Somali born congresswoman broke out at his last rally. We begin tonight with joe biden who weathered an onslaught of attacks on his record at last nights debate as some of his challengers even tried to call into question his association with the former president. In this afternoon, in detroit, the former Vice President fired back with a reminder of what the 2020 election should be about. Look, i hope the next debate we can talk about how we fix our answers to fix the things that trump has broken, not how barack obama made all these mistakes. He didnt. I want to make it clear is that this going back 10, 20, 30 years is just a game thats a game to make sure that we hand the republicans an election coming up. Some of these assertions being made were absolutely how can i say it nicely, not true and taken out of context. And the idea that its somehow comparable to what this guy is doing is absolutely bizarre. The world has changed. The President Trump has turned it upside down internationally. He had turned it upside down economically. Now we face a problem that the economy as well as the soul of this country is collapsing because of this presidency. Well, Vice President biden fended off attacks. They came from all sides actually last night as several of his challengers certainly tried to land a strong punch against him. Here goes. Mr. Vice president , it looks like one of us has learned the lessons of the past and one of us hasnt. Vice president biden, i didnt hear your response when the issue came up of all those deportations. You were Vice President of the United States. Mr. Vice president , your argument is not with me, its with science. And unfortunately, your plan is just too late. The Vice President has still failed to acknowledge that it was wrong to take the position he took at that time. Mr. Vice president , you cant have it both ways. You invoke president obama more than anybody in this campaign. You cant do it when its convenient and then dodge it when its not. Today Vice President biden was asked if the attacks on the obama legacy were a sign the party is being pulled too far to the left. Its not about moving left or right. I think i represent the party. I think my views are where the vast majority of the Democratic Party are. There is a lot of really, really good people who got elected who are really pushing the envelope, and its good. Its healthy to do that. But the idea that they represent what the party is today does not comport with who gets elected, does not comport with how we last in 18. It does not comport. For more im joined by ben rhodes, former Deputy National security adviser under president obama, zerlina maxwell, senior director of progressive programing for siriusxm radio, jon meacham, nbc news historian and author of songs of america and robert costa, National Political reporter for the Washington Post. Thank you, john. Youre first. What did you think watching for a couple of hours last night on the cnn debate . What did you think you saw there for two hours . Two things in terms of analogies. One is it began to feel a little bit like 1976 on the other side with the foured for and the reagan forces duking it out. Trying to pull the party to the left. In 76, it was pulling to it the right. In that cast, joe biden and the gerald ford role. The other thing that struck me is it was a little like 1988 and joe biden is in the george h. W. Bush position, being dinged for everything he could be dinged for, being attacked for not taking responsibility for the things that might not have been so wonderful in the reagan administration. But one thing to remember about that year is that Vice President bush became president bush, and Vice President biden it seems to me going to his case still it seems to me has the best chance at this distance to go all the way. Let me go to zerlina. Youre an expert on programing and broadcasting and it was two hours. I heard a lot of things from people like dan balts of the national post. We saw david broader. What did you see that you didnt like in it was a long night. Lets put it that way. I think the debates are too long, and they start too late, chris. I need to go to bed. Okay. Hey, i come on afterwards to do the spin room. Im on at midnight. I think we need sleep. Especially in the trump era. But i think last night that opening section about health care was a little bit too confusing for the average american. I think that it almost felt like the candidates were talking past each other on the issue of health care. I think that one of the candidates needs to stand on the stage and explain the taxes versus the premium costs and how that will shake out under a future plan and the difference there. And they need to explain that to the American People. I spent two nights watching debates about health care, and that wasnt explained, not a single time. And thats a very important issue. Well, i got into a scrum over that myself, because i think having paid into medicare for 50 years, i notice its coming out of my paycheck. I know the amount that comes out of my paycheck. I know i do that, or else i go to jail. Okay. How is the new system going to cover my health care for my whole life, its going to cost more. How much more . Will it be more than im paying for my Health Insurance . I think these are very legitimate questions, because the issue isnt about health care, really. Its about financing of health care. How is it going to get financed, who is going to pay the bill. At last nights debate, several candidates denounced President Trumps ongoing efforts to stoke racial division, including his recent attacks on congressman Elijah Cummings and baltimore itself, the city. Lets watch. Mr. President , this is america. And we are stronger and great because of this diversity. So mr. President , lets get something straight. We love it. We are not leaving it. We are here to stay, and were certainly not going to leave to it you. Donald trump from charleston to baltimore to even the border is using the tired old language of demagogues, of fearmongers, of racists to try to divide our country against itself. First of all, the president is a racist, and that was just one more example of it. We can no longer allow a White Nationalist to be in the white house, number one. He has done nothing except try to beat people down instead of lift people up. And thats what we want in the next president of the United States. Let me go to robert costa. Political analysis here, not just reporting. There are two ways to look at this fight for the democratic nomination. One is we run the safest bet weve got, biden. I know the argument. It may be wrong. Some people think thats the argument. He is the safest bet. He may not be. He may be too old. He may not be Strong Enough on the argument. The other argument is here is the chance for a real progressive to win because we have an unsightly president now. This guy expect get reelected. Hes awful. And here is our chance. Like reagan did when carter was weak. Here is a chance to put a conservative in there like we never could before, like in 76. Which ones right . What is the smartest analysis or are they equally valid until one is proven . The energy in the democratic ranks is with those on night one, senator sanders, senator woyrn. They got the applause. The rank and file. When i go to South Carolina and go to historically black church or go to a suburban area, the energy is more with Vice President biden, for someone who is just going to be a change from President Trump. I was up on capitol hill today at the senate, pulled aside some Democratic Senators for private conversations. They said they were happy to see Vice President biden talk about president obama last night. Not to be talking about segregationists, not to be talking about bussing, but to be talking about president obama. That to them is the safest zone if he wants to be the nominee. Thats so true. Let me go back to ben. It seems to me that its surprising about democrats, and ive noticed this for all my life. Democrats shoot their wounded. Republicans run them the next time. Theyre just different. They dont protect their own. In this case, why do you have to protect obama . He is one of the most popular president s weve ever had. Steve kornacki last night pointed out 973 he is among the Democratic Party voters right now, 97. Nobody is like that. And yet there wasnt much martial defense of the guy last night. I think the reason joe biden was out there today embracing essentially this contrast is its good for him. It is bad politics and bad policy to criticize someone who has a 97 Approval Rating with the democratic electorate and is the most admired man in america. And by the way, you can even talk about building on what he did. I dont see democrats criticizing lbj over medicare because it didnt create a single universal pair system. Barack obama did more to advance health care than any american president since lyndon johnson. He was the first democrat to get elected with over 50 of the vote twice since Franklin Delano roosevelt. I think the argument these candidates could make how do you embrace and build on that legacy. And the attack should be with trump. The fight should be republicans, not with our own past. In april, president obama issued a warning about the dangers of democrats beating up on each other over ideology. Lets listen to what he had to say. One of the things i do worry about sometimes among progressives in the United States, maybe its true here as well is a certain kind of rigidity where we say im sorry, this is how its going to be. And then we start sometimes creating whats called a circular firing squad where you start shooting at your allies because one of them is straying from purity on the issues. And when that happens, typically the overall effort and movement weakens. Zerlina, you know, i watched biden today. He was ten timesler than last time. Last night he was twice as good as he was the first time. But i still think this campaign is going to get down to probably Elizabeth Warren winning in iowa, and her number one challenger in the weeks ahead is going to be Kamala Harris. I just think that. Ive been watching that. I see that pattern. But i think this battle is interesting. And my question is are we in danger . We, im on the center left. Are we in danger of doing what the democrats did in 72 when they were so thrilled to defeat Richard Daley of chicago, so thrilled to defeat tip oneill in boston that they ran a candidate who was not going to beat dick nixon. George mcgovern was not going to beat dick nixon. Everybody knew it. We knew it from the beginning to the end, but they wanted a more important they wanted to beat the moderates. Did the people on the risk being so determined to get the moderates they commit suicide . Your thoughts. Its an open question because i dont know the answer. I think its a good question. I think whats happening right now in the Democratic Party is were having a robust discussion. And many of the issues we were also talking about during the Obama Administration like the level of deportations, those were things that progressives were, you know, doing, engaging in activism around at the time. So this is not new. And the circular firing squad, yes, is a danger. I think as long as the candidates are sticking to the policy disagreements and staying away from my personal attacks or challenging someones integrity or perhaps their motivation for supporting a certain policy, well be fine. I think that the key here is turnout. Donald trump only won by 77,000 votes, chris. And as you know, Hillary Clinton still won the popular vote. The fact of the matter is if we pick a candidate who isnt going to drive turnout to match those Obama Coalition numbers, then were not going to win. But that can do that. I believe that Kamala Harris can build that coalition. Elizabeth warren has been showing signs that she can build a coalition of diverse set of communities, and we dont have to rely on those midwestern white trump obama switch voters. What do i know this fight . I know whats behind this fight. I know it is and i understand it. Let me ask you. The historic nature of barack obama running in 08 and 12 was so dramatic, i can understand why people of color who dont normally vote, think its all bs showed up because it was so thrilling. I mean, i was thrilled. And i get thrilled thinking about what happened in 08. Its still thrilling to me. It is thrilling what he said in 04 in boston, obama. But youre not always going to have a thrilling, charismatic African American person of either gender or any background to come on and say im the candidate for president. Does it take that . Or can Elizabeth Warren running with say buttigieg or something, could they excite the inner city . Could they excite people of color to the degree youre talking about that needs to win . Yes. Because black people care about policies, not just the personality of the politician. Barack obama is a once in a lifetime politician. There are very few wheel as good at giving speeches at president obama. But i think Elizabeth Warren is charismatic. Anybody who can argue with me on that point, ill see you outside, because i think Elizabeth Warren is incredibly charismatic. And i dont think she gets enough credit for that, frankly. I think theyre waiting outside. But thats okay. Let me ask you this. Everybody here can jump on this. John, youre the historian. Last night Michael Moore said something that was outside the ballpark, but sometimes he said those things. Like last time he said trumps going to win. You got to listen to him. He is pushing michelle, Michelle Obama. He said Michelle Obama on a book tour, and youve been through book tours, 15,000 people show up to see her. She is 70 . Politicians dont get 70 . She is incredibly positive as a personality, and shes tough on issues. She knows history. She is not particularly happy about American History going back. But boy is she popular. Can she jump in this race at this point . Your thoughts. Is that reasonable, what Michael Moore said last night . Well, i have no idea. I do know that you and i are on our best day have not exactly gotten 15,000 people at a single book event. Maybe close here and there. She is a remarkable cultural and political figure. When she came to nashville here on her book tour, people were coming down the steps of the reimann auditorium after shaking her hand, weeping. Its like they were lords. And i think thats part of what moore might be getting to. People are looking for a miracle in this, because they see trump as such a disease. They see him as something that has to be overcome. And the other thing that i would just say about biden, and the excitement factor is Thomas Jefferson once wrote a love letter called the head and the heart to a woman not his wife. But anyway, it was the argument between the head and the heart. And that seems to be whats going on here. And the heart of the Democratic Party may be with warren and sanders, but the head, i think, is with Vice President biden. Let me go back to one of the questions with ben. It is important to me. I worry about this. Will barack obama, who has laid back during this primary fight, will he come on like richard the lion heart coming back from the crusades, will he come on next november, maybe starting in september and really be the lion of the Democratic Party for whoever the nominee is . Will he . Yeah, chris, absolutely hell be out there, just like he was out there before the mid terms. I think one thing you can learn from obama you dont necessarily have to choose between this idea of inspiration and progressive policies versus trying to reach out to people who are in the middle. Barack obama found a way to do both. And the way that he did is he identified progressive policies that help people in their own lives like expanding health care, for instance, but he also rooted a progressive message not in a complete rejection of the past and not in a complete rejection of people on the other side of the political divide. He rooted it in American History, in americas progressive tradition, in americas founding documents. I think there is way for the democratic nominee to stradle this divide and have progressive policies that are quite popular with people, but not present it in way that seems like a complete rejection of the american past. And i think obama holds a lesson for how you can do that. The other thing ive ever had against obama is when he recedes from us. He goes away. I want him back. Thats my only problem. The Democratic Party turning its lonely eyes to the obama family is revealing. Its a testament about how are you paul simon . Turn your lonely eyes to them. Go ahead. Its a testament to how this party feels about the president ial field. The leader of this party right now is speaker pelosi. The leader for the past eight years during the Obama Presidency was obviously president obama. They want someone to step forward in this president ial field and take control. They have deep respect for president obama. But who is going to lead the party in 2019 . Well see. I think they need a leader to push if impeachment is to go anywhere, it needs a strong leader like tip oneill against nixon. I dont think they believe in it yet, though. Are the numbers still there . Are they growing there to get to 218 . They are growing. Theyre growing every minute. Chris. 218 is the magic number. Ben, i like your cheerleading there so much. You dont even have to be called on. I know because the mayor of new york taught us that last night. Dont wait to be called on. Ben rhodes, thank you so much. Zerlina maxwell, jon meacham and robert costa. Coming up, warning that russia is still interfering in our elections. Lets listen to his warning. Over the course of my career, i have seen a number of challenges to our democracy. The russian governments effort to interfere in our election is among the most serious. But President Trump still hasnt gotten that message. Once again, he is coming to the defense of the russians. Wait until you hear what he said this time, i mean by today. Plus, what the candidates told me last night in the spin room there was a lot of talk about the frontrunner, joe biden. Much more ahead. Stick with us. Stick with us. You try hard, you eat right. Mostly. You make time. When you can. But sometimes life gets in the way, and that stubborn fat just wont go away. Coolsculpting takes you further. A nonsurgical treatment that targets, freezes, and eliminates treated fat cells, for good. Discuss coolsculpting with your doctor. Some common sideeffects include temporary numbness, discomfort, and swelling. Dont imagine results, see them. Coolsculpting, take yourself further. Thats ensure max protein, with high protein and 1 gram sugar. Its a situp, banana bend at the waist im tryin keep it up. Youll get there. Whoahoahoa 30 grams of protein, and one gram of sugar. Ensure max protein. There was no hesitation, i went straight to ctca. After my mastectomy, it was maddening because i felt part of my identity was being taken away. When youre able to restore what cancers taken away, you see that transformation firsthand knowing that she had options that she could choose, helped restore hope. My team made me feel like a whole person again. Cancer Treatment Centers of america. Appointments available now. Cancer Treatment Centers of america. Staining be done. Behr presents outdone yourself. And stay done through every season. Behr semitransparent stain. Find it exclusively at the home depot. Keith used to be great to roadtrip with. But since he bought his house. Are you going 45 . Uh, yes. 55 is a suggestion. Its kind of like driving with his dad. What a sign, huh . Terry, can you take a selfie of me . Take a selfie of you . Yeah. Can you make it look like im holding it . He did show us how to bundle home and auto at progressive. Com and save a bunch of money. Oh, a plaque. He later navigated northward, leaving. Progressive cant protect you from becoming your parents. But we can protect your home and auto when you bundle with us. But we can protect your home and auto lets cowboy up exhilarating speed. Woo precision control. Woo maximum reliability. Access denied. [ repeats ] access denied. If its not xfinity xfi, its not good enough. For wifi with super powers, get xfinity xfi. And go see, fast furious presents, hobbs shaw. August 2. Did you think that this was a single attempt by the russians to get involved in our election, or did you find evidence to suggest that theyll try to do this again. It wasnt a single attempt. Theyre doing it as we sit here. And they expect to do it during the next campaign. Welcome back to hardball. That was the stark warning we got from the former special Counsel Robert Mueller delivered just last week that russia interfered in 2016, and theyre doing it again right now. Well, unbelievably, when asked about that warning late today, today, President Trump questioned whether there is really interfering at all. Last week that russia is interfering in u. S. Elections right now. Did you raise that with Vladimir Putin . You dont really belief this. Do you believe this right now . Okay, okay. Mueller said right now he believes russia is interfering in the election. Well, i watched mueller. Im not sure mueller knows whats going on. The president s remarks daekly contradict members of his own administration who repeatedly raised alarm over the threat of russian interference. Here goes. The russians are absolutely intent on trying to interfere with our elections. Interference in American Election series unacceptable. Our focus here today is simply to tell the American People we acknowledge the threat, it is real, it is continuing, and were doing everything we can to have a legitimate election that the American People can have trust in. Im joined right now by former republican congressman carlos cabela of florida and a National Security reporter. Carlos, why is this president instinctive lie defending the russians when he when in doubt, remember, there is a bear in the woods. There might be a bear in the woods. Thats the way the republicans have always been there might be a bear in the woods, and if there is, we better be ready for that bear. The reason the president refuses to openly acknowledge this is any time he hears this discussion about russian interference in our election, he thinks that that delegitimize his election in 2016. In reality, the two things are completely separate. No one is out there saying that donald trump won because russians interfered. Some people may theorize that, but no one can actually prove that. But for the president , this is so personal, and he gets so insecure that he doesnt want to acknowledge a simple fact that pretty much everyone else in the government has acknowledged. So if the president can just understand that when people are talking about russian interference in our elections, were talking about trying to protect our country, trying to guarantee the integrity of our elections. Were not criticizing him. Then he can perhaps finally openly admit this. But as long as this is a complex for him or he has a chip on his shoulder about it, he is going to keep dismissing this, and its dangerous and its just dishonest. Thank you. I think thats very smart. Natasha, it seems like he also doesnt want anybody to say anything offensive against his pal in moscow. And i think it goes a little bit further than him just being afraid that this is going to delegitimize his election. One of the things that the president cares most about is money, chris, and one of the things that keeps getting overlooked in all of this is that he wants badly to do a business deal with the russian. After his presidency . He is going to leave eventually, and when he gets out of office, he will need to have maintained this relationship in order to fulfill his lifelong dream of building a trump tower moscow. He was doing it during the election. What makes us think that he is not in talks with the russians, perhaps right now to do the same thing once he leaves office. We only learned about a phone call he had with Vladimir Putin after the russians already reported it. And this happens constantly. We learned just today or yesterday that they had a long phone call supposedly about the fires that are ravaging russia right now. You know, we dont get details of their conversations and of their personal interactions until way after the fact. And so much of this is still so secretive, that of course its going to prompt suspicions about whats actually going on behind the scenes. Now to a big story very much related. Since the outset of the trump administration, the white house has refused to explain how Jared Kushner, his soninlaw, and ivanka, his daughter, obtained those security clearances necessary to access this countrys top secret intelligence. And now were learning that according to a letter obtained by nbc news, quote, the trump administrations intelligence watchdog has declined a request from four Top Senate Democrats to investigate how the white house has handled security clearances for Jared Kushner, ivanka trump, and others. That watchdog, the Inspector General of the Intelligence Community said he is willing to investigate, but could only do so if President Trump allows him to. In response, the four democratic u. S. Senators yesterday wrote to the president asking him to authorize a review of those security clearances granted to his daughter and soninlaw. Its another example of how difficult it is of course to conduct oversight during the trump administration. A president who has installed his own family in the positions of power. As we already said, as we already know, the white house overturned the recommendation to deny kushners security clearance application last year, which was rejected due to, quote, questions about his familys business, his foreign contacts, his foreign travel, and meetings he had during the campaign. So a couple of questions here in terms of the smell test. Why is Jared Kushner unable to get a normal security clearance . What is there stinking about his background that stops the president s soninlaw from getting approval to do this work . Well, foreign officials have been caught in intercepts by the u. S. Intelligence community discussing ways that they can actually leverage Jared Kushners business ties so that they can influence him. He can be leveraged. Basically, that he could be blackmailed. His foreign contacts and the fact that he failed to document them on his security clearance application the first time around, over 100 foreign contacts he had he just left off raised obvious red flags, because obviously, if youre going to have access to classified information and youre constantly talking to foreigners who have incentive to blackmail you with certain information, especially related to your money, then that is going to prompt career Security Officials to say we need to take a second look at this. And ivanka, just by virtue of being married to Jared Kushner might have issues of her own there too. You know, carlos, we didnt elect a family. We elected one guy in the electoral college. It seems like he has outsourced the stuff of power that he has given to jared is unbelievable. Jared is cooking up what he thinks is a middle east deal for peace which i dont think is going anywhere because its not creating a palestinian state. He is involved with running the 2020 election. He is doing everything in the World Without any kind of portfolio, any kind of responsibility to the public, no accountability. Who is this guy . And he cant even get a security clearance. These are serious problems. Well, chris, i think this is yet another example of how congress has rendered itself impotent and is unable to hold the executive accountable. Over the last few decades, we have seen the growth of the imperial presidency of the United States. Yes. Congress has turned over its constitutional powers and authority to the executive, and now not even congressional intelligence committees can find out why certain people were given security clearances, why the president overruled career staffers. Im not saying congress should have the last word on who gets security clearances. Obviously, any president has the right to build his or her team, but congress should certainly know what concerns exist and what grounds, under what grounds the president or anyone else overruled career staff in handing out security clearances. You know what . Youve just alerted me to the constitutional fact i should have had minded all these years past. The house, the winter games, the Appropriations Committee of the house have absolute power over all government spending, all government taxation. They could stop anything they wanted. They have stopped wars in the past. They could stop this administration in its tracks with its dirty dealing, and theyve been afraid or unable to do it. Theyve been unable to exercise their subpoenas for documents and testimony. Theyve not been able to use the power of the peoples house. And thats a question we have to ask why. Chris, thats not the way our founders designed the government. Congress is the article i institution. Should it be the most powerful. It is the one thats closest and most responsive to the people, and yet they cant do any of the things you just stated. And every day the president guess like this to the u. S. Congress. Thank you former congressman Carlos Curbelo of florida, natasha bertrand, youre a great reporter. Up next, some of the most illuminating moments from the spin room. I worked the midnight shift on these debates. I get to get them after they come out, and sometimes they come in wounded. Youll hear what the candidates said after the debate in the spin room. Youre watching hardball. L. Idle equipment costs you time and money. Thats why United Rentals is combining equipment, data, safety and expertise to help your worksite perform better. United rentals. You only talk about your insurancet, when you complain about it. garbled . Its so painful. Good point thats why esurance is making the whole experience surprisingly painless. So, you never have to talk about it. Unless youre their spokesperson. Esurance. Its surprisingly painless. Woman 1 i had no symptoms of hepatitis c. Man 1 mine. Man 1 . Caused liver damage. Vo epclusa treats all main types of chronic hep c. Vo whatever your type, ask your doctor if epclusa is your kind of cure. Woman 2 i had the common type. Man 2 mine was rare. Vo epclusa has a 98 overall cure rate. Man 3 i just found out about my hepatitis c. Woman 3 i knew for years. Vo epclusa is only one pill, once a day, taken with or without food for 12 weeks. Vo before starting epclusa, your doctor will test if you have had hepatitis b, which may flare up, and could cause serious liver problems during and after treatment. Vo tell your doctor if you have had hepatitis b, other liver or kidney problems, hiv, or other medical conditions. Vo . And all medicines you take, including herbal supplements. Vo taking amiodarone with epclusa may cause a serious slowing of your heart rate. Vo common side effects include headache and tiredness. Vo ask your doctor today, if epclusa is your kind of cure. With advil liquigels, what stiff joints . What bad back . Advil is. Relief thats fast. Strength that lasts. Youll ask. What pain . With advil liquigels. Welcome back to hardball. I spoke to many of the president ial candidates last night in the spin room. Why would you want to bleach the white house . Its already a white house. I was talking about the oval office. Oh. And that is because . Say it there is something unclean about this president . Yes. I think he is degrading not just our country, he is degrading our democracy. You said we have a White Nationalist in the white house. A White Nationalist . Yes. This is a president who has built his political fortunes on white nationalism. Now that is a strong statement, and i make it advisedly. Do you believe biden said it was about weapons of mass destruction . I only sort of voted for inspectors. Everyone knew george bush wanted a war. What i said tonight in my conversation with Vice President biden is look, you know, one of us has learned the lessons of the past. And some of those lessons are that you cant deport your way to the negotiating table with Mitch Mcconnell and the republicans. You said you cant marry obama, basically, mr. President , without defending his deportation decision, his record. Did he defend it today . Did he get back to what he did in terms of counseling the president at the time . I think he needs to speak more candidly about his record. When you say, when you brag all the way up to 2015 and call these bills your bills, he said, his words not mine, every crime bill, major and minor since the 1970s has had my name on it. Now by the way, i think he should call out that he was wrong, but he hasnt even done that. Why did you choose to go after Kamala Harris on her record as attorney general . I think its important for the American People to know what is in her record, that she is so proud of and how it has so negatively impacted peoples lives in california. And when she was in a position of power to do the right thing, she failed to do so. Were not talking about a record of 50 years ago in the case of senator harris. Were talking about her recent record in the last few years. Elizabeth last night saying, you know, well, were not for big ideas. Just because its big doesnt mean its good. For me, a thousand dollars a month is a sweet spot. But this is a move we have to make to build an economy that is actually going to work for news the 21st century. If you cant make this nomination, if you cant win this president ial election and youre an underdog, would you like to see that in the platform . Oh, yeah. In other words, that would be your legacy. I dont buy this analysis already tonight that somehow people were attacking the Obama Administration. We were asking the Vice President about his role on certain policies. You were asking about look, why do we have primaries . You know this so well, because we need to sort this stuff out. Lets have the fight right here in the family. And whoever is the nominee better be ready for donald trump, a low down dirty player. I think you got to know how to answer a question like that. Is he a racist . Yes, he. The microphone that is held by the president of the United States must always be used in a way that is about lifting people up and finding the commonalities between us and talking about that and encouraging americans to see those things we have in common instead of what he has done, which is continually try to sow hate and division among us. It is making us weak. It will make us weak as we go forward, unless we get this guy out of office. I plan to be the next president of the United States, and im going tell you how i use that microphone. It will be about lifting people up and saying hey, guys. The vast majority of us have so much more in common than what separates us, and that is the strength of who we are as a nation. It is so great. I got to tell you professionally oneonone with these very ambitious people who all want to lead our country. Senator Kamala Harris there and several of the other candidates with me last night in detroit. Up next, President Trump is holding a Campaign Rally right now as we speak in cincinnati. Were going hear more of that send her back chant crap. If so, will trump do anything to discourage it . Will we have a john mccain moment when he says no . Youre watching hardball. Re w. Humira patients, you inspire us. The way you triumph over adversity. And live your lives. Thats why we redesigned humira. We wanted to make the experience better for you. Now theres less pain immediately following injection. Weve reduced the size of the needle and removed the citrate buffers. And it has the same effectiveness you know and trust. Humira citratefree is here. A little change can make a big difference. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections. Serious and sometimes fatal infections, including tuberculosis, and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened, as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Ask your doctor about humira citratefree. Heres to you. My car insurance, so i only pay for what i need. And this is me now any physical changes to this mans appearance are purely coincidental. Only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Welcome back to hardball. Right now President Trumps hosting a rally in cincinnati, and the big question tonight is whether the president will let when referring to minnesota ck congresswoman ilhan omar. His closest advisers tell the Associated Press that even they are uncertain what he is going to do. In this cincinnati rally by the way comes after weeks of deepening divisions fanned by a series of racist president ial tweets directed at now, count them, five minority members of congress. It started when President Trump tweeted that a group of minority congresswomen, three of them born in the u. S. , should go back. Those are his words, to the crime infested places they came from. Well, last month while in north carolina, his audience chanted send her back. Obviously and importantly, omar has a history of launching official antisemitic screeds. Send her back send her back send her back send her back send her back send her back well, President Trump at first disavowed those chants, only to double down on them a day later. What if you asked him to stop saying them . It was quite a chant. And i felt a little bit badly about it, but i will say this. I did, and i started speaking very quickly. But it started up rather fast, as you probably know. So youll tell your supporters never to say that again . Well, i wont say that i was not happy with it. I disagree with it. But, again, i didnt say i didnt say that. They did. Those people in north carolina, those are incredible people. Those are incredible patriots. Well, this week he went full throttle on his racially incendiary language, insulting baltimore, the city, as a disgusting rat and rodent infested mess and attacking its congressman, Elijah Cummings, calling him a racist who should pay more attention to his district than his oversight duties. The Cincinnati EnquirerEditorial Board has implored the president to take the higher road tonight in his rally in this city, writing, quote, america doesnt need to see another raucous sideshow. A brotherhood to bring this Community Back together. We dont need more inflammatory rhetoric that puts us at one anothers throats. Stay tuned after this break to find out what he did or didnt to heed that warning. Youre watching hardball. Hmm. Exactly. Liberty mutual customizes your car insurance, so you only pay for what you need. Nice. But, uh. Whats up with your. Partner . Not again. Limu thats your reflection. Only pay for what you need. Liberty, liberty, liberty, liberty were going all in thion strawberries. Ra, at their reddest, ripest, they make everything better. Like our strawberry poppyseed salad and new strawberry summer caprese salad. Order online for delivery. Panera. Food as it should be introducing zero account fees for brokerage accounts. And zero minimums to open an account. At fidelity, those zeros really add up. Maybe ill win, saved by zero before discovering nexium 24hr to treat her frequent heartburn, marie could only imagine enjoying freshly squeezed orange juice. Now no fruit is forbidden. Nexium 24hr stops acid before it starts for allday, allnight protection. Can you imagine 24 hours without heartburn . For allday, allnight protection. Doctor bob, what should i take for back pain . Before you take anything, i recommend applying topical relievers first. Salonpas lidocaine patch blocks pain receptors for effective, nonaddictive relief. Salonpas lidocaine. Patch, rollon or cream. Hisamitsu. You get more than yourFree Shipping. Ir, you get everything you need for your home at a great price, the way it works best for you, ill take that. Wait honey, no. When you want it. You get a delivery experience you can always count on. You get your perfect find at a price to match, on your own schedule. You get fast and Free Shipping on the things that make your home feel like you. Thats what you get when youve got wayfair. So shop now pirate girl ahoy gotcha girl nooooooooooooo man nooooo vo quick, the quicker picker upper bounty picks up messes quicker, and is two times more absorbent. Bounty, the quicker picker upper. Its how we care for our patients like job. His team at ctca treated his cancer and side effects. So job can stay strong for his family. Cancer Treatment Centers of america. Appointments available now. Welcome back to hardball. Tonight, as i said, President Trump is holding a rally in cincinnati, a state he won in ohio of course by eight points in 2016. Its the state his Campaign Sees as crucial to getting reelected. The rally follows this weeks debate of the democrats who want to replace him in the white house. For more im joined by sam stein, daily beast politics editor and joel pine, democratic strategist. Do either of you know whether this is the end of the line for trump, that he is not going to go any further on this racial fever betting thing . Is he going to say okay, i went too far by pulling out these four women by saying they should go back to the countries they came from, which is the United States in most cases, going after a very popular statesman from maryland, Elijah Cummings. Is he going to say you know what . This is going to kill me among whites in the suburb. You cant be overly racist. You cant have people expect to like you if you call yourself a racist or act like one. There is one thing known for trump. He is known for introspection and insight. Thing is something guttural. He cannot deny it or contain it. People have been telling him forever tone it down. Youre making too big splash, youre risking too much politically, but he cant help it. A lot of people ascribe this to some grand strategy about ginning up the base, and maybe that is there. But my suspicion is and from talking to people who know him, this is just who he is. He cant stop it nor will he. High,er is trump moments ago talking about the squad. Thats the four women, of course, on the Progressive Side of the Democratic Party and american cities. Lets watch them and then joel responds. The are Democrat Party is now being led by four leftwing extremists who reject everything that we hold dear. No one has paid a higher price for the far lefts destructive agenda than americans riving in our nations inner cities. They have paid a dear price. You see whats happening. You see our inner cities. We spend billions and billions and billions for years and years and years, and its stolen money, and its wasted money, and its a shame. Well, thats the historic attitude of the suburbs towards the big city machines. We all know that. He makes its an ethnic thing here. Its familiar language. Chris, im thinking about this entire thing. This president , normally when you get this kind of language, its from a lee atwater, like a faceless adviser in the background. Its from jesse helms or George Wallace like a regional politician. Even when Ronald Reagan didnt the welfare queens, he wasnt president then. He was a candidate or a young buck. But usually you dont get this type of did you read what happened today in the paper . The negative, recall the monkeys in africa and tanzania. I would say deserved a little more credit than that. He is a great leader. But you get the point. Generally speaking the leader of the free world, the leader of the Republican Party or the Democratic Party, they dont speak like this. We saw some rough housing at the rally already tonight. And its just scary because you dont know how people get ginned up by this, and you dont know where it stops. You asked the question at the beginning. Is this the end . I dont think we can say that. He has no there is no pit. There is no bottom to the Bottomless Pit that donald trump thinks is in bounds or out of bounds. There is some boundary to him. He seems to go after states he doesnt have a prayer of getting, new york state, maryland, chicago. Sure. He doesnt go after states like ohio, which he desperately needs or florida, which he desperately needs or measure, pennsylvania, ohio. Using it last night. But he goes after states he knows are off the scope for him. Every now and then hell slip. Once he called New Hampshire drug infested and he made fun of the people of iowa, but those are slips and he always kind of walks back those comments to your point, this is calculated in the sense he knows these are states he can write off. Inner cities are places he can write off. Back to you, joel. Look, im in broadcasting for 25 years now. I know the danger of saying things, because you Say Something or somebody is the bad guy, they can say oh, theyre the bad guy and a little flipped out . They go after them. What happens if somebody gets hurt here . Is trump going to take the responsibility . Its at his feet, but he is not going take the responsibility. The only thing he is better at than ginning up crowds is passing responsibility. We know people have gotten hurt. There is documented stat occasional. Weve seen biden uptick. I would say there is a Straight Line between the president being more erratic and biden going up in the polls. The higher the stakes, the safer the bet. Thank you, sam stein. Thank you, joel payne. Up next, the importance of choosing sunlight over darkness. Youre watching hardball. L. More, more, more how do you like it, how do you like it more, more, more how do you like it, how do you like it all you can eat is back. How do you like that . Applebees. Now thats eatin good in the neighborhood. Whyou should be mad that airports are complicated. Hes my emotional support snake. But youre not, because you have e trade, whose tech isnt complicated. It helps you understand the risk and reward potential on an options trade. Dont get mad. Get e trade. Would shakespeare have chosen just some pens . Methinks a tul pen would serve mlady well. Thanks. And a unicorn notebook get everything on your list. This weeks doorbuster School Backpacks for 10; 10 in store or online from the advisors at office depot officemax. Liberty mutual customizes your car insurance, so you only pay for what you need. I wish i could shake your hand. Granted. Only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Our mission is to provide complete, balanced nutrition for strength and energy whoohoo greattasting ensure. With nine grams of protein and twentysix vitamins and minerals. Ensure, for strength and energy. And twentysix vitamins and minerals. Has four levels of defenseremium gasoagainst gunk, wear, corrosion and friction. That helps keep your Engine Running like new. Its fuel for thought. Here, hello starts with hi mple. How can i help . A data plan for everyone. Everyone . Everyone. Lets send to everyone [ camera clicking ] wifi up there . Ahhh. Sure, why not . Howd he get out . a camera might figure it out. That was easy glad i could help. At xfinity, were here to make life simple. Easy. Awesome. So come ask, shop, discover at your xfinity store today. Today i saw a splash of sunlight in whats been a grim democratic tussle for president. Joe biden went out into the streets of detroit today, his face toward the sun, took questions from a gaggle of reporters. In an instant, something was different. In place of the mean backbiting of last night, the nasty nitpicking shots back and forth between him and an assortment on both sides, i saw optimism today, optimism that democrats, the party of opposition, had the good humor, the hopeful nature to show daylight to a country so dismally denied it by the dark curtain of the trump era. Hope. Hope itself is the heart of the Democratic Party. Hope that things will get better. Hope for all the families that came here over the decades. Hope for all the families who have pulled themselves up over the generations with the help of Government Programs like the gi bill and Social Security and low interest Student Loans and medicare. Hope that because of this combined effort, the government and the country itself will become a better place for all its many peoples. I understand politics too. I understand what the challenges and why the challenges to the frontrunner joe biden have to hurt him and his legacy to get their shot. I understand the people now getting 1 or less in the National Polls need to get up to 2 , and the surest way to score a goal is to attack the frontrunner. I know that that being the goal, the frontrunner joe biden has to spend his valuable debate time defending his ole record rather than posting an agenda for the future. I know all this politics, but it sure doesnt look good, doesnt serve us as an uplifting couple of hours, doesnt show me the route to victory. Or if it does, it shows only a road that leads through more national division, including an assault on president obama and even more destruction of our national unity. As the Washington Post dan balz put it together, democrats took the stage last night without offering much in the way of an aspirational message or connecting directly with the voters they will need to win the president ial election. So count me in. I like more of the joe biden i saw today with his sun in the face facing that gaggle of reporters than i did watching him as a halting target in last nights human crow shoot. Ive argued for years the person who wins president ial election series the one outside facing the American People, talking about the future with the sun in their face. We thank god are simply that kind of people, which is why we are too good of people to keep donald trump as our president. And thats hardball for now. Thanks for being with us. All in with chris hayes starts right now. Tonight on all in mr. Vice president , there is a saying in my community, youre dipping into kool aid and flav. Round two is over. We have a predator living in the white house. Tonight the big takeaways. I get a little bit tired of democrats afraid of big ideas. The competing visions for democratic leadership. I dont understand why anybody goes to all the trouble of running for president of the United States just to talk what we really cant do and shouldnt fight for. And the frontrunners simple case for his nomination. I promise you if i get the nomination, i will win michigan. And then