, one man on that states ballot is running on the promise to break the law. Mark chillton is on his way to becoming the next register of deeds in Orange County, North Carolina. He won a threeway primary tuesday. If elected in november, and theres a good chance because hes running unopposed, he promises to become one of the first persons in the south to issue samesex marriage licenses. Theres a problem, though. The state constitution in North Carolina says no way. Mark chilton joins me live from raleigh. Mark, samesex merarriage illeg in the tar heel state. They banded it back in 2012. There was a famous song i fought the law and the law won. Is there going to be a different outcome for you, sir . Theyre the ones fighting the law. You know, the United States constitution as its been interpreted through roma versus evans and United States versus windsor last june make it very clear that the state constitutional amendment in North Carolina that prohibits samesex marriage is definitely contrary to the 14th amendment. So why not wait for that ruling . Well, i guess i would turn that right around on you and say why should i wait for that ruling . You know, my responsibility as an elected official in North Carolina is laid out in the state constitution in article 6, section 7. It says that my first and foremost responsibility is to uphold the United States constitution and that my second responsibility is to uphold the North Carolina constitution, as long as its consistent with the federal one, so your states attorney general not commenting on your pledge specifically but he has in the past upheld the states ban on samesex marriage even though that he says he supports the unions personally. Have you talked to him since tuesday . Do you plan to lobby his office in any way . You know, as far as im concerned, it really i dont work for attorney general cooper, i work for the voters of Orange County, North Carolina. And i intend to uphold by constitutional oath. Whats been the response there to your pledge . Well, you know, Orange County is a blue oasis in Orange County or in North Carolina, which is a very definitely purple state overall, so its been very well received i think for the most part in Orange County. But, you know, definitely there are people across North Carolina who have a lot of concerns and reservations and i understand that. But this is the thing, its not a question of whats popular, its a question of what the constitution requires. Really quickly, last question. Anyone in particular you plan on marrying first . Ive been contacted by only a handful of couples so far, but here im on msnbc so that should probably change soon. All right. Mark chilton, good saturday to you, sir. Thank you. Thanks for having me on, craig. First Lady Michelle obama today delivered the commencement address to the class of 2014 at dillard university. She told graduates they should set their bar high and let nothing hold them back. No dream is too big, no vision is too bold, as long as we stay hungry for education and let that hunger be our north star, there is nothing, graduates, nothing that we cannot achieve. Walter kimbrough is the president of dillard university. Dillard one of 100 historically black colleges and universities. How was the first lady received today by the class of 2014 . It was awesome, craig. We had a great crowd, probably 5,000 people. Everyone was excited. There was just a lot of energy, powerful selections from our choir so it built up so by the time she took the stage, we were all ready and excited so it was a great day for us. Theres a new report out that finds, quote, historically black public universities in four states continue to lag behind predominantly white schools in funding specifically. Dillard a private university, but are you finding the same difficulty in maintaining appropriate funding . Thats one of the challenges for all of Higher Education to figure out. How do we as a nation work, both the states and federally to provide resources for young people who have great minds and a lot of potential, but they just lack those resources. So that has to be the conversation that we develop in this country. How do we help prepare the next generation as. As a friend of mine said this week, this talent is spread equally across our country but opportunity isnt. Thats what we see. And so this becomes one of the barriers that we are facing. So it faces africanamericans, but i think really across the country regardless of race, young people are really looking for ways to be supported. One of the things im working on a series of stories on the future of historically black colleges and universities in this country and the video were showing is my visit at morgan state, i spent some time at a couple others as well. One of the things that i have found is the decision by the department of education recently to change some of the qualifications related to parent plus loans specifically. What has that meant for students at dillard, and what has th thatment for the university itself there . Weve been fortunate. We didnt have the same level of challenge with that parent plus loan, but it really provided another barrier for people. A lot of my colleagues, that was an opportunity that families could use to provide the resources for those young people to attend the schools. There was a report released not too long ago, because there was a lot of concern about default rates, but those default rates on parent plus loans are much lower than a lot of other loan programs, so people are saying if this wasnt really a problem, then why were we trying to fix it . So that becomes a valuable stream of revenue for young people and their families to provide for an education. We did not have as many students in that parent plus loan program, but it did impact some of them as well. Im not really a big fan of loans because i understand the concern about student debt. How do we find more ways to provide grants that dont have to be paid back for young people. Thats what we should work on and not so much about a loan here and a loan there. Your twitter hands is hiphop prez. How did that come about . When i became a president , i was 37, First College president from the hiphop generation, so i talked about being different from the average president who at the time was 58, 60 years old. So here i am at 37 with a new sensibility and new way to try to connect with young people. One of the local papers in arkansas where i was president before created it and i rolled with it. So it works for me. All right. Were going to have a big roundtable discussion on the future of hbcus in a couple of weeks and id like for you to come back and be a part of that larger discussion. I would love to. The first lady was there today. Thank you, sir. Up next, rand paul delivers a new attack against a future potential Hillary Clinton candidacy. Well put it to the brain trust. Instead of hanging out on the couch, you could be hanging ten. What are you waiting for . vo celebrate this memorial day with up to 40 off hotels at travelocity. gnome go and smell the roses. Wbecame your business. Passion. At t can help simplify how you manage it. So you can focus on what you love most. When everyone and everything works together, business just sings. And thats epic, bro, weve forgotten just how good good is. Good is setting a personal best before going for a world record. Good is swinging to get on base before swinging for a home run. [ crowd cheering ] good is choosing not to overshoot the moon, but to land right on it and do some experiments. So start your day off good with a coffee thats good cup after cup. Maxwell house. Good to the last drop if you have a business idea, we have a personalized legal solution thats right for you. With easy stepbystep guidance, were here to help you turn your dream into a reality. Start your Business Today with legalzoom. How much money do you think youll need when you retire . Then we gave each person a ribbon to show how many years that amount might last. I was trying to, like, pull it a little further. [ woman ] got me to 70 years old. Im going to have to rethink this thing. Its hard to imagine how much well need for a retirement that could last 30 years or more. So maybe we need to approach things differently, if we want to be ready for a longer retirement. This is about judgment, and were talking about should we, should we as a country have a commander in chief who didnt provide Adequate Security in libya, didnt send reinforcements and then gave us nothing but spin. My opinion is that Hillary Clinton has precluded herself from ever being considered for that position. Well, of course he would say that. Some strong words there from senator rand paul. Lets get right to the brain trust. Irin carmon, reporter Jackie Kucinich is here and republican strategist hogan gidley, always one of the best dressed men on television. Good to see you all. Let me start with you, irin. Its clearly not going to go away. That clip is a variation of what we are going to hear from republicans for the next several months leading up to the midterms into 2016 as well. How much is benghazi going to hurt Hillary Clinton should she run for president . So far it really seems like its a very activated small part of the Republican Base that is fired up about benghazi. There just isnt a smoking gun that links Hillary Clinton to what happened, to the tragedy in bengha benghazi. In fact even this most recent select panel, according to nancy pelosi, half the families said leave it alone. It was a tragedy that lives were lost in benghazi, but linking it to Hillary Clinton, its still missing something that showed her actions connected to it. So far the only people keeping it alive are republicans out there fundraising off of it. Hogan, lets talk about this select panel. Democrats, at this point they havent decided if theyre going to be joining the new select committee thats going to investigate benghazi. The Washington Post reporting, quote, the caucus remains torn over whether its members should participate. The panel, democrats say, is a politically motivated witch hunt. How effective can the committee be if theres so much partisan bickering from the outset, sir . They can be very effective if they end every question with a question mark . If its not grandstanding, if its not rhetorical politicizing of the event, if it actually tries to get to the bottom of what happened. Shes right, there is no link right now between Hillary Clinton and this issue, but thats the whole purpose of the hearing itself. Look, everyone has been focusing on the cia talking points, i understand that. Thats the reason we had the Congressional Committee in the first place. What we havent focused on is the real issue which are the white house talking points that brought up the video in the first place. Mike morrell said that he was concerned and didnt understand why susan rice brought that up on the sunday talk shows. Somewhere, somehow in that administration that was the focus of what they decided to spin to us and sell to us and lie to the American Public was that it was because of some video. This hearing, if theyre smart and wise, they will try to find the link between where those talking points originated and why we were sold a bill of goods and why, quite frankly, four americans were dead and killed at an embassy in benghazi. Its a tragedy and someone needs to be held accountable for it in our administration, but not just that. Its a year later and we havent made one arrest yet. Its just deplorable. Jackie, let me come to you here because hogan just said and ive heard this a lot the past few days that if the committee itself is engaged in a legitimate search for truth, there might be some good that comes from it. I talked to general carter hamm at the top of the 2 00 hour who essentially reiterated what he said in his testimony, some 140 pages worth. His contention is basically weve said everything there is to say. All of the facts have been reported. If that is true, jackie, then whats to be gained politically by continuing this . Well, this is an issue that fires up the Republican Base and continues to fire up the Republican Base. I mean, listen, rand paul is talking about it in terms of the president ial race. So in terms of keeping their base really fired up, as i said, thats the political aspect to gain. Look, theyre fundraising off of it so clearly theres money on the line. Lets pivot here and i want to talk about something else. Republicans have obviously been focusing a lot on benghazi here. It could be drawing attention away from domestic issues. We heard from former president ial nominee mitt romney this week who, this made some news. This is what he said about raising the minimum wage. Take a listen. I, for instance, as you know, part company from many of the conservatives in my party on the issue of the minimum wage. I think we should raise it. Frankly our party is all about more jobs and better pay. I think communicating that is important to us. Why not do that . It would seem to me again, im not a political strategist, but it would seem that jobs, the economy, raising the minimum wage, those would be the kinds of things that would appeal to lots of people versus talking about benghazi, that we know appeals to a small sliver, a smaller sliver. Well, every time the minimum wage has been raised over time its been through bipartisan consensus. That would literally be the only thing that could make this priority of president obama a reality. But theres just not enough incentive right now a few months ahead of the 2014 midterms for republicans to make it seem like anything is happening in washington. I mean if they benefit from washington is broken, there is apparently no incentive for them to come to the table and say lets do something about the hardesthit americans, people who are struggling to get by. Unfortunately i think it doesnt cost mitt romney very much to say that literally, and, you know, other republicans are just far too beholden to the chamber of commerce which opposes this and through restaurant interests and so on that have historically been the reason that the minimum wage hasnt budged. Hogan, are we going to listen to mitt on this one . Wed be wise to listen to part of what mitt romney has to say. Look, the minimum wage should be lifted, should be raised to some degree, but the fact is we need a leader out there from our party who can step forward and say, fine, you want to raise the minimum wage, lets talk about the actual amount we want to raise it but lets tie that to keystone in some way. Lets work out a deal to get something moving forward. Instead of focusing on one issue and just being obstructionists about it, lets bring in another issue and say ill give you a little to get a little. Thats whats missing in washington. The last time i checked, just to be clear here, that minimum wage increase failed in the senate. The democrats control the senate. The republicans dont. So the president needs to quit pointing the finger at us and focus on his own party. Its the same thing with the gun bill. That didnt get out of the senate either. Thats controlled by the democrats well, come on. Jackie, well give you ten seconds to wrap it there. I was just going to say thats because the republicans mounted a pretty hefty opposition. It wasnt a clean up or down vote they didnt have the votes. Come on, hogan. Thats a good spot to end on, come on, hogan. You control the chamber. Were going to leave it there. Irin carmon, Jackie Kucinich, hogan gidley, thank you all for your time. Jackie, im sorry i didnt get to come to you again, youre my favorite. Im joking. I was trying to make her feel better. Up next, m. J. Is back. A new album by Michael Jackson. Ill have a review and a preview right after this. Review and a w right after this. One thing ive learned is my philosophy is real simple American Express open forum is an online community, that helps our members connect and share ideas to make Smart Business decisions. If you mess up, fess up. Be your partners best partner. We built it for our members, but its open for everyone. Theres not one way to do something. No details too small. American express open forum. This is what membership is. This is what membership does. [prof. Burke] at farmers,we make you smarter about [bell rings] your insurance,because what you dont know can hurt you. What if you didnt know that collisions with wildlife on the road may not be covered . And that you could be liable for any accidents on your property . The more you know,the better you can plan for whats ahead. Talk to farmers and get smarter about your insurance. We are farmers bum pa dum, bum bum bum bum [announcer] call 1800farmers and see how much you could save. [ girl ] my mom, she makes underwater fans that are powered by the moon. She can print Amazing Things, right from her computer. [ whirring ] [ train whistle blows ] she makes trains that are friends with trees. My mom works at ge. Humans. We are beautifully imperfect creatures living in an imperfect world. Thats why Liberty Mutual insurance has your back, offering exclusive products like optional better car replacement, where if your car is totaled, we give you the money to buy one a model year newer. Call. And ask an Insurance Expert about all our benefits today, like our 24 7 support and service, because at Liberty Mutual insurance, we believe our customers do their best out there in the world, so we do everything we can to be there for them when they need us. Plus, you could save hundreds when you switch, up to 423. Call. Today. Liberty Mutual Insurance responsibility. Whats your policy . Just as so many before, the king of pop is out with a new album despite no longer being among the living for five years now. That features not only the signature sound of Michael Jackson but also cameo from one modern living music star. This is a taste from the albums first trarks love never felt so good. Senior editor with Rolling Stone magazine. Thats all we can afford to play of Michael Jackson. Still very expensive to play his songs on television. You heard the album. What did you think . Its a pretty good album. It surprised me with how good it was. What were you expecting . A lot of the early buzz was concern because its an album of leftovers. These are tracks that Michael Jackson left unfinished. But the material is on par with some of his best work. Just eight tracks i understand. There are only eight tracks. Its hard to begrudge that when hes no longer living. Are the tracks overproduced at all. Its surprising. The production on this album people were concerned that the production would be overproduced, but its really tasteful. It seems really in line with what michael would have done with these tracks. Your reviewer wrote in part most of these songs rot and sway with fear. Thats strong. This album has some beautiful love songs but some dark twisted songs that Michael Jackson was great at. We mention a modern living star makes a cameo. That would be justin timberlake. Hes the only one, if you dont count timbaland. This is him talking about how he approached the project. Michael was one of the greatest entertainers. I felt like i had to dig into a place where its just deeper than just music. I have to dig into a place to where he would accept what im doing without him telling me this is right. What does that say about how this album was put together . You can see when they talk about this the level that he had for the material. He wasnt going to rush this out. Hes trying to be respectful with what michael would have done. Is it the first of many . This is the second album. There was another one in 2010. All right. Thank you. Thank you so much as well for watching. I will be back tomorrow. A special time at 2 00 eastern. First right now disrupt with karen finney. Democrats are calling it a witch hunt, but whats behind this obsession with benghazi and were going to talk about what some nfl cheerleaders and fast food workers have in common. Well tell you their shared struggle coming up this hour. Im jane and i have copd. Im dave and i have copd. Im kate and i have copd, but i dont want my breathing problems to get in the way my volunteering. Thats why i asked my doctor about breo. Oncedaily breo ellipta helps increase airflow from the lungs for a full 24 hours. And breo helps reduce symptom flareups that last several days and require oral steroids, antibiotics, or hospital stay. Breo is not for asthma. Breo contains a type of medicine that increases risk of death in people with asthma. It is not known if this risk is increased in copd. Breo wont replace rescue inhalers for sudden copd symptoms and should not be used more than once a day. Breo may increase your risk of pneumonia, thrush, osteoporosis, and some eye problems. Tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high Blood Pressure before taking breo. Ask your doctor about breo for copd. First prescription free at mybreo. Com woman this place has got really good chocolate shakes. growls man thats a good look for you. woman that was fun. man yeah. man let me help you out with the. woman . Oh no, i got it. man you sure . woman just pop the trunk. man vo i may not know where the road will lead, but. Im sure my subaru will get me there. announcer love. Its what makes a subaru, a subaru. Thanks for disrupting your afternoon. Im karen finney. Whats a Political Party to do when attacking obamacare isnt working . Benghazi, benghazi, benghazi. That and much more coming up in this hour. Skbr the forecast for this weekend is benghazi. Make sure you bring a straight jacket. Christmas came early for the seven lucky republicans picked to be on the select committee on benghazi. Republicans have seven seats shs the democrats will have five seats and essentially no power. To say, look, elect republicans so we can have these kinds of investigations is appropriate. The autopsy of ambassador stevens should be released to the public. Should we say were not participating in this sham . This is a high risk operation. You would think obama had written a memo of traffic problems for benghazi . Can you imagine if they put this kind of effort of into a jobs bill