Transcripts For MSNBCW AM Joy 20170722

Washington post that u. S. Spy agencies intercepted conversations in which russias then am bassor to the United States, Sergei Kislyak allegedly told his superiors in moscow that he discussed campaign related matters, including policy issues important to moscow, with Jeff Sessions during the 2016 president ial race. Now if accurate that would directly contradict public assertions made by sessions like this one. Let me be clear. I never had meetings with russian operatives or russian intermediaries about the trump campaign, and the idea that i was part of a continuing exchange of information during the campaign between trump surrogates and intermediaries for the russian government is totally false. In a statement sessions spokesperson said the attorney general stands by his testimony last month that he never had any conversations with russians concerning any type of interference with any campaign or election. Now this latest scoop by the Washington Post has some really interesting timing, breaking just three days after trump said this to the New York Times. Sessions should have never recused himself, and if he was going to recuse himself, he should have told me before he took the job, and i would have picked somebody else. Its extremely unfair and thats a mild word, to the president. If youll recall sessions recusal came he had two meetings with kislyak in 2016 he failed to disclose during his confirmation hearing in january. The new revelations if true contradict the various explanations sessions offered about the content of those conversations, most of which he has said he cant recall. Now make no mistake, this kind of revelation is potentially very damaging to an attorney general especially one who just got a big vote of no confidence from the president. Joining me now is ari melber, host of the beat premiering monday night on msnbc, must see tv, malcolm nance author of the plot to hack America Sarah kinsey, and msnbc legal analyst paul butler. Thank you all for being here. Malcolm, you and i had a conversation, we will not disclose our undisclosable conversations that we talk about this russiagate stuff offline but you were make the point of kind of information, these intercepts released this would be a very big deal if it were true. This is twice there have been information released in the news media we call crowned jewels, holy grail type intelligence that absolutely positively just should not be in the hands of the media, and if this story is true, and lets give it a grain of salt. Its going to leak out from the russians or from one of the top eight people who have authorization to see raw intelligence. The post said it came from current and former officials. Would former even have access to this . Mike flynn would have had access to information like this, absolutely, he was the National Security adviser at the time but current . Youre talking one of the gang of eight, the people who are cleared for this level of information, and to be quite honest, i come from the secret intelligence world. I dont like to talk about this. This should not be seeing the light of day for 75 years and if its true it makes me wonder do we have a Valerie Plame style leak to put the final nation into jeff session coffin or do we have a russian game thats being played against us, and trying to confuse and create chaos in the white house. The other big question, if this was leaked from one of these sort of aides or nine people who have access to this kind of information the question would be why and the reason i found the timing sort of odd it seems clear that donald trump would love for Jeff Sessions to just walk away and resign. He didnt do it, surprising many people in the white house that after donald trump gave that New York Times interview and really gave him a vote of no confidence and he didnt quit, if the purpose of a leak like this is to induce him or encourage him to quit its a lot worse, right . It is worse and youre asking the question from the godfather, qui bono, who benefits . As you said in the top of your setup here comes at a time that donald trump is putting pressure on Jeff Sessions not for immigration or policy issues but how his tenure may be affecting donald trump and so there is that question i think a fair one about whether this current official is trying to help the president or match the president s criticism of Jeff Sessions. Of course, the ultimate irony ther there, would obviously be a white house that says theres nothing wrong with any contacts with russia, now the problem is that Jeff Sessions had a meeting on russia so obviously theres no internal logic there. It also goes to a political point i want to floag. Donald trump ran on saying he was really good at firing people, his reality show and his brand promise were supposedly matched. Weve seen he struggles to get the ondone. We know he doesnt hold loyalty for everyone but when it came to mike flynn the actual firing was hard for him. When it comes to Jeff Sessions if he lost confidence the president does have the authority so he could remove him and when it came to the most controversial example jim comey the president didnt stand up and say i know how to do this, youre fired. He pulled the Justice Department into that odd letter that hasnt stood the test of time, so this seems to be a problem for the president when he doesnt like how someones doing, he doesnt actually know how to pull the trigger cleanly and appropriately. In this case what he would have to do in order to get rid of a lot of people presume the ultimate goal here in a sense is to push and ill go to paul butler on this, is to push out Robert Mueller, that Robert Mueller is sort of the ultimate target of this, donald trump is pretty much telegraphing hed like to let him go but legally he cannot fire him according to the statute he could only be mueller the special counsel only fired by the attorney genial and since this attorney general recused, something trump is angry about hed have to rely on an underling, a rod rosenstein, he could go down the line in the Justice Department to to it. Paul butler, i wonder if the theory this is inducement for sessions to clear the way for a more pliable or attorney general who could fire mueller then why would donald trump tweet this, this morning, since 3 33 in the morning. And he tweeted a new intelligence leak from the amazon Washington Post, this time against a. G. Jeff sessions. These illegal leaks like comeys, must stop. Thats odd hes seeming to tweet in support of him. Yes, so the president has placed the American People in a position where we have two wretched choices. We can continue with an attorney general who, if the post story is right has been misleading at minimum about his dealings with russians, and possibly has lied under oath, which is a federal crime, or we can have a new attorney general who the president has made clear would be chosen with a litmus test, what he would do about this Russian Investigation, whether she, this new attorney general, might stop it, that will be the president s apparent main consideration and who he selects. The problem, joy, is if the president does either use his pardon power to thwart the investigation or select a new attorney general by getting sessions to be fired, the president himself is courting impeachment. Thats obstruction of justice. When we look at the last two itch peoplements, obstruction of justice, even if not criminally technically proven can be an element of impeachment and one thing we know from the constitution, the president cannot stop an impeachment. And it is interesting that donald trump one of his many tweets in his tweet storm this morning at 4 45 a. M. Was whi whileiwhile all agree the u. S. President has the complete power to pardon, why think of the leaks, fake news. I want to go with everybody and start with sarah, the weird time line and maybe its weird to me, maybe my brain is weird. The Washington Post story last night said one official said that sessions who testified that he has no recollection of an april encounter with kislyak has provided misleading statements that are contradicted by their evidence, a former official said the intelligence indicates sessions and kislyak had substantive discussions on matters including trumps positions on russia related issues and prospects for u. S. russia relations in a Trump Administration. So that contradicts sessions saying he didnt talk about policy. Here is Jeff Sessions on june 13th, giving testimony about his russia contacts. Take a listen. Clearly, colleagues, i have never met with or had any conversation with any russians or any foreign officials concerning any type of interference with any campaign or election in the United States. Okay. Now one day before that, interestingly enough, this is senator al franken, and al franken sits on the Judiciary Committee which sessions testified in front of, to get the job, in which al franken said that he misled al franken, when he answered a question as franken said he didnt even ask that franken asked him have you had any contact with russians and sessions volunteered that he never talked to any russians about impacting the election, about interference in the election, but here is senator franken talking about that with our very own Chris Matthews this is the day before the sessions testimony you just heard. Theyll be asking the attorney general about some of his testimony during his confirmation hearing i imagine, and which he actually answered, he didnt answer a question i asked. He answered a different question that he made up, and that was did you meet with any russians, and he said something that wasnt accurate. Theyve intercepted some contacts within kislyak and his people. Kislyak may have been exaggerating the meeting, you know, because he wanted to look important. That sounds, sarah, almost exactly like the Washington Post report including the fact the Washington Post supposedly had this story in june and only came out with it last night. What do you make of that, that franken was saying back in june, theyve intercepted some contacts with kislyak, he may have been exaggerating the meeting. Yes, i certainly think thats possible, and you know, one thing that id like to stress here is that none of this information about Jeff Sessions is new, not the meetings with kislyak, not his work and meetings with russian officials which he did over the entire Campaign Last year when he was first hired in march 2016, despite having no experience in that arena. Theres been reason to dismiss Jeff Sessions for a long time. We know that he lied on his sf86 security clearance forms. We know that now that he likely committed perjury and we know about this meeting with kislyak, so when trump is possibly trying to set up some sort of pretext, as if he actually cares about the legal process, and views sessions as anything more than his personal attorney, which is basically what sessions has been, sessions was put there not to uphold the u. S. Constitution but to uphold donald trump. I find that implausible. The aim might be to get rid of mueller that sessions is an obstacle in this respect but trumps claims that hes upset about sessions recusal just strikes me as false because sessions never acted on that recus recusal. He didnt honor it in practice. He fired comey despite the fact that violates the terms that he was given. So all of this is a bit suspect, and i think one of the questions to ask is why is trump bothering . He usually likes to flaunt the law. He usually likes to act as if hes above it and let everybody know that thats the way he feels. So its interesting that theyre creating this kind of elaborate theatrical facade with the media and also blaming the media in the process. It is interesting, because if there are reasons to dismiss sessions, okay, but dismissing sessions would open the door to dismissing mueller. Its all very odd and interesting. Dismissing mueller and also dismissing kushner. Another thing to note is that other people in the administration have committed the exact same crimes as Jeff Sessions, so if hes going to be dismissed for meeting with kislyak, so should kushner and others who committed perjury or lied or had other meetings with russian officials that they shouldnt have had. This opens up the door to a lot of problems for trump. A long list of people they could dismiss if thats the reason to do it. Malcolm and paul will be back. Aris brand new show the beat with ari melber premieres monday, 6 00 p. M. On msnbc. Watch it while youre eating your dinner and waiting for the rest of the nights incredibly disturbing breaks news. Donald trump is commissioning the uss gerald ford today. The navys newest aircraft carrier. If he says anything newsworthy well bring that to you right away. Up next, trump draws a red line. Stay with us. T. But every one of those businesses will need legal help as they age and grow. Whether it be with customer contracts, agreements to lease a space or protecting your work. Legalzooms network of attorneys can help you, every step of the way. So you can focus on what you do and well handle the legal stuff that comes up along the way. Legalzoom. Legal help is here. For years, centurylink has been promising fast internet to small businesses. But for many businesses, its out of reach. Why promise something you cant deliver . Comcast business is different. We deliver superfast internet with speeds of 250 megabits per second across our entire network, to more companies, in more locations, than centurylink. We do business where you do business. I love the president , and the president is a very, very effective communicator. The president has really good karma, okay, and the world turns back to him. Hes genuinely a wonderful human being. We got closer during the romney campaign, where we did a couple of fundraisers in his magnificent apartment. Ive seen this guy throw a dead spiral through a tire. Ive seen him at Madison Square garden with a top coat on standing in the key and hitting foul shots and swishing them. He sinks threefoot putts. I love the president and i think a lot of you guys know in the media ive been very, very loyal to him. You saw the newest member of trump world Incoming White House Communications Director Anthony Scaramucci. Apparently his nickname is the mucc. But the White House Team wasnt the only big reshuffle. The legal Team Spokesman mark caryo resigned and longterm attorney mark kaswitz reported to take on a lesser role. John dowd veteran d. C. Criminal defense lawyer will take the lead amid these shakeups theres one big question in washington, is trump working on another pink slip for special counsel Robert Mueller after trump said mueller investigating his Family Finances would be a red line. Both the New York Times and the Washington Post reported that team trump is investigating the investigator, looking for dirt that could discredit the extremely well respected mueller, and perhaps open the do are to his firing. The president was especially disturbed when he found out muleler have access to, wait for it, his tax returns. Malcolm nance is back, David Kay Johnson is back, all sorts of things in the prompter the making of donald trump is also his book. Lets bring everybody back in. Malcolm first before we talk about this red line, there was a point you wanted to make in the previous segment about that weird timing of the Washington Post bombshell about sessions. This story as it was heard in the washington rumor mill has been out there for a very long time and the post had this story. We heard al franken mention it. Right, maybe as far back as march. Interesting thats the sort of top secret atomic bomb information you would want three solid sources on who all verify it and maybe the post didnt have that, maybe it was sitting on it because they couldnt get verified but if you get a call from a Current Administration official, day after, you know, you put your hit out, the story goes out and now it does the bidding of the white house. This can only benefit the white house. It does not benefit anybody and puts a line towards mueller. It puts a line toward mueller and thats i think where we come in, David Kay Johnson. This was donald trump in the New York Times interview where he expressed no confidence in sessions, and the other bombshell was this, about Robert Muellers investigation. So david, trump says this is about russia, as his personal finances are not about russia. Is donald trump wrong about that . Well his finances are about russia. Donald has been going to russia and doing business with russians since the 1980s, there are deals that dont appear to make any commercial sense whatsoever involving the russian, theres the ongoing effort by trump to suppress and prevent trial on the allegations involving the Trump Soho Hotel and whether it was a big tax fraud, the money, the profits disappeared into an Icelandic Bank under the thumb of the oligarchs, and notice that donald trump is always attacking Law Enforcement, this didnt new. He was attacking anyone in Law Enforcement who went after him in the 80s and the 90s, mayor ed koch said trump should have served 15 days in jail. attach he attacks koch. Interesting he never attacked Vladimir Putin. He never attacks him but going back to the 1980s has had this sort of drawn to russia, and of course the 80s was when Vladimir Putin was still a kgb agent, and its interesting, malcolm, whats being isolated now is were getting dribs and drabs about what the investigation is about. Right. The fbi apparently had isolated at least three individual sort of pieces of trump world theyre looking at, trumps involvement in this soho hotel that David Cay Johnston just mentioned a failed development in new york he did with russian association, some have russian mobbish ties, the 2015 Miss Universe pageant held in moscow and trumps sale of a florida mansion he bought and sold for almost 100 million to a Russian Oligarch in 2008. What would the significance of that, lets pick one of them, the pageant. I wrote a whole book on this. You did. These are really easy things for u. S. Investigators to fall on, because one step before we go to Miss Universe, back to the sale of that house in palm beach, where he built it up, essentially does a flip, gets a 50 Million Commission off of that from an oligarch who levels the place and never sees it. Thats a dangle. You are testing that person to determine whether he is good for the money, and now you have a hook in him, and once you have that hook, with the igalarov you can start working and manipulating. As we saw between 2013 and 2015 Donald Trumps entire Foreign Policy flipped to moscows, and no one has ever been able to put their finger exactly on when it actually turned, but they do know when it started, it started with the Miss Universe pageant where he wined and dined and thought he was making Vladimir Putin his best friend. All of these things are part of the m. I. C. E. Acronym, money, ideology, cooperation or coercion and ego, those are the four factors that you recruit an agent for. He may not even know that he is an asset under your control until you pull that string and then suddenly you need him to do things for you, and they do. Clappers version saying people may not know theyre down a treasonous path. David ca johnston the professionals call. M. I. C. E. I call it need and greed. You see this pattern not just in donald trump but his entire family business. You have eric trump telling a reporter even though he now denies it that they have access to 100 million in russian money, they dont need american banks. You have donald trump jr. Saying a substantial portion of our assets are coming from russia, you have trump selling lots and lots of real estate, condos to russians, over and over again. Have you in your reporting all these decades on donald trump seen a pattern of him making, doing this much business with anyone else or are russians sort of uniquely positioned to constantly feed him money . Donald is deeply involved with the russians and to some extent the communist chinese banks that he owns money through, through various business entities, because american banks wont lend money to him. Remember, donald said after the fact, i borrowed money knowing i wouldnt have to pay it back. Well, try that with your banker and see if you can get a loan. And the russians have exploited this. They clearly think of him as an asset, and if you look at whats just leaked that was in the earlier segments being discussed, how convenient, when youre trying to find a way to get rid of your prosecuteor, in trumps case, Robert Mueller, that there is this intercept. How sloppy of the russians that they did this in a way that it was intercepted, but how curious this story has been out there for a while, and who benefits from that . Well, the russians benefit to the extent that they have their friend in the white house helping pursue their agenda, undermine democracy, break up nato, break up the european union, and expand russias territory to include the russian speaking former parts of the soviet republic. Yes. It is awfully convenient that this information drops just when donald trump wants to move his attorney general out and Sergei Kislyak seems to have given him one more hail mary. It is very convenient and interesting. Malcolm nance will be back in our next hour. David cay johnston thank you as always. Coming up, out goes spicy, in comes the mooch. Thats next. Whoa youre not taking these. Hey, hey, hey youre not taking those. Whoa, whoa youre not taking that. Come with me. Youre not taking that. Youre not taking that. Youre not taking that. Mom, im taking the subaru. Dont be late. Even when were not there to keep them safe, our Subaru Outback will be. vo love. Its what makes a subaru, a subaru. So find a venus smooth that contours to curves, the smoother the skin, the more comfortable you are in it. Flexes for comfort, and has a disposable made for you. Skin smoothing venus razors. We rbut we are not victims. Ack. We are survivors. We are survivors. We are survivors. And now we take brilinta. For people whove been hospitalized for a heart attack. We take brilinta with a baby aspirin. No more than one hundred milligrams. As it affects how well brilinta works. Brilinta helps keep platelets from sticking together and forming a clot. In a Clinical Study brilinta worked better than plavix®. Brilinta reduced the chance of another heart attack. Or dying from one. Dont stop taking brilinta without talking to your doctor,. Since stopping it too soon increases your risk of clots in your stent,. Heart attack, stroke, and even death. Brilinta may cause bruising or bleeding more easily,. Or serious, sometimes fatal bleeding. Dont take brilinta if you have bleeding, like stomach ulcers,. A history of bleeding in the brain, or severe liver problems. Slow heart rhythm has been reported. Tell your doctor about bleeding,. New or unexpected shortness of breath, any planned surgery, and all medicines you take. If you recently had a heart attack, ask your doctor about brilinta. My heart is worth brilinta. If you cant afford your medication, astrazeneca. May be able to help. Sean spicer, say it isnt so. Exactly six months after making his first statement in the White House Briefing room, a blistering atack on the press based on a trumpian lie about crowd size at the inauguration, spicer is getting off the trump train at unemployedsville. Yes it was a ride that was memorable to say the least, full of statements, contradicted by the bosss own tweets. By nature not a ban. I understand but the president himself called it a ban. Is he confused or you confused . No, im not confused. One very incorrect history lesson. You had a, you know, someone who as despicable as hitler who didnt even sink to using chemical weapons. He brought them into the, to the holocaust center, i understand that. Even a few minutes hiding from the press among the bushes. And seemingly ends the intrigue about his hold on the job. At one point he was reduced to petty theft he had to take the mini fridge the junior staffers refused to give up. What did spicy get for defending trump with alternative facts and feats of verbal gymnastics a big old snub from his boss left off of the officials selected to meet the pump to meet the pope, something spicer long wanted. At least we the American People got this cultural treasure, Melissa Mccarthy alsz the embattled and frustrated spokesman nicknamed appropriately just spicy on saturday night live. Now im going to open it up for questions and im going to probably freak if you start asking stupid ones, speaking of freaks and stupid ones, glenn thrush New York Times, stupid hat, go. Look, i just wanted to know what the president intends to do now that the Appeals Court denied your request to stop the travel ban. Youre testing me, big guy. Well miss you melissa and spicy, too. More on this and the man fitting spicys ill fitting shoes in the white house next. [brother] any last words . [boy] karma, danny. Karma [vo] progress is seizing the moment. Your summer moment awaits you, now that the summer of audi sales event is here. Audi will cover your first months lease payment on select models during the summer of audi sales event. Dad flash drives . Yup. Thats dad taking care of business. Laptop setup . Yup. But who takes care of dad . Office depot, office max. This week, all hp ink, buy one get one 30 off. Taking care of business buy one get one 30 off. Olay regenersit shatters livthe competitionype . Big hype. Big price. Big deal. Olay regenerist hydrates skin better than creams costing over 100, 200 and even 400. For skin that looks younger than it should. Fact check this ad in good housekeeping. Olay regenerist. Ageless. Now, boost your regimen with Olay Regenerist concentrate. To keep our community safe. Before you do any project big or small, pg e will come out and mark your gas and electric lines so you dont hit them when you dig. Call 811 before you dig, and make sure that you and your neighbors are safe. 811 is available to any business our or homeownerfe. To make sure that you identify where your utilities are if you are gonna do any kind of excavation no matter how small or large before you dig, call 811. Keep yourself safe. Ive seen this guy throw a dead spiral through a tire. Ive seen him at Madison Square guard within a top coat on, standing in the key and hitting foul shots and swishing them. He sinks threefoot putts. Thats love. Move over sean spicer, trump world has a new star. 53yearold financier White House Communications director Anthony Scaramucci may not have a lot of political experience but he excels one quality key to success in the white house lavishing excessive effusive praise on his boss. I think hes got some of the best political instincts in the world and perhaps in history when you think about it. What i have found when i travel around the country people love him. The president has really good karma, okay . But scaramucci wasnt always on the trump train. You called donald trump a hack . Hes a hack politician. Ill tell you who hell be president of, tell donald i said the Queens County bullies association. You got to cut it out now and stop this crazy rhetoric spinning everybodys heads around. Oops. Joining me theresa kumar, caidones do dawson, Michael Steele. Ill start with you and give you the gift of the trump tweet out of his 37 tweets or however many this morning he tweets, Anthony Scaramucci endorsed jeb bush, he was originally for scott walker who didnt run and he went to jeb bush. He endorsed a lot of other people before donald trump we wasnt for him and trump now tweets in all fairness to Anthony Scaramucci, he wanted to endorse me first before the republican primaries started but didnt think i was running. Its weird but i guess falling in love with donald trump and telling him how much you love him is part of the job. What do you make of his migration from trump critic to this . One of the things there was a great piece done by politico basically saying that scaramucci really desperately wanted to have an ambassadorialship. Thats what he was really going after so when you look at it in the totally of wanting to go abroad, this is not his first choice. Kind of like the president was not his first choice and so i think that there are a lot of interests that might be binding him to the president right now that bloomberg first reported back in january with his relationship with russia. We dont know what that kz loo li looks like but there were special conversations happening in davos while he was there with some of the financiers and that needs to be peeled back and that would all of a sudden make sense of why he has a new love interest. Right, and there were some questions among some congressmen, Michael Steele, his company sky Bridge Capital a Global Investment firm hes in the process of selling and i think back in february, there were some members of congress that wanted to know did that firm have any conversations about doing business in russia, maybe can he relate to trump on that level. It is interesting that you have the trump team, Michael Steele, looking into discrediting Robert Mueller, in part based on looking at the team hes putting together campaign donations, and yet they then turn around and hire a guy who is wellknown for having wined and dined both democrats and republicans, given money to both parties. He gave 5,600 to barack obama in 2008, 4,600 to clinton in 2007. He said that he voted for barack obama and bill clinton. He said that in 2011, and before the 2016 election scaramucci was saying he hoped bill clinton would be the next president. So if its disqualifying for muellers people to have given or in the past had any association with the clintons, does it strike you as odd that trump would hire somebody who is essentially a clinton and obama supporter to be his chief spokesman . Muellers people arent trumps people. Its that simple. This is a transactional thing with trump, okay . I can look past the fact that you supported clinton because hey, as a private citizen i supported clinton. Did you. Which trump did, but in the context of the ongoing investigations, yes, that becomes much more of a Political Tool or weapon for trump to use. Going after muellers folks and mueller himself is less of anything of real substance, more laying a predicate for any action he wants to take against mueller in the future that will help sell that action to his base. You know, and its interesting, caton, what it seems donald trump wants in his Communication Team is a certain look, there was a cnn person who said something to the effect of Anthony Scaramucci is what trump thinks he sees when he looks in the mirror, hes really rich, his suits fit and all that kind of thing but also a certain kind of combatant, this guy is a sean hannityesque kind of combatant who a few years agoer have viewing a pr firm for himself to use he was blunt according to a piece on him about what he was looking for. Scaramucci told this person i need someone who is prepared to go to the mat and lie for me. So caton, what does that tell you about the time of Communications Shop donald trump wants to see run . Tony scaramucci has been around a while. Hes wicked smart. He went to Tufts Harvard University Law degree. Hes taken one of the most important jobs in politics, all of us understand communications is critical, and were going to find out how quick can he turn gray headed, were going to find out how tough he is. Hes a political chameleon. Like donald trump theyve given to both parties, something Michael Steele and i have never done. Right. Theyve done a lot of things together so were going to find out how good a choice this is, because right soon weve got the 2018 midterms coming up, and the message better be about jobs, about everything that trump run on, because all this other stuff in russia is in the way of any kind of political success right now. Thats what concerns us on the groupe ground. Dana, its interesting, you can katon say this needs to be about the things donald trump ran on. Anthony scar mooch hou scaramuc against on. This tweet is still on his twitter profile. Walls dont work, never have, never will. The berlin wall 1961 to 1989, dont fall for it. Uhm dana . Well, joy, first, to paraphrase mooch, it is the greatest honor and privilege of my life to be with you this morning because you have the greatest instincts in all of broadcasting. Thank you, yes, more, more. I think what youre seeing here in the choice of the mooch is trumps instincts not to reach for people who have the best ideas, the most experience, the ability to get things done in government, but those who will flatter him. Its reminiscent of the, that famous Cabinet Meeting where they took turns dueling to praise him. Trump is willing to forgive a lot of things. Hes more interested in the thing youve said lately. Hes always interested in the last thing that was said to him, and scaramucci has been perhaps his most stalwart defender out there, on fox news, which is of course extremely important to the president. So he is basically reinforcing this echo chamber that hes built in the white house, with buddies of his, with kin of his, and weve seen where its got him but clearly hes doubling town. Its more of the same. Hes picking a guy who once said we need to get hillary, i love hillary we need to turn this around. Its one of the reasons he was for her and the wall street guys preferred hillary to barack obama for instance is that they felt obama was too tough on wall street. Exactly. This guy is nothing if not a huge fan of wall street, another contradiction with the way is he wall street. He comes from goldman sachs, but what is interesting is that i think his replacement of sean spicer is sending a signal very closely saying that what the only swamp that trump is actually going to drain are the people who understand politics, who are actually part of the establishment. Sean spicer is the first part of the shakeup but please expect more and i think what hes going to start is inoculating himself with more wall street insiders, more business folks and that is going to actually keep him and congress having really difficult time to actually have conversations and put anything forward. I want to go around quickly and start with you, Michael Steele. Donald trump does not have a team of professionals much as he did in the campaign. It worked for him in the campaign. Can he make it . Can he survive without anybody that actually understands politics or the hill . Hes just adding people from fox news or people from, sorry not fox news, from breitbart, hes got the bloggers in there. He still doesnt have any professionals and just let go one of his rnc guys. Yes. No, i think he can. Largely because even if he brought those individuals in, those professionals in, he would still be the ultimate decider of what those professionals would do and how they would do it, and when they would say it and what they would say, so trump is his own ringmaster here. He doesnt need anyone else managing any other part of this circus. Hes got it in his control and he will keep it there, so this is the state of the white house for the rest of the term. Very quickly, katon, same question to you in a way. He does have this sort of autocratic devotional crew. Is that more important to donald trump having people praise him and sort of, you know, whip up his base for him than be professional . Thats been his history, ands been a micromanager. The thing about the white house if youre coming to drain the swamp you better have some professional plumbers and thats what the base wanted. They wanted a big strategic change in washington, and we hadnt seen it yet. And dana, i guess at least provide more comedy for you writers in d. C. Well, thats the most important thing, but i think the pattern youve seen with trump he has a way of destroying the people around him, whether its spicer or Jeff Sessions, mike dubkey and eventually scar mooch even and the others, but he walks away relatively unscathed while those around him fail. Thank you very much. Dana will be back in our next hour. Coming up in our next hour, Jared Kushner, r. Kelly and o. J. Keep it right here. Your brain is an amazing thing. But as you get older, it naturally begins to change, causing a lack of sharpness, or even trouble with recall. Thankfully, the breakthrough in prevagen helps your brain and actually improves memory. The secret is an ingredient originally discovered. In jellyfish. In clinical trials, prevagen has been shown to improve shortterm memory. Prevagen. The name to remember. Wheyou wantve somto protect it. E, at legalzoom, our network of attorneys can help you every step of the way. With an estate plan including wills or a living trust that grows along with you and your family. Legalzoom. Legal help is here. Theres about to be a new fbi director in town, his name is christopher ray. Will he take trumps loyalty pledge . More on that on the other side of this break. Noo introducing the easiest way to get gillette blades text blades to gillette on demand text to reorder blades with gillette on demand. And get 3 off your first order. Is not just something you can see or touch. Home. Is a feeling. Its the place where you feel safe to have those little moments that mean everything. At adt, we believe that feeling should always be there. Whether its at your house, or your business, we help keep you safe. So you can have those moments that make you feel at home. You are loved wherever you are. Whats Critical Thinking like . A basketball costs 14. Whats team spirit worth . cheers whats it worth to talk to your mom . Whats the value of a walk in the woods . The value of capital is to create, not just wealth, but things that matter. Morgan stanley if im given the honor of leading this agency, i will never allow the fbis work to be driven by anything other than the facts, the law, and the impartial pursuit of justice. Period. Full stop. My loyalty is to the constitution and to the rule of law. Donald trumps nominee for fbi director has his work cut out for him. Especially considering what trump told the New York Times this week. Quote, the fbi person really reports directly to the president of the United States. Nope. Joining me now is former fbi agents clint watts. The fbi director has never reported to the president of the United States. What do you make of it when you heard donald trump say that . Hes trying to consolidate his power. And its pretty sad. He seems to think that every aspect of governance even out to the legislature at times is under his control. What he doesnt understand, is he fbi director, his job is to keep the citizens of this country safe from both crime and National Security threats. And so we have to have an independent fbi director. The tradition is he reports to the attorney general. Thats the way it will stay moving forward. The position was really created by the u. S. Attorney general. J. Edgar hoover was the fbi director, he didnt report to the president. We are in a unique situation historically. Youve already had donald trump fire an fbi director. How difficult is it going to be for Christopher Wray to be an independent actor knowing that is the propensity of the president . When the biggest qualification for the fbi direct ser when he will resign for a loyalty test, we have entered a new phase of governance. Were looking at his qualifications. But if donald trump does this, will you resign . Will you leave . Will you not follow orders . I think thats what hes walking into. Hes walking into the traditional job. Hes also walking into a job with a president whos under a serious cloud of doubt, of questions, of this russia investigation. Hes got a tall order to fill. And, you know, a lot of mine fields in front of him. Clint, i wonder, because theres so many potential mine fields here. You have the Mueller Investigation already taking place. You have some analysts saying if donald trump were to try to pardon his family, it would be proof of guilt of obstruction of justice. There are plenty of people available to investigate when i comes to russian allegations. How difficult will it be for an incoming fbi director to set himself up, learn the system, get to know the staff. This guy has not been an fbi agent, i dont believe, before and also try to keep tabs on an administration that is prone to fire any recalcitrant member of the administration. I think there are some pluses and minuses to it. You know, on the plus side, wray is coming in and he can really just focus on the fbi. In terms of the russia investigation, most of it is going to fall to the mueller team. So hes got an opportunity to really sort of focus on his troops. Really sort of build and restore some confidence in the agency about where the direction is going to be and how it moves forward. On the minus, hes now the third fbi director we are going to be talking about almost simultaneously. Youve got mueller. Comey is still going to come back into play in this investigation. And now youve got wray. So hes crowded by two other fbi directors that are taking a lot of the limelight. So hes got a lot to contend with. At the same point, he might be able to focus on the fbi team and really give those agents what they need for investigations out in the field. At the same time naveed, theres also the counterintelligence side of the fbi. How difficult is their job now when you have a president openly talking about russia. How can he possibly do that job . Its a very good point. Following up with the Jeff Sessions stories and even to the president s point as much as i hate to say this, the leaks are causing a major problem in terms of just the simple function of the fbi, the Intelligence Community. I think that theres you know, its an uphill battle. Not to mention to your point, joy, wray is coming in with a 12year break. It was 2005 the last time he was in government. A lot has changed. Technology curve was pretty great. He was very upfront of admitting theres a lot of things to get up to speed with. Hes also coming into as clint has mentioned, an interesting time where two other fbi directors are in the limelight as well. I think its going to be a real challenge. Clint, among your former colleagues in the fbi, hows mora morale . I havent talked to many of them recently. Im sure theyre busy with their investigations. I think for them they want to pursue their job without interference and do whats right for the American People. Im hopie ining under wrays leadership that could come back again. Thank you, guys, for your time. Really appreciate it. And up next, the latest in the russia investigations. Dont blink. Its going to be a big week. Mo more a. M. Joy after the break. Youre not taking those. Whoa, whoa youre not taking that. Come with me. Youre not taking that. Youre not taking that. Youre not taking that. Mom, im taking the subaru. Dont be late. Even when were not there to keep them safe, our Subaru Outback will be. vo love. Its what makes a subaru, a subaru. Only tylenol® rapid release gels have laser drilled holes. They release medicine fast, for fast pain relief. Tylenol® dad flash drives . Yup. Thats dad taking care of business. Laptop setup . Yup. But who takes care of dad . Office depot, office max. This week, all hp ink, buy one get one 30 off. Taking care of business in the New York Times he raised questions about Robert Mueller. Does he endorse his legal teams efforts to undermine Robert Muellers credibility . Again, the president has absolutely nothing to do with any of the allegations that are being made. I think hes maintained that. And he wants them to complete their process as quickly as possible so we can move on from theory lick th the ridiculousness of all things russia. Saying Robert Muellers investigation would include the finances. But mueller has a broad move to investigate. And hes working to follow the money wherever it leads. Trumps red line comment has led to speculation that he may be gearing up to fire mueller. But even with mueller gone, that wouldnt be the end of the investigations into whether trump colluded with russia. Theres still multiple investigations and plenty of money and debt for there to follow. Like the debt manafort reportedly owed before joining the trump Campaign Last march. Or the debt Jared Kushner and his family took on to buy the building at 666 5th avenue in 2007. Next week kushner, manafort, and donald trump jr. Might have to explain all of that and more to the senate. But not to the public. Kushner is scheduled to be interviewed in a closed door session on monday. Then hell go back to capitol hill on tuesday to speak with the House Intelligence Committee also in private. Meanwhile, the senate Judiciary Committee has worked out a deal with trump jr. And manafort to hold a session also close to the public next week. The Committee Also asks them to turn over all documents related to what to that eightperson that we know of june 2016 meeting that included russian nationals with connections to the kremlin and the former kgb. Now known as the fsb. All this comes as another member of trumps inner circle is under fire. Last night the Washington Post broke the news that u. S. Spy agencies intercepted alleged conversations that Sergey Kislyak says he had with officials in moscow. Had with officials in moscow about two separate interactions between him and Jeff Sessions in 2016. Kislyak said trump spoke with him about campaign and policy matters. Drip, drip, drip. Joining me now is author of the plot to hack america, paul butl butler, Jennifer Ruben, mckay koppens. Thank you all for being here. Jennifer, im starting with you on this first. The white house has been told to preserve all documents about the trump junior meeting. That takes care of him. You had Jared Kushner come out with yet another Financial Disclosure in which he remembered another 77 meetings and this financial filing about all the money theyve made. He and ivanka. This is now inevitably circling in on the trump family and inner circle. So what do you make of Donald Trumps threat to mueller not to go near his finances in light of all that . I think its a trial to see if the republicans balk. If he can get away with firing mueller. Whatever trump is afraid of must be really, really bad. Because he is now talking about not only firing mueller but of course pardoning himself which many of us think is not permissible. I think he fears that the finances are going to lead some place that is going to be either embarrassing or lead to crimes. And so hes desperate. And frankly, the republicans havent been all that strong. If they know whats best for them, i would suggest that mr. Mcconnell and mr. Ryan come out and flatly say if he fires mueller, theyll begin impeachment hearings. If he pardons himself, theyll begin impeachment hearings. Thats the only thing to der ter him from moving ahead. If not hell try to fire mueller and pardon himself. It doesnt bode well that republicans would send that kind of a warning to donald trump. This was on cnn. Chris collins was on cnn on friday and he was saying that mueller actually shot stay away from trump. Lets take a listen. I hope mueller wouldnt cross the line into tax returns and he should let go of the business things. The president is not subject to the normal ethics issues when it comes to business. That is the line. Youve been doing reporting on the hill about republicans wanting to stay away. Is there any chance that the Jennifer Ruben suggestion they say to trump dont do it or else would ever happen . Well, i think the place to look is not at the chris coll s collins. You want to look at the republicans who have spoken out a little bit, maybe tepidly but a little bit about russian interference of the election. Maybe criticize trumps handling of the comey situation. People who are kind of on the fence. And those that kind of thats where the movement is going to occur. What i will say is that my conversations with republicans on the hill over the past couple of weeks have not suggested there are any grand plans for Serious Movement against trump. The one possibility, you know, if youre looking for movement is if mueller is fired or if it looks really likely that mueller is fired, you might see Congressional Republicans just acting out of selfinterest. And, you know, urging him not to do it simply because they dont want the political pressure to shift back onto congress to be investigating this. For the most part theyve been kind of deflecting by saying, well, were going to find out where the Mueller Investigation leads. If that ends, then they have a world of hurt coming to them. I think a lot of Congressional Republicans are going to need to speak up now. Are you sure that that is where they stand . Because the question i have is, a, would they have that same reaction if sessions were to be fired . If donald trump were to force sessions out. And b, dont their interests align with the white house . If the Russian Investigation went away, that would also help Congressional Republicans who would like to clear this off the books so they can bring tax cuts and gut medicaid. Theres no question republicans would love for this to go away. For the most part what theyre most concerned about is getting some bills passed and winning reelection. Right . That said, i think that its an open question whether this would actually go away. I think if trump fired mueller or the deputy a. G. And then mueller however that would work out, it would cause a massive political fire storm. Im not convinced that the washington press, the national media, democrats would let them off the hook that easy. And i think theres a concern among Congressional Republicans i talked to that this would end up just consuming months and months of kind of. Still making it possible for them to advance their agenda. You would be among those that are covering it. You do have trump, his aides looking for leverage against mueller. You have this vote of no confidence from donald trump to Jeff Sessions. If he were to start i said gate these firings, put a lackey in his place, somebody willing to fire mueller. Again, if they could put in an a. G. Who suddenly declared weve investigated, we found no wrong doing, case closed, how would the washington meeting disentangle themselves from an attorney general saying theres nothing there. Listen. We had an email that came out two weeks ago of that june 26th meeting with Jared Kushner, paul manafort, most senior and intimate advisers. They colluded with the representative, the general of russia who is a putin crony to get dirt on Hillary Clinton. They claim nothing came of the meeting with but that wasnt because they didnt try. And how many republicans have reacted to that . This was outright evidence of collusion with a foreign power. Some people consider an adversary. And i dont consider what they bat an eye over this. That tells you all you need to know. They tied themselves to the ss trump. They will stay until the water is over their mote. I dont see them coming out even then with these trial balloons that trump is sending out about his ability to fire mueller or pardon himself and his family. So they are just running, theyre ducking, covering. Thats because not only do they fear him, they fear the fact that 80 , 90 of Republican Voters despite republicans are still with trump. Thats what their fear too. I dont see any, you know, any cavalry coming to the rescue in terms of Good Governance and drm principals from leaders. They will determine whether they are in proceedings or anything else. I have to agree. I dont see it either. But i wonder now if you switch to the Intelligence Community side. You have seen leaking which is the permanent government fight t back his own community akin to nazis. If you think trump would bioengineer an end to the proper that there would continue to be information coming to the press from the permanent government. I dont know. Lets go to the Richard Nixon Memorial Library and see how that worked out. I mean, this is not going to work. Its not permanent government. All right . Its the machinery that makes the United States government work. That facile sates everything on down to your treats. A part of that is the fact that they have documents. And this investigation is not you know, i say this once again. They do not understand this is a giant wood chipper bearing down on them and there is no way out if this investigation goes. Its going deeply into finances. 13 of the top financial fraud investigators in the Justice Department are already at work and they already know it. Not to mention the spy hunters. Put all of this together, theres just no way out of this freight train. That being said, you can fire them all tomorrow morning and all of that documentation is going to exist. Its going to fall off in front of the New York Times on a palette. And the next thing you know, the investigation will shift to a Senate Select Intelligence Committee with subpoena power. To six months or faster. And not to mention Jennifer Ruben that governments always change. They always change hands. And eventually democrats may get back in hour in the house and the whole thing changes. You also have, jennifer if you put up this is the people who were connected just that we know of to Sergey Kislyak. This is a Washington Post thing. I dont know if you see all the gray dots that may we may find out. Youve got kushner, carter page, donald trump with all these ties. Now you have these new information that Michael Flynn is in need of money. Michael flynn has started yet another consulting firm. He doesnt have the money to pay for his Legal Defense. There are all these places where trump would have to count on all these people going to jail for him. Yes. Its sort of amazing. Remember, none of these people ever remember meeting with russian ambassador. It was a memorable figure. A very large man, very loud, distinctive. So the level of duplicity here of lying about these contacts is one thing. And i think youve hit the nail on the head. First of all, in all the people that donald trump has thrown overboard and ridiculed and disdained and dispensed with, why is he so defensive of Michael Flynn . Hes not a family member. He wasnt there at the very, very, very beginning. So what is it about Michael Flynn that has donald trump so concerned about his fate . So concerned about the reputation . I think that is one big link, one big weak link in the defense around the presidency. And youre right. I dont even think trumps relatives are going to go to jail for him. Is Jared Kushner really going to go to jail for his fatherinlaw . I dont think so. Well see. Well see, yes. We have a prosecutor here. Let me ask him that. Paul butler, you tell me because youre the prosecutor, is that the risk that you have people with a lot to lose that may not have the money that donald trump has and he doesnt seem to be offering Legal Defense funds for everyone who then went up cooperating out of their own need. Is that what theyre looking for right now . Yes. So Michael Flynn will be one star witness. Paul month fort has got all these shady real estate actions with trump. You can be sure that mueller has all of the bank records from trump, manafort, everyone else whos involved. Seen he probably is looking to flip manafort. Plan fort was at this weird meeting with the russian operative with donald junior. He knows what happened there. He doesnt have the same kind of loyalty that trump junior might have. So its going to be really interesting to see what happens at this meeting on wednesday. Don junior testifies for the first time under oath. Hes got to tell the truth. Going to be able to ask specific questions about russia. It seems really difficult for folks involved in the Trump Administration to tell the truth, the whole truth about russia. So really interesting hearing on wednesday. Could they be prosecuted if they were found to have lied in those hearings . Absolutely. False statements, perjury. Its not enough to say oh i forgot. They have some of the worlds leading investigators and best prosecutors who are going to be on their case parsing every word they say. Thats why if it were a regular situation, no way would they go in there. Enter interesting. That may be why they arent going into public. Thank you very much, everyone. Coming up, Mitch Mcconnells quest to kill health care. Thats next. When heartburn hits fight back fast with new tums chewy bites. Fast relief in every bite. Crunchy outside. Chewy inside. Tum tum tum tum new tums chewy bites. The revised version of the Health Care Bill will still leave 22 million uninsured. Do you still think the senate should move forward at least with repealing . I do. I think thats a bogus number. What theyre basically saying is People Choose not to buy something that they dont want to buy if they dont have to buy it. The governments forcing people to buy something they dont want. And so if we stop forcing people to do something they dont want to do, they wont do it. No. No, thats still not true, speaker paul ryan. The cbo has found that under the senate gop plan, millions of people would lose health insurance. Not just because of the lack of individual mandate. But because of drastic cuts to medicaid and to premium subsidies that would make health care too expensive to buy. Despite daily reports of the demise, the republican effort keeps coming back. Because the health care fight has become the worlds scariest real life zombie movie. Joining me now, tara, dana milbank, and mckay coppins. Do you think this will eventually pass . I think theres a strong chance it may eventually pass. Mitch mcconnell is one of the most craven politicians out there. Hes also a teactician. People make fun of him say he looks like a turtle, all those things. They all belie his political skills. Thats why hes continued to win election even when being deemed part of the establish pment. He should never be underestimated. What he thrives on and benefits on is trumps controversies which allow him to operate in the cover of darkness while people are so focused on what Donald Trumps latest scandal is. And also what he benefits from is that he doesnt care. He has made the calculation that he can win reelection and that they can hold a lot of those seats if they still repeal it and that repealing it is better than not repealing it. Mckay, you talked to republicans on the hill a lot. You have a texas senator saying knowing the health plan ahead of time is a luxury we dont have. And many said dont people want to know about it beforehand . If republicans are willing to vote on something they dont know theyre voting on, doesnt it seem inevitable theyre going to vote for whatever Mitch Mcconnell puts on their plate . Its possible. Although so far that hasnt proven out. I agree with tara. Mitch mcconnell always has a plan and he wins more often than not. Even last week when it looked like it was imploding, i was cautioning people who were against his Health Care Plan not to be too optimistic. As one senior republican aide told me, obamacare died a hundred deaths before it passed. I think a lot of the republicans in the senate are looking at this the same way. That said, if you look at the state of play of this legislative situation, its kind of unclear what republicans are even going to be voting for next week. Its possible theyll be voting for again for a replacement bill that a lot of them dont like. Its possible theyll just be voting for a straight up repeal of obamacare. And it might be even something else. We dont know right now. So its hard to make a strong prediction about whats going to happen. But i do think you cant count mcconnell out at this point. He hasnt proved to be that deft at getting his caucus together so far. But part of the reason for that is theyve been very vague about what it is theyre doing. They just say vaguely obamacare is terrible, its imploding. Theyre not specific about the fact theyre talking about the problems in the individual market. 7 to 10 of the market. Youve got a quarter of the market is medicaid. That is the big thing. And in a lot of these states it is up to more. And yet you have a big state with a lot of population needs where they didnt expand medicaid but needed to because there are so many uninsured. This is one of the florida senators. Marco rubio openly saying that its time to gut medicaid. Take a listen. The fundamental difference within the republican conference if you want to narrow it down is between senators who argue why are we doing so much on medicaid . Lets only deal with the parts of medicaid that obamacare chan changed. And those like me who say this is an opportunity to reform an important Safety Net Program and put it on a sustainable path for the longterm. That is republicanese for lets gut medicaid. It is extraordinary to me that you now have some republicans ready to go out on the rail and say we need to gut medicaid when so many of their own republican constituents in red states want and need it. Right. Well, at least hes being honest saying thats what he wants and what hes up to. Look, the problem the republicans are having is theyve spent seven years saying we dont like obamacare but they havent spent time saying what they do want. Now theyre on a position of what do we vote on and everybodys got a different idea of that and theres no consensus there. But i do think its premature to say theyre not going to get away with it. Theyre probably not going to resolve much this coming week, but theyre going to be at this over and over again. You look at the republican budget in the house. Theyre going to take a whack at medicaid there. Likely at medicare. And youre going to see, you know, a thousand Different Things coming at obamacare to try to undermine it. And dismantle it. Theyve been very successful at sabotaging the Insurance Markets already. Its interesting because you have trump vote who are are telling the New York Times they dont even remember why they didnt like obamacare. You have conservative red state voters saying i really need my medicaid. And you have republicans and, you know, to danas point, rubio was honest saying this is an ideological choice. Theyve dreamed since they were in college of undoing and unwinding assistance programs for people in need. I wonder if donald trump has any thoughts on this . He doesnt seem to understand what any of these bills are. Do republicans really think that he is just the whisperer to red state voters to the point even if they took their health care away, he would convince that them thats good for them . I remember why people didnt like obamacare. Because it was obamacare. When they didnt know Affordable Care act was the same as obamacare, the polling changed around the bill even back then when it was less popular. And that speaks to the larger issue here. Right . So because it is trump, trump has cultivated this cultlike following on twitter. We see the cult45. But there is real legitimacy to the hash tag. Hes cultivated a following where what hes done is make people feel if you attack trump, youre attacking them. Thats why you see them upset about him getting rid of the Affordable Care act and medicaid, wanting to do that and at the same time still supporting him. And the overwhelming majority said even if this goes away, i am still going to vote for him. Because the environment were in right now is that there is no way that the majority of republicans are ever going to vote for a democrat. Thats the point weve gotten to. And thats what the Republican Party has created in this country. And they know that. And they also are aware of the infighting with democrats. Thats why i say they are never to be underestimated. The only thing thats standing in the way right now is the fact that democrats have done something they havent done in recent memory. And thats actually fight a sustained fight. Yeah. And thats what needs to continue. And what do elected republicans in washington fear more . The pain inflicted on their own citizens, their own constituents, or the donors coming at them for not repealing obamacare . Well, thats actually the i think the way to frame it in as much as theyre caught between supporting and voting for the most unpopular piece of legislation in 30 years. Or facing the wrath of the republican donor class who are desperate to get this repealed. What doesnt factor into this is Donald Trumps threats, i think. Because we saw some Court Reporting this past week he is making barely vailed threats at people like nevada senator heller who is, you know, in a tough spot here for reelection. The reality is donald trump is extremely unpopular. Hes popular with republicans. But for senators who are not in gerrymander districts it doesnt matter as much. Getting reelected, looking out for their own political selfinterest. When theyre staring down the barrage of negative ads from conservative groups, that does factor into their decisions. We are out of time, unfortunately. I would have loved to have gone on longer. Thank you, guys, very much. Up next, the inJustice League. Stay with us. Noo introducing the easiest way to get gillette blades text blades to gillette on demand text to reorder blades with gillette on demand. And get 3 off your first order dad flash drives . Yup. Thats dad taking care of business. Laptop setup . Yup. But who takes care of dad . Office depot, office max. This week, all hp ink, buy one get one 30 off. Taking care of business buy one get one 30 off. A trip back to the dthe doctors office, mean just for a shot. But why go back there, when you can stay home. With Neulasta Onpro . Strong chemo can put you at risk of serious infection, which could lead to hospitalizations. In a key study, neulasta reduced the risk of infection from 17 to 1 . A 94 decrease. Applied the day of chemo, Neulasta Onpro is designed to deliver neulasta the next day, so you can stay home. Neulasta is for certain Cancer Patients receiving strong chemotherapy. Do not take neulasta if youre allergic to neulasta or Neupogen Filgrastim . Ruptured spleen, sometimes fatal as well as serious lung problems, allergic reactions, kidney injuries, and capillary leak syndrome have occurred. Report abdominal or shoulder tip pain, trouble breathing or allergic reactions to your doctor right away. In patients with sickle cell disorders, serious, sometimes fatal crises can occur. The most common side effect is bone and muscle ache. So why go back there . If youd rather be home, ask your doctor about Neulasta Onpro. Donald trump persistently claims if it were not for voter fraud, he would have won the popular vote. But can that be true if you have an Approval Rating of 37 . Just a thought. More a. M. Joy up next. Led, what is your nationality and i would always answer hispanic. So when i got my ancestry dna results it was a shocker. Im everything. Im from all nations. I would look at forms now and wonder what do i mark . Because im everything. And i marked other. Discover the story only your dna can tell. Order your kit now at ancestrydna. Com. Only tylenol® rapid release gels have laser drilled holes. They release medicine fast, for fast pain relief. Tylenol® if you wanted to assemble a Justice League of Voter Suppression, you couldnt did better than Donald Trumps Integrity Commission which met for the first time on wednesday. Kris kobach, christian, and hance vonn spakovsky. And now together trumps superteam of vote suppressers are working to nationalize their attacks on Voting Rights all to substantiate his invented ideas of voter fraud and a rigged election. First hell have to get after a wall of opposition in the form of seven separate lawsuits. The most recent one coming from the naacp Legal Defense fund which claims in its lawsuit, quote, the work of the commission as described by its cochairs are grounded on the false premise that black and latino voters are more likely to perpetuate voter fraud. Joining me now is president and ceo of the naacp Legal Defense fund. No two better people to talk to on this issue. I want to put this back of of the socalled inJustice League. All of whom have a history on this matter. And play you one of them. Kris kobach saying something pretty extraordinary to our own katy tur. You think that maybe Hillary Clinton did not win the popular vote. We may not know the answer to the question. Really . You really believe that . Lets suppose the commission determined that there were a certain number of votes cast by ineligible voters. You still wont know whether those people who are ineligible voted for trump or clinton or somebody else. The votes for donald trump, that led him to win the bex as well . Absolutely. Sharon, this is a legal case. So presumably there has to be data floated in this. Is there any evidence whatsoever we cannot know who won the 2016 election . No, there isnt. But that is consistent with what has been this drum beat and claim that widespread inperson voter fraud happens in this country. And its a claim thats been perpetuated by the vice chair of the commission who you just played but also other members here. These are all people who have perpetuated the myth of voter fraud without any evidence of inperson widespread voter fraud. Each of them in turn premised that on the idea that noncitizens are voting. That is code for latinos who are not citizens are voting. During the campaign, thencandidate trump and even later after the election trump and his spokespersons continued to talk about noncitizens voting, illegals they called them. And attributed some of Hillary Clintons vote to illegals. But you also heard candidate trump talking about urban areas. Said watch chicago. Watch st. Louis. He actually instructed his supporters to go watch them, go stand behind them. Call Law Enforcement if necessary. We know what happens in those cities. This was all coded language to indicate that africanamericans and latinos would be engaged in voter fraud. For the purpose of wild allegations that the president made were, in fact, true. Whatever the commissions work is and now theyve announce what had they are going to do, we believe in our complaint we strongly lay out the case that much like the muslim ban, this was created for the purpose of engaging in Voter Suppression. Theres two ways to look at this commission. This wild claim by donald trump and his own ego he won the popular vote. He cant stan stand the fact he didnt. The other way to look at it, this is the culmination to purge the voter rolls of people of color. It comes after a rather chilling request to all of the secretaries of state to turn over their voting roles and personal information. Heres the talk about about the states resistance, more than 40 of them saying no to that. If any state does not want to share this information, one has to wonder what theyre worried about. And i asked the Vice President , i asked the commission, what are they worried about . Theres something. There always is. Setting aside this is a president who wont turn over his tax return so his transparency is in doubt. Just the desire to not turn over personal information about their voters is evidence of guilt in those states . You know, President Trump even before the election was tweeting out this possibility that there are 3 million to 5 Million People illegally voting. He is creating that narrative. What is particularly pernicious right now is this is not just the culmination of folks like kris kobach and others, theres an appeals process in the New York Times i wrote about where the Justice Department on the very same day issued a letter and the Justice Department can force states to turn over the data about how states are purging voter lists and maintaining voter rolls. Pursuant to the National Voter law. That law was passed in 1993 with the goal of tries to increase opportunities. To prevent it from accessing the polls. The legislate from doj asks not a single word about how states are actually complying to ensure access to registration. Its focused on what states are doing to maintain voter rolls. Right now you have processes through the commission and through the Justice Department that is seeking as its a prelude to voter purging. Thats who they represent on the commission. I think right now when you look at the news this week and whats happening and what the agenda is on Voting Rights, you see the threats repeatedly and ongoing persistence of attacks on the media. All three of these things are core ingredients to the health of american democracy. All three are quite blatantly under attack right now. Talk about a dream team of ken blackwell, you got kris kobach whos had an obsession about nonwhite immigration. This is what john lewis civil rights hero said about hans vonn spakovsky. Hes been hell bent to make it more difficult tr people to vote. Its like he goes to bed dreaming about this and gets up saying what can i do today to make it more difficult for people to vote. It almost seems like the makeup of the commission is the best evidence for your lawsuit. I think youre absolutely right. I think there are three main pieces of evidence. One are the statements made by the president , his spokesperson, and spokespersons and surrogates about what he believes is voter fraud and why he wanted to create this commission which came right out of his statements about widespread voter fraud. Which has been stacked with what was called a rogues gallery of Voter Suppression. All of the individuals you mentioned. Third are the actual plans of the commission. Talked about the request from the 50 states. A spokesperson for Vice President pence indicated they intend to compare the data they receive against federal data bases from Homeland Security and other places. Thats kind of like the Cross Check Program that secretary of state kansas secretary of state has been running which has been proven to have a bis proportionate influence. But never threat disproportionately. Because of the kinds of names that are likely to show up in the database. So everything about this commission from the president s statements about it, the formation of it, the membership, the plans for the commission, all of it leads to one conclusion that this is created to do the work that the piecemeal cases that we have been winning in federal court by the way on Voter Suppression and voter i. D. , its designed to take all of that piecemeal work and to combine it and put it together into one National Platform that voter suppressers can draw on to continue their efforts through voter purges and other means. This is a reconfiguration of what happened during the Bush Administration when many were fired for not pursuing the cases. If you want to know why republicans arent afraid to take your health care away, maybe its because theyre confident not everyone will be a toibl vote them out. Our dream team here of talking about Voting Rights thank you very much. We appreciate it. Thank you. Coming up, fallen stars. Two infamous names from the past. O. J. Simpson and r. Kelly. Back in the headlines again. More a. M. Joy after the break. Noo introducing the easiest way to get gillette blades text blades to gillette on demand text to reorder blades with gillette on demand. And get 3 off your first order how to win at business. Step one point decisively with the arm of your glasses. Abracadabra. The stage is yours. Step two choose la quinta. The only hotel where you can redeem loyalty points for a free nightinstantly and win at business. I am happy to announce that i will be at politicon out in l. A. On july 29 and july 30th. Ill be there talking about a variety of topics and would love to meet you. So if youre in socal, please free to come on by. And check out politicon. Com for more info on how to attend. Come see us. More a. M. Joy after the break. Where all the walls echo with laughter and every room has its own chapter youve carried on your familys tradition. Let us help you prepare for your familys future. Financial guidance while youre mastering life. From chase. So you can. On a hotel just go to priceline. They add thousands of new deals every day at up to 60 off. Thats how kaley and i got to share this trip together at this amazing hotel. Yeah ash and i share everything dresses, makeup, water bottles. We do . Mmhmm. We share secrets, shoes, toothbrushes. What . Yeah i forgot mine so ive been using yours. Seriously . Whats the big deal . I mean, we even dated the same guy. Who . uh, go to priceline and get the hotel deals you wont find anywhere else. When heartburn hits fight back fast with new tums chewy bites. Fast relief in every bite. Crunchy outside. Chewy inside. Tum tum tum tum new tums chewy bites. Did you know slow internet can actually hold your business back . Say goodbye to slow downloads, slow backups, slow everything. Comcast business offers blazing fast and reliable internet thats up to 16 times faster than slow internet from the phone company. Say hello to faster downloads with internet speeds up to 250 megabits per second. Get fast internet and add phone and tv now for only 34. 90 more per month. Call today. Comcast business. Built for business. Everything old was new again this week as two of the most infamous names from the past from past legal scandals reappeared in the news. Many of us were riveted thursday as networks went walltowall with coverage of o. J. Simpsons parole hearing. And we were horrified at a buzzfeed report detailing allegations that r. Kelly selfdescribed pied piper of r b was Holding Women against their will in what parents of one woman described as a cult. A representative for kelly has denied the allegations and one of the women has said shes not being held against her will. Back in 2008 kelly was acquitted on all charges when he went on trial for child pornography, but this weeks news has resurrected news of those old allegations. And this eyepopping thing from kelly. Do you like teenage girls . When you say teenage, how old are we talking . Girls who are teenagers. Joining me now is the afrofree msnbc contributor, toure. Didnt he look different in that picture . And jackie reid, my play cousin and host of nbc new york live as well as my cohost on my pod cost. I want to get video of you from ten years ago. His face in that interview. When we showed the picture of his face in that interview, it was priceless. During that time, this is something that happened in 2008. And you walked away from that thinking r. Kelly is a pedophile, what . I mean the answer he gave, when he struggled to say do you like teen age girls and he couldnt easily say, no, what are you talking about, that was a softball. Do you like teen age girls. You just got off of a child pornography trial. Just say, no, what are you talking about . But he couldnt say that. There was something in the face and the look that made it seem like, wow, were talking about teenage girls, where are they . The drool is there. And so, yes, from that moment i and many others felt like he was tacitly saying yes, even though his front brain knows i should say no but he cant say yes because the compulsion seems so great. And he was married to aaliyah who was a teenager. She was 17. The aunties are still listening to r. Kelly at the party. Its very infectious, great music, but have we failed black girls, knowing since 2008 since toure sat down with him and he couldnt say he wasnt into teenage girls and hes still allowed to perform. His new tour is actually selling better. One of the girls thats allegedly caught up in this cult, i believe the one whose mother had a news conference, she admitted when her daughter first met r. Kelly, she, the mother, was a huge r. Kelly fan and took her to the concert and introduced her to r. Kelly. And then when he asked for the parents blessing to take this girl under his wing and on tour or wherever he took her, they said okay because they really didnt believe the charges that were brought up against him since he was acquitted of them. You know, from james brown to chris brown, we make these sort of divisions, from the music versus the person. I mean roxanne gay talks about this in some of her writing, when the rhythm is that good, you cant divorce it from what your brain is thinking about. The person is evil or vile. You just get stuck. And dancing to music that you know is not aaffirming to you and your life. Race is also a factor. For so many africanamericans because of the history of how they have been treated in the criminal justice system, they look at r. Kelly like him being abused or mistreated by the system. But thats without them doing their homework and digging deeper. This buzzfeed piece isnt just gossip on the internet. This is a ninemonth journalist Investigative Journalism piece. And i have to read this one piece from karen atia in the Washington Post. The excerpt is for decades now the listening public has given that manpower, fame and money, the same tools that you yoosds to prey on girls. He wields his talents to entertain us and allegedly uses them to destroy the lives of black girls. This is the devastating part and america doesnt give a damn. I want to move on to o. J. Simpson. Your thoughts now on o. J. Simpson being freed. Remember, he wasnt in jail for the murder charges. Oh, no, he was jailed because of the murder charges, right . And sentenced to 33 years because of murder charges. You dont do nine years on this time of a charge, a firsttime offender, an older person, unless you have this other thing. I thought theyre never going to let him out and the political pressure on the board would be too great. Im glad to see that he got out because we should not have a government the government cannot convict you so theyll get you for something else. We dont want that sort of government. Even if you dont like o. J. , you dont want that sort of a government. It will be interesting to see if he continues to take these kind of moments and opportunities for granted, you know what i mean . What will he do . Because his time in prison, and prison even in a medium security prison, its not an easy thing. He had favor from guards, other prisoners, he had a flat screen, you know what i mean. It wasnt a tough life for him to come out remorseful. And he did watch his friend, donald trump. He attended Donald Trumps wedding to marla maples and so apparently he was in the know. Weve got to show this picture of toure. Can we show who he really looks like . No, no, no . There we go. Programming note, tune into a special o. J. Simpson chasing freedom tonight at 10 00 p. M. Eastern. Watch us tomorrow at 10 00 a. M. Eastern. You get used to food odors in your car. You think it. Smells fine, but your passengers smell this bell dinging new febreze car with Odorclear Technology cleans away odors. For up to 30 days smells nice. Breathe happy, with new febreze. Good day, everyone. Im alex witt here at msnbc World Headquarters in new york where it is high noon in the east, its 9 00 a. M. Out west and President Trump is in norfolk, virginia, where he has just wrapped up remarks at a commissioning ceremony of the uss gerald r. Ford navy ship. Heres what he told those gathered for todays ceremony. Wherever this vessel cuts through the horizon, our allies will rest easy and our enemies will shake with fear because everyone will know that america is coming and