Plus, the Vice President kicks off the gun safety campaign. But will the Senate Democrats have the guts to take the votes . Tonight, ill remind congress what courage looks like. And there is either a major hoax, major lies, or both going on at notre dame. I cry. I yell. I never felt that way before. Last thing she said to me was i love you. Tonight, the latest on the manti teo story with the people who broke the story at deadspin. And Howard Fineman on how the rest of the sports world blew the story. Good to have you with us tonight, folks. Thanks for watching. We knew it was coming. The conservative reaction to president obamas common sense gun measures was far too predictable. Today marked one of the most brazen attempts ever by an american president to unilaterally implement new laws without the consent of the legislative branch. I actually think the president , he just doesnt have the guts to admit it, is not a believer in the Second Amendment. There are certain things in his executive orders that are unamerican. In some ways theyre even fascistic. Hes a tyrant. He hates the Second Amendment. And hes unamerican. Righties are up in arms over the executive action signed by the president of the United States. The president s biggest orders include the nomination of an alcohol, tobacco, and firearms director. He asks for a study on gun violence prevention as well as reports on Safety Technologies on stolen firearms. Apparently, conservatives believe this is tyranny. Today Vice President joe biden detailed one of the major initiatives of the president s gun proposals. How do we make our streets and schools safer . With regard to our streets i believe and the president believes that cops make a difference. Were going to push again for another 4 billion in grants for the cops program. 4 billion for more cops on the streets and around schools in america . This is what the gun lobby was demanding. But the gun nuts, well, theyre not so happy. Texas governor rick perry is trying to push himself into relevance again. He said in a statement the Second Amendment of the constitution is a basic right of free people and cannot be nor will it be abridged by the executive power of this or any other president. Kind of threatening, is it . The national the Republican National committee wrote, president obamas series of gun control measures amount to an executive power grab. Really . These statements did not mention a single action or proposal by the president. They call these measures inconstitutional. But none of them point to anything of any detail whatsoever. Without the ability to attack specific proposals, conservatives attacked the president personally instead. Four children attended the president s announcement yesterday. These concerned young people wrote direct appeals to the president asking for changes to gun laws. Dear president obama, i think there should be some changes in the law with guns. I am very sad about the children who lost their lives in connecticut. I may not be that into politics, but my opinion is it should be very hard for people to buy guns. I love my country, and i want everyone to be happy and safe. No guns, no guns, no guns, no guns. P. S. , i know youre doing your best. Now, remember, michele malkin, she thinks thats child abuse. Some might call it education. Some might call it america. Heres how the drudge report rewarded the president of the United States for allowing children to share their voices and opinions. A picture of stalin with a small child. And if you had the bad sense to click onto the next page, oh, you were treated to this charming picture of adolf hitler with a little girl. On fox news the far right was just as unhinged. I consider it a form of child abuse and political malpractice. So conservatives say the president is an unamerican tyrannical child abuser. Is he really this bad . They must have a plan to stop him. After listening to the 23 executive actions the president announced today my next guest has decided to stand up to king obama and in a hannity exclusive senator rand paul is unveiling new legislation to stop obamas assault on your Second Amendment rights. In this bill we will nullify anything the president does that smacks of legislation. And there are several of the executive orders that appear as if hes writing new law. That cannot happen. No, its rand paul to the rescue. He has a bill to reverse all of president obamas executive actions. Talking points memo obtained senator pauls proposal. There is no mention of a single order in violation of the constitution. Not one. Maybe these righties just dont know enough about the constitution. Perhaps there is someone who could help them out. Lets try former bush attorney general michael mukasey. It seems to be by definition an abuse of power, a power grab, if you will. No . It is politically it is a power grab, yes. Politically is it then unconstitutional in some instances . I dont think its unconstitutional in the sense that i dont think its something you that could get a court to find unconstitutional. Uhoh. Its not the answer hannity was looking for. Maybe he should try asking it in a different way. So did you think that obama care was unconstitutional . Did i . Did you agree with the majority opinion . The Supreme Court said it was unconstitutional. You did . So you agree with john roberts . Yes. You did. Im surprised. Because in that case so through the use of the Commerce Clause we can now mandate that people buy things . No, he didnt say you could use the Commerce Clause. He said you could not use the Commerce Clause. Right. What he said was it was a tax. Must have been a mixup in the prenotes of the preinterview. But lets see a shot in freeze frame. This is the face of a truly confused man. The elevator doesnt go all the way to the top here, folks. If only sean hannity would listen to his boss, he might not be so confused. The constitutional right about guns is for selfdefense and hunting. Founders did not mean modern weapons of war. Lining up the crazy is not a difficult task for the right wing these days. But this rhetoric and hysteria i think is very dangerous. There is no basis to call the president of the United States a tyrant or a dictator, and no president ever deserves to be compared to stalin or hitler. But of course it continues. It happened earlier this week. Someone needs to be an adult in the room to tell them to cool it. You know . This is america. But abusing the First Amendment really is not good. There is a responsibility when youre in front of a camera and you have a microphone. And if this is the way they want to use it, what do you think is going to happen . Get your cell phones out. I want to know what you think. Tonights question, will Republican Leadership denounce this type of rhetoric . Text a for yes. Text b for no to 622639. You can go to our blog at ed. Msnbc. Com. Well bring you the results later on in the show. Im joined tonight by karen finney, msnbc political analyst and former Communications Director for the dnc. And eugene robinson, msnbc political analyst and pulitzer prizewinning columnist and associate editor for the washington post. Great to have both of you with us tonight. Eugene, first with you. Do these people even understand what they mean when they call the president a tyrant and a dictator . Well, obviously, they dont, ed. This is an incredible freakout. Lets have a little perspective here. First of all, theres nothing in the executive orders that they can name that smacks of legislation. In fact, the executive orders are fairly mild. And second, president obamas view of the Second Amendment is precisely antonin scalias view of the Second Amendment. The president has long believed it protects an individual right to keep and bear arms but he agrees with scalia that you can restrict the ownership of dangerous and unusual weapons. Like assault weapons. So when theyre arguing with the president and calling him stalin and calling him hitler, they are arguing with the most conservative justice on the most conservative court weve had in 100 years. Karen, where is the responsibility of republicans . Do they have an obligation to push back on this extreme rhetoric . Absolutely, they do. Think about the cowardice. Here they are accusing the president of using children as human shields. And yet i dont i think maybe Chris Christie is the only republican weve heard actually come out and say how disgusting it is that the nra is using the president s children in a web ad that does two things list building and fundraising. If were going to talk about the use of children, i have not heard a single one take responsibility for that. I think overall the tone and the tenor of this conversation is going to be a big problem for the republicans because remember, weve got a number of battles coming up where the republicans are already on defense. When it comes to Immigration Reform, we know the opportunity for their rhetoric to get out of control is quite big. On this theyre not talking about gun safety, reducing, you know, gun violence, and this kind of extreme rhetoric pulls them farther to the right. So if the leadership of this party doesnt get control, theyre going to have to answer theyre going to have to answer for the likes of Rush Limbaugh and some of those other whack jobs. You know, eugene, you have a United States senator from kentucky who is making comments about the president. You wonder how schooled he is on the constitution. And you wonder why republicans dont pull him off to lunch and say you know, what youve got to kind of correct this a little bit. I mean, their silence is deafening on this. He talks about it a lot. Rand paul, senator paul, has always talked about the constitution a lot. But clearly here hes not on thin ice. Theres no ice there at all. Theres simply nothing there. And he doesnt mention one specific item in the president s list of executive actions, they werent all executive orders as he claims, one single action that supposedly violates the constitution. What is he talking about . You know, ed, on the politics of this lets be really lets call this for what it is. Both marco rubio and rand paul are looking at 2016. So they are speaking about the president with the same kind of disrespectful rhetoric that weve been hearing from the Tea Party Darlings for quite some time. So clearly part of their motivation is looking ahead for their own political interest because theres not a lot of substance here to back up what theyre saying. Why would a United States senator from florida, rubio, question whether the president has guts . After what this president has done and the tough calls that he has had to make. I cant think of another word. Is it childish . It is childish. Particularly i mean, what gutsy thing has marco rubio done . Lets see. He proposed some Immigration Reform ideas that are pretty much like the president s. So i dont think weve got an original idea out of him. I dont think weve gotten a bold idea out of him. It doesnt take a lot to go on fox news and say that the president doesnt i mean, come on, right . Okay. The question to you, eugene robinson. Is this all dangerous . Well, it is dangerous. It is dangerous when rhetoric heats up to this level. Its dangerous especially when youre talking about guns. And look, theres an attempt to create the impression that obama and the mean democrats want to take away your guns. Very specifically, no one is talking about that. No one wants to do that. And in fact, as i mentioned, the president s view of the Second Amendment is really quite conservative. He doesnt want to take your guns. He just wants to make this place safe so we dont have newtown massacres every year. Well, i dont hear democrats talking like this. Theres no comparative vernacular we can use that come from the democrats on this. It will be interesting to see if there are any republicans that might step forward and say you know, lets tone it down a little bit. We all know what we want, we dont have to say what has been said so far. Karen finney and eugene robinson, great to have you on the ed show tonight. Thank you so much. Remember to answer tonights question there at the bottom of the screen. Share your thoughts with us on twitter edshow and on facebook. We always want to know what you think. Coming up, a moment of truth for democrats who were afraid to lose their nra class a rating. A former congresswoman will join me. And she made a tough vote that ended her congressional career, but it was the right thing to do. Stay with us. Well have that story next. Officemax has exactly the ink. Your business needs. At prices that keep you. Out of the red. This week get a bonus 15 itunes gift card with any qualifying 75 ink purchase. Find thousands of big deals now. At officemax. A College Football stars emotional story turns out to be a hoax . Well have the latest on notre dame linebacker manti teo and the mystery surrounding his online girlfriend. With deadspins managing editor tom skoka. And Howard Fineman of the Huffington Post will weigh in on it tonight. And another Business Owner comes out against obama care. Find out what ceo of whole foods has to say about the Affordable Care act later. You can listen to my radio show on sirius xm radio channel 127 monday through friday, noon to 3 00 p. M. Share your thoughts with us on facebook and on twitter using the edshow. Were coming right back. Excuse me, sir im gonna have to ask you to power down your little word game. I think your friends will understand. Oh no, its actually my geico app. See . I just uh paid my bill. Did you really . From the plane . Yeah, i can manage my policy, get roadside assistance, pretty much access geico 24 7. Sounds a little too good to be true sir. Ill believe that when pigs fly. Ok, did she seriously just say that . Geico. Just click away with our free mobile app. Welcome back to the ed show. Gun control debate that is going on in this country is a leadership moment for the president of the United States and for every single lawmaker who has a vote. Here is what Senate Majority leader harry reid recently told a local pbs station in nevada. Lets be realistic, he said. In the senate were going to do what we think can get through the house, and im not going to go through a bunch of gyrations just to say that weve done something. If were really legislators, the purpose of it is to pass legislation. Senator reid did not show the same kind of hesitation with another moral issue, relief for superstorm sandy. The relief package was passed by the senate even though House Speaker john boehner hadnt brought it up for a vote. In fact, the Senate Passage helped to put pressure on the house. Sandy relief passed in the house with a minority of republican votes and almost every democrat. Speaker boehner would not have brought the bill to the floor if it hadnt already been passed in the senate. There was similar pressure with the fiscal cliff deal. It passed in the senate first. Then boehner was forced to bring it to the floor for a vote and the house, even though only a minority of republicans supported it. Today senator majority leader harry reid seemed to clarify his position somewhat. In a statement he said, i am committed to ensuring the senate will consider legislation that addresses gun violence and other aspects of violence in our Society Early this year. All options should be on the table. Well, that sounds a little bit better. But there should be no hedging on this issue whatsoever. Especially from democrats. Because if they side with the president of the United States think about what president obama has done for the Progressive Movement in this country in the democratic party. How can you not stand with him on this . How much more information do these lawmakers need . Have we not covered it enough . Other Democratic Senators with high ratings from the National Rifle association have also refused to say if they support the president s package. Max baucus of montana, senator Heidi Heitkamp of north dakota, senator johnson of south dakota. Senator donnelley of indiana. Senator begich of alaska, senator manchin of west virginia, senator tester of montana. However, senator mark warner spoke out in favor of the president s plan and said he believes it has bipartisan support. Those senators all have a or aplus ratings from the National Rifle association. Reid has a b rating. These senators know they will lose their high rating and maybe become a target with the nra if they vote for a sensible assault weapons ban. You see, we had the assault weapons ban back in 1994, but were so screwed up in washington right now theyre even afraid to go back to that. Every senator should explain to their constituency why they would not cast a vote for the assault weapons ban. Whats the holdup . What are you afraid of . Certainly its not the nra. These senators should not fear the National Rifle association. The nra didnt affect any races in the last election cycle and it probably wont do it the next time around. Now, if Senate Democrats cannot get over the hump of losing their a rating from the National Rifle association, folks, this gun legislation, it isnt going to go anywhere. Senator al franken of minnesota is another democratic lawmaker who was somewhat puzzling in the last 24 hours who decided to clarify his position. He says, i cosponsored legislation to ban large clips like those used in so many mass shootings, he said in a statement. I also support the principle that we should reinstate a ban on assault weapons. And i will carefully review any proposal to do that. In principle. Can we get some Straight Talk . Because that in principle kind of thing leaves a little wiggle room that maybe you might not do it, al. There are other Senate Democrats ready to vote right now. There are multiple democrats sponsoring their own legislation. A background check bill from senator chuck schumer. An assault weapons ban from senator dianne feinstein. A magazine limit from senator frank lautenberg. And an antitrafficking bill from senator Kirsten Gillibrand out of new york. Heres Vice President joe biden today reminding the conference of mayors what this legislation is really about. That tragedy in all my years of public life i think has affected the public psyche in a way that ive never seen before. Parents in the streets, panicking. Trying to find out if the child they put on the bus in the morning had any prospect of getting back on the bus and going home that afternoon. Is that worth a vote . Im joined tonight by former congresswoman Marjorie Margolis mizvinski, now an adjunct faculty member at the university of pennsylvania. She was a oneterm congresswoman who i wish that wasnt the case, but thats what happened. And you cant i did a driveby. You cast the deciding vote for clintons tax increase for two decades, which took this country to surpluses. And you were targeted because you voted for a tax increase. But at the time you said, there are times in all our careers when we must ask ourselves why were here. Marjorie, great to have you with us tonight on the ed show. Nice to be here. You are an example of courage, and the president has said this is going to take courage. Can you apply what you went through to todays gun debate . What do you think . Oh, well, i was also targeted. I mean, they just loaded both of the barrels and came after me also. I was just talking tonight with somebody who worked for me in my congressional office, arlene halpernin. She said the phones never stopped ringing. And thats one of the problems. But as a member of congress you have to understand that people do not call in when theyre satisfied. So nine out of ten calls said vote against this. And at that time it was in 93 and we were talking about an omnibus spending bill. It was a deficit reduction bill but of course it was called the tax increase. And there were things in the bill that i liked and there were things in the bill i didnt like. I didnt think it went far enough with regard to deficit reduction. I didnt think it went far enough with regard to entitlements. So i was a no vote, and i walked into the house that night and the republicans were highfiving saying they dont have the votes and the democrats were figuring out how they could switch their votes and i said wait a minute, we came in with this president in 92, it was the largest class of women, there were 21 new women, 24 democrats. And the president was on the phone, and he said what would it take . And i said a serious discussion about entitlements, further cuts, and ill only be your last vote because there had only been two in the house as you know, a tie vote goes down. Sure. So i said id only be your 218th vote and there had been two votes i knew like this in history. One for the impeachment of Andrew Johnson and the other one for the draft. So and i said and they needed me. But i represented the most the president needed you, correct . Correct. And the president right now needs democrats to stand up the way you did no matter what the ramifications are going to be in the next election. Do you think Senate Democrats need to be willing to say goodbye to their National RifleAssociation Rating . But they also have to be willing to vote and be and stand up for what they believe in, and thats the reason the public is so darn angry with all of these representatives. It is a good job, but are you there to make sure you deep it or are you there to be a leader . And there is a difference between representing and leadership. And thats what you have to understand. Coming from me, i was such a lousy politician, and i represented the most republican district represented by a democrat in the country, and they came to me. I mean, it just i had to roll my eyes. I was very surprised. But it was really interesting the following day when there was all this hubbub, i talked to one of my kids who was at camp. And he saidy did you do that . You know, youre going to lose everybody he said youre going to lose. And i said because it was the right thing to do. And its so rare in life when you can say that to anybody. Especially one of your kids. And 92 of americans right now favor background checks, including republicans and gun owners. And a majority of the nra. People who belong to the nra. What would you tell a wavering lawmaker right now in the wake of what we have seen in this country, the carnage, the constant shootings, the death on american streets . What would you say to a lawmaker . Would you point to your experience . I dont know if im a great example. I just think that we have a window here. The people feel so strongly about this. The stories and the you cant i used to be a reporter. I know that i watched people cover this. You cant do it without weeping. Its so yeah. There is a window here. Wk make change. Step up to the plate. Have the cojones to do it. You need a spine. Get it done. Thats very good advice. Marjorie marguliesmezvinsky. I think you speak for a lot of americans who would say just that to congressional members. Coming up, we have the latest developments on the manti teo hoax. And it is unbelievable. There is actually proof he lied more than once. The managing editor of deadspin. Com and nbc news political analyst Howard Fineman are here with all the details. Stay tuned. I have a cold, and i took nyquil, but im still stubbed up. [ male announcer ] truth is, nyquil doesnt unstuff your nose. What . [ male announcer ] alkaseltzer plus liquid gels speeds relief to your worst cold symptoms plus has a decongestant for your stuffy nose. Thanks. Thats the cold truth thanks. So, im working on a cistern intake valve, and the guy hands me a locknut wrench. No way im like, what is this, a drainpipe slipknot . Wherever your business takes you, nobody keeps you on the road like progressive commercial auto. [ flo speaking japanese ] [ shouting in japanese ] we work wherever you work. Now, thats progressive. Call or click today. And these come together, one thing you can depend on is that these will come together. Delicious and wholesome. Some combinations were just meant to be. Tomato soup from campbells. Its amazing what soup can do. Welcome back to the ed show. Thanks for watching tonight. Well, it turns out the inspirational story of notre dame linebacker manti teos struggles this football season was a total hoax. On september 12th it was reported teo lost his grandmother to cancer and his girlfriend to leukemia. All within the span of six hours. The next day teo led notre dame to a big win over michigan state, racking up 12 tackles in the process. His play on the field and his heartfelt story went on to be the focal point of notre dames nearperfect season. Unfortunately, teo really did lose his grandmother to cancer in september on that day, but as deadspin. Com reports, his girlfriend, lennay kekua, never existed. There is no record of her death, no obituaries, and no funeral announcements. In fact, aside from a fake twitter account, there is no record of her at all. Teo says he was involved with a woman he met online whom he never met. He claims they communicated through the internet and over the phone. In a statement teo said, to realize that i was the victim of what was apparently someones sick joke and constant lies was and is painful and humiliating. However, on september 23rd Sports Illustrated asked the linebacker from notre dame how he met his girlfriend, and he responded with this answer we met just, um, just she knew my cousin and kind of saw me there so, just kind of regular. His stories simply dont add up. Teo also gave a number of interviews about his socalled girlfriend during the football season. Emotional week, losing your grandmother and your girlfriend on tuesday. How would you describe your emotions on the field tonight . I mean, theyre with me. You know, so i couldnt do it without them. I couldnt do it without the support of my family and my girlfriends family. I never felt that way before. This is six hours ago i just found out my grandma passed away. And you take, you know, the love of my life. The last thing she said to me was i love you. And that was it. As you see, the National Sports media jumped all over this story. They failed to verify the facts and played a major role in promoting this false narrative. And this guy was up for the heisman trophy. A few simple google searches could have avoided this entire mess. Meanwhile, notre dame is sticking by their star linebacker. But it could just be an attempt to save face. Every single thing about this until that day in the first week of december was real to manti. There was no suspicion that it wasnt, no belief that it might not be. And so the pain was real. The grief was real. The affection was real. The single most trusting human being ive ever met will never be able to trust in the same way again in his life. Thats an incredible tragedy. As notre dames Athletic Director pointed out, teo learned it was all a hoax on december 6th. But the Associated Press is reporting that he gave two more interviews pushing the lie. I dont like cancer at all. You know, cancer i lost both my grandparents and my girlfriend to cancer. Coaches at notre dame found out about the hoax on december 26th. And of course they kept quiet because their National Championship game was on january 7th. We know for a fact that teo lied twice and notre dame swept this under the rug to save face. But something tells me theres a whole lot more to this story. And weve got a lot of questions coming up next about this hoax. Well get to some of those answers next. Stay with us. Six hours ago i just found out my grandma passed away. You take, you know, the love of my life. Coming up, the editor of the website that dropped the manti teo bombshell. Tom skoka on how deadspin. Com got the sports scoop of the year. And Howard Fineman of the Huffington Post on how every other journalist dropped the ball. And another bigtime ceo picks another fight over obama care. The fascism in government doesnt own the means of production but they do control it, and thats whats happening with these reforms. Ill talk with Jonathan Alter about fascism and the founder of whole foods. [ male announcer ] finally, moms ovenbaked tastes straight from the microwave. Like ovenroasted chicken in a creamy alfredo sauce. Marie callenders new comfort bakes. Its time to savor. But with advair, im breathing better. So now i can be in the scene. Advair is clinically proven to help significantly improve lung function. Unlike most copd medications, advair contains both an antiinflammatory and a longacting bronchodilator working together to help improve your lung function all day. Advair wont replace fastacting inhalers for sudden symptoms and should not be used more than twice a day. People with copd taking advair may have a higher chance of pneumonia. Advair may increase your risk of osteoporosis and some eye problems. Tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high Blood Pressure before taking advair. If youre still having difficulty breathing, ask your doctor if including advair could help improve your lung function. Get your first full prescription free and save on refills at advaircopd. Com. Welcome back to the ed show. Thanks for staying with us tonight. And this bizarre story. Allamerican linebacker manti teo claims that he is a victim of a heartbreaking hoax. But hes going to have to answer some tough questions in the future if he wants to convince some of the sports fans hes coming clean. The Associated Press reports that teo kept the scam going. Teo says hes found out hed been scammed on december 6th. He talked about the fake girlfriend in two interviews two days later. Teo also gives conflicting dates about the car accident and the time of her death. Tonight its unclear who really got scammed and what this is all about, how it started, who knew about it, and is he a victim or is he a perpetrator . Lets bring in tom scocca, who is the managing editor of deadspin. Com, and Howard Fineman, also with us tonight, nbc news political analyst and editorial director of the Huffington Post media group. Gentlemen, good to have you with us. Tom, you first. Rather bizarre story. How long did it take your staff to unearth this . It took about five days from when we got the first tip to being ready to publish it. Because we got this tip, and it seemed like it had to be crazy, that this widely covered person didnt exist. So we put jack dickey, one of our reporters, on the records and tim burke went after the online side of it to try to find any evidence that she existed. And it was it was sort of a scary or confusing thing to do because what kept happening is we just kept not finding her. And then the question was at what point as youre not finding this person, you know, as you cant find her obituary, you cant find her death in the Social Security administration records, you cant find that she attended stanford because she didnt, at what point do all these negatives add up to a positive . So who started all this . What did your reporting find . Were still trying to figure out exactly what happened, but we found a woman whose picture had been used to represent this fictitious girlfriend. And she had no idea. She had given the picture to a High School Classmate of hers, whos either a friend or a distant relative of teos. And so the question is whether it was a friend pulling a prank on another friend or whether they knew from the start what they were both doing with this fake person. Did you have a chance, did your staff have a chance to interview the linebacker, teo . We didnt. We tried calling him when we were getting ready to publish, but we sort of it was a situation where we figured this was it was the kind of story, you know, that you can give to a friendly reporter and try to spin out of at the last minute and so we really dont know if he is a victim or a perpetrator. Right. He could have been, speculating, part of some scam to put him on the National Scene to get him plenty of visibility, a heartfelt story because he was up for the heisman. I mean, im speculating bigtime here. Theres a lot of crazy theories out there. But we really dont know, do we . No. One thing that we there are a couple of things that we do know. One is just that if he and notre dame were victims theyre victims who really did quite well by being victimized. Which doesnt mean that they werent. But this was a story that got tremendous benefits for him and notre dame in the course of the season in terms of publicity and goodwill. The other thing we know is as some of these other things youve been flagging tonight in the timeline show us, he was he lied. By the end he was lying and along the way he was certainly telling this very embellished story where whether he knew he was being scammed or not he certainly was talking about this love of his life as if it were someone he had actually ever been in a room with. We really dont know if he ever met her. I mean, theres some conflicting comments in interviews about whether he actually met this woman or not who obviously does not exist. Right. We know he didnt meet her. Thats right. Howard fineman, all i can say is bizarre. Should notre dame have reported the hoax when they found out two weeks before the championship game . Sure. I think they should have. And i think once again you have a situation of a muchbeloved, muchbeloved sports institution, a football institution in this case enveloped in myth and surrounded by friendly people telling them how great they are thinking that it was the right thing to do not to tell the truth because it might get in the way of a football game. But what i would like to focus on is the journalism here because i know a lot more about that than i know about the notre dame how could an athlete get away with a story like this . Well, i think its a good question. First i want to congratulate deadspin on some terrific classic shoe leather reporting. Shoe leathers online now, and its in the records. And they did it. And they should be congratulated for it. The mystery is how this gigantic empire of lies could have been constructed without anybody noticing it before deadspin did. Some very major journalistic institutions fell for this hook, line, and chinstrap. And its disturbing. And it happens all too frequently all across journalism. None of us is immune to it. You know, in the old days, ed, you had the old game of telephone effect where somebody would tell somebody else and somebody else and the story would get distorted over time. In this culture, in this instantaneous culture its kind of the exact problem. Digital copies are perfect copies. So once a story gets set in motion in a perfect mythic way, it gets repeated verbatim. And its not that the story changes. Its that the story doesnt change. From the beginning, when the south bend newspaper started printing these stories about this heartbreaking story of this mythical girl what turns out to be the mythical girlfriend, those stories in the south bend paper, the sort of smalltown, hometown paper get replicated all over the country unquestioned by major institutions, by Sports Illustrated, by the New York Times hes up for the heisman trophy. Yeah. Hes up for the heisman trophy. And people i will say this in defense of notre dame. And i dont know if they deserve to be defended here, and i think deadspin and others will continue to ask the right questions. But notre dame doesnt need this kind of story to embellish its legend in football or in sports. They dont need it. The last thing they need is a guy like this. But yet they got caught up in not telling the truth. He told them about it. He realized the story on the 6th, if you believe his version. He tells the coaches right away. It turns out the players on the team, tell me if this is correct, several players on the team and maybe many players on the team knew this was a bunch of baloney and didnt tell and neither did the Athletic Director. Needless to say they did not play well against alabama and teo did not have a very good game. I think theres still a lot more reporting to be done on this. And i think there is bigtime Major College athletics that has huge, huge ramifications when it comes to dollars and bowl games and who knows. It is yeah, the journalism story is a big one here, ed. The journalism story is a big one and we shouldnt forget it. No question. Tom scocca and Howard Fineman, great to have both of you with us tonight. Thank you so much. A Health Food Store with a ceo against health care reform. Ill tell you who called obama care fascist. Jonathan alter joins me. Stay with us. Hi dad. Many years from now, when the subaru is theirs. Hey. You missed a spot. Ill look back on this day and laugh. Love. Its what makes a subaru, a subaru. For their annual football trip. Thats double miles you can actually use. Tragically, their buddy got sacked by blackouts. But its our tradition thats roughing the card holder. But with the capital one venture card you get double miles you can actually use. [ cheering ] any flight, anytime. The scoreboard doesnt lie. Whats in your wallet . Hut i have me on my fantasy team. Ed show survey tonight i asked will Republican Leadership denounce the extreme rhetoric on guns . 5 of you say yes. 95 of you say no. Why did i switch to Natural Instincts . Its healthier, and the only one clinically proven. With aloe, vitamins, and no ammonia. My hair looks healthier than before i colored. I switched. You can too, to Natural Instincts. Woman what do you mean, Homeowners Insurance doesnt cover floods . [ heart rate increases ] man a few inches of water caused all this . [ heart rate increases ] woman 2 but i dont even live near the water. What you dont know about Flood Insurance may shock you including the fact that a preferred risk policy starts as low as 129 a year. For an agent, call the number that appears on your screen. We can afford to take an extra trip this year. First boston. Then san francisco. Hotwire checks the competitions rates every day so they can guarantee their low prices. So our hotels were half price. Hotwire. Hotwire. Com ed show survey tonight i asked will Republican Leadership denounce the extreme rhetoric on guns . 5 of you say yes. 95 of you say no. Coming up, another day, another ceo comes out against obama care. Jonathan alter joins me for the discussion of the story. Stay with us. [ male announcer ] house rule number 46. Whats good for the pot. Is even better for the cup. New single serve cafe collections from maxwell house. Now available for use in the keurig kcup brewer. Always good to the last drop. Omnipotent of opportunity. You know how to mix business. With business. And you. Rent from national. Because only national lets you choose any car in the aisle. And go. You can even take a fullsize or above. And still pay the midsize price. I could get used to this. [ male announcer ] yes, you could business pro. Yes, you could. Go national. Go like a pro. Hey hun, remember you only need a few sheets. Hmph [ female announcer ] charmin ultra soft is made with extra cushions that are soft and more absorbent. Plus you can use four times less. Charmin ultra soft. So we created the extraordinarily comfortable sleep number experience. A collection of innovations designed around a bed with dualair technology that allows you to adjust to the support your body needs each of your bodies. Our sleep professionals will help you find your sleep number setting. Exclusively at a sleep number store. Sleep number. Comfort individualized. Save 500 on our special edition bed set. Plus, 48month financing on all beds. Now at the sleep number white sale. Officeyour business needs. K. At prices that keep you. Out of the red. This week get a bonus 15 itunes gift card with any qualifying 75 ink purchase. Find thousands of big deals now. At officemax. And on the big finish tonight, back in 2009 whole foods founder ceo john mackey wrote an oped in the wall street journal labeling president obamas Affordable Health care act a form of socialism. As a result the Health Food Retailers leftleaning Customer Base staged nationwide protests and boycotts. Three years later mackey is back. Hes changed his mind a little bit. Technically speaking, its more like fascism. Socialism is where that government owns the means of production. In fascism the government doesnt own the means of production, but they do control it. And thats whats happening with the Health Care Program and with these reforms. Well, as you can imagine, whole foods leftleaning Customer Base didnt take too kindly to that label either. Mackey is already walking it back. I regret using that word now because its got so much baggage attached to it from the middle of the 21st 20th century when you had germany and italy and spain that were fascist and people still associate that with it. Of course i was just using the standard dictionary definition. Merriam webster dictionary defines fascism as a regime headed by a dictatorial leader that forcibly suppresses opposition. Mackey, a selfprofessed libertarian, gets his definition from the Ayn Rand School of thought. Listen, i believe mackey regrets using the word. But the most insulting thing about mackeys continued assault against obama care isnt the language. Mackey isnt biting the hand that feeds him. Despite this country being run by a socialist or fascist or whatever word hell come up with next, whole foods is doing pretty doggone good. Under president obama whole foods profits have risen 306 . Profits he seems unwilling to invest in the health of the employees that are with him making all that money. Lets turn to Jonathan Alter, msnbc political analyst and columnist for bloomberg view. Why do these ceos do this . Why would he do this again and go down this road . Well, they cant help themselves. He has a political philosophy as indicated, of libertarianism, where they think its just because of their genius and their hard work and their talent and that they dont get any help from anybody else. The rugged individual making it alone in american life. You know, as Warren Buffett or some of his fellow ceos who are a little more enlightened might tell him, the only reason that whole food or whole foods or whole paycheck, as its sometimes called by those who are a little here in new york thats what they call it. The only reason that they have been able to be so successful is because theyre operating in a country, this country, where they get all kinds of public services, whether its the good roads that lead to the whole foods near where i live or all of the other things that make a society work. And these guys just are oblivious to that. And they dont get it and they dont get that they do have certain social responsibilities. So they have kind of a were all in it for ourselves ethic, which is totally contrary to the ethic that hes using to make millions of dollars at whole foods. Its a crunchy, you know, earth tone ethic that they have in those stores. Why wouldnt he want his employees to have the best health care . According to glassdoor. Com, the average whole foods cashier makes an average of 10. 31 an hour. Without obama care what hope do these folks have . Well, yeah. Hes kind of throwing them to the wolves. And the sad thing, ed, is theres another way to do it. Look at costco. Excellent company. Provides health care for its employees and other benefits. Still manages to make plenty of money. So the subtext of what people like mackey are saying is if we have to actually do right by our employees we cant be in business. Thats false. That is utterly false. And people need to understand that you can do well and do good at the same time. You can be responsible and make a profit at the same time. And these ceos who get so much from this country need to understand that their customers are going to demand that they give something back. At the end of the day i think business is going to realize ha this is doing for their employees. But they all have this mindset that theyre going to get financially stuck. And thats simply not the case. Depending on the size of the company. But these Bigger Companies are going to benefit as the employees are going toned up with health care. Why dont they see that . Well, because it does cost them a little bit more money to do right. But they should be investing in