Transcripts For MSNBCW Morning Joe 20190731

July 31st, along with joe, themselves in the democratic willie, and me, we have msnbc party, do you want to be woke or do you want to win . Contributor, mike barnable, White House Reporter for the if you want to win, and amy associated press, jonathan klobuchar, tim ryan and others were pushing this point, you lemire, white house have to come to the table with correspondent for pbs news hour, the policies that will resonate with the American People, and what you laid out, joe, is not it. And mika, really quickly, by yamic yamiche. The way, its not an either or. The progressives were center stage, flanked on the wings by you can do both, its just moderates. Youve got to find the right there was great give and take. Balance. Lets bring in editor in i think any donald trump chief of cosmopolitan magazine supporter that saw this debate stage might not have as many jessica pelles. Easy targets as they did after the last round of democratic did candidates make a dent in debates because you actually had joe bidens lead in the poll for some more moderate candidates young voters . They did not. Hes still the leader in our actually suggesting more of a polls, and he is pulling ahead practical approach, lets say for two reasons. The first is that in a crowded than an overly utopian approach sea of candidates who are struggling to differentiate which i think a lot of americans themselves from each other, he has a couple advantages. Would think when youre talking the first is serious name about giving health care to Illegal Immigrants and youre recognition. He also evokes sent mimentalityf talking about giving Free Education to somebody because they cross the border, i think a calmer time. He has the obama halo. Thats a 80 20 issue, americans would be against it and think it was too utopian. I would be remiss if his and willie geist, first of all, i thought the debate was friendly relationship with obama really well run. They got a lot in there, the lt a lot of conversations. Wasnt fodder and they were i cant wait until we get back to smaller numbers. A little frustrating when they had to move on. Concerned about that. Who do you think had the stand i do not think he would hold out nights, a few candidates had that position unless hes really breakout moments . I think miami set up detroit, strong tonight. You asked readers about their and detroit was a reaction to biggest fears heading into 2020. What happened in miami. You had of all people, we were this is so important because you just talking about this, john have so many readers giving you delaney was the leadoff guy, feedback. What did they tell you . The most frequent response i posed as the moderate to go got from my readers last night was, im afraid that trump will after Bernie Sanders, elizabeth get reelected and hate will warren, and governor hickenlooper got in talking continue to spread. I will lose my reproductive about wish list economics. This was the push back of moderates against elizabeth freedom, Climate Change will warren and Bernie Sanders and continue to be ignored. These are very serious issues push back about some of the concerns that more moderate and there is a loft concet of c democrats have about the direction of the party and the direction this primary is about the damage he could do the next four years. Heading. Thats the bottom line. Well see if we see more of that it will be so interesting to see tonight. Whats interesting mike how it goes tonight and from barnicle, is that you did have your readers tomorrow. That give and take. You did have the back and forth, the question seems to be who can and i think a lot of people beat trump, and i think joe biden has a lot on the line have i cant say they have forgotten but perhaps it has tonight. He does. Well see which joe biden shows been pushed to the back of their mind. Maybe we remember it because we up tonight. Talked about it every day for his team knows he needs to have two years. A much better performance than the battle over obamacare and he had the first night, but he the fight, the struggle just to has a delicate needle to thread, get it to where it was. Right . Hell have to defend his record i think they ended up with 50 and at the same time hell have votes and the Vice President had to go on offense, so well see to break that vote. If hes able to land those but it was the toughest battle. Democrats lost. Punches. Governor bullock framed it as lets think about this. Over the next six years, wishful economics and thats democrats lost a thousand seats, legislative seats across the nation after obamacare passed in part because of the political sort of the debate democrats are having. And joe biden is going to need to show a better command of the fight that democrats put up stage than last time but be able with. To tie those two things george bush once said, its together. Hard, its hard, and the people a practical approach but also big ideas. Are going around throwing around jessica, millennials and joe promises, they sound an awful lot like Donald Trumps promises for universal health care, very bidens age . Its interesting. Easy to make promises on the millennials tell us by majority that they do not make choices by campaign stage. Elizabeth warren said the worst problem we have in washington, age or gender. D. C. Is corruption. Id say that americans probably what they are swayed by are think the worst problem we have policy. In washington, d. C. Over the th this is a very practical feet on last 20, 25 years are broken the ground generation that will promises and god bless elizabeth vote for a candidate on what warren and bernie if they can they believe in. So bottom line is, as we look toward tonight, into the future and next year, we have a real follow through with what they say, but i wont condemn people for trying to figure out what advantage in that trump unifies can we do, what promises can we our party, no matter who the deliver. Nominee is. I hate to keep going on and on absolutely. All right. Wow. A lot to look forward to about this, but man, obamacare tonight. That does it for us this was a fight to the political morning. Death, and for people to now go, Stephanie Ruhle picks up the that didnt go far enough. Coverage right now. Thanks, mika. Hi there, im Stephanie Ruhle. Lets do ten times the amount of work. Its not realistic, i dont it is wednesday, july 31st, and think. Joe, you know, that gets to a busy day it is, so lets get the point of the biggest winner last night, and i think a lot of started. One debate down and another to people would think that the go. Tonight were going to see part biggest winner last night was 2 of this democratic substance because they actually president ial debate and a lot of what we expect to see tonight discussed Health Care Legislation in some detail, and will have to do with what we saw last night in part 1. Elizabeth warren, she has a grasp of details that she it was packed with fiery moments manages to articulate in very from health care to immigration to economics. The idealogical divide between short bytes. The progressives and the 30 and 60 second bytes i think moderates within the democratic that resonate with people, and party was front and center. I think democrats win when we as far as the biggest problem in washington, i think it was going to revert to whats going to run on real solutions, not impossible promises. Happen tonight. I think a lot of people, when we run on things that are especially democrats watching these debates, to them, the biggest problem in washington is donald trump. And i think thats where it will go tonight. I think last night there were several people on that stage last night who will disappear from the National Stage but the debate last night that once it got going after about 20 minutes, it was pretty good. It was pretty educational. A lot of substance. That was kind of impressive. Lets go through it, mika. Right off the bat, it was a clash of ideas between lower polling candidates urging incremental change and Senators Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders advocating for a system wide overhaul. Here are some of the opening statements. Folks, we have a choice, we can go down the road that senator sanders and senator warren want to take us with bad policies like medicare for all, free everything and impossible promises that will turn off independent voters and get trump reelected. Last year, democrats flipped 40 republican seats in the house and not one of those 40 democrats supported the policies of our front runners at center stage. That teacher working a second job just to afford her insulin, they cant wait for a revolution. This isnt about left or right. This is about new and better. I will offer solutions that are bold, that are realistic. Youre going to hear a lot of promises up here, but im going to tell you this, yes, i have bold ideas, but they are grounded in reality. Our problems didnt start with donald trump. Donald trump is part of a corrupt, rigged system that has helped the wealthy and the well connected and kicked dirt in the faces of everyone else. Were not going to solve the urgent problems that we face with small ideas and spinelessness. Were going to solve them by being the Democratic Party of big structural change. By the way, willie, there is no doubt that you had Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders were on fire last night. Oh, my gosh. And for a primary, for a debate, that is what you want to do. I mean, im talking about the mundane mechanics of washington, d. C. But boy, they were on fire last night. Yeah, theres no question about it. I mean, to follow up with what mike said and you were saying earlier, this was a substantiative debate. Whether or not you agreed with what all of these candidates were saying, they were articulate, they were well versed, fluent in their policy, and you know, Elizabeth Warren, you may not agree with her ideas but boy does she know them, and john delaney, if youre a progressive, you may think he doesnt go too far, but hes thought out his ideas, and i think its worth pausing in the last couple of years worth that have been bereft of policy discussion, its nice to hear a little bit of that on stage, john l john, there was a lot of obama representatives, rahm emanuel put out a memo yesterday admonishing the democrats on the stage not to repeat what happened in miami, unless they want to lose and handle the election to donald trump. David axel rod after the debate, back and forth with Elizabeth Warren pushing her on her ideas. That was front and center, that sort of conversation in the party about how far left to go. Thats what the debate was about, where the spirit and soul of the Democratic Party is right now, between Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders who were both on fire and had very good moments, exchanging very little fire on each other, and that was interesting. It seemingly was a sense they are competing with some of the same voters, yet they didnt interact with each other, and when they did it was to agree, and they indeed took on fire from more of the moderates and some were scored points. At some point, if Elizabeth Warren or Bernie Sanders, some of the attacks that came from fellow democrats, you could hear echoed and amplified from republicans down the road. I think the debate about medicare for all of course is one thats going to really shape this democratic contest in the months ahead. Im certain it will be more about it tonight. Whats also interesting is what didnt come up last night. Talk about the federal judiciary and the Supreme Court didnt come up last night. Impeachment didnt come up last night. Robert mueller, who dominated the news cycle last night didnt come up last night. Yeah. Sure. But medicare for all did. Medicare for all. Also the red sox did not come up last nigh. Tons of exchanges. About paired for amedicare f. Theres no need to debate that. On the medicare for all, the hospitals will save substantial sums of money because theyre not going to be sending a fortune doing dealing and the other bureaucratic things they have to do today. It doesnt add up. Maybe you make money off of health care. His math is wrong. Thats all im saying. His math is wrong. Its been well documented if all the bills were paid at medicare rate, which is specifically, i think in section 1200 of their bill, then many hospitals in this country would close. I think were being offered a false choice, some who want to improve the Affordable Care act at the margins, others who want a medicare for all program that will force people off of private insurance. I have a better path. Medicare for america, everyone whos uninsured is enrolled in medicare tomorrow. At the end of the day, im not going to support any plan that rips away Quality Health care from individuals. This is an example of wish list economics. It used to just be republicans that wanted to repeal and replace, now Many Democrats do as well. Lets be clear about this. We are the democrats, we are not about trying to take away health care from anyone. Thats what the republicans are trying to do. Okay. So lets bring in yamiche, director of communications for Hillary Clinton. It must be interesting for barack obama and everybody who fought so hard for obamacare over the first two years of his administration to hear suddenly that their position is a republican sellout position, and that it just doesnt go far enough. I guess that does talk about how far the Democratic Party has come in a few years, but from when you go out and you interview people, do people want obamacare to be mended and not ended or do you see a lot of democrats in the base really wanting to try medicare for all . Well, this debate was really about the fault lines running through the Democratic Party. The question is do voters want someone whos going to be thinking about practical ideas and chasing independent voters who voted for President Trump but who are now double thinking their idea and thinking they can go with the democrats or do you want a democrat who has big progressive, bold ideas who wants to redo the entire system. When i talk to voters, theyre in some ways split on that. They like the idea of building on obamacare if youre a democrat, especially if youre someone who was a fan of the president , but then there are people who are saying, look, obamacare is really expensive. I want something that is bigger than that. Most democrats that i talked to recognize how long it took for democrats to get health care passed in it country, and theyre very worried that theyre not sure that if the republicans hold on to the senate, democrats will be able to change health care in any big ways. Thats interesting about last nights debate, the idea that Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren, they were going to fact off everyone else and they werent going to fight each other. A lot of people thought that putting Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren on the stage, youre going to get this big food fight, and instead what you got was a park picnic and classic straus and a conversation about substance. They have supporters that say we want medicare for all. Go for it completely. There was a split on stage. Im sure you heard the discussion for willie talking about members of the Obama Administration taking to task some progressives who suggested that obamacare was somehow too conservative, didnt go far enough. I dont know about you but i remember what it was like around washington in 2009. That was a pitched battle. Barack obama pushed washington, pushed congress, pushed america as far as he could possibly push them and barely got obamacare over the finish line. Now for it to be dismissed as a republican idea, now for it to be dismissed as too conservative, has to really be galling for barack obama and all of those who fought to pass obamacare. Yeah, joe, youre exactly right. I was working on capitol hill at the time that obamacare was passed and i will tell you, it was very very difficult to get that bill passed. There were lots of deals that were made, lots of concessions to try to get this passed. So the fact that this has now turned into something that people would insinuate that this is a republican type of bill is of course going to anger a lot of Obama Administration officials who were instrumental in getting this bill passed. Joe, you will see this tonight from joe biden. I have to think he lost the debate and is thinking heres a moment where i can draw a contrast. I want to Say Something about what yamiche just said is that the Democratic Party is split in terms of where we should go on health care. That is true but weve got to start looking forward at the general election and the 4 to 5 of the electorate who is going to be the ultimate deciders of this election. I can tell you, i dont think a lot of folks want to get their private Health Insurance taken away. I think a lot of them want to fix obamacare, want to make changes to the system, have Affordable Health care but they dont want to have the system overhauled because they remember how difficult it was to get this passed in the first place. It will be interesting tonight as we look ahead, joe biden on stage with Kamala Harris, cory booker and others, the centrist is the man leading the race. In other words, last night, the centrists who were pushing back frankly were fringe candidates, polling down low single digits. The man in the middle of the stage will be pushing back against medicare for all ideas and progressive concepts. Joe biden as weve talked about will have to have a good performance tonight. He looked rusty the first time out. America will be watching to see how he performs tonight, and again he will be the moderate at the middle of that stage. And what a perfect person to have at the middle of that stage defending obamacare. Yamiche, remember what he whispered to barack obama after it passed, something like, hey, this is a big dog gone good deal, something along those lines, but he was right, thats a guy who had been around washington since he was 29 years old. The Obama Administration pushed washington and america as far as it could be pushed. There were ugly town Hall Meetings. Just ask Claire Mccaskill. So biden in a sense seems like the perfect person to be center stage, and either he defends obama or hes overrun by progressives who want to go much further. Ive been having conversations with former obama officials and they tell me that, yes, of course, obamacare is hard to get, and they had to drag the country to get that over the finish line. They also recognize that obamacare was not something that was ever fully implemented. Democrats point to the fact that not all 50 states implemented the Health Care Plan in the way that they wanted to see it. I have been hearing from people who say that was a starting point. Were okay with people building on it. The sad thing is, and the thing that people say is frustrating for them is when people say, well, we need to pull that out completely, and start all over again. Democrats in the Obama Administration recognize how hard thats going to be. So mika, again, biden is going to be talking tonight about mending it, and not ending it. And again, you look at how difficult that was to pass. Its going to be fascinating. I would love to hear progressives tonight on stage when they Start Talking about, oh, no, no, obamacare is a sellout, lets have medicare for all. I would like somebody on stage, a progressive tonight to explain how when barack obama had almost a filibuster proof, almost a filibuster proof democratic senate, they still just barely were able to push it over the finish line, and we paid a tremendous political price for doing just that. Still ahead, were going to hear from a full group of president ial candidates, five of last nights 2020 contenders join us here on morning joe. Plus, Marianne Williamsons performance at last nights debate. Youre watching morning joe, well be right back. Watching well be right back. Liberty mut. They customized my Car Insurance, so i only pay for what i need. Then i won the lottery, got hair plugs, and started working out. And so can you only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Its something we take personally, and believe in passionately. Its the idea that if our mothers were diagnosed with cancer, how would we want them to be treated . Thats exactly how we care for you. With answers and actions. To hear your concerns, quiet your fears, lift your spirits. With teams of cancer experts and specialists, delivering advanced Treatment Options and compassionate support every step of the way. All here in one place, with one purpose. To fight your cancer, together. Thats the mother standard of care. This is how we inspire hope. This is how we heal. Cancer Treatment Centers of america. Appointments available now. Cancer Treatment Centers of america. At comcast, we didnt build the nations largest gigspeed network just to make businesses run faster. We built it to help them go beyond. Because beyond risk. Welcome to the neighborhood, guys. There is reward. Beyond work and life. Who else could he be . There is the moment. Beyond technology. There is human ingenuity. Every day, comcast business is helping businesses go beyond the expected, to do the extraordinary. Take your business beyond. This is part of the dark underbelly of american society. The racism, the bigotry, and the entire conversation that were having here tonight, if you think any of this wonkiness is going to deal with this dark psychic force of the collect vised hatred that this president is bringing up in this country, im afraid the democrats are going to see some very dark day sg s. Marianne williamson, talking about flint, and blasting President Trump. I will say, i am surprised, im going to say this, but actually she gave some of the best political advice, any democrats could give because were sitting here, again, its a wonky discussion about medicare for all versus mending obamacare. Very very important. But thats not where voters are right now. Voters are scared. Theyre scared of donald trump. They see something happening to their country that theyve never seen in their lifetime, and they dont theyll have some discussions, yes, tell me where you stand. But it is. It is a much bigger threat to this country. And i think americans want somebody up there. Ronald reagan was brilliant at it, bill clinton was brilliant doing it. Barack obama, the same. They want somebody that rises above Brookings Institute versus Heritage Foundation policy battle to talk about the bigger battle against racism, against bigotry, against all the things that donald trump has done to push this country to the edge. So willie, i think she was kind of good. Like, right there, up there with the other candidates. Honestly she had some great moments. She was sort of the punch line from the first debate, but, you know, shes not going to dive deep into policy. Thats not her thing, but she does, as joe says, she taps into the gut feeling of the election, theres the combination of the head and gut and shes talking about the gut. I will point out, she was the most searched google candidate yesterday. After the 50 states, steve bulls the most searched in montana, but all 49 of the other states, it was Marianne Williamson, people were most curious about after watching that. And seriously, the reaction is similar to anything we had, wait a minute, who is this lady, shes pretty good. Like searching her and going, you know, where has she been all of our lives. But im not sure shes going to end up making it to the top tier, having said that, she was impressive. It was critical for being on the stage after the first debate, i dont think its such a bad thing for the Democratic Party to have somebody who can go there. Out of ten candidates, out of 20 candidates and speak more generally about the challenges that are gripping the country. So again, shes, ill just say it, shes not going to probably go anywhere in any of the primary contests, but certainly i think she got the tone right. Yeah. When it came to what the battle lines really are. Again, mike, were not talking about the subsection of Bernie Sanders medicare for all bill. Thats not what americans want to hear about. They want to hear about how donald trump is a bigot, how donald trump is a racist, how donald trump has shattered constitutional norms, how donald trump is putting a dupe in for the most important position. Hes got a bunch of sycophants around him. Hes appointing federal judges that dont respect precedent. Thats what they want to hear. Joe, bingo with a capital b on that. Im going to tell you, the president of the United States is now in a position where he scares people. He scares average americans because they sense a portion of the country that they are familiar with, a portion of how they live and what they have become familiar with is going down the drain because of him. Yesterday, quinnipiac poll, 51 of those people polled think the president of the United States is a racist as opposed to 45 who say no, hes not a racist. That is an astounding number. And if you extrapolate that, joe, out into the suburbs, this fall or next fall, hes going to have real difficulty, because you cant scare people. He has scared people. Hes scared people, and you look at this 51 of americans think that donald trump is a racist, is a bigot. I think its safe to say in modern polling, no president has ever even had that question asked about him, let alone 51 of americans think that hes a bigot and a racist. Jonathan lemire, also, the Republican Party is going to pay for this, i believe, over the long haul because you have donald trump who makes a racist statement and then after making the racist statement, then will say, oh, the person i just made a racist statement about is a racist also. And then the republicans go, well, listen, we dont want to weigh in. Come on, everybodys calling everybody a racist. Come on, lets just all get along. Americans can see through that. Its sad and pathetic on the Republican Partys part. Theyre still not calling out racism and every demographic trend in america shows that the party acting that way is going to be relegated to the dust bin of political history in america. That would be the gop. Joe, i mean, youre right. And Marianne Williamson did sort of the touch on that, the idea of this shadow of racism is hovering over this entire campaign, and certainly the white house right now, and it is no republicans or very very few have spoken out and condemned what the president said, a few weeks ago about the four congresswomen of color, Elijah Cummings, and even discussed yesterday, mark meadows issued a wishy washy statement, saying neither cummings or the president were a racist, no honest assessment could suggest that Elijah Cummings was being racist in any of this. The president has not backed away from this at all. At the white house, he repeatedly went after cummings, baltimore, he is doing so on twitter, i expect were going to hear from him this morning weighing in on the proceedings in the debate. His rebuttal here, two nights after the democrats get his stage, the president will have his rally in cincinnati, ohio, tomorrow night, the first one he has had since the North Carolina rally, which dominated the discourse, and at that moment, seemed to rattle republicans, but then they quickly backed away from that, and the president who expressed some regret for the chant the day after then of course doubled down yet again, and it remains to be seen what happens, and i think there could be a real dichotomy of the democrats discussing the horrors of racism and condemning it, and potentially a chant breaking out at the president s rally that seems to embrace it. All right. Mayor Pete Buttigieg had a message for republican members of congress about this last night. Take a listen. The only reason weve got this president is that normal didnt work. We have to be ready to take on this president and by the way, something that hasnt been talked about as much tonight, take on his enablers in congress. You know, when david duke ran for congress, ran for governor, the Republican Party 20 years ago, ran away from him. Today they are supporting naked racism in the white house or at best silent about it. If you are watching this at home and you are a republican member of congress, consider the fact that when the sun sets on your career and they are writing your story, of all of the good and bad things you did in your life, the thing you will be remembered for is whether in this moment with this president you found the courage to stand up to him or you continued to put party over country. Adrian el rod, i cant tell you how many people i talked to when we talk about the democratic field over dinner o e drinks or whatever, long time democrats who loved barack obama, who really are disturbed by what theyre seeing today but know something needs to happen, they think hes the one, and then they shake their head because hes not going to be the one. What is it about mayor pete that has so many people noticing him, thinking hes remarkable, but then concerned because its like theres not really one candidate who they think can push them through this very difficult time. Yeah, mika, thats whats so fascinating about this primary. I think that reiterates why we need to winnow the field so we can really see an actual debate between the contenders who have a viable chance at becoming the democratic nominee. Mayor pete brings something unique and special to the race. Hes such a good messenger. So many people say he reminds them of the spirit and the, you know, the positive nature that barack obama brought to the race in 2008 and of course ultimately became president. Theres a lot of feelings people have toward mayor pete in that regard. You look, he may end up being the nominee, well see, but i think we actually need to see a real debate between the five to six contenders before maybe people will have a better chance to really see how he plays out in that setting and if he can actually be a viable candidate in their mind in terms of being the nominee. All right. Still to come, his hometown paper says he did well last night when he wasnt lost in the cross fire. Former texas 2020 president ial candidate, beto orourke joins us straight ahead on morning joe. Beto orourke joins us straight ahead on morning joe. Dont miss your golden opportunity to experience the luxury you desire on a full line of utility vehicles. At the lexus golden opportunity sales event. Lease the 2019 rx 350 for 389 a month, for 36 months, and well make your first months payment. Experience amazing. I think were being offered a false choice, some who want to improve the Affordable Care act at the margins, others who want a medicare for all program that will force people off of private insurance. I have a better path. Medicare for america. Everyone whos uninsured is enrolled in medicare tomorrow. And joining us now, former u. S. Congressman from texas, candidate for president of the United States, democrat beto orourke. Great to have you on the show this morning. Good morning. So beto, congratulations last night on the debate. It reminded me, though, of jurisprudence professor that would hammer home to us, what is and what ought to be the law, and i heard that last nighttime and time again. Where are we. What is possible, and what should be possible. It seems like you were trying to find the middle ground there. Tell us about it. Im trying to find the most ambitious goal on any given policy issue and find a way to get america there. On health care, which dominated the debate and dominates so many of the town Hall Meetings that we have across this country, medicare for america ensures that we have universal guaranteed high quality care. It enrolls everyone whos uninsured in medicare, those who are insufficiently insured can elect to move into medicare but it keeps employer sponsored insurance for the tens of millions of our fellow americans who have it, who like it, because it works for them, and their families. I think thats the best possible path to get there. And we can look at any other issue. And we can find those very pragmatic possible paths to get us to the most Ambitious Goals and i want to take america there. Congressman, its willie geist, its good to see you this morning. Thats where you sort of drew your contrast with senators Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren who want pure medicare for all which is to say get rid of private insurance, put everybody in the country on a Government Run Health Care program. Why do you think theirs is a bad idea . I dont know that theirs is a bad idea as much as what i know what were proposing is the best possible path because when i listen to our fellow americans. Ill give you an example. I was talking to detailer in nevada, president of the culinary workers, 60,000 members, many of whom have fought for Health Care Plans, in some cases in lieu of wage increases or other earned benefits, they want to keep that Health Care Plan and i think its just really important for those of us that want to hold these positions of public trust to listen to those who we want to serve and hear how it is that they want us to get there. In that case and so many other instances, they want us to be able to keep choice or employer sponsored insurance. We can still get to universal guaranteed care, but we listen to our fellow americans and ensure theyre part of the solution. You have served in the congress, do you think medicare for all has a chance of passing through both the house and the senate . I dont know. I think its a little bit less likely than the option that were proposing. Again, it respects the choices that our fellow americans are making and what im hearing, and what i figure republican members of congress are hearing are people who are really anxious about losing insurance or being unable to afford the care that they already have, rationing the medications that they are prescribed or just not going to a doctors visit because they cant afford the copay. We need a better system and what i learned in my six years in congress, we have to work with democrats, and we have to build democratic majorities but where we can, lets find that Common Ground with our republican colleagues and ensure we do whats right for america at the end of the day. Medicare for america that gets everybody covered, everybody able to see a provider is the best possible path on health care. Congressman, its jonathan lemire, another issue last night where there was a divide among democrats on health care was on immigration, a particular flash point is whether you should decriminalize border crossings, Elizabeth Warren, senator warren, among others suggested they should. You say no. Tell us why the bush era law should not be repealed . You know, its interesting and i tried to correct the record but wasnt recognized to do this. Senator warren mistakenly said that donald trump is using the criminal code to separate families and to cage kids and visit this cruelty and unhumanity on our fellow human beings and thats just not right. You can use the civil code, the criminal code or you can just look to one of the cruellest most inhumane president s that we have ever had. Thats the problem that we have right now. Its not an Immigration Law that has been on the books for decades. Having said that, we will rewrite that law, so we are specific that no one is seeking asylum or refuge will ever be criminally prosecuted or caged in a Detention Center will have a Family Case Management Program but well also ensure that theres a lawful, orderly, safe path for people to come here, to work jobs or to go to school, or to join family, and if we do that, then i expect people to follow our laws and reserve the right to criminally prosecute anybody who willfully does not or seeks to defraud the government. Its another example of getting to an ambitious goal, rewriting our Immigration Laws in our own image but taking a pragmatic approach that listens to our fellow americans who want to make sure that we maintain the integrity of our laws and the u. S. Mexico border. Race is a constant and volatile issue in life and american politics. Last night you were quite articulate in discussing reparations and in the words of sheila lee jacksons reparations bill, can you explain to the American People who are watching this right now and listening to this right now what form of reparations are you talking about. Who pays what how much . Thats the question that the Reparations Commission that Sheila Jackson lee has proposed would answer, and it would answer it by bringing every single american into the conversation, giving them a seat at the table, and finally, for once, telling the full and complete american story. How did we end up where there is ten times the wealth in White America than there is in black america or an internal mortality crisis that is three times as deadly for women of color or education disparities where you are five times as likely to be disciplined in a kindergarten classroom if youre a child of color, this is the legacy of slavery, and jim crow and suppression, alive and well today. We need to listen to everyone who has born the consequences of this problem in our country. This commission would begin that process of telling the national story, and from that we ensure that we repair the damage done, and we stop visiting these kind of injustices on future generations. So beto, some folks have said skrus talking about just talking about your campaign, that they would rather you run for senate because they want you in the game, they want you in the process, they want you as a part of this conversation because you have so much to offer. Youre sticking to your candidacy for president of the United States. What is it going to take to breakthrough and raise those poll numbers above 2 . Im so glad you asked and that you asked specifically about polls because yesterday there was a really exciting poll that came out from texas. It had each of the major Democratic Candidates in a headtohead match up with donald trump in the state of texas, and far and away, we were ahead of everyone with 11 points over donald trump. As you know, there are 38 Electoral College votes in texas. That beats donald trump in november of 2020 and it forever changes the e llectoral landsca in the United States of america. We can put texas in play, and further more, we can win texas. Im going to make sure that the rest of america hears that story because the number one priority for voters right now is defeating donald trump in 2020. So congressman, im glad you brought that up. We were talking earlier in the show about the demographic changes that obviously nobody in the white house or the Republican Party are aware of. All the demographic changes show that over the next 20 years, i think for the rest of our lifetimes, actually, those demographic changes will more reflect the coalition that elected barack obama in 2008 than donald trump in 2016. The game changer, though, is texas, and do you believe if you can convince enough democrats that you can win texas and completely scramble the electoral map that you have a shot at the nomination. Absolutely. Texas prior to 2018, despite the demographic changes that youve just described was 50th in the country in voter turnout. By going everywhere to those 254 counties, giving everyone a reason to vote. We saw the greatest turnout in a midterm election, perhaps in Texas History and importantly not just won more votes than any democrat in our States History but won nemindependence for the first time in decades, won nearly half a million republicans who voted for greg abbott for governor, and me for senator, its going to take that kind of movement of democrats and independents and republicans not just to defeat donald trump but to get the kind of majorities in the house and the senate that we need and then to be able to hold them year in year out, cycle in, and cycle out to overcome some of the greatest challenges we have ever faced and achieve the most ambitious agenda we have ever set on health care, on climate, on immigration, and on the economy. We can do it, and texas is absolutely key. All right. Beto orourke, thank you very much. Congratulations on last night, and its been fun getting to know you. Well see you soon. Thank you. And beto kicked off our big lineup of candidates today. Still to come, well be joined by mayor Pete Buttigieg, senator a Amy Klobuchar, congressman tim ryan, and standing between cory booker and Kamala Harris, well set the stage for that ahead on smoer. On morning joe. On morning joe. Fidelity is redefining value for investors. Introducing zero account fees for brokerage accounts. And zero minimums to open an account. We have Fidelity Mutual funds with zero minimum investment. And now only fidelity offers four zero Expense Ratio index funds directly to investors. Because when you invest with fidelity, all those zeros really add up. I didnt have to call 911. Help. And i didnt have to come get you. Because you didnt have another heart attack. Not today. You took our conversation about your chronic coronary Artery Disease to heart. Even with a stent procedure, your condition can get worse over time, and keep you at risk of blood clots. So you added xarelto®, to help keep you protected. Xarelto®, when taken with lowdose aspirin, is proven to further reduce the risk of blood clots that can cause heart attack, stroke, or cardiovascular death in people with chronic cad. Thats because while aspirin can help, it may not be enough to manage your risk of blood clots. In a clinical trial, almost 96 of people taking xarelto® did not have a cardiovascular event. Dont stop taking xarelto® without talking to your doctor, as this may increase your risk of heart attack, stroke, or cardiovascular death. While taking, a spinal injection increases the risk of blood clots which may cause paralysis the inability to move. You may bruise more easily, or take longer for bleeding to stop. Xarelto® can cause serious, and in rare cases, fatal bleeding. It may increase your risk of bleeding if you take certain medicines. Get help right away for unexpected bleeding or unusual bruising. Do not take xarelto® if you have an artificial heart valve or abnormal bleeding. Before starting, tell your doctor about all planned medical or dental procedures and any kidney or liver problems. Enjoy every momentand help protect yourself from an unexpected one, like a cardiovascular event. Are you doing enough . Ask your doctor if its time for xarelto®. To learn more about cost and how janssen can help, visit xarelto. Com. Lets go well call his racism out for what it is, and also talk about its consequences. We need to call out White Supremacy for what it is. Domestic terrorism, and it poses a threat to the United States of america. We live in a country now where the president is advancing environmental racism, economic racism, criminal justice racism, health care racism. The way we do better is to fight back and show something better. There are people that voted for donald trump before that arent racist, they just wanted a better shake in the economy, and so i would appeal to them. I have proposed that we do everything from investing in historically red line neighborhoods to build black wealth in Home Ownership to supporting entrepreneurship for black americans. Boy, i think last night was a good night for the democrats. I really do. You had progressives in the middle who were on fire. Bernie sanders woke up. And well see what happens. And Elizabeth Warren, shes two for two, and the moderates as well, i think hickenlooper did very very well. Hey, i was a governor, come on, get real. I said it like Chris Matthews there. Get real. Yamiche, what are you looking for tonight . Is it joe biden against the world . Joe versus kamala. What do you look for tonight . Im in ohio where there are voters here who are so receptive to President Trumps really putting culture and divisions at the center of his campaign, so im looking for democrats to see which one is going to be talking specifically and plainly about race. Last night what we saw were democrats not trying to pull any punches on saying what President Trump was doing, so i think all eyes are going to be on that, and of course this is joe biden and senator harris part two, so i want to see how they interact, whether or not she goes after him again and again points out their differences, whether or not joe biden comes more prepared. Last time he said that he was not prepared to be taking on senator harris so directly, so i think its going to be really interesting to see if his debate prep has changed and whether or not any of the other candidates, including Julian Castro who had a pretty good night the first debate, and of course kind of got overshadowed by all of senator harriss shine and her ability to take apart joe biden. And this reminds me of Ronald Reagans debate in 1994, he seemed lost and disoriented at times, his first debate against walter mondale, came back strong in the second debate. There are concerns about joe biden and the Democratic Party. We hear about it every day, we dont know if hes up to the task, even though its not what everybody says, every democrat is scared to death, hes too old and not up to running for president. Tonight is really a big night for joe biden, isnt it . Its a huge night for joe biden, joe, and look, if he does not have a strong debate performance, if he does not improve dramatically from his first debate performance, hes going to have some real problems going forward, but i have to think, especially based on comments that he has made and statements that his staff has put out, i think hes more prepared this time. I think hes willing to go after people like Kamala Harris, be a little bit more aggressive. You know, because hes fighting for this nomination. Right now hes riding high in the polls, we all know how the early polls look, joe, and if he does not have a more aggressive posture, if he does not defend his record and play some offense as well, i think hes going to have a hard time. Im looking to see how joe performs tonight. Im also looking to see how cory booker does. I do think hes rising in the polls a little bit. Hes obviously drawn a contrast with joe biden on several issues. Im looking to see if he goes after Kamala Harris on her record as a prosecutor on a number of issues that they have slight differences on, and im looking to Julian Castro who had a great breakout performance in the first debate, im looking to see how he does in the second debate again. Adrian elrod and yamiche alcindor, cant wait to hear from you tomorrow. Four more candidates on the debate stage last night, mayor Pete Buttigieg, senator Amy Klobuchar, congressman tim ryan, and governor Steve Bullock. What is different about the state of race this morning. Well discuss that as we look ahead to tonight, and round two of the debates. Morning joe is back in a moment. He debates morning joe is back in a moment you should be mad at tech thats unnecessarily complicated. Make ice. But youre not, because you have e trade, which isnt complicated. Their tools make trading quicker and simpler so you can take on the markets with confidence. Dont get mad. Get e trade. Lick fast like a cookie dough ninja. Apply that same speed to the ford hurry up and save sales event. For the First Time Ever get 20 estimated savings on select ford models, plus earn complimentary maintenance through fordpass rewards. It all adds up. Dont you love math . So get here asap because tasty deals and summer go fast. Get in or lose out on 20 estimated savings on select ford models, plus earn complimentary maintenance through fordpass rewards. Plus earn complimentary maintenance through if you have moderate Little Things can be a big deal. Thats why theres otezla. Otezla is not a cream. Its a pill that treats plaque psoriasis differently. With otezla, 75 clearer skin is achievable. Dont use if youre allergic to otezla. It may cause severe diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting. Otezla is associated with an increased risk of depression. Tell your doctor if you have a history of depression or suicidal thoughts or if these feelings develop. Some people taking otezla reported weight loss. Your doctor should monitor your weight and may stop treatment. Upper respiratory tract infection and headache may occur. Tell your doctor about your medicines, and if youre pregnant or planning to be. Otezla. Show more of you. Right now, congress is working to end surprise medical billing. Thats when patients are hit with medical bills they thought would be covered by insurance. But what congress is considering would cut money that vulnerabe patients rely on the most. That means seniors, children, and americans relying on medicaid would be hurt. Its already too hard for people to get basic medical care with hospitals closing and a shortage of er doctors. Tell congress we can end surprise billing without shredding the safety net. Paid for by physicians for fair coverage. Look limu. A civilian buying a new car. Ug lets go. Limus right. Liberty mutual can save you money by customizing your Car Insurance, so you only pay for what you need. Oh. Yeah, ive been a customer for years. Huh. Only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. After 2014 we will support a unified afghanistan as it takes responsibility for its own future. We will withdraw. We have to. In your first year . Yes. I would in my first term in office. Its time to bring those Service Members back home. We will complete our mission there by the end of this year. And americas longest war will finally be over. A reminder there, that historically ending the war in afghanistan has been easier said than done. Meanwhile, the Defense Department has identified two u. S. Service members killed in afghanistan this week. 24yearold specialist michael nance of chicago, 20yearold private first class Brandon Kreischer of striker, ohio, who was roughly 2 years old on 9 11, boy, if that doesnt bring it home. Welcome back to morning joe, it is wednesday, july 31st. Still with us, we have msnbc contributor, mike barnicle, White House Reporter for the associated press, jonathan lemire, and joining the conversation, National Affairs analyst for nbc news, and msnbc john heilemann, and host of msnbcs politics nation and president of the National Action network, reverend al sharpton. A great group to have. Great group to have. Mike barnicle, were going to get to the debate in one second, but i do want to talk about afghanistan. It is so much easier said than done to say lets get out of afghanistan. I remember saying lets get out of iraq in 2010, 2011, lets get out of afghanistan. We got out of iraq and the chaos that was unleashed because with e g we got out the way wer did, it led to isis, which led to americans having to go back and trying to clean up the mess after russia and iran had gained a foothold in the region. We are far less safe today than we were then. I was wrong. So, i mean, how do we get to a point where, if we get out of afghanistan overnight, which again, i supported for quite some time, how do we make sure that its not just like iraq, and could it be that maybe we have to understand that maybe were looking at a situation that we were looking at in the korean war n south korea or after world war ii in germany. Maybe we need to have a small reduced presence there for quite some time. Well, joe, thats probably the clear likelihood of what might happen. Yesterday, mika just referenced it, two young men, members of the 82nd airborne killed in afghanistan, shot to death by afghan soldiers, by basically our allies. One of the keys to afghanistan is and always has been our relationship with pakistan. And we have continually messed that relationship up but the obvious thing that might happen is what you just referenced. We might have a residual force in afghanistan. I dont know, a thousand, 2,000 troops, maybe forever. But that war, our participation in it, has officially ended in one sense but is never ending in another sense as is made clear yesterday by the bodies of two young man, being shipped back to dover, delaware. Its just never ending. Its such a tragedy, and the billions and billions of dollars that have been spent in afghanistan through the years. And stolen. Spent and stolen. Stolen, not only by the Afghanistan Government but also all the aide we gave musharf in pakistan didnt amount to much at all. Im reminded and well get to the debate, this is the last comment but im reminded in 2004, i was flying out of pensacola, a special ops guy next to him. He was going to afghanistan, i asked him because already people were talking about how iraq was impacting afghanistan, and i said should we have sent those troops to afghanistan and he said, this is 2004, he goes, you can send all the troops you want to afghanistan, it wont make a difference. If you can put a hundred thousand troops on the border in pakistan, that would make the difference, he goes, but this isnt a war between us and afghanistan, this is a war between us and afghanistan and pakistan, and its hard to tell who our friends and who our allies are. Its a mess. That was in 2004, mike. Its still a mess today. And one of the unyielding and unending tragedies of afghanistan is these two young men yesterday are just the latest to die, obviously, but they are also the latest of the 1 of americans who actually, and families in america, who actually participate and serve in both iraq and aversifghanist now afghanistan, less than 1 . That war is not on anyones screen other than the families who have relatives there, who have lost a relative there. That really in essence is not an american war because we are not fully involved as a nation. We are not sacrificing much, 99 of us. The 1 are carrying the whole load. Thats a tragedy. Well, the theme of last nights debate was moderates against progressives and the candidates were pressed on whether the partys policies were moving too far left. Take a look. Im saying the policies of this notion that youre going to take private insurance away from 180 million americans who many of them dont want to get rid of it. Many do want to get rid of it, many dont or the Green New Deal, make sure every american is guaranteed a government job. That is a disaster at the ballot box, you might as well fedex the election to donald trump. The American People want to have a living wage, a minimum wage, 15 bucks an hour, i have helped lead that effort. The American People want to pay reasonable prices for Prescription Drugs, not the highest prices in the world. Again, i think if were going to force americans to make these radical changes, theyre not going to go along. Throw your hands up. I will. I can do it, but you dont have to implement the plans. Us governors and mayors have to pick up the pieces, the government is supposed to take over the responsibilities, theres no preparation, you cant just spring a plan on the world and expect it to succeed. Senator sanders. I was a mayor. I helped transform my community. I have some practical experience. And interesting enough, today is the anniversary of medicare. 54 years ago under lyndon johnson, and the democratic congress, please dont tell me in a four year period we cannot go from 65 to 45 to 35, this is not radical, this is what virtually every other country on earth want. In this discussion we have talked about taking private Health Insurance away from Union Members in the industrial midwest. We have talked about decriminalizing the border and weve talked about giving Free Health Care to undocumented workers when so Many Americans are struggling to pay for their health care, i quite frankly dont think that that is an agenda that we can move forward on and win. Weve got to talk about the working class issues, the people that take a shower after work who havent had a raise in 30 years. If we focus on that, well win the election. I know that we have to win back some of those places we lost, and get those trump voters back if were ever going to win, but this isnt just a choice between the left and the center. Its not a choice just between these sort of wish list economics or thinking that we have to sacrifice our values to actually win. What folks want is a fair shot. The way i won, the way we can win is actually focus on the economy and democracy arent working for most people. Thats how i win. Thats how we can take back the office. Heres where we are, i get it, there is a lot at stake, and people are scared. But we cant choose a candidate we dont believe in just because were too scared to do anything else, and we cant ask other people to vote for a candidate we dont believe in. Democrats win when we figure out what is right and we get out there and fight for it. I am not afraid, and for democrats to win, you cant be afraid either. So john heilemann, a fascinating debate last night. Both the progressives and the center of the stage i thought performed admirally, ably and t moderates, John Hickenlooper, Steve Bullock and tim ryan making sure the same mistakes that occurred in the first debate didnt occur in the second debate. I wonder if Rahm Emanuels memo, David Axelrod saying hold on, lets remain elected. Their warnings, i wonder if they didnt override maybe some of the pmoderate candidates concers about twitter, and other social media platforms that are far left of where most democrats are. Lets hope so, joe, because anything that overrides twitter as a force in politics is probably for the best. I think that youre right in the sense, a couple of things helped in that regard one thing was the candidates who insisted that they not be forced into these kind of arbitrary and dumb questioning scenarios where its about a show of hands or a yes or no. That got ruled out of this debate, and i think those were some of the things that got people in trouble in the last debate, kind of forcing people to just be on one side or the other. I do think, though, if you are a person who is worried that the party is moving too far to the left, you would not be comforted by last night, in this sense. You know, i thought that Elizabeth Warren last night is continuing to be the most consistent performer in the entire field. Shes just, you know, shes incredibly disciplined, the message she has, shes driving it every single day. She emerged from that debate utterly unscathed and Bernie Sanders performed, i think you noted this, bernd caie sanders out strong, did much better than the previous debate. You have the dominant forces, are still sanders and warren. The moderates acquitted themselves fine. There was an attempt by at various points all of them to sort of go after warren and sanders together, and i just dont think they made very much headway because sanders and warren were compelling in defending their point of view. I dont think theres anybody on that stage who as a pure political athlete is better than either Bernie Sanders or Elizabeth Warren and so you have the sense that there was a lot of sort of attempts to kind of take on the left by the center, and to not very much effect, and i dont think many of those moderates looked back on last night and felt like they had a breakout performance in this debate. The only person who was an unexpected person who has a real break out performance, and problematic in various ways is Marianne Williamson. I agree. Again, im speaking as a former republican who is trying to figure out who beats donald trump, but i completely agree with you, john, that if you just look at who the political athletes were last night on the stage, it was Bernie Sanders who i will say again, had a horrible first debate. He might as well have just stamped 2016 on his forehead when he was talking. Last night he came out of the gate strong, and was very compelling. They both, Elizabeth Warren, two for two. Two great debates. I personally, again, take it for what its worth because its coming from a former republican, im concerned that some of their policies are too far left to get 270 electoral votes but youre exactly right, the political athletes on the stage last night were in the center and they did a great job. Speaking to their people. Yeah, and i think, look, if you think about, i was a little surprised to be honest with you, joe, in one sense that for some of those of the again, centrists moderates who are staring down the barrel of not qualifying for the third debate, there was a lot of discussion going in that those people were going to have to go for broke in this debate, i dont think it makes sense to set yourself on fire or set your hair on fire, i was a little surprised in some sense that some of them didnt try to do a little more than they tried to do on stage. I mean, in various cases they kind of took one shot. Delaney took a number of shots obviously, but some of the others kind of took a shot at warren and sanders who sort of were, i heard Chris Matthews say they were like butch and sun dance, they did not fight between themselves, they kind of teamed up to fend off the moderates and i didnt see anybody sort of swinging for the fences in a way that suggested the direness of their circumstances, and like i said, i dont think you come out of this debate saying, boy, you know, tim ryan now is suddenly on his way to double digits. No disrespect to tim ryan, you dont look at that and say, man, somebody really made a move. People like buttigieg, beto orourke, same thing, did not suddenly have the kind of performance that i think a lot of his donors and his fans were looking for, that kind of moment that he really came alive. You know, rev, you have been up on the debate stage as president , even in my little race for congress, i never ran. I had like eleven people to run against, i never once mentioned any of their names. I was running against bill clinton, somebody tried to drag me into their squabbles, i just kept talking about bill clinton. Wouldnt it make sense to you that, i mean, if youre on that debate stage tonight, and they want you to like pick a fight with somebody else up there, doesnt it make sense to stay focused, keep your focused, keep your rhetorical sights aimed on donald trump at all times. They can say, what do you think about joe bidens this, what do you think about senator harriss that, you just go, you know what, okay, listen, we can have our little squabbles here, but let me tell you what donald trump did this week, and talk about the racism, the attacks on Elijah Cummings, the attack on baltimore, setting this country on the edge of a racial split. I think youre exactly right. When you look at the fact that the ultimate goal of the democrats is to defeat trump, not only should you project that because that is the best debate posture, you want to put in the psyche of america, im the one against trump. Forget these other people. Its me against trump. And the more you can sell that, the more voters may see and put you in that position. I think the real reason last night that Elizabeth Warren and even Bernie Sanders came off very well is that people saw, wait a minute, they can get on the stage and take trump on. By them being able to, in a very rational and passionate way defend their policies whether you consider it too far left or not, gave america the opportunity to say, they can go hand in hand with donald trump in combat, not lose their composure skp composure and answer in a policy manner and thats whats important. These are preliminaries no matter how entertaining they are, youve got to use this to show the world youre ready for the main bout, if in fact, you are. And by the way, if im a democrat sitting in the chair or im an independent sitting asking this question, its not who can out debate kamala, who can outdebate biden, im thinking one thing, who can take it to donald trump. Thats the issue, so democrats, talk about donald trump tonight. Swat away questions that want to have you fighting other members of the Democratic Party because youre not going to make that much of a gain there anyway. And do whats needed. Go after donald trump. Thats what democrats want to know, who can beat this guy. That is correct. Former political writer, ron, thank you so much for being with us, ron. You know, i read in the News Donald Trump distracts so much, obviously. I really wish we didnt have to chase all the racist comments and everything else. We just have to, but while hes doing that, there is a transmission plant in mccomb county michigan thats getting shut down that donald trump promised to keep open. Talk about what democrats should focus on tonight and talk about where donald trump stands in the state of michigan right now with plant closings continuing. They might want to start with the fact that detroit is a majority africanamerican city, 85 , 80 africanamerican, a city where 47 of kids are living below the poverty line, a city where black ownership was 51 in 2000, its now down to about 41 . A city that has come back in a lot of ways in the last ten years but is still really hurting, especially among voters who need to come out and support the democratic candidate, especially among voters who didnt come out for Hillary Rodham clinton. Donald trump talks about how great he is for the blacks and my black, that is a place in detroit where donald trump is obviously ignoring and that democrats could take a huge advantage of. At the same time, youre talking about things Like Universal Health care and Government Run Health Care, and legalizing illegal border crossings, thats the kind of thing thats going to hurt democrats in a place like mccomb county, in a place that swings back and forth between change candidates and is certainly not a hard left county. They voted for obama twice. Im glad you said that. Excuse me just one second, i want you as a detroit guy to expand on that because this election is going to be won or lost in wisconsin, michigan, pennsylvania, and florida. What does a voter in mccomb county that voted for barack obama in 2008, 2012, but then donald trump in 2016, think when hes watching some of these candidates say you know what, if somebody krcrosses our southern border illegally, not only are we going to give them health care for life, were also going to give them a free college education. Lets get real for one second politically, what does that do in those obama trump districts . It makes the ability for someone like donald trump to dog whistle to them much easier. Same thing when youre talking about Government Run Health Care. People from mccomb country, they know Canadas Health care system is no panacea. You may be able to get out of the hospital and not have Big Health Care bills but you have a hard time getting in the hospital. These are people struggling with the economic and technological and demographic change in the last three decades and what they are looking for, joe, and you know this, looking for it in 92 t 2000, in 2004 and 2012, and they were looking for it again in 2016, and that is change. That is big disruptive change to the political system. Which is why i see someone like mayor Pete Buttigieg yesterday, who although he is a progressive, trying to find that middle lane, that connective tissue between the moderates and liberals as a generational clang agent, thats the kind of message that could play in mccomb county, as it did before with obama and clinton. You talk about latte liberals, talking about the issues brought forward, where do you see the Democratic Party right now, sort of the rank and files versus what you call the latte liberals and who wins that battle in the end . I think the rank and file want to see what is workable. They want to see the country move away from the extremes on both sides because they have seen the extreme bizarre behavior of donald trump but you also do not want to go over the cliff, and i think where we are now is when you look at health care, clearly last night sitting in that audience, i could sense people saying yes, we need to have health care for everyone but we need to respect the fact that people do not want to, in the majority of this country, give up what they already have in terms of private insurance if that works. We want to see us deal with the fact that there is racism and division, but we dont want to be extreme to promise things that we cannot really provide and we dont want to become the polar opposite of trump where hes all the way over here and were all the way over here. I think people are a lot more logical and sensible than a lot of the people that are just on either extremes give them credit for, and those that can thread that needle, that can deal with the passion and outrage that people have as a result of trump, but at the same time come in with practical, achievable things, i think will be the ones that can win the nomination, and win next november in the general election. But you cant fool the people. They have been promised things before that never came through. They know what that feels like. Amen. Reverend al, thank you very much, well see you again tomorrow morning after tonights round two of the democratic debates. Still ahead on morning joe, mayor Pete Buttigieg not only addressed democratic voters in last nights democratic debate, he also sent a message directly to any republican lawmakers watching at home. Mayor buttigieg joins us next on morning joe. Us next on morning joe. Tech at safelite autoglass, we really pride ourselves on making it easy for you to get your windshield fixed. Teacher lets turn in your science papers. Tech vo this teacher always puts her students first. Student i did mine on volcanoes. Teacher you did . oh, i cant wait to read it. Tech vo so when she had auto glass damage. She chose safelite. With safelite, she could see exactly when wed be there. Teacher you must be pascal. Tech yes maam. Tech vo saving her time. [honk, honk] kids bye tech vo . So she can save the science project. Kids whoa kids vo safelite repair, safelite replace background checks on guns. E that we should have but Congress Wont act because the nra and gun manufacturers have purchased our government. Thats just plain wrong. We know how to solve many of the challenges facing us. A majority of americans agree on the solutions. But corporate money is standing in the way. Im tom steyer. I approve this message. Because our democracy should work for the people. But one blows them allmany moisturizers. Out of the water. Hydro boost with hyaluronic acid to plump skin cells so it bounces back. Neutrogena® and try our hydrating makeup. Its how we care for our Cancer Patients like job. When he was diagnosed with cancer, his team at ctca created a Personalized Care plan to treat his cancer and side effects. So job could continue to work and stay strong for his family. This is how we inspire hope. This is how we heal. We love you, daddy. Good night. I love you guys. Cancer Treatment Centers of america. Appointments available now. Cancer Treatment Centers of america. Here, hello starts with hi mple. How can i help . A data plan for everyone. Everyone . Everyone. Lets send to everyone [ camera clicking ] wifi up there . Ahhh. Sure, why not . Howd he get out . a camera might figure it out. That was easy glad i could help. At xfinity, were here to make life simple. Easy. Awesome. So come ask, shop, discover at your xfinity store today. It is time to stop worrying about what the republicans will say. Look, if its true that if we embrace a far left agenda, theyre going to say were a bunch of crazy socialists, if we embrace a conservative agenda, you know what theyre going to do, theyre going to say were a bunch of crazy socialists. Lets stand up for the right policy, and go out and defend it, thats the right policy im putting forward, not because its the right triangulation, but because i think its the right answer. Trump campaign adviser, mercedes slap, yes, Pete Buttigieg, you all are crazy socialists. Lowest expectations, lets bring in mayor pete right now. Mayor pete, how do you think the debate went last night, more specifically, heres the toughest question of the day for you, how do you think you did . So it was a terrific debate. And a great opportunity for me to talk about whats at stake in the election. Not just some kind of ideological battle but how are we going to transcend the same argument that has been happening for my whole adult life and breakthrough and get to something new to actually tackle things like climate and health care and systemic racism in this country before its too late. Im convinced that we are coming up on the horizon of no return and we got to have the right sense of urgency, i appreciated the chance to lay out our plans and to talk about whats at stake. So obviously a big debate between the moderate faction of the Democratic Party last night. M mercedes schlapp, people like hickenlooper, and bullock, and ryan, who were moderate conservatives on a lot of issues. Just for helpfulness, i know no politician likes labels but where do you think you stand on that spectrum between Elizabeth Warren on one side and tim ryan on the other . Look, i view myself as progressive, but i think that response out of trump world was pretty revealing, right, most of what we stand for, the American People stand with us, whether its the idea that we ought to have universal health care or the fact that the minimum wage ought to be higher or what we think ought to happen around gun control. If we are crazy socialists then theyre saying the American People are a bunch of crazy socialists. Its time to put those labels to bed, talk about what were actually going to do for the American People and when we do, it turns out, voters are with us. Which is exactly why the president needs us to be talking about his latest outrage, rather than about the impact were going to have on your life when we get elected instead of allowing these folks to continue running the country for the benefit of themselves and their friends. John is with us and has a question. I want to ask you a question about the debates themselves and something i think is going to start to be an issue and i want to get your feelings about it. Theres the next set of debates which you are almost certain to qualify for, i believe, or have already qualified for, the ones in september. The lot of people are going to get excluded from that debate stage as the qualifications get tighter, and i think theres going to be a debate in the party whether thats an appropriate role for the Democratic Party, an artificial winnowing of the rules, what the whole nomination process used to do in every election in the past, so do you think its u useful and appropriate for the party to be setting up arbitrary metrics and ruling people out or should the market in some sense rule the day here and let everybody up on stage until people drop out of their own free will . Well, i imagine between now and the next debate, there will be some of that natural winnowing if candidates havent gotten traction, if theyre not able to pull the resources together, they may continue to move on and decide to do other things. It is challenging, right, to have 20 candidates spread across d two nights, we have to begin consolidating the conversation. Fundamentally, its up to us as candidates to do something that cuts through the clutter. If you have the right message, represent the right kind of messenger, you can do that. We have been able to cut through a very competitive field, and its obviously not based on having had a lot of fame or dollars on day one, its when you come out of the gate and you have something to say thats compelling, you can build that support base that you need, in order to last through all of these different cuts that are going to happen, whether theyre created by the party or whether its just political nature taking its course. As we get toward the end of the year, and the handful of candidates who are really going to go to the hat and compete in early states like iowa. Mr. Mayor, we opened this door discussing the two young men who were killed in afghanistan over the last couple of days. You obviously served in the military as wellment last night you well. Last night you committed to withdrawing forces from afghanistan in the first year of office. Can you walk us through what that looks like, entirely no force whatsoever, and what sort of vacuum may you be leaving behind . Look, as we would in any country to keep the homeland safe, well retain whatever intelligence and special operations capabilities we need, but the bottom line is the end of my first year as president represents the 20th year since 9 11, and if we cant wrap up our commitment of Ground Troops in afghanistan by then, then it truly has become a forever war. Were now at the point where you can be old enough to enlist and not have been alive on 9 11, and we do not have the strategic gains to show for it. We need to maintain the ability to defend the homeland from threats anywhere around the world and thats why we have the military that we do. But you cant just throw it around to meet undefined Mission Objectives and the problem in afghanistan, among others is that we cant seem to decide what the purpose of being there is. I think problems like that continue to arise, as long as we have these open ended authorizations for the use of military force. Its why i proposed that we have a three year sunset, anytime there is one of those congressional authorizations so if there really is a compelling, inevitable reason to keep american troops at scale on the ground, the president s got to go back to congress and sell it. Explain what the mission is, and i think when that process happens, when members of congress have to take tough votes, when a president has to explain the rationale for being on the ground, suddenly it all becomes a lot clearer and we dont find ourselves in these situations where were just in a never ending commitment where its not even clear what were trying to get out of it. Ron is in detroit and has a question for you. Just a follow up on that question. One of the young men who the pentagon announced was killed in afghanistan, was brandon of striker, ohio. He was 20 years old, which means he was 2 years old when the nation was attacked. If you were president and you were to call the family and his mother asked you, what did my son die for, what would your answer be . This is the conversation no president wants to have. Look, these are men and women who serve honorably, who make that decision to enter into an agreement with the United States to put your life on the line to defend us. Right now, there are people packing their bags to get ready to go over wondering why exactly am i here. We know how we got in. The United States was attacked, but is our mission over there complete peace and prosperity in aversion, is o afghanistan, is our mission to see the kind of Economic Development that we would expect in a western country, is the mission there to have a western style government. Thats not going to happen. Our mission has to be to keep the American Homeland safe and by that standard, by that higher standard, we will be avoiding new con flkflicts. Pete buttigieg, the american dilemma of race is with us today as prominent as it has ever been. Youre the mayor of a city. Sometimes divided by race with the Police Involved shootings, items like that, it sits in the american living room, race does, like a keg of dynamite off to the side, waiting for a single spark to ignite it again and again and again. My question is how dangerous is donald trump to igniting that thing, really igniting it. Extremely dangerous. Look, this has been a problem since the founding of the republic. If you think about it, the one thing that came closest to ending the american project was White Supremacy that led us to the civil war, and it is still an enormous problem of course for those who are discriminated against as a consequence of systemic racism and for the entire country as a whole. If theres any virtue in the moment bleak as it is when it comes to race, i suppose is the fact that we can no longer pretend, and frankly a lot of white progressives can no longer be comfortable in the belief that we have beaten back some of this naked racism that has come back to the surface, precisely because it was never gone in the first place, and having wrestled with these issues on the ground, as a mayor of a diverse community, i see why it is so important that we take this on systematically. I was glad to have a chance to share a little bit last night about our douglass plan that tackles systemic racism against housing, employment, education, access to capital for entrepreneurship, criminal justice reform. If you are a black american, you are living in a different america on all of these dimensions, and we will not have actually resolved this issue until we come to the day when your race has absolutely no bearing in predicting your life expectancy, predicting your wealth or your income, predicting how you are going to interact with law enforcement, until were there, americas got a problem and we have to stop talking about this like this is just a specialty issue to be discussed with audiences of color. This is something that diminishes the entire country. All right. Mayor Pete Buttigieg, thank you very much for coming on. Come back. Its always great to have you on. Joining us now, we have former u. S. Senator Claire Mccaskill who has joined the team of course, and claire, you and i are both fans of mayor pete. Whats it going to take to have him breakthrough and in some of the demographics where i think he struggles because hes such a solid strong candidate, and i hope hes listening to me. Well, i think he had a good night last night. I think he is making progress. His douglass plan is strong. Clearly he is lagging with africanAmerican Voters right now. Very hard to get the democratic nomination if you dont do better than hes doing right now with those voters. I will say one of the things hes done that i think is remarkable and important and i hope other candidates Pay Attention, and that is using his faith to support the values he is going after in this campaign. I thought not only was his moment strong when he looked at the camera and challenged my former republican colleagues to get a spine, and, you know, Pay Attention to how history is going to judge them, but when he talked about minimum wage in the context of the scripture. And when he talked about, you know, not recognizing that a living wage is something that is embodied in christianity, i thought that was hes done this a number of times in the campaign, its sometimes startling for democratic voters because were not used to canneds using their faith candidates using their faith but its terrific. Claire, somebody thats won a very red state a couple of times, im curious what you thought about the divide between the more progressive wing of the Democratic Party represented by sanders and warren in the middle, and the conservatives that were out to the sides. When they Start Talking about medicare for all, taking away private Health Insurance, Start Talking about giving people that cross the border illegally Free Health Care for life, and you know, other things, other benefits, how does that play in red states where democrats, if they want to take the senate away from Mitch Mcconnell, moscow mitch as some people are calling him now, how does that get in the way of that goal . Well, as i said last night, late last night, i think in my state, and states like it across the country, and those are some states that the nominee has to win, when they hear free stuff, they hear free stuff but not for me. They hear somebody else is getting free stuff. Once again, im working my you know what off and i cant get ahead, i cant afford to retire, and then theres this group of people over here getting stuff for free, particularly enraging if its someone who doesnt have legal documentation to be in this country. I will say this, everybody has to remember that the candidates on the stage agree on a lot of important fundamentals. Cheaper health care, more health care, immigration reform, you know, figuring out a way to do more manufacturing, the list goes on and on, but what last night did, which i think is very important, i think it reminded voters who hadnt really thought about it that Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warrens Health Care Plan means no choices. You get what the government is going to give you. So if you want to keep your insurance at work, if your employer wants to provide that benefit as an incentive, if you like your coverage at work, youve got no choice, and i thought congressman ryan particularly did a good job talking about the Union Members who have given up wages year after year to have these terrific plans and were going to say to them, never mind, youre going to get what the government says you can have. I think that contrast on health care, and look for tonight, kamala to talk about her plan where she now is firmly embracing choice, that americans should have a choice if they want to stay with an employer based program or they want to go with a public option buying government insurance. So ron, youre in detroit, orv obviously one of the most important swing states, what is michigan looking for tonight as they watch the democratic debate. Probably like most of us, theyre watching biden, what the big deal is about, why hes riding so high in the polls is he really up to the job, is he somebody who can take on donald trump or are throuere newer fac fresher faces with practical change messages that could help their lives. All right. Ron, thank you very much for being on this morning and coming up, montana governor Steve Bullock says the progressives in his party are making it harder for democrats to beat donald trump. He joins us next on morning joe. Joins us next on morning joe. Whyou should be mad that airports are complicated. Hes my emotional support snake. But youre not, because you have e trade, whose tech isnt complicated. It helps you understand the risk and reward potential on an options trade. Dont get mad. Get e trade. only tylenol® rapid release gels have laser drilled holes. They release medicine fast, for fast pain relief. Tylenol®. This melting pot of impacted species. Everywhere is going to get touched by Climate Change. Heres how its gyoure my sidekick. Aint nobodys sidekick. Hey boys. The fate of the world is in your hands and you cant even get along. Pretty disappointed right now. You want a sidekick . Im gonna find you one. See that guy over there . Hes too big. Look at you two. Bickering like a couple of old ladies. Woo at the end of the day, im not going to support any plan that rips away Quality Health care from individuals. This is an example of wish list economics. It used to just be republicans who wanted to repeal and replace. Now Many Democrats do as well. Joining us now, democratic president ial candidate and chair of the National Governors association, governor Steve Bullock of montana. Very good to have you on the show, governor. Great job last night. I want to ask you about the Democratic Party overall, and the candidates that you were sharing ideas with yesterday in debating. Is there a concern, do you have that concern that the issues that you all have platforms on will be not appealing to a Broad Spectrum of the American Voters which of course might end up to a second term for donald trump . Well, yeah, and thanks for having me this morning, mika. As the only one actually that won a trump state, i have the concern if were not speaking in ways that actually connect with peoples lives. As i talk about wish list economics, we shouldnt have to be choosing between what we dont want and what we cant afford, meaning that, look, we can make progress on health care, we can make progress on college affordability, we can make progress in so many ways without just these trillion dollar plans that are mostly written for press releases. John heilemann. Hey, governor, im running into your guys, welcome to the debate stanl lage last night. I ran into your guys afterwards and the folks that work for you, and theres a fair amount of tension and drama. Are you going to get to be back on the debate stage again in september, which raises the question i want to ask which is not just about you but about a bunch of people who are in danger of being excluded from these forums going forward. I know you have raised some complaints about that in the past but i really am having a hard time understanding why for the first time in my lifetime covering president ial politics the Democratic Party has decided to impose these arbitrary qualification metrics that may reduce the field to, you know, six or seven or eight people effectively just a couple months from now. Do you think thats the right thing to do . I dont, john. I think that, you know, what weve always done is actually the voters are the ones that winnowed down the big field. I have been so pleased. I have only been in this for eight weeks now, seven trips to iowa during that time, attorney general tom miller, john bauer, others on board. This really needs to be a robust discussion because weve got to beat donald trump, and weve got to have a candidate that can wen not just on the coast but all across this country and it shouldnt be rules or others that winnow down that field, it should be voters. Governor, its jonathan lemire, you made your big pitch here the you about win a trump state. And on a number of issues you disagree with some of your Democratic Candidates, whether that is on the Green New Deal or on medicare for all or on the idea of some of yothe immigrati policies. My question is this. Considering those stances but also considering where the poll numbers are, are you out of step right now with the Democratic Party . Youre making the case to beat donald trump, but dont you have to get there first . Well, you do, and only being in eight weeks, because my legislature was still in session, it meets 90 days every two years, needed to get Medicaid Expansion reauthorized, so saving health care for 100,000 people. But as im out traveling, what i hear is people want us to talk about the challenges of folks everyday lives economically, that theyre not Getting Better under this administration. Look, we all ought to be talking about, as we talk about immigration. The biggest problem right now with immigration, its actually donald trump, because hes dividing both families and our country. So theres ways to do this. Im a populist, prochoice, prounion democrat thats won three times in a red state. And ive done that by not compromising the values of our party, but we shouldnt have to be choosing, really, as i said, between what we dont want and what we cant afford. What we want to do is move this country forward, and thats what i hear from folks when im out on the stump. Governor bullock, i think youve just hit upon something i think you need to make sure people know, and that is you do you have a very progressive set of lists of things you want to get done. I think sometimes people confuse someone who wants to be pragmatic with someone who is a conservative, small c. I think you are someone who does have a few days as a progressive. Lets talk a little about the trade war. You are also unique, you and mayor pete, in terms of coming to a state where agriculture is so important. The folks out in Rural America have supported donald trump in an unprecedented fashion. They are also getting kicked in the gut in this tariff war. Could you speak to that a little bit and how we can make trade fair but not give such a short shrift to the farmers in this country . I was in rippey, iowa when a sixth generation farmer said, i dont know if i want my son to follow me and become the seventh. Right now were in this place where, what donald trump has done, he thinks that the tariffs will just be the cureall for everything. I dont think America First becomes america alone. What were seeing both in iowa, what im seeing in montana, is its got to be more than a blunt instrument of tariffs, because right now folks are losing money when theyre planting crops. Any payments from washington, d. C. , from the u. S. Department of agriculture, isnt going to make up for that loss of market shares. You can always we need to make sure that we open enough markets to have fair and competitive opportunities, but you cant do this alone. Governor, we live in a nation where Mass Shootings never make the front page unless the shooter racks up 10, 12 or above. Whats your position on a flatout ban of the manufacture and sale of assault weapons for civilians . Yeah, and it is. Im tired of lowering the flags. A fourth of the time ive been asked to lower the flags under this president and president obama were for Mass Shootings. Im tired of the fact that my sixth graders first week of school had to learn where to go in case of a mass shooting. Chains like walmart and dicks, theyve already stopped selling assault weapons, and i think as a country, we should as well. Theyre not used for hunting, theyre not used for selfdefense. So manufacture and sale of assault weapons for civilians, youre for that . To ban it. To ban the manufacture yeah. And sale of an assault weapon to civilians. Youre for it. I am. And im not unique in this. I mean, when you look at some of the major Sporting Good chains that say, were no longer even going to sell these things, if we could ever just look at this, as i noted, as a Public Health issue and not a political issue. As a gun owner as i am, i think that there are reasonable steps that we can take to keep our communities and families safe, but what you have when i was growing up, the nra was a gun safety and hunting organization. Now its nothing more than a dark money, foreign Money Organization thats used to try to divide our country. Weve got to be able to take steps to keep our kids and our families safer, and gun owners and nongun owners alike agree on that. All right. Governor Steve Bullock, thank you very much. Obviously we have to have you back because this conversation needs more time. We appreciate your coming on the show this morning. Congratulations for last night. We still have two more candidates to talk to this morning, congressman tim ryan and senator Amy Klobuchar join the conversation. Plus, well continue to look ahead to tonights debate as the candidates search for a breakout moment against joe biden. Morning joe is back in just a moment. A moment choosing my Car Insurance was the easiest decision ever. I switched to geico and saved hundreds. Thats a win. But its not the only reason i switched. Geicos a company i can trust, with over 75 years of great savings and service. Now thats a winwin. Switch to geico. Its a winwin. We really pride ourselves on making it easy for you tech at safelite autoglass, to get your windshield fixed. With safelite, you can see exactly when well be there. Saving you time for what you love most. Kids whoa kids vo safelite repair, safelite replace lowering Prescription Drug prices. Expanding criminal background checks on gun purchases. Blocking secret corporate money from elections. And giving dreamers a path to citizenship. The new democratic majority in the house of representatives is proving theyre up to the challenge. But, Mitch Mcconnells blocked every one of these important bills from getting a vote in the senate. That wont stop house democrats. Tell them keep up the fight for whats right for americas families. Were going all in thion strawberries. Ra, at their reddest, ripest, they make everything better. Like our strawberry poppyseed salad and new strawberry summer caprese salad. Order online for delivery. Panera. Food as it should be if you have moderate to thsevere rheumatoid arthritis, month after month, the clock is ticking on irreversible joint damage. Ongoing pain and stiffness are signs of joint erosion. Humira can help stop the clock. Prescribed for 15 years, humira targets and blocks a source of inflammation that contributes to joint pain and irreversible damage. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections. Serious and sometimes fatal infections including tuberculosis, and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Help stop the clock on further irreversible joint damage. Talk to your rheumatologist. Right here. Right now. Humira. There was no hesitation, i went straight to ctca. After my mastectomy, it was maddening because i felt part of my identity was being taken away. When youre able to restore what cancers taken away, you see that transformation firsthand knowing that she had options that she could choose, helped restore hope. My team made me feel like a whole person again. Cancer Treatment Centers of america. Appointments available now. I dont understand why anybody goes to all the trouble of running for president of the United States just to talk about what we really cant do and shouldnt fight for. [ cheers and applause ] our biggest problem in washington is corruption. It is giant corporations that have taken our government and that are holding it by the throat. And we need to have the courage to fight back against that, and until were ready to do that, its just more of the same. Well, im ready to get in this fight, im ready to win this fight. A snapshot of last nights democratic debate where the progressive wing of the party is literally center stage. Good morning and welcome to morning joe. It is wednesday, july 31st. Along with joe, willie and me we have msnbc contributor mike barnacle, lemire, and lapice. I thought they were flagged in the wings by some moderates. It was a great give and take. Any donald trump supporter that saw this debate stage might not have as many easy targets moving forward as they did after the last round of democratic debates because you actually had some more moderate candidates actually suggesting more of a practical approach, lets say, than an overly utopian approach. I think a lot of americans would think when youre talking about giving health care to Illegal Immigrants, when you talk about giving health care to someone who crosses the border, i think americans would be against it and think it was utopia. First of all, i thought the debate was really well run, they got a lot in there, a lot of conversations. I cant wait until we get down to smaller numbers so the conversations can be drawn out more. Its a little frustrating when they kept having to move on. Who do you think had the standout nights . There were a few candidates who had really great moments. I think miami set up detroit and detroit was a reaction to what happened in miami. So you had, of all people, john delaney was sort of the leadoff guy posed as the moderate to go after Elizabeth Warrens plans, to go after Bernie Sanders plans. Then John Hickenlooper got in, Steve Bullock, he got in talking about economics. This was the pushback of moderates against Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders and a pushback over some of the concerns the moderates have over the direction of this party and the direction this primary is heading. Well see if we see more of that tonight. Whats interesting, mike barnacle, is you did have that give and take, you did have the back and forth, and i think a lot of people have i cant say theyve forgotten, but perhaps its been pushed to the back of their mind, and maybe we remember it because we talked about it every day, it seemed like, for two years, the battle over obamacare. Uhhuh. And the fight, the struggle just to get it to where it was. I think they ended up with 50 votes and the Vice President had to break that vote. But it was the toughest battle democrats lost. Lets think about this. Over the next six years, democrats lost a thousand legislative seats across the nation after obamacare passed. In part because of the political fight the democrats put up with. As george bush once said, its hard. And when he was throwing around promises, they sounded an awful lot like Donald Trumps promises for universal health care. Very easy to make promises on the campaign stage. Elizabeth warren said, the worst problem we have in washington, d. C. Is corruption. I would say americans probably think the worst problem we have in washington, d. C. Over the past 20, 25 years are broken promises. And god bless Elizabeth Warren and bernie if they can follow through with what they say, but i wouldnt condemn people for trying to figure out what can we do . What promises can we deliver . Because again, i hate to keep going on and on about this, but, man, obamacare was a fight to the political death, and for people to now go, oh, that didnt go far enough. Lets do ten times the amount of work, its not realistic, i dont think. Joe, that gets to the point of the biggest winner last night, and i think a lot of people would think that the biggest winner last night was substance. Because they actually discussed Health Care Legislation in some detail. Elizabeth warren, she has a grasp of details that she manages to articulate in very short bites, 30 and 60second bites that resonate, i think, with people. As far as the biggest problem in washington, i think it was going to revert to whats going to happen tonight. I think a lot of people, especially democrats watching these debates, to them the biggest problem in washington is donald trump. And i think thats where it will go tonight. I think last night there was several people on that stage last night who will disappear from the National Stage, but the debate last night, once it got going after about 20 minutes, it was pretty good. It was pretty educational. A lot of substance. That was kind of impressive. Well, lets go through it, mika. Right off the bat it was a clash of ideas against lower candidates urging potential change, and Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders advocating for a systemwide overhaul. Here are some of the opening statements. Folks, we have a choice. We can go down the road that senator sanders and senator warren want to take us, which is with bad policies like medicare for all, free everything, and impossible promises that will turn off independent voters and get trump reelected. Last year democrats flipped 40 republican seats in the house and not one of those 40 democrats supported the policies of our frontrunners at center stage. That teacher working a second job just to afford her insulin, they cant wait for revolution. This isnt about left or right. This is about new and better. I will offer solutions that are bold, that are realistic. You are going to hear a lot of promises up here, but im going to tell you this. Yes, i have bold ideas, but they are grounded in reality. Our problems didnt start with donald trump. Donald trump is part of a corrupt, rigged system that has helped the wealthy and the wellconnected and kicked dirt in the faces of everyone else. Were not going to solve the urgent problems that we face with small ideas and spinelessness. Were going to solve them by being the Democratic Party of big structural change. By the way, willie, there is no doubt that you had Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders on fire last night, and for a primary, for a debate, that is what you want to do. Im talking about the mundane mechanics of washington, d. C. But, boy, they were on fire last night. Yeah, theres no question about it. I follow up with what mike said and what you were saying earlier, this was a substantive debate. Whether or not you agreed with what all these candidates were saying, they were articulate, they were well versed, theyre fluent in their policy, and Elizabeth Warren, you may not agree with her ideas, but boy, does she know them. And john delaney, you may think as a progressive, he doesnt go too far, he may pull back from his ideas. I think its worth pausing in the last couple years that had been pretty bereft of policy discussion, it was great to hear that on stage, jonathan lemire. It was great to hear a sort of push and pull. Rob emanuel put out a memo yesterday urging the people on stage not to lose to donald trump. Back and forth with Elizabeth Warren kind of pushing her on her ideas. That was front and center. That sort of conversation in this party right now about how far left to go. Thats exactly right. Thats where that debate was last night, where the spirit and soul of the Democratic Party is right now, Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders, who both were on fire and had very good moments exchanged very little fire on each other. That was interesting. In a sense, theyre competing for some of the same voters, but yet they didnt really interact with each other much at all. When they did, it was to agree. They took on fire from some of the moderates, but they scored points. If it was with warren or sanders, you could hear it amplified from republicans down the road. I think the debate for medicare for all, of course, is one thats going to shape this democratic contest in the months ahead. Im certain there will be more about it tonight. But whats also interesting is what didnt come up last night. Talk about the federal judiciary in Supreme Court didnt come up last night. Impeachment didnt come up last night. Robert mueller, who dominated the news cycle last week, didnt come up last night. Coming up, well hear from two more candidates from last nights debate, congressman tim ryan and senator Amy Klobuchar joins us straight ahead on morning joe. Straight ahead on morning joe. Great riches will find you when Liberty Mutual customizes your Car Insurance, so you only pay for what you need. Wow. Thanks, zoltar. How can i ever repay you . Maybe you could free zoltar . Thanks, lady. Taxi only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. So, every day, we put our latest technology and unrivaled network to work. The United States Postal Service makes more ecommerce deliveries to homes than anyone else in the country. My copd medicine. Thats why ive got the power of 1 2 3 medicines with trelegy. The only fdaapproved 3in1 copd treatment. Trelegy. The power of 123. Trelegy 123 trelegy. With trelegy and the power of 1 2 3, im breathing better. Trelegy works 3 ways to. Open airways,. Keep them open. And reduce inflammation. For 24 hours of better breathing. Trelegy wont replace a rescue inhaler for sudden breathing problems. Trelegy is not for asthma. Tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high Blood Pressure before taking it. Do not take trelegy more than prescribed. Trelegy may increase your risk of thrush, pneumonia, and osteoporosis. Call your doctor if worsened breathing, chest pain, mouth or tongue swelling. Problems urinating, vision changes, or eye pain occur. Think your copd medicine is doing enough . Maybe you should think again. Ask your doctor about oncedaily trelegy and the power of 1 2 3. Trelegy 123 save at trelegy. Com stay on top of things. A faster laptop could help. Plus, tech support to stay worry free. Worry free. Boom ha. Ha. Boom now, save up to 40 off furniture. Up to 40 off at Office Depot Officemax or officedepot. Com. You should be mad at leaf blowers. [beep] you should be mad your neighbor always wants to hang out. And you should be mad your smart fridge is unnecessarily complicated. But youre not mad, because you have e trade which isnt complicated. Their tools make trading quicker and simpler. So you can take on the markets with confidence. Dont get mad. Get e trade and start trading today. Dont get mad. I am bsuperhuman. Things that money cannot buy. Oh, like your soul back. Your brother took my soul. The boys in the lab made me a new one. Im black superman. Black superman is good. Very good. Theres two of us and one of him. Time to work as a team. [ screaming ] this is part of the dark underbelly of american society. The racism, the bigotry and the entire conversation were having here tonight. If you think any of this wonkiness is going to deal with this dark force of the recognized hatred this president is bringing up in this country, then im afraid that the democrats are going to see some very dark days. That is author and selfhelp guru Mary Ann Williamson when asked about the crisis last night. She said the problem is deeper than donald trump. Im surprised im going to say this, but actually she gave some of the best political advice any democrats could give, because were sitting here again, its a wonky discussion last night about medicare for all, mending obamacare very, very important, but thats not where voters are right now. Voters are scared. Theyre scared of donald trump. They see something happening to their country that theyve never seen in their lifetime, and they dont theyll have some discussions, yes, tell me where you stand, but it is. It is a much bigger threat to this country, and i think americans want somebody up there Ronald Reagan was brilliant at it, bill clinton was brilliant doing it, barack obama the same. They want somebody that rises above Brookings Institute versus Heritage Foundation policy battle to talk about the bigger battle against racism, against bigotry, against all the things that donald trump has done to push this country to the edge. So, willie, i think she was kind of good. Like right there, up there with the other candidates. Honestly, she had some great moments. She was sort of the punchline from the first debate, but shes not going to dive deep into policy, thats not her thing, but as joe said, she taps into the gut feeling about this election. There is the combination of the head and the gut and shes talking about the gut. I will point out she was the most searched google candidate yesterday. After the debate, in 49 of the 50 states, Steve Bullock was the most searched in montana, but in all 49 of the other states, it was Mary Ann Williamson who people were most curious about after watching that. And i think if the reaction is similar to what we had, theyre like, wait a minute, who is this lady . Shes pretty good. Searching her and where has she been all our lives . Im not sure shell make it to the top tier. Having said that, she was impressive. It was critical, willie, of her being on the stage after the first debate. I dont think its such a bad thing for the Democratic Party to have somebody who can go there out of ten candidates, out of 20 candidates, and just speak more generally about the challenges that are gripping the country. So, again, shes ill just say it, shes probably not going to go anywhere in any of the primary contests, but certainly i think she got the tone right when it came to what the battle lines really are. Again, mike barnicle, were not talking about the subsections of Bernie Sanders medicare for all bill. Thats not what americans want to hear about. They want to hear about how donald trump is a bigot, how donald trump is a racist, how donald trump has shattered constitutional norms, how donald trump is putting a dupe in for the most important position at ndi. Hes got a bunch of sycophants around him that dont respect the president. Thats what they want to hear. Joe, bingo with a capital b on that. Im going to tell you, the president of the United States is now in the position where he scares people. He scares average americans because they sense a portion of the country that they are familiar with, a portion of how they live and what theyve become familiar with is going down the drain because of him. Yesterday quinnipiac poll in late 51 of most people polled think the president of the United States is a racist as opposed to 45 who say, no, hes not a racist. That is an astounding number. And if you extrapolate that, joe, out into the suburbs this fall or next fall, hes going to have real difficulty because you cant scare people. He has scared people. Coming up on morning joe. Ive heard some of these candidates say that its somehow not moral if you not moral to not have that public option. Senator sanders was actually on a public option bill last year, and that was, bernie, the medicaid bill that senator shaatz introduced. That was Amy Klobuchars take on the medicare fight last night. Well ask her more about that, ahead on morning joe. Ahead on morning joe. This is not just a headache. This is not just a fever. This is not just the flu. Its meningitis b. And youre not there to help. While meningitis b is uncommon. Once symptoms appear, they can progress quickly and can be fatal. Sometimes within 24 hours. Before you send your teen to college. Make sure you help protect them. Talk to your teens doctor. About meningitis b vaccination. And i dont add trup the years. S. But what i do count on. Is boost® delicious boost® high protein nutritional drink has 20 grams of protein, along with 26 essential vitamins and minerals. Boost® high protein. Be up for life. Dprevagen is the number onemild memopharmacistrecommendedng . Memory support brand. You can find it in the vitamin aisle in stores everywhere. Prevagen. Healthier brain. Better life. Its how we care for our Cancer Patients like job. When he was diagnosed with cancer, his team at ctca created a Personalized Care plan to treat his cancer and side effects. So job could continue to work and stay strong for his family. This is how we inspire hope. This is how we heal. We love you, daddy. Good night. I love you guys. Cancer Treatment Centers of america. Appointments available now. Can you guarantee those Union Members that the benefits of medicare for all will be as good as the benefits that their representatives, their union reps, fought hard to negotiate . Two things. It will be better because medicare for all is kpre comprehensive and covers all Health Care Needs for senior citizens. It will cover dental needs and eyeglasses. You dont know that. I do know because i wrote the damn bill. Senator sanders does not know all contracts in the United States. Im trying to explain these Union Members are losing their jobs, their wages have been stagnant, the world is crumbling around them. The only thing they have is possibly really Good Health Care. And the democratic message is going to be, were going to go in, and the only thing you have left, were going to take it and were going to do better. I do not think thats a recipe for success for us. You know, i like bernie and i like elizabeth, but were asked by people at nbc to tell the truth on what we think about things, so im going to tell the truth. Okay. Thats neverneverland, saying that medicare for all is going to be better than a lot of those Union Contracts and youre going to get full dental, full comprehensive no, its not. Its just not. And the Democratic Party really needs to wake up. You can keep talking about that, but run this tape two years from now. Those promises will be broken as much as Donald Trumps promises are broken, because again, as ron fournier said, living in detroit, people know in detroit that Canadas Health care system not a panacea. Yes, you dont get billed when you get out of the hospital, but its hard to get into the hospital sometimes. Il its hard to get health care. Mika and i have friends in canada who come to the United States to get health care and to get procedures. So its just again, i think its a good debate to have. I believe in universal health care coverage. But, man, it reminded me so much of the 2016 debates when donald trump would just Say Something and everybody would cheer and applaud. They were applauding at a utopia thats not going to exist in the United States of america, and yes, yes, twitter, america, that comes from a former republican congressman, but a former republican who wants donald trump to be beaten every bit as badly as we do. Thats for sure. That was the Exchange Last night between senator Bernie Sanders and congressman tim ryan over the medicare for all bill. Congressman ryan of ohio joins us now. Congressman, thanks so much for being with us. Thank you. I just have to ask, and again, obviously, i think the Democratic Party should provide universal health care, but they need to provide choice as well to Union Members and other people, working class americans. What goes through your mind when you go on stage and Bernie Sanders says, were going to give everybody everything, and its going to be for free, and dont worry about those Union Contracts that Union Representatives have sweated and toiled and fought over for decades . I represent a lot of these people, joe, and its not good. Im just trying to let everybody know this could be a potential disaster for us. If our message isnt that we want to provide health care for everybody, it will be that we want to take good medical from people who have negotiated Good Health Care. I cant tell you how many times ive watched members give away wages in order to get really Good Health Care because they know they need that security. And to go in as a party and say, were going to take that away from you, is not good. Lets focus on giving health care, Getting Health Care affordable and accessible to people who dont have it. That should be the message, not taking it away. I think we lose 48 states, joe. Im having a hard time figuring out what the two states are were going to win if our lead message is were going to confiscate health care from people. Okay, tim, package that medicare for all to decriminalizing health care for undocumented workers. I dont think we should decriminalize. Look, this has nothing to do with taking kids from their parents. Obviously thats a disaster and we shouldnt be doing it. Its heartbreaking. We should secure the border. We should have a comprehensive path to citizenship. We should welcome people who are seeking asylum here in the United States. Were a Strong Enough country to be compassionate. But at the same time you cant just wander into the United States without it being a criminal charge. I dont think thats that out of step with the vast majority of people in the country. Im sorry, tim, but again, not only that, you come into the United States illegally and some people on the debate stage are saying you get health care for life, Free Health Care for life, Free Education for life. I mean, free everything for life. Im sorry. Some people on twitter may not like to hear this. That aint going to sell in youngstown, ohio, that aint going to sell in mccomb, mississippi, and that aint going to sell in wisconsin. Youre talking to people who are struggling to make ends meet. Theyre barely keeping their nose above water. Their health care is insecure, their wages are insecure, their job is insecure. Their pensions they worked their whole life for insecure in a vast majority of these places in the United States, and the message coming from our party is an undocumented person can get Free Health Care. So this person who can barely make ends meet and struggles to pay Health Care Works a second job, a second shift to pay health care for their family, theyre hearing us say, well, the undocumented person should get it free. I think the undocumented person should get health care, too, but they should pay for it like everyone else does. I just dont think you can wander into the United States without it being a criminal charge. These are and i dont think we should confiscate peoples Health Insurance. Look, if you think what im saying makes sense, and this is the direction we need to go for the party, we need to Start Building support. Go to timryanforamerica. Com. You saw it last night, joe. I was talking about manufacturing. I was talking about the new jobs of the future and how do we get those in mccomb county, michigan and youngstown, ohio and the textile communities in south carolina. New jobs, electric vehicles, chief manufacturing officer, building things again in the United States. Thats got to be the message for us if were going to beat donald trump because people are still living paycheck to paycheck. Were getting off on these issues that arent resonating with the Kitchen Table issues that people are living with every single day. I think there is a huge disconnect that happened last night on the stage with what average people are dealing with and what the Democratic Party is talking about. I think it could be trouble for us. Congressman, you represent go ahead. Jonathan, im sorry. Did he say that was timryan. Com . Timryanforamerica. Com. Timryanforamerica. Com. Timryanforamerica. Com. Im sorry, jonathan lemire, go ahead. Joe, i know youre obsessed with your own web sites. It makes sense you want to clarify at this point. I have a website . Thats the rumor. Congressman, you say he won last night and he did so on trade. The president is talking with china about trade and tariffs. You say you agree with some of the president s tariffs on china which may come as a surprise to people watching last nights debate and the show this morning. Explain why. Because china has been cheating us and cleaning our clock for a long time on trade agreements. Theyve been manipulating their currency for years. One of the first bills i was on 17 years ago was to stop china from manipulating their currency. They steal our intellectual property, they participate in industrial espionage, they subsidize goods coming into our country, putting workers and companies out of business here. So to say it frankly, they need a punch in the mouth. You just cant keep doing that. I think donald trump did that. Now, hes botched it since then. He hasnt done anything. But i do think we need to have a firmer position and then lets sit down at the table and negotiate how we fix this. He hasnt done any of that, so i support being firm with them, but hes got to have a bigger term strategy. As i said last night, china has a 20year strategy, 30year strategy, 100year strategy, donald trump lives in a 24hour news cycle. So be firm on it and get to the table and negotiate. You dont hang your farmers out to dry like were doing now. Farmers havent made a profit in five years. You have to be smarter about it and have a bigger strategy to which the tariffs are a tactic. Hes botched it and we have to do a better job with it because china is our number one competitor at this point. By the way, mika, speaking of farmers, most of Donald Trumps relief for farmers, socalled relief for farmers, as you know, went to the richest farm conglomerations its been rank and file farmers, average farmers got nothing out of Donald Trumps plan. By the way, when you have a president talking about a 16 billion farm payoff, thats called socialism in most countries. Anyway, congressman, thank you for being with us. Tim ryan, thank you very much for being on the show this morning. Thanks, mika and joe. Take care. One more candidate to hear from this morning. Senator Amy Klobuchar says democrats are more worried about winning an argument than winning an election. She joins us next on morning joe. Morning joe. You try hard, you eat right. Mostly. You make time. When you can. But sometimes life gets in the way, and that stubborn fat just wont go away. Coolsculpting takes you further. A nonsurgical treatment that targets, freezes, and eliminates treated fat cells, for good. Discuss coolsculpting with your doctor. Some common sideeffects include temporary numbness, discomfort, and swelling. Dont imagine results, see them. Coolsculpting, take yourself further. Right now, congress is working to end surprise medical billing. Thats when patients are hit with medical bills they thought would be covered by insurance. But what congress is considering would cut money that vulnerabe patients rely on the most. That means seniors, children, and americans relying on medicaid would be hurt. Its already too hard for people to get basic medical care with hospitals closing and a shortage of er doctors. Tell congress we can end surprise billing without shredding the safety net. Paid for by physicians for fair coverage. Dto experiencer gthrilling performance. Now, at the lexus golden opportunity sales event. Get 0. 9 apr for 60 months on all 2019 models. Experience amazing at your lexus dealer. Its rukmini here from the new york times. Hey, you see this . only tylenol® rapid release gels have laser drilled holes. They release medicine fast, for fast pain relief. Tylenol®. Everyone wants to getie lekd, but my point is this. When we ever a guy in the white house who has now told over 10,000 lies that we better be very straightforward with the American People. And no, do i think well end up voting for a plan that kicks half of america off of their current insurance in four years . No, i dont think were going to do that. I think there is a better way to get what we all want to see, which is lower cost for health care. Do i think were going to vote to give free college to the wealthiest kids . No, i dont think were going to do that. Thats what im talking about. But what i dont like about this argument right now, what i dont like about it at all is that we are more worried about winning an argument than winning an election. And i think how we win an election is to bring everyone with us. Joining us now, democratic candidate for president , senator Amy Klobuchar of minnesota and former senator Claire Mccaskill has the first question. Good morning, amy. I thought you did well last night. My question to you is, can you take a minute and explain the reality of a 60vote margin and what that means in terms of the values that we all embrace . More health care, immigration reform, infrastructure. Talk about it in context of the reality of the numbers right now and what congress is capable of doing. See, this makes me wish, claire, that you were asking the questions last night as well. Because we did need that reality because, in fact, thats what i was trying to say there, is you have to make sure you can get things done or youre going to be overpromising people. And the reality is that even if we take back the senate, right, which i want us to do and i think we can do, and the presidency, and we keep the house, were still going to have to get some more conservative democrats on board as well as some moderate republicans to vote with us to get things done. And so thats my argument. This doesnt mean that you dont have bold plans, because i think, claire, you know that a lot of republicans are ready to move on immigration reform. They wanted to do it in 2013. A lot of republicans wanted to move on infrastructure. Theyre getting the same kind of calls about Prescription Drugs. I actually think we could have this amazing year moving forward, but we have to first of all win, and then second of all, govern. And thats the point im making, and it concerns me with some of these proposals that i dont think are ever going to be able to pass. So explain why the 60vote margin was our friend when the republicans had the house, the senate and the white house. I think people forget some of the crazy town stuff that was blocked by that 60vote margin. Exactly. People forget the door swings both ways. Ive talked to a lot of progressives who say, get rid of the 60vote margin. Then if the worm turns, we are looking at serious inroads to a womans right to choose and a whole host of other issues. Talk about that for a minute. Sure. The 60vote margin, of course, allows the minority power, whatever party doesnt have power, to have power. You have to get to 60 votes to get things done. In this case, what was going on before, we took back the house. The senate was able to stop a lot of things donald trump has wanted to do over the years. It would have been very devastating to our environment and to the world around us, to Womens Health care. When i get in there, and i do want to win this and lead this ticket because i believe ill win big in the midwest and places like im in today, michigan, i think you could use it as leverage if we take back the senate, and those guys arent playing ball, which i think they will. They will have to because things have been sitting where nothing is happening on so many important fronts. You can always use it as leverage to say, look, im going to make changes to it, but of course the democrats and the senate would have to make that decision. But to just say were going to get rid of it right now and Mitch Mcconnell is running the place and wont let us advance on issues i raised last night, sensible background checks for guns, wont let us go forward on Climate Change, wont let us go forward on protecting our elections from russian interference, my bill, its time you know, weve got to be honest that weve got to be able to use the tools that we have. Investigators looking at simple homicides look at motive. I know you probably have friends that voted for donald trump in 2016. So my question to you is what do you think the motive was for people who voted for donald trump in 2016, and how can you, as a democratic candidate for president potentially running against him, get to that motive and change their mind . Exactly. There were a mix of motives. I had a question similar to this last night related to racism. And i made clear there is systemic racism in our system, that donald trump himself, especially with what youve seen this last weekend about baltimore, is a racist, puts out racist remarks every day, and that did motivate some of the people that voted for him. But then there was another group that was simply looking for a change in the economy. They wanted something that helped them, and the case that i would make to them is, really, has he delivered on his promises . When you go home and see those pharmaceutical bills and hes on tv boasting about what hes done, yet you see those prices go up and up, he hasnt delivered for you. Or when youre in a traffic jam and you cant get your world broadband despite his promise on election night, he hasnt delivered for you. So we have to make the case for those farmers like hes treated as one of his poker chips in one of his casinos, we have to make a case for him that this hasnt succeeded and we have an optimistic agenda that will include them. Senator, explain whats going on with Mitch Mcconnell and russia, because weve had the intel chiefs, weve even had berman saying russia tried to interfere in american democracy in all 50 states. You have trumps picks for the fbi, the cia, the director of national intelligence, the United States military intelligence. Kirsten nielseknee jirs k nielsen, everybody said he tried to interrupt american democracy, theyre doing it now. Why is Mitch Mcconnell blocking every bail like yours and others that are trying to protect america from a russian invasion of our election process . I can tell you clearly because hes putting his party first instead of our democracy. I dont think this is the patriotic thing to do. He has personally always liked to get involved in these election issues. By the way, when i asked about this at a classified briefing just a few weeks ago pto all th intelligence chiefs, i cant reveal what was said there, but i will tell you this. When i asked, he literally tried to shut me down and said thats a Campaign Finance issue in front of the whole senate. Im like, no, its not. Its a security issue for our country. And as i pointed out last night, hundreds of thousands senator, you can go back to 2016. The intel chiefs came to the preside president , to the senate and house and said therefore trying to undermine it. Mitch mcconnell actually threatened everybody there, that if they said anything publicly, he would try to turn the issue. So, again, tell us because i dont know why anybody from kentucky let my explain are for a guy thats trying to stop. I will tell you why i think hes doing t. Totally in line with the president. We have 11 states that dont have backup paper ballots or dont have paper ballots, only partial. So imagine what would happen if we had a close president ial race, swing state, its a mess. They get hacked into. We wont even be able to tell what the result is. Thats the first thing. The second is just as insidious and thats the bill we talked about before, which would basically say to the social media companies, youve got to tell us what youre paying for these ads and what they are, all you big platforms, not just a few. Thats where all the dark money is going, not just russian money, but dark money to divide people on issues. He doesnt like that bill at all because they want to use it to run a bunch of dark, dirty ads on peoples facebook pages like the one that showed an africanamerican woman during 2016 who said, hey, dont stand in line, you can text to vote for hillary at 83124. That was a crime. Those were the kinds of ads showing up on peoples pages. He has stopped those bills in their tracks. In the case of backup paper ballots, he literally made calls, as did the white house counsel, to republican senators to stop it from getting marked up in the rules committee where im the ranking member. Its like i have the smoking gun evidence, this happened, hes doing and thats why hes doing it, because it protects their party. But look at whats on the other side. Hundreds of thousands of people losing their lives on the battlefield to protect our democracy and democracies around the world. Four little girls in birmbirmin dying in a church at the height of the civil rights movement. Innocent, innocent, because people simply wanted to have the right to vote and be part of our democracy. Thats whats at stake here. You have the russians trying to ruin our democracy and you have others trying to ruin our country. Lets call it what it is. That sounds unamerican. I have made very clear what i think about this. I think it is not patriotism. I think its pure partisanship, and i think weve got to call him out on it because once you get those bills to the floor, i promise you, we will get the votes to pass them. But he has blocked them from coming to the floor and the American People need to understand that. As president , i will be able to get all this done, but i dont even want to wait until im president , i want to get it done now. Thats why every debate ive worked to try to bring it up no matter what the question is because people have to know whats going on. Senator Amy Klobuchar, thank you very much. Thank you. See you, claire yep, old friends. We want to show you two sound bites that pretty much encapsulates last night. Take a look. I think democrats win when we run on real solutions, not impossible promises. When we run on things that are workable, not economics. Look at this city of detroit, this amazing city were in. This city is turning around because the government and prooifrt s private sector are working well together. That has to be our motto going forward. We need to encourage collaboration between the government, the private sector and nonprofit sector, creating jobs, improving their pay. I get a little bit tired of democrats afraid of big ideas. Republicans are not afraid of big ideas. They could give a trillion dollars in tax breaks to billionaires in profitable corporations. They could bail out the crooks on wall street, so please dont tell me that we cannot take on the fossil fuel industry and nothing happens unless we do that. John delaney leading the moderates on stage warning of unfair economics. The progressive wing against those democrats are afraid of big ideas. Joining us now, nbc news capitol hill correspondent and host of k ark ka kasie, kasie hunt. And alicea melendez. Alicea, well start with you. Who stood out to you last night . It was less about who stood out than the conflict on that stage, the debate between progressives and moderate. Ive heard a lot on this show oo but it is great for the Democratic Party to have this debate. Whats interesting is that the real political athletes in this democratic field of 20 seem to be the most progressive. Bernie sanders and Elizabeth Warren hit all of their marks last night, elizabeth hit all of her marks in the first debate. She could not have done better for the position she was fighting for. And bernie, it was like a tale of two bernies. The last debate he seemed old, tired, repeating the same thing. And last night, man, he was on fire, had a great opening and was aggressive all night. He was. He was very much on his game, and i think he showed why it was he gave Hillary Clinton such a run for her money back in 2016. But i have to tell you, joe, what the debate last night left me wanting was a faceoff between Elizabeth Warren and joe biden. Bernie and warren sort of teamed up, right, to present their progressive ideas instead of going after each other, but warren and biden right now represent the two strongest candidates in the respective sort of pillars. And joe, i go back and forth, because ive obviously watched everything you said on the show and tweeted about the risks of these progressive ideas that Many Democrats are pushing, getting rid of private Health Insurance, decriminalizing crossing the border, et cetera, and on the one hand, i agree with you, there are definitely pitfalls in a general election in these rust belt states. But on the other hand, Hillary Clinton, i remember, in 2016 very often carried this message to people that they couldnt go that big because it wouldnt work. She had this realist message where she said, im not going to try and sell you something thats never going to happen, and it fell so incredibly flat, and look where we are now. I think there is still an aspect here, and part of why there is so much excitement on the progressive side, is that people are looking for somebody thats going to say, you know what, we get the system is not working for you, and what were going to do is not try to work within the system but it is to throw it out. So that, i think, is the central tension and it goes beyond idealogy. It goes beyond idealogy, and again, michael, still the great political athletes on the stage right now seem to be the progressives. There arent moderates that are talking about really aggressively taking it to donald trump. There are some very good candidates out there, but let me just say to democrats, its very simple what youll hear from the Republican Party this week, what youll hear from donald trump is you want to give health care to Illegal Immigrants coming across the border, and yet there are millions of americans that dont even have health care right now, 40 million, 50 million. You can claim youll give Everybody Health care, but that doesnt come without taking away all choices. No, you cant have the doctor you want, you cant have the uniform health plan you love. Same with illegal immigration