Transcripts For MSNBCW Morning Joe 20181009

Reading axios am in a bit. You can sign up for the news letter going to sign up. Axios. Com. That does it for me. Morning joe starts right now. Its a very scary situation where youre guilty until proven innocent. Due process. Due process. Due process. Due process. Due process. Due process. I must say that you, sir, under historic scrutiny, were proven innocent. Thank you. Okay. President trump yesterday declared an end to the scary time for Brett Kavanaugh. Good morning. And welcome to morning joe. It is tuesday, october 9th. Along with joe, willie and me we have msnbc contributor mike barnicle, National Political correspondent for nbc news and msnbc and author of the book the red and the blue, the 1990s and the birth of political tribalism Steve Kornacki. Joe, my question to you is how you would sum up what you saw yesterday happening in the east room at the white house . It was graceless. Yeah. It was a president who once again had an opportunity not to be the great uniter, not to be Abraham Lincoln after the civil war talking about with malice toward none, but to do a small thing or two, send an olive branch, but he had all the members of the Supreme Court there, including the liberal members of the Supreme Court, and instead it ended up being a political pep rally. Willie, that would be unbecoming in any circumstance. I remember being very bothered by barack obama in the state of the Union Address using Supreme Court justices as a prop, attacking them for citizens united, with when he knew they had to sit on their hands and not clap. But last night was nothing short of a political pep rally, with even Brett Kavanaugh calling out the republicans who voted for him and ignoring everybody else. Yeah. Time and again when the president gets a chance to heal the country he does the opposite. From charlottesville forward and go back to the campaign as well. When you look at Brett Kavanaugh and that two shot, how uncomfortable he must have felt or maybe he didnt, i dont know, i cant get inside his head after what hes been through the last month to have the politics continue. Im sure he wanted to move on and get past this. The president knows and we know beginning last week with his change in tenor about this whole situation, that this is a good political cudgel for him, it works for republicans, they feel theyre under siege and hes going to push this as he said explicitly yesterday, into the Midterm Elections. The president gathered i was going to say, willie, wasnt it Brett Kavanaugh himself that was going down the list, thanking republican senators, not mentioning anybody else, making it clear that his political allegiance were on one side of the aisle. If you thought he was partisan in his testimony which a lot did when he talked about a clinton conspiracy, that wasnt helped by yesterdays event whatsoever. He looked even more partisan, as the president and republican senators got together at the white house as mika said for a ceremonial swearingin for Supreme Court justice Brett Kavanaugh, here is how the president began his remarks. On behalf of our nation, i want to apologize to brett and the entire kavanaugh family for the terrible pain and suffering you have been forced to endure. Those who step forward to serve our country deserve a fair and dignified evaluation, not a campaign of political and personal destruction based on lies and deception. You, sir, under historic scrutiny, were proven innocent. Wow. Mike barnicle, usually thats crazy. That would be seen as so offensive for a president to use the Supreme Court swearing in after he had already been sworn in, to score even more political points, divide the country even more, that there would be political repercussions, but every poll that has been coming out over the past week showed just the opposite, that actually the president being tacky and the president behaving the way he has, has done nothing but help. Well, were no longer surprised by his behavior, joe. Were just at least myself, i am constantly amazed and depressed at some of the things he says. Hes the president of the United States. He uses a faux swearing in of a Supreme Court justice who had been sworn in prior to last evening as a platform to go after the white male vote in this country and perhaps other votes just like that, akin to that. But the level of hypocrisy also is striking. We played the clip coming in to the segment about due process, due process, due process, and yet the president , you know, talking yesterday to the International Association of Police Chiefs sort of applauded stop and frisk, which is basically no due process. He goes out to he sets out to the country each and every day as weve said before to divide the country, not to try to unite the country as you alluded to. Its never occurred before in the presidency. Never. It was an incredibly strange and graceless moment and heres kavanaugh and what he said last night. Every american can be assured i will be an independent and impartial justice, devoted to equal justice under law. Although the Senate Confirmation process tested me, as it has tested others, it did not change me. My approach to judging remains the same a good judge must be an umpire, a neutral and impartial decideder who favors no litty gant litty gant. A judge must be independent not interpret or make the law. I have to say, its really hard to figure out which Brett Kavanaugh to believe. Do you believe the one in 2015 that was talking like that . Do you believe the one in 2018 that sounded like the right wings version of Hillary Clinton when he talked about right wing conspiracy, but this time Brett Kavanaugh talking about a left wing conspiracy . What about last night when Brett Kavanaugh decided to call out every single republican senator that was responsible for him getting through the process, getting through the Judiciary Committee . Was there a time since the man is on the Supreme Court for life, to figure out a way to extend an olive branch . Of course there was. But this is a graceless, tacky, trump era that republicans believe like Lindsey Graham that the way that you win is by being graceless, by showing absolutely no class, by refusing to turn the other cheek, and to ram victories down your opponents throats. And we will see in less than a month whether voters will reward them for that. That all really depends not on the republicans that come out, but the democrats who decide to stay home. If after two years of this democrats still decide to stay home, if after two years of this, women decide to stay home, if after two years of this, after charlottesville, after everything else, black Voters Decide to stay home, if after two years of being called breeders and rapists, mexicans and mexicanamerican and other hispanicamericans decide to stay home, well, then they and we get the government that we deserve. Steve kornacki, its hard to find any trend lines over the past week that dont overwhelmingly favor Republican Senate candidates. What can you tell us right now . Yeah. I mean especially when you say on the senate side. I think we have to go into the discussion of the senate just acknowledging the battleground there to begin with is already on trump territory largely. Its ten democrats trying to defend seats in trump states, one republican trying to defend a seat in a clinton state. The biggest movement, the most significant movement, potentially were seeing on the senate front the one that jumps out is tennessee. Tennessee was sort of this surprise target that emerged for democrats over the summer. Phil brettson personally popular, former governor not too attached within his National Partys image. He got in the senate race and has led in the polls in spring and summer, nbc marist poll, but in the last two weeks weve seen two polls come out in tennessee, one shows him pulling behind by five points, one shows him polling behind by eight points. Another one in the field right now, im interested to see what final result there is if weve got three showing a pretty steady gap there for brettyson we start to Say Something significant maybe has changed in that race. This is one of those when a democrat trying to stitch together a path to a Senate Majority tennessee was emerging something as close to an essential state for you, especially because some of the other big movement we seem to be seeing is in north dakota and north dakota is probably the single most vulnerable democratic seat on the map, Heidi Heitcamp running in a state trump carried in 2016, falling behind by 11 points in one poll last week and that 11point gap came before she announced her opposition to the nomination of Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court. So again, if you lose a kavanaugh seat and youre democrats at that point you got to pick up in arizona. Thats doable. Pick up in nevada. Thats doable. But you need like a tennessee or a texas, also the polling news not encouraging for democrats. The latest out of texas either. The red states, whether talking about tennessee, north dakota, something happened. The kavanaugh fight happened and that was a battle that was on republican ground. That was like robert e. Lee sending his soldiers up pickets charge, except it was democrats over the past several weeks in the red red States Running straight up the hill into political gunfire. Let me ask you steve what you thought about the Washington Post article and the poll that they conducted yesterday that came out about 46 or 66 of the most highly contested swing districts actually 69 and there were i guess theres democrats had a fourpoint lead, do democrats see that as positive news or does that show perhaps some slippage there as well . Yeah. No, they see it as positive news, but its tough to know exactly what that number means because we dont have past polling from these 69 districts to show you how they looked exactly a couple years ago. We also it would be helpful if youre going to sort of take an assortment of 69 districts, instead of getting a number from across those 69, i would be curious to get the individual race numbers because one possibility there is, you know, is there a handful of districts, particularly these suburban districts that republicans represent but that Hillary Clinton won in 2016, this a handful of those districts thats potentially driving that number and sort of unevenly distributing the democratic strength . Im not quite sure what to make of it except i think it speaks to the Bigger Picture trend or story line that i think weve always known is there with the house, in these metropolitan suburban areas of the country, right outside washington, d. C. , right outside denver, right outside kansas city, you know, southern california, you can find a bunch of new jersey, you can find a bunch of examples of it around the country, the Democratic Energy there has been off the charts since day one of the Trump Administration and i expect us to be seeing blue waves in these metropolitan areas around the country. The question, though, becomes, is it a National Blue wave thats enough to get democrats past 23 seats or does it just become a series of isolated metropolitan waves. One guy energized by the confirmation of Brett Kavanaugh is Senate Majority leader Mitch Mcconnell who led the process, spoke in kentucky yesterday where he said how proud he is of the Republican Caucus for not being intimidated by protests against kavanaugh. We were literally under assault. These demonstrators, im sure some of them were wellmeaning citizens, but many of them were trained to get in our faces, to go to our homes up there, basically almost attack us in the halls of the capitol. Thats a theme you will be hearing. The Washington Post reporting republicans believe they can channel their issue by recasting democrats as an angry mob over the recent protests and what they perceive as the mistreatment of Brett Kavanaugh. The radical democrats have turned into an angry mob. The angry level wing mob. Thats what theyve become. They have encouraged mob rule. I hope we can say no to mob rule. Those who tried to overturn the rule of law and replace it with mob rule lost. Ive never been more pissed in my life. Im really proud of my members for not buckling under those moblike tactics. We want to bring in now from washington, the author of the New York Times news letter on politics, with lisa lara, lisa is with us. Good to have you on this morning, lisa. Give us your reaction to the display at the white house last night and what are you hearing in terms of how people in washington are reacting to it . Well, i think we have to break down a little bit whats happening here. What happened for weeks and weeks, republicans saw this huge Enthusiasm Gap in their midterm polling and you would talk to republican pollsters and they would say theres a 12point gap in how excited democrats are to vote and how excited rinse are to vote. That was not a good thing. They were concerned about it. The kavanaugh confirmation fight started happening and they saw that gap close up and we got to sort of an equal place between republicans and democrats. Then Something Else happened, which is that republicans won the fight. Everyone knows that losers are more energized to vote than winners. Grievance out beats out gratitude at the polls every time. This is part of republicans trying to keep that sense of grievance, that sense of fight going, for the next 28 days. You know, theyre taking a little bit of a victory lap and thats deserved. They won this huge goal of getting a conservative majority on the highest court for a generation. But the fact is that they won. So i wonder, it feels like it will be a little difficult to maintain the sense of grievance for the next 28 days. 28 days in politics is a long time. Lisa, let me just push that a little bit because usually that works, usually thats the way sort of the aggrieved side ends up being able to raise money and develop enthusiasm, but in this case, theres a lot of grievance the way republicans feel the way kavanaugh was treated isnts this the number one thing this they are looking for is to name Supreme Court justices and get them through. I would think this could be a nightmare scenario for democrats . Yes. It is the number one thing that theyre looking for from the president and, of course, the president he did it. It was a big accomplishment. Of course the president s base loves this about him, hes a fighter and sticks it to everybody all the time. Dont forget that democrats also are very aggrieved about this. I was in michigan yesterday and i sort of one thing i wondered whether democrats could be any more energized than they are already, particularly democratic women, i was talking to activists in that state they were wondering the same thing and the fight over kavanaugh has supersonic charged their efforts. They are seeing more engagement. Yeah. From women and there is this historic gender gap and independent women will matter, particularly in those suburban districts that house districts we were talking about. Its energizing on both sides. Its not yeah. Just that. Thats what so i think thats important to remember. Yeah. But thats the danger for democrats, joe, i think because they are energized for sure, but arent republicans now going to be saying, not just the base, joe, but republicans across the board, you know what, hes hes definitely outside the lines of the norms, but hes getting it done for us. Hes getting everything that we want, that we havent seen for decades, joe. Right. Done for us, and including one of the most important things on their list . Yeah. You know, the it is true that it is so much easier to get people out to vote when you have a list of grievances. Thats why Midterm Elections usually go against president s. Thats why in 94, there were a lot of grievances against bill clinton that had nothing to do with the economy. Republicans won big. In 2006, a long list of grievances against george w. Bush, despite the fact that economy was strong. 2010 and 2014, willie geist, in both instances, Barack Obamas coalition of the ascendent could not come out and win in a off year elections. Willie, let me talk to willie, can you show me willie, i would like to see willie looking for willie. Im hiding. How are you . Go ahead, joe. Its good to see you, willie, how are you doing . But its like what tom nicoles said yesterday, which is, which is, the remarkable thing about donald trump and this Republican Party is, that they play the card of grievance and they play the card of grievance, despite the fact that they own the Supreme Court, they own the house of representatives, they own the United States senate, they own the state department, they own the defense department, they own the epa. Do i need to continue . They own everything in washington, d. C. , and yet theyre still aggrieved, poor Lindsey Graham, hes pissed, never been so pissed in his life, you know what, lindsey is part of a monopoly. The republicans own washington, d. C. They own a monopoly. They can do whatever they want to do. And yet, theyre still playing the aggrieved card and well see if it works for them a month from now. Yeah. We will see. Well see where that energy is. I think you cant overstate what lisa said, which is that President Trump is a fighter and thats the way hes viewed by his party, thats the way hes viewed by conservatives as you know well, joe, and this was a moment in our culture where they saw a man un fairly accused in their eyes, they believed that a lot of these allegations were scurrilous and he highlighted the ones that were the worst of them yesterday, did the president , and he stood there at the side of judge kavanaugh in a moment where a lot of people might have walked away from kavanaugh and said i dont need the headache, i think that moment we really cant overstate how big it was for a lot of people, that President Trump stood there at the side of a man that a lot of people in this country believed was getting a raw deal and didnt do the thing other politicians might do, which would be to walk away from him. Thats part of Donald Trumps unique and bizarre gift. I mean he has a capacity to just concentrate on resentment and anger, he does it very skillfully. Joe, let me ask you, youve been out there running, youve run for office, is it possible for a candidate in this case the president of the United States, to fuel an entire party for a month on anger . Is that possible, on anger . Well, listen, if the election were being held seven days from now, then i would tell democrats to duck, they were going to be disappointed. It is true that a week in politics is a lifetime. If i always say this and know it to be the case just by following election, if james comey letter had come out 20 days before the election, Hillary Clinton would have won. 30 days before the election. Hillary clinton would have still won. It depends on what happens between now and election day, what is there that donald trump can use as a trigger to gen up his base. As you know in off year elections its really, really k difficult, for president s, even popular president s from Ronald Reagan to barack obama, reagan had a disastrous midterm in 1992 followed by a disastrous midterm in 1996 when the democrats took back the senate by winning a lot of seats in the supposedly solid republican south. Theres still a very, very long way to go, but i must say, mike, ive been extraordinarily disappointed in the Democratic Party. Ive been extraordinarily disappointed in their inability to to fight back. To put together a message, extraordinarily disappointed in their ability to fight back. Extraordinarily disappointed in their ability to organize, to have a national plan. Im getting calls from people in the Democratic Party every day talking about the fact that right now, they dont have a robust, aggressive way to make sure that they pull out voters, that they dont have a game plan to pull out for instance the black voters that helped doug jones win in alabama. Its just amateur night. It seems constantly that its amateur night for the Democratic Party. They have 29 days to wake up or theyre going to be sitting around the morning after the election whining and complaining about how republicans stole another election and maybe they will blame martians this time, except for blaming themselves and looking in the mirror and blaming themselves for not having a coherent message again, for the second time, in the trump era. For the second time in two years they dont have a coherent message and apparently they dont have a ground game. If democrats win, mika, theyre going to win because they have strong candidates district by district by district. This national Democratic Party does not exist. Okay. Still ahead, its i dont disagree. Still ahead on morning joe, in the views of the president , the allegations against Brett Kavanaugh are, quote, hoax. Much like Climate Change and the russia investigation. More on how branding could impact the midterms. And speaking of russia, the russia probe, a new report is shining a bright light on the social media strategy of rick gates, who has already pleaded guilty in the special counsel investigation, but first, lets go to bill karins with a check on the hurricane closing in on the florida panhandle. Good morning, mika. We know its heading to north florida about noon wednesday the expected landfall. The only question how strong will it be. One day left for preparations in north florida. 90mileperhour winds, as strong as you get for a category 1. Later today should be a category 2. Maybe by tomorrow morning a category 3. Heres the latest Hurricane Center forecast. They have a category 3 coming straight into Panama City Beach florida, apalachicola, the area hardest hit, and the storm surge worst to the right. Tallahassee with the forecast we get very strong winds too. We have, obviously, hurricane warnings for north florida and even watches for areas of georgia and South Carolina on the right side your winds could be high if we get gusts. The storm surge, the thing thats the greatest concern for life and property, eight to 12 feet to the right of the center. Notice thats not in panama city. Right now about five to eight feet for you. The wind forecast as we go throughout wednesday, watch what happens. Panama city gets up there, 88, apalachicola, 125mileperhour winds and the worst for tallahassee would be wednesday evening with winds into the 90s. These Power Outages will be widespread through southern georgia and all of north florida. We got the wind with this storm and the storm surge, those will be the two most deadliest things that we have to worry about. Other areas of the country, a lot of active weather out there, but for once, areas from new york and the northeast, you get a decent, dry day and record highs in some areas. A crazy october, but all eyes are on hurricane michael. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Be right ba. A onceinfive hundred year storm should happen every five hundred years, right . Fact is, there have been twentysix in the last decade. Allstate is adapting. With drones to assess home damage sooner. And if a flying object damages your car, you can snap a photo and get your claim processed in hours, not days. Plus, allstate can pay your claim in minutes. Now that you know the truth. Are you in good hands . Takes more than just investment advice. From insurance to savings to retirement, it takes someone with experience and knowledge who can help me build a complete plan. Brian, my certified financial planner™ professional, is committed to working in my best interest. I call it my comfortable future plan, and its all possible with a cfp® professional. Find your certified financial planner™ professional at letsmakeaplan. Org. With a cordfree vacuum, you need a shark. Because only sharks cordfree lineup has Duoclean Technology so you can deep clean carpets and give hard floors a polished look. And with two swappable batteries at maximum suction, our shark ion f80 gives you more run time than the dyson v10 absolute. And now shark takes cordfree beyond stick vacuums by introducing a full upright model. Shark ion cordfree vacuums available in stick and upright. This is moving day with the best inhome wifi experience and millions of wifi hotspots to help you stay connected. And this is moving day with Reliable Service appointments in a twohour window so youre up and running in no time. Show me decorating shows. This is staying connected with xfinity to make moving. Simple. Easy. Awesome. Stay connected while you move with the best wifi experience and twohour appointment windows. Click, call or visit a store today. You know, willie, the reason why willie geist, tvs willie geist it was a late night. The reason why i gosh. I think the politicians should be graceful, is because theres always the next election and the shoe is always on the other foot. Yeah. So here we had on sunday night was it sunday night . Saturday night. David price got shelled, didnt survive, one and twothirds inning, last night severino wasnt fooling anybody. When you got it you got it. Sometimes when theyre guessing where every pitch is going theres very little you can do. Last night was the red sox night, which means tonight, the yankees will win 153. I like your continued fatalism. After last night the red sox beat the yankee, it pains me to say this on national television, 161, i say. I asked mike when i came in, joe, is it a bad sign when in a critical playoff game in the ninth inning your backup catcher is pitching as austin was for the yankees . Gave up the cycle to brock holt. That was the first, mike, cycle in the history of the playoffs, in the long history of baseball playoffs, first time anybody has hit for a cycle. It is a new day. They are only down 21. You have to win two games out of two. Cc sabathia pitching tonight. Lets stick with the themes of what we do here each and every day. Politics and baseball are pretty much similar. You do it every day. You play baseball every day. They do politics every day. Votes are like runs. You can never have enough. 16 runs last night. We need a few tonight. You dont get to transfer those over to tonight, joe. And mike, you dont really even have enough against the yankees. When we were ahead 100 last night, i said the yankees can score 12 runs in six innings. Its the truth. I have to say, though, the Democratic Party, obviously, doesnt have a leader that knows thou guide it. The boston rod sox, lets look at, you know, bringing in devers at third base, taking out newness, bringing in holt at second base, taking out kinsler, vasquez behind the plate, and who was the fourth, pearce, holt, devers at third base. Yeah. Every one of alex coras moves came through and produced runs in a big, big way. Yeah. But that was last night. Tonight we got to do it again tonight. We have to do it again tonight. Nothing better than beating the yankees on their own lawn. Tonight is the night. Yeah. So willie, i know it will be a shock, but there are some teams that play outside of the acela corridor. I have been saying for a week now that i thought that it was actually going to be the dodgers and astros in the world series. How good are the Houston Astros . That is an extraordinary team, top to bottom. The dodgers, this may be their year. The brewers, man, theyre about as hot as anybody in baseball too. Those are three great teams that are going to be colliding. I mean the brewers, mike, absolutely crushed the brewers the brewers are great. Nobody talks about them. The dodgers are great and they play on the west coast, we dont see them as much as other teams. But the astros might be better than last year. The brewers have won 11 straight games, the hottest team in baseball. The astros are a fully rounded ball club, great pitching staff and to be feared. No matter even against the red sox. The astros should be feared. All right. More purse cleaning. Still ahead, okay, there are more what . Four weeks im just saying, you guys talk a lot about this. I clean my purse. She cleaned a lot of her purse last night and i think shes going to be reorganizing. Baseball wife. I got her to stay up until the sixth inning which is a world record. Mika, excuse me yeah. Are you aware joe calls during the game. Yes. No. He calls you and he i cant believe these and lamere, who is obsessed. The thing i like about lamere is were up 100 and lamere and i and marty. Jonathan lamere going my god, if he doesnt get us into the seventh inning the yankees will come back. I agree. I told lamere yesterday, yesterday he said of pitching, were down 21, were going to go to it is isnt it remarkable, mike, i know we have to go, and willie, i was very concerned about evaledy, he had a lot of up and downs, you can tell after the first batter in so many cases when a pitcher has his stuff, evaledy was throwing 99mileanhour fastballs to righthanded pitchers on the inside high. He was first inning, he he threw about ten pitches that were just unhittable. You can tell early on that guy had his stuff. Joe, willie and i were saying the same thing earlier. You could tell about evaledy and louie from the bronx. Mookie betts, first batter up for the red sox, barreled it up hit the ball 415 feet into left centerfield, it was caught, but you could tell they were on him. Yeah. You know, i was excited until i watched last night and i realized when i kept hearing this name, you have been talking about vivaldi and now i understand theres this player. I love him. I love him too. Hes basically a relief pitcher. He has three pitches. We should all love him. Pinpoint accuracy last night. Hit his spots. Mika did say, though, she goes if they win tonight is it over . I go no. Then they have to win tomorrow night. If they win tomorrow night is it over . I go. Well this series, but we have a sevengame series against the astros. She goes then is it over . No, if we win we have another this is going to be going on until halloween. Its endless. Just like this segment, alex says. Wrap it. There are four weeks left until the midterms and i would like to like maybe we could play vivaldi on the way out. Several gop candidates using the fight over Brett Kavanaugh as a line of attack, but can democrats turn the issue around on vulnerable republicans . The New York Times Jeremy Peters joins us with his latest reporting next on morning joe. Here we go. Discover. I like your card, but im absolutely not paying an annual fee. Discover has no annual fees. Really . Yeah. We just dont believe in them. Oh nice. You would not believe how long ive been rehearsing that. No annual fee on any card. Only from discover. Experience has done is gotten republicans excited. Fox news reported over the weekend the Enthusiasm Gap has closed by about eight points, almost even now on enthusiasm and our fundraising, our Online Fundraising has sky rocketed. The saga to confirm Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court may finally be over, the outrage over his appointment is beginning to catch fire across the Political Landscape in competitive contests around the country. Our next guest writes that both sides of the aisle are intent on making the kavanaugh appointment a rallying cry for their side. Joining us now, New York Times reporter Jeremy Peters. Jeremy, what are you hearing beyond capitol hill on the reaction not just to this appointment but to the ceremony last night and moving forward politically in terms of how they plan to use this contentious nomination as a Political Tool . I think, mika, last nights remarks by trump that kavanaugh was proven innocent, as he said, just a classic example of the president trying to rewrite history on his own, more favorable terms. I think its statements like that that have really energized the left to the point where, you know, they have linked trump to the kavanaugh confirmation bat until a way that battle in a way that he wasnt before. This was a debate about gender and equality and the treatment of women and believing survivors of Sexual Assault that was unfolding with trump kind of largely as a side character. Then he opened his mouth, he opened it twice, when he started attacking Christine Blasey ford, when he said yesterday that this is all a hoax and a fraud and made up language weve heard all sorts of times before about allegations leveled at trump himself, and that feeds the sense more broadly that the Republican Party is being dismissive and disparaging of women like those who came forward, like dr. Ford. You know, lisa, weve seen the first sort of the first wave of political reaction that was from republicans on the defensive and then going on the offensive trying to defend Brett Kavanaugh and getting him over the finish line, but youve got to believe if the last year and a half is any indication of how politics in america works, there will be a counter offensive from the very groups that jeremy just brought up, the very groups, the women voters in virginia that helped elect a governor, women voters in alabama that helped elect the first democratic senator there since the early 1990s, youve got to believe that that counterattack is coming . Right. I think thats right. Thats exactly right and a really good point. What we have seen is a sustained burst of enthusiasm among the Democratic Party and the grassroots and democratic voters. This level of enthusiasm is something thats been going on for, well, really since the president won. I actually have a question for my colleague if i can throw it back to jeremy, a question im asking a lot myself, we know the president s base is solidly behind him, but is that enough to get them over the hump in these midterms . Like whats your gauge of the level of enthusiasm there from all your reporting on these various races . Right. You know, as we were talking about before, lisa, voters dont come out in midterms to say thank you. Right. I think thats a real concern among republicans that the confidence and the enthusiasm that exists right now dissipate four weeks from today and that energy on the left matches and exceeds that of the energy on the right. In the piece that i wrote today, one of the things that we tried to look at very carefully, how are republicans in house races, in close competitive house races responding to this, what you find from dave brat in virginia to rosscom in the suburbs of chicago and elsewhere in the in these suburban races, republican incumbent house members are not talking about this. Who else isnt talking about this, martha mcsally, the republican nominee in arizona for senate, dean heller, the incumbent senator republican in nevada. They dont want to get near the kavanaugh confirmation because its such a toxic issue with the types of voters they need in the these purple states. Thats a sign of the difficulty here republicans have in threading the needle. Do they spike the football over kavanaugh or approach it with more delicacy . As we talk about what will or will not motivate republicans to go to the polls, the politics of it, one of the things you and i have been talking about is this cultural aspect, which is that although republicans control washington right now, conservatives and republicans feel like the culture is aligned against them, by that i mean the media, pop culture, late night shows, things like that, and donald trump is the man out front defending them against all of that. Donald trump has all the right enemies to them and he fights back against them, he doesnt apologize to them, doesnt bow to them. Theres a big element that folks on the right see in that and i think that the kavanaugh fight brought that out a lot. I think it brought out a sense on the right that maybe they werent that invested in Brett Kavanaugh himself or kavanaughs opinion on this or opinion on that, but they were invested in the atmosphere that was created and the atmosphere they perceived was that the media majoring in television and cable news media, was out to get kavanaugh, that pop tour culture was out to get Brett Kavanaugh and they were going to stand with him and trump was going to stand with him and i think thats the tension that trump has benefitted from time and time again. One thing that i think trump sometimes succeeds the doing is, sometimes he can push his opponents enough to start acting the way hes been trying to tell his voters they act like. You know, Jeremy Peters, youre right that some republican candidates are staying completely away from kavanaugh, but if you have a trumpist, a guy thats completely embraced donald trump and actually has made Donald Trumps sort of existence the justification for his campaign, youve got a guy like ron desantis, hes talking about it. Oh, yeah. Hes going right into the middle of the battle and still trying to kiss up to donald trump. Oh, yeah. Absolutely. Ron desantis is kind of a perfect example of the conundrum the party is facing right here. Ron desantis, you cannot become governor of florida just by relying on trump voters in a midterm cycle like this. He was quiet about this, and only over the weekend did he really erupt and say, you know, this is a disgrace and he started echoing the language that trump has been using, this really aggressive tone, this angry leftist mob has undermined the rule of law in our country, how dare they, we cant let them get away with this. Races across the country youre seeing the split reaction. All right. Jeremy peters, thank you so much. Li lisa lare and Steve Kornacki as well. Coming up, Rod Rosenstein finally had his meeting with President Trump yesterday and he may have learned something from james comeys experience, dont go alone. Well talk about that ahead on morning joe. Minimums and fees. They seem to be the very foundation of your typical bank. Capital one is anything but typical. Thats why we designed capital one cafes. You can get savings and checking accounts with no fees or minimums. And one of americas best savings rates. To top it off, you can open one from anywhere in 5 minutes. This isnt a typical bank. This is banking reimagined. Whats in your wallet . And my brother ray and i started searching for answers. vo when its time to navigate inhome care, follow that bright star. Because brightstar care earns the same accreditation as the best hospitals. And brightstar care means an rn will customize a plan that evolves with moms changing needs. woman because dad made us promise wed keep mom at home. vo call 8444brightstar for your free home Care Planning guide. New sleep number 360 smart bed. It senses your movement and automatically adjusts to keep you both comfortable. Its the final days of our fall sale. The queen sleep number 360 c2 smart bed is now only 899. Plus, 24month financing on all beds. Ends sunday. Lets do an ad of a man eating free waffles at comfort inn. They taste like victory because he always gets the lowest price on our rooms, guaranteed, when he books direct at choicehotels. Com. Or just say badda book, badda boom. Book now at choicehotels. Com. Joining us for tonights ceremony is every sitting Supreme Court justice. Chief justice roberts. Thank you. Justice thomas. Thank you. Justice ginsberg. Thank you. Justice breyer. Thank you. Justice alito. Wow. A ceremonial swearing in for Supreme Court justice Brett Kavanaugh which began with trump apologizing to him on behalf of the nation, declaring kavanaugh has been proven innocent. Plus new details in the search for a missing saudi journalist and the Washington Post columnist. Turkish officials are searching for a black van believed to have carried the body of Jamal Khashoggi out of the saudi consulate in istanbul last week. Hurricane michael is pushing towards floridas panhandle. Its expected to be a category 3 storm by the time it makes landfall. Morning joe is coming right back. Perfect drive. [laughter] vo go national. Go like a pro. See what i did there . Discover. O. I like your card, but im absolutely not paying an annual fee. Discover has no annual fees. Really . Yeah. We just dont believe in them. Oh nice. You would not believe how long ive been rehearsing that. No annual fee on any card. Only from discover. Cal we saved our money and now, we get to spend it our way. Valerie but we worry if we have enough to last. Cal ellen, our certified financial planner™ professional, helps us manage our cash flow and plan for the unexpected. Valerie her experience and training gave us the courage to go for it. Its our confident forever plan. Cal . And its all possible with a cfp® professional. Find your certified financial planner™ professional at letsmakeaplan. Org. To severe Rheumatoid Arthritis was intense. My moms pain from moderate i wondered if she could do the stuff she does for us, which is kind of, a lot. And if that pain could mean something worse . Joint pain could mean joint damage. Enbrel helps relieve joint pain, and helps stop irreversible joint damage. Enbrel may lower your ability to fight infections. Serious sometimes fatal events including infections, tuberculosis, lymphoma, other cancers, nervous system and Blood Disorders and allergic reactions have occurred. Tell your doctor if youve been some place where fungal infections are common, or if youre prone to infections, have cuts or sores, have had hepatitis b, have been treated for heart failure, or if you have persistent fever, bruising, bleeding, or paleness. Dont start enbrel if you have an infection like the flu. Since enbrel, my moms back to being my mom. Visit enbrel. Com and use the joint damage simulator to see how joint damage could progress. Ask about enbrel. Enbrel. Fda approved for over 19 years. Does he feel that now . I have to go back to the specific comments. I must state that you, sir, under historic scrutiny were proven innocent. Thank you. [ applause ] the white house wouldnt say last week whether the president recognizes the exoneration of five men wrongly convicted just as Justice Kavanaugh doesnt face. This about donald trump and, of course, you can talk about Michael Flynn as well during the campaign. These are people and donald trump still has crowds chant locker up for a political arrest. Donald trump without due process calling for a political arrest when no indictments came down. Donald trump and mike flynn and others around him saying if somebody pleads the fifth that must mean they are guilty. You have the central park five case. Donald trump believes in due process when it suits donald trump. Of course, you can say that about a lot of people in politics. It really is, it really is sad that weve gotten into tribes and people believe in due process when it suits their political purposes. They dont when it doesnt and donald trump is chief among those offenders. It was a strange display last night along with joe, willie and me we have mike barnacle, msnbc political analyst and former chairman of the Republican National committee Michael Steele. Nbc news capitol hill correspondent and host of kasie dc, kasie hunt. And professor of history at Tulane University walter isaacson. Great panel this hour. Great panel. I want to start with walter really quickly. Walter, i cant be shocked. None of us can be shocked by anything that goes on any more. I just thought last night was the most tacky, classless display for the president of the United States using the United States Supreme Court as a political prop, so many of them do. But they dont call them over to the white house and they dont have all the justices sitting there in an attempt to show some, some unity and have the president of the United States turn into a political pep rally. Ive never seen anything like that. Im wondering if you have. No. Thats what donald trump does. He turns them into pep rallies. He turns them into reality shows. Thats what he knows how to produce. The problem for joe and people like yourself is its successful. He is somehow articulating what a lot of people feel, which is boy, i guess everybody ganged up too much on this guy. It was unfair. And i think it was astonishing that donald trump almost with the help of the democrats had been made something that should have played very strongly into the democrats hands into something thats going to on balance help republicans especially running for the senate. By painting it as a notion of mobs of people who tried to destroy this nice man, somehow or another he changed the narrative. Walter, you said almost with the help of the democrats. Did the hemisphere theres a great piece in the Washington Post this morning. Did the democrats, did the media play right into Donald Trumps hands over the past two weeks . Absolutely. Right into Donald Trumps hands. Whether it was avenatti. The way understandably passionate democrats felt they had to show the same passion that some republicans have, but they played into the hands of those who thought this was a mob rule, and that people werent listening to both sides. And it was a shame that the democrats, in my opinion, so over played that hand because up until then, whichever way the vote went, it was going to help the democrats. Now if the democrats lose the Midterm Election i think the democratic politicians who did that really ought to go into another line of work. If you can win the midterms you ought to get a different type of job. Agreed. I would say the same applies to members of the media covering the story. I think everybody went overboard in a way that im down here in louisiana, back again after being up with you last week. Even down here, people who felt that dr. Ford could be trusted, maybe this guy on balance you wouldnt want on the Supreme Court, they had reasonable thoughts about it, they just felt everything got so piled on with ridiculous accusations that seemed to undermine the very serious ones of dr. Ford. By the way, mike barnacle, allegations against the Supreme Court nominee that five, ten years ago most likely would not have made print, unsubstantiated allegations on one side and then on the other side and im talking about the stories that followed dr. Browns story dr. Fords story, would have been much stronger if dr. Fords story would have stood alone instead of unsubstantiated claims that followed a string of them. On the other side, what New York Times reporter, what the Washington Post reporter was assigned a story by their editors to go see what really happened with Dianne Feinstein and fine and her staff. The sort of questions that would have happened if the Republican Party had done the same thing. Not one. I challenge New York Times reporters this morning, not reporters, editors, i challenge the Washington Post editors, i challenge wall street journal editors, i challenge editors across america, write that story. What happened with dr. Fords agreement with a congresswoman, with Dianne Feinstein . Why did they leak that story . More importantly look at yourself and ask yourself the question why didnt we report on this in realtime when we would have reported it if grassley and his office had done the same thing. Ive been quite clear here. I think republicans acted shamelessly in those judiciary hearings. Lindsey graham embarrassed himself. Republicans embarrassed themselves. But mike so did a lot of democrats. So did whoever leaked that letter and pushed dr. Ford out of the closet. And journalists in america have a lot to answer for. Why count they play this down the mid signal well, joe, first of all quickly the republican members on the Judiciary Committee put them aside. Theres no separation between them and president donald trump. They speak the same language. They could after the same sores to peel the scabs off on the american public. On senator Dianne Feinstein i believe and other people believe that was the core of the democratic weakness in their blafr over the course of the past month. That letter to senator Dianne Feinstein, she received it in early july. The idea i understand, you know, dr. Ford wanted to remain anonymous. There was a way to do that. There was a way to get that letter, the contents of that letter into the hearings. That was a critical point in what happened during these hearings. And the other thing was Michael Avenattis client, the woman who reported she went to several parties, several parties Justice Kavanaugh was present and there was a series of gang rapes. Preposterous story. It ran on the front pages of many newspapers. You know, i dont know what to say after that. The ball game was lost in terms of Public Opinion and now were in, to you know, it was a hoax. The president of the United States basically calling it a hoax. It was truly depressing experience. Well, again, willie, the question is why didnt they focus on the allegations before them . Why didnt they ask the same tough questions of Dianne Feinstein and her staff that they should have rightly asked of Chuck Grassley and his staff. You held the letter for a couple of months. You waited until kavanaughs hearing was over. And then you released it at the very end. Again, the only question im asking today is why didnt one editor for the New York Times or one editor for the Washington Post or one editor for the wall street journal say you know what . Thats a story we really need to dig into deep because they are not telling us the truth. I cant answer that question for them, joe, but your larger point is absolutely right, which is that, you know, Oprah Winfrey made a speech before the usc graduating class in may who said dont fight hysteria with more hysteria. I think people who are against Brett Kavanaugh still have a good case that the fbi investigation was not a real investigation. If they just focused on dr. Fords allegation, we want to look into this, that was not a real investigation and they are right about that. I want to play for you Michael Steele what the president said followed by what judge kavanaugh said afterwards. On behalf of our nation i want to apologize to brett and the entire kavanaugh family for the terrible pain and suffering you have been forced to endure. Those who stepped forward to serve our country deserve a fair and dignified evaluation. Not a campaign of political and personal destruction based on lies and deception. You, sir, under historic scrutiny were proven innocent. Every american can be assured that ill be an independent and impartial justice devoted to equal justice under law. Although the Senate Confirmation process tested me, as it has tested others, it did not change me. My approach to judging remains the same. A good judge must be an umpire, a neutral and impartial decider who favors no litigant or policy. A judge must be independent and must interpret the law, not make the law. So, Michael Steele, what did you make of what was a political scene. Justice kavanaugh was sworn iran officially the day before. What did you make of the two shot of the president making a political speech with the newest justice standing by his side . It was sort of this split screen moment because you had the president still engaging in the political game. He was throwing down the politics as much as he could just affirming to his base and those who rallied around him and judge kavanaugh what this moment was really about. What it symbolized right there in the white house with those Supreme Court justice sitting there. For kavanaugh a different narrative. Kavanaugh recognizes one thing to be a nominee. Now im a member of the bench. Im a justice. Ive got to live in this town as a Supreme Court justice. I can live here as a nominee under those political pressures and scrutiny. Ill be scrutinized as a justice and in need that reputation, my reputation to be a fair jurisprudence. Once thats balanced not the imbalanced nominee you saw who was reactionary and quite honestly political. So you saw kavanaugh trying to continue to rehabilitate his own narrative while the president was holding on to his own black robe saying a little bit, not too far, not too fast we have some politics to do here. Its the way trump sees things. He sees things through that political pricism. The republicans want engagement, okay lets engage. That turning point is when he went after Christine Blasey ford. When he made his own decision despite what everyone else was saying im going to take her down my way, ill take this down politically my way and he was successful. You know, kasie hunt, democrats listened to the president last night. Listened to Brett Kavanaugh. Kavanaugh saying he needs to be an umpire, he needs to be neutral, he needs to be independent. Then he did roll call of republican senators that fought like hell for him. Didnt mention a single democrat. Donald trump talking about a fair and dignified process that every nominee deserves as if Brett Kavanaugh was the first person to ever be put up and as if merritt garland never even existed and the ugliness of merritt garland never even existed. A man they even refused to talk to. There wasnt a process for that. I wonder how down are the democrats right now are. Are they beaten down or do you sense defiance . Defiance. I would say the opposite. I think theres a little bit of concern or at least ive spoken to some people who were a little worried perhaps the Democratic Base would get discouraged by their leaders here in washington. That has happened in the past over the course of the last year. But i do not think that that is this is how this is shaking out at all. Instead the anger is just growing around this idea that, you know, now Justice Kavanaugh can go through all that and still end up on the Supreme Court. I mean youre seeing in their fursin i fundraising, Kamala Harris and heidi heitkamp. This is animating people. The other piece of this, i think, thats remarkable as well is that this fight united the entire Republican Party for what may be the first time in the trump presidency. I mean, you know, normally i spend my time with a microphone talking to these republican senators about the latest tweet that the president sent or latest thing he said today and oftentimes they have to figure out how to say that they dont agree with it without actually getting under the president s skin. This is not like that. This across the board from the president to Mitch Mcconnell, this is mcconnells lifes work and while a lot of people always thought kavanaughs confirmation would be in doubt my sense is Mitch Mcconnell was never going to let this go. So in that the Washington Post survey we were discussing last hour, a decisive factor in the democrat support appears to be women who prefer Democratic Candidates by 14 points, 54 to 40 while men favor republicans by five points. New cnn ssrs poll shows 31 of women approve of the job that the president is doing. 62 disapprove. On the flip side 51 of men approve while 43 disapprove. Thats a gender gap of 39 points. Potentially more troubling for republicans, a spike in the number of women who support the democrats over the republicans in their choice for congress. This chart based on nbc wall street journal poll shows the trend since 2010 when republicans took over going from a six point gap that year to a 25 point one this year, joe. Its a gender gap, kasie that seems to be very significant. The question, though, is do democrats get out the vote . Thats what it all comes down to. We saw in Northern Virginia, obviously, women in Northern Virginia making a big difference in the virginia gubernatorial race. We saw black women in alabama helping doug jones get elected in alabama. Can you tell me what are the democrats doing . Do they seem organized around this concept that if they win this fall they will win because of motivated women . I think thats absolutely what they think. That gender gap is devastating. Those trend lines im not clear how the Republican Party can recover from Something Like that in the long run. I think the question is, you know, how much of this is strictly about President Trump and will those lines start to trend back together if hes no longer seen as the leader of the Republican Party. I think every piece of evidence we have from the sheer number of women who are running for office, irmean Record Numbers and we should be clear these are mostly democratic women. There are some republican women running, of course, but this is predominantly a democratic trend. When you look at virginia, this organization a lot of times was coming from the bottom up not the top down. If anything the Democratic Party here in washington has had to sort of take a breath. Theres been some congressional races where they missed really good candidates, amy mcgraph in kentucky is a good example of this. I interviewed a couple of months ago. Shes incredibly sharp candidate. They wanted to nominate someone else, the mayor of lexington who had been in the political system for a long time, a white man. She beat him in the primary. So now they are helping her. But you saw that in that breakdown in the state house races, first transgender woman winning in a republican state. We dont fully have our heads around the depth of this yet. So i think it could actually, as much as we talked about it, it could surprise people on election day. Walter i remember jimmy carter in 1980 when he made his announcement to run for reelection against Ronald Reagan and he came out swinging against reagan and he talked about and ill just paraphrase. He talked about a country that was divided between men and women, blacks from white, urban america versus rural america. Maybe president carter was about 40 years too early to really see the sort of division were seeing now where you do see, you look at the poll that shows a massive gender gap for women between republicans and democrats. You can see the same for rural and urban. You can see the same for black and white. This is politically a country divided, almost split straight down the middle. Pick your category whichever ones jimmy carter brought up 40 years ago that seems to be, you know, where the dividing lines are. You know, joe, you put your finger on the worst thing about this, which is we were very, very divided as a nation. We got more partisan over the past 15, 20 years. The trump election made it even more so. And with dr. Christine blasey fords testimony, so deeply appealing and resonate with a lot of women but also the whole circus that ended up surrounding the thing that got a lot of men upset. Now you see a big divide between men and women. Im teaching at tulane, im seeing a divide between young men and women in the classroom where they are rolling their eyes at each other. So youre taking a nation and ripping it apart on every seam line, every fault line you can possibly find. Liberal, conservative, republican, democrat, rural, urban, north, south, now male, female. I just hope people get sick of this and by the way get sick of the way both parties have resorted to lets see how much we can whip apart the dna of america rather than join it together that some candidate will come along and say, okay, timeout, lets start bring this thing back together. Walter, what do you tell your students in class today . What do other educators across america, talking to High School Students or College Students or grad students, what do you tell them . How does this how do we repair the breach . How do we move forward . I tell them this happened many, many times in our country. That it happened in my memory during the vietnam period, in the civil rights marches down here in new orleans and the rest of the south. It happened during the mccarthy period and, of course, in the greatest tragedy of all, happened during our civil war. Were pretty good at bringing people back together. But, the question is do we have systems now that just continually push us apart . Systems ranging from gerry maar gerrymandering. What can we do about the systemic problem tearing us apart. Second youre in college, youre around the table, this is the most diverse table youll ever be around. I look at my seminar people, look these are people from vietnam and heres some that are black, we have whites, some very conservative, a couple of kids from kentucky deeply supportive of trump and thought that Brett Kavanaugh had his reputation savaged. Lets see if we can have a civil conversation about it to show that it doesnt have to become the way it is in this country. Walter isaacson thank you very much. Still ahead on morning joe weve been talking about how women vote but what about how they run. The president of emilys list weighs in on the number of female candidates putting their names on the ballot. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Lets face it everybody hates fees. Now sofi has no fees on personal loans. Thats right no fees on loans to remodel your bathroom. No fees on loans to consolidate your credit card debt. See no fees just feels good. Boo yeah. If youve got the drive, you can do a lot with no fees on personal loans. Boo yeah. Unstopand its strengthenedting place, the by xfi pods,gateway. Which plug in to extend the wifi even farther, past anything that stands in its way. Well almost anything. Leave no room behind with xfi pods. Simple. Easy. Awesome. Click or visit a retail store today. Thinking about impeaching a brilliant jurist, a man that did noning wrong, a man that was caught in a hoax, that was set up by the democrats, using the democrats lawyers. Now they want to impeach him. Ive heard this from many people. I think its an insult to the american public. And i think youre going to see a lot of things happen on november 6th that would not have happened before. I think a lot of democrats are going to vote republican because i have many friends that are democrats. The main base of the democrats have shifted so far left that well end up being venezuela. This country would end up being venezuela. I think a lot of democrats are going to be voting republican on november 6th. Thats the president speaking yesterday outside of the white house and joining us now former republican Media Consultant to four president ial campaigns and founder of the Communications Firm merrimac potomac. And president of emilys list. Two sides of the coin here of the conversation weve been talking about which is who is more energized by the confirmation of Brett Kavanaugh. Ill start with you. Do you believe that the progressive base, do you believe that women will take the energy of having lost this fight and bring it to the polls with them in a month . Well, youve seen the results of democrats success for the last year and a half. These particularly women have been on fire, rearing to go from virginia a year ago to alabama, to over 40 legislative special elections that democrats have picked up. We have a historic number of women on the ballot. They are organizing. This just puts some gasoline on a fire thats burning pretty hot anyway and were seeing nothing changing that. In fact, i was just in Washington State a couple of weeks ago, the weekend after the hearing. They had Record Number of canvassers this was still september canvassing that weekend women wrapping around the block wanting to canvas. Patrick, you said there are not a lot of winners in this kavanaugh episode, but republican intensity if you listen to President Trump yesterday he has seized on this. He believes this is a moment where he stood by the side of a man in his view unfairly accused and walked through fire. What happens to republican intensity . If you look at the rcp average a couple of weeks before this all started with judge kavanaugh, democratic intensity was 10 points and more, significantly in some polls. Were now seeing about 6 depending on the polling you look at. I think whats happened is both bases, unfortunately, are back alive. The base politics of this continues to be problematic. What does that mean . The ugly side of both ends of this thing tends to drive thoughtful dpriefrs the middle out of the process. This is ugly and nasty. When you see the way people are reacting to this i think what we got realize is between new york and california theres a big country out there. While each of these senate races are interesting to us and we look at the up and down what we have to think about is what does the average person, what do independent voters think . What do Younger Voters think. We talked about this off camera. Do people turn out or are they so turned off by this process that fewer people come out than we would like to have participate. Its a double edged sword. I cited an nbc poll with the stipulation that it was taken two months ago, in the summer before all this kavanaugh episode took place. Which showed millennials only 55 of millennials which is a huge voting block, 55 said they planned on voting in the fall and 16 of millennials said they were deeply involved in politics, that they were deeply interested in politics. Does that concern you given that millennials trend towards democrats . Well, whats interesting about the polls were seeing with millennials though the numbers are not where we want it in general, its higher than the previous midterms and youre talking about a huge population. Its the largest voting bloc right now if they choose to vote. An uptick of a couple points is a lot of votes. Theres also a lot of organizing going on on college campuses. Folks arent focused on whats going on the ground. Theres an active ground game going on. Again, i was with some younger women who are sort of in shock about what just happened with kavanaugh. They are digesting it. They are not sure what to do about all of this because does this mean i can i should not tell my story. I feel like im back in college. We cant go backwards. We have a choice here. There wasnt an election held on saturday. It was an appointment. A nomination. The election happens in november. We have a voice now. Its all about voting. I think were going to see, honestly i think well see one of the largest turn outs in Midterm Elections possibly in our lifetime. Yet weve always expected that the republicans, you know, they are pretty good voters in midterms. Its our side that doesnt always vote. What weve seen in the last 18 months is really high turn out among democrats and independent women are coming our way. Michael steel has a question. One thing that is curious to me, theres a lot of eye rolling amongst the boys and girls, the men and women. We look at polls showing this wide gap, this gulf really between the way men are seeing this president , this presidency, kavanaugh and the way women are. Im curious as to anyones fought as to what animates this difference . How does that translate into the turn out . You see the president trying to create a him too moment, sort of playing up white male victimhood in the face of these allegations. Does that further split this effort between men and women in terms of how they look at the election . How do you see that narrative playing itself out . You know, i think it certainly is a good point. The question becomes for most of us who is responding to polling data. As a fan of polling i thought for a long time we got this figured out. We all live and die by these polls. My problem is im suspect of polling as someone who has relied on polling my entire professional life based on what happened last time. Theres something about this president , theres something about this guy and the mood of our country which puts us ainu economic place. I think people underreport. Its not politically correct for many of Donald Trumps biggest followers to sort of tell you what they are really thinking. More importantly, i think theres a lot of people in this country who dont necessarily identify as strong trump voters, who dont talk about it because its not polite at a cocktail party, unkchl at the country club and not what you want to talk about at the faculty room at school. Theres a great amount of underreporting. I do believe what stephanie said, women are angry and highly motivated to come out and vote. Theres a lot of people in this country who saw the ugliness of this battle and its not as clear as that. I talk to women all the time who say yes it makes me angry but other things make me angry besides this. I do think women are very smart consumers, smarter than us gentlemen most of the time and very good at separating the wheat from the chaff. Stephanie, the democrats just lost big time in this kavanaugh fight on so many levels. Im curious to hear what you have to say, you say theres a lot going on out there. A lot of excitement. What is going on exactly . What is the universal unifying message for the democrats . Well, right now what weve seen for the last 18 months is really a desire to change the party in power, right. Folks say this election needs to be nationalized. The truth is this election is about donald trump and the Republican Party. Its a midterm. Voters will decide whether or not they like the direction of this Republican Party or not and what we have seen for the last 18 months is a strong absolutely not driven by women voters, the turn out of democratic women, and independent women coming our direction. I do not believe that anything that has happened over the kavanaugh hearings will change that trajectory. Keep in mind the electorate the 53 women or more, so this is a huge problem for the Republican Party. So i do know that women right now, a lot of women, not all women, were not all the same, but theres a lot of women right now who are taking a breath and trying to digest what happened over the weekend. But that doesnt mean they are stepping out. I think they are gathering their strength and were going to see something pretty extraordinary led by women and really fabulous women candidates who are running in historic numbers this november. Stephanie and patrick, thank you both for being on this morning. Still ahead, new reporting that during the 2016 election former Trump Campaign official rick gates solicited for a social Media Disinformation Campaign and it wasnt from russia. That is coming up on morning joe. At booking. Com, we cant guarantee youll find gold on your wild west vacation. But we can guarantee the best price on that thar rental cabin or any hotel, home, boat, yurt, whatever. Just dont get carried away with the wild west thing. Hey guys. Get the best price on homes, hotels and so much more. Booking. Com, booking. Yeah i have no idea how were going to get through this. Follow me. Unitedhealthcare has the people and tools to help guide you through the confusion, well that wasnt so bad at all. Thats how we like it. Unitedhealthcare. Thank you as well to our Deputy Attorney general Rod Rosenstein for being here. Flew down together. The press wants to know what did you talk about . [ laughter ] we had a very good talk, i will say. That became a very big story actually, folks. We had a good talk. We just had a very nice talk. We actually get along. And really good talk. I think well be treated very fairly. Everybody understands theres no collusion, no russia, all made up by the democrats. They are the ones that cluollud with russia. Just lies. Just lies. Just showering down on the president there, no collusion, no russia. There was collusion, there was an attempt at collusion. Its clearly out there. We already have the evidence, mr. President. I dont know if you know it but in this case youre the elm pmp without any clothes. We already have evidence that there was collusion. Was it illegal . We dont know. Certainly an attempt at collusion by you and your sons and everybody around you. Yeah, there was a lot of russia. No russia . What your even talking about . What planet do you think were from . Do you keep insulting your supporters and followers by saying no russia. Do you really think they are stupid . Remember you said the last 400 pound guy. Oh, wait hold on. The guy that you appointed your director of National Intelligence said it was russia. Guess what . The person you put in charge of the department of Homeland Security said yes there was russia interfering in the election. The fbi said, yes, there was russia interfering with the election. The cia, same conclusion. Guess what . The United States military, that you say you support, you support the military. Fill their intel tells you russia was involved as well. Yet you believe the word of Vladimir Putin, a kgb agent. You believe what the kgb agent says instead of everybody that you hired to run the Intel Community of the United States of america. So you trust putin, you trust the kgb, you just dont trust the United States military. Actually, guess what . There was collusion. There were attempts at collusion. And there was russia. Russia tried to interfere. You dont have to believe me. Please dont. Please dont because i know it hurts you. You might tweet a nasty tweet or something. Youll go crazy about that. Why dont you just talk to dan coats . You hired him. Right. Talk to dan coats. Guess what, you can talk to chris wray. You hired him. You can talk to kirstjen nielsen. Youre the one who hired her. Believe it or not in this case she said not only did russia try to interfere with american kird its an ongoing effort by Vladimir Putin and russia to interfere with american democracy and you say no russia, no russia. What . No russia where . Because when it comes to election, when it comes to your election, there was russia involved and you and your sons and your campaign staff, you guys were all so eager to hear from russia. You were monti hall with russia. Lets make a deal. I love it. Its like me eating Fried Chicken in my grandmas house in dalton, georgia. Grand marks i love it. Except in this case it was don jr. And trump tower. You mean the russia government has a representative that will come here that has bad news about Hillary Clinton . You mean we can work the enemy of the United States for our own political purposes, somebody who is trying interfere with american democracy . Not im going to call the fbi. I love it. Then you walk out together, mr. President. You said the russians were just interested in adoptions. It was about adoptions, mr. President. Oh, my god. You know, thats a great line, i guess. Except for the fact, mr. President , that it was a lie. And heres the thing that you should be really concerned about. You were the one who concocted the lie. The lawyers were on the ground because the lawyers would have told you, mr. President , dont do that. That suggest to prosecutors youre obstructing justice. But they werent there to warn you. So you dictated the letter to hope hicks. She sent it. And guess what . The lie was spread. The attempt to obstruct the truth got to the New York Times and then, of course, it fell apart, like a cheap suit just like that and we found out we found out that actually there was collusion. There was russia. There was an attempt. Now listen, we dont know if its against the law. We certainly dont know if russia had an impact on the 2016 election. I dont think they did. I think james comey did more than Vladimir Putin. But we do know this. Youre lying on the tarmac and when it comes to russia youve been lying for years. I just cant wait to find out one of these days what Vladimir Putin has on you. I know. Well be right back. Well be right back my name is elaine barber, and im a fiveyear cancer survivor. Surviving for five years is a big deal. I had so many people at ctca helping me find a way to go through the treatments. The reality of cancer is not everybody survives. At ctca, they have a huge celebrate life event. That was amazing, because the whole day was about all of the survivors. Im excited about my future. Visit cancercenter. Com to schedule an appointment now. Takes more than just investment advice. From insurance to savings to retirement, it takes someone with experience and knowledge who can help me build a complete plan. Brian, my certified financial planner™ professional, is committed to working in my best interest. I call it my comfortable future plan, and its all possible with a cfp® professional. Find your certified financial planner™ professional at letsmakeaplan. Org. Wat t. Rowe price, hundreds of our experts go beyond thesional numbers to examine Investment Opportunities firsthand. Like a biotech firm that engineers a patients own cells to fight cancer. This is strategic investing. Because your investments deserve the full story. T. Rowe price. Invest with confidence. This is moving day with the best inhome wifi experience and millions of wifi hotspots to help you stay connected. And this is moving day with Reliable Service appointments in a twohour window so youre up and running in no time. Show me decorating shows. This is staying connected with xfinity to make moving. Simple. Easy. Awesome. Stay connected while you move with the best wifi experience and twohour appointment windows. Click, call or visit a store today. Under Republican Leadership america is leadership, america is booming, america is thriving, america is winning, because we are finally putting america first. We are putting america first. And we have the best economy in the history of our country, the best. But if democrats take control, they will try to plunge our country into gridlock, poverty and chaos. And thats whats going to happen. Thats President Trump speaking over the weekend in kansas. Joining us now, senior political reporter dave leaventhal. Also with us, Fortune Magazine editor at large lee gallagher. We heard the president s case here. Historic lows on unemployment, 3. 7 , the lowest in half a century, the dow going through the roof as he got into office. What did you find . Donald trump likes to present himself as being the savior for the u. S. Economy. Make no mistake about it, there are plenty of places all across the country that are doing just fine right now. We wanted to go to cities that are struggling, places that feel theyve been left behind. That while other places may be benefitting from this economic boom, theyre failing right now and theyre failing on key issues like housing, education, infrastructure that are Critical Issues in this Midterm Election. The people dont really care whos in the white house. They just want washington to work for them and they feel Like Washington has done nothing but fail them. Was there a difference between when you set out to do this project, when you identified these communities and once you actually got on the ground consequential we heard th once you actually got on the ground, was it a lot worse than you imagined . In some cases. We identified these places which are representative of plenty of places across the country. When we got on the ground, what we found was a profound sense of hopelessness often times from people, but still hoping that things could get better for them. I think one particular story that we tell is about lumberton, north carolina. Thats been in the news recently because of hurricane florence, but theres almost this hurricane that people forgot about, hurricane matthew. So many of the folks we talked to for this piece said, man, two years ago things were bad and they never got better and now theyre even worse. Its that depth of despair that they have to say im still couch surfing two years after the fact. What is going to help me . Were a poor county. What are you going to do for us, washington . And the answer hasnt been forthcoming. This is a great series, a valuable series. Its also a series that could have been written 20 years ago, 30 years ago. We live in a country where, at least in my experience, i dont know anybody who would like to be born poor in america. Its always almost the same trilogy of items that keep them lacked into poverty. Its the lack of access to good education, health care and the most important word in america, jobs. So what do you hope will happen from this series . Or is it just another sort of take a look at whats still happening here in america. Youre absolutely correct that this is a series that has a sort of sad timelessness to it and could be written at any point in time during a year or in the past and sadly in the future too. In part, were publishing this because were on the eve of a critical Midterm Election and the issues that we write about in the series are Critical Issues in this Midterm Election. People have an opportunity to decide for themselves the direction of this country. Is Congress Going to be dominated by republicans . Is the house going to go to the democrats . We dont know yet, but the choice is going to be made soon. All of these places also said they felt like the political disconnect between them and washington is something that hurts them. We want to shine a light on these places to effectively show the country and also the politicians that represent these places that there are cities out there, there are communities out there that have deep, deep needs. Lee, whats going on in that youve got these grand statistics, 3. 7 unemployment, economy is growing, wall street is booming. Why arent republicans telling that story . What is it thats preventing them from getting into that narratives s as opposed to play the donald trump bright shiny object of the day game when there is a consistent narrative about the economy they could be running on this fall . I think everyone is running on the narrative that everything is doing great. The bright shiny object is this wonderful economy that the pthd president is taking credit for. Why arent we focusing on these economies and the other half . Never before has the economy been so divided in this way. The statistics are stunning. Things are going great if you are invested in the stock market, if you are a ceo of a corporation. But there are many, many people who are not participating at all in this. In fact, some are suggesting that we need new statistics to show that. We dont need to just focus on gdp and the stock market. I think things like this are really important. You are starting to see some attention being paid attention to some of these communities. Lets create innovation in places far away from silicon valley, places like kentucky. Theres no question this is a lost narrative. Youre right. The series abandoned in america is out today. Still ahead, Brett Kavanagh gets a seat on the Supreme Court and a rare apology from a president who never says sorry. But it wasnt the kind of apology you think. Plus, why democrats should avoid pinning their hopes on a big turnout from young voters. Morning joe is back in a moment. Voters. Morning joe is back in a moment was pregnant, inlaws were coming, a little bit of water, it really it rocked our world. I had no idea the amount of damage that water could do. We called usaa. And they greeted me as they always do. Sergeant baker, how are you . They were on it. It was unbelievable. Having insurance is something everyone needs, but having usaa now thats a privilege. Were the bakers and were usaa members for life. Usaa. Get your insurance quote today. So shark invented duo clean. While deep cleaning carpets, the added soft brush roll picks up large particles, gives floors a polished look, and fearlessly devours piles. Duo clean technology, corded and cordfree. Its a revolution in sleep. The new sleep number 360 smart bed is on sale now, from 899, during sleep numbers fall sale. It senses your movement, and automatically adjusts to keep you both comfortable. It even helps with this. So you wake up ready to put your pedal to the metal. Dont miss the final days of sleep numbers fall sale. The queen sleep number 360 c2 smart bed is now only 899. Plus, 24month financing on all beds. Ends sunday. Sleep number. Proven, quality sleep. I saw my leg did not look right. I landed. I was just finishing a ride. I felt this awful pain in my chest. I had a pe blood clot in my lung. I was scared. I had a dvt blood clot. Having one really puts you in danger of having another. My doctor and i chose xarelto®. Xarelto®. To help keep me protected. Xarelto® is a latestgeneration blood thinner thats. Proven to treat and reduce the risk of dvt or pe blood clots from happening again. In clinical studies, almost 98 of patients on xarelto® did not experience another dvt or pe. Xarelto® works differently. Warfarin interferes with at least 6 of your bodys natural bloodclotting factors. Xarelto® is selective, targeting just one critical factor. Dont stop taking xarelto® without talking to your doctor, as this may increase risk of blood clots. While taking, you may bruise more easily, or take longer for bleeding to stop. Xarelto® can cause serious, and in rare cases, fatal bleeding. It may increase your risk of bleeding if you take certain medicines. Get help right away for unexpected bleeding or unusual bruising. Do not take xarelto® if you have an artificial heart valve or abnormal bleeding. Before starting, tell your doctor about all planned medical or dental procedures and any kidney or liver problems. Learn all you can. To help protect yourself from another dvt or pe. Talk to your doctor about xarelto®. And my brother ray and i started searching for answers. vo when its time to navigate inhome care, follow that bright star. Because brightstar care earns the same accreditation as the best hospitals. And brightstar care means an rn will customize a plan that evolves with moms changing needs. woman because dad made us promise wed keep mom at home. vo call 8444brightstar for your free home Care Planning guide. [ beep ] first man is the best were going to the moon. Neil armstrong. Buzz aldrin. That is a big mother. Its gonna be a hell of a ride. [ dramatic music playing ] we got a bad fire. Theres no easy way to say this. Theyre gone, neil. We need you to be commander. We need to fail down here so we dont fail up there. What are the chances this is the last time the boys are gonna see you . 5. 4. 3. 2. First man. Rated pg13. Its a very scary situation where youre guilty until proven innocent. Due process. Due process. Due process. Due process. Due process dunch. Due process. I must state that you, sir, under historic scrutiny were proven innocent. Thank you. President trump yesterday declared an end to the scary time for Brett Kavanagh. Welcome back to morning joe. It is tuesday, october 9th. Along with joe, willie and me we have msnbc contributor mike barnicle, National Political correspondent for nbc news and msnbc and author of the book the red and the blue, the 1990s and the birth of political tribalism Steve Kornacki. Joe, my question to you is how on behalf of our nation, i want to apologize to brett and the entire kavanaugh family for the terrible pain and suffering you have been forced to endure. Those who step forward to serve our country deserve a fair and dignified evaluation, not a campaign of political and personal destruction based on lies and deception. You, sir, under historic scrutiny were proven innocent. Wow. Mike barnicle, usually that would be seen as so offensive for a president to use a Supreme Court swearingin after he had already been sworn in to score even more political points, divide the country even more, that there would be political repercussions. But every poll that has been coming out of the past week has shown just the opposite, that the president being tacky and behaving the way he has has done nothing but help. Well, were no longer surprised by his behavior, joe. Were just at least myself, i am constantly amazed and depressed at some of the things he says. Hes the president of the United States. He uses a faux swearing in of a Supreme Court justice who had been sworn in prior to last evening as a platform to go after the white male vote in this country and perhaps other votes just like that, akin to that. But the level of hypocrisy also is striking. We played the clip coming in to the segment about due process, due process, due process, and yet the president , you know, talking yesterday to the International Association of Police Chiefs sort of applauded stop and frisk, which is basically no due process. He goes out to he sets out to the country each and every day as weve said before to divide the country, not to try to unite the country as you alluded to. Its never occurred before in the presidency. Never. It was an incredibly strange and graceless moment and heres kavanaugh and what he said last night. Every american can be assured i will be an independent and impartial justice, devoted to equal justice under law. Although the Senate Confirmation process tested me, as it has tested others, it did not change me. My approach to judging remains the same a good judge must be an umpire, a neutral and impartial decider who favors no litigant or policy. A judge must be independent not interpret the interpret the law, not make the law. I have to say, its really hard to figure out which Brett Kavanaugh to believe. Do you believe the one in 2015 that was talking like that . Do you believe the one in 2018 that sounded like the right wings version of Hillary Clinton when he talked about right wing conspiracy, but this time Brett Kavanaugh talking about a left wing conspiracy . What about last night when Brett Kavanaugh decided to call out every single republican senator that was responsible for him getting through the process, getting through the Judiciary Committee . Was there a time since the man is on the Supreme Court for life, to figure out a way to extend an olive branch . Of course there was. But this is a graceless, tacky, trump era that republicans believe like Lindsey Graham that the way that you win is by being graceless, by showing absolutely no class, by refusing to turn the other cheek, and to ram victories down your opponents throats. And we will see in less than a month whether voters will reward them for that. That all really depends not on the republicans that come out, but the democrats who decide to stay home. If after two years of this democrats still decide to stay home, if after two years of this, women decide to stay home, if after two years of this, after charlottesville, after everything else, black Voters Decide to stay home, if after two years of being called breeders and rapists, mexicans and mexicanamerican and other hispanicamericans decide to stay home, well, then they and we get the government that we deserve. Steve kornacki, its hard to find any trend lines over the past week that dont overwhelmingly favor Republican Senate candidates. What can you tell us right now . Yeah. I mean especially when you say on the senate side. I think we have to go into the discussion of the senate just acknowledging the battleground there to begin with is already on trump territory largely. Its ten democrats trying to defend seats in trump states, one republican trying to defend a seat in a clinton state. The biggest movement, the most significant movement, potentially were seeing on the senate front the one that jumps out is tennessee. Tennessee was sort of this surprise target that emerged for democrats over the summer. Phil bredesen personally popular, former governor not too attached within his National Partys image. He got in the senate race and has led in the polls in spring and summer, nbc marist poll, but in the last week weve seen two separate polls in tennessee, one that shows him falling behind by five points, one that shows him behind by eight points. Theres another one thats sort of in the field there. Im very interested to see what the final is there. This is one of those when youre a democrat trying to stictch together as a path to a Senate Majority, tennessee was emerging as something close to an essential state for you, especially because some of the other big movement weve been seeing is in north dakota. North dakota is probably the single most vulnerable Democratic State on the map. Thats heidi hieitkamheitkamp. She fell behind 12 points last week. Again, if you lose a kavanaugh seat and youre democrats, at that point youve got to pick up in arizona. Thats doable. Youve got to pick up nevada. Thats doable. Then youre going to need a tennessee or a texas. And the reddest of the red states, whether youre talking about texas, tennessee, north dakota, youre right, something happened, the kavanaugh fight happened. And that was a battle that was on republican ground. That was like robert e. Lee sending his soldiers up pickets charge, except it was democrats over the past several weeks in those red, red states that were running straight up the hill into political gunfire. What do you think about the Washington Post article and the poll that they conducted yesterday that came out about the 46 or 66 of the most highly contested swing districts actually, 69, and i guess democrats had a fourpoint lead. Did democrats see that as positive news, or does that show perhaps some slippage there as well . They see it as positive news, but its very tough to know exactly what that number means. We dont have past polling from these 69 districts to show you they looked a couple years ago. It would be helpful if youre take an assortment from those 69 districts, id be curious to get the individual race number. One possibility there is, is there a handful of districts that republicans represent but that Hillary Clinton won in 2016, is there a handful of those districts thats potentially driving that number in sort of unevenly distributing the democratic strength . Im not quite sure what to make of it, except i think it speaks to the Bigger Picture, trend or story line, that i think weve always known with the house. That is in these metropolitan suburban areas of the country, right outside washington, d. C. , denver, kansas city, you know, southern california, new jersey. You cou the Democratic Energy there has been off the chart since day one of the Trump Administration. And i expect us to be seeing blue waves in these metropolitan areas around the country. The question, though, becomes is it a National Blue wave thats enough to get democrats past 23 seats, or does it just become a series of isolated metropolitan waves . Mitch mcconnell says republicans were, quote, literally you shouliteral ly under assault by protesters. First, here is bill karins with a check on the forecast. Good morning, mika. All eyes on hurricane mika. Its now up to a category 2, wind up to 100 miles an hour. In about 24 to 30 hours its going to be coming into north florida. Theres the center of the storm. There is florida. Its heading almost directly for panama city. Right now less than 400 miles away. The forecast path will update again at 11 00 east coast time. They have a category 3, 120 miles an hour winds and weakening as it goes through southern georgia. This would be a daytime landfall tomorrow between about 10 00 a. M. And 5 00 p. M. Thats when youll see the worst of the damage. Then the storm with 60 Miles Per Hour winds travels to 50 Miles Per Hour winds off north carolina. We could still see Power Outages scattered because of downed trees in areas of South Carolina and north carolina. Storm surge is typically the most deadly portion of these storms. 812 between cedar key and apalachicola. Our thoughts are with them as theyre evacuating and getting out of town. This is tomorrow 4 00 p. M. , 125 miles an hour winds at the coast. On the backside, 88. Its a small, exact storm. But whoever gets it, youre going to see thats almost catastrophic damage to roofs and trees all through this area. Well watch this for you and give you updates throughout the day. Washington, d. C. , it looks like you could get a little bit of rain from this storm as we go through thursday. But a lot of the worst winds will stay to your south in the carolinas. It was always our singular focus, a distinct determination. To do whatever it takes, use every possible resource. To fight cancer. And never lose sight of the patients were fighting for. Our Cancer Treatment specialists share the same vision. Experts from all over the world, working closely together to deliver truly personalized cancer care. Specialists focused on treating cancer. Using advanced technologies. And more precise treatments than before. Working as hard as we can doing all that we can for everyone who walks through our doors. This is Cancer Treatment centers of america. And these are the specialists were proud to call our own. Treating cancer isnt one thing we do. Its the only thing we do. Expert medicine works here. Learn more at cancercenter. Com Cancer Treatment centers of america. Appointments available now. They wont hike your ratest foover one mistake. See, Liberty Mutual doesnt hold grudges. For drivers with accident forgiveness Liberty Mutual wont raise their rates because of their first accident. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty cal we saved our money and now, we get to spend it our way. Valerie but we worry if we have enough to last. Cal ellen, our certified financial planner™ professional, helps us manage our cash flow and plan for the unexpected. Valerie her experience and training gave us the courage to go for it. Its our confident forever plan. Cal . And its all possible with a cfp® professional. Find your certified financial planner™ professional at letsmakeaplan. Org. You can do things like change your settings, learn tips and tricks, troubleshoot, and even manage your account. Finding your Xfinity Username or wifi password, restarting your equipment, or paying your bill is easier than ever with x1. X1 help. Another reason to love x1. Say teach me more into your voice remote to get started. One guy who was incredibly energized by the confirmation of Brett Kavanagh is Senate Majority leader Mitch Mcconnell. He spoke in his home state of kentucky yesterday where he said how proud he is of the Republican Caucus for not being intimidated by protests against kavanaugh. We were literally under assault. These demonstrators, im sure some of them were wellmeaning citizens, but many of them are obviously trained to get in our faces, to go to our homes up there, to basically almost attack us in the halls of the capitol. Thats a theme youll be hearing. The Washington Post reporting, republicans believe they can channel their supporters outrage into a winning issue by recasting democrats as an angry mob over the recent protests and what they perceive as the mistreatment of Brett Kavanagh. The radical democrats have turned into an angry mob. Angry, left wing mob, thats what theyve become. They have encouraged mob rule. I hope we can say no to mob rule. Those who tried to over turn the rule of law and replace it with mob rule lost. Ive never been more pissed in my life. Im really proud of my members for not buckling under those moblike tactics. We want to bring in now from washington, the author of the New York Times news letter on politics, with lisa lara, lisa is with us. Good to have you on this morning, lisa. Give us your reaction to the display at the white house last night and what are you hearing in terms of how people in washington are reacting to it . Well, i think we have to break down a little bit whats happening here. What happened for weeks and weeks, republicans saw this huge Enthusiasm Gap in their midterm polling and you would talk to republican pollsters and they would say theres a 12point gap in how excited democrats are to vote and how excited. Republicans are to vote. That was not a good thing. They were concerned about it. The kavanaugh confirmation fight started happening and they saw that gap close up and we got to sort of an equal place between republicans and democrats. Then Something Else happened, which is that republicans won the fight. Everyone knows that losers are more energized to vote than winners. Grievance out beats out gratitude at the polls every time. This is part of republicans trying to keep that sense of grievance, that sense of fight going, for the next 28 days. You know, theyre taking a little bit of a victory lap and thats deserved. They won this huge goal of getting a conservative majority on the highest court for a generation. But the fact is that they won. So i wonder, it feels like it will be a little difficult to maintain the sense of grievance for the next 28 days. 28 days in politics is a long time. Lisa, let me just push that a little bit because usually that works, usually thats the way sort of the aggrieved side ends up being able to raise money and develop enthusiasm, but in this case, theres a lot of grievance the way republicans feel the way kavanaugh was treated isnt this the number one thing this they are looking for is to name Supreme Court justices and get them through. I would think this could be a nightmare scenario for democrats . Yes. It is the number one thing that theyre looking for from the president and, of course, the president he did it. It was a big accomplishment. Of course the president s base loves this about him, hes a fighter and sticks it to everybody all the time. Dont forget that democrats also are very aggrieved about this. I was in michigan yesterday and i sort of one thing i wondered whether democrats could be any more energized than they are already, particularly democratic women, i was talking to activists in that state they were wondering the same thing and the fight over kavanaugh has supersonic charged their efforts. They are seeing more engagement. Yeah. From women and there is this historic gender gap and independent women will matter, particularly in those suburban districts that house districts we were talking about. Its energizing on both sides. Coming up, enthusiasm doesnt exactly feel like the word youd associate with the bitter fight over the Supreme Court. But thats the marker when it comes to how Brett Kavanaghs confirmation might impact the midterms. Well see which party has the edge, next on morning joe. S t edge, next on morning joe. [narrator] its a difficult conversation, but an important one. How do you plan on taking care of your final expenses . A guaranteed whole Life Insurance policy from united of omaha Life Insurance company, a mutual of omaha company, will help. The expenses after someone dies, those that we incurred with my motherinlaw, it was expensive. [narrator] our guaranteed whole life policies provide 2,000 to 25,000 in cash benefits. And with some of the most affordable premiums available, rest assured youll get the right policy at a price that fits your budget. It would certainly make me feel better knowing that you dont have that additional pain to go through. [narrator] acceptance is guaranteed for people aged 45 to 85. Coverage begins immediately. And most claims are paid within 24 hours. Dont go another day without coverage. Click or call for your free quote at the number on your screen. soft piano music hundred roads named park in the u. S. Its americas most popular street name. But allstate agents know thats where the similarity stops. If youre on park street in reno, nevada, the high winds of the Washoe Zephyr could damage your siding. And thats very different than living on park ave in sheboygan, wisconsin, where ice dams could cause water damage. But no matter what park you live on, one of 10,000 local allstate agents knows yours. Now that you know the truth, are you in good hands . And i am a certified arborist for pg e. Ughes i oversee the patrolling of trees near power lines and roots near pipes and underground infrastructure. At pg e wherever we work, we work hard to protect the environment. Getting the job done safely, so we can keep the lights on for everybody. Because i live here i have a deeper connection to the community. And i want to see the Community Grow and thrive. Every year we work with cities and schools to plant trees in our communities. So the environment is there for my kids and future generations. Together, were building a better california. What the kavanaugh experience has done is gotten republicans excited. Fox news reported over the weekend that the Enthusiasm Gap has closed by about eight points. Its almost even now. Our Online Fundraising has skyrocketed. While the saga to confirm Brett Kavanagh to the Supreme Court they finally be over, the outrage over his appointment is beginning to catch fire over the Political Landscape. Our next guest writes that both sides of the aisle are intent on making the kavanaugh appointment a rallying cry for their side. Joining us now, New York Times reporter Jeremy Peters. Jeremy, what are you hearing beyond capitol hill on the reaction not just to this appointment but to the ceremony last night and moving forward politically in terms of how they plan to use this contentious nomination as a Political Tool . I think, mika, last nights remarks by trump that kavanaugh was proven innocent, as he said, just a classic example of the president trying to rewrite history on his own, more favorable terms. I think its statements like that that have really energized the left to the point where, you know, they have linked trump to the kavanaugh confirmation battle in a way that he wasnt before. Because this was a debate and gender and equality and the treatment of women and bheefing s believing survivors of Sexual Assault that was unfolding with trump kind of large lly as a side character. Then he opened his mouth, he opened it twice, when he started attacking Christine Blasey ford, when he said yesterday that this is all a hoax and a fraud and made up language weve heard all sorts of times before about allegations leveled at trump himself, and that feeds the sense more broadly that the Republican Party is being dismissive and disparaging of women like those who came forward, like dr. Ford. You know, lisa, weve seen the first sort of the first wave of political reaction that was from republicans on the defensive and then going on the offensive trying to defend Brett Kavanaugh and getting him over the finish line, but youve got to believe if the last year and a half is any indication of how politics in america works, there will be a counter offensive from the very groups that jeremy just brought up, the very groups, the women voters in virginia that helped elect a governor, women voters in alabama that helped elect the first democratic senator there since the early 1990s, youve got to believe that that counterattack is coming . Right. I think thats right. Thats exactly right and a really good point. What we have seen is a sustained burst of enthusiasm among the Democratic Party and the grassroots and democratic voters. This level of enthusiasm is something thats been going on for, well, really since the president won. I actually have a question for my colleague if i can throw it back to jeremy, a question im asking a lot myself, we know the president s base is solidly behind him, but is that enough to get them over the hump in these midterms . Like whats your gauge of the level of enthusiasm there from all your reporting on these various races . Right. You know, as we were talking about before, lisa, voters dont come out in midterms to say thank you. Right. I think thats a real concern among republicans that the confidence and the enthusiasm that exists right now dissipate four weeks from today and that energy on the left matches and exceeds that of the energy on the right. In the piece that i wrote today, one of the things that we tried to look at very carefully, how are republicans in house races, in close competitive house races responding to this, what you find from dave brat in virginia to roskam in the suburbs of chicago and elsewhere in the in these suburban races, republican incumbent house members are not talking about this. Who else isnt talking about this, martha mcsally, the republican nominee in arizona for senate, dean heller, the incumbent senator republican in nevada. They dont want to get near the kavanaugh confirmation because its such a toxic issue with the types of voters they need in the these purple states. Thats a sign of the difficulty here republicans have in threading the needle. Do they spike the football over kavanaugh or approach it with more delicacy . Coming up, its not the type of response democrats are hoping for. Were with nbc news. Is anybody here going to vote in the election on november 6th. Anybody . Anybody . Nobodys going to vote. Of course, thats just one snapshot in a larger picture. A look at what some california students think or dont think about the Upcoming Elections. K about the Upcoming Elections vo this is not a video game. This is not a screensaver. This is the destruction of a cancer cell by the bodys own immune system, thanks to medicine that didnt exist until now. And today can save your life. Somebody left a note on my door the other day. It said ted cruz, tough as texas. I mean, come on. If somebody called my wife a dog and said my daddy was in on the kennedy assassination, i wouldnt be kissing their ass. You stick a finger in their chest and give them a few choice words. Or you drag their ass out by the woodshed and kick their ass, ted. Come on, ted. Oh my god. Really i had somebody tell me earlier that wasnt that good of an ad. Its a great ad. I dont know. Maybe im just a red neck but thats exactly what ive said off screen. If somebody insulted my family, i wouldnt be kissing their butt the way that ted cruz has for the past couple of years. That aint texas. I dont care what anybody says. This isnt about politics, at least from the south i was born and raised in, that aint right, the way hes been kissing up to a man who insulted his wife. That aint right. And insulted his daddy. Were a long way from the Republican Convention in cleveland where ted cruz was up there getting booed. Hes come all the way around on President Trump since he became president. The ad points out how the senator has aligned himself with President Trump despite trumps repeated insults aimed at cruz and his family during the campaign. The ad featured the actor Sonny Carl Davis as the character he portrayed in bernie. The state already has set a record with nearly 15. 7 million registrations in this years midterms. Some people saying a taylor swift effect. Vote. Org says they were up 65,000 registrations nationwide since taylor swift said she was voting for two democrats in her home state of tennessee. Registrations in tennessee were up by more than 2,000. Joe, donald trump after hearing about taylor swifts endorsement said i like her music 25 less now. That was his quote. Im not sure how much he liked it to begin with, so that could be a lot or a little, depending. Yeah. Im sure that shattered taylor. So she got a lot of people out to vote apparently from vote. Org. Look what you made me do. There you go. Thats for my kids. Its really interesting that you like that . Its really interesting that i had somebody tell me last night that ted cruz ad was not that good. That was somebody that was a yankee from new york city. Because i can guarantee you that speaks to i dont know if it moves a vote or not, but it certainly would speak again to the south that i knew where somebody insulting your wife or somebody insulting your father would not go over very well. I thought it was a very effective ad. Tough as texas. Hes not tough as texas. He snivels in Donald Trumps shadow. Well, well see if it moves voters. Hes doing okay in the polls. Were going to hop over to california. Jacob soboroff is here. What did you find out . I think that guy in that ad could beat any candidate running in the United States of america right now. Thats sort of part of the problem with what we saw in california. Most people think california is uber liberal. Those people have not been to Orange County where there are four districts that are republican held. I think they have a lot of work on their hands. Watch this, you guys. Los angeles, downtowns Union Station probably isnt where youd think to start a quest to find some of the most traditionally republican territory in america. The biggest county in america is also one of its more diverse and democratic. But if you take a short train ride south, the politics can seem a world apart. Used to be that when you were going from l. A. To Orange County, you crossed through what political pundits would call the orange curtain because you go from a democratic area into a republican area. This year back in washington, democrats are hoping thats changing. So you all live in Orange County . Yes. If you watch the news, all you hear about is Brett Kavanagh. Thats all you hear about. Its hard to think about Something Else and all you hear is about kavanaugh. Do you think thats what youre going to be thinking about when you go into the polling booth on election day . I hope not. What things would you rather be thinking about . Traffic and pollution. We hopped off the train in irvine so we could carpool with the rest of our team. Democratic support hinges on turning out people of color and young voters, at least in part. We headed to the university of california campus. In and out burger. What do people care about in irvine . Myself and a lot of my friends are minorities. Were a lot into like minority rights and stuff. Are there enough of you to flip the district . I hope so. There are about 26,000 kids that go to school here at uc irvine. If the democrats can get them to vote for them, then maybe republicans will be in trouble in this district, but i dont know. Not to be annoying, but were with nbc news. Is anybody here going to vote in the election on november 6th . Anybody . Anybody . Nobodys going to vote . Is anybody going to vote in the Congressional Election in november . You are. Thank you. Sir. What do you care about . School. What about you . So if you were going to vote, what is the thing thats going to get your vote . Probably school and expenses. Youre not talking about the issues that people talk about on the news, the russia investigation. I dont watch news. You dont watch that stuff. Are you registered to vote . Not yet. How old are you . 18. This could be your first election. Yeah. Ultimately you could decide whether or not the house of representatives is in democratic or republican control. Are you thinking about all that . Not currently. Maybe if i took more time to get informed about whats going on right now in politics. I assume that the people voting have at least some idea who theyre voting for. Are you going to vote . I should. Were like the most unreliable voter demographic. I should vote to increase those numbers. Thats what the democrats want. But they cant count on you guys, necessarily . No. Better vote. All the old people are telling us to vote. Oh, am i old . No. Older. Sorry. Dude. Once you have a kid, youre old unfortunately. So joe, earlier i was watching you and you were saying how the democrats were failing miserably to connect with people across the country. I spoke to the secretary of state in california. We have automatic Voter Registration in california. The Number One Party people are opting into is no Party Preference at all. Both of these parties are failing miserably to sign people up. You know, i had younger kids, younger people in my district. Always asking why i only advertised on talk radio when i did radio, why didnt i advertise on stations that Younger Voters listen to. And i said you dont vote. I could do it, but id be wasting my money. Im here to talk to you to try to get you to vote, but it is remarkable that these students that have crushing debt, that are going to have crushing debt when they get out of college, that have crushing debt from what the federal governments dumping on them, that are growing up in an america that could be radically different than what they expected, that they remain just as disengaged today as always. Not only, that but these four contiguous districts in Orange County are all within striking distance for the democrats. If these young voters chose to tune in, they could literally be the ones theres 26,000 of them at uc irvine alone to actually flip the district. But theyre more concerned with the issues they think about when they wake up. A lot of times when you watch whats going on in washington, d. C. , they feel like they dont have faith in our institutions. When they see Brett Kavanagh yelling or Christine Blasey ford and feel like her story doesnt get through, i feel like they dont feel like they have an incentive to get up and actually go to the polls. Yeah. Same as it ever was as far as young voters go. It is impossible to get young voters out at a high level. This year the big question is for democrats are they going to be able to get out hispanic voters, black voters, Younger Voters and other demographic groups that should be flooding out in support of them. Yeah. Thats going to be the ongoing issue over the next three weeks as early voting has started now in many states around the country. So thats a separate turnout effort from what you do on the ground election day. The other piece of that and what is so, i think, poignant and important about jacobs piece is these voters, if they had something exciting to get them to the polls, theres still no guarantee that would do it. Theres just something about Younger Voters when it comes to the Civic Responsibility of voting and participation that they just dont connect to. And both parties, quite honestly, as much as democrats talk about it, the runup to that evide effort on election day is not as effective as theyd like to brag. Both parties fail miserably at it. Nbc news poll from august, only 55 of millennials, a huge voting bloc say they intend to go out and vote in the Midterm Elections. Thats surprising, because companies are falling all over themselves to get millennial employees. One of the things they care most about are social issues. I think one way to connect with them is music. I dont know the demographic of those new registrations we saw after taylor swift. But that is where a lot of these young voters connect. You go to where they are and they sign up. Will they vote . Thats another question. You can certainly understand that, though. Sure, they like eddie veddar and taylor swift and like the music, but they dont like what they hear out of washington. Theyre not going to vote. They dont like what they hear. Right. 100 . Theres nothing else to say other than politicians in washington at some point have to realize that fighting with each other is turning people off all across the country. If it doesnt stop, these young people will never go out to vote, many of them. Jacob soboroff, thank you very much. Lee, thank you as well. Up next, to those calling for term limits on the Supreme Court, our next guest says welcome aboard, because hes been making that argument for decades. E hes been making that argument for decades. My love has come along my lonely days are over at last. Applebees new neighborhood pastas. Now thats eatin good in the neighborhood. Every road in the world is now an information superhighway. And the car has become an accessory to the smartphone. Ride hailing, car sharing carpooling. Mobility services are proliferating. And theres a new generation who dont seem to want to own cars in the first place. It all means massive disruption to the car industry, cities, businesses and investors. My mom was freedom, and my dad, adventure. They baptized me in mud and christened me on rock, so i got tougher. They fostered a love of learning, so i got smarter. Taught me to appreciate the finer things in life, so i became more civilized and refined. Thank you, freedom and adventure, for giving me this rugged, civilized, wandering soul. For giving me this rugged, civilized, [ beep ] first man is the best were going to the moon. Neil armstrong. Buzz aldrin. That is a big mother. Its gonna be a hell of a ride. [ dramatic music playing ] we got a bad fire. Theres no easy way to say this. Theyre gone, neil. We need you to be commander. We need to fail down here so we dont fail up there. What are the chances this is the last time the boys are gonna see you . 5. 4. 3. 2. First man. Rated pg13. Takes more than just investment advice. From insurance to savings to retirement, it takes someone with experience and knowledge who can help me build a complete plan. Brian, my certified financial planner™ professional, is committed to working in my best interest. I call it my comfortable future plan, and its all possible with a cfp® professional. Find your certified financial planner™ professional at letsmakeaplan. Org. Find your certified financial planner™ professional. Ancestrydna can pinpoint where your ancestors are from. And the paths they took, to a new home. Could their journey inspire yours . Order your kit at ancestrydna. Com. When the guy in frontd down the highway slams on his brakes out of nowhere. You do, too, but not in time. Hey, no big deal. Youve got a good record and Liberty Mutual wont hold a grudge by raising your rates over one mistake. You hear that, karen . Liberty mutual doesnt hold grudges. How mature of them. For drivers with accident forgiveness Liberty Mutual wont raise their rates because of their first accident. Liberty mutual insurance. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty joining us now, former clerk to Supreme Court justice thorough thorou thoroughgood marshal. His new book is invisible. The forgotten story of the black woman lawyer who took down americas most powerful mobster. Stephen carter, when want to get your take on the confirmation battle we just saw with Brett Kavanaugh. You argue in a recent opinion piece entitled the Supreme Court needs term limits that more vacancies would make the confirmation process less vicious. Tell us more about that. Well, first of all, the kavanaugh process was so sad on so many levels. I dont think anybody was happy with it. One of the reasons i think we fight so hard is you look at the number of 54 decisions the Supreme Court reaches. Those are going up. The more those decisions go up, the more valuable each seat is, each vacancy. Vacancies dont come around very often. We fight over them because there arent many of them. If you have more vacancies, theres less to fight over. If you lose one, theres always one the next year. Moreover, you also know whoever you confirm, youre not confirming for 30 years or 40 years, youre confirming for nine years. Which interestingly, is about the time that us judges served in the early years of the republic. And you know, stephen youre exactly right. Thats why the arguments are so vicious. You always hear people saying this is for a lifetime appointment. This election could be on the court 25, 30 years. If suddenly thats nine years, youre right, that defuses the process. Also, you talk about strategic retirements. Im reminded of that moment early on in 2000 when the election returns were coming in. Somebody quoted Sandra Day Oconnor turning to her husband and sighing and say, well, i guess well have to stay in washington for four more years. Started with a lot of how these justices think. Ruth Bader Ginsburg is not going to retire until donald trump leaves town. I think unfortunately thats right. Justices like the rest of us sit around and make these political qualificationings. All of us would rather live in a world in which they didnt. Unfortunately, its not the world we have. Yes. Mike barnicle. How would it work . Rotating three justices at a time, the term limits nine years . My idea, the ideal, would be actually to have nineyear terms and one justice appointed every year. People say wouldnt that mean thered be a big fight every year . I think there would be a big fight every year. What youd have instead is people realizing its not that important because its only nine years and theres another one next year. Entitled invisible, the forgotten story of the black woman lawyer who took down americas most powerful lobster. I suspect im not alone there. But also a deeply personal story to you. So unis carter, the woman the book is about, was the granddaughter of slaves and in the 1930s when no one was doing anything like this, she was an extraordinary woman. She was a prosecutor in new york. Who came up with the legal story that put Lucky Luciano in prison. In a dition to that, she was an early feminist. In the early 30s talking about Sexual Harassment including the treatment of women in the workplace by their male superiors back when that wasnt even a word, when no one had even thought of those things. And she is also your . Shes also my grandmother. Its a story i heard about in bits and pieces when i was growing up. But i fever really understood quite how extraordinary and rare and brave she was. You have to imagine, in the 1930s, the special prosecute effort for organized crimes, thomas dewy, later ran for president , he hired these 20 lawyers. The press called them 20 against the underworld. Theres 19 white males and one black woman who was my grandmother. And then in the office, they seat her all the way down at the end of a long hallway, by herself, away from everyone else, dont give her any important work to do and shes still the one that came up with the theory that put him in jail. How did that happen . How did she gain the entree to be considered for a job . I know its hard to think of today, black people overwhelmingly voted republican. We forget in the 1930s, 1940s, the Republican Party was actually the party of civil rights. Of beAbraham Lincoln. The Democratic Party was the party of segregationists at the time. I know its not that way anymore. Im saying thats the way it was then. And so she moved in republican circles in new york. There were stories that dewy was looking for a woman to hire but no one thought he was going to hire a black one, especially one who had only been out of law school at the time i think for four years. Mika. You also wrote a piece about what your grandmother would think of what was happening today pertaining to Brett Kavanaugh. What would she have said . So her response would have been complex. At first, i mentioned before, my grandmother was a big republican back in the days when black people were overwhelmingly republicans. She was a big republican. At first, she would have been in favor. But she was also as i said, she was an early feminist. She gave a speech in 137, for example, about women and the way theyre mistreated in the workplace, the way men press them for sexual favors and other things. She said boiling oil is too good for those men. She campaigned constantly for the rights of women in the workplace. I think with the actual facts of what happened, she would at the very least would have demanded a much more detailed investigation than we actually got. If that investigation wasnt forthcoming, i think she probably would have broken with the party and ended up in opposition. It would not have been the first time she broke with a party on a moment of principle. The book is invisible, the forgotten story of the black woman lawyer who took down americas most powerful mobster. Professor stephen l. Carter, thank you, congratulations on the book. Good to see you. Great pleasure, thank you. Couple minutes here for final thoughts as we head into another day here. Another day here. A lot of people looked at what happened last night and may think that america cant go on. This is the worst breach in etiquette, in constitutional norms yet. Well, america can go on. We have a way to counterbalance. Its called registering to vote and then going out and voting. Right now, there is no doubt democrats need to understand, donald trump has had the best week or two of his presidency just over the past couple of weeks. Right now, hes got the wind at his book for the first time id say in a year or so. If democrats want to challenge donald trump, theyre going to have to work hard. Well, at the beginning of this really ugly process, i just felt in my gut, i said it out loud, this is exactly what donald trump wants. And he got it. And i think the democrats handed it to him. And so did the media. And he won. Mike barnicle. Theres a lot going on with donald trump as we know every day, multiple times a day. The front page of the New York Times today is about another issue. Its a front page story, seeking mercy from the u. S. At 2 years old. A story of about a 2yearold who was in federal Immigration Court yesterday trying to find out if a judge will either deport her, give her a guarantee of asylum or reunite her with her parents. This is in the United States of america today, a 2yearold. Watching the president last night, he feels he had a victory on two fronts. On the one hand, he got his second Supreme Court justice in just 20 months. Open the other hand, he believes what the process revealed about his opponents will help him in the midterms. Unemployment at 3. 7 . Stock market as high as its been. 8 07 p. M. All that really matters, right . Dig deep, one more time, thats all we need. A good start from c. C. All right. Whatever that means. Okay. That does it for us this morning. Stephanie ruhle picks up the coverage right now. Thanks so much, mika. Good morning, everyone, im stephanie ruhle. Starting with day one. Brett kavanaugh set to hear his first argument as a Supreme Court justice this morning after last nights primetime swearing in ceremony. Judge kavanaugh, emotional, after being sworn in, promising to be independent and impartial, while President Trump promising no such thing. Instead, apologizing to his nominee o