out. >> yeah. >> but how does president biden, if you were advising -- how would he respond to that argument? >> when joe biden became president of the unemployment rate was 10%. one in ten americans and have a job -- unemployment rate was the lowest it has been in 50 years. our economy was growing while other western economies are not growing. so, we are creating jobs. we are growing. manufacturing is coming back. you heard him a lot talk about saying electric vehicles -- in the united states. we don't have to import them the batteries from china, we are making batteries in the united states. all over the country -- so, i think american america in decline is not a good message and it's not a true diagnosis. i think -- first was clears to the truth on this was nikki haley, who said, look, who -- big deficits in washington. the republicans did -- trump pence administration -- deficits. -- republicans in congress -- bringing the deficit down, he has been spending money wisely in the economy is doing much better than he was when he got. here >> so, one of the issues that i think everyone was