Transcripts For MSNBCW Morning Joe 20200915

Willie, donald trump says on the 13th of april, privately of course, you dont have a chance. This is the plague and yet, this is, of course, the same president who was desperate to reopen the economy. I must say the same president who last night got a lot of people together in arizona with this plague that he also told bob woodward was so dangerous and deadly because it was airborne this is a plague that donald trump, obviously, understood about a long time ago and yet he was trying to open schools, trying to open the economy at the same time he was saying that behind closed doors, and, of course, hes still having superspreader events where most of the people there are not Wearing Masks. So that was april 13th, the clip we played, that was a monday he was talking to bob woodward what was the day before that april 12th was easter. The date he had circled on the calendar to reopen everything. We want to reopen by easter, get back play baseball, going back for easter the next day hes calling it the plague, rips you apart, this thing is a killer. Its stunning over the past week as these tapes have come out where to the day you can find President Trump saying Something Different publicly than he was saying privately or the next day or the day before, on and on bob woodward this book is going to be out. Hes on with us tomorrow well hear new audio tomorrow. These tapes come out and the president is constantly over the course of this entire pandemic saying something entirely different to the public than he reveals to be true and he has revealed it by talking to bob woodward. Lets bring in Jonathan Lemire, he was at the president s event in arizona and nevada, a dangerous situation, nobody Wearing Masks, most people not Wearing Masks inside, except in nevada those closest to the president behind him on the stage Wearing Masks. Funny how that works but you have the president talking about this is a plague, its airborne, if youre the wrong person it rips you apart notice donald trump doesnt have a lot of people packed in around him like this because its not him. But hes convinced those people and millions of other people that this is no worse than the flu, even though he told bob woodward its worse than the flu, more dangerous. And yet donald trump is willingly leading all of these people to put their lives and the lives of their loved ones at risk i suppose it just doesnt matter to people that are in the personality cult, but Jonathan Lemire it does matter to Senior Citizens who know that they may be the ones, as donald trump said, are, quote, finished by this plague. I cant believe its helping him in arizona i cant believe its helping him in florida i cant believe its helping him with seniors across america. This is the tone he set in the beginning from the early days of the pandemic he deliberately underplayed it to the American People he downplayed its effects, how lethal it is, particularly for seniors but others as well in another audio tape he acknowledges its dangerous for young people but in another tape hes saying children are all but immune. What we saw this weekend was striking, it was a western trip for the president , heading from nevada to arizona. Looking to spread his map because hes losing in arizona he had a rally outdoors in nevada, where people were not Wearing Masks and not social distancing but at least it was outside. Thats the formula theyve been usi using, whether its airport h g hangers or whatever, its outside. After the tulsa event where it was inside and a superspreader event. Suddenly the plan changed, sunday night in nevada, henderson, an indoor event an event the campaign did not advise to reporters traveling with the president would be indoors. And most of the networks pulled out the correspondents, pulled them from the warehouse that was packed with several thousand people, very few in masks, no social distancing because it wasnt safe. The press pool, of which i was a part, did indeed attend. Youre right, you nailed on something a second ago there was a section of people behind the president , they had masks on a staffer was spotted making sure they were wearing them before the president took the stage. How interesting is that they werent wearing them when the earlier speakers were on, but before the cameras turned on, before the rally was taken live on a few channels, they were told to put on masks unbelievable. I have to say, lets get this straight so donald trump is mocking people Wearing Masks he has rallies where he has people coming in and everybody is showing their unity with the president by not Wearing Masks which, of course, very dangerous. The president has called this the plague he called it the plague back in april, back when he was trying to reopen the country. Said on its airborne which makes it dachk rous, you can get it airborne just being next to somebody and if youre the wrong person youre finished this is really bad its deadly. The president , though, if people are in his proximity, they have to wear masks. I think thats pretty revealing. But if you are in a personality cult, you may not be able to sort through all of that here, let me help you. The president is concerned about himself and not you. Speaking about people being concerned about themselves, this is the time were coming up on an election, how exciting, this is when a president flies into town and everybody on the ballot, especially in close races stand up on stage and all hold their arms up with the president unity. Everybody is cheerful. Unity. They think it might help them get over the finish lines. What was Martha Mcsallys key moment last night at this rally . What did she say in support of donald trump maybe she introduced him. This is what i love about american politics. This is the pageantry of it, what did Martha Mcsally say in arizona at this donald trump rally, when he came to her state with her whole career in the senate on the line well, joe, it might surprise you to learn that Martha Mcsally was not there yesterday in phoenix when the president came to town. What . Ill say it again, Martha Mcsally was not there are you sure . Joe, im glad youre sitting down right now but she was not there. The governor of arizona did was there. Greeted the president at the airport when he landed in arizona at phoenix after we came from california and the wildfires. The governor of arizona i guess since he was there, hes on the ballot in november, is that right thats why he was there . The governor made a point of yes, the governor was there, joe, and it should be noted this as well the governor attended the event. It wasnt just at the airport. He went to the latinos event rally. It was called latinos for trump round table. He had one the day before in las vegas that consistented of six people, small socially distanced the governor was there so he must have an election coming up this year, right is he on the ballot in a month and a half in arizona . Thats right, joe is he yes or no . Do you know . I dont think he is, joe. Joe, i dont think he is. So i dont understand this. Wait willie, this is the strangest thing in the world, can you help i know i am just such im not a dumb country lawyer. Im feeling this morning like a caveman lawyer so what Jonathan Lemire with that new York City Press outfit, the Associated Press is saying, that the arizona candidate who doesnt have an election coming up in the next month and a half was there with president donald j. Trump, but the senatorial candidate whos fighting for her very political life and who you would think would be the first person there to be with donald trump, arms up in the air, go, im so proud to have backed donald trump and attacked reporters and played the whole maga game you would think that she would have been there jumping up and down with the president. Isnt this a Strange Development . Its very Strange Development as youre indicating im picking up on the subtly here joe of what youre saying i think what youre saying, governor doocy, hes term limited and theres not an election until 2022, so no concerns there Martha Mcsally, whos in a tight race was not available because she had Senate Business to attend to is what we heard okay. So she was tied up with that. So either she was concerned she didnt want to be on a stage with donald trump in a tight election in the state of arizona or perhaps she was concerned for her own safety as many others were in a tightly packed room. Yes , you know, maybe, willie, she has underlying conditions. So maybe it would be dangerous for her to go to the event. Or maybe she wanted to follow proper social distancing guidelines because if you were following proper social distancing guidelines, whether you have underlying conditions or not, you dont want to get the coronavirus, one way to avoid it is not to go to a superspreader event where people are clustered together and breathing all over each other without masks on sunday, thepresident was asked about whether he had any safety concerns when it comes to Holding Indoor rallies heres that exchange arent you concerned about getting covid, though, in a closed room . No, im not concerned im more concerned about how close you are. Sorry about that. Because you know why, im on a stage, its very far away. So im not at all concerned. So hes not concerned about himself because hes on stage. Hold on, willie all the other people are hes saying the outloud parts that he should be keeping inside that head of his. He often does. Yes, im starting to notice that so hes 5 or 6 feet away from this reporter and he is concerned that shes 5 or 6 feet away and yet he has events where he jams people in and even in tulsa staff were removing those signs that were supposed to keep people apart from one another. Some might even say that is so selfish it could endanger the lives of his very supporters, willie. It was on display last night as jonathan described very well. For the public they want to see the masks behind him so the tv cameras are shooting President Trump, masks were responsible we get it, this is bad but were fine to fill this place up, packed shoulder to shoulder with our supporters and get them in there. Despite weve heard President Trump say on tape again and again be, its deadly stuff, its airborne, its a killer and he told bob woodward its the plague the reason he was uncomfortable with that reporter that close to him is because he knows all of these things and has said them outloud on tape to bob woodward. He knows how dangerous it is lets bring into the conversation professor at the lyndon b. Johnson school of public affairs, victoria defrancisco soto. Mr. David drucker, a contributing writer at vanity fair. You know in 1994 in the midterm elections i remember reading articles, the first year i ran, and i remember reading articles talking about how some members of congress, it said, they would put antiaircraft guns on the border of their districts and if bill clintons air force one came their direction they would fire warning shots to keep them away. Thats how lilittle they wanted bill clinton in their district in 1994. Of course there was a landslide. Im not sure thats how Martha Mcsally, thom tillis, certainly Susan Collins and a lot of other atrisk republicans are feeling right now. Its been interesting to watch different vulnerable republicans and how theyre playing President Trump. Susan collins has tried to distance herself shes trying to deal with the fact that the coalition that shes relied on for years, moderate republicans and moderate democrats and stalwart republicans to keep her in office even as the state turned more blue is in trouble because President Trump is so polarizing a figure shes losing a lot of women shes relied on. Martha mcsally made a different bet. Notwithstanding the fact she wasnt with the president yesterday, she has really tied herself to trump and part of her challenge is on the one hand the phoenix and tucson suburbs have moved away from President Trump who did win the suburban vote in the exit polling four years ago but they moved away from trump but arizonas Republican Base is very, very loyal to trump. So shes trying to thread a needle that may be impossible. She decided to keep herself close to trump and go that route. And i think Corey Gardner is trying to separate himself from everybody. The challenge he faces is colorado is a blue state for all intents and purposes and any republicans capable of getting a crossover vote and surviving, it would be him because hes skilled and hes in a tough race and its because the president is not popular in colorado so all of these down ballot republicans are trying to deal with, on the one hand, a Republican Base loyal to the president , but on the other hand, a suburban voting block and others that simply think any republican who is supportive of President Trump has got to go. Is it safe to say that Martha Mcsally in arizona and Corey Gardner in colorado, those two republicans and those two adjoining west everyoern states safe to say theyre probably the two most endangered republicans in the senate this year . I think they are. I go back and forth on Susan Collins. But i think gardner and mcsally probably have the steepest challenges its interesting because guai tn gardner is a skilled politician, mcsally had fits and starts that she cant figure out what kind of republican she wants to be. She started out as a house member, more as a john mccain style republican so she knows how to appeal across the aisle but in responding to her Republican Base in arizona, she has become more trumpy, for lack of a better word. Gardner i think has been more consistent its whether he can survive a democratic onslaught in the suburbs mcsally, gardner, both in deep trouble. Susan collins. I know republicans are optimistic shell pull a rabbit out of the hat because she survived so long there doing what she does. Keep an eye on thom tillis because of a fundraising edge that Joe Cunningham has. I also note we still have so much time for different aspects of the campaign to influence the vote theres three president ial debates. The news cycle brings us a new this is going to determine the election thing every couple days and there are a lot of republicans that survived. So a lot of things happening that were not thinking is going to happen. So, victoria ya. Go ahead, joe. You look at some of the races and Corey Gardner is in such trouble, willie. And Susan Collins is in a state where the race may be close but statewide joe biden seems to have a lead on donald trump, at least some of the polls that ive seen that people stop splitting their vote a long time ago between parties. So its hard to see how she survives. Susan collins to watch her do that tap dance every day in the state of maine where she condemns President Trump lightly on some things, supports him on others, shes trying to walk that line and it may be too tight of a line. Victoria, that event in arizona was billed as a latino round table to talk about issues facing latinos its basically the same rally that weve seen regardless of who the audience is. Trump said latinos are tough, ive done business with them, i know theyre tough like me thats the connection and the appeal he was trying to make and draw there how is his message playing in arizona, in south florida . In arizona im not seeing much difference than in 2016 the latest poll numbers from the cbs poll have trump at about 20 . So come election day well see trump anywhere between 25 and 30 . In arizona latinos have been a tad more conservative than in california, not as conservative as those in texas. Its a mix of prolife, evangelicals, probusiness latinos, and theyre latinos who are of hispanic decent but dont identify as latinos. Thats the coalition that trump goes after everywhere when it comes to latinos the achilles heel for President Trump in arizona and what is going to hurt him in terms of seeing a substantial latino turnout is sb 1070, which weve talked about before on this show and the Sheriff Joe Arpaio effect latinos have been ticked off and this is a key mobilizing factor come november. All right vict victoria thank you well get to new news. New video has emerged from the minutes after two los angeles sheriffs deputies were ambu ambushed the 31yearold female deputy called in the incident and jumped out of the patrol car to tend to her male partner shes a 31yearold mother of a 6yearold boy she was shot in the jaw. The female deputy seen here applying a tourniquet to her 24yearold partners arm as she hides them both behind a column. The l. A. County sheriff said the deputy went beyond the call of duty as her motherly instincts kicked in. Neither of the deputys identities had been released but both were sworn into the force 14 months ago. A reward for information leading to the shooter has climbed to 175,000 the chief checkiexecutive of the Worlds Largest vaccine manufacturer warns not enough covid19 vaccine will be available for everyone in the world until the end of 2024 at the earliest he told the Financial Times he believes pharmaceutical companies are not increasing Production Capacity quickly enough to be able to vaccinate the global population in a shorter time frame he estimates 15 billion doses will be needed if the covid19 shot is a twodose vaccine still ahead on morning joe, dozens of major wildfires are burning across the west coast and firefighters are racing to contain the flames well have the latest on that and how the issue is making its way onto the campaign trail. Including the president s claim about exploding trees and also science not knowing anything youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Rollercoaster love like yours will surely come my way ahey, aheyhey [music playing] love like yours will surely come my way always have been. And always will be. Never letting anything get in my way. Not the doubts, distractions, or voice in my head. And certainly not arthritis. New voltaren provides powerful arthritis pain relief to help me keep moving. And it can help you too. Feel the joy of movement with voltaren. I feel like werey forglet me check. Ing. Xfinity home gives you peace of mind from anywhere with professionally monitored Home Security built around you. No, i think were good. Good. So when youre away, you dont have to worry. The tent. We forgot. The tent. Except about that. Xfinity home. Simple, easy, awesome. Hey look, i found the tent and, see, its safe. Call, click, or visit a store today. The death toll from the wildfires in california continues to rise as authorities are still searching for a number of people who are missing. And firefighters are working to keep multiple blazes from rea reaching populated communities as of last night there have been 25 fatalities in california, more than 3 million acres have burned across the state this year, the largest amount on record and forced more than 60,000 people from their homes. In oregon devastating wildfires torched more than 1 million acres across the state since last week, killing 9 people and forcing tens of thousands of residents to flee from their homes. The unprecedented wildfires out west has well get to this next story in just a moment. Jonathan lemire, you were with the president yesterday as he went out west to discuss these issues and it appeared there were some comments that he made on Climate Change that might have showed he knew a little bit less than one might imagine. Thats right. The president had been largely silent on these wildfires in recent days, received some criticism for perhaps not paying as much attention to a disaster that was ravaging a trio blue states, california, oregon and now Washington State as well but while out west for these trips we were discussing earlier, yesterday morning he did fly to Northern California outside sacramento, where he met with Governor Newsom to receive a briefing on the wildfires. As well play in a moment here, he illuminated his own belief as to what should be done to prevent these forest fires, his belief in forest managing and raking the floors of the forest. And was pressed by a california state official as to what the real reason is behind the increase in wildfires in recent years. What would you like to see specifically done on the issue of Forest Management is it possible that its also Forest Management and Climate Change i think something is possible i think a lot of things are possible but with regard to the forest, when trees fall down after a short period of time, about 18 months they become very dry. They become really like a match stick and they get up, you know, theres no more water pouring through and they become very, very they just explode. They could explode also leaves when you have years of dried leaves on the ground, it just sets it up we want to work with you to recognize thchgid what it means and Work Together with that science. That science is going to be key. Because if we ignore that science and sort of put our head in the sand and think its all about Vegetation Management were not going to succeed in protecting californians. Itll start getting cooler. You just watch. I wish science agreed with you. I dont think science knows, actually. First, fact check trees dont tend to explode. Secondly what we heard there sounds reminiscent to the president s approach about the coronavirus, itll eventually just disappear yesterday you heard him saying it will get cooler that perhaps the science doesnt know this isnt about cooler in terms of summer turning to fall and then winter, this is the globe warming up and scientists believe thats the reason why the increase in natural disas r disaste disasters. California has been in a mega drought for quite some time. But the president has been a Climate Change denier for his entire time in office. Showed no interest yesterday in embracing that issue at all saying that was the cause behind the disasters out west. Jonathan lemire i know you have to go but before you go, let me ask quickly who do you think the red sox are going to get their first rounds in the playoffs. Joe, im hopeful were playing so well i expect well have homefield throughout. Maybe well get the yankees, the rays, but it doesnt matter. Team of destiny. It doesnt matter, does it . No going down that backstretch, like the belmont, 1973, watch our red sox go and go and go down the drain Jonathan Lemire, good to talk to you. So willie, i must say that donald trump provided an opening for protesters, environmental protesters to do what they did in one of Ronald Reagans campaigns where he said trees were one of the largest emitters of carbon in the world so when he would go around speaking they would hang signs around trees saying kill me before i kill again. So with donald trump we have exploding trees, and yes, theres something to be said about management of vegetation and so many other things that a lot of people are talking about right now. But this quote, this quote that i dont think science actually knows, is staggering, because its so inline we really do get a real time comparison on donald trump and a lot of republicans not all, but a lot of republicans contempt for science as it pertains to Climate Change we have a realtime tragedy unfolding right now with this plague, as donald trump calls it, where you have republicans who again distrust science, distrust medicine, even the spokesman for the department of health and Human Services yesterday accusing doctors inside the white house of sedition and talking about armed left wing assassins after the election this is not your fathers its certainly not my fathers Republican Party but how incredible that donald trump is not smart enough i mean, really incredible to avoid the comment oh, its going to cool down its going to cool down. What does that sound like . Its going to go away. Its going to magically go away when things warm up. Like a miracle. He was wrong then, almost 200,000 americans dead because of it. Now hes flipping it, its going to cool down, i dont think science knows as we had some of of the more disturbing news on the Climate Change yesterday we were talking about how he says the quiet part outloud often he often does it explicitly, heres what i think, science doesnt know you can apply it to so many things over the course of the administration, including this plague as he described it of coronavirus. When he would go on a rift like that say 10 years ago about forestry and raking the floor. You can laugh it off as the guy from apprentice and a clown, but hes the president of the United States and he can pull us out of the paris accords and do things that affect the environment that he couldnt do when he was hosting the apprentice because he is here controlling whats in this country, in the world to the environment we saw his attitude toward science, which is that it doesnt actually know. So two years ago, remember he was in paradise its one of those things where he gets a nugget of information somewhere. He heard from the president of finland that they keep their forest floors clean so he went on the rift about raking the floors of the forest in finland. He hears one thing and becomes an expert on forestry and Vegetation Management and there are dire implications of that when he wants to change the subject from whats happening in the world, in the environment, just brush this aside like hes tried to do with coronavirus meanwhile, Hurricane Sally is slowly moving toward the gulf coast. Lets bring in meteorologist bill karins with more on that. Bill science has improved our lives probably more than anything else. And ill leave it at all lets get into sally we are watching this storm system crawling, drifting towards the coast. The winds have come down the winds were never the story its the rain event that is unfolding from pensacola to gulf shores to mobile, into all through Central Alabama in the days ahead, that will be the story. Eventually well get a landfall. Its a slow moving system, it may even be a Tropical Storm for landfall its not the reporters blowing in the historic winds type landfall, just pouring rain in the next two days straight so we will get minor wind damage, have concerns with the storm surge, especially the mobile bay area im watching, and then it just slowly rains. It doesnt make it to atlanta until friday morning so the rain is the story, 10 to 20 inches expected there could be isolated rainfall totals of 30 inches. Talking about a florence type of event, a harvey type of event for areas along the coast. Our european model predicts 14, 15 inches of rain from pensac a pensacola, destin, Central Georgia could get 7 to 8 inches of rain. The storm surge, 6 to 9 feet is nothing to sneeze at that will cause problems we will get damage along the coast mika, every Tropical Storm, every hurricane is different this is not a laura, which was an intense hurricane but this is moving at 2 miles per hour, thats not walking, thats walking backwards towards the coast and thats going to cause a lot of problems with rain. Well be watching that. Bill, thank you very much. Coming up, whoever wins the election will likely be confronted with a dire economy well look at that damage and discuss what should be done to get things back on track for everybody. Morning joe is coming right back nah. Here . Nope. Here. When the middle of nowhere. Is somewhere. The allnew chevy trailblazer. With safe, convenient service. Were here for you tech well come right to you. Upbeat music tech youll get a text when were on our way. Tech before we arrive, just leave your keys on the dash. Well replace your windshield with safe, nocontact service. Upbeat music tech and thats service you can trust when you need it the most. Upbeat music tech schedule at safelite. Com. Upbeat music singers safelite repair, safelite replace. Hold on one second. Sure. Okay. Okay safe drivers save 40 guys guys check it out. Safe drivers save 40 safe drivers save 40 safe drivers save 40 thats safe drivers save 40 . It is, thats safe drivers save 40 . Hes right there. Its him hes here. Hes right here. Hi hi. Hey thats totally him. Its him thats totally the guy. Safe drivers do save 40 . Click or call for a quote today. To soccer practices. And new adventures. You hope the more you give the less theyll miss. But even if your teen was vaccinated against meningitis in the past. They may be missing vaccination for meningitis b. Lets help protect them together. Because missing menb vaccination could mean missing out on a whole lot more. Ask your doctor if your teen is missing meningitis b vaccination. I mean, there are parts of the book youre not going to like what wont i like, bob . Just, you know, there is its tough times the virus, as you repeatedly told me and as youve said publicly, its derailed things, and its a its a big reality in peoples lives, as you know so i will get it to you and you know the market is coming back very strong you do know that. Yes, of course. Did you cover that in the book sure. Nothing more could have been done nothing more could have been done i acted early. This will be the history that we start thefirst draft of and it it will continue and so you think the virus totally supersedes the economy sure. But the economy is look were close to a new stock market record. That was newly released audio from the last conversation bob woodward had with President Trump last month were going to have bob woodward on, i think, tomorrow. Staggering. You know, i got to say, its fascinating that, you know, all of this information about covid19 and donald trump lying to the American People about this and 200,000 people dying and the president saying its a plague, while saying something quite differently publicly in april, this is all, of course, very shocking and has impacted and killed a lot of people, it has, history will show that, there will be causation. Dont worry. Im sure, obviously, research s researchers, scientists, doctors will be able to figure out, put a number on probably what his lies were responsible for, the killing of how many americans, wont be 200,000 might be 100,000 who knows well leave that to history. But what i find actually riveting in this book, and i cant wait to talk to bob about this, is actually the first half of the book where you hear james mattis and rex tillerson, poor dan coates, and others, that are trying to run americas Foreign Policy apparatus and keep us safe and keep the alliances in place that helped us beat the soviet union and helped the American Century explode over the past six, seven decades. And listening to them and their despair, trying to figure out what the best way is to save america stay the course. From this man who admiral mcraven said, is most likely one of the greatest clear and present dangers to this country and how telling when you have general mattis saying we have to go public with this, we have to go public with this, and dan coates being politically astute saying what goodwill that do look at whats happened with everybody thats gone public, that quit and attacked him publicly, its had no impact and them sitting around the table being frustrated no one more than senator coates, ambassador coates, being just shocked, actually, at the dereliction of duty exhibited by not only the president of the United States but also from his former friends in the United States senate. Thats tomorrow. Well talk about that tomorrow lets talked to, though, about the last part of the clip you just heard about donald trump talking about the economy. Lets bring in former treasury official and morning joe economic analyst steve analyst, and also the author of the Washington Post Early Morning news letter jackie palamini. Thank you all for being with us this morning. Its great his focus on the stock market joe when bob woodward was talking to him about the coronavirus and how its ravaged the country right. All he cared about hes talk about the stock market but steve, i want to talk to you about something i brought this up at the end of the show yesterday that its really concerning me, all the i know you have a lot more conversations with finance people, but just this past week alone in random social conversations not related to, hey, how is the economy going, not where im picking up the phone asking people what theyre thinking, i talked to a top banker at one of the big three banks in america, a Small Business lawyer that actually handles small to mid size companies, a finance ceo, and also a few Restaurant Owners that own quite a few restaurants, and they all told me the same thing, and i want to know if youre hearing this and if you have the same concern that im hearing time and time again, not to be a cassandra here but they say get ready for 2021, it doesnt matter who gets elected, theres going to be a depression i keep hearing the word depression, what theyre seeing from their clients are people that have held out for six, seven, eight, nine months on the verge of collapse. People that own property theyre all saying the same thing, the rich are going to get richer, the poor are going to get poorer, cash is going to be king in 2021 and there is going to be economic chaos again, these people dont know each other they i didnt lead them theyre all saying this. Whats going on . Why are there such grave concerns up and down the economic food chain that were not hearing about in the main stream press joe, i think we are facing a huge number of economic challenges im not sure i would go quite so far just to cut to the question you asked to declare a depression as a likelihood, but whats where we clearly are at the moment is an economy thats still slowly recovering, but by the fall of this year, maybe by the end of this year well only have recovered maybe half of the ground or thereabouts of what it lost during the pandemic and the early part of this year. And from there, i think the return path back is a very slow and potentially painful one. Because until we reopen the full economy just like it was before, youre going to have whole swaths of the economy, you mentioned restaurants, that are simply not able to operate at any kind of capacity that looks normal therefore theyre not going to be able to bring back all their people, they have to let more people go, and i think youre going to be looking at an economy that is very, very slow, into next year and then to your other point, the impact of this pandemic and recession has been completely and wildly disproportionate among various groups if youre a woman, a person of color, if you have less education, you have done far worse than the average american, think about some woman of color who cleans hotel rooms in a marriott in cleveland, who is perhaps unemployed in this moment versus again all of us in our world who are doing pretty well and this gets into Public Health until we have gotten people to a place where theyre totally comfortable resuming their normal lives, whether its with a vaccine or some other way, Economic Activity is going to be muted and we are going to feel like were in a very, very weak economy. And donald trump, every time hes asked a question like this, he looks at the stock market the stock market is not the economy. They operate for very Different Reasons in very Different Directions and the stock market tells you nothing about almost nothing about the state of the economy, except how well or poorly wealthy people who own stocks are doing. And it seems the values are wildly inflated. Fernando, lets talk about the front line workers whether youre talking about the worker that steve ratner was talking about, are you talking about other front line workers, people who have to go to restaurants, have to go to Retail Stores, have to go out and about, and theyre staying at home, they cant pay their rents. I understand that for now theres a freeze of evictions, they cant pay their rents, Small Business owners cant pay their leases you have huge Retail Stores in manhattan and across the country defaulting on their loans. That all everything goes up and then everything ollapses i dont want to sound too grim here, but yeah, were recovering a little bit but based on what payments from the federal government to front line workers that are going away. Joe, i think youre not overdramatizing the risk were in lets remember that before this terrible crisis hit us, we already had a situation where a majority of American Families couldnt put together 400 for an emergency weve had an economy that has been benefitting wealthy people for a long time, an economy that has kept a lot of workers working at minimum wage, which is not a living wage its not nearly enough to raise a family this has created a whole cycle i think of poverty in this country. So i think were now moving towards some sort of inflection point. I dont want to be dramatic either but when people think about the french revolution, 17 people were shocked one of the most powerful, stable countries on earth blew up and caused 20 years or more of tumult throughout europe. Were in one of those situations, i think, hopefully not that explosive but akin to the Great Depression where fdr had to step in there was the real need to fix structurally the economy from within. We set the stakes here we know how dire the situation is for many people in america is, lets talk about what congress is doing 600 checks were gone long awgo the ppp money has been burned through by most businesses, that was supposed to be a bridge to get us through the pandemic. Is there hopes for congress to do something by at least election day, the end of the year or at all is Congress Acting on this will there be another bill congress is showing little appetite to reach an agreement before lawmaker head home for a final campaign push. That means millions of americans who relied on the enhanced Unemployment Benefits is grim. Its worth underscoring what joe pointed out. Not enough in the media are saying, i wrote down a number of startling statistics that came out hours before the senate voted down the skinny stimulus package they voted on last thursday there was worrying outlook to numbers put out, 835,000 people filed unemployment claims last week 800,000 had claims processed for assistance 10 of adults reported not having enough to eat, not having enough food on the table the poverty rates are rising, up 22 among africanAmerican Families 29 million americans, according to data from the Labor Department are oasis answer the in total thats 20 times the amount of people on assistance last year at this same time. And 5 million americans are facing evictions those google searches are spiking, and the inaction from congress is exacerbating the situation. Right now youre considering House Speaker nancy pelosi, Majority Leader Mitch Mcconnell and Steve Mnuchin are all putting out competing bets Steve Mnuchin is urging congress not to worry about the deficit when thats what Mitch Mcconnell is worrying about. And House Speaker nancy pelosi is sticking to the 2. 2 trillion package the house previously passed putting the bet the pressure on trump will force him to put pressure on republicans in congress to put through some sort of bill and package you know, and steve ratner, unfortunately, as Richard Haass has said, ill quote him again, this pandemic hasnt changed history, its actually expedited the changes. Its not reshaped it, its just accelerated all of these forces. You and i and others are this table have been talking for a decade about the rich getting richer and poor getting poorer, income disparities, trying to figure out a way to bring the numbers closer together. Here we have a pandemic showing ceos they dont need as many workers, fulltime workers, they dont need the buildings, they can hire contract workers. A lot of those jobs arent going to come back again, everybody is so obsessed on november the 3rd. I think thats the election day. Whether its the vaccine or jobs, this seems again, steve, not to be a downer but this seems to be a massive challenge for next year and over the next decade i completely agree with that, joe. We are going to be looking at high unemployment by any historic measure as we get into the next administration. A lot of that is going to be structur structural people who lost jobs that are not coming back. So the new president is going to be faced with an enormous job. Right now you have a situation where we cant get an agreement on what everybody i think agrees is needed, which is a package but we cant agree on the details, even as were in the middle of the crisis then you have a new president come in and he or she he, rather is going to face potentially a divided congress, we dont know which way the senate is going, good idea which way the house is going to. So getting legislation through, you can see how hard it is to get a rescue package through, when everyone should agree its essential. Imagine going to the hill with an infrastructure bill trying to rebuild america and get those through congress when you have a divided senate and a house that probably will be democratic. And remember also the new president is coming in with a weaker tool box. When obama became president in the middle of the financial crisis, the deficit was about 760 or 750 billion, this president is coming in with a 3 trillion deficit. When obama came in, the debt to gdp was like 35 or so now its 100 we have Hospital Trust funds for medicare close to running out of money. We have a huge set of fiscal challenges as well as the impact of the pandemic. And so, this is going to be a huge job and, therefore, i think your concern is well placed. I think its going to take a herculean effort to get us back to where we were before, even with a vaccine. Steve ratner, jackie and fernando thank you all for being on for this conversation. Still ahead, President Trump packs supporters into another rally even as we hear more audio of him admitting back in april how deadly the virus can be. Plus the dangerous claims being pushed by the Trump Department spokesman, Michael Caputo. Roger stones protege whos now accused of interfering with cdc reports. Morning joe will be right back what up, paul ruud here . Actor and certified young person a few days ago i was talking to andrew cuomo and he was going off saying how us millennials need to wear a mask. So he asked me, paul, you got to help, what are you 26 . I didnt correct him my name is paul and im 6 feet tall almost. I wear my mask and its all i ask that you wear your mask. Please wear your mask. Just wear a mask just wear a mask its easy, its simple its not hard, people are dying. Hundreds of thousands of people are dying and its preventable just wear a mask, i shouldnt have to make it fun. Its science its science that was Actor Paul Rudd assuming the persona of a young person to get young people to wear a mask to prevent the spread of the coronavirus in a new psa for the state of new york its good. Have you seen the whole thing . I have. Paul rudd national treasure. If hes selling, im buying, period we have to play the rest of it later on, where hes playing its good. And listening to a boom box, pretending like hes talking to Billie Eilish hes going full on dad dork there. Its fantastic. The running joke about paul rudd is he does not age. So he could pass for 26 years old. I dont know how old he is. Thats why he didnt correct him. It it is tuesday, september 15th along with joe, willie and ma ma me we have eugene robinson, editor of the Washington Examiner magazine jay caruso joins us and Alexi Mchammond joi joins. Welcome to all of you to the hour we have new polling that shows little difference in confidence among voters when asked about President Trumps and joe bidens ability to handle law and order in america in the latest Monmouth University poll 48 of americans are confident that President Trump can maintain law and order in this country. 51 not confidence compared to 52 of americans who are confident joe biden can maintain law and order, and 45 not. On the president s handling of the nas wide protests over Racial Injustice just 24 think President Trump made the situation better while 61 think hes made the situation worse. 45 think biden would have handled the protests better as president. 28 think he would have handled the protests worse and 23 think he would have handled them the same. So gene robinson, the thing about political campaigns, as tom brokaw reminded us after everybodysaid Hillary Clinton campaign was over going into New Hampshire and she shocked barack obama. He said sometimes you have to wait for voters to actually vote before you know, before calling a race and obviously thats something that we all need to be reminded of time and time again we dont know how the election is going to turn out but we have seen two things happen already in this election. Two defining moments, june the 1st when the president had troops storm Peaceful Protesters so he could hold the bible upside down at st. Johns church and then kenosha that ended in tragedy and a 17yearold out of state kid shooting people with his ar 15. Those events and the ongoing riots, ill call them riots because at times theyre riots in portland, that are happening in portland and unrest in the rest of the country were supposed to help donald trump. Weve seen time and time again, poll after poll, showing not only did it not help donald trump, if you look at polls after june 1st, or you look at wisconsin polls since the kenosha unrest, actually joe bidens numbers have gone up and Donald Trumps have gone down. Yeah. Its you know so the your basic point is absolutely right. We dont know whats going to happen and you have to wait until the voters actually vote my question about those numbers, and similar numbers, are these attitudes about how trump has handled this issue or that issue, how biden would have handled this or that issue what theyre going to do about the economy, this and that i wonder how much those feelings are moving the needle. I wonder how much of this to what extent this cake is baked in the sort of split along cultural lines that we have in this country and you have the trump base and whatever they think about what trump is doing, theyre with trump. And you have the antitrump base and the biden base that no matter what they think about what biden said yesterday or will say tomorrow, theyre theres no way theyre going over to trump. So are there are there persuadable voters in the middle is there still a middle in american politics . Or are we just you know, are we going to cruise in these lanes until we get to november 3rd. I think thats a question, obviously, we wont be able to answer until after november 3rd, and maybe not for a couple weeks after that yeah, important question, you look at the polls that show biden near 50 or above 50 . Yeah. A lot of those numbers arent going to be moving jay caruso, how fascinating weve been talking about law and order, and the medias been talking about that, and how thats going to impact white voters in wisconsin, michigan and pennsylvania but the talk the last week or two, hasnt been about that because biden seems to be holding his own there. Its been about actually the democratic nominees problems with latinos in florida and arizona. So suddenly you have the upper midwest, a lot of those states still comfortably in bidens camp while you have arizona and florida going a bit south for him. Yeah. Its a perfect metaphor for 2020, everything is kind of crazy, isnt it . You would think based upon trumps rhetoric, things he said in the past, actions hes taken in the past, that he would be struggling with the latinos, especially in arizona and florida but surprisingly hes not, doing rather well and biden needs to make up that ground, now granted, biden if he wins the three states that trump won, if biden wins wisconsin, pennsylvania, and michigan, and trump wins every other state he won last time around, biden wins the election regardless. Its not as if he has to win florida or he has to win arizona, but, of course, if we dont want a bunch of mayhem after the election, of course it would be a lot better if either one of the candidates wins big i would rather not see this stretch like gene was talk about weeks ahead of november 3rd. I would i think everybody would want this settled on november 3rd. Alexi, this is what the president is going with, this law and order argument against joe biden. Hes lying about him in many cases when he says he wants to defund police. Joe biden has said well point out again, he wants to add money to Community Policing programs that will help build the communities and relieve pressure on the police. But the president has mishandled the coronavirus epidemic, lied about it, thats not my opinion its on the bob woodward tapes and also the resulting economic challenges that stemmed from this we did a segment on how bad the economy is right now this is the heart of President Trumps argument its what he has left, joe biden will leave the cities to burn and these suburbs will be abolished. Is that getting traction anywhere as you cover these tight races in battleground states thank you for having me and good morning to everyone the thing we see President Trump relying on the most to cater to that base group of supporters is the message you pointed out, willie but on top of the fear message hes pushing the idea that donald trump is the brand, the product, that he is once again selling to voters in hopes hes still an appealing enough product to them. You see that at some of the trump boat parades weve seen around labor day, at the rallies hes still holing when people print out their own trump flags and drape themselves with these flags. We see how this cult of perso l personalty is something that the president is leaning into. But its working with a small group of voters. To your point, there are those around the country who have viewed his handling of the coronavirus negatively thats something that happened with voters 65 and up who made up 20 of the electorate in 2016, but its not enough for the president to rely on the small group of voters. The question is now if he turns to a persuasion strategy or turnout strategy or a turnout strategy that tries to depress turnout among likely democratic voters. Here is more audio of President Trump telling bob woodward that he knew quite well how dangerous the coronavirus was. This is from mid april its not playing. Okay all right. We have it now are we ready to go with it . Lets play with it. This thing is a killer. If youre the wrong person you dont have a chance. Yes, yes, exactly. Just rips you apart. This is the scourge it is the plague. I mean, my god, gene robinson, publicly hes still today, yesterday, last night putting people inside next to each other and yet he knows that theyre look at the number on the screen were at 196,000 thousand people dead well be past 200. These people die alone and the president knows. The president knows they die alone, hopefully possibly in a hospital but alone with people who cant touch them, talk to them, help them. Mostly on ventilators. Thats it. If youre on a ventilator, chances are youre not getting out. You cant say goodbye your life is over. This is a painful, horrible, lonely death that tens of thousands of people in america, a thousand a day, are going through. And yesterday he created more coronavirus spreading by putting people together inside scientists will prove that tulsas numbers weeks later proved that. As we do numbers two to three weeks after these events, you will see the numbers go up in coronavirus. Gene, you look at the people so close to each other, and then the reporter interviewing him afterwards, the reporter was 5 feet away wearing a mask and donald trump said he was afraid of her because she was too close to him yeah, i know. Its its incredible. So this rips you apart this is it is the plague, he says he knows exactly how deadly this disease can be you look at that crowd, that crowd in phoenix, look at the demographics of that crowd, the number of people who are over 60, in the high risk group, who have, you know, one obvious cofactor, which is obesity, probably other cofactors, it is entirely predictable that there are people who will get sick and some, sadly, who will die because of that event last night in phoenix and that is you know, what does President Trump care about, he cares about himself he cares about his own reelection, his own health. And as he said to that reporter, oh its really no problem because im up here on the stage, im away from the petrie dish out there i created of infection. It is stunning and youre right to play that and play it again because we should never rush past the fact that he knew he knew all along and he has lied consistently and in a way that is that has been deadly. That has been deadly for tens of thousands of americans who didnt have to die had this been had he been truthful, effective in handling this pandemic. That tape we played was from april 13th, the day after Easter Easter was the day on the calendar the president circled as time to open the country again. A day later hes saying this thing is a plague, it rips you apart, its easily transmissable. He knew this for a week. Whats your sense of the impact of the woodward book hes tried to dismiss it you cant dismiss something where your voice is on tape, on record is this going to hurt him in the final days of the election is it going to stay around it probably will. Heres the thing this is the thing that bugs me the most the insult to i think everyones intelligence about, he did this because he didnt want to create a panic. And his supporters are going out and saying this is true. This is a guy who tries to create panic on his twitter feed every day. If joe biden wins the low Income Housing is going to take over your suburbs and the agitators and rioters are going to take over and we saw in 2018 the caravan freakout before election day. So the idea he doesnt want people to panic is insulting to everyones intelligence. I read half of the book. I havent gotten to the coronavirus issues yet the first half speaks mainly about three members of his administration, james mattis, rex tillerson, and dan coates and Foreign Policy and even thats a disaster so but its a question of whether or not joe biden can keep his eye on the ball here and really hone in on coronavirus as the one major factor that can keep those kind of wobbly republicans, you were talking before about is there a middle im not sure there is. But i think theres probably some Republican Voters who are not on the fence between the two candidates but rather between voting and not voting. And thats where trump is going to that is where hes most at risk. Well have bob woodward on the show tomorrow. Hell be with us on morning joe. We have hours of questions for him. We look forward to that. Jay caruso thanks so much. President trump was out west looking at the damage from the wildfires. Authorities searching for missing people, firefighters battling to keep a number of blazes from reaching populated communities up and down the west coast. Joining us from ashland, oregon miguel almaguer. Good morning whats the latest there . Reporter these are the most destructive wildfires we have seen in oregon state history later this week we were hoping for rain to aleave the situation here were hearing it could actually turn into lightning, now, though, its exactly what they do not need. These are the apocalyptic scenes firefighters in oregon face. This morning dozens remain unaccounted for. Its the worst thing i have ever seen in my life. Reporter six towns virtually wiped off the map, destroyed by the flames in minutes. Along highway 99, it looks like a war zone it is remarkable how unrecognizable all of these buildings are. Reporter across the west, at least 35 are dead with more fatalities expected. Travis cook just learned his brother justin and mother kathy lost their lives in oregons beachy creek fire. I never thought of anything like this. Its unbelievable. I wake up in the mornings and its like, is this really happening . Reporter in california, 28 wildfires are now burning across the state. President trump who attended a wildfire briefing in sacramento pressed on the role of Climate Change. Itll start getting cooler. You just watch. I wish science agreed with you. I dont think science knows exactly. Reporter governor gavin newsom disagreed. The hots are getting hotter, the dries are getting dryer. Reporter with 85 wildfires burning in the west, breathing can be a chore air quality in portland, seattle, San Francisco and los angeles now among the worst in the world. We started to wear the n95s rather than just the cloth masks because of the ash. Reporter today alaska air is suspending all flights in and out of portland and washington due to Poor Visibility satellite images show how far the smoke is traveling to the east as far as new york but not high enough to be a danger and to the west 1,000 miles off the Pacific Coast the smoke has formed a cyclone storm these views showing the widespread disaster below. The wildfires here in oregon for the most part are now burning in the mountains and not threatening homes, but the bad news is theyll likely burn well into the winter. Willie. Stunning images day after day from there thank you for bringing that to us mika lets get to some of the stories making headlines this morning. Alexi navalny is recoverying from a poison attack this image was shared on social media showing the opposition activist in his hospital bed surrounded by his wife and two children incredible. Its incredible navalny had been in a medically induced coma at a berlin hospital since last month. Despite that near death experience hes cracking jokes noting that hes breathing on his own and he highly recommends it the German Government announced that labs in france and sweden confirmed the substance used to poison navalny was the form of a nerve agent novichok results that match berlins own findings and provide additional confidence that the russian state was involved despite the threat to his life, he says he plans to return to russia as soon as possible willie, heres just one more example of remember the last time i spoke with john mccain, he was talking about another political figure in russia that Vladimir Putin had killed. This time it appears that the attempted assassination was just that, attempted. And remarkably enough, this dissident for democracy appears willing to go back to russia incredible courage. Incredible courage and thank god hes able to sit up and joke with his family right now. It was just 10 days ago that President Trump said there was no proof he was poisoned thats how he responds to any story around russia, whether its allegations of russia directing taliban backed militants to kill american troops in afghanistan or Vladimir Putin having dissidents killed, President Trump will not cross putin on these issues. In his first interview since being a key witness in the impeachment trial, retired Army Lieutenant colonel Alexander Vindman claims that President Trump is being used by russias Vladimir Putin when asked if he thought trump was an asset of russian intelligence or being blackmailed by them, vindman told the atlantic, quote, President Trump should be considered to be a useful idiot and a fellow traveler, which makes him an unwitting agent of putin that may or may not have dirt on them but they dont have to use it. They have more effective and less risky ways to employ him. Adding, quote, in the army we call this free chicken, something you dont have to work for. It just comes to you this is what the russians have in trump, free chicken if you look at Bob Woodwards book, and i know jay was saying before that he was reading the part of the book, mika, that i had been reading, the first half of it going through the Foreign Policy appointees of donald trump and you had the director of national intelligence, the person responsible for overseeing all of our intel agencies continuing to wonder about donald trump and how he was compromised, why Vladimir Putin had such sway over him, and he could never find the information he was looking for, but he knew, talking to bob woodward and talking to other people that something was just not right and that relationship was deeply disturbing. Now to this a 19yearold audit found that postmaster general louis dejoys former company was awarded noncompetitive contracts that may have cost the Postal Service at least 53 million more than it should have a review of the 2001 report shows that new breed logistics was awarded more than 300 million in Postal Service mail equipment, transport contracts in the 1990s while dejoy was running the company. Reports of the audit raises additional questions over the postmasters business practices. A spokesman told nbc news the audit was a review of the postal contracting and not of new breed. Alexi, it may end up that one of the poorest life choices mr. Dejoy ever made was taking on a position that he was not recommended for out of, i think, a group of like 50 possible candidates we have this story coming up of an ig report where he got tens of millions of dollars, probably more, in overcharges we also had a report a week or so ago that he had moved money around in a sort of a shell game with his employees to illegally give candidates more money than he was legally entitled to give them which, of course, people go to jail for doing that. Dejoy continues to face problems whats the response from democrats on the hill . Whats the plan moving forward right yeah, i mean, thank you for ticking through all that to give everyone a reminder how crazy things have been lately. Democrats on the hill are seeking and demanding answers. To your point, joe, all the things you ticked through requires more answers to get through a solution to remedy those problems that louis dejoy has created and that people fear hes creating now just months if before an election in which a lot of people are going to be relying on the Postal Service to even participate in our democratic process one thing im thinking about, of course, is this is the pattern weve seen with President Trump and the folks that he likes to install personally in his high profile positions that dont come at the recommendations of others or experts or folks who have come before them but rather are selected by President Trump because he thinks theyll show this loyalty and level of loyalty that he demands of the people around him. We see the ways in which that creates press briefings not just at the post office but across the board with President Trump in the folks hes implementing Alexi Mchammond thank you, and welcome as a contributor still ahead weve been talking about the climate this morning and now Scientists Say two of the most watched glaciers in the antarctic are deteriorating. This as the president claims its going to get cooler youre watching morning joe well be right back. Thats safe drivers save 40 . It is, thats safe drivers save 40 . Hes right there. Its him safe drivers do save 40 . Click or call for a quote today. And now your copilot. Safe drivers do save 40 . Still a father. But now a friend. Still an electric car. Just more electrifying. Still a night out. But everything fits in. Still hard work. Just a little easier. Still a legend. Just more legendary. Chevrolet. Making lifes journey, just better. Tech when youve got. Safelite can come to you. Tech and youll get a text when were on our way. Tech just leave your keys on the dash and well replace your windshield with safe, nocontact service. Tech schedule at safelite. Com. Singers safelite repair, safelite replace. Now you can trade stocks and etfs for any amount you choose instead of buying by the share. All with no commissions. Stocks by the slice from fidelity. Get your slice today. Sprinting past every leak in our softest, smoothest fabric. Shes confident, protected, her strength respected. Depend. The only thing stronger than us, is you. I feel like were forglet me check. Ing. Xfinity home gives you peace of mind from anywhere with professionally monitored Home Security built around you. No, i think were good. Good. So when youre away, you dont have to worry. The tent. We forgot. The tent. Except about that. Xfinity home. Simple, easy, awesome. Hey look, i found the tent and, see, its safe. Call, click, or visit a store today. We want to work with you to really recognize the changing climate and what it means to our forests and actually Work Together with that science, that science is going to be key, because if we ignore that science and sort of put our head in the sand and think its all about Vegetation Management were not going to succeed together okay. Itll start getting cooler you just watch. I wish science agreed with you. I dont think science knows, actually painful. The stupidity ugliness. He knows. Safe to say you can just actually say without being concerned that its opinion. Its an objective fact that that was a remarkably stupid thing to say that shows continued contempt contempt. For science, for education, learning our country, our world. For the enlightenment. You name it thats what the president showed contempt for. Science doesnt know it will start getting cooler that sounds like, itll go away. Trust me, itll go away when it gets warmer. Didnt go away, actually the coronavirus accelerated. Heres something that science does know. New satellite images show two glaciers are rapidly deteriorating. According to the Washington Post, glaciers located in west antarctica, most watched by scientists over recent decades are among the fastest changing glaciers in the region a new image shows the naturally occurring buffer system that prevents the glaciers from flowing outward is breaking down and could unleash far more ice into the sea in coming years the survival of one of those glaciers, about the size of florida, has been deemed so critical that the u. S. And britain have launched a targeted multimillion Dollar Research mission. The loss could trigger the collapse of the west Antarctic Ice sheet which contains enough ice to raise seas eventually by 10 feet. For the president , thats bad. Joining Us Senior National Affairs Correspondent at the Washington Post, juliette, and ambassador mark bra zip ask you, he was brought to the white house by president obama to stand up a new office called the arctic executive steering committee. The goal of the office was to closely coordinate from the white house a unified u. S. Government approach to the future of the arctic, which is at stake right now so this segment is sort of old home week because i knew juliette, she covered congress when i was there, which is actually was as much of a disaster as Climate Change and, of course, mika knows mark somehow. Somehow juliette lets start with you. Its good to see you again you, of course, are having to follow right now, two extraordinarily disturbing climate related stories, one on the west coast and the other involving Climate Change and the possibility of a set of dominos beginning to fall that could raise sea levels 10 feet try to put this in perspective for us who dont do this every day. Were seeing these visible impacts of Climate Change across the globe. Thats what were seeing when you look at whats happening, for example, in california and across the west, you have these huge fires, which are clearly linked to Climate Change, scientists have found that fires out west are 50 more intense and had the the season has been extended by weeks as a result of human contributions to Climate Change. And then what were seeing in the west antarctic and not only there, but elsewhere in terms of greenland and places in the arctic is the melting of sea ice that is accelerating as a result of rising temperatures weve seen unusually warm temperatures in the arctic as well as elsewhere. Fires in siberia this summer just huge indicators across the globe of the impacts were seeing you know, mark, this is something that obviously president obama brought you in to focus on. Yesterdays developments were obviously dire and while donald trump says that its going to get cooler, obviously the United States government and the British Government dont agree with that, because theyve been very troubled and, in fact, are doing as Much Research as they can right now on trying to figure out the longterm impacts, the economic devastation, the environmental devastation that could come if these trends we saw yesterday continue joe, President Trumps statement yesterday is one of the biggest misuses of the bully pulpit of the presidency that ive seen. The bully pulpit of the presidency is a great teaching tool the fact is that the arctic and antarctic are changing and what happens there doesnt stay there. It impacts you in your own backyard the essence of the challenge that we face is that our children and our childrens children, because of the impacts of Climate Change in the arctic, theyre going to see the basic outlines of Human Society that they inherit from us contracting, creating haves and have notes in terms of who lives well and who lives awfully the fact is, as these ice sheets melt, sea level rises and that water has to go somewhere. 6 feet sea level rise, wipes out miami beach and washington d. C think of countries that are just now at sea level, philippines, 100 Million People, bangladesh, 150 Million People where will those people go as sea level rises . Thats the essence of the challenge we face. And to dismiss science and say its going to get cooler because fall is coming is disgraceful. Joe biden put it well. This is an existential threat. So gene robinson, youre writing abourespects, it seems now that theres data backing it up. But is it at the point where people can visualize how it will impact them. What mark was just talking about completely impacts us. But do American Voters really see that thats a good question. And i think, frankly, until perhaps fairly recently, i think American Voters probably didnt. I you know, i write about Climate Change every once in a while just to be frank, those columns dont get the response that political columns do. And certainly not the intensity of response. But look around at whats happening now. Look at the west on fire look at the temperature records broken in phoenix and parts of california hottest summer ever. Look at the five tropical cyclones whirling in the atlantic at the same time. Look at the effect of sea levels that have already risen. Its not that theyre going to rise at some point they have risen, theorizing. They will rise more. So what has to penetrate and maybe its now penetrating is that Climate Change is not something thats going to happen in the future. Its something that is underway right now that we see around us. And that we must act in order to mitigate in the future because it will get much, much, much worse. And juliette, obviously most of the world agrees with genes assessment most of the world agrees with the assessment of the overwhelming number of scientists the United States of america under the leadership of donald trump is isolated right now. What is the biggest concern as you cover this day in and day out . What should americans be looking at what should americans who havent been focused on this enough start focussing on more well, you know, i mean, one of the things thats interesting is because this happens over a long period of time, it often is difficult to recognize the Washington Post, along with my colleagues, wrote a series called 2 sea where we mapped that 10 of the globe has warmed 2 degrees celsius or 3. 6 degrees fahrenheit, thats the Tipping Point globally that the world is trying to ignore right now. We found there are hot spots in areas throughout the United States, including in southern california, western colorado, in the northeast. So whats interesting is people can often look at the temperature record in their own communities and see how much things have changed over time. And by looking at that, in some cases do make the connection between whats happened with burning of fossil fuels and the temperature change but historically this has not been a high priority for voters. One of the things interesting to see is in this president ial election where there is a stark contrast and these events happening in real time, whether it will impact the conversation. Mark, lets talk about what can be done. If joe biden is elected president and i certainly know that youre supporting Vice President bidens president ial bid. What are some of the action items that he needs to do immediately that his Administration Needs to do immediately to not only change the way we do things in the United States but also to focus on china, india, some of the other countries that are the greatest po luters on the planet. The first step is to make a realistic assessment of what it is we all face the fact is that america already has its first climate refugees there are more than 30 towns in alaska that are being washed into the sea and the entire town, the schools, the people, the roads, have to be moved and placed on higher ground. Lets look at the cost of this to move a town of 60 people costs about 100 million what do you think it will cost to move a town of 30,000 people on the coast of louisiana or florida . I mean, we are looking at a 1 trillion price tag being handed to our kids that we didnt expect. We all have families that sometimes we get price tags that we sometimes dont expect. This is something that is coming down the pike. So first a realistic assessment and second a collective response is the most Effective Response the fact is this isnt just americas problem. This is a global problem and reaching out to others to build up a collective understanding of what we face in terms of the science and the response in terms of the cost would be the most responsible approach i think a Biden Administration would be more effective in generating a collective response because it seeks to unite our friends against this and not divide our friends on this ambassador Mark Brzezinski and yule yjuliette thank you for coming on this morning. Our next guests say the coronavirus has served as a wakeup call for the western world, exposing the failures of leadership particularly here in the u. S. But they have a plan on how to fix that morning joe is back in a moment donald trump warns that integration is threatening our suburbs. Thats ridiculous. You know what is threatening our suburbs . Wildfires are burning the suburbs of the west. Floods are wiping out suburban neighborhoods in the midwest hurricanes are imperilling suburban life along our coast. If we have four more years of trumps climate denial, how many suburbs will be burned, how many neighborhoods flooded out, how many suburbs will have blown away in super storms if you give a climate arsonist four more years in the white house, why would anyone be surprised if we have more america ablaze if you have a climate denier four more years in the white ushoe, why would anyone be surprised when more of america is under water from prom dresses. To soccer practices. And new adventures. You hope the more you give the less theyll miss. But even if your teen was vaccinated against meningitis in the past. They may be missing vaccination for meningitis b. Lets help protect them together. Because missing menb vaccination could mean missing out on a whole lot more. Ask your doctor if your teen is missing meningitis b vaccination. Ask your d ctorhere . Our teen nah. Here . Nope. Here. When the middle of nowhere. Is somewhere. The allnew chevy trailblazer. Verizon knows how to build unlimited right. Start with americas most awarded network. Im on my phone 24 7. Then for the first time ever, include disney , hulu and espn . Were a big soccer family. Handmaids tale. I love frozen. Then give families plans to mix and match, so you only pay for what you need. And offer it at a price built for everyone. Plus, get the Samsung Galaxy s20 5g uw on us when you buy any note20 5g. And 300 when you switch. The network more people rely on gives you more. Keeping your oysters growing while keeping your business growing has you swamped. you need to hire i need indeed indeed you do. The moment you sponsor a job on indeed you get a shortlist of quality candidates from a resume data base so you can start hiring right away. Claim your seventyfivedollar credit when you post your first job at indeed. Com promo eve going faster than a closerollercoaster love like yours will surely come my way ahey, aheyhey [music playing] love like yours will surely come my way here was the scene yesterday and earlier at the president s rally and event in arizona and never neada. You dont see much social distancing, you dont see many masks. What kind of message does that send look, President Trump believes people can make their own decisions. Weve put out guidance for how people should follow most of the president s events have been outdoors we wanted one of the events in nevada to be indoors the governor everywhere we went threatened to pull liquor licenses for anyone who would hold events. Thats Jared Kushner talking to Savannah Guthrie on the today show a few minutes ago President Trump believes people can make their own decisions, while he said to bob woodward, for example, its so easily transmissible, you wouldnt believe it he called it the plague. He said its a killer. He said it rips you apart. Joe, ill give you another quoted, and theres a lot in there with that interview with Jared Kushner, the president was very forthcoming with the American People about what he knew and when he knew it Jared Kushner said that despite all the tapes we played that were laid out by savannah in that interview, and he still after hearing that and knowing that the American Public knows exactly the way the president felt and how his private statements to woodward contradicted what he was saying publicly, he Still Believes the president was, quote, very forthcoming with the American People yeah, i just wrote down, i had seen a quick bite from the interview where Jared Kushner said that donald trump was straightforward. A couple notes here. Donald trump, he said privately, i think february 7th, that it was a deadly disease, that it was a killer, that it killed people a month later he was calling it a democratic hoax. He said that it was a plague on april the 13th also talked about how this didnt just kill old people, that this was really bad it hurt younger people, too. This was the same time when he was calling it a plague and after he admitted it hurt younger people, that he was going crazy trying to get people to put their kids back in school, not in the fall, in the spring and to open up businesses by easter. There would be a at the same time he was privately calling it a plague. Another thing thats very instructive about Jared Kushner, in the bob woodward book, Jared Kushner basically says to woodward, hey, listen, okay, so he lies. Heres the deal, heres how it works here if the president says something or we Say Something and were liars, that actually is good, because what it does is it gets the media to talk about it even more so, if Donald Trumps a liar and im a liar, Jared Kushner says, and i go out and say its the best economy that weve ever had, yeah, sure were lying, but guess what, the media will talk about it and our opponents will talk about it, and that will be good for us. Thats so sick. Im sorry im sorry. I can think of some historical parallels of people who spoke this way but because its early in the morning, and i would rather have a calm, comfortable day, i wont draw those historical comparisons. But it suggests that americans that are watching this show read some history and draw whatever parallels you want to draw yourself but, no, Jared Kushner said, okay, the more we lie, the more we tell deliberate untruths, the more controversy we cause, and the more people are talking about donald trump and the more theyre talking about the things we want them to talk about so that is who you just saw on television that is whos helping to run the white house. And that is the philosophy that he has gained from his fatherinlaw, who continues to lie about everything because he knows it numbs people, causes a controversy and he considers that good for him. And Jared Kushners the same guy who said in april that this is a Great Success story, talking about the federal government and President Trumps response to coronavirus. He said the economy will be rocking and rolling by june. He went back to that line this morning with savannah. He said, we rose to the challenge as a federal government President Trump rose to the challenge, said Jared Kushner, despite everything weve now heard in the woodward tapes. Well come back to that story in a minute, but willie, really quickly. Almost 200,000 americans dead. To put it in perspective, the United States has 4. 5 of the worlds population and about 25 of the worlds deaths from coronavirus. It is a staggering failure of historic proportions historians for decades to come will remember how donald trump, when faced with the greatest crisis of his presidency, which is National Security adviser told him this would be on january the 28th of this year, donald trump decided to lie to the American People, decided not to use the defense production act, decided not to use the federal government to push forward testing, to push forward ppe, to push forward all the things that his advisers were begging him to do, and as a result, we have 200,000 people dead and historians will have to sort out how many of those lives could have been saved if donald trump had decided from the start to tell the truth to the American People instead of continually lie. On the subject of governments handling of this pandemic, lets turn to editorinchief of bloomberg news, jonathan, and editor of the economist, coauthors of the wake up call why the pandemic has exposed the weakness of the west and how to fix it. Good morning john, let me begin with you. There are lots of places we could point to failures. Leadership, we were talking about that health care systems, federal government not being able to get the products it needs out to state governments. You can talk about inequality thats been exposed, how wealthy people, we were talking about the economy, have done fine during this and poor people have suffered the most, particularly communities of color where do you begin as you attack this question . Well, almost, joe, its like he just read the book because the whole book is saying when historians look back at this year, theyre going to look at the numbers and say, why did america end up with around 600 deaths per million you go to asia and you come up with numbers like 20 deaths per million, 10, 5, these are countries like south korea, singapore, japan china claims a number of three, which none of us really believe. Even if theyre lying by a factor of ten, even if theyre hiding 90 of the deaths, that would still mean xi jinping has been better at protecting people than donald trump by a factor of 20 what were saying is pretty much what joe is saying historians are going to look back at this year and ask fundamental questions, first, why american why was this the year when maybe asia began to pull ahead the reason we called it the wakeup call is because we think people need to go and set this in the complex of history, they need to understand the big political theories of the past, we look at those and we ask the question now that people need to answer because everything that the bob woodward book says is fascinating, none of that will matter to historians when they look back at this year, theyll look and say, is this the year asia moved ahead of america if america doesnt respond. Where does it begin for you when you look at the differences in the countries that have fared better than, say, the United States during this whats the disfiction for you . The fundamental distinction is Good Government what weve learned from this crisis is government really matters. Its not enough to dismiss government as something thats irrelevant and say is that all that matters is the strength of the productive private economy government is the difference between living and dying for many people. America has failed the Good Government test. Britain has failed the Good Government test. Some western countries have succeeded. New zealand, obviously, germany has done quite well. The governments that have passed the Good Government test are overwhelmingly in the east china is one of them singapore another of them. Korea, south korea, vietnam, to some extent, and also taiwan and what this tells us is that the west for the last 400 years the west has been ahead of the east when it comes to government thats been our success. Thats been our competitive advantage, that weve had Good Government that can secure order, that can sponsor innovation and things like that. Now that advantage is has gone, is going, is disappearing, its moving to the east. We have to wake up to this fact that Government Matters and were falling behind in the race for Good Government. And whats fascinating, you talk about those Asian Countries, some of those countries are totalitarian, autocratic, some are free, but across all forms theyre doing better than us weve grown up ill speak for myself, but ive always grown up with this sort of superior attitude, sort of the americananglo alliance when it came to us figuring out how to do things than, say, the french, or even other european countries. What a comeuppance we have had that its been that angloamerican alliance thats failed most spectacularly if you look at just the per capita deaths in our in the countries. It is the United States and Great Britain that is doing far worse than the Asian Countries or, say, germany absolutely. What weve been brought up, complace complacency. We assume we do things right, we do things better than these faroff countries and it hasnt proven to be the case. Whats more extraordinary about this, this virus started off in china, spread to east asia and and instead of looking what they were doing, learning from them, we have an advantage in terms of time, but we didnt use that time to learn from them. And that is because of complacency. We just think were the best and extraordinarily, were no longer the best. In so many ways were actually at the bottom of the Global League that is the wakeup call were trying to sound in this book our thanks to both John Micklethwait and adrian woolridge. The new book is the wake up call. Just ahead, when asked if he was concerned about covid spreading at his indoor rally yesterday, the president said, not at all, because hes far away on a stage. He did not appear to express concern about anybody else that and much more on what the president knew and when he knew it america is continuing to make critical progress at our war against the virus. Over the weekend the number of daily new infections remain flat nationwide, flat hospitalizations are slowing in hot spots like new york, new jersey, michigan and louisiana this is clear evidence that our aggressive strategy to combat the virus is working that was President Trump on april 13th, touting his administrations progress fighting the virus sounds good that same day, april 13th, he was also saying this only behind closed doors this thing is a killer if it gets you if youre the wrong person, you dont have a chance. Yes, yes, exactly so, this this is a scourge and it is the plague. If youre the wrong person, willie, donald trump says on the 13th of april, privately, of course, you dont have a chance. This is the plague and yet this is, of course, the same president who was desperate to reopen the economy. And i must say, the same president who last night got a lot of people together in arizona with with this plague that he also told bob woodward was so dangerous and deadly because it was airborne. This is a plague that donald trump obviously understood about a long time ago and yet he was trying to open schools, trying to open the economy. At the same time he was saying that behind closed doors and, of course, hes still having superspreader events where most of the people there are not Wearing Masks. Its amazing. So, that was april 13th, the clip we just played. That was on a monday he was talking to bob woodward. What was the day before that april 12th was easter. Easter was the day he circled on the calendar to reopen everything, and everyone does remember, well be back in church, well be playing baseball by easter this is the next dade hes calling it the plague. He said it rips you apart. He says this thing is a killer its really been stunning over the last week as these woodward tapes have come out how to the day you can find President Trump saying Something Different publicly than he was saying privately, or the next day or the day before on and on and on bob woodward, this book is going to be out, hell be on with us tomorrow well hear new audio tomorrow. These tapes come out and the president is constantly, over the course of this entire pandemic, saying something entirely different to the public than he knows to be true and has revealed so by talking to bob woodward. You know, Jonathan Lemire, lets pull in Jonathan Lemire because he was at the president s event in arizona and nevada, where a really dangerous situation. Nobody Wearing Masks most people not Wearing Masks inside except, of course, in nevada, those people closest to the president standing behind him on stage. Funny how that works but you have the president talking about how this is a plague, its airborne. If youre the wrong person, it ri rips you apart and, quote, youre finished. Youll notice donald trump doesnt have a ton of people around him packed in like this because, well, its not him. But hes convinced those people, and hes convinced millions of other people, that this is no worse than the flu, even though he told bob woodward its a hell of a lot worse than the flu and more dangerous and donald trump islingly leading all of these people to put their lives and the lives of their loved ones at rick i suppose it just doesnt matter to people that are in the personality cult, but,on th ojon lemire, it does matter to Senior Citizens who they know, as donald trump said, quote, are finished by this plague. Cant believe its helping him in florida cant believe its helping him with seniors across america. Joe, this is the tone he set right from the beginning in the early days of this pandemic. He deliberately underplayed it to the American People he downplayed its obvious insidious effects. How lethal it is for seniors and others in other audiotape he acknowledges its dangerous for young people hes still disputing that saying children are all but immune and science does not back that up. What we saw this weekend was striking it was a western trip for the president , his first in quite some time, heading out to nevada first and then arizona, looking to expand his electoral map with nevada because, in large part, hes losing in arizona he had a rally outdoors saturday night in northern nevada near reno, where, you know, certainly people were not in masks certainly there was not much social distancing. Again it was at least outside. It was a big crowd thats the formula theyve been using lately whether in airport hangars or elsewhere keeping people outside after his last attempt at an indoor rally, june, in tulsa, went so poorly there was a coronavirus spike traced directly to that event. Of course, we know herman cain, who was there, died a few weeks later of covid19. Though, of course, we dont know for certain that is where he got it suddenly, though, the plan changed. Sunday night in nevada, in henderson, just outside las vegas, an indoor event an event the campaign did not advise to the reporters traveling with the president would be indoors in the hours before that event started, most of the networks pulled out their correspondents, they pulled them from the warehouse that was packed with several thousand people, very few in masks no social distancing because it wasnt safe the press pool, of which i was a part did, indeed, attend youre right, joe, you nailed on something a second ago there was a section of people set up behind the president. They had masks on. A staffer was spotted making sure they were wearing them before the president took the stage. How interesting that, huh they werent wearing them when the earlier speakers were on before the cameras turned on, before the rally was taken live on a few channels, they were told to put on masks unbelievable. Then we had a similar scene lets just get this straight. So, donald trump is mocking people Wearing Masks he has rallies where he has people coming in and everybodys showing their unity with the president by not Wearing Masks, which, of course, is very dangerous. The president has called this the plague he called it the plague back in april, back when he was trying to reopen the country. Said its airborne, which makes it so dangerous. You can get it airborne just being next to somebody, and once you get it, if youre the wrong person, youre finished. This is really, really bad its really deadly but the president , though, if people are in his proximity, they have to wear masks. I think thats pretty revealing. But if you are in a personality cult, you may not be able to sort through all of that here, let me help you, the president s concerned about himself and not you. Speaking about people being concerned about themselves, this is the time, were coming up on an election. How exciting this is when the president flies into town and everybody thats on the ballot, especially in close races, they all stand up on stage and they all, like, hold their arms up for the president and everybodys cheerful. Unity. Unity and, you know, they think it might help him get over the finish line. What was Martha Mcsallys key moment last night at this rally . What did she say in support of donald trump this is this is maybe she introduced him. This is what i love about american politics. This is the pageantry of it. They always do this. What did Martha Mcsally say in arizona at this donald trump rally when he came to her state with her whole career in the senate on the line well, joe, it might surprise you to learn that Martha Mcsally wasnt there yesterday in phoenix when the president came to town. What . Ill say that again Martha Mcsally wasnt there. Im glad are you sure . Yeah, joe, im glad youre sitting down right now but she was not there. The governor of arizona did was there, greeted the president at the airport when he landed in arizona at phoenix after we had come from california wildfires. Jonathan, the governor of arizona, i guess, since he was there, hes up on the ballot in november, is that right . Thats why he was there . The governor made a point of yes, the governor was there, joe it should be noted as well, the governor attended the event afterwards it wasnt just at the airport, he went to this latinos rally. It was called a latinos for trump roundtable he had had one the day before in las vegas that consisted of six people, small, socially distanced. Right but jonathan, what im saying is the governor was there, so he must have an election coming up this year, right is he on the ballot in a month and a half in november thats right, joe is he yes or no . Do you know . I dont think he is, joe. I dont think he is. Okay. I dont understand this. Wait i know. Willie, this is the strangest thing in the world can you because, you know, im just such im not a dumb country lawyer willie, im feeling this morning more like a caveman lawyer so, Jonathan Lemire with that new York City Press outfit, the Associated Press, is saying that the arizona candidate, who doesnt have an election coming up in the next month and a half, was there with president donald j. Trump, but the senatorial candidate, whos fighting for her political life, and you think would be the first person there would be there with donald trump, arms up in the air maybe she thought it was too dangero dangerous. To support donald trump and attack reporters and play the whole maga game. You think she would have been there jumping up and down with the president. Isnt this a Strange Development . Its a very Strange Development, as youre indicating im picking up on the subtlety of what youre saying. I dont understand. I think what youre saying, governor ducey, hes termlimited theres not a Gubernatorial Election until 2022 so he had no concerns there Martha Mcsally, in a tight race against mark kelly in the state of arizona was not available because she had Senate Business to attend to, we heard so she was tied up with that either she was concerned that she didnt want to be on a stage with donald trump in a tight election in the state of arizona, or, perhaps, she was concerned for her own safety as many others were in a tightly packed room. Maybe, you know, maybe, willie, she has underlying conditions so maybe twook dangerous for her or maybe she just wanted to follow proper social distancing guidelines, because if you were following proper social distancing guidelines, whether you have underlying conditions or not, you dont want to get the coronavirus. One way to avoid it is not to go to a superspreader event where people are all clustered together and breathing all over each other with masks. Speaking of the Las Vegas Review journal on sunday, the president was asked about whether he had any safety concerns when it comes to Holding Indoor rallies. Heres that exchange. Are you concerned about getting covid, though, in an enclosed rally no. Im more concerned about how close you are. Sorry about that. You know why . Im on a stage its very far away so im not at all concerned. So, hes not concerned about himself because hes on stage. Yeah, but hold on, willie all the other people are hes saying the out loud parts that he should be keeping inside that head of his because yes, yes, im starting to notice that. So, hes five or six feet away from this reporter and hes concerned shes five or six feet away, and yet he has events where he jams people in. And even in tulsa, staff were removing those signs that were supposed to keep people apart from one another why, some might even say, that is so selfish, it could endanger the lives of his very supporters, willie. It was on display last night, as jonathan described very well. For the public they want to see the masks behind him so the tv cameras are shooting President Trump, masks, we get it, this is bad, but were fine to fill this place up, packed shoulder to shoulder with our supporters despite weve heard President Trump say on tape again and danny again, its deadly stuff, its airborne t can be transmitted that way, its a killer and what he told bob woodward, its the plague. The reason he was uncomfortable with that reporter that close to him for his own personal safety is because he knows all of these things and has said it on tape to bob woodward. Still ahead, more on the most embattled members in the u. S. Senate. How those vulnerable incumbents are trying to thread the neelgsdz this november youre wchating morning joe. Customizes your car insurancekl so you only pay for what you need . I should get a quote. Do it. Only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. [camera man] actually anyone 50 or over is at increased risk for shingles. The pain, the burning my husband had to do everything for weeks. And the thing is, theres nothing you can do about it [camera man] well, shingles can be prevented. Shingles can be whaaat . [camera man] prevented. You can get vaccinated. Frank they have shingles vaccines whaaat . Thats what i said. Were taking you to the doctor. Not going through that again. [camera man] you can also get it from your pharmacist talk to your doctor or pharmacist about getting vaccinated. Talk to your doctor or pharmacist keeping your oysters growing while keeping your business growing has you swamped. you need to hire i need indeed indeed you do. The moment you sponsor a job on indeed you get a shortlist of quality candidates from a resume data base so you can start hiring right away. Claim your seventyfivedollar credit when you post your first job at indeed. Com promo noand if youre troubledan a liby falls and bleeds,ners. Worry follows you everywhere. Over 100,000 people have left blood thinners behind with watchman. Its a onetime, minimally invasive procedure that reduces stroke risk and bleeding worryfor life. Watchman. Its one time. For a lifetime. And now your copilot. Still a father. But now a friend. Still an electric car. Just more electrifying. Still a night out. But everything fits in. Still hard work. Just a little easier. Still a legend. Just more legendary. Chevrolet. Making lifes journey, just better. No uh uh, no way come on, no no nnnnono only discover has no annual fee on any card. Lets bring into the conversation senior Political Correspondent for the washington xmer, david drucker. Its interesting in 1994 in the midterm elections, i remember reading articles, the first year i ran, and i remember reading articles talking about how some members of Congress Said they would put antiaircraft guns, these are democrats, on the border of their districts saying if bill clintons air force one came their direction, they would fire warning shots to keep him away thats how little they wanted bill clinton in their district back in 1994 there was, of course, a massive landslide. Im not sure thats not exactly how mcsally, cory gardner, thom tillis, certainly Susan Collins and a lot of other atrisk republicans are feeling right now. Yeah, look, its been interesting to watch different vulnerable republicans and how theyre playing President Trump. Susan collins has tried to distance herself shes trying to deal with the fact that the coalition she has relied on for years, moderate republicans and moderate democrats and stalwart republicans could keep her in office even if the state turned blue are in trouble because President Trump is such polarizing figure that shes losing a lot of the women shes relied on. That race is tight mcsally, notwithstanding the fact she wasnt with the president yesterday, shes really tied herself to trump part of her challenge is that on the one hand the phoenix and tucson suburbs have really moved away from President Trump, who did win the suburban vote in the exit polling four years ago, but they really moved away from trump. But arizonas Republican Base is very, very, very loyal to trump. So, shes trying to thread a needle that may be impossible, but shes decided to keep herself very close to trump and go that route. And i think cory gardner is just trying to separate himself from everybody. Part of the challenge he faces is colorado is a blue state for all intents and purposes it cant totally be ignored. I think if any republican is capable of getting a crossover vote and surviving, it would be him because hes very skilled but hes in a tough race its simply because the president is not popular in colorado all of these downballot republicans, i think, are trying to deal with on the one hand a Republican Base that is loyal to the president , but on the other hand, a suburban voting bloc and others that simply think any republican who is supportive of President Trump has got to go. Is it safe to say that mar it ha mcsally in arizona and Corey Gardner in colorado, those two republicans in two adjoining western states, is it safe to say theyre probably the two most endangered republicans that are going to be running for reelection this year in the senate i think theyre two of the most endangered. I go back and forth on Susan Collins. But i think gardner and mcsally probably have the steepest challenges its interesting because gardner is a very skilled politician i think mcsally has had sort of fits and starts where she cant seem to figure out always what kind of republican she wants to be she started out her career as a house member, more of a john mccain style republican, winning a leaning Democratic House in tough races so she knows how to appeal across the aisle. But in responding to her Republican Base in arizona, shes become more trumpy, for lack of a better word. I think gardner has been more consistent its just a matter if he can survive a democratic onslaught in the denver suburbs. We saw two years ago, congressman kaufman, who worked as hard as any ive seen, with nonwhite voters and suburban voters, simply was swept away because he had an r next to his name mcsally, gardner, both in deep trouble. Susan collins. I know republicans are optimistic shes going to pull a rabbit out of a hat because she survived for so long there, doing what she does. Also won a tough race. I keep an eye on thom tillis simply because of a fundraising edge that Joe Cunningham has i also note, we still have so much time for different aspects of the campaign to influence the vote there are going to be three president ial debates this news cycle seems to bring us a new, you know, this is the thing thats going to determine the campaign every couple of days and as we saw in 2016, there were a lot of endangered republican senators that survived senator toomey in pennsylvania, senator johnson in wisconsin a lot of times things happen that were not thinking will happen. Coming up well talk to republican congressman tom cole. First, the american crisis a new collection by the atlantic examines a country in chaos. Everyday its agetting closer going faster than a rollercoaster love like yours will surely come my way ahey, aheyhey [music playing] love like yours will surely come my way that life of the party look walk it off look one more mile look reply all look own your look. With fewer lines. Theres only one botox® cosmetic. Its the only one. Fda approved. To temporarily make frown lines. Crows feet. And forehead lines. Look better. The effects of botox® cosmetic, may spread hours to weeks after injection, causing serious symptoms. Alert your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems, or muscle weakness may be a sign of a lifethreatening condition. Do not receive botox® cosmetic if you have a skin infection. Side effects may include allergic reactions, injection site pain, headache, eyebrow, eyelid drooping, and eyelid swelling. Tell your doctor about your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions, and medications including botulinum toxins as these may increase the risk of serious side effects. So, give that just saw a puppy look. And whatever that look is. Look like you. With fewer lines. See results at botoxcosmetic. Com managing youre on it. Es . Staying fit and snacking light . Yup, on it there too. You may think youre doing all you can to manage type 2 diabetes and heart disease. But could your medication do more to lower your heart risk . Jardiance can reduce the risk of cardiovascular death for adults who also have known heart disease. So, it could help save your life from a heart attack or stroke. And it lowers a1c. Jardiance can cause serious side effects including dehydration,. Genital yeast or urinary tract infections, and sudden kidney problems. Ketoacidosis is a serious side effect that may be fatal. A rare but lifethreatening bacterial infection in the skin of the perineum could occur. Stop taking jardiance and call your doctor right away if you have symptoms of this bacterial infection, ketoacidosis, or an allergic reaction. And dont take it if youre on dialysis or have severe kidney problems. Taking jardiance with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Lower a1c and lower risk of a fatal heart attack . On it with jardiance. Ask your doctor about jardiance. I feel like were forglet me check. Ing. Xfinity home gives you peace of mind from anywhere with professionally monitored Home Security built around you. No, i think were good. Good. So when youre away, you dont have to worry. The tent. We forgot. The tent. Except about that. Xfinity home. Simple, easy, awesome. Hey look, i found the tent and, see, its safe. Call, click, or visit a store today. I get along very well wither ed wan even though youre not supposed to its funny the relationships i have, the tougher and meaner they are, the better i get along with them youll explain that to me some day, okay . But maybe its not a bad thing the easy ones are the ones maybe i dont like as much or dont get along with as much thats unwithone of the rece released clips with Journalist Bob Woodward and donald trump back in january. Meanwhile, michael capu it o, the Top Communications official at the department of health and Human Services, left wing hit squads were being trained for an armed insurrection after a contested election and accused government scientists of, quote, sedition according to the new york times, caputo in a 26minute video he hosted live on his personal facebook page, accused of cdc of harboring a, quote, Resistance Unit determined to undermine trump. He said cdc scientists, quote, havent gotten out of their sweatpants except for meetings at coffee shops to plot how theyre going to attack donald trump next adding, quote, there are scientists who work for this government who do not want america to get well. Not until after joe biden is president. The times also reports caputo predicted the president would win reelection in november but his democratic opponents would refuse to concede leading to violence he said, quote, when donald trump refuses to stand down at the inauguration, the shooting will begin the drills that youve seen are nothing. He told his followers, quote, if you carry guns, buy ammunition ladies and gentlemen, because its going, to be hard to get. Caputo faces criticism for leading efforts to interfere with the cdc Health Reports to fit the pandemic narrative, he suggested on sunday that he personally could be in danger from his opponents of the administration and said that his Mental Health has definitely failed he said, quote, i dont like being alone in washington, describing shadows on the ceiling in my apartment, there alone shadows are so long. He said the mounting number of coronavirus deaths were taking a toll on him. In a statement the department of health and Human Services said, mr. Caputo is an integral part of President Trumps response as americans need Public Health information to defeat the covid19 pandemic. So, yes, the Trump Administration confirmed that a man who basically said civil war was going to break out after this years election and that people listening needed to get ammunition to target leftwing, quote, hit squads that hes imagining in his mind, that that was an important part of this administration lets bring in right now staff writer at the new yorker and author of the book surviving autocracy, author of twilight of democracy, Anne Applebaum and editorinchief of the atlantic, Jeffrey Goldberg, and the american crisis is out today published by the atlantic in recent years. Masha, lets begin with you. I, of course, read your book and annes book and have recommended it to anybody i get a chance to talk to. It seems everything you warned about in your book, mr. Caputo yesterday confirmed. Yes, in my book i talk about an autocratic attempt. This is a term i borrowed from hungarian political moderist i think according to his model, which actually fits our situation very well, were now in the autocratic attempt stage of the process, which may end on november 3rd or whenever our election season ends and may lead to an autocratic breakthrough but speaking of Michael Caputo, i dont think Michael Caputo said anything that his boss doesnt say on a regular basis we have become so accustomed to. It only stands out when somebody we dont expect to be spouting hateful, crazy lies every day, says the same things well, this goes to a line from your book that ive underlined the outrageous is rendered ordinary and you go on at some length, and i think its extraordinarily valuable insight, that regular political lexicon that we use to define not only elections but american democracy, somehow fails us when you have autocratic actions and autocratic attempts going on before our very eyes. Absolutely. When we talk about part of the reason the model i use developed this model was because he realized that he used the language of liberal democracy. Talking about free and fair elections. Talking about freedom of the media are inadequate for describing these systems thats not what we should be looking at of course, we should be looking at elections but thats not where most of the rhetorical and cultural and political shifts are happening. Anne, in reading your book, theres a line that always came back to me i think its very haunting you were talking about the law and Justice Party took over in 2015 you talked about them going after state media. You talked about them going after the judiciary and then you talked about them deconstructing the state, just like donald trump has attempted to do. Theres a line that i always keep going back to, and its this there was very little pretense about any of this the point of these changes was not to make government run better the point was to make government more partisan, the courts more pliable, more beholden to the party. Again, i go back to it there was very little pretense about any of this. And, my god, who could not listen to the tapes of bob woodward interviewing donald trump and not be staggered by that very fact in america about a crisis that wasnt just about making courts more pliable but in a crisis thats already killed 200,000 americans yes, i think one of the difficulties weve all had with trying to understand trump is we expect we expect him to keep secrets. We expect him not to tell us that he prefers the company of authoritarians over americas allies we expect him not to ask the russians for help in his election campaign, but because he did all of those things openly and publicly, because theres no investigative reporting needed to find out about any of it, we find it confusing. Were taken aback. Really hes been telling us since 2015 that he despises and dislikes the american political system, that he wants to undermine it, wants to change it, that he doesnt respect the institutions of american democracy. And its really been our own blindness, our own refusal to take that seriously, our own insistence that hes joking or its only an electoral strategy. I think eats been telling these things telling us these things all along were in a really interesting moment now, though, you know, in this electoral cycle we have a couple of months left before the campaign. Were now in a moment where trump and the people that work for trump like Michael Caputo, his election staff and everybody else, now need to create a totally false picture of the world. They need to get people to believe it so, they need to create a world in which america is not suffering from a deadly disease, in which the greatest threat to American Peace and stability and the economy is leftwing anarchists and not economic crisis or fire or pandemic he needs to create this false picture of reality and people around him are going to start doing that. They even tell us thats what theyre doing because thats the nature of the beast. But resisting this, understanding thats whats happening, is going to be very difficult for a lot of people. The narratives are going to be very strong. Theyre going to be repeated frequently people of dubious Mental Health, like mr. Caputo, are going to begin seeing leftwing anarchists in the streets, some americans are going to prepare for combat and i think we need to be ready for this and we need to keep people keep as many of our friends as possible focused on reality and not what theyre hearing on television. Anne, this is, again, whats so instructive about your book and also mashas, but you actually explain how this has already happened in poland, how its already happened in hungary. Of course, in hungary, deciding to declare war on the muslims, the invading muslims, and you point out, withell, there aren really any invading muslims but they make a nice alternative reality. Poland tried to do the same thing there. It didnt work there so then the war was launched against sexual minorities, as your husband said, and that war, of course, even included religious leaders from the Catholic Church joining in, suggesting that gay and lesbian poles were trying to destroy the country. Yes so, the need to create a false enemy, you know, and, you know, is of course central to these kinds of ideologi ideologies youve underlined an important point. Its possible to create them and to create fear of them even when they dont exist or even when theres one or two of them. You know, there are real examples of you know, there have been one or two acts of left wing violence, there have been things that scare people. Those incidents are going to be blown up and created and made into a kind of army thats coming to get you and your family in the suburbs. And the lesson of poland and hungary, the lesson of russia, the lesson of turkey, is that these kind of narratives, when you begin repeating over and over again, when you begin showing people, you know, clips, over and over again, this he can genuinely become afraid. The Virtual World is as frightening as the real world. It can be used to create a false or completely largely fictitious enemy that will make people afraid and will cause them to want to vote for trump. Jeffrey, one of the phenomena of the trump era is the elevation from the shadows of people like Michael Caputo to positions of power where you could ignore him previously. Hes now a senior official at hhs which oversees the cdc the cdc is an agency under the hhs and thats how hes talking about the cdc. Hes saying theres a Resistance Movement inside, get your bullets, get your guns ready for election day because theyre coming so, hes not the only one, but there are a number of them who, because of loyalty to President Trump, and this goes with the theme of what weve been talking about, loyalty is paramount. If youre loyal, youre going to get an important job if you get an important job, youre going to be in a position to say and do things like we heard Michael Caputo do and say yesterday. Right were in a moment right now when subtext is becoming text i mean, it was never that on the surface as masha and anne note, that things that are and as you all have noted on this show for a while, things formally said quietly are now being said out loud the closer we get to election, the more nervous they get and their true anxieties come out. What youre seeing in this particular case is, i think, the manifestation of a really extremely outlandish Conspiracy Theory or web, the qanon kind of thinking, the deep state thinking, moving closer and closer into the center, so that actual government officials, caputo is a taxpayer paid official of the United States government, is now saying things that a year ago you would find on weird dark websites and so, you know, and the real problem here, and lets watch this today, does he keep his job in the federal government . I mean, does the white house look and say, you know what, this is this is crazy, or, to your point, do people in the white house say, well, hes a good, loyal foot soldier in the trump campaign, so why would we punish him thats whats going to be very interesting about the next couple of days with this guy, whos gone further than other government officials have in this particular narrative. Jeff, jay rosen at nyu talked about the need for networks and some newspapers to start what he called threat modeling teams talked about mashas book and what he learned from masha and anne and talked about the need to prepare, mitigate and respond to threats because the next month and a half, two months, may be unlike any months weve seen in american democracy you, to that end, have released a book be today from the atlantic. Tell us about it right its called the american crisis. Its a real threat to woodward sales, i believe e oh, of course. Well, naturally same publisher, actually its a great question. Anne applebaum wrote the foreward the goal with the book, in all seriousness, discount my partisanship here, in all seriousness is an amazing collection of pieces to go to your point, a lot of the pieces could be considered warnings a lot of the a lot of the stuff weve done over the last year, the last several years, has been to warn, going back to david fromme warning about autocracy four years ago, this is a book designed to tell americans the reality of where were at, the fragility of democracy, the fragility of our norms and also provide some pathways out of it i think readers will really enjoy might not be the exact word, but i think its illuminating and i think together you see the power of some of the atlantics best thinkers and writers im very excited this is out today. So, masha, i want to underline something you bring up very early in your book, that has certainly been a mistake that ive made and that a lot of other people have made if you look if you read woodwards book, its a mistake that tillerson and mattis and dan coates and even people who loathes donald trump, dr. Brzezinski, bob gates and others, they made the mistake, i made the mistake, we made the mistake, that barack obama you have that barack obama quote, the day after the election, the sun has risen. I talked to donald trump and you said that barack obama said that he and trump had, quote, shared goals, quote, we both want whats best for the country. It is that presumption of good faith on which the constitution of the United States is built, that George Washington believed so much in, but hamilton and madison actually were far more skeptical about it, but that presumption of good faith, that we gave to donald trump, that barack obama gave to donald trump, that were used to giving to our president s, that you say we can no longer give. You know, i dont know that we have the option of not giving it no constitution, no set of institutions is built to withstand bad actors a man who a president who just flaunts law, who refuses to obey both norms and, you know, ethical norms, cultural norms, political norms, but also legal norms, who ignores the law and pushes through, bulldozes his agenda through the courts, in the best Case Scenario and in the worst Case Scenario, for example, congressional subpoenas, no Political Institution is built to withstand that what is in our power is to stop putting stock in institutions and realize they will function to the extent they can function, only if society is behind them, we embolden them, if were involved in politics, and if were you know, if we make our institutions do their jobs hes still going to do an extraordinary amount of damage hes already done an extraordinary amount of damage but if we think in terms of harm reduction, we have to be much more involved in it. And, anne, what i heard from all of these people, again, the nevertrumpers in the Foreign Policy community, leaders for that had worked in democratic administrations, all said the same thing, and echoed what barack obama said. You know what, the sun has risen and we only have one president at a time. Again, there was this presumption of good faith, but it certainly seems to me, 3 1 2 years later, our constitution, as good as it is in so many ways, depends too much on the good faith of its chief executive. Yes, i do think that in 20162017 you could very legitimately say this is the president of the United States i would like to work on behalf of my country. Im going to work in his white house. Im going to work in his Administration Im going to do my best as some as we know mattis and others said to themselves and to others, im going to do my best to protect the constitution from him, if necessary, and to protect americas Foreign Policy interests or domestic interests from the president , if that becomes if that becomes necessary. And there were a lot of people who i think went into that First Administration thinking that was the case second time around, if trump wins again, we will not have those kinds of people in washington they wont be there. Instead well have a different category of people who will be working to aid donald trump in his attempts to undermine the constitution, in his attempts to, you know, use his position they will be using their positions in order to make money or for other, you know, other personal goals we will we will have a completely different cadre of people in washington and thats one really important way in which the second trump term will be quite different from the first all right staff writer for the at laethe, Anne Applebaum, thank you as always staff writer at the new yorker and author of the book surviving autocracy, masha guess gessen, and editorinchief, Jeffrey Goldberg its going to be huge. Woodward is going to be eclipsed in a day, jeffrey. Jeffrey goldberg, mr. Sunshine, thank you so much for being with us thanks, joe again, the atlantic is out today with a new book. Its called the american crisis a collection o crisis a collection of the magazines recently published journalism and commentary. Please read it lets bring in the ranking republican on the rules committee, congressman tom cole of oklahoma. Tom, i want to take you back to a conversation we had about an hour ago im sure youve had a lot of these conversations with Small Business owners in your district but i keep talking to my friends all over the country, whether theyre Small Business lawyers or whether theyre bankers, whatever they are, and they keep telling me, whoever gets reelected in whoever gets elected in 2020, whether its donald trump getting reelected or whether its joe biden, were in for a mess economically in 2021 real concern a lot of concern like i didnt hear before 2008 are you hearing some of those same concerns, and what in the world do we do, regardless of who gets elected president , to prepare for the coming onslaught of more economic problems . I do hear those concerns, joe, and very much on the minds of voters and businesspeople quite frankly, we have come about halfway back from where we were thats good. But the next half probably is a lot tougher than what weve done in terms of what we, do the first thing we do is act now look, we could have a Coronavirus Relief bill if about five or six people would just simply come off their high horses and might sit down and bargain. The choice is not between 2. 2 trillion and 1 trillion its really between about a trillion and a half and zero and the only reason its at zero is because we have people unwilling to put on the floor things that both sides agree to. We both agree for 105 billion to reopen schools. We both agree that every american making less than 75,000 a year ought to get 1200 bucks for child and household. We agree not whether its 400 or 600 for relief on individuals unemployed through no fault on their own on a weekly basis republicans moved to 400. Democrats havent moved from 600 we need more help for Small Businesses so the best thing we can do for whoever the next president is, is act now that will make the economy enormously and it will keep us on whats been a positive trajectory for about the last 10, 12 weeks. Tom, i i think we talked about this before i came to congress in 94 because i was concerned about the deficit, the debt concerned about Big Government spending but we find ourselves in a position now where federal governments only lifeline for working class americans. Theres a balance between passing on debt to future generations but also just keeping things running now my bigger concern is, what happens even if there is another stimulus package what happens when that money runs out lets say its extended two or three months what happens when that money runs out what does the economy look like . How do we get back on our feet look, i think the underlying economy precoronavirus was very robust and it still is. You can see this is an economy or a pandemic that hits in enormously disparate ways than different parts of the economy this is pretty good year if youre working at amazon theyre hiring people, adding people same thing at microsoft and with all the big tech so parts of the economy are doing pretty well. And i think once you get a vaccine, i think youll see things get a lot better. And well have a vaccine at extraordinary speed. Its actually undercovered, in my opinion, what the biomedical and pharmaceutical have done whether its two weeks before the election or two weeks after the election really is immaterial its going to arrive faster than any vaccine in Human History and were going to have the ability to distribute it faster. Doesnt mean throw away your mask or quit social distancing youll have to do that for a while. Its been seamless cooperation between private industry, government, and medical researchers doing the right thing with unprecedented resources placed at their disposal by the federal government congressman cole, willie geist. I want to ask you on a different topic. President trump, as you know, has been warning that mailin voting could lead to a rigged election he was talking about it again this morning in an interview your state election board says theres nothing to worry about they say weve done this in our state for many, many years the time or wait is not going to be any different than it has been in the past its an important issue for voters across the country. In your state, do you have concerns about mailin voting, or do you think its solid i think its solid. Look, i used to be a secretary of state im not worried about the elections being corrupted. I do worry a lot about people saying theyre going to be corrupted, delegitimizing them in advance and i see that on both sides weve spent a lot of time with the russians tried to influence the election theres like zero evidence that they actually were successful. And so we hear this from both sides. Its unfortunate i know a lot of the secretaries of state around the country. I used to sit on the secretary of States Executive Committee when i was one and ive got to tell you, democrat or republican, theres not a more Honorable Group of men and women. They want to get it right. They work hard theyve got very capable staff so i think the election will be fine my biggest concern is sometimes in the haste to make sure that we extend the ability, which we should to everybody to vote, we dont often match up the postal reasonable postal delivery dates with the election calendar so thats going to be a problem. In our state we havent changed anything you can still vote by mail i vote by mail but its an absentee system. We dont mail out a ballot to everybody and you have to go to a notary public to identify who you are. Its a very safe system. But i think thats true in most states the states that vote tradition leil by mail have been doing it for a long time and doing a good job. So again, i wish we would just focus on the issues and the election itself. Not worry too much about i dont think theres going to be broadscale voter fraud in the United States by either side all right congressman tom cole, always good to talk to you. Thank you so much. Stay safe out there. And that does it for us this morning. Stephanie ruhle picks up the coverage right after this final break. To soccer practices. And new adventures. You hope the more you give the less theyll miss. But even if your teen was vaccinated against meningitis in the past. They may be missing vaccination for meningitis b. Lets help protect them together. Because missing menb vaccination could mean missing out on a whole lot more. Ask your doctor if your teen is missing meningitis b vaccination. Ask your doctor if your teen techand your car. , were committed to taking care of you tech well fix it right with nocontact service you can trust. Tech so if you have auto glass damage, stay safe with safelite. Singers safelite repair, safelite replace. Find a stock basedtech. On your interests or whats trending. Get realtime insights in your customized view of the market. Its smarter Trading Technology for smarter trading decisions. Fidelity. Rakuten is free to sign up and its in over 3,000 stores. I use it to buy makeup. Travel. Clothes, electronics to me, rakuten is a great way to get cash back on anything you buy. Sign up today and get cash back with rakuten. Im stephanie ruhle. Its tuesday, september 15th lets get smarter. This morning, the u. S. Is facing two simultaneous natural disasters with millions of americans at risk. Down south, Hurricane Sally is closing in on the gulf coast threatening to bring several feet of rain when it makes landfall some time tomorrow. Out in the west, the threat is for wildfires. Dozens of them burning millions of acres and leaving at least 35 people dead. All of this has put the issue of Climate Change f