Transcripts For MSNBCW Hardball With Chris Matthews 20171116

For me, the judge has 24 obamacare. This is really awful. Hours. Theyre paying by those tax you Must Immediately and fully breaks by taking away the come up with a satisfactory underpinnings of obamacare, the Affordable Care action. Explanation for your this is hardball, where the action is. Inconsistencies that i just showed. You must remove any doubt. If you cant do this, then judge moore needs to get out of this race. While there have been reports that steve bannon is weighing in, whether to ditch or weighing whether to ditch moore, dad molly trash nbc reports for now, hes standing by moore. Despite all the pressure, moore is defiant. Whoo hes denied the allegations and he tweeted today, we believe in god, the constitution, the sanctity of life, and the sanctity of marriage. We are everything the washington elite hates. They will do whatever it takes to stop us. Mom hey, molly . Its time to go we will not quit. Well, last night judge moore bell ringing joked about his situation. Class, lets turn to page 136, obviously, ive made a few recessive traits skip generations. People mad. Who would like to read . Im the only one that can unite democrats and republicans. Molly i reprogrammed the robots to do the inspection. Its running much faster now. Because i seem to be opposed by see . Its amazing, molly. Both. Why do you think theyre giving thank you. Me this trouble . why do you think im being harassed by the media and by ltry align probiotic. N your digestive system . Thank you. For a nonstop, sweet treat goodness, people pushing forward hold on to your tiara kind of day. Allegations in the last 28 days get 24 7 digestive support, with align. Of this election . This is not just a battle for the 1 doctor recommended probiotic brand. Democrats and republicans and how they vote on issues. Also in kids chewables. This is a spiritual battle. Well, nbc news spoke with one of moores accusers, leigh corfman, who said moore pursued her hen she was 14 years old. Moore has denied that charge today. She told nbc, i stand by the story, its absolutely true. Tive nothing to gain, nothing to lose. Meanwhile, there are two very different pictures about where this race stands. A new public poll in alabama shows moore, judge moore, leading his democratic challenger by six points, thats six points past doug jones. But nbc news obtained part of a poll taken by the National Republican Senatorial Committee which rescinded its support for mo moore. It shows the republican firebrand trailing jones by 12 points. Are they putting out bad news on this guy on purpose to get him out of the race . The committee isnt sharing the rest of the poll nor is it saying which polling firm actually conducted the poll, which is very sneaky. Anyway, also this evening, two additional accusers have come forward, as i said. In a new report from al. Com, one woman accused moore of groping her in his law office back in its whats inside isthe person who opens it. X. 1991. Give ancestrydna, another woman said she was 17 the only dna test that can trace your origins when a 35yearold roy moore asked her on date. To over 150 ethnic regions. She said she turned him down and he walked away. Save 20 for the holidays well, nbc news reached o out to at ancestrydna. Com. The campaign for a response. Sof so far, we have not heard back. Ana claire is with the paper that broke that story. Brett stevens, a columnist with the new york times. Let me go to ana claire. Tell us about the two separate cases. They are different types of inappropriate behavior and some of it felonious, some of it not. But what do you make of it . Tell us about them . You know, i would not have reported on it if i did not find both of these women credible. One of them reached o out to me, wanting to tell her story. The other one, i was directed to by another person that i had been talking with. And i reached out to her. And she finally decided she wanted to tell her story. Its my job to be skeptical about these things, but as i dug into it and spoke with them several times and did my research, i found what they had to say very credible. Well, the first one was a mature woman in her 20s, who you said, what did he do improper . Just describe the improper behavior there . Oh, sure. She had gone to his law office in gadston, alabama, with her mother, to sign some papers, regarding a custody situation. Her mother had hired roy moore welcome back to hardball. Now that President Trump is back at the time he was a private from his marathon tour of asia, attorney, to handle this. Which produced few concrete and they went to the office to accomplishments, his fixit sign papers. Skills will quickly be put to he immediately started flirting the test. With her, she said. In washington, republicans still have to pass an unpopular tax she said he told her how pretty she was, that she had beautiful bill that now includes the eyes. She said he asked her out on a repeal of the Affordable Care date, those kind of things. Acts individual mandate. And then when they were done, recent polling shows that voters they got up to leave, her mother reject the plan by a 21 margin. Walked out the door first. The republican plan. She walked out and roy moore, for more, im joined by the roundtable tonight, our she said, was behind her and hardball roundtable includes that he grabbed her bottom. Rosie gray, White House Correspondent for the the atlantic. Msnbc political analyst, ely and the other case was more like the other ones, with a teenage girl, older man type stoeblgs of tthe wall street situation. Yeah, she was a she was a hostess at the red lobster in journa journal. I want to focus on one thing gadston, she was 17, a high tonight, we dont have a whole lot of time. School senior. She said he walked up to her one its this statement to finance day in the restaurant and hes tax cuts for the capitalist pretty well known around there class by getting rid of the individual mandate, which back then, and he asked her out basically knocks about 4 Million People off medicare, off of on a date, she says. And she said she told him, do obamacare, just knocks them off, you know how old i am . Because the young and Healthy People are not going to go into this thick without some and she said that he said, yes, incentive. I go out with girls your age all let me go to what do you make the time. Wow. Of that, ruth or rather, ely . Let me go to sam stein on this. Thanks for that reporting. Well be back to you in a i think assist poiszen pill for democrats, it so makes it moment. This seems to be all of us are pretty distant from this harder for democrats to get the case. Its years ago, but the pattern is so strong. Votes. When they tried to do anything in his 30s, he was known to be on obamacare, they couldnt somebody that had to be banned secure 50 republican votes on that. So i think it just complicates this. The politics are complicated. From a local shopping mall, we understand the republicans are desperate for some sort of sounds like a nice place to hang out for teenagers. Win on tax reform at the end of what was he hanging out there the year. But again, you showed the poll. For . And why did he have to be 24 of americans actually banned, which is an amazing atrocious situation. Approve of this plan rate now. If thats their win, its not a grown man with a law degree, an assistant d. A. , even, having going to be pumuch of a win. To be physically banned from a public space because of his let me go to telu. What do you make of this what horrible behavior, his trolling do you make of the fact that you behavior. Thats very hard to deny as a take away the individual fact, it seems to me. Mandate, which i was always for, if you hear this from so many hillary was always for. People. Well, i think it would because you cant get people who certainly be a senatorial first, are young, restless, and healthy to take out insurance until theyre getting a little sick, a if he were elected, the first little more vulnerable. Person ever banned from a and if you have an Insurance Plan based on only sick and more shopping, but accepted by the. Vulnerable people nit, it really and voters, i suppose. You know, the reporting, i isnt an Insurance Plan, its a think the process of the reporting in this story is Maintenance Program for unHealthy People, for older whats critical to this story. People. Thats what it becomes. Thats exactly right, chris. Which is the reporters have been on the ground. You can expect democrats, theyve been hearing these consumer groups, Health Care Groups to come out furiously things, rumors, stories. Against this bill. And theyve been following it up this is really a redux of skinny diligently by talking to people, repeal, which went down in getting them on the record, and then corroborating their stories flames earlier, earlier this were sources. Year. The Health Care Bill that the this is what Good Journalism is republican tried to put through about. And i know that Roy Moore Says earlier this year was unpopular. That this is all fake news and this tax bill is unpopular. That this is part of the now theyre putting the two establishment media. But these are people not in together. And what do you get . Nothing but a very unpopular washington, d. C. Or in new york bill. City or the acela court. You can expect there to be these are people going to furious backlash against the alabama, talking to locals in idea of taking Health Care Away from potentially 13 million alabama, listening to the people by getting rid of this stories that alabamians tell them and reporting it. Mandate and also increasing and i think thats where roy premiums by 10 . Not something that people are moores problem is, is that this going to be happy about. Isnt a concocted story. And especially when its for this is something that has, Corporate Tax cuts. Rosie, lets go into the unearthed, that was in his past, Industrial Areas where trump was but that people apparently knew able to win the election in the about and are just speaking up Electoral College last year. About now. Im thinking wisconsin, brett, you know, ive been pennsylvania, ohio, indiana, these places you tell those trying to figure out politics middle class and working class since world war ii as a kid. People up there that dont have and theres a certain pattern. Thurns because its opinion its what side are you on . Undermined by the president to its gotten more vicious lately, finance wealthy tax breaks, what but its almost like facts dont do you think . Is that going to even be anything more than laughed at . Matter. You say, sos your old man to the other side and stick to your well, look, i mean, its clear that this tax plan polling side. Is there a Tipping Point . Has shown that its unpopular. But i think that the republicans something that even the are thinking to themselves that altright, or something that the if they dont get something hard right wont accept . Passed on this, theyll have is this a case where people like Mitch Mcconnell, and hes pretty gone the entire first year of prudish, i think, on these kind trumps presidency without a of things, which i like, has major legislative been over the years, has been accomplishment. So i think there is a thought written up, is this one of those cases where you dont just say, screw you, youre on the other that politically its advantageous to get something done, get something on the board. But something very unpopular side, youre the sblimestablish youre the elite, im sticking like this, thats very selfdefeating. With my guy. Sometimes its better to do is there a Tipping Point . Nothing than anything. I think the precedent here is up next, well get some scoops from these people well be 1991 when david duke was running for governor of louisiana and george h. W. Bush and the rest of talking about. Youre watching hardball. Sactn the republican establishment got secure from hacks and threats others cant see. Sactn this is a skyscraper whose elevators use iot data behind his democratic rival, because duke, of course, was so and ai to help thousands get to work safely and efficiently. Toxic to the republican brand. And i think moore is just about this is not the cloud you know. This is the ibm cloud. Meeting that test. The ibm cloud is the cloud for business. On the other hand, i feel, i have mixed feelings about the yours. Republicans trying to take a mulligan on moore. Hes the guy they nominated. He was already a fairly wellknown quantity, even before the recent charges came to light. They should own this kind of candidate, if only as a lesson in the kind of politics that people like steve bannon are indulging. Someone, at some point, republicans so learn the lesson that if they go with candidates like moore, theyre going end to up with results like this. Well, thats a hard you have to hold on to the guy, no matter how bad he looks, because youve got to teach yourself how bad he looks. Anyway i understand. Well get back to that. I think we have seen for years now, decades now, the weaknesses of the american political establishment in spades. We have seen how bad the leaderships are. What comes to mind . How boring they are, how cold toast they are. Your next getaway . They say nothing new, except how connecting with family and friends . To raise money, the latest way to do it. And now were learning the a big night out . Downside of the outsider. Or maybe your everyday shopping. Anyway, republicans in washington continue to jump whatever it is, ship, as i said. Aarp member advantages can help save you time lae lets watch it. Weve got a disturbing and money along the way. Situation in alabama. So when you get there, are you going to write in you can enjoy it all the more. Yourself . Im not going to write myself for less. In. I wouldnt do that. Surround yourself with savings but i will be writing in as a at aarp advantages dot com. Distinguished republican. I met a lot of people on the to find smarter solutions. To offer more precise and less invasive Treatment Options than before. Ball, iand if you get kicked ou of the ball, thats a pretty bad like advanced Genomic Testing and immunotherapy. Situation to find yourself in. I dont want the republican see how were fighting to outsmart cancer at party to tolerate behavior like this when its just overwhelming that the man has a problem. Cancercenter. Com outsmart believe that it was appropriate for me to withdraw my endorsement and i think its the Energy Conscious whopeople among usle . Obviously in the hands of the voters on december the 11th. Say small actions can add up to something. Humongous. If the choice is between a democrat and roy moore, i would choose the democrat. A little thing here. I got to give some praise to a little thing there. Lindsey graham. Starts to feel like a badge maybe millions can wear. He has a sense of humor. Almost anybody can hang around a shopping mall. Who are all these caretakers, advocates too . Theres no standards of admission and to find that turns out, its californians youve been banned from a shopping mall. Its me and its you. Anyway, there are no indications dont stop now, republicans in alabama are divorcing themselves from moore. Its easy to add to the routine. Join Energy Upgrade california the chair of the state party had and do your thing. This warning for republicans in the state even considering endorsing a third party candidate. Quote, it would be a serious error for any current elected gop official or candidate to publicly endorse another partys candidate, an independent, a third party, or a writein candidate in a general election as well. I have heard of no gop elected official or candidate that is even considering this option. Well, under Alabama Republican Party rules, the party can keep any candidate off the ballot for six years if they publicly support another candidate other than the republican. Anita, what do we know about that. Is there political news down there . I know youre covering the misbehavior front, the serious stuff, but anything in the politics down there that would allow the republicans to get were back with the through this and still have a roundtable. Rosie, tell me something i dont know. A story that didnt get much republican senator from, richard notice today is that the russian shelby from alabama . Parliament has passed a law that would require foreign Media Companies to register as foreign the national gop leader soon agents in retaliation for rt having to register as a foreign to be jumping ship, but down agent in the u. S. Here, a lot of the we really and so i think that that will be havent heard anything like that a sort of interesting dynamic to from local republican leaders. Watch as the sort of broader russia story plays out. I believe even as recently as they have no idea what a free press is. Anyway, thank you. Early this afternoon. Eli . Everyone pays such close leaders from some of our largest counties, one up in north attention to the theatrics at the white house that oftentimes things that are happening at the alabama, and one Shelby County near birmingham have come out agencies get overlooked. Today, the interior department, the fish and Wildlife Service supporting moore. Overturned another obamaera so he does still have a lot of move that basically barred the support here on the ground from importing of elephantlion gop. And big Game Trophies from some anna claire, explain that. Is it his history, his legacy . Places in africa. Now they reversed that. What is it that they like about they can go over there and bring him that allows them to get past those things back. This real embarrassment, i would koconservationists are really say at the minimum . Upset about that. You mean, trump has legalized hes been talking about things that alabama voters care the ivory trade . About for decades. Essentially, yes. He was around, he was he was thats a fairly rotten thing roy moore long before steve to do. Bannon or anybody else came so he wants to eliminate a species known as the elephant . Around. And he people like his got very little coverage outsiderness. And i think now maybe even more today, but conservation groups than ever, and hes been talking are pretty upset about it. One of the more despicable about, you know, the constitution. Pictures i ever saw, and i dont he talks a lot about his faith. Mind talking about his family in and those are things that alabama voters really care this case, is the picture of his sons over there standing over about. Some dead animals that they and i think its hard for them to separate in their mind now killed. Its unbelievable. Ny, toluse. The roy moore that they think they have known for three or more decades with what theyre in deep red oklahoma, hearing now. Well, heres how desperate democrats flipped a state senate this case has come to be for roy moore and his lawyer. Heres his attorney, appearing seat. It was a seat that went for on msnbc earlier today with ali donald trump by over 30 points pap democrat newcomer took that velshi and stephanie ruhle. Sneet and democrats are looking when the lawyer was asked about at that saying its a sign that moores comments that he didnt theres going to be a big wave remember dating teenage girls, in 2018. He strangely alluded to ali thank you all. Velshis own, quote, background, up next, ill speak with a man who was there, in the firing closed quote. Lets take a look at this rough line when robert f. Kennedy was exchange here. If roy moore doesnt assassinated. Vince depiero caught bobby right remember, how could he say that after he was shot and mortally its definitively false . Wounded. He tells his story, coming up and number two, why would he next. This is hardball, where the action is. Need permission from any of and youre talking to your rheumatologist these girls mothers if they about a medication, werent underage . Sure. This is humira. Thats a good question. And culturally speaking, i would this is humira helping to relieve my pain say theres differences, looked and protect my joints from further irreversible damage. Up alis background there, and this is humira helping me reach for more. Wow, thats awesome that you have got such a diverse humira has been clinically studied for over 20 years. Background. Its really cool to read through that. What does alis background humira works for many adults. Have to do with dating a it targets and blocks a specific source of inflammation that contributes to ra symptoms. 14yearold . Im not finished with the humira can lower your ability to fight infections, context of it. Well, please answer. What does ali velshis including tuberculosis. Background have to do with serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, dating under children, including lymphoma, have happened, as have blood, liver and nervous system problems, 14yearold girls . Sure. In other countries, theres serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Arrangement through parents for what we would before treatment, get tested for tb. Alis from canada. Alis from canada. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas i understand that. Where certain fungal infections are common, and alis also spent time in other countries. And if youve had tb, so have i. Its not a bad thing. Hepatitis b, are prone to infections, i dont know where youre or have flulike symptoms or sores. Going with this. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Sam, what do you make of talk to your doctor and visit humira. Com. This . Theyre trying to talk about this is humira at work. Countries where they have harems and typically stuff we dont like, and therefore, hes saying you or joints. Something for your heart. Ali comes from a background but do you take something for your brain. Thats different from the with an ingredient originally found in jellyfish, caucasian world of north america. Whatever theyre up to, i dont prevagen is the number one selling brainhealth supplement know ma hes up to. In drug stores nationwide. That maybe he would be more prevagen. The name to remember. Sympathetic, or could be accused of being more sympathetic to the idea of going out with 14yearolds . I mean, im speechless. Its just like. Well, you know what youre speechless, sam, but [burke] abstract accident. Seen videoit. Covered it. C you know and i know what he was we know a thing or two because weve seen a thing or two. Up to everyone knows what he was up we are farmers. Bumpadum, bumbumbumbum to. Its racism, basically. But it also doesnt make any sense . Is he saying that roy moore is acceptable because someone of indian descent has got a culture i just cant even welcome back to hardball. On june 4th, 1968, Bobby Kennedy put i cant draw the lines together in my head. Maybe im slow, but it doesnt won the decisive california make any sense. And i think its indicative of president ial primary. And after midnight, he stood with his wife, ethel, before a the great hole in which roy ballroom of cheering supporters. Moore finds himself. And yes, this may be passable his victory signaled he now had a good chance to win the for the voters of alabama in the end, but he still has to democratic president ial contest, if he were to win, he nomination. Then came the horror. Still will have to contest with leaving the ballroom through the kitchen, bobby was shot and what happened should he come to mortally wounded. Washington, d. C. And this is going to be a rude standing near him was 19yearold vincent depiero. Awakening for roy moore. And youre not going to be able hes here with us right now. To insult ali velshis heritage vincent, thank you for joining as a way out of it. I think were going to have us. The reason im inviting you, the to call this, sam, the lowell other night when i was speaking abner defense. About Bobby Kennedy, the moderator asked if anyone was in were out here in the holler and we do things different out here. The theater the night that come on, give me a break. Kennedy was shot and you said you were. So tell us what you told me the anna claire, thank you so much, other night about why you were and sam stein, as always, and brett stevens. There, what happened. Coming up, much more on roy moore, of course. Well, i was working for the latest allegations and the new counterattack his team and Robert Kennedy from the interesting silence from the great tweeter. Approximately april 1st until ron reagan is going to be with june 5th. Us coming up in a minute. Plus, the hardball roundtable and i had no intention, really, and the troubles ahead for trump of even being at the event. Now that hes in washington. He and his party are doubling and my dad, who was the maltre down on their plan to kill obamacare at the same time they d for the hotel, he said that want to give rich people a tax cut. And big show tonight, a big robert had asked where was i . Moment. A witness to an assassination. Well talk to the man who caught and i said, well, you know, tell Bobby Kennedy, caught him physically when he was shot a him im studying for my finals. The ambassador hotel. So i kept doing that and doing vincente detiero held bobby up that and finally, after three after the assassins bullets hit him. Finally, let me finish times, he said, roberts really tonight with my reflections on that fateful night in 1968. This is hardball, where the pis r action is. Pissed off, you better come im open to that. Down. So around a quarter after 11 00 lower premiums . Extra benefits . That night, i got dressed, went its open enrollment. Down to the hotel. And i got there around a quarter time to open the laptop. And compare Medicare Health plans. Why . Because plans change, so can your health needs. Of midnight. And my dad said, do you want to go up and get him with me . So, be openminded. And i said, no, ill wait down look at everythinglike Prescription Drug plans. Here. So when he came down in the and Medicare Advantage plans from private insurers. Elevator from the room service, he looked at me and he goes, oh, use the tools at medicare. Gov. Or call 1800medicare. I see you made it. And i said, yeah. Open to Something Better . And he says, he said, that start today. Didnt sound affirmative. And i said, well, i do want to really go. We were going to the factory, which was a private club for a party after. This job that they created to do Online Grocery grocery. And he says, ill see you in a little bit. And he went up and through the and to have that oneonone experience with the customers, kitchen, we made a path, and he hes meant for it. Went up on to the stage. From the bottom of the stage, and then he made the speech. He was supposed to come back down the same way. And at the last minute, he was im joey gabe, personal shopper for walmart told they were going to do a and i love to see a smile on my customers face. Press conference. So he turned around and walked through the back of the stage. At that point, i went running into the anteroom, as he was coming down the incline, and i during the 2016 republican put my arm around him and as we primary, donald trump repeatedly mocked lil marco rubio, he were going through the anteroom, called him, even poking fun at as we called it, there was a the senator for his water break double doors going into the during the state of the union response. Heres trump. When they put marco on to pantry and paul schrade actually refute president obamas speech, got in between me and robert, do you remember that and i knew paul, because he had catastrophe . Worked with the auto union, so and hes like, and we will, uh, he was okay to be there. And so, i was walking through, uh, i need water, help me, i need water robert shook my hand as we help passed the swinging doors, and hes this is on live turned to the other people on television its rubio his left, made some handshakes, and as he released his hand from jesse perez, which was a dishwasher, he i saw this gun so anyway, today at the white house, trump had his own rubio literally come up from the right moment. Lets watch. Japanese companies have side of my eye and it was sirhan announced investments in the and the gun literally was inches United States worth more than 8 away from his head. When the first shot rang out, i billion. 17,000 jobs. Got splattered with the splash thank you. They dont have water. Of blood from his head. Thats okay. The second shot his hands what . Oh, its okay. Went up to his head. The second shot, i didnt see. It went right in it looked o like it hit him in his left excuse me, his right arm. He went limp and he started oh. Well, senator rubio responded falling backwards towards me. On twitter, saying that the president , quote, needs work on and the third shot went through his form. It has to be done in one single the top of his jacket, hit pall motion and eyes should never leave the camera. Schrade in the head. Now i had Robert Kennedy in the but not bad for his first time. Rubios getting funny. Middle of me, i had paul schrade well be right back. Wondering, what if . On my left. I let go of all those feelings. And carl yuker was trying to subdue sirhan and banging the because i am cured with harvoni. Gun on the table. Harvoni is a revolutionary and what was terrible was that every time that gun was banged treatment for the most common on the table, the bullet went type of chronic hepatitis c. You know, the shot was came its been prescribed to more than a quarter Million People. And is proven to cure up to out. 99 of patients who have had no and so for seven of the eight prior treatment with 12 weeks. Shots, i actually shot come out certain patients can be cured of that gun. With just 8 weeks of harvoni. That was, for a 19yearold, before starting harvoni, that was quite horrific. Your doctor will test to see if did you catch senator kennedy youve ever had hepatitis b, as he fell . Which may flare up and cause what were you doing at that serious liver problems during moment . And after harvoni treatment. Yeah, as he came back with tell your doctor if youve his hands up to his head, he ever had hepatitis b, a liver transplant, other liver or kidney problems, fell backwards and i put my arms hiv or any other medical conditions and about all out, and i caught him. The medicines you take including herbal supplements. And as the third shot rang out taking amiodarone with harvoni can cause a serious slowing and paul got hit in the head he of your heart rate. Common side effects of harvoni fell on top of me and my left include tiredness, headache and weakness. Side and now im going down on ready to let go of hep c . My left side with paul and i ask your hep c specialist about harvoni. Have robert in my hands. And were now almost on the floor. Ira goldstein was walking away from the shooting and he got shot and then he fell on top of me on my right side. So i had paul schrade on my left, Robert Kennedy in the middle of me, and i had Ira Goldstein on my right. So i was in the middle of all of that on the familiar. Did you have do you have any after all of these years, do you have any doubt from the beginning that it was Sirhan Sirhan who shot and killed and mortally wounded Robert Kennedy . No, i have zero doubt. The reason being, according to the testimony that i gave, and i didnt testimony that i gave and i didnt realize it at the time, i was the only witness who had the only unobstructed view of the first shot and that first shot is what killed Robert Kennedy. And the only Person Holding that gun was sirhan. And the only one aiming a gun, no one else present with a gun . No, i didnt see anybody else welcome back to hardball. With a gun. There was a Security Guard who even before those latest had a gun but he didnt carry allegations against Alabama Republican Senate candidate, roy moore, advisers to moore a. 22. It was a. 38 and that was a launched their own counter attack against one of moores hotel Security Guard and i dont accusers. Ive traveled with judge believe he ever fired a gun moore all over the state, in different states across the nation. Ive been with him probably over his gun at that time. 100 different meetings and been there was balloons popping. There was a lot of noise. Around probably in excess of it was chaos and many people 10,000 different ladies in judge said, oh, theres more than moores presence. And not once, not one time have i ever seen him act even eight shots. I dont know. Remotely inappropriate against any women. It was so much bedlam and so toward any women. Well, Beverly Young nelson difficult and a 19yearold is not exactly paying attention to said on monday, she was sexually assaulted by moore when she was all this. I was lucky i was alive. 16, when he offered her a ride i was very lucky i lived through home from her job at a restaurant. That because i the shirt i she spoke with reporters while was wearing actually has a accompanied by her attorney, bullet hole through it. Gloria allred. Thank you. Mr. Moore reached over and stay with us. Back with you in a moment. I want to talk to you about began groping me. Him putting his hands on my Bobby Kennedys last words. You were there. Well be right back. Breasts. I tried to open my car door to leave, but he reached over and he locked it so i could not get out. I tried fighting him off while yelling at him to stop. But instead of stopping, he began squeezing my neck, attempting to force my head on to his crotch. At some point, he gave up he then looked at me and he told me, he said, youre just a child and he said, i am the District Attorney of etowah county. Well, nelson also said that moore even signed her high school yearbook, writing in it, get, to a sweeter, more beautiful girl i could not say merry christmas, christmas 1997, love, roy moore, d. A. Well, his attorney disputed that the handwriting blocks to moore. Judge moore not only has denied everything that she has said before, but now flatly denies that. And he says its not true. We have a handwriting expert, pardon me, thats laooking at those. But heres the problem. A handwriting expert cant look at a copy on the internet, right . Theyve got to look at an original. So right now, trent garman, our attorney, is sending a letter to Gloria Allred demanding that the yearbook be released. Anyway, while the attorney disputed miss nelsons claims, he took no questions and gdid nt address any of the allegations against moore. Moore himself has denied the Liberty Mutual stood with me Washington Post claims, calling when this guy got a flat tire them false. For more, im joined by ruth in the middle of the night, so he got home safe. Marcus for the Washington Post and ron reagan, an msnbc yeah, my dad says our insurance doesnt have that. Political analyst. I want to start with ruth on what . this. Ruth, you can watch this lawyer. You can leave worry behind hes so obviously a lawyer. When liberty stands with you™. He says, my client says, my Liberty Mutual insurance. Client says, my client says. Hes not saying he believes him. This looks like tactics. Theyre playing for time with sean hannity of all people, whos now playing Spencer Tracy in this thing and saying hes im back with vince dipeiro going to be the judge. If he can get away with it, fine for sean. Who was with Robert Kennedy when but it seems like this is tactical. He was shot in 1968. Im asking you, yeah, we want to you were there as i lied on the get the original, the actual ground in the kitchen. Do you remember what he said . Yearbook, and Gloria Allred will did he have something to say . Not give away anything without yeah. The he was laying on the some sort of negotiation. Floor bleeding and he was very shes now calling for senate hearings. Groggy, obviously. And the first thing that we were this give sean the chance tonight to give the guy a pass for a couple of days, at least. Telling him is dont speak, just it looks all so tactical, only lay calm. Addressing one in five of the and the first thing out of his claims against judge moore. Mouth was and ill never only one in five at a press forget this, was, is everybody conference with no questions. Your thoughts . You work with when youre else all right . He was more concerned about the people that were around him than a defense lawyer, and hes essentially in the role of a defense lawyer, you only can himself. Well, sir, thank you for coming on. Work with the facts that you i cant think of any greater have at hand. Last words than somebody caring and this is an ugly and not very about other people as they powerful set of facts for the themselves are passing away. Roy moore defense. Vince dipierro, im so glad you did not hear anything in that raised your hand when they asked News Conference that i found to was anybody there when robert be exculpatory in any way. Kennedy was shot. Honor to have you on. Thanks, chris. The Campaign Adviser who said he when we return, let me had seen roy moore with a whole finish with that night in los bunch of ladies, thousands of angeles, that night in 1968. Ladies, never seen any bad behavior. Well, we all know from harvey youre watching hardball. Weinstein and everything else, guess what, thats not how it i love you, basement guest bathroom. Happens, not out in public. It happens behind closed doors. And even the they couldnt even say that the handwriting expert could dispute the thing. Nobody would have written if you were making it up, you would not have written that weird phrase from roy moore. So, i dont know what sean hannity is going to say, but i was decidedly unconvinced. Ron, i think well see that this guy tries every dirty trick in the book. The one with ali velshi, well, you people, you understand. Alluding to his ethnic background. This whole thing was so low brow, so below the belt. Having the guy with supposedly with a new york accident, with a jewish name, Bernie Bernstein calling up and saying, do you have any crap on we dont want to investigate, were just going to smear him with it. This is getting dirtier and dirtier, but it is bringing out all the rats. Everybody is now going to know all the dirty tricks in the business, right now. And its fascinating, too, of course, these same republicans were so outraged by harvey weinstein, as they should have been, as we all should have been, kevin spacey, louis ck, on and on and on. All those people, by the way, are on hiatus. Harvey weinstein the no longer producing films. Your privacy makes you my number 1 place to go number 2. Kevin spacey is no longer acting in a television series. Louis cks comedy specials have i love you, but sometimes you stink. Been canceled. Roy moore on the other hand, may be heading for the senate, you know . And donald trump has got a big febreze air effects doesnt just mask, it cleans away odors. Problem on his hand, because donald trump is expected to say because the things you love the most can stink. Something about this. And what is donald trump going and try febreze small spaces to say about roy moore and his to clean away odors for up to 30 days. Accusers, who sound awfully like breathe happy with febreze. Donald trumps accusers. Theyre saying the same sort of thing. And of course, the difference between donald trump donald trump and roy moore is we dont have roy moore on tape bragging about doing this sort of thing. Let me go back to ruth. Youve been to many pressers like today, what did you make of that presser on the white house lawn or whatever the hell it was. What do you make what do you in the mirror everyday. When i look when i look in the mirror everyday. Make of the game theyre playing everyday, i think how fortunate i am. About the yearbook . I think is today going to be the day, the yearbook, im not sure about that yearbook game youre that we find a cure . Talking about. Well, allred wants to i think how much i can do to help change peoples lives. Allreds got the yearbook with the little happy signature at i may not benefit from those breakthroughs, but christmastime to this older mans younger, supposed, what he im sure going to. Thought was his girlfriend, i guess. And then we have then we have im bringing forward a treatment for alzheimers disease, yes, the fact that the lawyer for moore says, oh, we want to see in my lifetime, i will make sure. The actual yearbook, because then we can do a proper handwriting analysis. Boy, they want to stretch this baby out pretty long. Yeah, good luck with that. But, like i said, thats just the kind of, incredible when you have bad facts, youre going to sort of do with them what you can. Theyve got a bunch of really bad facts here. And let me make a bold prediction. Theyre only going to get worse. As terrific as my colleagues are at the Washington Post in the newsroom, i did not think they had found the only four women in alabama that roy moore had molested or asked out when they were teenagers. Turned out they didnt. And i suspect there are more bad facts for the moore attorneys to deal with to come. I think the question of what President Trump is going to do, as ron suggested, is really interesting, because he is in a very bad situation. Hays got all the senate republicans, essentially, saying i believe the women. If he says i believe the women, then the question becomes, okay, how about the women who accused you . And if he says, i dont believe the women, then theres a well, why not you, if everybody else does. I want to Say Something good about Mitch Mcconnell, because i do believe Mitch Mcconnell let me finish tonight with believes in a couple of things. That night in los angeles in one is, the institution of the 1968. United states senate. I really think he wanted to keep the filibuster rule, because it i dont think you know where you really does make the Senate Different than the house. You actually haveunlimited were, we remember what we felt. I was in montreal and woke up who had won the great president ial primary between Bobby Kennedy and Eugene Mccarthy and when he announced the previous november i had been praying for bobby to win in california for the basic reason that he was the only candidate who could win and end the war. When i turned on the radio i heard what sounded like a replay of that old recording from five years before in dallas, texas. I suddenly realized, it wasnt a rerun of a tragedy but a new one. An incredible shooting of a second kennedy. I didnt know then nor did any of us what bobby had been thinking the last hour of his life. Now i do. I have an association with those who are less well off, bringing the country back together and that we can start to put into effect all this work and programs that will have some meaning. If the division continues, were going to have nothing but chaos and havoc here in the United States. I think we can end the divisions within the United States, he told that last crowd the night of victory, whether its between blacks and whites or the poor and more affluent. We are a great country, an unselfish country. I intend to make that my basis for running. Bobby kennedy had found his purpose, his mission in life. He wanted to go on, wanted dearly to go on. Thats hardball for now. Thanks for being with us. All in with chris hayes starts right now. Tonight on all in im sorry being harassed by media. Roy moore remains defiant and the president remains silent. Do you believe the accusers of roy moore, mr. President . Should he resign . Tonight, why donald trump is mum as the Senate Candidate accused of child molestation gets forensic. Release the yearbook so we can determine, is it genuine or a fraud. Plus, a republican defection on taxes as a roomful of ceos debunks the entire white house argument. Why arent other hands up . Then, why some democrats disagree with todays