Transcripts For MSNBCW Morning Joe 20180312

Matt, maybe after you talk to bob mueller you wont think its quite so easy. Thats President Trump stumping for a candidate that he reportedly trashes in private. Hes doubling down on everything. On all of these headspinning policy decisions, hes doubling down on his attacks against the media. Hes doubling down on his attacks against Hillary Clinton. Hes doubling down on his inflated margins of victory in 2016. In short, just another day at the office. Good morning and welcome to morning joe. Its monday, march 12th. With us, we have got veteran columnist and msnbc contributor mike barnacle. Noah rothman, columnist and associated editor for the washington post, David Ignatius. Also Nbc News National Political reporter heidi prison bella will be with us shortly and mika is out. She is feeling a bit under the weather. You know, theres so much to talk about, but David Ignatius, i think the take away from this speech is that there was Donald Trumps worst instincts coming out, the very things that concern me the most that i dont think concern a lot of people in middle america. But its a trashing of constitutional norms. In this speech specifically, you had him attacking a member of the media by name. Encouraging the audience to boo that member of the media. And then you had him praising dictators and actually discouraging this crowd that he just encouraged to boo a member of the free press, discouraging them from booing kim jongun. It was vintage donald trump. Joe, i thought he was almost trashing the traditional role of president in that little clip that we saw, making fun of the orderly conduct of power, the dignity and behavior we associate with the president of the United States, likening that to atomton marching around like a penguin. No, with donald trump you have something different. You sited some of the points. You have inflammatory kind of rabble rousing we used to say speeches. You have attacks on the media which i think should really worry people. Hes direct, offcolor attacks on members of the media. And you have a president who has decided the things that people criticize that are seen as destabilizing, as upsetting the system are the things that he prizes. Thats what he wants to do. Youre right. He is doubling down. Hes saying this is the kind of president that i want to be. Well see if he loses this race tomorrow in pennsylvania and we sure saw it in this speech. We certainly did. And thats what the president was in western pennsylvania for. Theres a special election tomorrow in pennsylvania 18. It is a seat just in case you havent kept up with it that the republicans always win by 15 the 20 points. Donald trump won it by almost 20 points just a year ago, a year and a half ago. And the last republican to run, i believe he was unopposed but usually wins by 20 percentage points. Paint this district red all the time, but right now once again we have a republican who should easily be coasting to victory in big trouble. Here is more from the president s rally for rick saccone. President xi, president for life. I was joking and i said, huh, president for life, that sounds good. Maybe were going to have to try that. President for life. But im joking. But im joking. South korea came to my office after having gone to north korea and seeing kim jongun. No, its very positive. No. After the meeting you may do that, but now we have to be very nice because lets see what happens. That washington, d. C. , got a lot of evil there, but were getting it out. Step by step. Lot of evil. Lot of bad people. Lot of bad people. Lot of fake media. Look at them. Lot of fake media. Fake, fake media. Its 1999. Im on meet the press, a show now headed by sleepy eyes chuck todd. Hes a sleeping son of a bitch. Ill tell you. You know he likes to put names on people. He did that through the entire president ial election, including all the republicans that he beat. So, these are Campaign Rallyishes. This is something at a Campaign Rally and the president likes making funny names. If were to dismiss everything he says at a Campaign Rally, as i think youre trying to imply, then are you saying we should cover these things . Youre putting words in my mouth. I wasnt in any way saying you should dismiss that whatsoever and you should obviously carry them because these are important moments for the president and this is news. What im trying to say is, im focussed on the policies. Well, you know, the president likes funny names. Mike barnacle, he actually talked about the fake media. He got people booing. The booing is getting stronger by the day when ever he goes out there and whips up like its a mussolini rally. Yes, thats what i said. There is certainly nothing american about what donald trump did in pennsylvania when he tries to turn an entire audience, whether its against katy tur or chuck todd and this weekend he went after maggie haberman. When youre in rallies like that and you whip your supporters into a frenzy, there are real life consequences to that. Threats follow, often death threats. And that is actually, mike, unfortunately thats exactly what he wants. Well, joe, i mean, his constant attacks over many, many months and days, including many, many months and days as president of the United States theyve worked. Theyve had an impact on this country. Theyve had an impact on people. Theyve changed the way people think about the news that they read or the news that they see. Thats one thing thats certainly happened. But in that clip that we just showed he was talking about washington, d. C. And he said theres lots of evil in washington, d. C. Lots of bad people. And president of the United States has injected successfully a slow poison into the culture of this country. I dont know what the impact is going to be years down the road, but i do know that one of the things we tuought to be worried about is the damage that hes already done to the presidency. And we should be worried about how lasting is it and can it be repaired. Yeah. When he said, you know, i could be president ial just look at me be president ial sort of mocking, as david said, president ial behavior. Hes saying impulse control is easy. I would love to do that. I would love to see impulse control just to demonstrate youre capable of it. Hes in pennsylvania now speaking to this audience because of his lack of impulse control. The reason this is a competitive race and likely to see some democratic victories in november is because of donald trump. Its not because of the economy. The economy is humming. Its got room to run. Its not because of Foreign Policy. Theres some troubles abroad, but we dont have a lot of bodies coming home of american soldiers, thats why people vote on a Foreign Policy election. This is a values election. This is a referendum on donald trump and his behavior. Behavior like that is precisely why voters will go to the polls to register their dissatisfaction with this president. I sat there looking at the rally, looking at clips of the rally and was thinking the same thing that again donald trump always rightfully accuses the media of being in a bubble. But nobody is in a bigger bubble than donald trump because he goes to these rallies where he finds people who like him and he speaks to that 33 . But everything he did in that speech offended, educated suburban voters in the pittsburgh suburbs that will be voting in this election. A lot of what he did offended a lot of women as he does everyone of the speeches offends a lot of women. There was a New York Times article yesterday talking about how trump support is falling among evangelical women, significantly, 13 over a short time period. All of the rabble rousing that david was talking about. Noah, it gets him big cheers. He used to like to brag that he was, you know, the biggest show on earth that didnt carry around a guitar or play a piano, often likening himself to elton john in these venues, and hes getting that feedback, but youre exactly right. He is the one that is helping elect people like conor lamb or keeping races close in pennsylvania 18 that republicans should have locked up weeks ago. And you mentioned the coalition movement, which is really key here. Hes definitely courting this whiteworking class base that help prod pel him to victory in 2016, but the reciprocal side of that is that College Educated voters, women, et cetera, in the suburbs are moving away from republicans, moving away from donald trump. This is only going to exacerbate that tension. Its one of those things that you would like to see republicans who are interested in electoral victories say, look, this is a bad deal. We are still enthralled to this 2016 myth about Donald Trumps coalition because nobody saw it coming. After november, if they really get hit at the polls hard, that 33, 38 whatever it is going to look more like 38 and its not going to be the tiger that we make it out to be. Thank you so much for using the word most relevant about this myth. There has been this myth around donald trump since he got elected in november. And the myth has grown that somehow everything that he did worked perfectly. And somehow thats going to work in the future. Ive said it 1,000 times. It happened in 2016. It was a fluke. Even donald trump himself told me one time he could have had the election 20 times and that is the one day he would have won. And its insane. Hes focussed on one demographic, white, workingclass voters. Hes offending a lot of other demographics he needs to win elections and he is doing exactly the opposite of what we were criticizing Hillary Clinton of doing last fall in the home stretch where she was ignoring White Working Class voters. I mean, youve got to have the entire coalition. And, if youre helping White Working Class voters but youre losing College Educated republicans, youre losing republican women, youre starting to lose republican evangelicals, you certainly wont have them vote for Hillary Clinton over you but you will keep them home in Midterm Elections, then you really are sealing your own fate. Lets go right now to mt. Lebanon, pennsylvania, and go to von hilliard. Theres so much to talk about. They are reporting this morning that donald trump is trashing actually rick saccone the republican candidate he went out to support. If donald trump is trashing rick saccone, he would not be alone. It appears the entire Republican Party in washington, d. C. Seems to be doing the same thing. Set it up for us one day out and what actually is a very significant election. Joe, its a significant election, right, because if this is really the plus 20 trump state that mccain won, mitt romney won and youre potentially not only losing democratic voters that voted for donald trump but also those Republican Voters that you were talking about, im going to play you a little bit of sound with three of those republicans. You just met conor lamb. You usually vote republican. Usually. How did this interaction go . It went pretty well. He is pretty dedicated, passionate. It was certainly nice to meet him. Would you vote democrat on tuesday . I would. I would. Im voting for conor lamb. The democrat . The democrat, yes. And really i dont think the labels are all that important. You vote for the best man. Hes the real deal. Straight as an arrow. And he is every mothers dream. Im totally honest. Really. Do you usually vote democrat . Nope, i dont. You have seen two different type of campaigns here. We were with conor lamb with coal miners, couple Steel Workers on friday night. Hes been on the trail. Theres an energy. We were with him in carnegie, canvassers coming in off the street they had not been contacted by the campaign seeing how they could help. Compare that to rick saccone, outside of the rally on saturday night, he had no events on saturday, he had no events on saturday. On friday he had two events. The first one had eight people come, the second had 15 people come. This is the paul ryanbacked super pac. I talked with their executive director yesterday. This is a super pac thats put in twice the amount of money into this district here. They have paid staffers on the ground that have been knocking doors compare that to the Rick Saccone Campaign not put up much of an operation, hasnt spent a Million Dollars on the air waves here and we heard this race should be a warning to all republicans here in the future that a seat like this, plus 20 trump is ultimately if you dont have better candidates and dont have better campaigns any seat in november is vulnerable. All right, vaughn. Thank you so much. Greatly appreciate it. And David Ignatius, i wanted to follow up on what vaughn had said going around talking to those people. You know what so many people in the media and politics forget is how nonideological most americans are. In that audience, where conor lamb was speaking, so many people in that audience voted for reagan twice, voted for clinton twice, voted for george w. Bush twice, voted for barack obama twice and voted for donald trump last fall. You could just hear in the voices that were interviewed in that piece people thinking, i want to do whats right for the country. That woman said conor lamb is every mothers favorite son. Shes saying this is somebody that i trust. That kind of basic citizen instinct. I want to pick somebody who will be good for the country, who i feel comfortable with. When that predominates, our politics work. Well see tomorrow. Its been important to note that conor lamb may succeed on issues like trade. Hes saying identical things to what donald trump is saying. Hes a National Security democrat. Hes sounding more traditionally. Sort of reminds me of a Scoop Jackson democrat, 20 or 30 years ago. But if that message works in this race, i think youre going to see a lot of republicans get nervous. But again, my take away from this whole interview was, hear voters trying to do what is it zens need to do to make the democracy work. Look at the candidates, make a choice about who do i trust . And so often we see this where if the white house is going in the wrong direction, voters two years later always correct them. And for republicans, my gosh, if democrats were to win tomorrow in an unlikely scenario, but looking more likely by the day, then the Democratic Party is going to have big wins in western pennsylvania where they shouldnt have won, a big win in alabama, and a huge win all across the state of virginia. Again, another state that nobody would have expected the type of victories that they had last fall. So any way, still ahead on morning joe we now know that the president s Current Trump organization email to help arrange that sixfigure paycheck to a former porn star to try to keep her quiet weeks before the election. We have got new details on that front. And also, speaking of attorneys, the president s other legal team is reportedly trying to speed up the Mueller Probe with certain catches. Were going to explain what theyre doing straight ahead. But first, here is bill karins. Hes got a check on the forecast. Bill, my gosh, third week in a row. I know. Were going to get slammed again hard with another big snowstorm in the northeast. Yeah. This is a new england special. Especially the boston area could get possibly up to a foot of snow in some areas. Cape cod could have a blizzardlike conditions tomorrow during the morning and into the afternoon. Right now its snowing in northern alabama. Middle of march, that doesnt happen very often. Snowing in nashville and lexington throughout the morning and heading through the carolinas and virginia. Raleigh could pick up two inches of knsnow later this afternoon. So then the storm comes over the carolinas off the coast becomes a noreaster. Third one in two weeks. By the time we get to monday evening, still a little bit of snow there in north carolina. This is as we go through the night snow blossoms. Youll wake up to snowcovered ground and roads in all areas of new england. Its plenty cold enough. This is mostly an allsnow event and it will be snowing hard. The morning commute tomorrow, i95 back across 84 the mass pike into boston and spreads north wards during the day. The winds will be their strongest as we go through the morning. As far as the snowfall amounts will go, not a huge ordeal in new york city, albany not that big of a deal. Hartford to providence, somebody will end up with a foot, foot and a half of snow out of this. Ski country will be great, looking through april in this year. Well have more on the storm as we go throughout the day today and of course tomorrow morning the latest with all the travel concerns well have. Glancing blow, d. C. , philadelphia, new york doesnt look like a huge ordeal. Youre watching morning joe well be right back. Im a concrete mason. I had severe fatigue, went to a doctor. Became diagnosed with hodgkins lymphoma. I had to put my trust in somebody. We recommended chemotherapy, and then a stem cell transplant. When his disease progressed, i thought that he would be a good candidate for immune therapy to unleash his immune system against the cancer. Im back to working hard. Ive honestly have never felt this great. The evolution of cancer care is here. Learn more at cancercenter. Com Appointments Available now. Bp is taking safety glasses to a whole new level. Using augmented reality so engineers in the field can share data and get expert backup in the blink of an eye. Because safety is never being satisfied and always working to be better. But through goodt times and bad at t. Rowe price weve helped our investors stay confident for over 80 years. Call us or your advisor. T. Rowe price. Invest with confidence. Depend silhouette active fit briefs, feature a thin design for complete comfort. They say move it or lose it and at my age, im moving more than ever. Because getting older is inevitable. But feeling older . Thats something i control. Get a coupon at depend. Com to to me hes, well, dad. Son pro golfer. So when his joint pain from Psoriatic Arthritis got really bad, it scared me. And what could that pain mean . Joint pain could mean joint damage. Enbrel helps relieve joint pain, and helps stop further damage enbrel may lower your ability to fight infections. Serious sometimes fatal events including infections, tuberculosis, lymphoma other cancers, nervous system and Blood Disorders and allergic reactions have occurred. Tell your doctor if youve been someplace where fungal infections are common. Or if youre prone to infections, have cuts or sores, have had hepatitis b, have been treated for Heart Failure or if you have persistent fever, bruising, bleeding or paleness. Dont start enbrel if you have an infection like the flu. Since enbrel, dads back to being dad. Visit enbrel. Com. And use the joint damage simulator to see how your joint damage could be progressing. Ask about enbrel. Enbrel. Fda approved for over 14 years. Why is dark magic so spellbindingly good . Its a bold blend of coffee with rich flavors of uganda, sumatra, colombia and other parts of south america. Like these mountains, each amazing on their own. But together . Magical. All, for a smoother tasting cup of coffee. Green mountain Coffee Roasters. You know whats not awesome . Gigspeed internet. When only certain people can get it. Lets fix that. Lets give this guy gig really . And these kids, and these guys, him, ah. Oh hello. That lady, these houses yes, yes and yes. And dont forget about them. Uh huh, sure. Still yes xfinity delivers gig speed to more homes than anyone. Now you can get it, too. Welcome to the party. Theyre not going to send missiles up. Think of it. Theyre not sending missiles up. And i believe that. I believe that. I really do. I think they want to do something. I think they want to make peace. I think its time. And i think weve shown great strength. I think thats also important. Right . And i must tell you, president xi of china has really helped us a lot. Theyve really helped us. And theyve been very good. They could have done more, but thats okay. I say to them, youve been great. You could do more, but theyve done a lot. Theyve done more. China has done more for us than they have ever done for any other president or ever done for this country. And i respect that. Because we go from a lot of people thought we were going to war. All of a sudden they come in and say were going to have a meeting and theres no more missiles going off and they want to denuclearize. Nobody heard that. Nobody thought but they said they want to they are thinking about that. Who knows whats going to happen. Hey, who knows. If it happens, it doesnt happen. I may leave fast. We may make the greatest deal for all these countries and the world. Frankly north korea, thats what i hope happens. Welcome back to morning joe. David ignatius, not exactly sure where to start there. The president s on again off again love affair with china continues. Crediting china with whats happening with the man he used to call rocket man. Whats your take away . Well, i think President Trump summed it up when he said who knows whats going to happen. He is rolling the dice. I think any sensible person should root for diplomacy. This visit with kim jongun has not been well prepared. There are a lot of question marks. There are a lot of uncertainties. There are dangers in the aftermath, but its hard to argue that stepping toward diplomacy, toward a face to face meeting the first ever between an american president and north Korean Leader is a positive development. What i hear Foreign Policy experts say, joe, as they look at this, is President Trump has to avoid making the mistakes hes made in other areas of Foreign Policy. He needs to stay close to allies. In this case, that means south korea, japan in particular. He needs to avoid being too disruptive. Hes so proud of how he overturned the tables. Heard him bragging about that earlier in the campaign speech. Needs to be careful about that. Finally he needs to be careful in this diplomacy that he doesnt back himself into a corner where in the aftermath of a failed negotiation has no alternative but the use of military force in a way that would not help the United States or its allies. Root for diplomacy, but lets encourage a more disciplined policy process that avoids mistakes hes made in other areas. So from north korea to china, again, we had the president trashing china through the entire campaign. Now he seems to be trying to figure out exactly how to embrace china. It seems that he again constant ly saluting power. I dont know if you saw it, couple weeks ago there was an article in the atlantic the title why china loves trump. Yes, part of that is because but also the article fascinating neatly enough says that chinese leaders want to avoid criticizing him because they actually think this is a guy they can work with and more jarring at least for me as i was reading the article the Chinese People seem to have a real affinity for this strong who they see as an american who is not being politically correct and who has all the tendencies of a chinese strong man. Trump has been part of this process of validating the leadership of president xi jinping who has, as trump sort of i think enthusiastically has become the president for life in china, there may be a touch of envy in trump. In the u. S. china relationship something quite interesting happened with trumps announcement hell meet with kim jongun. He cut china out of deal. The chinese are saying nice things, theyre being supportive. But if you read the Chinese Press the last few days you get a real sense of anxiety that the u. S. And north korea are going to do this separately. And that china is in this is one of chinas key longterm allies, north korea. Suddenly china is out of that game. I actually think thats one of the benefits of whats happened is there a try aingelation effect when nixon went to china, it was tough for the russians. They were cut out of that deal. As trump goes to kim jongun to pyongyang, maybe theres a way in which china is cut out of that and that has a benefit. But, yes, in general the chinese love donald trump. Very strange that donald trump again saluting dictators while attacking democratically elected allies as well as members of Americas Free press. Coming up, we may just have the 2018 version of the sarah palin campaign. Oh, manatees. Aka the sea cow oh theres one. Manatees in novelty ts . Surprising. Whats come at me bro . Its something you say to a friend. Whats not surprising . How much money matt saved by switching to geico. Fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more. After that photo, when did President Trump see Stormy Daniels . Did you have a text, email . I dont have anything else to add. You said from the podium, you acknowledge that the president to follow up on aprils question knows about the arbitration involving Stormy Daniels. Does he remember speaking about his lawyer with that . Does he remember meeting daniels . I dont have anything else to add. Ive addressed this extensively. Did the president approve the payment that his personal lawyer made to Stormy Daniels . Not that im aware of, but Michael Cohen, the attorney in question, has addressed this. The white house has addressed sarah addressed it earlier this week and i have nothing further to add. Did the president reimburse Michael Cohen for making that payment . Michael cohen has addressed this matter extensively. Nbc news has learned that trump lawyer Michael Cohen used his Trump Organization email just 13 days before the election to discuss paying daniels 130,000 of what cohen says was his money. Cohen explained to abc that he used his Trump Company email for both personal and Business Matters and that the funds were transferred from his home equity line. Joining us now Nbc News National Political reporter heidi pisbeli, media commenter New York Times magazine jim, law professor at George Washington university, jonathan turlly, New York Times reporter michael schmidt. Jim, lets start with you based upon a couple of those clips about this interview thats already taking place, 16 minutes. Is it going to go on or not . Well, 60 minutes says it has no plans to stop. Theres speculation yesterday that maybe cohen the president s lawyer would file some sort of injunction. That would be like a First Amendment class of the highest order. So at this point, all plans all systems are go. Jonathan, could you measure grade please Michael Cohens aptitude as a lawyer for sending out these emails on Trump Organization email . Well, first of all, the use of the email is probably the least of his problems. I mean, the most challenging client that Michael Cohen may have will be himself. Theres a very good chance hell be subject, in my view, to some form of review in terms of his conduct in this matter. He tripped wires all over the place. I mean, if you go through i have a column out today in usa today going through just five or six of the ethical issues that are quite problematic in terms of what he did. Everything from using personal funds to the question of whether his client knew about this agreement to whether the client consented. Theres even questions about his shopping a book when hes still doing representational issues for the client. And michael schmidt, as they approach legal armageddon here, how many names are on the door of the Law Firm Representing Trump . Who is it . Whats going on here . Well, the president still has his personal lawyers in john dowd and jay seculo. The question is about ty cobbs role. They brought him in to deal with the Mueller Investigation. The president engaged in discussions with a longtime lawyer emmitt flood. He represented clinton during impeachment and represented Vice President cheney years later and has deep experience in washington and would be interested in representing the president if things were to sort of intensify and become different here. You have to remember about ty cobb, he was in charge of the document production to mueller. He was going through all of the emails, the notes, those sort of things, getting them to the special counsels office, the president s lawyers have insisted that theyve not exerted privilege on any of those documents. This would be a new phase. The production is over and theres a new phase that the president would go into with the investigation and thats where flood would take the lead. Michael, this is not a few phase, but the president of the United States denounced the report in the times and calmed out maggie haberman, New York Times spectacular reporter, as are you, michael, called her out by name as this is wrong. This just is not wrong. This is wrong. Obviously the president will say whatever he wants to say when ever he doesnt like a story. He didnt like the fact that this had come out. He went after maggie in an unfortunate way. Shes the best that we have. I think he knows that. So heidi, its up to you now to try to unpack all this mess for us and explain a bit according to your sources. Because when you tie this bundle together, and its a bundle thats wrapped each and every day it seems out of the white house, but you have reports that the president of the United States now feels completely unshackled from john kelly, from anything or anyone in the white house who would try to monitor his conduct and his behavior and that he is literally a man alone operating on Foreign Policy and maybe even on legal policy. Well, the question now is how much of this is also driven by the fact that like michael reported, this investigation may be entering a new phase. This white house all along and the president himself even according to our reporting seemed to think and actually believed that this investigation may be wrapping up at the end of the year. Well, that didnt happen. And now not only is it not wrapping up but the new information thats coming out for example about this meeting suggested theres a very strong thread there in terms of the money, but then also in terms of the collusion aspect. And now that you see you have more and more witnesses potentially cooperating with this white house, how much of the president s temperament is being driven and his decision making, for example, on these tariffs, for example, on the north korea meeting by a sense of panic potentially in this white house to take the headlines away from russia, to take the headlines away from all of these external stories like Stormy Daniels. Joe talked a lot about that the other day about potentially the timing of the president trying to shift attention from these external controversies that are swirling around him. So, this scandal sounds like something should really resonate. The sentences the president s personal attorney used his personal funds to cover up the affair months after the president s child was born with a pornographic industry. What is it that this white house fears will result from this investigation into this affair with this porn star because we do hear that theyre getting very nervous inside the white house but its more than just the narrative is getting away from them, right . By the way, the narrative is getting away from them. Its almost like the noreasters that keep bashing the east coast. It flairs up and flairs up. The problem or concern doesnt seem to be so much about the politics of this story as it is about the legalities. Once youre into a Court Situation and Stormy Daniels is bringing a lawsuit, then you get exposure. Who knew what when are the key questions that go into her suit. So shes trying to get out of her suit. Michael cohen saying donald trump didnt have anything to do with the inking of this deal, the Trump Organization didnt, the campaign didnt. Well, then is she bound by it . The flip side is if she is bound by it, maybe did he know more than cohen is letting on. It exposes a lot about the money. The real issue is where did the money come from, what tract did it take . What did the president know about it . Was it coordinated. Then you get coordinated independent expenditures on the campaign. What do you think is the worst Case Scenario . That Michael Cohen ends up having to be deposed about this and opens up new fronts on the Campaign Finance side. Was Stormy Daniels paid off to be quiet about an affair to benefit the president s campaign. From the sounds of it just listening to jim here, any encounter between bob mueller, his people, and the president of the United States if one were to occur . It seemingly could last for weeks. But lets start with the fact that theres been reports that the white house is trying to make out work out a deal where mueller would meet and sit with trump. Trump would sit with mueller, but only for a specific period of time and they would want to have a commitment that the investigation would be closed shortly after that meeting. The odds of that happening . Well, the last part is the problem. In fairness to the white house, previous negotiations with president s have focussed on that time frame. To say youve got a set amount of time, you have to get everything done in that period. I really dont see how the special counsel could agree to even informally to wrap up an investigation as a condition for this type of sitdown. Part of the problem for the white house is this is coming a bit late. You know, really the mueller matter has metastasized. If you had done this early, he could have done the interview on the collusion and obstruction issues, had a relatively limited and confined interview. I think you could prepare trump for that. Ive prepared clients for depositions that were far more challenging and you can certainly keep him between the navigational beacons. Now you have this sort of metastasis. Its now going into Stormy Daniels, to the issue of the Stormy Daniels payment, the issues of the meetings with the russians. The scope of the potential interview is now much broader. Now, mueller could agree to say, look, im willing to sit down with you on the subjects that you lay out. But its very doubtful that he would limit himself to those subjects. One possibly would be the white house would say, how about if we do this . Well talk to you on the original purposes of the investigation, collusion and obstruction and nothing more. Mueller could cut that deal but it would not limit mueller to come back later and say i need to sit down with you and talk about these other issues. Michael, theres the lead for this block, the mueller matter has metastasized. Now, according to your sources in the white house, whats the level of panic or chaos within the white house that the mueller matter metastasizing has added to . Well, the president s aides and associates went out of their way this weekend to make it clear that the idea of bringing in a new lawyer is not showing that there is any more concern that they have about the special counsels investigation. They think its still in the same place. Remember, these are the folks that thought it would be over by the end of last year and still exists today. But theyve been insisting that this is not a change in posture whatever. The thing that i wonder about is that the president has long discussed the fact that if mueller was looking into finance issues outside of the russia matter, that that would be a red line. That that would be something that he would say that mueller should not do. And its clear from some of this reporting about money that came from the gulf states that mueller is looking at issues that may be beyond russia. I would be very interested to know what the president really thinks about that and how closely theyre looking at it and how concerned they are. Well, it could be that Donald Trumps redline over the Mueller Investigation is similar to Barack Obamas red line in syria. It will be crossed. Jonath jonathan, thanks all. We appreciate it. Now, this was the tease you probably didnt hear a minute ago when joes camera froze up, but because the guys who write part of this program liked it so much they wanted to make sure we got it in again. So, what may be the 2018 version of the sarah pailen, katie kouric interview, only this time the players are education secretary betsy devos and leslie stall. There you go. Morning joe will be right back. Plaque psoriasis can be relentless. Your plaques are always there at the worst times. Constantly interrupting you with itching, burning and stinging. Being this uncomfortable is unacceptable. Im ready. Tremfya® works differently for adults with moderate to severe plaque psoriasis. With tremfya®, you can get clearer and stay clearer. In fact, most patients who saw 90 clearer skin at 28 weeks. Stayed clearer through 48 weeks. Tremfya® works better than humira® at providing clearer skin and more patients were symptom free with tremfya®. Tremfya® may lower your ability to fight infections, and may increase your risk of infections. Before treatment, your doctor should check you for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection or have symptoms such as fever, sweats, chills, muscle aches or cough. Before starting tremfya®, tell your doctor if you plan to or have recently received a vaccine. Ask your doctor about tremfya®. Tremfya®, because you deserve to stay clearer. Janssen wants to help you explore cost support options for tremfya®. Dr. Ben carson, whats wrong . All of it. All of it is wrong. A drama so unnerving you cant look away. This whole thing with the president having sex with a porn star, it just didnt happen. Sarah, sarah the numberone drama in america. United arab emirates . This is Jared Kushner. Can i borrow 800 million. Nbc presents this is u. S. The show critics are calling like this is us but without the parts that feel good. Baby, im scared. Its okay. Youre going to make a great surgeon general. No, i run the department of housing and urban development. Thats hilarious. It is hilarious. That was also snls taken to drama playing out on prime time and in the oval office. Speaking of the administrations challenges, education secretary b betsy devos was featured on 60 minutes where she struggled to explain her mission. Why take money away from that school thats not working to bring them up to a level where that school is working. Well, we should be funding and investing in students not in School School buildings, not in institutions, not in systems okay, but what about the kids who are back at the school thats not working . What about those kids . Well, in places where there have been where theres a lot of choice thats been introduced, florida, for example, the studies show that when theres a large number of students that opt to go to a Different School or Different Schools, the traditional Public Schools actually the results get better as well. Has that happened in michigan . Where in michigan . This is your home state. Michigan well, yes, theres lots of great options and choices for students here. Have the Public Schools in michigan gotten better. I dont know. I cant say overall they have all gotten better. The whole state is not doing well. Well, there are certainly lots of pockets where the students are doing well no, but your argument that if you take funds away that the schools will get better is not working in michigan where you had a huge impact and influence over the direction of the School System here. I hesitate to talk about all schools in general because schools are made up of individual students attending them. The Public Schools here are doing worse than they did. Michigan schools need to do better. There is no doubt about it. Have you seen the really bad schools . Maybe try to figure out what theyre doing . I have not i have not i have not intentionally visited schools that are underperforming. Maybe you should. Maybe i should, yes. Kind of painful, noah, less money means greater success in education . Kind of painful. That wasnt a great interview, no. Im not sure why they let her on camera without the stats at hand she was trying to refer to. She was talking about florida and referring to an urban Institute Study that suggests College Enrollment increased among students who took part in the choice programs but that was not great for the cause of School Choice. I have to say, however, that betsy devos is not the impetus for the movement that favors choice in schools. She is the product of a movement that favors choice in schools. That favors flexibility and innovation in the Education System and removing the impediments to fungibility on funds for schools and contracts that are mandated by unions that allow that freeze teachers from doing what they want to do. So betsy devos should be a better advocate for her cause but the cause will persist with or without her. Fungibility. Big words. Heidi, betsy devos, we saw the clip coming in, ben carson, there cabinet is not exactly thrilling. Well, when the president said on the campaign trail that he would bring the best people in with the most experience, we now have a pretty stark juxtaposition and i would say to add to what noah said that part of the challenge for betsy devos is that even though as a Campaign Donor and republican big republican heavy hitter in michigan, she and her family put a lot of money into pushing the School Choice initiatives in that state in the direction that that state has taken. She hasnt been an educator and she hasnt been on the ground as an educator even now when she acknowledged that she hadnt been into these underperforming schools and so she herself is in a pretty tough position there. But you would expect that she would have a lot of data at hand just because michigan in many ways has been kind of a testing ground, a lab for the School Choice and whats happened there, fair or not, because we were starting, for example, in detroit with some pretty poor performing schools, but those schools are still really underperforming and she should have at least the basic amount of data at her fingertips to know that that is a question that shes going to get if she walks into an interview with lesley stahl. Odd thing, the education secretary not doing her home work. Shes on today this morning to talk about the president s gun policy but what happened to raising the age to buy rifles . Well go live to the white house. And after a slew of scandals, the white house chief of staff reportedly calls in cabinet secretaries to remind them to behave, but what about the behavior coming from the oval office . Speaking of bad behavior, how about the president s rally in pennsylvania this weekend . Morning joe is coming right back. Heres the story of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters sumatra reserve. Lets go to sumatra. The coffee here is amazing. Because the volcanic soil is amazing. So we give farmers like win more plants. To grow more delicious coffee. Which helps provide for wins family. All, for a smoother tasting cup of coffee. Green mountain Coffee Roasters. I thought i was managing my moderate to severe ulcerative colitis. But i realized something was missing. Me. The thought of my symptoms returning was keeping me from being there for the people and things i love most. So, i talked to my doctor and learned humira can help get, and keep,uc under control when other medications havent worked well enough. And it helps people achieve control that lasts so you could experience few or no symptoms. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. Serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening Heart Failure. Before treatment, get tested for tb. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Be there for you, and them. Ask your gastroenterologist about humira. With humira, control is possible. On the only bed that adjusts on both sides to your ideal comfort, your sleep number setting. Does your bed do that . Its the last chance for clearance savings up to 600 on our most popular beds. Ends soon. Visit sleepnumber. Com for a store near you. Next chapter our new slogan when we start running in can you believe it two years from now is going to be keep America Great exclamation point. Welcome back to morning joe. Joe scarborough here with working camera and all. On set with us this morning we have Mike Barnicle and noah rothman, heidi przybyla, David Ignatius and bob costa. Bob, i think its safe to say chaos reigns a bit inside the white house. We obviously have a lot of concerns about bob mueller inside the white house but also concerns about rick saccone, donald trump trashing him behind the scenes saying republicans may not be able to hold a seat in deep red pennsylvania. What have you heard . The white house has walked away from candidates like senator Luther Strange before who have disappointed them but it will be more difficult for Congressional Republicans to walk away for from a defeat tomorrow if it happens in southwest pennsylvania. High stakes for the president and the gop as they try to keep their majorities. This is a heavy trump district. The president rallied there over the weekend trying to get his voters ginned up to come out and votes but its looking like a tough race. Republicans trying to run against House Democratic leader nancy pelosi but its not exactly catching on. And a very tough race and once again the president of the United States goes to a rally, he does this time and time again and he doesnt make it about the guy hes supposed to be campaigning for, instead he makes it all about himself and boy did he make it about himself this weekend. Lets look at the tape. President xi. President for life. I was jokes and i said, ha, president for life, that sounds good, maybe were going to have to try it. [ cheers and applause ] president for life. But im joking. But im joking. South korea came to my office after having gone to north korea and seeing kim jongun and [ boos ] no, its very positive. No. After the meeting you may do that but now we have to be very nice because lets see what happens. That washington, d. C. , theres a lot of evil there but were getting it out step by step. A lot of evil. A lot of bad people. Lot of bad people. A lot of fake media. [ boos ] look at them. A lot of fake media. [ boos ] fake, fake media. Its 1999, im on meet the press a show now headed by sleep eyeeyes chuck todd. Hes a sleeping son of a bitch, ill tell you. You know, he likes to put names on people, he did that through the entire president ial election including all the republicans that he beat so these are Campaign Rally issues. This is something that is at a Campaign Rally and the president likes making funny names. If were to dismiss everything he says at a Campaign Rally, as i think youre trying to imply, then are you saying we shouldnt cover these things. Youre putting words in my mouth. I wasnt saying you should dismiss that whatsoever, you should obviously carry them because these are important moments for the president and this is news. What im trying to say is im focused on the policies. We have a trade deficit of almost 800 billion. They said he cannot win, he cannot get. Remember . To 270. And we didnt. We got to 306. We got 306 to 223. You know, noah, im having difficulty i dont know whats harder to get your arms around, the president of the United States is speaking using the language that he was using or the fact that Steve Mnuchin is secretary of the treasury. Both are tough to grasp. I suppose im not sure if i would do better than the president likes making up funny names if i was in his position. There is no defense and if youre going to defend him, theres a reason why his defensers and the administration outside of it have reached for these analogies to a young child without impulse control because thats what it sounds like when hes on the stage like that and we make excuses for it because it rattles up his crowd and makes him interested in rallying his crowds but its diminishing returns if youre a republican. The republican covenant with this president was well make him look good, well protect him, well have investigations into him and run block. And he signs our legislation and he doesnt make our lives more difficult and sometimes he makes their lives more difficult. By endorsing sweeping gun control measure, Immigration Reform along democratic line, tariffs now protect i impulses towards small population that affect the economy negatively. The republican burden is getting very hard and Donald Trumps is not that difficult. Watching that crowd, you could see people were being entertained, many of them smiling, some of them laughing. He speaks to a captive audience, he is a president seemingly alone but i was wondering your take on the percentage of republicans who are with him to the end. Whatever the end however you define the end, whenever the end occurs. We keep hearing 33 , 34 . Do you think its that high . No. Not until the end. This is politics vmg. Its always important to remember a lot of people went to see the darkest hour. Thats Winston Churchill in 1940. Churchill saves western civilization in 1940. Helps, along with fdr and the russians, helps defeat hitler win world war ii and is immediately voted out of office. Itssier ees easier to say t donald trump until theyre not. When you ask people are you with donald trump . They say of course i support donald trump, its a linear decision, the only other choice is Hillary Clinton. When its donald trump or ben sasse or donald trump and or James Langford or donald trump or jeff flake or other republicans that jump in or a business person, Donald Trumps biggest fear is it may be donald trump versus mark cuban in the republican primary. He doesnt want that. In fact, he probably wouldnt run if mark cuban ran in the republican primary and a lot of people around him dont think that will happen. So for now they are with him but theres no doubt that a lot of them, heidi, are going stay at home and lets have a counter for a second, lets talk about counter history here. What if donald trump didnt take to twitter . What if he didnt insult all of his political adversaries and political friends. What if donald trump had had discipline . You would have rick saccone saying weve lowered your taxes, weve made it easier to operate because regulations have been lowered as well and you know isis, that terror Group Two Years ago that we were hearing was going to not only take over the middle east but come to your hometowns and blow you up and blow your children up at school and blow our military theyre gone. Weve beaten them. They could be talking about all of those victories. Instead the president shows there just cant get out of his way so hes offending a lot of educated republicans in the suburbs of pittsburgh who are going to do just what educated republicans in the suburbs of philadelphia or birmingham did and that is vote against a republican for the first time in their lives. Were seeing a perfect illustration of that in that race, joe because were looking here at the numbers. What is Donald Trumps effect on this race . Its pretty significant considering the fact that this district is not one of those obama trump districts that first voted for obama then voted for trump. Its not by any definition a swing district. In fact, murphy, the previous republican who held that seat, didnt even have a challenger in his last election so then we drilled down into the numbers in this district, joe, and what we see is what were seeing in a lot of these districts across the country where republicans are increasingly concerned strong disapproval ratings for President Trump among people who disapprove of him so their feelings and intensity is strong compared to what were seeing on the republican side and, yes, even in these districts that are deep red, which is what i would characterize this district as, you have this component of suburban educated voters here in Allegheny County in pennsylvania who are going to be more mobilized and as you tick through those examples, joe, of the ways in which trump has alienated these voters, you explain this Enthusiasm Gap and what the democrats are doing here to take advantage of that are here again in pennsylvania, a perfect example, recruiting democrats who really fit the district likes conor lamb. Democrats could dont this alone just on antitrump fervor, but its part of the method of also recruiting democrats who really fit the district, in this case conor lamb and well see if this is a good example of the economic populist message these democrats will carry. And David Ignatius, you know, you brought up a couple of things last hour, one, you talked about how donald trump seemed to be denigrating the office of the presidency and what we expect of our president. At the same time you brought up the one voter that said conor lamb, hes such a good young man, hed id love him to be my son. And you see the great contrast there. While heidi was talking we had the president waddling around like he was a penguin. The president of the United States, not exactly Ronald Reagan at normandy. Not exactly barack obama in charleston. And there is such campaigns are always about contrast and here you have the president going in trying to defeat a young man who is probusiness, who is reasonable and rational on guns according to people even in that district and hes a vet who carries himself with dignity. I think the democrats may have found a way forward against a president who openly mocks the presidency and what we americans want from our president. Joe, well have to count those results tomorrow focusing on precisely that issue. Im struck watching this tape. This is what donald trump does best. It may be appalling, it may offend a lot of people but this antielitist show that he puts on and Campaign Rallies and really from the white house almost everyday, thats the thing hes accomplished in the year of his presidency is to have this daily pounding of the elites in particular the media and, lets be honest, those are popular lines. When he goes after the media, the media is not beloved in our country, i wish we were more popular but were not. Were doing our job. I think this is very much the way he has come to view the presidency. We had a perfect example over the weekend. The issue of gun violence in our schools deeply vexes americans. What did the president do after talking about how he was going to rise to this challenge . Essentially nothing. He backed away from the tougher limits on who can buy assault weapons. He kicked this to a National Commission headed by, of all people, betsy devos, one of the least unifying personalities i can imagine. He didnt address the issue the country cares about. Instead what he does is take the show on the road as he did to pennsylvania and it does appeal to his core base, you can see him smiling and laughing and cheering in the background but were going to have another test tomorrow about how wide that appeal is. Well find out. And thats just the thing, bob costa. It seems like narrow casting. You can go into one of Donald Trumps crowds, you can insult chuck todd, you can insult katy tur, you can insult mika brzezinski, but you look at the polls and people trust the press more than donald trump, people trust bob mueller than donald trump. This narrow casting got him in trouble in alabama and virginia and i wonder what you hear on the hill. Is there any understanding that Donald Trumps narrow casting is going to put nancy pelosi or somebody else in as the next democratic speaker of the house . There certainly is that fear, joe, but you floated names earlier. Senator sasse, senator lang ford who could rupture the dynamic but perhaps the most revealing interview was senator flake on meet the press talking about how he could look at a run in 2020 but he doesnt know if it would be inside of the Republican Party. He acknowledged on air the Republican Party is in essence owned by President Trump, the base, even though it doesnt comprise the country, comprises a big part of that beating heart of the Republican Party and thats the challenge facing those people you were mentioning. How do they do it in this environment or do they have to run as an independent if they want to change american politics . Of course, bob, that all changes if one democrats up to l and then suddenly you have democrats winning in a massive landslide in the fall. Obviously, bob, that would change certainly the environment in the Republican Party, wouldnt it . It would. If you see the democrats take the house and move to impeach President Trump this Time Next Year you could have a Republican Party in full revolt but its going to take until november. At this point, every lawmaker im talking to still think thinks theyre going to hang on to the trump ship as long as they can through this Midterm Election because at this point they tell me hes their best chance of getting out their own voters as they face the resistance and energy democrats. Well see if that works. Everybody stay with us. Coming up next, the president backs off his principle pledge when it comes to new gun safety laws. Well go live to the white house with a report on that. Plus, its one of the more baffling aspects of todays american Political Landscape the president s appeal among evangelicals when his words and actions seem to be antithetical to their beliefs. And some evidence that some of that support may be waning, especially among women who are evangelicals. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Your brain changes as you get older. But prevagen helps your brain with an ingredient originally discovered. In jellyfish. In clinical trials, prevagen has been shown to improve shortterm memory. Prevagen. The name to remember. When did you see the sign . When i needed to create a better visitor experience. Improve our workflow. Attract new customers. Thats when fastsigns recommended fleet graphics. Yeah now business is rolling in. Get started at fastsigns. Com. Oh, look. Yeah now business is rolling in. Another antiwrinkle cream in no hurry to make anything happen. Neutrogena® rapid wrinkle repair® works in just one week. With the fastest retinol formula available. Its clinically proven to work on fine lines and wrinkles. One week . That definitely works rapid wrinkle repair®. And for dark spots, rapid tone repair. Neutrogena®. See whats possible. The white house has unveiled several policy proposals in the wake of last months mass shooting at a florida high school. Joining us now, nbc News White House correspondent kristen welker. Kristen, what kind of steps is the white house looking to take in response to the shooting in florida, including, you know, raising the age of being able to buy an assault weapon. Thats the big question. President trump had indicated in the days after the massacre in parkland, florida, that he was ready to take on the nra over that issue. Ready to support increasing the minimum age to buy some weapons but now if you look at this plan, it looks like hes backing away from that fight. Backing away from increasing the age or at least that fullthroated support of it. Here are the main pillars of the plan. It calls for rigorous firearm training for some teachers. Thats the controversial proposal this the nra fully supports. It also calls for establishing a commission to study School Safety, ways to make schools safer. It supports legislation that could strengthen background checks but no language about increasing the age to buy some weapons. Now the white house says, look, they are looking into studying the possibility of that so theyre not backing away entirely but theres no language to that in effect this initial proposal that is being unveiled. Another point thats interesting, mike. If you listen to the president over the weekend when he was at the rally in pennsylvania, he criticized commissions saying that theyre ineffective and now this commission that theyre creating to deal with School Safety is the crux of this plan so an interesting dichotomy there. Education secretary betsy devos is going to be heading up the commission. She was on the today show just moments ago defending the proposal. When pressed over and over again by savannah about arming some teachers she said look, this would be done on a casebycase basis. Critics say bottom line this plan isnt tough enough and relies too heavily on states to fix this problem, mike. So heidi, betsy devos, head of the School Safety commission, we saw the secretary on in an earlier clip from last nights 60 minutes and she was totally unarmed with facts and now shes going to be head of the School Safety commission . I dont know. Well, there is a joke here in washington that when you want to punt on an issue, what do you do . You create a commission. Weve seen many more examples of failed commissions. That said i do hear from folks on the hill that this is such an intractable issue that that may be the inevitable starting place where we have to go because if you look at what the president is supporting, its nothing coming out of the white house other than this commission. Its kicking everything to the states, everything to congress. And even his own proposals, for example, increasing the age, if you remember the one thing from the round table he had with lawmakers that he was so strong on was strong background checks, strong back ground checks. Theres none of that in here other than to strengthen the Current System that we have. Theres no expansion of the background check system which just a few years ago was considered a minor concession that we couldnt even get through congress. So my guess is that, yes, well create this commission and, no it wont do anything but it will collect ideas and if at the end of the 2018 election there is an agreement that guns was an issue then maybe the new congress can pick up with those ideas and run. Whats unbelievable is the new congress may pick up ideas and run but this Congress Wont even do the nra said they should do. This president wont even do what the nra claims they should do. Maybe they are quietly killing it behind the scenes, they are that cynical but the nra said its okay to move on bump stocks yet theyre not moving on bump stocks. The nra said its okay for them to move on the Cornyn Murphy bill on enhanced background checks, nobody is moving on that either and David Ignatius, how remarkable. You have to president of the United States mocking republicans saying youre scared of the nra when they were doing far more, the ones that he was pushing, pat toomey and democrat joe manchin were actually doing so much more than other republicans did and now you have the president in the corner cowering in fear of the nra weeks after claiming to be so much stronger than them but look what happened at the nra meeting, look what happened with the gun meeting. Look what happened with the dreamers meeting with Dianne Feinstein there and everybody the president saying whatever you guys decide to do we want to do. It makes you look at his announcements not only on the transgender ban but even in meetings with north korea around you start saying this man means absolutely nothing that hes saying, even if he announces it from the white house or the cabinet room and so i think arent we wise to question whether hell even have a meeting with north korea . Well, i think my bet is that meeting will take place but i think, joe, youre right that there is a pattern here where the president makes strong emphatic disruptive statements. People are wondering, oh, my gosh, is he going to fight the nra . Is he going to take some radical new departure and it ends up that basically time after time the president punts. He defaults to congress. Thats what happened on daca legislation. The president came out saying im going to solve this, i care about this problem. In the end he let it go, didnt even support the congressional compromise that emerged. Same thing happened on iran. Im ready to tear up the deal. In the end he punted it to congress. We dont know what the policy is. Same thing on obamacare, the question of health care vexing the country, the president claimed he was going to deal with it, couldnt, kicked it off to congress. So i think you see through the first year of the administration now very clearly this issue of gun safety, the president does not want to take responsibility himself for major changes. And, again it lines up with what weve been saying all morning. This is a president whos playing to a small strong base. Maybe its 33 of americans and when he promises action on daca but punts, when he promises action on rational gun safety and punts, when he promises action on reforming health care and punts, all hes doing is offending those demographic voters he needs for his candidates to win this fall. So i think choppy waters ahead not only for this president but for the republican congress. When we come back, well talk to a man whos considered to be the foremost evangelical writers and thinkers in america, michael gerson. Hell talk about how evangelicals lost their way and got hooked on donald trump. Plus, im to ask him what he thinks about the latest polls showing evangelical women moving away from this president. More when morning joe returns. Hey. Pass please. Im here to fix the elevator. Nothings wrong with the elevator. Right. But you want to fix it. Right. So who sent you . New guy. What new guy . Watson. My analysis of sensor and Maintenance Data indicates elevator 3 will malfunction in 2 days. There you go. You still need a pass. Spring clearance event. The dual adjustability of the sleep number bed allows each of you to adjust to your ideal level of firmness, comfort and support. Your sleep number setting. For your best. Sleep. Ever. In the morning, youll discover the amazing effects the bed is having on your sleep quality. Your sleepiq score. And snoring . Does your bed do that . Only at a sleep number store where queen mattresses start at just 899. Last chance for clearance savings up to 600. Plus, free Home Delivery on all sleep number 360 smart beds. Visit sleepnumber. Com for a store near you. So allstate is giving us money back on our bill. Well, that seems fair. We didnt use it. Wish we got money back on gym memberships. Get money back hilarious. With claimfree rewards. Switching to allstate is worth it. avo if yand constipation,ling and youre overwhelmed by everything youve tried all those laxatives, daily probiotics, endless fiber it could be wearing on you. Tell your doctor what youve tried, and how long youve been at it. Linzess works differently from laxatives. Linzess treats adults with ibs with constipation or chronic constipation. It can help relieve your belly pain and lets you have more frequent and complete bowel movements that are easier to pass. Do not give linzess to children less than six and it should not be given to children six to less than eighteen. It may harm them. Dont take linzess if you have a bowel blockage. Get immediate help if you develop unusual or severe stomach pain, especially with bloody or black stools. The most common side effect is diarrhea, sometimes severe. If its severe, stop taking linzess and call your doctor right away. Other side effects include gas, stomacharea pain and swelling. Ask your doctor if 90 days of linzess may be right for you. Welcome back to morning joe, so glad you could be with us. Lets bring in mike gerson. Hes columnist for the washington post. His cover story for the atlantics april issue is how evangelicals lost their way and got hooked by donald trump. He wrotes in part, quote, one of the most extraordinary thinks about our current politics is a loyal adherence of religious conservatives to donald trump. The president won fourfifths of the votes of white evangelical christians. This was a higher level of support than either Ronald Reagan or george w. Bush. An outspoken evangelical himself ever received. Trumps beliefs could hardly be more incompatible with traditional christian models of life and leadership. This is a result when christians become one Interest Group among many, scrambling for benefitsover at the expense of other rather than seeking the welfare of christian evangelicals to rescue the faith of their worst leaders. Michael joins us now. Michael, of all the things that has discouraged me over the past year and a half and there have been quite a few things that have discouraged me its watching people that ive grown up with my entire life. Im not calling these people out specifically but this is where i grew up, First Baptist churchover meridien, mississippi, First Baptist church of pensacola, florida. I could go through the list. We moved across the deep south. I grew up among vanings, when i ran for office i got 95 of the evangelical vote but when i see these evangelical leaders come on tv i feel about as removed from them as i would when lets say nancy pelosi was speaking to the Democratic National convention in San Francisco in 1984. I dont get it. I wrote this piece in many ways because i was wrong. I thought around 2,000 that the with model we have found thats not true. Evangelicals were uniquely susceptible trumps message. They are his army of enablers. There are a lot of reasons but they come to view themselves as this persecuted minority that needs the protection of a strong man and this is fundamentally is mistake. One of the more fascinating developments in the Evangelical Church for me is when i first ran in 1994. Young people that came to work on my campaign wanted to talk about abortion and traditional marriage and the social issues that had been framed at least since 1980 and the rise of the moral majority and the Christian Coalition with social issues. By the time i left in 2001 every young evangelical coming in was wearing birkenstocks and what were they talking about . Poverty programs, they were what i call matthew 25 christians and they were absolutely obsessed with malaria in africa, aids in africa and thats why they found such a strong voice with george w. Bush. How did we go from matthew 25 evangelicals to Stormy Daniels evangelicals . Right. I was part of developing pep far, the president s emergency plan for aids relief and it was an extraordinary example of evangelicals coming together with liberal Public Health advocates and doing something extraordinary, saving the lives of millions of people, its a model. But thats not where were headed. Theres a generational element to this. Evangelicals 55 and older really are more in this camp than not matthew camp, the trump camp. And evangelicals that are maybe 45 and younger have a very different view on this. There are two things going on. One a generation is being alienated. So millennials selfidentify as evangelicals at a much lower level. Theyre essentially saying if this is religion i dont want any part of it but i spent a lot of time on evangelical College Campuses and there the spirit is different. Theyre not oriented towards the culture wars, they really are want to take christian ethics and apply First Principles to large problems instead of just reacting to perceptions of social aggression in ways that are really in many ways often focused on sexual matters, reacting to sexual matters rather than taking the basics of Christian Faith and practice which is really a certain anthropology, a view of human beings, their rights and dignity, and applying it to a broad range of issues which is where i think the Younger Generation is headed. This is not selfhelp talk that michael is speaking about, this is what jesus said when his disciples asked how they got to heaven, you read the last half of matthew 25 and it talks about helping the helpless, feeding those who are hungry and you go down the line. Of course the golden rule is called that for a reason because jesus said love others as you love yourself, do unto others as you would have them do unto you and of course weve gone a long way from that if you look at donald trump at these rallies and noah rothman, i wont ask you how old you are, noah, but i know youre younger than i am. Im 54, 55 years old. I grew up in the suburbs of atlanta, maybe this explains the generational divide, and i saw my parents being horrified by what they saw on the tv set in chicago 1968, what they saw at kent state 1971. What they saw when campuses were burning, streets were burning and life long fdr democrats who suddenly started voting republican starting in 1972 and i just wonder if thats the generational divide that has explained so much, this feeling of siege because if you were in suburban atlanta or suburban philadelphia or suburban anywhere in the 1960s and 1970s, you would have felt like your world was under siege. Yeah, im 36, i was raised in new jersey in a secular household, conservative household so i dont have any of that personal experience with 1968 but when it comes to or religion, frankly, but when it comes to moral orthodoxy, it was the moral majority position on bill clinton, the attacks on his character and his vacuousness and his immoral ability to stake out a position that was absolute struck me as direct and it was a lot of the stuff that helped my political maturation and the fact that quite a few of these people who staked out a position on bill clinton has abandoned it for donald trump is a real betrayal and its affecting my political leanings and those who came of age in the 1990s. I dont think it has anything do with donald trump im not sure if michael would agree with me but when you saw, for example, roy moore running for the senate, before the allegations involving young women came out, the issues that i was confronted with were that judicial interventionism is good when it helps us. We need somebody to intervene in law and make law from the bench when it supports us because otherwise you dont have a moral nation. You have a country that is base and impure and thats the reasoning that i guess leads people like Jerry Falwell to say Jeff Sessions is probably a deep state plant but and thats like the craziest of those positions but i bet it resonates a lot with evangelical leaders of a certain age who believe that the trajectory of the country is in such a terrible place that all actions are justified on their behalf. I think thats true. I think many evangelical leaders i talked to think theyre making a realistic bargain here. They know trump is flawed but hes going to do the right things on judges and other matters. I think thats a very mistaken trust. First of all just from a political perspective, associating issues like prolife issues and prolife family issues with misogyny, for example or exclusion or nativism is discrediting to those ideals so in the long run i think that that is a devils bargain, its not a good bargain. Its also theyre joining in the disillusion of important norms about decency and character. Thats the height of hypocrisy. But ultimately the Biggest Issue that i think which i develop in the essay is theyre discrediting their approach to faith itself. Theyre turning off people to their deepest beliefs, alienating them for reasons that have absolutely nothing do with the christian gospel, thats a very serious matter. I think there are a lot of people who have reacted and said i dont want any part of it. Michael, weve had a lot of good matthew talk this morning, matthew 7 12, do unto others as you would have others do unto you. Im taken by one line in your piece. This is the result when christians become one Interest Group among many scrambling for benefits at the expense of others rather than seeking the welfare of the whole. So based upon your experience, benefits. What benefits are they talking about . Are they talking about religious benefits or swapping their own cultural religious benefits as if theyre in a caucus room . They think theyre under siej. By whom . By courts that would rule against them on religious liberty issues, by bureaucracies, particularly under the Obama Administration where they felt like these were hostile bureaucracies so they have these reasons but i think its just its bad politics and bad spirituality. Theyre mistaken on a number of different levels. All right, michael gerson, thank you so much for being with us. We appreciate it and want to make sure everybody picks up a copy of the atlantic how evangelicals lost their way. Great conversation, we would love to have you back soon to talk about it more. Up next, all eyes are on pennsylvania and well talk to a guy who probably knows more about pennsylvania politics more than anybody else. Not that guy on the screen but ed rendell, who came on our show during the republican National Convention in philadelphia and predicted that donald trump was going to win his state. Hes see what his redictipredic tomorrow when morning joe returns. You know whats awesome . Gigspeed internet. You know whats not awesome . When only certain people can get it. Lets fix that. Lets give this guy gig really . And these kids, and these guys, him, ah. Oh hello. That lady, these houses yes, yes and yes. And dont forget about them. Uh huh, sure. Still yes xfinity delivers gig speed to more homes than anyone. Now you can get it, too. Welcome to the party. Welcome back to morning joe, great to have you with us. Now, in the wake of the president s decision to implement stiff tariffs on steel and aluminum imports, President Trump has spent the last several days fielding calls from foreign leaders pressing the president on his decision. The list of leaders who have spoken with the president includes a number of u. S. Allies such as the canadian Prime Minister, the japanese Prime Minister, the australian Prime Minister and the french president emmanuel macron. The white house says in his telephone call that his decision is necessary and appropriate to protect National Security. But while the Trump Administrations readout focused on the president s arguments for tariffs, it failed to mention macrons serious concerns with them. That includes his warning to the president that, quote, europe will. Respond clearly and proportionately against any unfounded practice that is contrary to the rules of world trade. David ignatius, thats a fairley strong washing from the french president. And im sure its a similar warning that the president got across the eu and from from, of course, our closest allies. Joe, i spent the last few days in brussels in belgium with a lot of leaders from europe who were talking above all, north korea was obviously in the air, but talking about these tariffs. European leaders fear that the fundamental structure of what they see of as the Global International system, International Economic system, their own europe kwan union, is under attack from the president. And they see these tariff threats as potentially major disruptions in the way that theyve been doing business. So, yes, they are beginning to prepare lists and they were specific about it in our conversations. Lists of products where they would sooem seek to retaliate against the United States for its tariff moves on steel, aluminum, perhaps other products. Also, theyre thinking about going to the world trade organization. The organization that the u. S. Over the last several decades built to be the instrument of the u. S. Led rulesbased order, theyre thinking of going to that body to seek to bring it this in to curtailing Trump Administration trade policies. So it was a scene where you saw the degree to which our allies are worried. Our allies are worried about costs and the president s allies also wondered what would it take for republicans to speak against donald trump. I think we got our answer, tariffs. Theyve got to answer to their constituents in their local areas. The chamber of commerce. As a reporter, you look at this and you say, this is a political test. In the coming months, lawmakers tell me theyre going to be watching. Can he actually cut a better deal on nafta . Those talks swr r have called. In his words, the 25 and 10 tariffs, hes taking on steel and aluminum. Hes gotten some progress on tried and thats going to have a political cost, whatever way it swings. Stay with us. Coming up next, President Trump sums up his north korean policy. By saying who knows what is going to happen. Were going to show you what he told the revved up crowd in pennsylvania. Plus, londons mayor is going to join the conversation on morning joe. Growing up, we were german. We danced in a german dance group. I wore lederhosen. When i first got on ancestry i was really surprised that i wasnt finding all of these germans in my tree. I decided to have my dna tested through ancestry dna. The big surprise was were not german at all. 52 of my dna comes from scotland and ireland. So, i traded in my lederhosen for a kilt. Ancestry has many paths to discovering your story. Get started for free at ancestry. Com. Take 5, guys. Tired of your bladder always cutting into your day . You may have overactive bladder, or oab. Thats it we really need to get with the program and see the doctor. Take charge and ask your doctor about Myrbetriq Mirabegron for oab symptoms of urgency, frequency and leakage. Its the first and only oab treatment in its class. Myrbetriq may cause serious allergic reactions. If you experience swelling of the face, lips, throat or tongue, or difficulty breathing, stop taking myrbetriq and tell your doctor right away. Myrbetriq may increase Blood Pressure. Tell your doctor right away if you have trouble emptying your bladder or have a weak urine stream. Myrbetriq may affect or be affected by other medications. Before taking myrbetriq, tell your doctor if you have liver or kidney problems. Common side effects include increased Blood Pressure, common cold symptoms, urinary tract infection, constipation, diarrhea, dizziness and headache. Okay, time to do this dont let your bladder always take the lead. Ask your doctor if myrbetriq is right for you. And visit myrbetriq. Com to learn more. On the only bed that adjusts on both sides to your ideal comfort, your sleep number setting. Does your bed do that . Its the last chance for clearance savings up to 600 on our most popular beds. Ends soon. Visit sleepnumber. Com for a store near you. When i was in china, and other places, by the way, i said, mr. President , do you have a drug problem . No, no, we do not. I said what do you attribute that to . Well, the Death Penalty. So i dont know that the United States frankly is ready for it. They should be ready for it. But at a minimum, you have to give long, tough sentences. Think of it. You kill one person, you get the Death Penalty. In many many states. You kill 5,000 people with drugs because youre smuggling them in and youre making a lot of money and people are dieing, and they dont even put new jail, they dont do anything. Thats why we have a problem, folks. And i dont think i dont think we should play games. Welcome back to morning joe. That president , that line has been the crowd tested by the president quite a lot. And i suspect hes going to be using it much more in the future. Its going to stick around. Interesting, though, that, again, hes getting his policy. And the guy he seems to admire the most and the guy he seems to be obsessed with the most is the man who is patterning himself after chairman mao and that is the leader of china. Very interesting. In had that case, also, later the philippines, two men with absolutely no democratic impulses whatsoever. Welcome back to morning joe. With us this hour, weve got mike barnacle, David Ignatius. Oh, we have nelba rothman. As i said, David Ignatius, heidi prisbella and robert costa. And it is, David Ignatius, how fascinating it is. And troubling that donald trump seems to be obsessed with the leader of china who has spent the last six months consolidating his power and liking himself more up with chairman mao than any other chinese leader since maos departure from the world stage. Well, watching trumps performance in pennsylvania, this is not the fireside chats of franklin roosevelt, but it is a kind of intimate way of connecting with his followers. And i do think he sees xi jinping in china as a model, a fellow big guy. They both take up a lot of space on the stage. In china, its interesting that xwhr xi has been known as xi dada, big daddy xi. Thats the way donald trump would like the to be seen, i think, by a lot of americans. Big daddy donald, the guy who tells it likes it is, the guy who increasingly seeks to form a cult of personality around himself. So i think there are parallels. The president speaks with obvious enthusiasm about the opportunity to be president for life, which is what xi jinping has just become. Well assume hes joking. He doesnt really want to change our constitution. But theres obviously an affinity there and you can see it in the way the president carries himself. Every time he talks the about xi jinping. Well, the president wants us to believe that hes joking when he talks about being president for life. But he did use it as an applause line in a speech in pennsylvania. Lets listen to some of the clips right now. President xi, president for life. I was joking and i said, ha, president for life, that sounds can good. Maybe were going to have to try that. President for life. But im joking. But im joking. South korea came to my office after having gone to north korea and seeing kim jong un and no, its very positive. No. After the meeting you may do that, but now we have to be very nice because lets see what happens. That washington, d. C. , got a lot of evil there, but were getting it out step by step. A lot of evil. A a lot of bad people. A lot of bad people. A lot of fake media. Look at them. A lot of fake media. Fake, fake media. Its 1999. Im on meet the press, a show now headed by sleepy eyes chuck todd. Hes a sleeping son of a bitch, ill tell you. Women wont like donald trump. It will be a rough night for donald trump. Because the women wont come out. We got 52 , right . 52. Right. They said, he cannot win. He cannot get. Remember . To 270. And we didnt. We got to 306. We got 306 to 223. Many people, including myself, raise their kids to respect the office of the presidency and the president of the United States. When he uses vulgarity to talk about individuals, what are they supposed to tell their kids . Again, ill be with my kids this morning and ill be focused on them on what the president is doing to protect the United States, its citizens and more important its economy. So dont worry about his values, dont worry about him as a role model ive never said that whatsoever, so i dont know why youre putting these words in what im trying to say, okay. So, again, i am very comfortable with what were doing, okay. And, again, i think youre trying to take this out of perspective and implying something im not saying. Fair enough. What do you did what are you supposed to say when hes using these vulgarities to to kids . Again, i think you should be focused on what the policies are. Hes using these vulgarities in the context of a Campaign Rally. And, obviously, there were a lot of funny moments on that rally. They were hilarious. Yeah. Now, actually, chuck had a reason to be a little sarcastic there in the end. The president attacking chuck todd just like hes attacked myco host, katie terr and others and getting the crowd bewhipped into a frenzy. And, again, the treasury secretary just sits the there and i guess apologizes for it. He can say whatever with he wants to say, but bob costa, at the end of the day, maybe the president s cabinet is not going to be critical of it. But, again, you look at alabama, you look at virginia, you look at some of these special elections that have been taking place. And women have moved away from republicans if in large numbers. In alabama, black voters turned out in historic numbers. Hispanics, educated republicans, suburban republicans. It seems to me that these speeches that the president gives, yeah, he gets crowds, big crowds and he gets up a certain part of the base, but it seemed like he offends far more. How is that going to play out tomorrow . The republicans have bought the ticket and have taken the ride. At this point, theyre in. There is no real choice here. Theyre going to start running against President Trump a few months before the mid materials. The more intrigued comments in that rally were about xi jinping. President moon of south korea is trying to get north korea boxed in, brings in President Trump, gives him the invitation. Prime minister abe in japan cozies up to trump to box out china and the president is trying to have his own relationship with china, assert the u. S. As a rival in the region, as a power. He makes his own move with north korea. Thats the real news to me coming out of this rally. Everything else, its pretty predictable. Of course republicans are cringing behind the scenes about some of his language, the inappropriate vulgarity, but they know that is who he is. And here not about to run away from him because theyre scared about whether the voters are going to come out in november. And noah, how regardble is it that you have a president from the party of Ronald Reagan going to western. And getting an applause line by praising an autocrat running china with an iron fist, president xi with, whooile condemning chuck todd, a member of the free press, and discouraging voters from booing kim jong un. Its remarkable and disconcert issing that the president seems to think that the voters in western pennsylvania booing a despit the e in north korea will derail negotiations there. I dont think that will be a problem for him. We talk a lot about the resurgence of populist nationalist movements, nostalgic movements, even liberal movements in europe. We dont talk a lot about it in asia. But it is in asia, too, where a cult of mao is resurging in china. Duterte, a populist figure executing people in the streets for drug dealing and is a very popular figure for it. Illegal figures, they dont make any bones about what their enemy is, classical liberalism. Theyre very nakedly hostile towards these things. And i think the defenders of classical liberalism is going to have to get more aggressive naming their adversary, too, because theyre very apologetic for their values that elevated so many millions out of poverty over the course of these years. This is something they need to be very expressive about. Their adversary is no holds barred. David ignatius, i found it interesting that you referenced fire cha fireside chats a couple of minutes ago. 83 years ago today, Franklin Delanor roosevelt gave him first fireside chat to this nation. There had been Bank Holidays called by the president. The country needed to be calmed down. People needed to be reassured that democracy if in america would survive and fdr managed to do that, not just with a single fireside chat, but over the course of his career, obviously. It was called then and is called today leadership. So id like to ask you, i discertain going around, theres a ripple of unrest in this country that hasnt been dealt with. And one of the reasons for the unrest is the unneringly playing to the cheap seats cadence that comes out of the white house. Lets have the Death Penalty for drug abusers. But one thing went unnoticed in the past few days that id like to ask you about. And it is this. Russian operatives in syria apparently with the passit consent of the kremlin, and thus putin, attacked an American Special forces unit. They picked on the wrong unit and they got crushed. But its virtually a declaration of war against the United States of america, another one. Not a cyber war. A real physical gunshot war. And the president has yet to say a single thing about it. His silence about russia is confounding. Its one of the strangest things about his presidency. I was in syria on the morning that that attack finished. I was with the commander who ordered it about three or four hours after the battle ended. And its striking that it was very clearly because of the liaison conversations between u. S. Officers and russians on the scene. The u. S. Kept saying these forces are coming at us. These forces are connected to you. Are you going to stop these forces . And nothing was done. And timely, the russians had been denying any connection, asked for a truce so they could collect their dead and wounded. But it shows that the use of American Military power has effects. The russians have not protested or respond ed. They knew they were offside and they took that pounding. On this question of the fireside chat, you and i, mike, remember american politicians who could speak to the country and calm anxieties. That used to be what we would celebrate as the great quality of leadership. Ronald reagan had it. Lind Linden Johnson had it. This president has a approach that if there is a scab forming in American Life over a difficult issue, rather than trying to heal that wound, he rips the scab off. We saw some of that in the speech in pennsylvania. We see that on every issue, every campaign, every speech. If something is wrong, if something is trying to heal in america, wlets rip it off and expose the friction and the anger. And i think thats the thing that worries me the most about him is were a country that we are divided. Had there is no question about that. That predates donald trump. The problem is that he just keeps driving a wedge deeper in the divisions. We saw that as clearly as i can remember in the speech in pennsylvania. And the only response in our democracy has to come from voters. People have to say, thats not what i want. Thats not where we want the country to be going. John mcglock lynn salaughline recall president s party by their words. Inalienable rights, four score, nothing to fear. Ask not. Shining legacy. Trump legacy so far . Mostly insults. Crooked, fake, loser, will i ddel, hoax, scam, psycho, s. O. B. , ribbed, flungky, shole. Sad. I go back to what David Ignatius said. Obviously much to be discouraged about. You look at the interviews that voters had in pennsylvania. Voters are always the leveling win. When democrats go forward to the left, their their Midterm Elections pull them back to the center. When republicans go too far to the right, there are Midterm Elections that pull them back to the center. And all of this demagoguery from donald trump, we go from fireside chats to this firestorming the demagoguery. It seems at least if you listen to those interviews that Vaughn Hilliard had that americans at least temperamentally are determined to pull this country back to the center. And specifically when it comes to that demagoguery in pennsylvania, we are looking at different demographic groups, right . Were looking at the suburban swing women. Theres another group i want to draw your attention to here. It has to do with the economic populism that i think could be instructive for additional races going into 2018. That is union households, joe. We saw a lot of Union Members actually vote for trump in the past election. Well, whats happening now is youre hearing from some of these same Union Members saying that they may be willing to quote unquote split their ticket and vote for the democrat this time. Here is the reason why i think republicans have to be worried going into 2018 based on what were seeing here. The tax bill is just not resinating in the way that they hoped that it would when it comes to these voters and when it comes to the benefits that theyre seeing in their pocketbooks. Really interesting trend here, joe, that has kind of flown under the radar is that republicans, after investing about 2. 5 million in promoting the tax plan has now pivoted away from that. What are they running on . Theyre going after conor lamb on more social issues, like em gra immigration and tough on crime issues. Thats a real problem. Republicans said this tax bill would be their everything going into 2018. In the first case here of that tax law becoming law, its not resinating with these voters and with trumps core base of working class white voters. As i said last week, the real shock for supporters of this tax bill, despite the fact they spill spent millions and millions of dollars promoting it, trying to turn the numbers around, Donald Trumps own Political Organization took a poll and the majority of people in that poll agreed with nancy pelosi, that most americans outside the 1 would only receive, quote, crumbs. And if you really want to know how a policy selling a middle america, how important its going to be for the election, you go to where what ross pe rot said was where the rubber met the road. Thats in pennsylvania 2018. A deep red republican seat that republicans always win. Guess what . As heidi said, theyre not even talking about tax cuts there any more because those tax cuts are seen as disproportionately helping the richest americans. They voted for obama twice before that, voted for bill clinton before before that and voted for Ronald Reagan before that. Again, its a levelinging wind and it looks like that leveling wind is coming Donald Trumps direction. David ignatius, thank you so much. As always, for being with us. Your voice is always extraordinarily invaluable. Thanks so much. Coming up, john kelly is reportedly cracking down on the cabinet after members spent taxpayer cash on everything from a dining room set to a european getaway. Drain the swamp . I dont think so. Were going to run through the worst offenders, coming up next on morning joe. Why is dark magic so spellbindingly good . Its a bold blend of coffee with rich flavors of uganda, sumatra, colombia and other parts of south america. Like these mountains, each amazing on their own. But together . Magical. All, for a smoother tasting cup of coffee. Green mountain Coffee Roasters. When this bell rings. It starts a chain reaction. Thats heard throughout the connected business world. At t Network Security helps protect business, from the largest Financial Markets to the smallest transactions, by sensing cyberattacks in near real time and automatically deploying countermeasures. Keeping the world of business connected and protected. Thats the power of and. Welcome back to morning joe. White house chief of staff john kelly is reportedly cracking down on Trump Administration cabinet members for a run of bad headlines over their spending. This after hud secretary ben carson spent almost 31,000 for a customized dining room set. Ryan zinke spend 139,000 on a budget labeled secretarys door. Veterans Affairs Secretary david shulkin, his staff hit a taxpayer funded trip to europe for the secretary and his wife. Ep administrator scott pruitt was revealed to exclusively fly first class. After the Trump Administration lost the cabinet secretary over his pension for private jets. Meanwhile, education secretary betsy devoss is going to be lead ago commission tasked with examining ways to protect schools from gun violence. You might remember her position on guns and schools from her confirmation hearing. I would imagine that theres probably a gun in the school to protect from potential grizzlies. Yeah, our kids arent worrying about grizzlies in their schools. Theyre worried about ar15s. Well, in in an interview with 60 minutes last night, devoss seemed to struggle with the most basic of questions. Are the Public Schools in michigan gotten better . I dont know. Overall, i cant say overall that they have all gotten better. The whole state is not doing well. Well, there are certainly lots of pockets where the students are doing well and but your argument that if you take funds away that the schools will get better is not working in michigan. Where you had a huge impact and influence over the direction of the School System here. I hesitate to talk about all schools in general because schools are made up of individual students attending them. Have you seen the really bad schools . Maybe try to figure out what theyre doing . I have not i have not i have not intentionally visited schools that are underperforming. Maybe you should. Maybe i should, yes. Are you in any way, do you think, suggesting that the number of false accusations are as high as the number on of actual rapes or assaults . Well, one Sexual Assault is one too many and one falsely accused individual are one too many. But are they the same . I dont know. I dont know. But im committed to a process thats fair for everyone involved. Mcbarnacle, you played the entire or larger chunks of the interview earlier. Boy, a rough, rough stretch of questions and answers there for an education secretary who has been under fire since the day she walked into office. Yeah. Joe, no doubt. And we led this segment talking about june kelly, the chief of staff. I dont think most americans have a great idea of the scope, the responsibility of the job of the of chief of staff. But i would say this. John kellys 40 years if the marine corps in the course of those times, he dealt with a lot. Theres no doubt about that. But i dont think he has ever had to deal with the constant stream of chaos and incompetence that hes surrounded with, not only, you know, within the white house weve seen, but with the cabinet secretaries. Its just incredible. And i dont know i dont know how any human being can handle that. Never mind just one individual. The white house with chief of staff. Yeah. Its obviously amateur hour at the white house. Theres a reason for that. Donald trump didnt expect to be president of the United States. In the process he had a transition that was rocky, to say the least, and put a lot of people in their positions not based on whether they were prepared, but for a lot of different reasons. Bob costa, though, lets talk about john kelly for a minute. The general, well, hes faced quite a bit of controversy himself. Weve had report over the past month that he was going to be headed out, that he was going to be pushed out of power. You had a showdown between Jared Kushner and john kelly, people like myself said the family always wins because the family has always won. I think its safe to say, at least at this point in march, that john kelly has proven himself to be a lot tougher and more of a survivor than most of the Washington Press core expected. One metric security clearance, john kelly, the general still has his high level security clearance. Jared kushner does not. Hes close with general mattis, the defense secretary. Talking to white house officials over the weekend, they say he go struggling. And hes had these meetings with cabinet officials and hes had to tell them, these arent your kingdoms, these cabinet departmentes. Just because you have black suvs and a security staff and a large office, an operation, that doesnt mean youre not a government employee. You see all these stories about furniture pure chase, extravagant travel, but hes hindered, joe, because at this point in 2018, very limited time if they want to make a replacement to get a senate cop firmation. And Senate Majority leader Mitch Mcconnell isnt trying to have a major cabinet post inauguration. Despite the fact we hear reports that the president s tired of general kelly trying to bring a little bit of discipline and order to the white house, and that all the staff members, as well, dont like him because hes doing what chief of staffs are supposed to do and that is stopping people from just wandering in and giving the president their thoughts. There is an order there and its an order that, my gosh, only leaves you with the relation of just how bad it would be perhaps if general kelly werent in the west wing. Bob costa, thank you so much for being with us. Were going to continue talking about pennsylvania 18 and also specifically were going to be talking about the president s political analysis of the pennsylvania election. And i know youre going to be surprised by this. Much of it focused on the physical appearance of both candidates. Well have that when morning joe returns. And you had the president using what we used to call a dirty word to describe one of my colleagues. And i wonder as the education secretary who is in charge of what our kids learn, what do you think of that kind of language . Would you wash someones mouth out with soap . Well, i would probably use different language myself. I think we all have an opportunity and responsibility to be examples to our kids. Which includes the president . That would include the president , as well. Most people come to la with big dreams. We came with big appetites. With expedia one click gives you access to discounts on thousands of hotels, cars and things to do. Like the Avalon Hotel Beverly Hills for 40 off. Everything you need to go. Expedia. Had a little incident witht kia moped in bermuda. E. Oh. Even with insurance, we had to dip into our 401 k and it set us back a little bit. Sometimes you dont have a choice. But it doesnt mean you guys cant get back on track. Great. Great. Yeah. No judgment. Just guidance. Td ameritrade. Like you do sometimes, grandpa . And puffed. Well, when you have copd, it can be hard to breathe. It can be hard to get air out, which can make it hard to get air in. So i talked to my doctor. She said. Symbicort could help you breathe better, starting within 5 minutes. Symbicort doesnt replace a rescue inhaler for sudden symptoms. Symbicort helps provide significant improvement of your lung function. Symbicort is for copd, including chronic bronchitis and emphysema. It should not be taken more than twice a day. Symbicort contains formoterol. Medicines like formoterol increase the risk of death from asthma problems. Symbicort may increase your risk of lung infections, osteoporosis, and some eye problems. You should tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high Blood Pressure before taking it. Symbicort could mean a day with better breathing. Watch out, piggies get symbicort free for up to one year. Visit saveonsymbicort. Com today to learn more. If you cant afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help. More and more people are finding themselves in a chevrolet for the first time. Trying something new can be exciting. Empowering. Downright exhilarating. See for yourself why chevrolet is the most awarded and Fastest Growing brand, the last four years overall. Switch into a new chevy now. Current qualified competitive owners and lessees can get this 2018 chevy equinox for around 199 a month. Chevrolet. Find new roads. With pg e in the sierras. And im an arborist for around 199 a month. Since the onset of the drought, more than 129 Million Trees have died in california. Pg e prunes and removes over a Million Trees every year to ensure that hazardous trees cant impact power lines. And since the onset of the drought weve doubled our efforts. I grew up in the forests out in this area and honestly its heartbreaking to see all these trees dying. What guides me is ensuring that the public is going to be safer and that these forests can be sustained and enjoyed by the community in the future. Coming up, weve got a political round table standing by. Its going to be al sharpton, ed rendell and chris hayes. They will be talking about the president in pennsylvania. Plus pennsylvania 18 tomorrow. But first, here is bill carin wes a check on the potential for another hard hitting storm. Bill, man, what is it . What comes in like a lion, does march come in lie a lion and remain a lion . The whole time. This is a brutal march. Do you remember when it was like 75 in february and we were all like, oh, winter is over. You never say that. I know. Thats one thing ive learned being north. Youll get two or three days warm in february. People will say to me, hey, looked like we survived the winter. Im like, dont ever say that. And boy, this month especially. So what does it look like . How bad is it going to be . This is a eastern new england special, joe. This isnt going to be as widespread, but the areas it hits will be hit hard. The storm now is over kentucky and tennessee. Now the storm is breaking out in virginia. Youll drive home in the storm today. Mid march snow is very rare, even three areas of the midatlantic. Then we develop into a noreaster. Overnight tonight, snow spreads up from the south. Winter storm warnings from montaugh, hartford and maine. How much snow are we talking . This is a good solid 8 to 12 inches from portland to boston. Hartford is the dividing line of if youre east of hartford, heavier snow. 6 inches plus. West of hartford, lighter. New york in, light pavement. And our friends in northern vermont and New Hampshire and maine, snowmobile and ski season is just going to keep on going. And the other components of a noreaster, shouldnt be too bad with this one. Could get up to 55, 60, near 70 Miles Per Hour tomorrow afternoon. Its not 90 like the other storm we had. Still, that could do some minor damage and knock out some peoples power. New york city, were going to be spared this one. I havent heard a complaint yet about that. Morning joe will be back in three. You totanobodys hurt, new car. But there will still be pain. It comes when your Insurance Company says theyll only pay threequarters of what it takes to replace it. What are you supposed to do . Drive threequarters of a car . Now if you had Liberty Mutual new car replacement™, youd get your whole car back. I guess they dont want you driving around on three wheels. Smart. With Liberty Mutual new car replacement™, well replace the full value of your car. Liberty stands with you™. Liberty mutual insurance. Heres the story of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters sumatra reserve. Lets go to sumatra. The coffee here is amazing. Because the volcanic soil is amazing. So we give farmers like win more plants. To grow more delicious coffee. Which helps provide for wins family. All, for a smoother tasting cup of coffee. Green mountain Coffee Roasters. The markets change. At t. Rowe price. Our disciplined approach remains. Global markets may be uncertain. But you can feel confident in our investment experience around the world. Call us or your advisor. T. Rowe price. Invest with confidence. Sconor lamb, lamb the sham, hes trying to act like a republican. I hear hes nice looking. I think im better looking than him. I do. I do. Permanently, i like rick saccone. I think hes handsome. We need our congressman saccone. We have to have him. We have to have him. The people of pittsburgh cannot be conned by this guy, lamb. You just cant do it. I really i dont know what to say. Like this con or lamb guy is pretty good looking, but the president says i think im better looking than him. Obviously, every time ed rendell campaigned in pennsylvania, that was his line, as well. Al sharpton is with us. Along with ed hayes. Mike barnacle, heidi and noah also still in the house. Ed rendell, you actually when we were in philadelphia at the rnc at the dnc, you had predicted along with joe biden that donald trump could win and toll us off camera would most likely win pennsylvania if in part because the Clinton Campaign wasnt reaching out the to White Working Class voters in pennsylvania who were such an important part of pennsylvania politics. But here, how bizarre that you have donald trump who only seems to be reach out to voters and my gosh, its going to be fascinating to see what is happening in the suburbs of pittsburgh. It will be turnout. Obviously, there will be a greater democratic turnouten than republican. But the question is how much greater . The if its significantly greater, conor lamb is going to win. If its fought too great a margin, conor lamb will probably lose. But hell run 18, 16 points ahead of trump. Talk about how surprising it is that its still close and what other republicans will run in 2018, what should they take away from the fact that we dont know who is going to win this race today . Well, its interesting. This is still a pretty good donald trump district. Monmouth poll shows 51 of the people if in the district have a favorable opinion of the president. Those are pretty good numbers for donald trump. If he cant deliver a candidate in that type of district because the democrat turnout is so great and the republican turnout is dispirited, i think tier in trouble across the board. And remember, he has a way of member mizing his candidates hes trying to help. I thought he made senator on saccone look small. Chris, first of all, were going to get to your book a colony in a nati a nation out today. Talking about the democrats and appealing the light ethnic working class folk, weve been talking about that for pomonths now. The union vote is going to be interesting to watch tonight, but the larger question is how does a democrat go and appeal that working class ethnic vote . Look, i think the model of this right now you in american politics is, i would say, a senator shar sfee senator Sharrod Brown of ohio who runs 8 to 10 points ahead of someone like donald trump in ohio. I think hes favored to win that race. And he is laser focused on a bunch of core economic issues. S supported the steel tariffs, not surprisingly. He has been a critic of trade since he was a congressman in ohio. But he also doesnt pander, right . He takes tough votes with the Democratic Caucus on a whole bunch of social issues, on things like abortion, things like lgbt rights, etcetera, but his emphasis are economic populist issues, things like trade, a living room wage, and hes deeply affected. If anyone has a key, keep in mind, this is someone whose political career has spanned a rightward shift of ohio. Ohio, which was a swing state has moved much more into the republican column and brown has been able to sort of maintain his fold. Thats a tough tight rope to walk, though, for a democrat. I think its a rope theyre going to have to walk, though, no matter how tight. And i think what were going to really see tomorrow, we keep hearing about the erosion of support for President Trump, particularly among some of the white women that gave him a vote. Were going to see how real that is, no matter what the results are. And the enthusiasm level of the democrats. I think that we have a lot on to watch tomorrow, no matter how the race goes, because i think pennsylvania will tell a lot of that story. Are we really taking for granted a democratic surge . Are we that taking for granted that his base is ee rosing, he being donald trump, because i can what we saw on saturday nights rally was a donald trump rally. Donald trump does not have the capacity to campaign for anybody but donald trump. Exactly. So the theres no such thing as does he have any coat tails. He never leaves you his coat. Governor, there seems to be an issue on the convergence of trade. Conor ham never said he was against this and the republicans are for it. Were now for these protectionist moves. We have this conception of western pennsylvania as a steelproduci steelproducing town, but pittsburgh is a Medical Center for innovation and technology. I dont really see them having this conception of themselves as a steel town that was and is no more. What does western pennsylvania think of thats more of the outlying areas outside of pittsburgh. There are stell coal miners and steelworkers, but fought a lot. So pittsburgh itself is a high tech city now. And youre right, but look on trades, i think the democrat ek position has to be evidence of that trade. Arlen specter and i testified we finally, after five years, got the quota card played. He think they buy at the store could go up. Are you concern about that . No. Its understandable. We need a broadbased Democratic Party. Conor lamb is prolye. Thats okay. Conor lamb is mild on gun control. But hes for universal background checks. Thats okay. Conor lamb is encouraged by the steeler workers union. So we have to have a broadbased party. What i used to tell people is conor lamb will cast one vote thats important to you for the next speaker of the house of representatives. We progressives understand it. Im working on chris, but were getting there. So chris hayes, youve got your book out now in paper back. This is to regional best seller. This is no National Best seller. Its an interNational Best seller. Its news to me, yeah. And a galactic best seller with a new afterword. Tell us whats new, what were going to see in the book. I wrote the book while during the election and the election of donald trump. Trump was only mentioned once in the book. The afterword focuses on technically the politics of law and order and what the president means when he talks about it. Its sort of a remarkable thing. Here is a president that supporters rail against illegals and illegal immigration and the lawlessness of that, who surround onned himself by, it can now be said, felons. Weve had numerous felons in part of the campaign who have no concern whatsoever about lawlessness or criminality. And wines about due process when the person loses his job. This is what someone whose vision of what law and order is a profoundly tribal one, right . He doesnt care about the law in general. What he cares about is protecting the people close to him and using the laws of tool against those who are against hem. No. But i can whats important, also, about some of the issues you raised, which ive given my life to, is around the criminal justice issue. I think that what we are missing while we deal with all of the salacious stories, he has been began appointing federal judges. He has began putting federal prosecutors in that reverse where we had started going under eight years of president obama that went all the way back to the beginning of the king movement. So the whole movement around criminal Justice Reform has been stalled and slowly being reversed under trump and that is very significant and devastating. And its true. And weve seen Jeff Sessions, even against some of the sort of think tank right, you might call it, the crime coalition, people like cato and others who have advocated for getting rid of mandatory minimums, different sentencing guidelines. We have seen sessions take the party and take the doj in the direction of the old even if its cato and others. And now you have the president of the United States talking about executing drug dealers. Chris hayes, with thank you so much for being with us. Again, of course, a colony and a nation, we greatly appreciate it. Also, reverend al, great talking to you as always. And ed rendell. Cant wait to talk to you after the relates come lets bring in austin, texas, the mayor of london, sadik khan. Giving an address at the southwest by southwest conference. He delivers his keynote speech later today. If i understand correctly, mr. Mayor, you, like me, are a Liverpool Fan and if that is, in fact, the case, i expect at least half of your remarks to cover the absolutely horrific officiating and the man u match this past weekend. Morning, joe. Its an outrage. Serious questions have to be asked about that referee. I always use the words long suffering before describing myself as a Liverpool Fan because you and i grew up on the glory days where our team did so well but its always embarrassing as the mayor of london. We have five premier league teams. Explaining that i support liverpool. You will know, joe, you can change your spouse, you can change your job, you can change where you live. You dont change who you support. No, you certainly dont. Chances are good, mr. Mayor, we may meet up in london in early april when liverpool actually goes to Stamford Bridge and plays chelsea. Be very interesting to see you in Stamford Bridge cheering for liverpool. So tell us by south by southwest. And what is your message to everybody there and to america . Well, im really excited to be here in austin at south by southwest. This is a really important tech conference that takes place every year. Where the tech giants come as well. Theyll be a number of things of course for investment in london. But also explaining that in my view i think politicians and policymakers have vacating the field when it comes to the Tech Revolution taking place around us. Social media platforms have been a source of massive, massive benefit and good. We use it to keep in touch with our loved ones. To keep in contact with friends. To access information. And its great. But actually what weve seen in the recent past is social media being used to incite hatred, to spread fake information, allegations of interfering with elections. And i think what needs to happen is the Tech Companies have got to realize they have a social responsibility to make sure theyre not amplifying messages of hate. If they dont, im afraid theyll have more of the regulation weve seen in countries like germany. Where basically if the social Media Companies are used as a platform to have fake news or have hate language and dont put it down within 24 hours, they have massive, massive fines. I think us politicians need to have a conversation with the social Media Company and say, you know what, youve got a responsibility. Youve got a responsibility to bring people together rather than dividing them. Right. And of course here in the United States, over 50 of americans have facebook as their primary nice source. If fake news is spreading around on facebook and they dont regulate that, that actually is very damaging to an educated electorate. Let me ask you about how you and the people of london and the people of britain are now coming to terms with donald trump as president of the United States. Obviously a lot of people in britain as well as in america were concerned when he he retweet retweeted profascist videos from a british radical party. Is there more of an understanding that congress and members of his cabinet are actually more mainstream than donald trump himself and that there still are places we can Work Together with a special relationship . Absolutely. The context is i dont think you appreciate how much americans and america are loved and appreciated. Not just in london and uk but around the world. Youre a beacon of liberty. We enjoy your music, your film, your culture. The innovation taking place with the tech giants. One of the consequences of having a special relationship is very similar to being best friends. When you have a best friend, of course you stand shoulder to shoulder with them in times of adversity. Theyre your closest ally. You are closest together on big issues. One of the consequences of having a best friend is when you disagree with them, you got to call them out and say, you know what, i think youre wrong here. And the relationship with a best friend is different to the relationship with an acquaintance or with a Long Distance friend who you see infrequently. Were under no illusion that your president doesnt speak for all americans. Many, many americans, the people on a daily basis in london, businesspeople, tourist, student, those who are artists, and many, many others, dont necessarily agree with the views of your president. Why would they . In a healthy democracy, youll always get people who disagree with the winning candidate. I think the concern is this, though, joe. One of the reasons we have a special relationship are our common values and the things we believe in. People in the developing world, people in all parts of the world, look to you as a country for inspiration, for leadership. And as somebody who loves america, i think i worry about the perception people will have over your great country because of the things your president may have tweeted or said elsewhere. All right, mr. Mayor, thank you so much for being with us. Good luck in austin, texas. Its a great town. Lets hope liverpool has a good draw in the champions league. Thanks for being with us. Well be back here in two minutes. Hands go here. Feet go here. You know what goes here. And your approval rating. Goes here. Test drive the ztrak z540r at your john deere dealer and learn why its not how fast you mow, its how well you mow fast. Nothing runs like a deere. Save 250 dollars when you test drive and buy a john deere residential z540r ztrak mower. Al say to friends, did you see my speech last night . Yes. At first, i have to say, how good was i . How good . And they say good. And thats what he does. Thats what hell always do. Hes out there, mike, trying to help a candidate, and thats what he would always do. After debates, after everything. Pick up the phone, go, how great was . I so how was the president on saturday night . Saturday night we saw the president who he was. All about him. Hes a solo act. Saconne running for congress is an appendage. He did all this on the weekend prior to the anniversary, as we alluded to earlier, march 12, 1933, the first roosevelt fireside chat which was about leadership. Yes. Noah. Big story on nbcnews. Com right now about alleging qatari information regarding Jared Kushners relationship with the uae that possibly influenced trump to endorse the blockade of qatar by Saudi Arabian military. Its an interesting story. Fascinating. Heidi, final thoughts . Joe, regardless of what happens tomorrow in pennsylvania, it is part of a national trend. Weve seen from kansas to South Carolina to virginia and alabama, which is the democrats are vastly outperforming their past performance. With money. Outraising his opponent. And so are democrats a cross the country. In big, big in a big, big way, especially in pennsylvania 18. All right, thank you guys so much for being with us. Thank you at home for watching. Greatly appreciate it. Well see you tomorrow. For now, Stephanie Ruhle picks up the coverage. Stephanie. Thanks so much, joe. Good morning, everyone. Im Stephanie Ruhle with a lot to cover on this monday. Starting with armed with a plan. The white house takes its First Step Towards Arming Teachers while backing away from previous calls to raise the age