The magazine charlie hedbergo had provoked rage in the muslim world in the past for publishing cartoons of the prophet mohammed. One of the men shouted, they avenge the prophet mohammed. Well dress in the black they carried assault weapons. In video taken, two of the gunmen one of the gunmen walks over and shoots and kills him. Then the walkmen walk to a waiting car. Late today a Large Police Operation was launched in the french city in reims northeast of paris. And again tonight, nbc news can report that one of the gunmen is dead and the other two are in custody. Lets get the latest from justice correspondent Pete Williams in washington. What have we got . Well, the assumption all day long from the eight waive this unfolded in paris was when the gunmen were identified and found, they would not simply give up. And that seems to be the case here. That there was some kind of shootout. We dont know the condition of the other two who were arrested. We dont know whether they were wounded. What their condition is. Where theyve been taken. What weve been told by several u. S. Officials is that this did end. The police were able to identify them relatively quickly. The police in paris, final them in this suburb in a city in northern france, and move in and encounter them. One was killed. The other two are in custody. We dont know a couple of things here. We dont know how the police found them. Whether it had to do with the car that they were, they used as their getaway. There was an accident. The gunman got into a crash with the car and had to abandon it. They carjacked another car and moved on is our understanding. Whether they would exploit the car, whether it was rounds that they recovered at the seasonable of the shooting. Where it was tips from the public intelligence that the police developed. We dont know. In any event, it was very fast work. They identified the three. One of the three, french officials say, had actually been arrested and convicted in 2005. Nine years ago of trying to recruit people go to iraq to engage in jihad against american soldiers in iraq. So this is according to officials, we talked to a blend of a lot of things. Did everything to prison for that . Do we know if he served time . Yes. 18 months is my understanding. A year and a half. So it is not a person unknown to the french. But were told by u. S. Authorities that there was no intelligence that led up to this. Nothing that was missed so far. Also chris, no known connection between any of these three and peel in the United States. No threats against the u. S. No plans to raise the Terror Threat level here. It seems to me that we had surveillance camera weve been watching it all afternoon of the little black car the suspects got into. The fact they would drive around in that little car. That was not much of an escape vehicle. Then to go oh and shoot that com in cold blood. It is almost like please follow us. Police in france, we shoot one of you to make sure you follow us. And remember this is the third encounter, according to our understanding with Law Enforcement. The first was when they went in to the offices of the magazine or the newspaper. They had a bodyguard there. The editor had a bodyguard. He was killed. Then outside on the street outside the Newspaper Office a police car had blocked the road. And youve probably seen the pictures of the police car windshield that was riddled with bullets. Our understanding was the gunman fired at that car and backed away. Then some distance away several blocks away is when the third encounter takes place. Thats the pictures you see of the policeman who was on foot. So they actually encounter Law Enforcement or security three separate times. As for driving the little black citroen. If youre trying to blend in, thats not a bad choice. They seemed to know or accidentally or awfully on time to hit the group just as the editorial meeting was taking place where everyone was gathered around the table at 11 30 parisian time this morning. Somebody tipped them off as to when to hit. We dont know whether they knew that or whether that just was coincidence. And there are some contradictory indications about this. It doesnt, it does seem relatively disciplined. They seem to act calmly. They seem to be comfortable with womens. Theyre not just firing indiscriminately all over the place or panicking. On the other hand it doesnt seem to be a highly professional operation. Indications are that they went to the wrong door first. And had to be told where the Newspaper Offices were. Then they had to hold a woman at gunpoint for her security. Then they had to ask the people in the newspaper who they were. They hadnt studied pictures. But they were fairly well disciplined. They were all dressed the same. They seemed to have a definite purpose. One Law Enforcement official said this was like a mob hit. Thank you so much for that reporting tonight. Lets go now to nbcs chief global correspondent. Bill, we just got a report from Pete Williams that one man has been killed. Two have been arrested. What more can you tell us now . Yes. This handle yet been confirmed by French Police. This is news from a u. S. Senior correspondent terrorism official. We think it relates to an operation in the city of reims about 90 miles northeast of here. There was a French Commando terrorist operation there involving men on the ground helicopters in the air and it was reported that gunshots have been fired. We havent quite linked up those two incidents yet. Remember, it is just a few hours ago that French Police confirmed the names of three men they wanted to question. Three suspects. Two were brothers. One had actually been convicted of terrorist offenses in france ten years ago and another reportedly had returned to france from syria just last summer. So obviously, if the three named suspects by the French Police are indeed three who have been cornered in reims and the u. S. Counter terrorism officials saying one is dead and two are under arrest that is a very, very significant development. Are we getting any reaction from the Muslim Community in paris . And are they assimilated in the parisian french life . Or are they still seeing. They as outsiders from the middle east and north africa . Reporter first of all original reaction, the imam of a significant french suburb a parisian suburb from where jews were deported to auschwitz in world war ii. That came out very quickly and criticized this attack saying this is not islam. This does not represent our religion. That line has been repeated by many imams in paris throughout the day. As for integration, it is very difficult. France has a huge muslim population. It is the second biggest religion here and there have been desperate efforts to more fully integrate them into french life for deck axds france fought a very bitter war. There are very bitter memories of that. And many french, when the two team play at soccer france and algeria, many will support algeria. So there are great difficulties in integrating the population here. And just before christmas, there were a number of incidents of french muslims attacking people in this country. One was a stabbing incident. And two other incidents, men drove their vehicles into crowds injuring about two dozen people. So a lot of french Counter Intelligence officials were here saying, it is not a question of if there will be a very big terrorist attack. It is just a question of when. And this magazine of course as we know had been threatened many times before. Thank you. Im joined by Evan Kohl Mann and a senior fellow for Strategic International studies. Evan, you first. Put this together. It is not just a terrorist thing, it is a cultural thing where people see the west as the enemy. They dont want to hear anything against their religion. Their view is that is evil and it must be struck down with harshness. Certainly in a lethal fashion today. How do we live in a society where some people share the views of ours which is tolerance toward other religions and even for femmous statements. And people who dont accept that. I think it is important that anyone looking for tolerance be able to tolerate the ideas of others. So it is a bit odd that these folks are unwilling to tolerate people criticizing islam and yet you see what happens today. It doesnt make a lot of sense. But in perspective, france has a very serious problem with islam phobia. That may not the cause today but the suspects who have been named, these were individuals who were radicalized in their youth. They were recruiting people to go to iraq when they were 19 20 years old. Thats very young. And that means they were radicalized at a young age. I think it is important to consider that there are a lot of french muslims who feel that they are alienated from the society theyre in. They feel like they cant get hired for normal jobs. Theyre not treated the same by police. Just on the virtue of their religion or their ethnic back ground. And again, there is no excuse for murdering people and there is no excuse for murdering people especially when it comes to the freedom of speech. At the same point, it is very important for French Society to be demonstrating to everyone who lives there that they can be accepted into society. That they dont need to wage war against society to have their voices heard. And im not necessarily saying thats what has happened here but certainly it contributed to the atmosphere that leads to people like this who have apparently grown up in france to decide to turn their backs on their own country. And i think it is important to ask why that happened. They dont see it as their country. And thats the whole thing. That when people become alienated to that degree, they start associating. They with algeria or tunisia or syria instead of french. And these guys by every indication, these individuals are french. They speak french. They are french. Theyre classically french. Theyre not some kind of alien species from another planet. And i think we should be asking what led these kids to become so radicalized so young . At age 20 one of these guys was caught trying to travel to syria and then go on to iraq. This was in january 2005 when al qaeda in iraq was only about 2 months old. They were early documenters. What led them down that path. This was not a decision that was made in the last two weeks. These guys were on this mission for a long period of time. And the other question is how is it that these individuals who were so heavily radicalize asked had been involved in this so long how is it the French Authority missed them . Okay. I must say, i have no sympathy for killers. And the world is filled with hundreds and hundreds of millions of poor people who have no prospects at all but they dont go around killing people. India is packed with poor people. These are killers. I dont accept the idea of economic or social purposes that can be achieved by what they did today. No connection as far as im concerned. Your thoughts . Thomas. This idea that these people being radicalized at a young age. It seem the geopolitical events they had made up their mind early they would be killers. At least a couple factors are important. They grew up in the post 9 11 period and they see a lot of combat on tv. They see whats happening overseas. At home they are marginalized. You combine these things and they get individuals who have a sense of purpose. You combine that with the den grags of the prophet mohammed. And i think it is important to point out that you have over 900 French National whos to have gone syria to fight in just the last three years. Those individuals, the ones that survive, will come home or move on to a third country. And they represent a threat similar to these guys. It is clear they were very comfortable with women. They had battlefield experience or they were trained overseas. So think about that large number that comes back with the battlefield experience, the street cred, the networks the communication links and think with what they could do. One more thing these guys appear to be French Nationals so they have french passports. They come from one of 30 european visa waiver countries which means they can get on a plane to the United States any of these fighters with passports, get on a may not to the United States without having to go through a visa interview at a u. S. Embassy. Look at their loyalties. Their loyalties arent to france. Theyre rooting for algeria in the International Soccer competition. Obviously their loyalties are against france them killed 12 frenchmen. They killed a police officer, they killed a guard, they killed people who are french. Thats what they did today. Out of hostility to france which i dont think suggested theyre French Nationals in any real sense. No of course not. Thats irrelevant. The notion of bringing up the French National point is that they could have a passport which means as a citizen of a visa waiver country, they can travel to the u. S. Without an interview. I know it. Theyre going to have to figure out who are the loyal french people and who are not. Thank you both. Coming up the terrorists in todays attack targeted journalists, cartoonish and what they consider caricatures. It is not the first time free speech has been under attack by islamic extremists. Again the breaking news at this hour, nbc news is reporting one terrorist suspect is dead. Two in custody after that deadly attack early today in paris. This is hardball, the place for politics. Our thoughts and prayers are with the families of those who have been lost in france and with the people of paris and the people of france. What that beautiful city represents. The culture and the civilization that is so central to our imaginations. Those who carry out senseless attacks against innocent civilians, ultimately theyll be forgotten and we will stand with the people of france through this very, very difficult time. [ fishing rod casting line, marching band playing ] [ male announcer ] the rhythm of life. [ whistle blowing ] where do you hear that beat . Campbells healthy request soup lets you hear it in your heart. [ basketball bouncing ] heart healthy. Great taste. [ mm. ] [ tapping ] sounds good. Campbells healthy request. Mm mm good. ® your eyes really are unique. In fact, they depend on a unique set of nutrients. Thats why theres ocuvite to help protect your eye health. As you age your eyes can lose vital nutrients. Ocuvite helps replenish key eye nutrients. Ocuvite is a vitamin made just for your eyes from the eye care experts at bausch lomb. Ocuvite has a unique formula thats just not found in any leading multivitamin. Your eyes are unique so help protect your eye health with ocuvite. In my world, wall isnt a street. Return on investment isnt the only return im looking forward to. For some every dollar is earned with sweat, sacrifice, courage. Which is why usaa is honored to help our members with everything from investing for retirement to saving for college. Our commitment to current and former military members and their families is without equal. Start investing with as little as fifty dollars. Theyre still after me. Get to the terminal across town. Are all the green lights you . No. Its called grid iq. The 4 51 is leaving at 4 51. They cut the power. Itll fix itself. Powers back on. Quick thinking traffic lights and self correcting power grids make the world predictable. Thrillingly predictable. Today, tomorrow in paris, across the world, the freedom of expression that this magazine, no matter what your feelings were about it. The freedom of expression that it represented is not able to be killed by this kind of act of terror. On the contrary it will never be eradicated by any action of terror. What they dont understand with these people who do these things dont understand they will only strengthen the commitment to that freedom and our commitment to the civilized world. Lets hope thats true. At this hour nbc news is reporting that one of the suspects has been killed. The other two are arrested. Todays attack was an attack on free speech of course. The author who was forced into hiding because of his book was considered offensive to islam issued a powerful statement of his own today. Rushdie said i stand with Charlie Hebdo as we all must to defend art of satire which has always been a force for liberty and against tyranny, dishonesty and stupidity. An islam reformist, thank you both for joining me. It seem liberty is the issue here. Is it a value shared by the east and west . All people share the view that liberty is more important than opposing blasphemy, even if you find it hurtful . I think the west has a lot more experience with liberty in it. It has gone through different phases. No doubt it has taken stronger roots in the west than certain parts of the muslim world, particularly the arab world where liberty across all spectrums of society, social political, individual liberty, hasnt taken as strong of a root. So i think theres that fundamental question as to whether or not the tolerance of some times of offensive cartoons and some types of offensive speech are tolerated. Obviously, this is an abhorrent act, what happened in paris. Youre right. There is a gap in the way the two societies appreciate and tolerate liberty as a whole. Ive read some polling in the islamic world, pretty frightening to hear, people believe if you commit adultery, youre worthy of stoning. Overwhelming percentages believe it is appropriate punishment. Do we believe that or is it lip service . When people offer these really frightening ideas of what justice constitutes. Clearly some people believe it. I have to say that i think there is a generation gap here. Ive been doing work on muslim reform for about 15 years now. When i started, the Death Threats that i would receive, you know surprised even me and i was expecting them. But 15 years later, i can honestly tell you a new generation of muslims all over the world, not just the west and not just the middle east but all over the world, are defending freedom of expression. They are hungry for debate and discussion because they themselves see that they cant realize their own individuality unless that basic tolerance that he was talking about of freedom of thought exists in their societies. Why do i see numbers of 80 and 90 in countries like pakistan who support stoning for a woman who is unfaithful . These are high percentages. You say it is only older people. It sounds like it is most people. I dont know the methodology behind this so im not going to comment on what the ages were in the people being polled. What i can tell from you hard personal experience is that very representative of the kind of tweets that i got today, and that didnt just come to me but were retweeted by others and in that way came to me was one from a muslim woman, young, who said i am muslim. I defend fully freedom of speech including offensive speech. And people like these terrorists make a mockery of islam. I hear this every single day. From members of a new generation. Heres the thing. They dont make the news. Idiots like these terrorists make the news. So a lopsided understanding here. Let me finish the point. Theres a lopsided understanding. What we news is what we think is all there is. If we dont see it on the news, we dont believe it exists. But youve got to look hard and you will find the hope. Let me go to you. Where were they hoping to find safe harbor . Who were their people . Who were their people that would bring them in afterwards . They must have had a plan and a home to go to politically, culturally. Listen at the end of the day these guys carried out an attack. They looked like they had an escape plan. It doesnt necessarily mean they would go back and brag about it. If they really wanted to make a statement and h their identities known, they would have made that statement very clear. The fact that this is still shroud in the ambiguity as to who is behind it from an organizational standpoint. Were they individuals that acted on their own or did they have a linkage to an organization . The fact they did this and went about and tried to escape doesnt mean they have an embase from their community. As weve been hearing and reporting, there has been widespread condemnation from the leadership in organizations and france and europe as well as here in the United States. At the same time they may not necessarily represent anybody broader than themselves at this particular time unless we know more about why they carried this attack out. I hope the Muslim Community of france, a Large Community and robust, joins the demonstrators tonight. And im very sure that they will as well. And i think that well see a very large contingent of young muslims out there. By the way secretary of state john kerry used an interesting phrase in his speex about what happened in paris. He used the phrase martyrs of liberty. That these people who died were martyrs of liberty. You know where that phrase came from . From an imam. A muslim leader in france. Thats good to hear. Back in 1989 a fatwa was issued. His verse was considered offensive to slaum. And in 2004 Theo Van Gogh was murdered because his work was considered antiislamic. In 2005 when a dutch newspaper published cartoons, the artists and publishers were met with Death Threats. I want your view because youre so optimistic on this. What do you think . Do you think it is an odd occurrence . Or will we have to live with it for decades . This whole thing being disaffected. Tough luck. Youre living in france. The country is called france. It is french. Liberty, equality, fraternity. Get with it. If you dote like dont like living there, moving. Somehow france has to ajust to your thinking is outrageous. Agree 100 . You asked do i think this will go on for decades . Yes. And ill tell you why. This is where my optimism comes from. These folks, the criminals behind these acts today, know that they are on the losing side of history. I firmly believe that they know this because again, im seeing around me young people who are now young muslims who are now having children. Writing openly that we are going to be raising our children with the pluralistic values that reformist islam stands for. When these criminals understand that theyre soon going to be outnumbered. When i say soon i mean programs in two generations. This is the kind of back lash that they are going to be engaging in. So weirdly, and i realize that this is a hard sell. And time will tell. But im making the prediction that what we saw today is not an act of the future. It is an act that bemoans the future. It is an act of back lash against a much more pluralistic and progressive future. Losing sides can be very dangerous. Right now were looking at a live picture from outside the museum in washington, d. C. Where people have gathered for a ridge is nil honor of the victims of todays attack. And to voice support for freedom of the press and expression. And in new york city, people are gathering in union square to pay tribute to the 12 People Killed in the attacks. There they are. Discover card. Hey, i heard you guys can help me with frog protection . Yeah, we help with fraud protection. We monitor every purchase every day and alert you if anything looks unusual. Wow youre really looking out for us. We are. And if there are unauthorized purchases on your discover card, youre never held responsible. Just to be clear you are saying frog protection right . Yeah, fraud protection. Frog protection. Fraud protection. Frog. Fraud. Frog. Fraud. I think were on the same page. Were totally on the same page. At discover, we treat you like youd treat you. Fraud protection. Get it at discover. Com news were reporting right now is that one of the terror suspects in the attack in paris is dead and the other two are arrested. Thats according to two senior u. S. Counter terrorism officials. For reaction in the United States lets turn to nbc news chief Foreign Affairs correspondent Andrea Mitchell. And deputy spokesperson. We americans pride ourselves in at least in most cases, you can a simulate when you come to our country. You can learn the language you have to become american dressed like us more or less. You dont to have change religions but you can become an american. In france you get the sense these people from north africa are still rooting for algeria in the soccer games. They still see themselves from arab countries. Is that an advantage for us that should give us some security or not . Well i think that there is a lot of county politics also in the politics. Were a broader country. We have more diversity of grooms. I think this is a segment and a growing segment, 10 , perhaps, French Society with deep roots of an 10 they and a lot of restricted laws, the head scarf controversies and a feeling of isolation and also an identification with these groups, with al qaeda and the al qaeda peninsula. There have been aspirational and inspirational attacks from isis the civil war in syria that has been going on for four years now unabated. Increasing numbers of deaths. The proximity to syria and the civil war. The fact that westerners from europe go back and forth. That we have so many thousands of foreign fighters that can be retrained and professionalized as military people. We dont know if thats the case here. I think what experts tell us is there is less and less difference. Whether this is isis inspired or al qaeda. This is something well have to live with. That the rest will have to defend against. Let me to go maria. I think it is impressive that we have a secretary of state who is fluent in french. What was the message after this horror . Youre right. His message directly to the french people was that we are going to stand by you and that we will not be afraid. You saw thousands of people on the streets of paris echoing that sentiment. The u. S. Will stand by you. Not just in the aftermath of this horrible tragedy. But also working together speaking to what andrea just said. Looking at disaffected communities and trying to figure out before the tragedy hams how you can possibly identify people that might do this and ultimately ideally prevent it from happening. Thats the long term challenge. We work the french on it every day. How do you deal with a small operation like this . It is hard to kill a dozen people but it is not 9 11. Do you hear chatter . Do you hear noise levels . The nsa approach to connecting peel up by data points . How do you stop a small operation like this which may have only involved a few people. A huge challenge. And our Intelligence Community is working very closely with the french. Pulling every threat. Seeing what we know, what we didnt know. Intelligence as you know, is a very complicated puzzle where we often dont have all the pieces. We need to do better and thats what were working with the french. On i wholeheartedly agree with your previous guest who said these people these terrorists are on the losing side of history. But as you said, the losing side can be very dangerous and the challenge is identifying people and as i am ultimately preventing this from happening. Were going to hem the french try to figure out how they were radicalized. How they ultimately became part of this group that turned to violence. There are a the lovet of disaffected people. Thats the long term challenge. Andrea youre the expert on this. Weve all watched from afar but you closer in. This pattern of going after cultural challenges. Up in scandinavian countries, the threats about the movie maker. It seems like this is not going to go away. That there will be wise guy, if you will editors. They will take chances that maybe they shouldnt in terms of blasphemy. There will certainly be a reaction. I dont think the answer is for us to start censoring ourselves. I think we have to permit the kind of expression and we have our own channels here in america that do comedy and that do really sometimes offensive stuff. Offensive to all sorts of ethnic groups. So the answer is not to start senseoring ourselves. I think we have to be more vigilant. We live in a new reality. I remember i was saying earlier, not that many decades ago when i was covering capitol hill and i had my own parking space on the plaza. Well, thats long since passed since 9 11. You dont drive up on to the plaza right across from the capitol. We have pennsylvania avenue closed off. There are a lot of sacrifices we make. The peoples house is no longer as accessible as it used to be. We cant wanteder through Old Executive Office building as when i was covering the white house. We have to preserve the important aspects of our values. Freedom of speech, freedom of expression and yes, go back. Look at the chatter. Im told we havent found anything thats demonstrative but the french Counter Terrorism people who work so closely with us got two suspects. And one is dead. We hope it is not part of a larger conspiracy. This is not the first or last time as salmon rushdie certainly experienced going back to the 80s that well see insane kinds of violent actions and threats of violent action against free expression. And we have to resist the impulse to crawl into our own caves. I agree with that. Thank you so much for your excellent reporting. And thank you for the word from the state department. Up next ottawa sydney and paris. The latest in the string of attacks against western targets. How vulnerable are we here in the states . For fastidious librarian emily skinner, each day was fueled by thorough preparation for events to come. Well somewhere along the way emily went right on living. But you see, with the help of her Raymond James financial advisor, she had planned for every eventuality. Which meant she continued to have the means to live on. Even at the ripe old age of 187. Life well planned. See what a Raymond James advisor can do for you. More on the deadly terrorism attacks. Nbc news has learned one of the suspects has been killed and the remaining two have been arrested. Thats according to two senior u. S. Counter terrorism officials. Sadly todays tragedy is the latest in a recent string of incidents around the globe linked back to islamic extremism. Last october someone shot a canada soldier in ottawa and then opened fire inside parliament before being gunned down by the comments sergeant at arms. The very next day an islamic convert attacked two nypd officers with a hatchet. Authorities say the attacker was inspired after watching isis beheading beheading videos. Then 17 people were taken hostage in a sydney cafe. Three died as police stormed the scene. And today as weve been reporting, three masked men left a line of carnage. Witnesses said they heard the gunmen say they were avenging the prophet mohammed. What is coming next . I want to start with you. If youre advising clients around the world about security questions, risk factors, what are we looking at . Is this a trajectory that is leading to more culturally based attacks where people dome like what we say in the west . This appears to be a trend as you mentioned. Very low key. Less than sophisticated attacks taking place in western and western allied countries. What we should expect in the future is not exactly a rise in terrorist attacks or a decrease in them. I think we should just increase our proactive security measures. Our protective measures. And not only in Diplomatic Missions or embassies. We should take it to heart every time we see an issue like this that we dont back off and we are afraid. We should be speaking out and putting out a counter narrative out there for the youngsters. So communities around the world encouraged by governments or just communities, organizational institutions and what not, academics and what not, they should be putting out a counter out there that could prevent youngsters from following this. What do you mean . Im a little skeptical. If you put out a pob Public Service announce many on a regular basis that say we should have tolerance in this country and even if your religion is impugned you should keep your violence down . What can you say to a young person who will counterman this strength of the push again the west. The attack on western satire. We see people being recruited every day to not only enjoying radical grooms around the world and fighting war zones but to commit acts at home. If we dont put out some sort of narrative out there for them to not join these groups to not adhere to that kind of ideology we will fail eventually. Were going on see this trend on the rise. So we have to do something about it today. And though it may take months years or even generations on end. If we dont do something about it right now, the trend will continue. The youngsters who grew up in post 9 11 the jihadi war zones, who were five six, seven, eight years old, children at this point theyre adults. And they have been spoon fed this ideology and the converts are now learning from the radicals. Theyre not learning from the moderate muslims or the i know i know. Theyre converting to a much more radical islam. It seem to me it would be just as hard to argue that todays horror will discourage further horrors. It will probably encourage company cats. We talked about this guy. We talked about him a couple moments ago when i ran down the series of terrorist acts. One person was inspired by watching beheadings. If you have that kind of mindset. Youre watching Something Like this would probably be equally exciting to you and encouraging for to you join the movement. Yeah. Each of the cases that you mentioned were very low tech. One or two or three people. And they captured the attention of the world. They got big media reactions. They got big political reactions. And the way terrorists measure their success is not only in the number of victims. It is in how we react to them or how we overreact to them. I think a lot of the time weve seen terrorist attacks since 9 11 and onward there has been a big overreaction. That produces back lash. That feeds their movement. And it has very, very low cost to these terrorist groups. Some cases, all it took with the guy in australia was to go in with a machine gun and an ipad and film people and show the terror in their faces. Just the other day, david, i was at the u. S. Capitol where i used to work all those years. And i was a capitol policeman for a while in the early 70s. Let me tell you. It is a totally different world. We used to live in a really free society. Anybody could walk in almost any time of day without annic d. Card or a special pass. You could find your congressman and stand there until he or she had time to see you. Could you really petition congress. Today you have to have an i. D. Card flashing on your coat to show that you can walk in the capitol. You cant walk anywhere. You come in today, youre treated like a tourist. You have to go wait in the Visitors Center to get in so freedom is being taken away from us as Andrea Mitchell pointed out. You stay terrorists are not winning . Theyre winning that argument. Theyre making us act more secure but at the cost of our lebanon liberties. Well go back to paris for more on the attack with bill. The world is filled with air. But for people with copd sometimes breathing air can be difficult. If you have copd, ask your doctor about oncedaily anoro ellipta. It helps people with copd breathe better for a full 24hours. Anoro ellipta is the first fdaapproved product containing two longacting bronchodilators in one inhaler. Anoro is not for asthma. Anoro contains a type of medicine that increases risk of death in people with asthma. It is not known if this risk is increased in copd. Anoro wont replace rescue inhalers for sudden copd symptoms and should not be used more than once a day. Tell your doctor if you have a heart condition, or high blood pressure. Tell your doctor if you have glaucoma, prostate or bladder problems, or problems passing urine as anoro may make these problems worse. Call your doctor right away if you have worsened breathing chest pain, swelling of your mouth or tongue, problems urinating or eye problems including vision changes or eye pain while taking anoro. Nothing can reverse copd. The world is filled with air and anoro is helping people with copd breath air better. Get your first prescription free at anoro. Com. Well, a mortgage shouldnt be a problem your credit is in pretty good shape. Pretty good . I know i have a 798 fico score thanks to the tools and help on experian. Com. Kaboom. Well, i just have a few other questions. Chuck, the only other question you need to ask is, what else can you do for me . Ill just take a water. Get your credit swagger on. Become a member of experian credit tracker and find out your fico score powered by experian. Fico scores are used in 90 of credit decisions. Curling up in bed with a Favorite Book is nice. But i think women would rather curl up with their favorite man. But heres the thing about half of men over 40 have some degree of erectile dysfunction. Well, viagra helps guys with ed get and keep an erection. And remember, you only take it when you need it. Ask your doctor if your heart is healthy enough for sex. Do not take viagra if you take nitrates for chest pain; it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. Side effects include headache, flushing, upset stomach and abnormal vision. To avoid longterm injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than four hours. Stop taking viagra and call your doctor right away if you experience a sudden decrease or loss in vision or hearing. Ask your doctor about viagra. Welcome back. Nbc news is reporting that one of the terror suspects in todays attack in paris is dead and the other two have been arrested. Thats according to two senior u. S. Counterterrorism officials. Lets get right back to paris for a recap of whats happened today. Nbcs chief global correspondent bill neely. Give us a recap from paris on what were probably going to know tonight. Reporter yeah just to pick up on your last point, chris, were still waiting for French Police to confirm what u. S. Counterterrorism officials are telling nbc news. Were still waiting for them to say, in fact one suspect is dead, two have been arrested but it did take them quite some time to confirm the names of the suspects even as those names were circulating widely among the french media on social media and even as the french arrest warrant was shown on social media, the French Police still would not confirm that. So it may take them some time to actually publicly say that there has been a shootout and that two suspects are under arrest. Just to recap, it was about 14 hours ago that three gunmen although in the videos you just see two, two gunmen entered the offices of Charlie Hebdo. First of all they killed a security guard, then they forced a woman to take them upstairs to the Editorial Office where there was a meeting of about 15 journalists. They asked for the editor Stephane Charbonnier by name. They shot him, then they shot the policeman who was his body guard, a policeman, its interesting has emerged in the last hour was a french muslim. They then sprayed the room with gunfire, killing many of the journalists including some of frances best known cartoonists. One was 80 years old. They then went outside. As they began their getaway, they were confronted by police and they shot dead one of the Police Officers in cold blood at point blank range. They then escaped paris in one of two cars. There was another hijacked car later on and they were traced to reims, a city about 90 miles northeast of here and we believe thats where the shootout has taken place. But as i say, French Police have not confirmed that. And a couple of other details they were shouting these gunmen, god is great, allahu akbar in arabic although one of the witnesses said they spoke absolutely fluent french and theyre believed to be French Nationals. Thats where we stand at the minute waiting for confirmation from the French Police. Do we know if they were racing for the border . Could be tell or is that too much speculation at this point . Well belgium is in that direction, but i suppose they i mean they may just as easily hoped to blend in to provincial french towns or cities perfectly possible to get quite a distance on french motorways in that time. And if they were tracked to reims, then probably its cameras on the french motorways, on the roads that would have tracked them. Pretty easy to track that car. Because obviously they were masked. So no identification at the scene was possible. Chris . That was good work by the French Police and it doesnt surprise me. Its a heck of a police force. Thank you, nbcs bill neely for that great reporting today from paris on a grim day. He helps looks after all our money. Kid do you pay him . Dad of course. Kid how much . Dad i dont know exactly. Kid what if youre not happy . Does he have to pay you back . Dad nope. Kid why not . Dad it doesnt work that way. Kid why not . Vo are you asking enough questions about the way your wealth is managed . Wealth management at Charles Schwab in my world, wall isnt a street. Return on investment isnt the only return im looking forward to. For some every dollar is earned with sweat, sacrifice, courage. Which is why usaa is honored to help our members with everything from investing for retirement to saving for college. Our commitment to current and former military members and their families is without equal. Start investing with as little as fifty dollars. Fact. When you take advil you get relief right at the site of pain. Wherever it is. Advil stops pain right where it starts. Relief doesnt get any better than this. Advil. So ally bank really has no hidden fees on savings accounts . Thats right. Its just that im worried about you know hidden things. Ok, whys that . No hidden fees from the bank where no branches equals great rates. The breaking news tonight that nbc news is reporting that one of the terror suspects in the attack today in paris is dead. And the other two have been arrested. Thats good news. Our coverage continues now on all in with chris hayes. Tonight on all in, an attack in paris leaves 12 dead. Gunmen open fire on the offices of the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo tonight as the french fill the streets in protests, the latest from paris on the hunt for the gunmen. What we know about why this magazine and thee cartoonists were targeted again and again and what this attack means for free speech around the world. All in starts right now