Transcripts For MSNBCW Morning Joe 20200204

Things that the white house everything is in dispute in youre a loser. Legal team put up during the its the ricky bobby club. Iowa. Turn the corner, go to new competing in New Hampshire. Go straight to South Carolina senate trial, all sorts of bills because i have two neighboring son, if you aint first, youre hampshire and maybe finish he passed. Second behind Bernie Sanders and senators who will wipe up the last. Right . What were hear from the thats a good result for us. Floor here and i need to wait. Hold on, mika. President is an optimistic yes, he needs something here. I got this. I think those pictures we saw in actually have that fire to add hold on. Message but also i think not this is all very exciting. Able to not talk about the gyms last night, splashed intent to it. Uhhuh. Buttigieg, victorious. Impeachment. I think there are people in the i dont think theyll ever make white house who want the across msnbc were a reflection that play because it speaks to hmm right . Not just of the vote in iowa but weakness. That conversation has to be bernie victorious. President to say, wait until happening in campaign nationally. You see young people like the hmm. Wednesday and deal with that. College students, enthusiastic headquarters. Not after thing much in iowa. Amy, stay happy i dont know us covering President Trump so closely, for Bernie Sanders and elizabeth pushing the focus on to south hmm. Usually he wants to be able to warren and andrew yang and warren, you won uhhuh. Spike the ball. Buttigieg, and then they would carolina. The challenge is South Carolina biden, look going. I think hell be spiking the sort of pan over and there would ball this morning and of course is quite aways away. Lets go on. Okay. On wednesday when hes be three people knitting in the so maybe our graphics will help corner saying were for joe and hard to get through acquitted, what we think will clear things up. No, no. Biden. Multiple contests without a win first the winner board. Happen, the white house is good god. What does this muddled result prepared to deal with a censure and move into South Carolina and nobody won. Thats a problem. And we will get a result today, expect that to propel you later. Fight and think eventually it say were going to find out who lets go to the map. Were going to go to the map to will fail and joe manchin wont won but called into question by the results last night, be clear, terrible for biden. Break things down county by a lot of people. What does a muddled result mean get enough people to censure the only saved by the bureaucratic county. President. For joe biden . Joe biden, 0. David, what are you expecting the best thing that could have Bernie Sanders, 0. Happened to him . Incompetence of the democratic okay. Tonight . The challenge for biden, maybe the bell get count will does the president deal with party. Republicans in the senate and do challenge for klobuchar, a fourthplace finish, everyone help shed light on things and probably the challenge for what his own white house wants everybody but maybe bernie, projected from internals is and talk about the economy . Or does he get down in the dirt . Elizabeth a little pete is the truly horrible. No. Thats because a technical lets wait and see what the i guess on script, which money. Right . Its that you need these events results actually are, but it did meltdown set off chaos and anger to propel you forward to raise means he will give a fairly really bad images coming out. Last night in the first we need to go to break. Standard state of the union. Online money. Thats the whole allimportant test of the 2020 the state of our economy is the reality is that no result strong. Guy, ask you first about what markets are near record highs. Is almost as bad as a you guys are doing, doing so president ial race. As politico notes, triggering best economy ever. Fourthplace result in this competing claims of victory and continues to grow, the whi particular case, because were much work on trying to figure stoking doubts about the going to have 1,300 delegates up out where trump voters are, legitimacy of the eventual where the persuadables are. Economy. For grabs in a month, in the in outcome. Unemployment growing. I can tell you over the past a little scary. Good morning and welcome to couple of months, people who, morning joe on this tuesday, pull troops back from unpopular you know only thing that february 4th. We are in washington this wars and give us kind of a status report on that. Impeachment has done for a lot morning, where tonight president the negatives, i think have been of people who might be trump delivers the state of the Union Address before the senate so clearly demonstrated in this persuadable, say you know what . I dont like the guy. Votes tomorrow on his acquittal impeachment trial. Id never invite him over to my for weeks ive been wondering, in the impeachment trial. More on that in a bit along with would the net effect of this house. Hes a jerk, an embarrassment. Joe, willie and me here in hes rude. My never let him around my trial leave the democrats more washington we have the host of vulnerable heading into november kids. Hes just hes the worst or stronger . Msnbcs politics nation and right now id say probably a human being. Little stronger. Around my wife. President of the National Action you know, the fact that lease is worst to ever be in the white house but my Small Business is murkowski describes the doing better than its ever been. Network. Reverend al sharpton. President s conduct as shameful political reporter for the and wrong. Tax cuts really helped me out Washington Post and msnbc that Lamar Alexander essentially and saying im going to vote for political analyst robert costa, him. Certainly not voting for a grants all particulars of moderator of Washington Week socialist taking away my Health Democratic case. On pbs. Those and other examples we can care. Is that what youre hearing and White House Reporter for the right now in february . Look, theres no question Associated Press Jonathan Lemire cite i think carry into november that the biggest gap in american is with us. With the sense they did prove politics is the fact that 50 of so im sorry. Most of their case. President of the National Action didnt get impeached. Americans believe donald trump is doing a good job on the network. I think i said it wrong, but that wont be talked about i wouldnt think tonight. Economy. Making sure. Hell give the standard speech but 65 of americans dont and undersecretary, come on and if the economy stays strong believe their wages are keeping theres a thing today about up with cost of living and cost as it is hell be tough to beat. President s and whos going to be of health care. And what title. Be honest. Number one strategic imperative so i understand. And peter you wroewrote impe for democrats help close that i apologize if i messed up gap. If we are not making clear the your title. Challenge is that workingclass just cant get right who the would leave a stain on Donald Trumps legacy. Americans are facing, president s. And undecided. You say hell remove from this middleclass americans are going to jump in. I have already won. Look at the results. Unshackled . Yeah. Facing are a direct result of especially if any democrats this president. Not a thing happening to a exactly. Voted to acquit him. So, willie, the first manchin said yesterday still singular family, problem is, undecided. Significant event after a jones still undecided. Were not doing that. Were talking about impeachment, we havent heard from others. President ial contest questioned iowa caucus results, about and look, claim exoneration no process, about apps. This is not the way we win a the legitimacy of which matter what. General election. If we are not talking about questioned in 2016. Acquitted him. It was a hoax, witchhunt all we come to iowa and here we have health care, wages, jobs, again reports of apps not that kind of stuff. Education, were going to lose. Working, the possibility of the longerterm impact where is hacking going on with the apps. Accountability left now . Guy cecil, thank you, david democrats rolled out their and this lets just face it. Ignatius thank you as well. Biggest constitutional weapon thank you, guys. Coming up, senator and it didnt work and now he iowa. Every four years now. Wait. Will feel he can do all sorts of breaking news. Breaking news. Guy they have problems. Things without the consequences if its about star wars. Four years ago declared victory of worrying about congress. Not as good asters ststar w for Hillary Clinton in the early whos going to impeach him morning when nobody else would again . The constitution says you can, have claimed victory, and but as a practical matter, does undercut sure she won at the end, well, but undercut the anyone think that could happen . Its close. It could. Tater tot casserole. It could. Think about the timing, legitimacy of that. Yep. The picture of your dinner. And then four years before willie. This ukraine call happened right that, the Rick Santorum debacle. Four helpings of tater tot after muellers testimony. I mean, this is ive got to immediately after. Casserole. Whats he doing thursday . Before i went to bed. Tell us about tater tot say that we dont know who won, so i cant wait yeah to casserole to get a bite. But we know who lost, and its the star wars cantina would iowa. Figure out what hes going to do have ban much better example of hmm. I would be democratic on thursday, because he cant last night than your death star party will be hard pressed to help himself. And iowa start their election process in analogy. Cheese, potatoes, cream of and whats the remaining iowa in january 2024. Check on his power . They went all the way to mushroom soup. Ah. What else . This is insanity, when the impeachment and its not a little protein in there. Resulted in his conviction. Steak. A little steak in the world, the whole world is whats left . Yeah. Heart attack, man. Watching. I knew it was a bad sign when i has republicans saying, yes, delicious. It was great. Ply into the des moines airport this was horrible. All right. Marco rubio, just because its first bathroom i go into, two of coming up senator dick durbin an Impeachable Offense doesnt says the house impeachment the five stalls, not working, mean i have to impeachmur prosecutors made clear, out of order signs. Compelling and thorough i knew it was an omen. Arguments, but could we see a number of democrats vote to i kept it to myself. Acquit the president . Murmur murkowski, worst of well talk to the senator about wow you never talk about things where tomorrows pivotal vote like that on the air, but i just the worst. The democrats proved the case stands ahead on morning joe. Did, because im thinking, you with a mountain of evidence but one of the best music know what . Yall, no, Lamar Alexander. You cant run a bathroom how are turnarounds ever. Thats great. And not only vote to convict like a 20second. They going to run democracy . I wont vote to allow witnesses and actually hold a trial. Youre going to Start Talking 20second turnaround. About 14 times, or whatever went one step further. Cute. Rnaround cute. Yes. beep i dont want to know the truth is what republicans told donald trump early polling from joe from trump. Do what you want to do. We wont hold your feet to the the airport bathroom at des fire. It in fact, we will make sure you have an unfair trial. Moines. Positive news. Well find out later today who we will obstruct justice for you. Won i bap Everything Else is bad we will stop evidence from news. Coming in. An unmitigated disaster for iowa we will stop witnesses from and the entire process. Coming in. Go ahead. Do what you want. David plouffe ran the campaign question is, what country might he then go and ask for for president obama in 2008 said this last night. Information for other political we may be witnessing the last rivals . Iowa caucus. Because already suggested it. Yeah. Its bad on its face. All right suggested it, and if youre just waking up, went on the lawn talked about china to bed early, we have no idea and reporter its did we hear who won, no results until that right jt did he just ask the ups and downs of frequent mood swings because of inconsistencies. Can plummet you to extreme lows. Incredible. China for political opposition . But worse because of the yes. We know the president will crying context you put around it, which feelemboldened. Lift you to intense highs. Is in 2016 we know russians and muffled arguing others interfered in our what were the conversations with putin, no notetaker . Or, make you feel both at once. Election. Theres already now a blanket of curious. Overwhelmed by bipolar i symptoms . Suspicion thats over all of our you never will know. And white house says ask about vraylar. Elections. And this feeds that, and i will. Privately their position now is some medications only treat the lows or the highs. That democrats came at the king how about counting them by hand . Twice and missed. Vraylar effectively treats depression, first with the mueller acute manic and mixed episodes of bipolar i. The Trump Campaign last night already put out a tweet where he investigation. Survived that. I mean a lot of evidence there suggested the process was was wrongdoing there and now fullspectrum relief of all symptoms. Rigged, and now they will go on and say the entire process, the grog to survive impeachment. With just one pill, once a day. He walks through the fire like a elderly patients with dementiarelated psychosis entire process by which this martyr in the eyes of nominee has chosen is rigged, republicans. Have an increased risk of death or stroke. You know what, though . Because of what happened last night in iowa, i got to say, call your doctor about unusual changes i remember people, people like in behavior or suicidal thoughts. First of all who cares . Tearing their hair out and antidepressants can increase these its pure. In children and young adults. Just saying theyll say it putting on sack cloth and ashes report fever, stiff muscles, or confusion, all through. Before 2018, because donald pure insanity. Which may mean a lifethreatening reaction, probably focus on teaching the trump was sending troops to the president of the United States or uncontrollable muscle movements, to do this. Border and he was talking about may be permanent. Pledge of allegiance. Side effects may not appear for several weeks. While the National Anthem is people coming in and a lot of metabolic changes may occur. Going on. Probably keep their mouths shut his trumpists were talking about movement dysfunction, restlessness, sleepiness, until they put the president of stomach issues are common side effects. United states in a room and Illegal Immigrants with leprosy when bipolar i overwhelms, teach him what we teach our coming to the border and the vraylar helps smooth the ups and downs. 3yearold children, because if caravans and everybody shocked, my 3yearold child, 4yearold, how can he do this and hes for a nasty cold, take dayquil severe with Vicks Vapocool. Going to get away with it . Whoa 5yearold child acted the way no. And vaporize it with an intense rush of vicks vapors. The president of the united biggest landslide for a midterm states did during the national ahhhhhhhhhh election against donald trump and republicans. Anthem at the super bowl. There is a check and its called dayquil severe with Vicks Vapocool. Mocking it, ridiculing it, the american vote. Well see in nine months. The daytime, coughing, stuffy head, like fake conducting. Thinking that was a time to vaporize your cold, medicine. Interesting about this trial, point fingers at people. I thought he had an itch upon finishes up a process of several sensethe lack of control when iover my businessai, months where his actions have been questioned. Made me a little intense. Kneeling. He hasnt been impeached and but now quickbooks helps me get paid, show the president showing disrespect to the national will always be impeached in manage cash flow, and run payroll. Anthem, disrespect to the history. And now im back on top. The public where it was when it with koala kai. American flag, disrespect to vo save over 40 hours a month with intuit quickbooks. America. Now, back to iowa. Started. Slightly for than against. Almost exactly what the popular that short video posted on vote was in 2016. Instagram appears to show the the public hasnt changed its president doing all that, its mind about this guy. Pretty much him. Can i just ask a question to mand up their minds about him everybody. Were throwing this up and on early. The table, and dont worry its what does that mean . In november pull the same inside not about des moines bathrooms. Straight he did three years ago. Its about paper ballots. Thats a hard thing to do, to does last night not show again get especially running as an people with their crappy little apps. Remember mitt romneys crappy incumbent instead of a challenger. Little app. Not one day of his support weve got the best app in the you know mitt was a tech guy. Happened in the history of polling. I think obamas health care a weak place for an incumbent president to be, however, he app had a rollout. Plays a weak hand strong. Very good taking down enemies. But, rev, we got to have good at taking down opponents, whoever the democrats nominate ought to be, has to be strong paper ballots everywhere. They had some paper ballots there last night but you want to enough to stand up to it and im rig a process, make sure no not sure they have that candidate in front of us. Before we go to break talking paper is involved. No question about it. To democratic sources, the iowa people need to realize is the people in iowa are Democratic Party maintains their app didnt crash but a lot of disenfranchised. They robbed people. Precinct leaders just couldnt upload results. Voters rights. Then tried a secondary method came out and caucused for hours, and they tried to call the spent weeks some of them, they results in to the iowa robbed them of their vote. Democratic party hot line. Results will come out it will they couldnt get through and now will have to count them one almost not matter because it by one. My question, why cant they just will be under a cloud. Say how long thats going to and what about the people of take and iowa . I also think this will be the because they dont know. Last iowa caucus, those that just some information. Felt it didnt represent its pathetic. This is pathetic. Diversity, now all of a sudden everybodys going to say move it the vacuum of real out of iowa. Information when the whole i have to say this. Country is waiting. Youve got to go back to that im hearing from campaigns the app definitively did il trump mocking the National Anthem. The app failed. Oh, my gosh. And theyre now going back because for those of us that through the paper trail and stood by the right for counting the votes. Literally counting the votes. Kaepernick to take a knee, he tell us that. Did not mock the national i mean peter baker, yamiche anthem. This is a mockery. This is acting like it was composed for me and i think it thank you both. Still ahead on morning joe was unpatriot for the president of the United States to act like president ial candidate Pete Buttigieg join us live from new this was some composition that he could exploit rather than hampshire where the final sprint to that that primary is under respect. Way. Plus, joe biden already fund no one for him to criticize raising uf iowa suggesting it kaepernick and him to do that was close race even while other shows the ultimate hypocrisy. Campaigns say that might not disgraceful and any be. Republican senators who need anymore evidence about this mayor pete or bernie. President needs to look at this who won . Close to being a complete video. Unfit. Failure. Sam stein is digging into all of unfit this next on morning joe. Give me your reports from the president s behavior was iowa. What happened last night wasnt a surprise for political reporters. You think the Iowa Caucuses have shameful and wrong. Been a thing in american his personal interests do not i see no path to the 67 politics since jimmy carter in take precedence over those of 1976, but in 2012 we are on the this great nation. Votes required to impeach ground in iowa, when rick President Trump and havent the president has the since this trial started. Santorum seemed to lose the iowa however, i do believe a caucuses then seemed he won the responsibility to uphold the bipartisan majority if this body Iowa Caucuses. Integrity and the honor of the would vote to censure president complications in 2016 early on whether senator sanders or office. Trump for his actions and his not just for himself, but for manner. Censure would allow this body to secretary clinton won the iowa all future president s. Unite across party lines and as caucuses. This is the Third Straight cycle an equal branch of government to weve seen challenges in iowa. Degrading the office by actions formally denounce the questions about iowa. President s accesses and hold so now you move into new or even namecalling weakens it him accountable. His behavior cannot go unchecked hampshire, and fascinating about for future president s, and it by the senate and censure would last night beyond not having a weakens our country. Allow a bipartisan statement re cooker, result, nobody dropped out of the best of pressure cooking and air frying condemning his unacceptable this race. Do we know when well get the now in one pot, and with tendercrisp technology, behavior in the strongest terms. That is joe manchin. You can cook foods that are crispy on the outside yep. Brother joe comes from a results jchlts th state, willie, how much did results . And juicy on the inside. They say theyre going to the ninja foodi Pressure Cooker, donald trump win it by . Announce them. Have they lost them . Spread 42 points. Whats going on . Does anybody know what the Pressure Cooker that crisps. A democrat in a plus42 trump actually happened. State. Jump to Vaughn Hillyard. Telling me it was close . Hear the latest. Walking the line. Telling me that, youre the story keeps changing. Telling me that Elizabeth Warren manually verifying all if she returns against trump, she has a chance . Precinct results validating going to steal that state every piece of paper against the knop question about it. And Senior Editor for paper trail and took pains, not National Review and bloomberg election interference as weve come to understand it. View columnist, and with us usa Vaughn Hillyard what are you hearing about what happened last today opinion columnist and night . Former senior advisers for the reporter thats the issue. House and government oversight youre not hearing anything from committee, a morning joe the Democratic Party, guys. Contributor. Great to have you both with us this morning. 2 00 a. M. Eastern, 1 00 a. M. And just saying, ib lo love she is on her way to our house. What . I got it. Alexa, start roomba. Press time, a press call lasted reading the articles. The lexus es. Do what i do with the new york 24 seconds. Eagerly prepared for the unexpected. Little we know. There are reports from lease the 2020 es 350 for 389 a month for 36 months. Times. Take them out back and burn them in the backyard. Precincts. Thats not okay. 1,678 precincts around this you read and learn. State. Experience amazing at your lexus dealer. I call youre on the right i was on the phone with a couple half. Call jack and start yelling at Iowa Democratic county chair lease the 2020 es 350 for 389 and i like to question your im yoevery move. N law. Him. You learn a lot. You have a new column. Folks last night who were baffled by what the position like this left turn. Alan dershowitz is wrong. Its the next one. That they find themselves in you always drive this slow . How did you make someone i love . Of course, dershowitz, i love right now. That must be why youre always so late. Dershowitz. Wholly acknowledging what this just like donald trump and i do not speed. Means for iowa and the part everybody else around trump. About this for the iowa caucus and thats saving me cash with drivewise. He forget that we live in an age and what reverend al just my son, he did say that you were the safe option. Mentioned was everything that that has videotape. Went into this moment. And thats the nicest thing you ever said to me. That we can actually see what he for the last year hundreds of so get allstate. Stop bossing. Said on the floor, and now, of staffers have been on the where good drivers save 40 for avoiding mayhem, like me. Ground, young people that have course, writes an oped left school, left their lives at home to come and be a part of yesterday doing this is this is my sons favorite color, you should try it. This process. Dangerous. They have twisted my words from youre working with volunteers their proper context. That were knocking on doors in [mayhem] you always drive like an old lady . [tina] youre an old lady. Nah. Yeah. Zerodegree weather this winter. Got a lot of blowback and dealing with folk whose went to for the past few weeks because, criticism say ig was making Campaign Events to be a part of fun fact, a recent Study Suggests crime goes down myself out to be a better lawyer than him. Hes a good lawyer. This democratic, or believed to when people tune in. And football is awesome. Be democratic process and it if i ever kill and exwife he is comes down to the fact that folks dont know what to win, win. The first person i would call. To thank you for watching, exactly. Believe. In the Democratic Party here in were kicking off adts pass the protection contest. Lets not do that. Iowa right now, saying they will but he but the its your chance to win a 250,000 home makeover release the results here at some constitutional argument that he was making point later today. By the way, a wonderful so has means potentially from adt, designed by us. Reference to sonny von bulow. Sometime when the sun is up, but and a new adt Smart Home Security system. The Biden Campaign is pushing visit adt. Com passtheprotection thank you. Back sending a letter to iowa okay. Democratic party saying they and tell us what you want to protect. We got o r. Resent jeffrey want to be able to review the results before the Democratic Party puts them out there. Epstein . Last night they released two i think i heard such a thing. Phone calls that the campaigns just party with him . He actually represented took part in with iowa there was an association Democratic Party, but there. They have a lot of frustration on those calls and, connections together. Again, little answers from the so go ahead. He and jeffrey. Iowa Democratic Party. I think the constitutional argument that if its not a and as robert just mentioned there, this is not surprise. Stach other violation you cant over the last year, they have impeach the president. Nothing in the context of the talked about the development of the app and, yes, an effort to constitution or nothing in the original founders that reflect try to make this a more open that narrow understanding of process, but ultimately in the impeachment and the experts who process they never were able to are actually constitutional law experts who looked at this and say that they were wholly ready looked at the history of that for the moment and clearly the last hours proved that they were not ready for it. Near lly concluded dershowitz i willie . Quick, followup on vaughns great reporting, a campaign most wrong about this. Frustrated on that call with the and the other arguments were Iowa Democratic party, senator preposterous. Of all the people to make the Bernie Sanders campaign. Argument. How many people are there . Called the process bogus and about 8 billion people on earth right now . Pushing 8 billion, and you says maybe flawed for decades. Vaughn, do you have sanders pick out of 8 billion people, internal numbers . Hey, why dont we get ken starr. The result that, nonresult, aloud everyone to declare right. Too much impeachment. This has gotten way out of hand. Victory. Joe bidens campaign wants to yes, maybe make that argument review the numbers before made public. With somebody else, but that Pete Buttigieg hopped onstage, person making that argument the mayor saying we were really was almost as though, to victorious last night. What are those internal sanders troll everybody. Numbers telling that campaign . Yeah. Republicans very concerned about the culture of impeachment the Sanders Campaign says except joni ernst says theyll that based on their own internal numbers from about 44 of the impeach joe biden soon as he precincts in the state that they [ fastpaced drumming ] steps into the office. Are going to be the ones that and for lawyers across country, come out victorious, but then started pulling out their hair the Buttigieg Campaign just a when he set effectively the short while later put out their president believes his own reelection is in the national own internal numbers say be from interests, therefore can do what has to be done including 75 of precincts their oeb apparently holding up military internal numbers from their aid to ukraine to get dirt on an organizers across the state indicate theyre the winners the iowa caucus. Opponent to get reelected. Yes, the Sanders Campaign is thatsopponent. Frustrated. Look at Pete Buttigieg. You could say the south bend he is not saying you can do mayor needed that moment upon that stage to declare himself the one individual in this race anything because you cant break who could win the midwest against donald trump. Yet he didnt take the stage statutes in a criminal wade, until 11 30 last night, and right . Otherwise it is fair game. He says in his book that the after every other candidate went up there and suggested that they president could give alaska back to the russians, right . Were leaving iowa doing well. That is where that comment comes so it was a missed opportunity for the Buttigieg Campaign. They took a plane and will be from. Showing up in New Hampshire but the dershowitz argument, thats not able to go and launch not a crazy thing that someone themselves into these next state able to declare themselves you would be surprised how invented, that is an example of many members of the senate are what he says surprise withiners of the iowa joni earnst walked back her talking about the chiefs dont caucus. Thank you, vaughn. Know that kansas city is appreciate your reporting. Really appreciate it. Primarily, is in missouri. So Jonathan Lemire what is wrong come on. No. Seriously. Comment by the way saying that with the Iowa Democratic party . Seriously. But a little more screening on it was taken out of context. Again, this is a party who that. We had, there were lots of botched the call four years ago, the state of impeachment, kansas fans there last night and rushed it when the media was it was a great game. What are you hearing for what it will look like in there, what shocked that they would be so come on, roy will the democrats do to perhaps transparent. And and now they get on the you know, people joked. Rattle the president. I was talking to folks in the the republicans would come to phone for 74 seconds . The president s defense after he house leadership last night and the worlds watching this. Theyre trying to make sure ut initially congratulated kansas. Were not being melodramatic. And it was just a joke. Instead of missouri for the hou for a year and a half, american chiefs super bowl victory, the house impeachment managers politics has been focused on but senator roy blunt this moment, and the democratic obliged. Thats just sit together in his line of thanks, roy. Party has a crappy app and say, with us now, politics editor for well, Nothing Happened to the sight. He will not be able to help app. Then you hear reports something the daily beast and for himself, he will riff and start did happen to the app. Was there election interference . Going off and do what we have did somebody try to hack into priorities usa, guy cecil. The app . Seen him do many times and lose was it just pure incompetence . Guy, come on, baby. Whats going on in your party . That air of being president ial is the information lost . Yeah. Whats going on . Did they lose the information . Pathetic. Is it gone . Just pathetic. To go after those that impeached why were they only on the embarrassing. Embarrassing phone for 74 seconds when they i dont have the words. Im in the slot where should be holding 2hour press everythings been said but not everybody has said it. Him. Previewers of the speech said its your turn. Conferences explaining to im trying to think of new america and the world what agetives of what happened. Happened. This is a disaster on every it youre a 22yearold field level for democrats and for organizer paid basically nothing for the past year living in that it is very optimistic. Iowa. To the reserves point, already questions about iowas place supporter housing, knocking on doors in snow, organizing being first with iowa and new he will not be able to resist volunteers, up all night for hampshire not being this moment and this is your taking swipes at the democrats representative of the country in terms of demographic. First experience, its just in the process. The third cycle with issues. This was going to be mayor how do you think voter wills an app provided by a company petes breakthrough. Take this. More people will be watching yes. Mayor pete and. Tonight than any other speech a called shadow inc. And might have been. Talked about bernie, reason appropriate nickname for to be angry. President will give probably something that until the convention. Lev must have helped him name that not provided any daylight mayor pete, with his if you twor awere to advise the whatsoever. Ask you, though, is it true supportering given their all and taken away from them. That you had cybersecurity strange. At this hour the strongest president , everyone is expecting people that said no safeguards, you to take the low road, do no tests run on this app . Photograph youre seeing at least i an online, the one of what you do at the rallies. Early reports are, yes, questions about security, but the somewhat grandfatherly joe biden with a big, beaming smile the state party flat out saying and mayor pete who may have had the breakthrough he dreamed of, werent not election interference rather wouldnt it be a joke on the Bernie Sanders who is as strong out there as he kept saying he a malfunction a glitch. Media, you would be playing a how can we believe that . Fast one on the main stream was, must be just shaking their media. I would love to write a speech for a president that can talked to reporters 74 seconds. Heads, more than that furious at and sat there for hours, no how this happened. Its like the los angeles interest whatsoever, state get up there and say the state dodgers. How angry they have to be all of officials huddled upstairs with those years that arod was doing of the union is great. No update its and the call talk about the lowest steroids no, no. Come on. Lasted only a minute and a half. Come on unemployment, the economy is makes sense. Growing and china is staggering shadowed in darkness throughout. Theres a big astros, big this is how we will fix it, none along. Of that and dont know what time astro scandal. All of the things you have, life and a big asterisk in results are coming out. Your point cant be underscored american politics. Enough. This is the moment. Expe the 2020 election. My own inititakeaway, iowa and expectancy is going up, the party that built everything hampshire muddled, michael everything is going up. To defeat President Trump. This is the first step and botched it. Bloomberg. Too early to say but you begin yes, talk about the national were in the 10th year of the anthem again, we will. To wonld sir thder is that the but youve handed the republicans a clutch hold. Couldnt have been a better obama recovery. He has a lot of good news to cant trust this party to run a night for bloomberg. Talk about and work with. Caucus, suggest fraud, big night for bloomberg. He has a Democratic Front runner corruption and also incompetence if the Democratic Party that appears to be a socialist. And thats what theyre doing. People will be talking about wanted to get people organized, it appears that bernie is going the National Anthem, because you inspired ready to go, this was cant trust the president of the an unmitigated disaster that United States to show respect to the flag. To come out of these first few i think a lot of people would depresses a ton of voters and find that to be a little more saps confidence and the ability contests looking like a front of the party to organize the searing. Disturbing. Runner. And disturbing, but, willie, stuff. Two things for the candidates up can Bernie Sanders actually win top too. Think about it. One, bernie supporters will feel in november against donald trump. You had mayor pete. I dont know if he would be like this was rigged this was going to be his moment. Essentially. Favored especially with the and Dave Wasserman is coming up yeah. And make a lot of noise. Economy looking the best it is next block. And irresponsible and, two, it looked as the night went on right now. But yeah, i mean trump has been like mayor pete may be the guy if mayor pete did in fact win. Moving out front and he was theres no indication yet. Weak. Sanders has been leading him in going have the headline that he won in iowa, which could propel michigan consistently in the we have noiad of the results. Thats a historic moment. State head to head polls. Him to New Hampshire and who you were losing this. I think that just given the knows, propel him to do well first openly gay candidate to unusual popularity of this super tuesday. Win a nominating process and and then bernie, thought this doesnt get that chance to president that any democratic would be his state as well. And on the other side of it we actually celebrate that moment, nor do we . Nominee at least has a shot heard a lot of negative reports against him. Thats something we shouldnt about joe biden. Lose sight of. What a disaster. But jonathan, if bernie makes we dont know. Of course, they dont know how terrible. First mayor from south to record votes and report them it to the general election, we in iowa, but we heard he might bend thats big, too. I thought about that, but, be doing better in the country, read the oped from new york really valid point. In the rural districts, but say Jonathan Lemire really magazine about Bernie Sanders he didnt. Lets say he got in fourth and his past. Valid point Jonathan Lemire, it is a varied it is a varied place. Or maybe even fifth place. I mean it always goes back to the other candidates would say, okay, he deserves to be knocked star wars. Around by that. No, please. Why . Theres one. Past. Not going to get knocked around. Im in. And it was a progressive very lets do it. Youve got the death star in cant get punched. If im joe biden im going to front of you. Well known columnist talking say the whole process was and youre staring at the death rigged. These people dont know how to star for three and a half years. About him paddling around with run an election. Guess what . Our first election in new soviet leaders and really right . Hampshire next week. Okay. And youre like, okay. Were going to get luke and han radical positions he has yep. Throw out the raumt esult in io. Taken i think they said he would be and were going to go blow that cant trust. One shes completely different the worst nominee in thing up. Result from one poll to another. And luke and han get up and its you cant have Campaign Data like that. Not surprising. Like, whoo and Princess Leia you mentioned it. Generations. Saying he would be a disaster the state party went out of its way to say this was not the app. For democrats. Nothings wrong with the app. And the wookie and may the force this is not someone that can win volunteers on the record inside be with you and, boom, crash in the general nebecause he is t these churches and high schools who said the app didnt work. Into each other. Dont even get off the ship. Oh, my god. And volunteers on the phone this is a fight im joking of step. Two hours trying to get on to Bernie Sanders did win in the hot line to explain why the and most importantly nobody in democratic primaries in places process wasnt working angd tv land is laughing, but this is couldnt get through because the an incredibly critical moment like michigan and wisconsin. He might have an appeal in some lines were so overloaded. For the Democratic Party and i i mean, its a quaint process would say, as somebody whos not of the rust belt states that flip for President Trump last that everyone enjoyed for a long time because it speaks to a democrat, for our time. There is certainly a white watching democracy in action. House, this is the candidate constitutional republic. Quaint . And the democrats have had three time to get rid of it. They want. When watching our coverage and we see it not just years to get ready for this, and necessarily from the Campaign Last night and elections for the they got a bunch of candidates presidency are determined by but the president himself. The process is being rigged coin tosses, and people, that run in the first contest and they dont even get off the against bernie. Someones offering to buy youre trying to steer the launch pad. Somebody dinner if he comes and blows up on the launch pad. Democrats that way because they votes over here, its quaint, this is a disaster for feel like she is too far left. Thats a polite word at this democrats. Point. We cant go on like this. Theyve got to figure out how to fix quickly. So the millennial falcon and for every worker that they what about a separate ballot . Pick up, how many people in the some of these small towns you lukes x wing run into each dont want to be seen. Other all the way to the death suburbs did he lose, in for instance, the republican star. Yeah. Caucus. Yes. Charlotte, in tampa, in orlando, sure donald trump would the have an appropriate analogy. Won 95 . See, mika . Say somebody in a small town, a see . It worked. Small town pharmacist wanted to lemire, youre a suckup. And in atlanta. This is why he is going out register a protest vet against keep going. I like star wars. Of his way to promote Bernie Donald trump. Just you couldnt do that, do rankings of the movies later. She couldnt do that, because certainly, its such a she is not going to sit alone in selfinflicted wound here. And this is, to underscore the sanders. What are the odds that trump the corner over there and risk point, this has been threeplus years in the making. Says what happened in iowa is upsetting everybody inside that small town. Democrats since the moment of this is when it works. November 8, 2016 when donald very bad. He sees that for every person he this doesnt work. Trump scored his shocking a small town they have to live in after the election. Victory democrats said all that matters this cant happen again. Yes a secret ballot, paper all that matters, marshal might lose. Ballot, all of that is important, but as we raise these forces, organize, raise money, all right, thank you both for set up a process to beat him. Questions, of Voter Suppression being here this morning. To not let him be reelected and thank you, guys, appreciate and voting suppression and all, now as the starting gun goes off it. Still ahead on morning joe. They stumble out of the box. Start the first votes for this iowa, you have shocked the and the results are going to be season in terms of a democratic questioned even when they do primary with this kind of nation. That is for sure if is the catastrophe is devastating for come out later today. All of us, particularly those to sams point. Morning after the Iowa Caucuses everyone at the table. Bernie sanders and pete and we still dont know who won, that consider the right and use buttigieg deprived of a bounce. Of the vote to be sacred. Should be noted. Its devastating. This would be a historic win for but pete boouttigieg is declari as the morning goes on i the former mayor if he were to think well be able to get our actually grab this. Also sort of gives joe biden arms around this. Still ahead on morning joe, breathing space here where he victory. Morning joe is right back. Can say, look, maybe i didnt, as a struggling actor, Pete Buttigieg reacts to last questioned results say lets move on to New Hampshire and nights fiasco. Pretend iowa never happened. He has 0 of the vote yet he i need all the breaks that i can get. And looming to complete the says hes victorious never the at liberty butchemel. Cut. Les. Our guest live from new strds st liberty mu. Line . Hampshire, and speaking of, new star wars looming is the death cut. Star. Darth vader, the president. Liberty mutual customizes your Car Insurance poll numbers from New Hampshire who is stronger now. So you only pay for what you need. Well show you one week away from that primary, plus the got the nation watching tonight as he delivered his state of the cut. Liberty m. Senates second ranking am i allowed to riff . Union. What if i come out of the water . We know already hell deliver a fiery attack on the impeachment Liberty Biberty. Cut. Well dub it. Process and now suspect youll Liberty Mutual customizes your Car Insurance democrat, voting on censuring hear about this too. So you only pay for what you need. The president rather than voting suspect hell go after the iowa only pay for what you need. To remove him. Process talk about democrats youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Look how they bungled this. A if they cant be trusted to run this nominating process, how can until i found out what itst it actually was. Ed me. You trust them to run the dust mite droppings country . That was good. Like whered the mandalorian now . Eeeeeww your best comfort and protection guaranteed. Dead skin cells gross talk about, because talking so now, i grab my swiffer sweeper and heavyduty dusters. Because, perfect or not, lifes better when youre in it. About mayor pete and also talked duster extends to three feet to get all that gross stuff be there with depend®. About gotcha and for that nasty dust on my floors, my sweepers on it. The textured cloths grab and hold dirt and hair try eucerin advanced dry sd ceramidesn . With natural moisturizing factors found in skin no matter where dust bunnies hide. No more heebie jeebies. Eucerin advanced repair lotion phew. For healthier looking skin. Glad i stopped cleaning and started swiffering. A lot will happen in your life. The best of pressure cooking and air frying wrinkles just wont. Now in one pot, and with tendercrisp technology, neutrogena® rapid wrinkle repairs fastest retinol formula works so fast. You can cook foods that are crispy on the outside it takes only one week to reveal younger looking skin. And juicy on the inside. The ninja foodi Pressure Cooker, neutrogena® the Pressure Cooker that crisps. Yes. Yes. Yeah sure. Yes. Yes. Yeah, yeah no problem. Yes. Yes, yes a thousand times yes discover. Accepted at over 95 of places in the u. S. Americans come to lendingtree. Com to compare and save on loans, credit cards and discover. And that was all you knew, would you really understand it, more but with the new lending tree app you can see your full with just that point of view . Financial health, monitor your weve got a different way to look at it, credit score, see your cash flow and find out how you can cut from right here on the ground. Your monthly bills. Download it we dont just the United States we see united towns. Now to see how much you can save. Apps are used everywhere. Except work. Why is that . Were grateful for what you bring, is it because people love filling out forms . And all the sparks youve shown, in the thousands of towns that we get to call home. Maybe they like checking with their supervisor to see how much Vacation Time they have. Or sending corporate their expense reports. Ill let you in on a little secret. They dont. By empowering employees to manage their own tasks, paycom frees you to focus on the business of business. To learn more, visit paycom. Com wean air force veteran made of doing whats right,. Not whats easy. So when a hailstorm hit, usaa reached out before he could even inspect the damage. Thats how you do it right. Usaa insurance is made just the way martins family needs it with hasslefree claims, he got paid before his neighbor even got started. Because doing right by our members, thats whats right. Usaa. What youre made of, were made for. Usaa breathe freely fast, with vicks sinex. My congestions gone. I can breathe again ahhhh i can breathe again ughh. Vicks sinex, breathe on and that was all you knew, would you really understand it, with just that point of view . Weve got a different way to look at it, from right here on the ground. We dwere grateful for whatates we you bring, towns. And all the sparks youve shown, in the thousands of towns that we get to call home. We are going on to New Hampshire victorious. Were doing very well here in Amazon Prime Video so when you say words like, show me best of prime video iowa. Lets head to New Hampshire, into this, youll see awesome stuff like this. Thank you, iowa you won discover prime originals like, we feel good about where we the Emmy Award Winning the marvelous mrs. Maisel, tom clancys jack ryan, are, and look, so it is on to and the man in the high castle. All in the same place as your live tv. New hampshire yes, youre all winners. Its all included with your amazon prime membership. It sounds like five different thats how xfinity makes tv. Candidates claiming victory in simple. Easy. Awesome. New hampshire last night. This is like the whole boomer to im feeing good right now kids thing. Trophy culture. Serve the winner. I have to say you and i post boomers, what do we tell our kids youre a loser. If youre not first, youre last. The ricky bobby quote. This is all very exciting. Well, the Iowa Democratic party is working to get this buttigieg victorious. Result, get them straight, and i want to make sure theyre very bernie victorious. Careful in their deliberations, amy stay happy. And indications are, Warren Warren you won. Biden, looking good lets go on. Indication is close, were going to walk out of here with our so maybe our graphics will share of delegates. We dont know exactly what it is help clear things up, first the yet but feel good about where we are and, look, so so its on winner board. To New Hampshire that is a problem. Were going to go to the map to hmm. Break things down county by that was joe biden last night. Trying to figure out how to county. Couch this. Kind of impossible when the joe biden zero, bernie Democratic Party of iowa doesnt know how to couch it. Sanders zero. Bring in Dave Wasserman. Thats because a technical melt so, dave, this read the tea down set off chaos and anger leaves for us, and tell us who did well last night, who last night in the first all important test of the 2020 appeared to be overperforming, who appeared to be president ial race. Underperforming, and do any of us have any idea whos going to as politico notes is causing win this thing . Remember the last Des Moines Register poll . Competing claims of victory. Selzer poll spiked because, of course, issues. Good morning and welcome to that turned out to be the best morning joe on this tuesday, most accurate poll around. February 4th. Were in washington this morning right . But, look, this wasnt quite the where tonight President Trump delivers the state of the union fire festival of results reporting but it was close. Address before the senate votes look, were probably going to tomorrow on the acquittal and the impeachment trial. Have results today that show more on that in a bit. We have the host of msnbc that Bernie Sanders came out on top. Thats my expectation. Politics nation and president of buttigieg, warren, two, three in the National Action network some order, but i think the interesting thing about the reverend al sharpton. Timing last night was that the political reporter from the fact it was clear biden and klobuchar would not be in the Washington Post robert costa top three kind of freed them to and moderator of Washington Week go on tv before everyone went to bed and seized the stage at a on pbs. Time that, you know, probably served them as best it could given the circumstances. Yeah. And jonathan lamire. So i think the networks were going to a lot of the places that served joe bidens interests worse. You know, lets go now to there is a lot going on today hippieville and exactly. About president s. The field is sleepy. A lot of colleges. Yeah. And happy sack you to see how i have already won, look at the results. Thats going to youd have, like. Remember hackysack . So willy, the first youd have like 800 for significant event after after president ial context questioned. Hackysack. The legitimacy questioned in whered you get that . 2016. And 800 for colored hair and we come to iowa, and here we elizabeth her crowd and half of have again reports of apps not that for yang and then there would be three people, like, you working. The possibility of hacking going know, playing with pixie sticks, on with the apps. And they were for joe biden over and this, lets just face it, in the corner of the gym. Iowa every four years now has and time and time again, joe biden that week, or was it just problems. Four years ago they declared unfortunate they went to all the victory for Hillary Clinton in colleges and universities on the early mornings. Cable news . Because you know what . The threesecond way to ask that nobody else would have claimed question is, did the images we victory, im sure she won in the see last night reflect the results on the ground across end, but under cut the iowa . No. Totally distorted. Legitimacy of that. And four years before that the caucuses dont provide an Rick Santorum debacle. Accurate portrayal. Its a caucus, rewards liberal we dont know who won, but we passion and also about 90 know who lost, and its iowa. White. Which is not reflective of the the Democratic Party is hard large Democratic Party which is pressed to start their election a 50 50, and process in iowa in january 2024. A lot younger. A lot younger. This is insanity. All three of those things are the whole world is watching, i know it was a bad sign when i joe bidens worst factors. The danger for joe biden two fly into the des moines airport states echo first giving a and the first bathroom i go totally wrong impression how the larger electorate is feeling and a better version of his speech, into, three of the five stalls, please hold the results from iowa and New Hampshire until out of order. After South Carolina in i knew it, you dont talk about february. Looking ahead to do New Hampshire one Big Questions that, but im thinking if you facing mayor buttigieg is, and cant run a bathroom how are he has a big outcome in iowa, they going to run democracy. Can he consolidate the center . Take on Vice President biden and say to the Democratic Party, im going to be that moderate early entrance polling from candidate and for senator sanders, can he consolidate the joe from the mens room at the left . Likely hell have a strong democrat airport. Outcome out of iowa, but does he were going to find out later go into New Hampshire which he won in 2016 and win . Today who won oiowa. This is an unmitigated disaster carry that into super tuesday . For the state of iowa and the entire process. And can joe biden go into the david pluff who rap in t in 2008 next state and say im going to be your candidate. Lets go beat donald trump. Said we may be witnessing the show pictures of mayor pete as well, because mayor pete last iowa caucus. Its bad on its face. Could have won. We have no idea who won. This is if youre there you go. Thank you. We have no results in because of so if youre at home, bernie may inconsistencies, but it is worst because of the context you put have won. Around it. Mayor pete may have won. In 2016 we know that russians and others interfered in our biden may have come in third place after they count all the rural counties. Election. Biden could have ended a there is now a blanket of disastrous fifth place, because Amy Klobuchar seemed to be suspicion the Trump Campaign, already overperforming. We know absolutely nothing. And, of course, thats not that put out a tweet where they different, but the rest of the world knows absolutely nothing suggested the process was rigged this morning either about and now they will say the entire american politics. Process by which this nominee is so lets talk about new chosen is rigged because of what hampshire. Because okay. What the hells there to talk happened last night in iowa. About in iowa . First of all, that is pure not much. You heard joe biden say its on to New Hampshire one week away from that primary. Senator Bernie Sanders leads the democratic president ial field insanity. There. According to the latest boston they should probably keep their globe, wbztv poll sanders at mouths shut until they put the president of the United States 24 . Six points ahead of former Vice President joe biden who has 18. In a room and teach him how to Elizabeth Warren 13. Essentially tied with mayor pete at 11, both candidates sit with act. The polls margin of error. And not good news for like fake conducting, thinking Elizabeth Warren. Good news for bernie, of course, that was a time to point fingers also, joe biden at this point, at people. Hell take a place. Why dont you worry about the hell take a show. President showing disrespect to you know what . Just dont keep me in the barn. The National Anthem, showing its good for joe biden disrespect to the american flag, particularly when theres going to be questions about iowa. Showing disrespect to america. Yeah. If he comes in second in new back to iowa. And that was posted on hampshire, a neighboring state instagram appearing to show the to Bernie Sanders vermont, president doing all of that. Thats good for him. The challenge coming out of the iowa debacle is now can pete consolidate latino votes in it is not just about democrat nevada and the black vote in bathrooms, it is about paper South Carolina where hes been having problems. Thats where people are going to ballots. People with their crappy little have to watch now. And can we see bernie deal with black votes in South Carolina . Apps. Mitt romney said i have the best right. App in the world, he kept saying so i think coming out of iowa, if everything remains the way it looks, sanders wins, but i have the best app in the world buttigieg gets a big boost or and it crashed two minutes in. We have to have paper ballots reverse, theyve got to prove an expanded field and what they everywhere. You want to rig a process, make ought to think about this sure there is no paper involved. Morning, and iowa will hurt candidates, if youre bernie, you needed that win last night. You needed the headline. No question what people need to vaelz that the people in iowa clarity. You needed to send a message to the South Carolina older black voters. Thats right. I can win an election, same with mayor pete who desperately disenfranchise. They came out and said weeks, needs momentum in South Carolina. Again, taken away from them last some of them. Night. Another winner last night, it will almost not matter. Michael bloomberg. In a big way. It will be under a cloud now. Another poll come out. What about the people of iowa. Morning consult poll comes i also think it will be the last out. Look in bloomberg, third place, iowa caucus. Now all of a sudden everybody 14 tied with Elizabeth Warren, will say move it out of iowa. Up two and, dave i havent i have to say this, you to go back to that trump mocking the National Anthem. For those of us that stood by had your take on Michael Bloomberg. Yesterday heard a lot of people the right of kaepernick to take on tv when it looked like bernie a need, he did not mock the National Anthem. Would sweep the first three this was a mockery. States and saying, okay. Maybe the democratic this was like it was composed establishment will throw all of its weight behind bloomberg to for me, and i think it was stop sanders from sweeping to the nomination. Think thats a possibility . Unpatriotic for him to act like i think thats a little this was a kopgs suggestion. Crazy, and im a bit more and for him to criticize skeptical than you are, joe, when it comes to bloomberg. Kaepernick and to do that shows 15 . The number that will be really the ultimate hypocrisy. Important for here on howe out. Any republican senators that the minimum you need in each need any more evidence about this president need to look at caucus and primary. Keep in mind, 90 are primaries this video. Unfit. Give me your report from iowa. To be eligible to win delegates. The numbers keep going on. What happened last night was not a surprise from political he was at 3 , 5 , 9 , 14 . You ang 9 , 10 higher than i reporters. But in 2012 were on the ground would have expected him to be at in iowa when Rick Santorum this point. The problem, the only two candidates virtually assured of seemed to lose the Iowa Caucuses, then he seemed to have being at at least 15 everywhere are joe biden and bernie won. Complications in 2016 about sanders. They have a geographic breadth of support that is important whether or not senator sanders when it comes to this nominating or secretary clinton won. Process and the rules on the this is the Third Straight democratic side. The problem i see for bloomberg cycle. We have seen questions about and to an extent buttigieg and warren, their support is likely to be concentrated among whites ohio. With college degrees, nobody dropped out of this race. Geographically clustered in this country. That means they could fall short of that threshold on their do we know when theyre going to get on the results current trajectories in a lot of have they lost them . Congressional districts. What is going on . Jonathan lemire, talk about does anyone know what actually happened . Bloomberg, latest poll has him up to 14 nationally. We have Vaughn Hilliard and how does last night impact him . Get the latest in democrat. Theyll lean into this idea suggesting theyre the moderate alternative. The Iowa Democratic party says if these results sort of hold and joe biden does put up a their manual validating all of disappointing fourthplace the results. Finish, thats certainly they say they took pains to Say Something that mayor bloomberg this was not election and his team will try to interference as we have come to emphasize. Look, hes wounded. Understand it. What are you hearing from the were the best alternative to Democratic Party this morning donald trump. Pete buttigieg, and why last about what happened last night. Night hurts mayor Pete Buttigieg so much. Thats the issue, youre not he could have come out with a hearing anything from the iowa headline, if hes won a strong Democratic Party last night. Second, he could make that at 2 00 a. M. Eastern. Attempt to coalesce modern there was a press call that democratic voters say, look, im your alternative. Lasted 74 seconds. You dont need to turn your eyes there was no opportunity to ask to bloomberg, a billionaire, questions. Used to be a republican, maybe there is little that we know. Out of step with parts of the Democratic Party. Another candidate, its just bad 1678 presipcincts around this throughout. Joe biden here may be in some ways the luckiest guy here, as state. I was with a couple county chair pointed out, he can suggest results of invalid, say you folks and they were just shouldnt trust these. Move on to New Hampshire. Baffled. They were acknowledging what ill do better there. This means for iowa and the part if hed come out with fourth or about this, what you guys and fifth, what were talking about right now, thats a tough blow what reverend al just mentioned for him and potentially will was everything that went into slow down his fundraising, and issue throughout his campaign this moment. For the last year hundreds of and he needs a war chest for staffers have been on the South Carolina and super tuesday still a month away. Ground. People left school to come be Elizabeth Warren also part of the process. Volunteers were knocking on anecdotally seetmed to be pickig doors in zero degree weather. Up days before the caucus, folks that went into campaign another uncertainty pip goes into New Hampshire not nearly as events to be part of the popular as a neighboring senator democratic process and now it comes down to the fact that as Bernie Sanders is, so right folks dont know what to now with momentum being so key, believe. In the Democratic Party here in no one got any. Iowa right now they say they now instead were, the release the results here at some Democratic Party is looking at point later today, so that means itself and has to ask potentially some time when the themselves, how did we mess this sun is up, but the biden up again . No one got any and, again, campaign is pushing back saying talking about bloomberg, if hes the Iowa Democratic party they want to review the results trying to fill that gap in the before the Democratic Party puts middle of the Democratic Party, them out there. His main competitor is the guy last night they released two who by all accounts is running phone calls that the campaigns out of money fast. Took part in with the iowa joe biden. And as Vice President biden Democratic Party. Goes through a brutal february, there was frustrations and state after state, contest after little answers from the Democratic Party. As robert just mentioned there, contest trying to fight for his vote, mayor bloomberg is sitting there ready for early march, this is no surprise. Super tuesday, spending millions they talked about the on television advertising. Development of the app, and it largely avoiding the fights. Was an effort to try to make hes not on television that this a more open process. Often. Hes taken strategic trips ultimately in the process they around the country, and you see him with his message introducing himself to voter on social media were never able to say they were and television and his numbers wholly ready for the moment. Keep rising. Just to follow up on vaughns his team is watching. Can biden really come out of great reporting the campaign South Carolina with a boom and most frustrated on that call say, im going to be the last night, senator benny sand standard bearer for the moderate wing . If thats not the case, if its a muddled result out of south Bernie Sanders campaign. Carolina heading into super tuesday, thats where bloomberg believes he has the opportunity. They say maybe the process has because he comes out of super been flawed for decades. This result that oreffect. Tuesday maybe inching up to 20 in polls. 25 , and mayor buttigieg and biden, if theyre not there, say joe bidens campaign wants to we are ready to take on sanders for the long haul. Remember, sanders committed to going all the way to the review them. Convention. Yes, he will. What are the internal sanders so bloombergs whole argument is im the only one in his view, he says, who can do the same. Numbers telling that campaign . His theory of the case, the Sanders Campaign says based on their own internal sitting here waiting if there is chaos. Havent made up your mind im sitting here waiting. Pump all of this money in states numbers from nobody even has staff yet. What we have this morning so far precincts they say theyre is chaos. Id say one for one for victorious. And their own internal numbers bloomberg and see what goes from here. Quickly. Got to go. Cant let you go before we talk from boouttigiegbuttigiegs cam about the house races and the senate races. Where do they sit right now with impeachment about to end . Well, for the 30 democrats their own internal numbers say sitting in trump districts they cant wait to get it over with. Democrats look pretty good in theyre victorious. Terms of their odds in the house of keeping the house first. He didnt take the stage until theyve got a number of republican retirements. 11 30 last night and after every they can pick up i think four or other candidate went up and five seats in republican suggested they were leaving iowa districts. Doing well. So it was a missed opportunity new North Carolina map gives two districts for free. More than that, democrats are for the Buttigieg Campaign. Clobbering republicans in the they took a plain and theyre money chase. Are they really . We havent seen impeachment give republicans the energy boost in terms of recruitment sh showing up in New Hampshire, but and fundraising i thought they they not able to declare might get out of it. In the senate, uphill climb for democrats. Key is really going to be, can they put those two seats in themselves the surprising winner georgia in play . You know, mika, everybody claiming that impeachment is such a nightmare, all of the trumpists online and, you know, writing columns and on cable of the iowa cause discucuses. Cu. News saying that impeachment is so bad for democrats. Have laser drilled holes. They may want to pass that word they release medicine fast, along to the republican senators for fast pain relief. Who are begging donald trump to tylenol®. Not talk about impeachment tonight. Please, mr. Trump, just talk about the economy. Oh, my lord. Or maybe how you hold your hand over your heart when they play the starspangled banner. Well see. Dave wasserman, thank you so much. Still ahead, we dont know who won iowa but we learned a lot about the voters and the issues that matter most to them. Steve kornacki joins us from the big board next on morning joe. Applebees new irresistabowls now starting at 7. 99. Now thats eatin good in the neighborhood. You may have gingivitis. When you brush, and the clock could be ticking towards bad breath, receding gums, and possibly. Tooth loss. Help turn back the clock on gingivitis with parodontax. Leave bleeding gums behind. Parodontax. This rounds on me. Eat. The best of pressure cooking and air frying now in one pot, and with tendercrisp technology, hey, can you spot me . You can cook foods that are crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. Come on in. The ninja foodi Pressure Cooker, the Pressure Cooker that crisps. Find your place today, with silversneakers. Included in most Medicare Advantage plans. You make time. When you can. Enroll today by calling the number on your screen but sometimes life gets in the way, or visit getsilversneakers. Com and that stubborn fat just wont go away. Coolsculpting takes you further. Breathe freely fast, with vicks sinex. A nonsurgical treatment that targets, freezes, my congestions gone. And eliminates treated fat cells for good. I can breathe again ahhhh discuss coolsculpting with your doctor. Some common sideeffects i can breathe again ughh. Include temporary numbness, discomfort, and swelling. Dont imagine results, see them. Vicks sinex, breathe on coolsculpting, take yourself further. Go to coolsculpting. Com for a chance to win 25,000. Coolsculpting, take yourself further. Hi with the worldse first invisible trailer. Invisible trailer . And its not the trailer right next to us . This guy . You dont believe me . Hop in. Good lookin pickup, i will say that. The best of pressure cooking and air frying oh wow. Silverado offers an Optional Technology package with now in one pot, and with tendercrisp technology, up to 15 different views you can cook foods that are crispy on the outside including one enhanced view that makes your trailer appear invisible. And juicy on the inside. Wow. The ninja foodi Pressure Cooker, thats pretty sweet. Thats cool. The Pressure Cooker that crisps. Oooohh thats awesome. Whered the trailer go . I love it. Its magic. sensethe lack of control when iover my businessai, made me a little intense. But now quickbooks helps me get paid, manage cash flow, and run payroll. And now im back on top. With koala kai. vo save over 40 hours a month with intuit quickbooks. Welcome back to morning joe. Former mayor Pete Buttigieg of south bend, indiana. Do we congratulate you . Youre a winner, everybodys a winner. It does seem by the early results that you deserve more than a precipitation trophy, youre cutting across all types id say he has a reason to of voters, it seemed very be ang gris thry this morning. Successful for you and your whos that . Team. I think we were able to kcorkornacki. Demonstrate the winning message and the Winning Organization and rb we all . And political reporter and aunger of the red and the blue what was so important. Steve kornacki. Steve what can you tell us about iowa . Not at much as i thought id we voted democratic in the past be able to 24 hours ago coming and we do d well, this is really into today. The first proof point for the there you go. Looks exactly like it did yesterday. What . Yeah. Campaign putly going on to we thought it might actually be a relatively quick night turned into the longest night ever in defeat trump. Iowa caucus history. No results in yet across the and fighting people and not state. Shutting people out, and i think hopefully we will get some of that approach served us very those today. We do have, the only thing to go on basically two things. Number one, isolated precinct well. Media folks observing going through the process and saw what i dont think there is anyone happened in those few precincts. The other thing we have, the more eager than i am to get the entrance poll. A look at the iowa caucus electorate as it entered the numbers certified. But we did have the numbers we caucuses last night. We can show awe few findings had and those numbers are just from that one. Talked about it so much in the polling going into the caucus. Phenomenal. What is the campaign being the divide when it came to age. Told about what exactly went what we saw in the polls very much what we saw in the results wrong . What happened . Last night. Look at this. So i have not heard much of first you see about 55 of an explanation about what the caucusgoers over age 45, 45 technicals are. Were told there is a paper trail under age 45. Start with older voters, 45plus and a back up system and that is what that picture looked like. Biden and buttigieg basically very important giving that plan battling for the lead there. A did not work out. We need to see those numbers and klobuchar, warren, guess whos name you continue to see here . Im glad there is that way back, buried in low single verification process. But im frustrated and impatient digits here among voters like everybody. And here we are in New Hampshire 45plus, Bernie Sanders. So buttigieg, biden leading where of course a week from today were going to have the there. Sanders not registering. Next test, the next opportunity, what youre seeing at that end and im convinced here, too, of the hd. Go to the other end. 45 and under. That our effort, our message, completely different story. And our organizing approach will here is where you see Bernie Sanders running away with it. Serve us well. Mr. Mayor, tell me about your 41 for sanders, in single decision last night to go out digits over 45. At 41 under 45. And declare victory. That is doubling up Pete Buttigieg, warren, look that. Andrew yang double digits and we were looking at the guess whos name you continue to see here . The former Vice President joe internal numbers that we had and biden. Hes buried in Single Digits on beginning to realize that something extraordinary happened this question of age. So that the divide weve been last night pap cap pain that was seeing in the polls. Very much the divide we saw in the entrance poll. Obviously, im sure folks at really talk about reaching the home can do the math. What youre seeing, when you flatten those things out perhaps a bit of advantage, suggesting position that we did, and it was a clear victory for this possibly for buttigieg and campaign. Not based on anything you sanders with the others a little heard from the state democratic behind them. Thats the entrance poll. Party, for example . No, we dont have anything always take that with a grain of salt and start measuring against from the party. Nothing that you wouldnt have the actual results. Heard as well. We saw that early trickle, but quickly on ideology, the nix mi the thing about this, unlike a primary where there is a secret the iowa caucus. Somewhat liberal voters, larger ballot, this is folks standing in the room for all to see, with group, take you through what that looked like. Why was the presser right there and with our own observers right there. This group, largest among so it made it possible for us to democrats. See him leading there. Get a very clear sense of just also the Smallest Group here how extraordinary of a night it is and thats what i want today ideologic share with our reporters who are ideologically, liberal and no surprise here. Where sanders was running away just so charged up and excited with it. About this campaign. Buttigieg buried biden further behind with that. I know youre certainly those were divides we saw in pleased with the results or your polling leading up to uit. Sense of how last night went, but there is certainly a sense of dismay about the process that surprise in the entrance polls we dont have conclusive buttigieg stronger than expectations. See how that actually plays out in the individual precincts and counties. Hopefully infew hours results. There has been whispers from other campaigns suggesting that. Days, weeks . Well see. That perhaps iowa should be and its willie. Watching saying thank god we have Steve Kornacki on our team. Tossed out. So let me just ask you that, he is so good even with no should americans, should information to work with, but tell me about your interactions last night with the iowa state americans feel confident later Democratic Party . Today, if we get those results you did read a statement about two hours in at least an hour should we believe them . That is why that paper trail after you thought wed have some results, that was sort of the is so important. First red flag to a lot of people they didnt have what they needed. It wasnt forthcoming. The entire thing takes place out what type of panic, what did you in the open. Pick up from them as you spoke the frustration is the timing. To them over the course of the the results will come in and i night . What we picked up was not very much. Will trust the results but we i can tell you, look at the past wanted to see those results last four democratic Iowa Caucuses before last night. Night to we could support them. 2000, 2004, 2008, 2016, in all of those cases by about 8 30, thats why were waiting for the 8 45, you started to have a official numbers to come through, and at the same time we fairly significant amount of vote that was in that you could know for the road ahead that we start to look at. Are arriving with the 8 50 last night, 850, we have extraordinary momentum. We have beaten other expectation zero. At that point, 8 50 p. M. Eastern and this is why i was about to time, Iowa Democratic party told say with confidence when we got us its coming soon. On that plane that we were the word they used, soon. And used the word soon victorious. Repeatedly over the next couple just to pick up on jonathans of hours and soon became 9 30 point, why should any democratic and 10 00. Then when you start, got a statement there saying that, hey, they were having some, Quality Control issues. Party under take an iowa caucus right. What exactly that means . Basically got a couple without a mass i confusing statements out of them revealing result in the end. Quality control concerns left a well, i think one question is lot of questions and then at about how do you put together a 2 00 a. M. Eastern time said they technical system to move out e would do a Conference Call with reporters. Got on that 2 00 a. M. Eastern time. Precinct numbers. Chairmanning of state party came another is the future of the on read a very brief statement american public. Saying the results would be out i see a gathering majority of sometime today trying to make it americans that are united in sound like they had been wanting to make sure we turn the prepared for this all along. There were no questions. Page on this presidency. There were no specifics. There was no sense of what the timing would be today. We saw democrats, we saw is it 8 00 a. M. . Independents who walked away from the process in the past, we 8 00 p. M. Today . Ended the call. Saw a lot of republicans, took no questions. That was the last communication disaffected republicans that we were with them. Will not agree with me on the exit poll suggests everything but are just tired of obviously that only Pete Buttigieg seems to do well in trying to look their kids in the almost all of the demographic eye to explain this to them. Groups. Probably if those exit polls end while there is certainly up being accurate thats good frustration about the reporting news for him. But based on the the reports numbers coming out, this is about the American People that you got from the media, the choosing our future in a way media reports you got from some of the caucuses, just whats that will will what all things are about. We need a surge of support and i have to ask anybody who is your thumbnail sketch of what youre looking at, what youre following this campaign that believes in that approach to expecting when the results are politics to go to finally made public . Yeah. Peteforamerica. Com to chip in here what im looking for. Take you back to the map here. And lend us a hand. I know we have four daughters see. Go to this one. So what youre describing there between us, mayor pete youre in terms of the sanders support, if the entrance poll is number one from my girls and right and sanders is blowing everybody out with the youngest voters, but isnt registering joes daughters are waiting for even with the oldest voters, it your campaign texts as we speak. Raises the question to me again, is hi support concentrated in the college counties around the someone made a snide remark state . Iowa state, you know, luther and they said joe and mika will colleges, Grinnell College over here. Is his support going to be win iowa because of their concentrated in a few big daughters. If is a good start, if we can College Student dense young voter dense county where is he just count the votes, just runs up the score and congratulations. Potentially is able to win that from everything youre saying it first preference . Seems like you had a heck of a you know the people who night last night. Initially show up popular vote thanks for having me on. Essentially. Able to do that for him . Just i have to say, how whereas, again, entrance polls frustrating. The work they have done are right and buttigieg this is after all of that supporters are more spread out work. Agewise, potentially spread out i feel like this is the first geographically, is buttigieg doing a little better significantly better than sanders in the more rural areas, lord of the rings. In the older areas of the state . I watch itd for 3 1 2 hours because there is an imbalance in with my kids and at the end of the iowa state democratic it im like okay, how will it partys formula in terms ever awarding actual state delegates end, right . In this thing and the imbalance i sure do like walking with favorses the rural parts of the you, frodo. State. We showed it yesterday. Go west of des moines basically, i like walking with you, sam. Take this part of the state, and im like thats it . This is probably about 10 or star wars, lord of the 11 of the turnout in the Democratic Caucus is. Rings but you get into the second its more like 14 or 15 of one. I could do potter all day. Delegate strength. Two and three in lord of the bonus delegate wise in the rural rings. Areas and looking at that you can tell he feels like he entrance poll and extrapolate did great last night. It, an if, if it happens, it it was an extraordinary night. Those are internal Campaign Raises the possibility. Look for it today. Numbers, but the reason he is on hopefully today, of a split tv, they think they did well verdict. Thank you so much, steve. Last night. I know youre exhausted. Go back into your star wars well find out if the actual numbers match internal numbers cryogenic pod and theyll unfreeze you in an hour or two. Today. But pop cultural references we greatly appreciate it. What a mess. Aside, but what stood out the he wont sleep whamplts. Most is you had joe biden doing what a mess. The entire purpose of iowa and talk to these campaigns every well with older voters, but day. You talk to the candidates. Ive sat down with them. Really pour with Younger Voters. More than a year of their life, Bernie Sanders doing great with oh, on the ground, des moines, Younger Voters and poorly with sioux city. Iowa city. All wonderful city. Older voters, and mayor pete great city. Doing well with both sets of i love iowa. I love the people in des moines. Voters. That means something. Not just in iowa. Java joes. Great people. That is a transferable skill however, these people, these candidates, these aides spent months, years, for this one night. Yeah. Every place he goes. Tireless, regardless of which campaign youre on, tireless work. And i will say that he was reporters go in there. Were not the story but were there covering it, taking it he dismissed the idea that you should be worried about this but serious seriously. And then on the night where it turnout was not up that much matters, were just looking for an accurate result for the iowa last night. If i were a democratic looking at this, it is not just the Democratic Party, to not have it ready, it raises serious missteps, but where was the questions about iowas role, because iowa beyond just the problems last night, 90 white. Entuesde yeah. Enthusiasm to beat trump was not many older voters. Quite there last night either. Its not representative of the do you feel robbed . Democratic party. And why has this process continued after all of these challenges in previous cycles . I dropped a dumb and dumber because people want the bounce. Reference earlier this morning. Time and again. So youre saying he has a unbelievable, Jonathan Lemire. Again, the backdrop to this is chance. Wouldnt you say . I had ricky bobby, if youre even more remarkable where you have the director of the fbi, not first youre last. When im throwing i stay this director of the cia, the ndi, you name it. The military intel community. Weekend, it was on. Everybody saying that the it was awful. Greatest threat to american she would sit back there democracy is the sanctity of our going oh, its awful, and then election process, that it is the father would show up to the under attack and we have a president who ignores their career day and she is dieing laughing in the back of the warnings. Right. Room. How about the dinner table and so we come to the scene with the prayer, he thanks democrats first chance to show all of the sponsors and little that they know how to return an election, and it is just baby jesus. Coming up on morning joe botched. Right. The president , of course, downplayed the election the Impeachment Vote is a day interference in 2016. Taken a few steps to safeguard elections this nime 20time in 2. Away. Well talk more about that and to bobs point, taken coming up on morning joe. Coming up on morning joe. Seriously and dealt disservice by the state party the results cant be counted in a timely fashion all for democrats now this unknown, just going to feed into intraparty tensions and given life to conspiracy theories. The other concern, talk in the days before this iowa caucus about record turnout. A statement the state party put out earlier in the evening, how bout no . No. Turnout along the lines of 2016. Uh uh, no way. Not a record. Seems turnout might be down from come on. No. Where the party hoped it would no. Be. A question of enthusiasm . N. Ni ni, no no a question about the candidates . Only discover has no annual fee on any card. Adds to the utter mess for democrats coming out of iowa. We have to be careful talking the best of pressure cooking and air frying about this because we, again now in one pot, and with tendercrisp technology, have no idea what happened last night. Candidates are putting out their you can cook foods that are crispy on the outside own internal polls used and juicy on the inside. The ninja foodi Pressure Cooker, beneficial to them, but if youre joe biden and not likely the Pressure Cooker that crisps. To finish one, two or three and consternation about your candidacy coming out of iowa, can you not just leap ahead, plant your feet in New Hampshire and say, we got to throw out iowa. I mean, not literally throw out iowa but say we dont really know what happened in the state of iowa. The Campaign Starts now in New Hampshire and if i finish a close race against Bernie Sanders. 22 points eventual nominee Hillary Clinton a pretty good start for me . Put it this way. If i was joe biden i wouldnt want to clear up what happened our Retirement Plan with voya gives us confidence. Iowa. As long as it is cloudy, he can yeah, they help us with achievable steps along the way. Escape through the smoke, so to. So we can spend a bit now, speak, but i think it raises knowing were prepared for the future. Surprise we renovated the guest room, so you can live with us. Distinction for him in South Carolina. Mayor pete, im worried more oooh, well. Im good at my condo. Than before how i can get the black vote support up, and bern you who is not, whos doing oh. Better than 16 but not killing i love her condo. Nana throws the best parties. It in terms of the black vote. The question now is nevada and well planned, well invested, well protected. In terms of the latino and the voya. Be confident to and through retirement. Black vote expanding this. The winners last night unfortunately was donald trump hoot can now say, oh, theyre talking about vote incompetence. Look what happened in their opening round. Yep. And Michael Bloomberg who can say, im the one democrat that is an expert on competence and im not supporting anybody at this point, but bloombergs got to be fixing his collar for appearances today, because hes the one that can say, im competent. They cant even run an election. I know how to run things. Talk about whats going on on when a nasty cold wont let you sleep, the hill today obviously. Try nyquil severe with Vicks Vapocool impeachment continues. Whoa and vaporize it. You spoke with joe manchin. Ahhhhh important speech. Shhhhh nyquil severe with Vicks Vapocool. Moderate democrat. On the phone after announcing the vaporizing nighttime, pushing for censure and got a coughing, aching, stuffy head, best sleep with a cold, medicine. Copy of that censure resolution. Trying to win over some republicans, romney and collins be stronger. Both voted for witnesses. With nicorette coated ice mint. Murkowski, worst thing in the layered with flavor. Its the first and only coated nicotine lozenge. World wasnt going to impeach. For an amazing taste. That outlasts your craving. What about alexander . Its an option. Senator manchin has work to do nicorette ice mint. To win them over. No one came out yesterday on the for an amazing taste. TAmazon Prime Videocraving. So when you say words like, republican side said we stand with manchin on censure, but show me best of prime video into this, youll see awesome stuff like this. Thats way to have a lesser rebuke than removal from office. The questions for senator discover prime originals like, the Emmy Award Winning the marvelous mrs. Maisel, manchin and others who want to tom clancys jack ryan, go down that path is senate and the man in the high castle. Majority leader Mitch Mcconnell could kill the effort. All in the same place as your live tv. Make sure it never comes to the senate floor. Ahead well speak with one its all included with your amazon prime membership. Of the six winners of the iowa thats how xfinity makes tv. Caucuses. Simple. Easy. Awesome. President ial candidate Pete Buttigieg joins us live from the im feeing good right now campaign trail. In New Hampshire. Morning joe is coming right back. As a struggling actor, the president s behavior was shameful and wrong. I need all the breaks that i can get. His personal interest do not at liberty butchumal cut. Take precedence over those of Liberty Biberty cut. Well dub it. This great nation. Liberty mutual customizes your Car Insurance the president has the so you only pay for what you need. Responsibility to uphold the only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Integrity and the honor of the office. Not just for himself, but for all future president s. Degrading the office it weakens our country. I spend a lot of time sin my truck. Y . Its my livelihood. But im not going to do rock music anything would not want to degrade the man so im not taking any chances when something happens to it. Office. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi so when my windshield cracked. Says the impeachment trial of my friend recommended safelite autoglass. Tech hi, im adrian. President trump has forced h h, no problem. Tech check it out. Man yeah. They came right to me, with Expert Service President Trump to admit that he where i needed it. Was wrong to pressure ukraine to thats service i can trust. No matter what im hauling. Right, girl . Investigate his political rivals. Singers safelite repair, safelite replace. Pelosi said i think we have pulled back the veil of behavior totally unacceptable to our founders. And the public will see this with an unblurred eye. Whatever happens, he has been impeached forever and now these senators, though they dont have the courage to assign the appropriate penalty, are at least recognizing that he did something wrong. In the interview she called Mitch Mcconnell a wholly owned subsidiary of the white house, and trump is the puppeteer of nyquil severe gives you powerful relief for your worst cold and flu symptoms, on sunday night and every night. Nyquil severe. The nightime, sniffling, sneezing, the senate. She said he is a guest in our coughing, aching, stuffy head, best sleep with a cold, medicine. House tonight, and we hope he will behave as a guest in our its an easy way to earn its cashback on the stuff house. Im already buying. When you have a child and theyre constantly growing joining now, minority whip dick out of clothing, earning cashback from rakuten durbin of illinois, great to have you on the show. Just makes everything easier. Sometimes its 3 sometimes its 8 but youre senator, great to have you here, im sure you have mixed always getting cashback. The way cashback works on rakuten is so they get a feelings when you hear us. Commission from the store and then they share that is certainly so much that commission with me. And you have money, more money to spend better. Because you got free money. Go to rakuten. Com and sign up today for a 10 bonus. You always want to be able to for your patients. F get them out of pain, get them out of pain fast. But the office, marco rubio says we have a new product out there sensodyne rapid relief. He has committed impeachable if you use it on monday, by thursday, pochbss, but not going to have youll be enjoying that Chocolate Ice Cream again. Him removed. They can start it, and 3 days later, i can go down the long list. I know that theyre going to have the results they were looking for. La march alexander, im still trying to figure out what he would say, right . They wont vote for a fair trial, will they vote for a senture. Just remember that a senture wou centure. It would take place in the senate. All right, would you support a senture resolution . I certainly would, but i hope it is not viewed as an alternative to impuchment. Senator murkowski who is my friend and who i respect very much, they have all but conceded the facts of this impeachment trial, they understand what he did, we all do. And i think they put something on it. The iowa caucus is the big i guess that leads to my next deal of the day for democrats today. Why . I still dont know. Question, assuming the kwle feel the iowa caucus, a lot like polaroid cameras in that no one even more emboldened, what is understands how they work. The next procedural. Iowa gets to go first because i dont know. I guess they have nothing else to look forward to. You live in iowa you dont have it is clear that even despite to actually be in iowa to cast the admission by my republican your vote. This is what they call a colleagues of his wrong doing, satellite caucus in florida, they will take no action to show snow birds go and tells you him down or stop him. His aides or staff have now caucuswise all you need to know about this process. Exact on the mans decision especially when you throw a little florida in the mix. Sanders won. Steyer, two. Making, but prepared and be warren, 12. Yang, one. And i dont have uncommitted yet. Ready. Hey senate eor durbin, you h were there any uncommitteds . Been in that body for tsome tim now. Im curious what you make of his okay, okay. Wait, wait. Were you uncommitted back there . He voted not to acquit the what about deceased . President , he didnt even want is anyone deceased . No . Okay. To vote to have witnesses or evidence. How does he explain that vote to you . Good luck havie hacking that, p did you lobby him at all . Welcome back to morning did you speak to him privately . Joe live in washington it is tuesday february 4th. I didnt walk the floor or lobby my friends on the other joining joe, willie and me, columnist and associate editor side. I listened to him and i know for the Washington Post david ignatius. White house correspondent for theyre saddened by this moment. Pbs newshour, Yamiche Alcindor and peter baker, from the new york times. Good to have you onboard. Still do not know. Send the impeach mement they bod last nights caucuses after what the Democratic Party says are inconsistencies in reporting the data. We have that story. Claim. Im aphrase this impeachment also the miami herald showed a trial was a sad moment in the clip of the president of the United States. Oh, my goodness. Body. Thinking about the document mocking the starspangled rendered now i have the voters, banner. Peter baker, any word from the what is the message that you white house yet from this miami would like the senate to ask the Herald Report the president mocking the star bangled voters to deliver. President trump will say this banner. Look at him there conducting, vote acquits him, showing it was a witch hunt, how do you counter everybody else, wife, hand over heart. Showing respect. And here he is clowning that as you think about november . Around and being extraordinarily i just think it doesnt disrespectful. A City Council Person who did reflect the majorities of this would be run from their office. A Country Music star who did america. He does not reflect who we are this would lose their fans and who we want to be. Overnight. A preacher who did this would probably lose their congregation which he put economic numbers up as long as he wishes, but the next sunday. Look at this. Here he is mockingly intuitively the American People mocking are not being as pushed and horsing around. Yes, horsing around during prodded and persuaded by this at all. They understand this president the starspangled banner. Is not someone that respects our is he making fun of it . Values our speaks for us. It looks like it. It is extraordinary. Of course we know the backdrop to it also. Lets not miss this opportunity. That he made such a big damn deal for a year or two when a whether or not it is tonight at the state of the union or black man didnt so sufficient some time in the very near respect to the flag and, oh, you future, we expect the president have to respect the flag. Theres the president , in the to go on and it will happen super bowl. Yeah. And this is what he said last year about this. Tomorrow, but could you just talk about what this means for you have to stand proudly for the senate itself . The National Anthem or you do you feel like your colleagues shouldnt be playing. Shouldnt be there, maybe you on both sides of the isle lived shouldnt be in the country. So he says you should stand up to what they asked them to proudly. Take another look at miami uphold about delivering herald the clip the miami impartial justice . Herald showed from an instagram it was saeved here in the last few weeks. Photo of him and see if you think hes standing closing the door was the end of respectfully. Looking around, talking, patting any effort to show. People on the back. Pointing at them. Mockingly conducting the and i will give you one number to remember. We considered exactly 22 band. So peter baker, heard anything from the white house about this . Ive got to say, just say, at least in my district, my old amendments opinion six were throw away no votes, 22 were district. That wouldnt work. They would consider that to be disgusting behavior. Havent heard anything from the white house about it but a amendments. By saying were going to take up phenomena with donald trump, all no substantive election, were the things you said. If this were done biby fill just focused on filling federal judicial spots and that is it. The blank. And identified the kansas city that is a change in the right chiefs being located in kansas. Direction and this senate is a hmm. And same rules dont apply for donald trump. Capstone of the mcconnell right . The other thing utraged b strategy. You mentioned that there was will they in this case . Ntic recourse. There was confusion what is your so many other things provoked reaction to what youre seeing. The fact that we have no idea outrage and dont seem to among his own supporters. What happened last night because he has a remarkable political skill at sort of skating through of the technology vote, do you things that would seem to be inconsistent, seem to be think the iowa caucus is a good way to elect a president ial inappropriate or outrageous, and his own people just cheer him on and think that, that show as nominee. I spent a lot of time real person in their view. Campaigning for them over the and the super bowl link. Remember many people expressed years, theyre wonderful people and theyre a great bunch. Moral outrage about the halftime having said that i think that show. Franklin graham and others who the Democratic Caucus in iowa is support donald trump looked a kwauquarky tradition that sho other way for someone who cheated on his wife with a porn wife and paid her off to keep it quiet. Illegally, we might add. Come to an end. Top story of the morning, the iowa caucus is the most painful situation we face for voting. People that work all day, do you david ignatius, intread it think theyre going to the reporter. Tell us, what happened . Caucus next . An extraordinary story we of course not. We have to have a means for feel just dont know. Hows that possible . Well, were going to find out. Its going to be one of the express themselves and the better tick tock as we say in caucus is not it. Our business reconstruction stories. Just how did this happen . Youre the second most why was there such poor powerful democratic in the communication by the iowa authorities . Why was the system so vulnerable United States senate. We talk about this all of the after so many months of preparation . But it is one of the big time. The Democratic Party doesnt anticlimaxes i can remember in look to two of the whitest states in america to pick the primary history. You know, david, you remember president ial nominee from for back at the 2000 recount. Republicans and democrats alike a very diverse party. Got together and a lot of us were talking after that about how does this it has to stop, having a more unified, National Everybody says it has to stop. System to stop butterfly ballots in florida from happening to stop this sort of thing from happening. I know we want to allow the the same thing happens. States to have some deference, why not start with florida, but should there be a minimum illinois, jazz even. Standard . So, thats one of the questions were going to look these two very white states. At. The vulnerability thats been i love my neighbors in iowa demonstrated in the system, the and i have campaigned with them fear is the demonstration effect. And i respect them very much for here in this primary weve been their commitment to the party, waiting for a whole year, its but the state of iowa does not reflect our party and the fact obvious to anyone who looks at that were putting so many chips home or abroad that the system on the table in iowa. Here we are the morning after in some ways that we still dont with the iowa caucus to be one understand can be interfered with, and i just worry that that demonstration effect will encourage other people to play games down the road. Big political asterisk. I just was talking last week i would like to see a more diverse beginning. With secretary of state from a key swing state and he had been all right, senator dick meeting with other secretaries of state and they are pulling durbin, thank you very much. Out their hair thinking how do david, iowa and New Hampshire we, without having federal make sense for the republican rules, which saints dont want. They want to run elections on party. I would guess about 90 of their own, have severe republicans are white. Elections . I dont have the exact number, just the rumor of what happened iowa could happen in your state but were saying this is nothing will be the destabilizing factor. Theyve got to figure it out. Against iowa. And yamiche, not like iowa and New Hampshire work. But if you have a party that is tornadoes were racing through more diverse, you have to go to there. Wasnt even apparently a record turnout which we heard about. States like florida or arizona in fact, in many of the precincts heard the turnout was or georgia or illinois. Yeah, i think that message about the same as 2016. Will be clear that this was a they werent overwhelmed. Muddy Tuesday Morning where were just trying to think how they knew what to expect for four years and still botched it. To parse all of this, but one how long did you say the call . 74second call report but you said actually shorter than that . Clear conclusion this being the the call, yeah. Iowa state Democratic Party had a call between 53 seconds and 74 seconds to say basically we will starting gate, that has to end, give you more information when we have it. And if the democrats want to be that obviously means they are the start of the minority being defensive, because its embarrassing for them. Iowa, this is something that majority they talk about all year. The idea of pushing iowa something that was so out they could make the first anticipated and then when the actual big night comes there are contest a battleground state. No results. I think if youre someone like there is diversity where they Amy Klobuchar or joe biden this is a gift for you, that you can could capitalize on them. Say, well, you know, just stick michigan would be a great with me in New Hampshire. Stick with me in South Carolina, state. Michigan would be a great state and super tuesday. For democrats. Of course, the president and the you have diversity. You have cities, you have rural Trump Campaign has already seized on this making fun of areas, you have working class democrats saying how in the world can you fix health care, democrats, you have union a redesign the Health Care System strong union. If you cant deal with item wa you have all of the elements that make the Democratic Party strong and made it strong over caucuses . Also a big question whether or the past century all in the not iowa should be first to get it. Im not sure theyll change it state of michigan, why not start because of this one thing but look at demographics of iowa and there. Iowa seems like the wrong a state like florida or texas or place to start and this morning other places more we dont even have results which demographically look like the makes it worse. Rest of the state, you have to there is a lot of history being wonder whether or not democrats will say, is this the day or the made in politics lately. Year we really rethink our nominating system . Well, and a textbook example well be back on morning joe. Of a winner. Here are the candidates. So we dont know all the results. But we know by the time its all said and done, iowa, you have shocked the nation. [ cheers and applause ] i love rakuten, its basically free money. Because by all indications we. Its an easy way to earn cashback on the stuff are going on to New Hampshire victorious im already buying. Sometimes its 3 sometimes its 8 but youre always getting cashback. So its like getting free money. Go to rakuten. Com and sign up today for a 10 bonus. I imagine, have a strong feeling, that at some point the results will be announced. [ cheers and applause ] introducing a razor that works differently. And when those results are the Gillette Skinguard announced, i have a good feeling has a guard between the blades that helps protect skin. Were going to be doing very, very well here in iowa. The Gillette Skinguard. Lets stay in a good spirit, because you all know what happened out there in those precincts. You know that we have been this rounds on me. Eat. Punching way beyond our weight hey, can you spot me . [ cheers and applause ] you know that despite some limited resources compared to some of those bigger bank come on in. Accounts, we are way on the find your place today, with silversneakers. Board. So lets stay up included in most Medicare Advantage plans. Enroll today by calling the number on your screen lets stay up lets stay happy and lets head or visit getsilversneakers. Com to New Hampshire. Thank you, iowa, i love you [ cheers and applause ] dealing with our finances really haunted me. Ttle cranky. So, listen, it is too close thankfully, i got quickbooks, to call. So im just going to tell you and a live bookkeepers helping customize it for our business. What i no know. You won [ cheers and applause ] live bookkeeper youre all set up janine great vo get set up right with a live bookkeeper with intuit quickbooks. When youyou spend lessfair, and get way more. As the baby daughter of a janitor, i am so grateful to be so you can bring your vision to life up on this stage tonight. [ cheers and applause ] and save in more ways than one. Tonight as a party we are one step closer to defeating the most corrupt president in american history. [ cheers and applause ] for small prices, well, the Iowa Democratic you can build big dreams, spend less, party is working to get this get way more. Result. Get them straight. Shop everything home at wayfair. Com and i want to make sure theyre very careful in their deliberations. The best of pressure cooking and air frying and indications are, from our now in one pot, and with tendercrisp technology, indication its going to be you can cook foods that are crispy on the outside close. Were going to walk out of here with our share of delegates. And juicy on the inside. We dont know exactly what it is the ninja foodi Pressure Cooker, yet but we feel good about where the Pressure Cooker that crisps. We are and, look, so its on to hea country that puts working New Hampshire. Appropriate. All right, so i will agree. Together ahead of oh, my god. Standing apart. I will agree with pete where we find Common Ground to buttigieg. I think his statement was best. Expand health care and build a stronger, fairer economy and whats that . Iowa did shock the world last save our planet. Night. Sure did, and were on to new im a problems solver, i build teams, hampshire. The electrical current of i nurture good ideas, i hold myself accountable inprehenceable incompetence. For results. We are shocked, iowa. Its how i led a complex, we are shocked. Diverse city and its how ill you know, willie, the sanders unite and lead this country. Supporters right there from time im Mike Bloomberg and to time are described as angry i approve this message. People. I will tell you if i were a sanders supporter or if i were Bernie Sanders, man, and theres not a word for what i would be. He worked his ass off for years survived a heart attack, like like outperformed everybody on the ground. Supporters. 500,000 doors and the victory, either he or mayor pete won last night. We dont know. But if im bernie, man, or if im mayor pete, i am really angry right now. Yeah. This is inexcusable. All that work, all of those volunteers, all of those door knocks, those tens of millions of dollars in advertising were all pushed into iowa for this morning. And this morning is when we go on the air and announce the winner. Bernie sanders believed it would have been him. Pete buttigieg thought it would have been him and then youre off to the races. Right . You go into New Hampshire. Pat buchanan said got 100 million of earned media from an iowa win. Yes. They got nothing. Got nothing. So they all did last night what they should do. With no result go up on the stage and say you won. Why the hell not . Pete buttigieg got out early said we won. Theyve all turned the corner. Going to New Hampshire. Mayor buttigieg on the show notw joining us now, susan a page hampshire. Theyre walking away from this. And author on nbc news news well get a result later in the day. Peter, i think to the question president ial historian michael about what the Democratic Party in iowa has said or hasnt said in that lack of communication beshlov. Can you think of anything like what you have seen tonight . That yamiche talked about. Bike we see tonight, on the the last communication, they said the ad did not go down. Not a hack or intrusion trying heels of the caucus. To put to rest the speculation in terms of news, no. About foreign intrusion or 21 years ago, you all remember everything we know russia has been up to over the last few that when bill clinton gave his years but those in the precinct state of the union in the middle of his impeachment trial he was said the app didnt work. Saying we were on hold two hours not running for reelection. Trying to work out the kinks and clinton was so disciplined with our app or report results. He tried to keep what he with this is an unmitigated disaster. No other way to put it. The question now is, will iowa impeachment, and these long speeches, they felt longer the remain the first in the nation when we do this four years from better, people would hear a proposal that would make clinton now . And more immediately, was does more popular, but didnt mention it mean for this race, today . Thats right. Impeachment. Look, if youre message is we do you think donald trump will have the same inclination dont need the russians to screw tonight . I remember those speeches, i things up because we do it was sitting in the chamber. Ourselves, its not a good message. Right . It went on and on. Oh, my god. For years whats looked like a quirky, charming relic of i would wander to the cloak room, lie down on the couch, watch tv, wander back out. American democracy today looks i always thought this is going dangerous, reckless, to bomb. No. People loved it. Incompetent, embarrassing, dysfunctional, pick your the numbers went up. Adjective. Susan, somebody whose numbers you heard last night even former didnt go up, joe bidens. Dnc chairman Terry Mcauliffe saying its over. Looked like joe may have dodged we cant keep iowa as first in the nation. For all sorts of reasons long a very bad result. Before this issue started in the luckiest man in america terms of representation, in today is joe biden because we terms of why them . To test our kwn best state in know from what indications we have, he was not doing well in iowa, enabled him to dodge the bullet. If Pete Buttigieg does as well as it seems he has done in iowa, it prevents him getting that banner headline going into New Hampshire today. So what is the soonest we would get results if they hand count and everything . Does it matter . How are the results impacted by the catastrophic delay . I think they still matter, but they dont have the impact they would have had if they had come out as they usually do last night. It is beyond unbelievable. Youre the president ial historian, lets talk competence. We have a president talking tonight, we have Mitch Mcconnell, nothing happening in the senate, nothing happening from the white house other than nasty tweets and a lot of back and forth. You think back, look at the field. I ask in the field who has the competence, who has the understanding how to make washington work again. You think about lbj. He inherits the presidency from a martyred president who though wildly popular didnt know how to get things passed. Lbj breaks the log jam, passes civil rights. Same thing with tr. He had the working knowledge to use the bully pulpit to pass some remarkable break up the trusts, give working class americans rights. Whos out there that knows how to run washington in. Youre making an argument for experience. Richard nixons slogan in 1960 was it is experience that counts. I wouldnt suggest that be a great slogan for people to use nowadays, but what youre saying is strong president s who hr effective had been ones with a history of knowing how to deal with congress and knowing how to talk to the American People. It is not something thats really very much valued in a lot of early contests. Lbj wasnt popular. I remember reading about how the congress who had their way with kennedy tee siddecided they wer stopping him sending grain to russia. He said in his subtle texas way im going to kill that bill. And he did. And he did it in such a way that suddenly the power went back. From the days after kennedys death with this life force, this passion, famous moment where he said what the hell is the presidency for if not to make a difference. And people picked up on that. Theres one person that will have a pretty interesting argument today, Michael Bloomberg, the guy that sort of invented modern data crunching, who was a competent mayor. Interesting to see how he plays this. Say after the mess of iowa, personal positions move into the post iowa, post New Hampshire, post South Carolina world, maybe Michael Bloomberg. Wasnt that his plan . His plan is sanders will be doing well, he is leading in New Hampshire, biden will stumble, there will be an opening for someone more centrist than Bernie Sanders. We never had a super tuesday like march 3rd, one so early and big, a third of delegates to be nominated elected on that single day. Thats the Michael Bloomberg dream. Michael, on the question of competence, the president and republicans are already saying theyre drawing a Straight Line from what the Iowa Democratic party did to say Bernie Sanders being president , the line is they cant run a caucus in iowa but they want to run the national Health Care System. Does that strike you as an effective argument . It might actually work in certain ways with certain voters just as in 1968, for instance, when Richard Nixon was running for president , he said the democrats could not run a convention in chicago, do they have the competence to lead america. I want to show you guys as we end, miami herald showed the president of the United States clowning around, acting mockingly, mockingly conducting an orchestra during the super bowl starspangled banner. Can we run the clip real quick . Yeah. Michael, i would ask you for precedent to this. Im pretty certain i think we would be waiting a long time to find one, joe. You know of none. Do you guys have it . It is coming. Have you seen the clip . I have seen the clip. Here is donald trump, everybody else, hand over heart, his son, hand over heart, his wife, hand over heart, lock at him mockingly conducting, pointing at people that are all hand over hearts. Thoughts, susan . I think it is distressing and it probably will not have any impact on President Trumps supporters giving what we have seen happen in the past. I agree with susan. People think they know him, it is not a huge surprise he would do Something Like this, i think theyll cut him slack. That does it for us this morning. Stephanie ruhle picks up coverage after a quick final break. As parents of six, this network is one less thing i have to worry about. vo why the aceves family chose verizon. We all use our phones very differently. These two are always gaming and this one is always on facetime. And my oldest is learning to be a pilot. We need a Reliable Network because i need to know hes safe. As soon as he lands, he knows he better call mama. Mama vo the network more people rely on, gives you more. Like plans your family can mix and match starting at just 35. And apple music on us. Plus, up to 700 off the latest iphone when you switch. Thats verizon. Yeah. Only pay for what you need with Liberty Mutual. Only pay for what you need with Liberty Mutual. Con Liberty Mutual solo pagas lo que necesitas. Only pay for what you need. Only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Nyquil severe gives you powerful relief for your worst cold and flu symptoms, on sunday night and every night. Nyquil severe. The nightime, sniffling, sneezing, coughing, aching, stuffy head, best sleep with a cold, medicine. The best of pressure cooking and air frying now in one pot, and with tendercrisp technology, you can cook foods that are crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. The ninja foodi Pressure Cooker, the Pressure Cooker that crisps. Hi there. Im stephanie ruhle. It is tuesday, february 4th. Heres whats happening this morning. Absolute chaos and confusion in the state of iowa as technical issues overshadow the first votes of the president ial election. By this time this morning, we were supposed to have a clear winner and delegate count. One or more Democratic Candidates were supposed to be riding a wave of momentum and iowa was supposed to be boasting a new transparent reporting process. Instead, front pages of newspapers across this nation are telling a very different story of a party in self inflicted disarray. The Iowa Democratic party says