Transcripts For MSNBCW Andrea Mitchell Reports 20191007

Leader of ukraine, further taking down the president s defense. Its really part of a mounting body of evidence along with those Text Messages and this witness testimony that trump wasnt just being trump on that phone call. Betrayal, President Trump ordering american troops to abandon the kurd allies. Green lighting turkeys president erdogan who has threatened to wipe them out, even angering some of the president s strongest defenders. The kurds have nobody to count on because we abandoned them. This is a big win for iran and assad, a big win for isis. And alternative facts. Republican lawmakers twist themselves into rhetorical pretzels defending the president leading to this Rare Exchange on meet the press. Senator its pretty clear were only dealing with the facts that we have, not the facts that you wish them to be. I cant get the answers and i cant get the answers, the American People cant get the answers. Something pretty fishy happened during the 2016 campaign and the transition in the early part of the Trump Presidency and we still dont know. We do know the answers. Good day, everyone. Im Andrea Mitchell in washington where President Trump is lashing out on twitter after learning there is a second whistleblower who reportedly heard that call to ukraines president and is willing to cooperate with house investigators. More vitriol from the president for nancy pelosi and adam schiff using words like high crimes and treason, then calling for their immediate impeachment even though members of congress cannot be impeached. As well as a new screed against the sole republican critic in the senate mitt romney. Joining me now kristin welker. Former fbi assistant director for Counter Intelligence and a senior director in president Obamas National Security council. What is going on at the white house . Reporter this second whistleblower deepens the controversy for the president , for this administration. It deprives them of the argument that the allegations against them are based on hearsay. Of course, we have the notes from the transcripts so people were able to see what President Trump said to the president of ukraine, at least the notes of that phone call with their own eyes. But that is why you have President Trump taking aim at the whistleblower, the press secretary stephanie grishom trying to dismiss the significance saying its part of the broader witch hunt against President Trump. It underscores some real concern behind the scenes about what the second whistleblower might have to say. Will this person further the narrative . It comes as were expecting the standoff to intensify between the white house and capitol hill. Administration officials telling us over the weekend that early this week they expecting to send that letter to House Speaker nancy pelosi essentially saying theyre not going to turn over any documentation until the full house votes to, as they say, officially open an impeachment inquiry. Theres nothing in the constitution that requires that although the past three impeachment inquiries have started with a vote in the house. Bottom line, the white house signaling they do not plan to cooperate. And theres been an unprecedented attack again by the president and his defenders. We saw this on meet the press with ron johnson against the fbi and the cia. This could also include as bloomberg was reporting on friday night a wholesale wiping out of National Security Council Members who are detailed from the Intelligence Community. The president using labels like deep state. What are you seeing here . Well, what were seeing is what trump views as a direct threat. The Intelligence Community represents two things that scare the president. They represent knowledge and they represent truth. And when you have knowledge and truth, you have power. So trump sees this as a power threat to him and hes got to lash out at people who possess truth and knowledge, because when it comes out, it becomes clear that witch hunt is not whats rhappening but rather we have people who have really seen the witches, they know the truth, theyve got the scoop. Youre going to see an increasing effort to taint the cia, the fbi and the entire National Security council in terms of the detailees there because they represent a clear and present threat to the president and his agenda. And theres a letter that youre on from 90 former National Security Council Members that says in part, he or she, the whistleblower, has by law the right and indeed the responsibility to make known through appropriate channels indications of serious wrongdoing, being a responsible whistleblower means that by law one is protected from certain egregious forms of retaliation. There have been a lot of threats from the president of retaliation and claims against the whistleblower and now a second whistleblower has stood up apparently according to the whistleblowers attorney. Also this report by Jennifer Jacobs that we have not confirmed frankly that the president has ordered all of these detailees, so many from the National Security council staff, the people who do listen on these calls and take these notes, not cia but others potentially to be removed, to be sent back to their apparent agencies. Its incredibly on brand for donald trump because rather than cut down on the betrayal hes essentially taking aim at the fact witnesses, people whok coud blow the whistle. The fact that we now have two whistleblowers is in some ways the least surprising document. I say that remembering the first line in the original whistleblower complaint. In the course of my official duties i have received information from multiple u. S. Government officials is how that whistleblower started that complaint. In some ways trump has invited this on himself because he has tried to per son fie t personif. He has tried to kill the messenger. This is about our National Security and the need to place that oath that we swore to the constitution ahead of any loyalty to a single president. Ron johnsons pushback against chuck todd was so unprecedented for this senator. He also said in answer to chucks final questions there do you trust the current cia and fbi and he said no, i dont. What signals do that send . This is deeply disturbing on a couple of levels. First of all, lets remember that the current directors of cia and fbi are indeed trump appointees. Even on a dieeper level im really concerned about what this says to our allies who have to work with us, our Intelligence Community every single day. And then i get very concerned when someone at that level says that because at some point our administration is going to have to confront adversaries or present our allies with serious intelligence that calls for it to be acted upon. They can look across the table at us and say is this the same intel from the same intelligence agencies that you say you dont trust . Why should we listen to this . It has harmful effects for Foreign Policy, for morale, for recruitment. Michael mcfaul is a former ambassador and joins me now. This has been an extraordinary series of events. Theres the fallout from the phone call which now implicated the Vice President of the United States, the secretary of state, the energy secretary, the president s personal lawyer, who knows who else. And tough witnesses lined up now, those agreeing to cooperate and the secretary of state pushing back and not turning over to this moment as far as we know documents from the state department about this entire episode. Shocking ining is the right. It is an irony that secretary pompeo is the one not turning over these documents when he proceeded during the benghazi hearings to ask the same from the oesh whitbama white focus on the facts, which are simple and clear and it doesnt matter who testifies in the future and it doesnt really even matter if we have three or four or more whistleblowers. All the facts are in the transcript of the phone call from President Trump to president zelensky and then c p corroborated by the Text Messages released last thursday when mr. Volker testified. They were offering an oval office visit with the president in return for one investigation of the Vice President s son and, two, investigation into alleged ukrainian involvement in our 2016 election. Its just clear as day we dont need any more whistleblowers. Let me ask you about the former ambassador to ukraine and an experienced diplomat in both russia, ukraine and the region. Shes supposedly going to testify. We dont know how forthcoming she will be, but she is one of the witnesses who has agreed to show up. But the fact that she was pulled back from her post and has been supplanted really by this Eu Ambassador when ukraine is not part of the European Union and this other ambassador was a political appointee and contributor. Yeah. Its just shameful. Its thepower of people around the president at the expense of National Security interest. I have known her for over 30 years. She was a top notch diplomat. Serving for democrats and republicans and she, obviously, clashed with this conspiracy. The prosecutor general who at the time mr. Giuliani was in consultations with said the ambassador was getting in the way of what youre trying to do and the private people basically working with this to get rid of our u. N. Ambassador general. Were referring to the political contributor upwards of 1 million to the Trump Campaign who, according to the Text Messages was circumventing William Taylor who succeeded and marsha in the ukraine post and another career diplomat and the only one in this whole group who was pushing back and saying it would be crazy to withhold Security Assistance to ukraine in exchange for help with a political campaign. Yes. I think ambassador taylor who you are referring to who is now out in ukraine serving as our temporary ambassador. Hes the real hero here. He was not willing to play along with this scheme and its just, i want to just emphasize all the evidence is there in the Text Messages and in the transcript. Everybody should just go and read them closely because what you see here in the text especially, is it wasnt just a phone call, a one off phone call with the president , you know, asking for a favor one time. That was part of a scheme over many, many months to try to do this quid pro quo. Thankfully ambassador taylor pushed back. But why ambassador sondland is involved, completely mysterious to me. Ukraine is not a member of the European Union. The United States is not a member of the European Union. It seems to me reading those texts that hes just the trump spy to make sure people like volker and taylor do what theyre supposed to do. I look forward to his testimony tomorrow. The other piece of this, of course, is vladimir putin. Who benefits most from the freeze, the temporary freeze as it turns out of 391 million in aid to ukraine at a key moment when a newer president was taking over and trying to negotiate with russia. Obviously, vladimir putin. But i think its bigger than that, andrea. We look like we cannot do Foreign Policy in the name of National Security interest. We look like we cant basically run a play that is designed to advance our interests and our allies. So, on an even broader platform, i think putin and all of our competitors and enemies around the world benefits from this very tragic moment in terms of american Foreign Policy. Ambassador mike mcfaul, thank you so much. Abandoned. President trump gives into turkeys demand to move in against allied forces in syria sparking condemnation including the fight against isis who says the president is committing malpractice. Brett joining me next right here on Andrea Mitchell reports only on msnbc. Nbc. Uppo and ease into quitting so when the day arrives, youll be more ready to kiss cigarettes goodbye. When you try to quit smoking, with or without chantix, you may have nicotine withdrawal symptoms. Stop chantix and get help right away if you have changes in behavior or thinking, aggression, hostility, depressed mood, suicidal thoughts or actions, seizures, new or worse heart or blood vessel problems, sleepwalking, or lifethreatening allergic and skin reactions. Decrease alcohol use. Use caution driving or operating machinery. Tell your doctor if youve had Mental Health problems. The most common side effect is nausea. Talk to your doctor about chantix. There are lots of people who are confused about which medicare plan is right for them. Hey, thats me. I barely know where to start. Well, start here with me, karen. Im a licensed humana sales agent. Well, its nice to meet you, karen. Im john smith. Hi, john. At humana, we know youre unique. So you have different needs from other john smiths. Yeah, ive always thought so. And together, we can find a plan thats right for you. Great i go to the doctor a couple of times a year. And i have some prescriptions. But im never fully sure of whats covered and whats not. With humanas allinone Medicare Advantage plans, you get coverage for hospital stays, doctor visits, and part d Prescription Drug benefits. All for an affordable, and sometimes, no monthly plan premium. Do you have any more information . Sure. Ill get a decision guide in the mail to you today. Theyre free. Finally. Someone who understands the real me. Your health and happiness is important to us. Call or go online now to get your free decision guide. Call a licensed humana sales agent today. As a doctor, i agree with cdc guidance. I recommend topical pain relievers first. Like salonpas patch large. Its powerful, fdaapproved to relieve moderate pain, yet nonaddictive and gentle on the body. Salonpas. Its good medicine. Hisamitsu. That could allow hackers devices into your home. Ys and like all doors, theyre safer when locked. Thats why you need xfinity xfi. With the xfi gateway, devices connected to your homes wifi are protected. Which helps keep people outside from accessing your passwords, credit cards and cameras. And people inside from accidentally visiting sites that arent secure. And if someone trys well let you know. Xfi advanced security. If its connected, its protected. Call, click, or visit a store today. President trump announcing sunday night he is abandoning longstanding Syrian Kurdish fighters who have been u. S. Allies and lost 10,000 lives fighting isis in effect by the announcement that came last night. A dramatic policy change was announced on sunday night reversing the president s own commitment and the longstanding advice of past secretaries like jim mattis and u. S. Diplomats in the region and even his closest senate ally senator lindsey graham. Why . The president talked earlier in the day and long try to wipe out the kurds who he considers a threat to his hold on power. The endless and ridiculous wars are ending. We will be focused on the big picture knowing we can always go back and blast. He added, as i have stated strongly before and just to reiterate, if turkey does anything that i and my great and unmatched wisdom, consider to be off limits. I will totally destroy and obliterate the economy of turkey. Formernato supreme ally commander and analyst. Brett, you resigned in part when jim mattis resigned after the president tweeted that he was withdrawing all u. S. Forces from syria. That was then slow walked in the succeeding weeks and months. But this looks like the final pull back of the remaining special forces and a green light clearly to move in. These are the most consequential decisions a president can make. We have American Military personnel on the ground in syria carrying out a mission that he had authorized and then from a call with a foreign leader, it happened twice now, very impulse e ly reverses gear. This is no way to run the country and i dont say that lightly. This is very serious. No one knows what to do. I see the administration scrambling to make sense of what is happening. The president is all over the place. His tweets indicate that he has no real idea or conception of what is happening on the ground. So nobody really knows where this is going. We can go back in if isis comes baic. Look, we took isis capital without a single life because the syrian kurds did the fighting. They lost thousands of fighters. If he thinks we can go back in, who will do the fighting . Does he want to put american troops in those cities and towns to do the street by street fighting . I dont think so. This is totally incoherent. It applies to foreign policies across the board. And this is just the latest example. Admiral, when he says he can go back in, i know from my sources back in december when he tweeted that withdrawal announcement, not only a shock to the military, the u. S. Military, it was a shock to the brits who were on the ground with their own special forces. Our allies did not get a heads up at all. As a formernatoee e o commander is the effect on the u. S. . It will have a Ripple Effect throughout our global structure of alliances. I was struck, andrea, by the president s tweet that were now going to focus on the big picture. News flash, this is the big picture. This is the connective tissue that brings our allies, partners and friends to conduct these operations. I get it, we have middle east fatigue. People want to come home. But doing so opens a pandoras box and throws the field open to iran. By the way, right next door in iraq were seeing today riots. A lot of discontent in the government system. This kind of decision will have impact way beyond the immediate area and it is a fundamental part, therefore, of the big picture. We are not going to simply go back in there. The way i would think of it is, its like a forest fire. We put out the fire but still a lot of embers on the ground, except when we go back in, we will not have any firefighters helping us do it after we abandon them in the field this way. It is a mistake. And admiral and brett mcgurk this is the last Inspector General report from the pentagon that said while the territory is gone, rakka was retaken as you have pointed out, brett. The isis fighters are resurging and the refugee camp can no longer be guarded and 18,000 fighters in iraq and syria who are coming back. So, those embers are absolutely there. The president as recently as june 29th at the g20 specifically said at a News Conference with the japanese prime minister, he specifically said he would not yield to erdogans demands to go back in and take out our allies. Watch this. President erdogan, hes tough, but i get along with him. He wanted to wipe out. He has a big problem with the kurds, as everyone knows. And he had a 65,000man army at the border and he was going to wipe out the kurds who helped us with isis and we took out the caliphate. We have 100 of the caliphate and i called him and i asked him not to do it. Can i just make a Military Point here, andrea. Yeah. Which is we dont have to send 150,000 troops here. When i commanded the mission in afghanistan, fraor example, we d 150,000 troops. We had almost 200,000 troops in iraq when brett mcgurk was there doing fine work on the ground. Those days are gone. We dont need to send 100,000 troops in there. The irony of this is that it is well within our capability to have a limited number, a few thousand troops in syria could make all the difference in the world. This is being penny wise and pound foolish to withdraw them. Brett, in addition to the diplomatic fallout. I know americans, all of us are, wary of the endless wars, but this does seem like the president trying to notch up a political victory so that he has a campaign talking point. I got us out of syria. Well, maybe, but just to follow up on jims point, we have about 1,000 troops on the ground in syria. I spent a lot of time on the ground in syria. Ive seen this thing from the beginning. They are dependent upon what we call the Syrian Democratic forces. A force of 60,000 syrians we helped built. And the back force are the syrian kurds. If we betray them, we cant stay. We were dependent upon that force for our force protection and logistics and everything. That allows us to operate with a light footprint with very few forces. One more thing about what President Trump says. He talks about the isis fighters in the camp. We were asked to build u. S. Prisons for them. None of this is true. These fighters in this camp are being guarded by the syrian kurds. If the kurds now have to face an attack from turkey, these fighters may well get out. No coherence here and no plan and a very dangerous, risky situation. No way for any president to make the most consequential decisions of war and peace. Its just very troubling. Well, brett, the president has been threatening, in fact, for days, to no longer guard those camps and just let the isis fighters go back to europe saying europe wont take them, so im just going to let them go. How foolish is that . Where does a president get his information . Were not guarding these camps. Americans are not guarding these camps. The Inspector General report you just referenced go into this in some detail. Its not an american prison. They are being held by the Syrian Kurdish forces. The Syrian Democratic forces. If the Syrian Democratic forces now have to face an attack from turkey, that means even less resources to guard these fighters. Again, a total lack of coherence and the president seems to have ideas in his head that bear no relation to the facts on the ground. Very dangerous when president s make consequential historic decisions without facts. This is happening across the board on Foreign Policy and this is the latest example. Im thinking about the americans on the ground in syria who are sent there to do a mission. The Trump Administrations expanded their mission. Were going to stay on the ground until we end the Syrian Civil War which will take year. That is the Trump Administration policy for better or worse. But President Trump i dont think ever signed off on that and he now just reversed course, again, after a call from a foreign leader. Andrea, just final point from the pentagon perspective here. Everyone was absolutely flabbergasted by this. I tell you that as a fact. Nobody saw it coming and that is a real problem when youre trying to conduct not only Foreign Policy as brett points out quite well. But also military operations. That kind of whip sawing effect is extremely detrimental, not only in this tactical situation, but strategically as our planners try to prepare in other theaters from north korea to afghanistan. It is a very dangerous way to have a collision between foreign and military. One has to ask, where is the secretary of state in all of this. Thank you all, very much. Coming up, republican reckoni reckoning. New reports that lawmakers in the president s party are paralyzed by the impeachment dilem dilemma. Stay with us on Andrea Mitchell reports on msnbc. Even pet care services. And theres never been an easier way to get great advice. A place for mom is a free service that pairs you with a local advisor to help you sort through your options and find a perfect place. A place for mom. You know your family we know senior living. Together well make the right choice. Spokesman fraudsters theyre meout to get your medicare number so they can bill fake claims in your good name. Dont give them that chance. Fraudster just calling to confirm your medicare number. Do you have your card available . Spokesman for example, if a caller says theyre from medicare, watch out. Its probably a scam. Dont give out your card number. And always check your claim statements for errors. Report fraudulent charges to 1800medicare. Guard your card. Learn more at medicare. Gov fraud. What might seem like a small cough can be a big bad problem for your grandchildren. Babies too young to be vaccinated against whooping cough are the most at risk for severe illness. Help prevent this talk to your doctor or pharmacist today about getting vaccinated against whooping cough. Im asking a simple question about you clearly were upset that somehow there was an implication that military aid was being frozen because the president wanted an investigation. Why did you . Because i didnt want those connected. And i was supporting the aid, as is senator murphy and as is everybody who went to that initial inauguration. Heres the point i went forward. When i asked the president about that, he completely denied it. He adamantly denied it. He angrily denied it. Republican senator ron johnson ducking questions from chuck todd on sunday. Bringing up past investigations ignoring the president s controversial phone call about ukraine. Joining me now is robert costa for Washington Post moderator of Washington Week on pbs and Ashley Parker White House Reporter and msnbc senior political analyst, as well. Welcome, both. Ron johnson just completely imploded on meet the press. And, clearly, was surprising to chuck todd and to all of the viewers, as well, that ron johnson who had criticized what went down and reading off of notes and citing lisa page and peter struck from the fbi as though they were cia analysts. He was even getting his talking points from the white house wrong. Andrea, senator johnsons remarks on meet the press are indicative of lawmakers and roan leade leaders are responding to this measure. Theyre rallying to the president s side. Going to the barricades politically. Senator johnson, for example, has told me in recent days that he would like to perhaps mount an investigation of hunter biden and the biden Family Finances with regard to ukraine and hes the chairman of the Homeland Security committee. Thats no small thing to say for him. And you see senator johnson being very much like congressman jordan in the house. Ready to be there for President Trump who they say is the leader of their party despite this impeachment process. Mitt romney tweeted on thursday when the only american citizen, President Trump singles out for chinas investigation is his political opponent in the mist of the democratic nomination process to suggest it is anything other than politically motivated. This resulted in a tirade from the president attacking mitt romney over the weekend. Im hearing that the great people of utah are considering their vote for their pompous senator mitt romney to be a mistake. I agree. Ashley, what is going on there . Well, for a lot of the republicans who bob was just alluding to, they look at what happened with senator romney as a cautionary tale. And they realize that if you cross the president and keep in mind, in those tweets, mitt romney was quite critical, but he didnt actually say it was an impeachable offense. There is a world in which he could be far more critical. If you lightly criticize the president the message trump sent is i will come after you. I will come directly after you in very personal terms and a lot of republican senators dont want to see that. Mitt romney is a slightly different example. He is actually unfedered and popular and he sort of sees this as a last act. He feels confident in his seat but also has a wife, five children and a number of grandchildren, a ton of money. For some reason, things go awry he has a postpolitical life. Not many senators are in that position. They watched what happened with mitt romney and decide to retreat and be silent. And bob costa, you and ashley are reporting on a complete break down of any kind of action on the republican side. Its been, its been extraordinary. I mean, Susan Collins kind of dipped her foot in the water. You heard from nikki haley who may have future ambition he even say it was an offense . Entirely overhauled by the celebrity populism by candidate trump and other forces on the right from talk radio to conservative media and steve bannon and other figures who tried to inject the Republican Party with totally new ideas. So, these republican lawmakers when im up at the capital they say they sometimes barely understand their own voters and at the same time, they also see President Trump as useful politically to get a tax law through. To get conservative judges installed on the federal bench. So, its a transactional relationship and a bewildered position for many of these republicans as they move forward. They dont know who else could win a state like wisconsin or pennsylvania. So for now they operate often in fear. Robert costa and Ashley Parker, thank you. To be continued. Coming up, the tax battle. President trump losing the first round of his immunity claim against a new york probe into his taxes. Whats going to happen next . Thats next right here on Andrea Mitchell reports on msnbc. You just saved a bunch of money by switching your boat insurance to geico. It was easy. Folks, can it get any better than this . Is that what i think it is . That is an armada of tiny sushi boats. Awesome i forgot to pack lunch. You had one job. Chopsticks wasabi and soy comin in a little hot. It only gets better when you switch and save with geico. Tailored recommendations, taxefficient investing strategies, and a dedicated advisor to help you grow and protect your wealth. Fidelity wealth management. The way you triumph over adversity. And live your lives. Thats why we redesigned humira. We wanted to make the experience better for you. Now theres less pain immediately following injection. Weve reduced the size of the needle and removed the citrate buffers. And it has the same effectiveness you know and trust. Humira citratefree is here. A little change can make a big difference. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections. Serious and sometimes fatal infections, including tuberculosis, and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened, as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Ask your doctor about humira citratefree. Heres to you. Where people go to learn about their Medicare Options before theyre on medicare. Come on in. Youre turning 65 soon . Yep. And youre retiring at 67 . Thats the plan its also a great time to learn about an aarp Medicare Supplement insurance plan, insured by Unitedhealthcare Insurance Company. Heres why. Medicare part b doesnt pay for everything. This part is up to you. A Medicare Supplement plan helps pay for some of what medicare doesnt. Call Unitedhealthcare Insurance Company today to request this free decision guide. And learn about the only Medicare Supplement plans endorsed by aarp. Selected for meeting their high standards of quality and service. This type of plan lets you say yes to any doctor or hospital that accepts medicare patients. Do you accept medicare patients . I sure do so call unitedhealthcare today and ask for your free decision guide. Oh, and happy birthday. Or retirement. In advance. A federal judge has eviscerated the president s records that he should not have to turn over his tax returns. The judge calling the president s claim of immunity. The president s strategy is working because he has now won a temporary stay from an Appeals Court keeping his taxes out of view for now. Msnbc Barbara Mcquaid joins me. What about the president s claim of immunity from the state, the manhattans d. A. To look at his taxes. Well, the judge completely a annihilated that theory and what President Trump tried to say here not only immune from prosecution, hes immuned from investigation. Investigators cant even look at things like tax return documents to investigate a president. What the judge here said is, of course, we can. He said the olc opinion was not deserving of the kind of recognition it seems to get by the public. So, that was one thing. But he said even if it were true that a president cannot be charged, it does not make sense that the president cannot be investigated because its important to gather evidence so that he can be charged after he leaves office or so any coconspirators can be charged with crimes now. I also want to ask you, barbara, about a new step from the three house chairs who are leading this impeachment inquiry. Subpoenaing both defense and state department documents regarding the hold up of that aid to ukraine and saying that they were surprised by it, as well. Obviously, the state department has yet to turn over any of the documents that secretary of state pompeo was supposed to turn over as of friday night. This is a new and also omb. Mick mulvaney is the director and acting chief of staff. Andrea, this says to me that they understand why this scandal is so different from the Robert Mueller scandal. This isnt about joe biden or about tundermining the 2016 election. This is about holding up military aid in abuse of the president s power in exchange of getting something of value that he wanted. Theyre going to the heart of that. What were the directives and reasons the people were being told to hold up this military aid. The abuse of power that happened here by President Trump. One thing that will be interesting to see is whether those documents get turned over or we see executive privilege. You know, this cry by President Trump to fight all the subpoenas is something that i think could ultimately be itself a basis for impeachment of this abuse of power to override the checks and balances that exist in our courts and in congress. Barbara, thank you so much. Thanks for your legal analysis there. Coming up, biden striking back. The former Vice President has a new counteroffensive against President Trump. Youre watching Andrea Mitchell reports on msnbc. Terwork decompression zone. So when my windshield broke. Woman what . vo . I searched for someone who really knew my car. I found the experts at safelite autoglass. Woman hi vo with their exclusive technology, they fixed my windshield. Then recalibrated the camera attached to my glass so my Safety Systems still work. Who knew that was a thing . woman safelite has service i can trust. Singers safelite repair, safelite replace. At humana, we believe your healthcare should evolve with you. And part of that evolution means choosing the right medicare plan for you. Humana can help. With original medicare, youre covered for hospital stays and Doctor Office visits, but youll have to pay a deductible for each. A Medicare Supplement plan can cover your deductibles and coinsurance, but you may pay higher premiums and still not get Prescription Drug coverage. But with an allinone humana Medicare Advantage plan, you could get all that coverage plus part d Prescription Drug benefits. You get all this coverage for as low as a 0 monthly plan premium in many areas. And humana has a Large Network of doctors and hospitals, so call or go online today. Find out if your doctor is part of the Humana Network and get your free decision guide. Discover how an allinone humana Medicare Advantage plan could save you money. There is no obligation, so call or go online right now. All this talk of the preside talk of corruption comes from the president corrupted from the state department and the Defense Department and the justice department. All about making sure that he, in fact, allows somebody else to pick his opponent for him. Im not going to talk about anything other than what the facts are. Hes indicted himself by his own statements. This is not about me, its not about my son, not a shred of evidence done that has been wrong. Former Vice President joe biden responding over the weekend to President Trumps unfounded claims about bidens son in ukraine. The Biden Campaign announced their plan to counteract the president s efforts to put the former Vice President in the middle of this impeachment debate by, quote, sticking to the facts. But New York Times reporting biden is being faulted by some democrats for not responding more forcefully. Joining me now joel payne and Kimberly Atkins senior Washington News correspondent and bostons mpr news station and also msnbc contributor and Jeremy Peters reporter for New York Times and msnbc contributor, as well. Jeremy, first to you. The New York Times reporting faults the biden the bidens ca not being more aggressive. This is a huge liability, andrea. This is trumps sweet spot. His campaign and the president himself time and time again when they are attacked have taken this kind of yi know you are bu what am i approach . No, joe biden, you are the one, you and your sons were corrupt. In ordinary time, most other democrats kind of shrug off but it is proven so effective because of President Trumps unique amendment to command the attention of the media and drive the news cycle. Whatever he says because it comes and was at sheer volume and force, ultimately ends up changing the tune here and thats whats happening here with biden. Already you are seeing him struggle with how to push back. Joe payne, is he dammed or he does not dam going opening up a whole pandoras box. If hes not aggressive and does not push back, Many Democrats will say is he tough enough to take on donald trump in the elections. I love jeremy framing the news cycle. Thats what we call where i am from lying and operating without shame. Thats what the president does. Hes been telling this story of joe biden for a while now. I think with democrats are frustrated with the fact that joy d joe biden is forced to respond on trumps term. Thats problematic. He has to talk about it on president s terms and democrats looking back to 2016 and thinking of what happened with Hillary Clinton and looking back in 2008 and 2012 of what happened with barack obama and some of the lie that is donald trump reported against president obama. I think democrats dont want a repeat of that. Democrats going onto school for how not to be swift voted. Some democrats are probably going to want more fight out of joe biden. Again, no matter how hard joe biden fights, donald trump is the bully puppet out of the white house everyday. We have seen donald trump tried to frame and identify his opponents and try to define them for voters. We saw that with everybody from Hillary Clinton and the lies he told about ted cruzs father. Thats what he does. Thats something every democrats need to be prepared for. Thats why some folks i talked to were perplexed that it took biden so long to hit back. Everything he says about his family and wanting privacy is notwithstanding. Hes in this race and he knows what hes up against. Something more than an oped is something a lot of people are looking for. Jeremy, what about the head to head matchup, 4839 and Elizabeth Warren 4541. Biden is way out front in these poll poll poll polls. This is one of the states of wisconsin where trump won by a hair. I have been out talking to voters in all three of these states. The support among the people that we call the obama trump voters. Has really slipped. It is not all gone by any sorts of imagination and there is time to recover all these unknown variables including wholl be the democratic nominee and the president s late possible impeachment or really kind of clouding the picture here. What we do is his support is soft. This kind of polling. These numbers are what the Trump Campaign and the rnc are looking at themselves in their own private polling data. I will pull one number out of there that i thought was really surprising. 20 of the people of wisconsin say the new allegation of ukraine could change their view of the president. For somebody whos so well known to the American People and somebody about whom the American People have fixed opinions already. That 20 number is pretty striking. Indeed it is. Joel payne, Jeremy Peters, thank you to all. The unstoppable, jimmy carter building a habitat for humanity house a day suffer frg ing from a fall. Getting a black eye on the face. Extraordinary. You are watching Andrea Mitchell reports on msnbc. Carbon capture is Important Technology and experts agree. Thats why were working on ways to improve it. So plants. Can be a little more. Like plants. Billions of problems. Morning breath . Garlic breath . Stinky breath . Theres a therabreath for you. Therabreath fresh breath oral rinse instantly fights all types of bad breath and works for 24 hours. So you can. Breathe easy. Theres therabreath at walmart. Gimme one minute. And ill tell you some important things to know about medicare. First, it doesnt pay for everything. Say this pizza is your part b medical expenses. This much about 80 medicare will pay for. Whats left is on you. Thats where an aarp Medicare Supplement insurance plan, insured by Unitedhealthcare Insurance Company comes in. This type of plan helps pay some of what medicare doesnt. These are the only plans to carry the aarp endorsement for meeting their high standards of quality and service. So call Unitedhealthcare Insurance Company today and ask for your free decision guide. With this type of plan, youll have the freedom to choose any doctor who accepts medicare patients. And when you travel, your plan will go with you anywhere in the country. Whew call unitedhealthcare today and ask for your free decision guide. Call unitedhealthcare today pain happens. Saturdays happen. Aleve it. Aleve is proven better on pain than tylenol. When pain happens, aleve it. All day strong. Thats it. Im calling kohler about their walkin bath. Nah. Not gonna happen. My name is ken. How may i help you . Hi, im calling about kohlers walkin bath. Excellent happy to help. Huh . Hold one moment please. [ finger snaps ] hmm. The kohler walkin bath features an extrawide opening and a low stepin at three inches, which is 25 to 60 lowr than some leading competitors. The bath fills and drains quickly, while the heated seat soothes your back, neck and shoulders. Kohler is an expert in bathing, so you can count on a deep soaking experience. Are you seeing this . The kohler walkin bath comes with fully adjustable hydrotherapy jets and our exclusive bubblemassag. Everything is installed in as little as a day by a kohlercertified installe. And its made by kohler americas leading plumbing brand. We need this bath. Yes. Yes you do. A kohler walkin bath provides independence with peace of mind. Call. And ask about saving 1000 on a walkin bath, or visit kohlerwalkinbath. Com for more info. I got up this morning and ready to go to church. After that, we had a Family Reunion and we went to natureville and i fell down and hit my eye on a sharp edge and had to go to the hospital and they took 14 stitches in my forehead. But, my number one priority coming to nashville to build houses. [ applause ] 95 years old, jimmy carter at the auditorium in nashville rallying volunteers ahead of a Home Building project for habitat for humanity hours after suffering from a fall. Hes out on the job site leading a new build for habitat with his black eye, 14 stitches. This is a man survived brain cancer, broken hip not too long ago and tomorrow hell be joining me as my special guest right here on Andrea Mitchell reports. You are not going to want to muss it. That does it. I am still stunned looking at his black eye, get better mr. President. Follow the show online and on facebook mitchellreports. Here is velshi ruhle. Well definitely tune in tomorrow. Thank you, andrea. It is monday, october 7th, coming up. Breaking news, more subpoenas just issued in the impeachment inquiry. A second whistleblower is coming forward. This persons lawyer says they have firsthand knowledge of important events. Republicans struggling to defend President Trump, the politics trying to protect the president. President trump is pulling u. S. Troops out of Northern Syria to allow a Turkish Operation there. A decision thats being slammed by lawmakers on both sides of the isle with some republicans calling it a