For not paying their fair share. We will look at who is and who isnt. Senator Kamala Harris out of the 2020 president ial race, is that forcing the Democratic Party to come facetoface with an uncomfortable reality, all six candidates to qualify for the next debate stage are always. We set the stage for the democrats next impeachment hearing just hours from now. Reporter we are learning a lot more about what tomorrows hearing will look like. Im not going to take any blank that is what jerry nadler had to say about a procession, his warning shot referred to gop antics to undermine the first impeachment hearing in the judiciary committee. Nadler will gavel in a hearing was four constitutional lawyers for what congressman referred to as a Law School Class about the meaning of impeachment, their discussion will revolve around a 300 page report from the House Intelligence Committee approved on a partyline vote. Democrats say it lays out and unprecedented effort in obstruction because of the president s refusal to comply with angry by producing documents or allowing ministration aids to testify and lists the president s attempts to block witnesses from testifying and allegedly intimidating those who did on top of his alleged pressure to trade aid in a white house meeting for Ukrainian Ambassador on an investigation of joe biden. This is about whether the American People have a right to expect the president of the United States to act in their interests, their security in mind and not some illicit personal political reason. Reporter this was a new part of the report in terms of information we learned, it included phone records between Rudy Giuliani and republican devon nunez, the white house and the office of management and budget in april suggesting coordination of a Smear Campaign against then ambassador to ukraine yavanovitch. The phone records are remarkably consistent with the coordination of the scheme. I remember to talking to Rudy Giuliani and laughing about mueller. Maybe they have recordings of my phone calls with Rudy Giuliani. Everything i spoke with Rudy Giuliani about is nothing i wouldnt care if the American People found out. Reporter whatever happens it will be a while. Democrats pumping the brakes on fast track to impeachment. Earlier today the house said they would stay in session next a week leading up to christmas but by tonight a Senior Member of Nancy PelosisLeadership Team says it is unlikely the house can vote on impeachment before christmas calling it too complex to do too quickly meaning another holiday dinner for all of us to talk about with our families regarding impeachment. The question i got was what is congress doing besides this . We will see. We will have that discussion with my side of the family over christmas, thank you. 79 times in the democrats impeachment report, obstruction appears 50 times, bribery mentioned in passing, democrats say it is clear the president not only abused his power but is actively obstructed their investigation so tomorrow, phase 2 of the House Judiciary Committee, lets bring in tony. We are told the president plans and doesnt plan to watch tomorrow. Is that your understanding . The president is representing the United States, important strategic allies of nato and there could not be more clear the president representing our country, working on issues of concern for National Security, democrats fixated on this impeachment process and we saw 300 pages of their opinion, commentary, no evidence, no factual support for their claims the president did anything impeachable. What do we know after 12 star witnesses the democrats brought forward . Ukraine got the aid without conditions, met with the Vice President and the president and ultimately even people like ambassador yavanovitch, Mister Taylor and others who were brought in his critics of the president said we achieved a better ukraine policy that was achieved under the Obama Administration so again you have democrats misrepresenting facts, misrepresenting testimony to put forth false narratives and the American People are not buying at the polls show. Shannon the phone records show Rudy Giuliani making calls to the omb, why would he be involved with monetary policy, they will talk about the fact the president used phrases like quid pro quo when he knew there was an investigation to better allegations and the reason the aid flowed is he knew he got caught. Here is what house intel chairman adam schiff says. The president of the United States solicited for interference in our election and used the power of his office to get his political dirty work done. The only question is how much more extensive was the scheme, how many of this may have been involved . Reporter is turning this from house intel to house judiciary cases the investigation will continue, hes not going to stop looking for witnesses or information or documents, he says the white house unlawfully withheld from him. Im happy to talk about obstruction of justice which the constitution will tell you is a separation of powers the executive branch has to protect itself as an institution and argument republicans and democrats of made in the past but lets look at this timeline. The aid was only released. It is all nonsense. The entire narrative is nonsense. What they omitted from this report was senator johnson submitted to congressman jordans request on explaining a phone conversation he had with the president on august 31st in which the president said to him you will be happy about what we will do with the aid and ukraine. What they omitted from his supporters ambassador sondland presumed there was a quid pro quo but when he talked to the president the president said there is no quid pro quo and i want nothing from the ukrainians. Volodymyr zelinsky made very clear there was no quid pro quo, no preconditions. This is again part of the false narrative we have become very accustomed to when it comes to adam schiff and his opinions, nothing based in fact. On obstruction this is probably one of the most of the disclaims they can make. The executive privilege is something every institution of the presidency has been able to exercise. If adam should has a problem he couldve challenged that in court but he chose not to, witnesses and other documents to be produced. This entire process almost unreasonable for any participation for the executive branch, never due process, Constitutional Rights for outside, dont have attorneys present, we dont have the opportunity to introduce rebuttal evidence. This is a continuation of the same sham process. In the case of jerry nadler we have to give up our due process rights, rights to privilege in order to have fair participation in the hearing. Thats not away any attorney would advise the client to participate and at the end of this process what we learned is democrats are really focused, hyper focused on ramming this through, their Christmas Gift to the American People, to do what adam schiff said in that bite. Let me ask about the idea they are going to expand beyond the ukraine phone call. Congressman out green sponsored impeachment many times, well before the ukraine situation said they might look at things in the Mueller Report, there are suggestions they after the committees if they have anything on the president , bring them forward and they will all be baked in together. And also because of the tweet he didnt like. Keep in mind the Impeachment Vote got 80 something democrats to vote for it to show how quick they have always been from the day donald trump was inaugurated. This has been impeachment in pursuit of an actual reason to impeach. Bottom line clearly remains theres nothing impeachable here, democrats through the judiciary process will try to get 3 constitutional professors to try to make the claim they can but we have seen adam schiff and the others tried to create this impression that the Mueller Report has damning evidence, two years of investigation doj concludes no obstruction, no collusion, nothing. They are not done with that. He says he will continue to investigate but we will be watching tomorrow as the process plays out whether a Christmas Gift or not, thanks for coming in. Democrats pushing ahead with impeachment despite growing opposition in battleground states, new numbers from the Washington Post show 51 of those in key election states oppose impeaching donald from while 44 support it, a 7 point spread comes from an average arizona, florida, michigan, pennsylvania, nevada coming to him for, North Carolina and wisconsin. National polls virtually unchanged since before the impeachment hearings began, the latest shows 47 support impeachment, 43 oppose it. Fox news alert, just hours from the next round of the nato summit were donald trump is bringing his America First philosophy to the stage. Clashing with Emmanuel Macron and offering an optimist outlook for the future of the alliance. This summit celebrate natos 70th anniversary looks like a family thanksgiving get together gone wrong and at the center of it is donald trump and Emmanuel Macron, claiming the alliance is braindead due to loss of American Leadership on the world stage. My statement created some reaction but i stand by it. He double down on his criticisms of nato during a bilateral meeting with donald trump who blasted the french president s, quote, nasty statement just a few hours before. I heard macro said that was very braindead, that is insulting to a lot of different forces and we cant go around making statements like that about nato. Very disrespectful. Natos secretary general pushing back on the statement arguing the alliance is stronger than ever thanks to Donald Trumps efforts to get european allies to pay their fair share. We are making progress on the burden sharing and your leadership on defense spending is having an impact. The fact is we are doing more together now than for many decades. You can see the impact in the numbers. In 2014 only three nato countries will build a pledge to spend 2 of gdp on defense. On friday the Alliance Announced 9 of its 29 members are living up to that pledge and since 2016 european allies have increased defense spending by 130 billion with plans to hit 400,000,000,000 x 2024. Nato has come a long way in 3 years and become very powerful, very powerful and much fairer statement in terms of the United States, we are able to go down a little bit. Donald trump set the stage for his bilateral meeting with Angela Merkel by suggesting he could use tariffs to try to force berlin to increased defense spending beyond what it is already doing. The anniversary celebration continues. We will be watching, thank you. Donald trumps lawyers not ruling out an appeal to the Supreme Court in the battle over Donald Trumps financial records. Federal Appeals Court ruling georgia bank and capital one must comply with congressional subpoena to handover years of the president s records including his tax returns. There are already two cases before the Supreme Court regarding the president s tax returns. We could know as soon as the 13th whether the justices will actually hear one of them. Devon nunez is suing cnn for defamation. The California Republican accused the opposition to the House Democrats impeachment inquiry and accusing the network of publishing false hit pieces. He said he never met with ukrainian prosecutor victor shelton. One story included a quote from an attorney who claimed he had information that the meeting had happened. Nunez mocking one of cnns sources, a business associate who was recently indicted. Democrats 2020 field just got older and waiter. Our panel weighs in on Kamala Harriss decision to drop out next. Ladies and gentlemen, your attention please. Geico would like to take a moment to say thank you to our military Service Members at home and abroad for all their hard work and sacrifice. We all sleep easier knowing youre out there keeping us safe. And on a personal note. Sfx jet engines. I just needed to get that off my chest. Thank you. Geico proudly supporting the military for over 75 years. Some things are too important to do yourself. Get customized security with 24 7 monitoring from xfinity home. Awarded the best professionally installed system by cnet. Simple. Easy. Awesome. Call, click or visit a store today. I dont use some waxy cover up. I use herpecin l, it penetrates deep to treat. It soothes moisturizes and creates a spf 30 barrier to protect against flare ups caused by the sun. Herpecin l. It does more for a cold sore. The way that the media treated senator harris in the way the media treated senator harrison this campaign has been something else, grossly unfair and unfortunate. Black women especially. This becomes an older and waiter field for the toptier candidates. At this moment we went from the most diverse set of candidates in my lifetime to an allwhite stage. Reporter Kamala Harris fresh out of the 2020 president ial race hunting donald trump on twitter and there are still people of color vying for the white house, harriss departure present an uncomfortable reality for the Democratic Party, the candidate to qualified so far to be on the debate stage are allwhite. Richard fowler, founder of turning point usa, and charlie kirk, good to have you with us tonight, the president tweeting we will miss you. Her comment, dont worry, i will see you at your trial. She will be a juror if this is in the senate. I just have to say senator hurst might have run a one of the worst president ial campaigns in american history. Going from where she started over 20,000 people in her Campaign Launched last january raising money, she was raising incredible amounts of money, going to almost frontrunner status over the summer, and her unbelievable collapse the last couple months will be studied by every political observer but i push back a little bit and say i dont like this at reaction by certain people to say she failed because she was a black woman, she failed because she couldnt connect with voters in her ideas were horrible, she had no grassroots appeal, she struggled in iowa and New Hampshire and the lesson we can take away is what did she stand for. What was her actual stance . Looking back over the summer, the only moment that got her traction was going after joe biden. She continued in that direction, not getting much traction whatsoever. Shannon primaries are winnowing down the field looking for the most effective candidate to take on the opposing party. The la times running democrats value diversity but the president ial field is increasingly white saying the absence of any candidate of color is the point of consternation for Many Democrats at a time when African American and latino voters have become the partys biggest constituencies and crucial to its hopes of defeating donald trump, your reaction . The article is absolutely right. For democrats to be donald trump they need to turn out africanamericans, latin voters, collegeeducated folks, single women, it is going to have to be a coalition similar to what obama did in 2008, and 2012 and for that to be a reality. Kamala harriss campaign i will disagree with charlie, how she was portrayed by the media, look at her press clips, compared to beta or who was praised, he is amazing, the stuff he was doing and kamala did not get that same praise, what she got was more scrutiny, something the media could do a better job of, covering the candidates based on the issues instead of based on the color of their skin. That is something weve got to think about in this election and the Democratic Party needs to wake up to the fact that they have to really go after africanamerican voters in a new way to win them over and get them to turn out. I want to get you both to react to this. They say the question about whether her failure to gain traction was a result of america being unprepared to elect a woman of color, she said when theres not a Reference Point for who can do what there is lack of ability or difficulty imagining someone we have never seen into a job that has been done 45 times by someone who is not that person. I am disappointed instead of taking responsibility and thing no one likes her she has to use that as a reason and i dont find any validity behind that whatsoever and i will just say if Michelle Obama entered this race she would do very well and shes a person of color. I dont think thats a good argument to say she failed because shes a woman of color. This entire race, Kamala Harriss entire campaign raised 24 million. Mayor bloombergs first ad by was 37 million. The fact we have too much private money in politics speaks to the fact that voices like Kamala Harriss and cory booker have been locked out of the primary by millionaires and billionaires using money out of their personal Bank Accounts to fund their election campaign. And julian castro, the formula for electability has pushed aside women and candidates of color, diversity should be our strength, it is a shame about the Single Person of color. 2020 president ial candidate Pete Buttigieg looking for new ways to build his own numbers with africanamerican voters come his pointing the finger at Donald Trumps supporters. I believe also that while anyone who supported this president is at best looking the other way, at best, there are a lot of people who his message might have found Fertile Ground for them. That was buttigieg in south carolina. Fox news night indicates the shocking details of how china is collecting data to crack down on religious minorities next. For the whole family. New vicks vapopatch. Breathe easy. Thousands of options nationwide from National Insurance companies. Dont miss the deadline. There are only days remaining in open enrollment. Funny thing about Health Insurance, you dont think about how much you need it until you need it. Hes not going to be okay. With so many changes to Health Insurance plans, are you still sure you have the right fit . Having the wrong fit can cost you thousands. New plans are available that can save you money. Thats why i love healthmarkets, your Insurance Marketplace. They guarantee you wont find a lower price anywhere for the plans they offer. Their new fitscore instantly compares thousands of plans, both on the Government Exchange and off, to find the one that best fits your insurance need. Call or visit healthmarkets to find your fitscore today. In minutes, you can find out if your current plan is the right fit or if theres another one that can get you extra coverage or help save you money. Best of all, their service is completely free. Their new fitscore makes it easy to compare your plan to new ones that could lower your costs and save you money. Try the new fitscore today. You may even qualify for free Health Insurance with no monthly premium. Dont get stuck using the Government Exchange either. Healthmarkets can find you the right health plan and make sure you get all the subsidies you deserve without all the hassle. They even have new alternative options most dont even know about that can save you thousands. They work to help you and do it all for free. Dont assume that your plan is still the right fit. The Healthmarkets Fitscore makes it easy to find the right plan for you. Having helped enroll people in millions of policies with an a Customer Satisfaction rating, you can trust healthmarkets. For this free service, go to healthmarkets. Com or call right now. Your Insurance Market place, healthmarkets. Call healthmarkets before the december 15th enrollment deadline to see if you qualify for 0 premiums. Call the number on your screen now. Sa new buick . For me . To james, from james. Thats just what i wanted. Is this a new buick . I secret santaed myself. Oh i shouldnt have but i have been very good this year. I love it. I love it. Dont forget you this holiday season, get an syouv, from buick. Celebrate the holidays with up to 25 below msrp for current eligible nongm owners and lessees on most of these 2019 buick models. Shannon new tonight, the house overwhelming the house overwhelmingly passing a bill demanding the administration get tough with chinese officials over treatment of muslims. Fox news at night investigator troubling the report about how china is using new technologies to crack down on its own people with help from the west. Trace gallagher is on the case for us tonight. If you can hear the technological stepbystep you get a better understanding of the concern over how china monitors its people, china requires citizens to have, quote, real Name Registration many offline accounts have to link with your government id and now if you buy new phone in johnny are mandated to submit to a facial scan. If you connect government id to the facial scan it pretty much eradicates being online anonymously but the next step is the most concerning. You take dna to reconstruct human faces. For example this video shows an American Company developing phenotyping to help solve crimes by eliminating criminal suspects but there are reports that chinese scientists are using the same technology to establish whether a person is a Muslim Minority china has long targeted. Human Rights Organization say hundreds of thousands of uighurs are being held in chinese Detention Centers to bd radicalized. Critics call them brainwashing centers. John cotton calls from concentration camps. The Chinese Communist party is running concentration camps, make no mistake. Its appetite for expansion is far greater. Its methods of control applicable to anyone anywhere. The free world must confront this threat in plain view and act now to avert such a dark and chilling future. And today the u. S. House passed human rights legislation that would impose sanctions on chinese officials for abusing uighurs. Sinuses the bill could lead to retaliatory sanctions against us companies. All of this comes as donald trump warns the tariff battle with china could linger past the 2020 elections. Next up former attorney general Jeff Sessions is preview the impeachment process it moves to the House Judiciary Committee but first around up, huge logs mysteriously popping up in west and oakland including some behemoths measuring 10 feet long, blocking roads, reportedly position to stop the homeless from parking cars and rvs and dumping their waste into the streets. The city says it is not responsible for the logs and no one else is owning up how they got there. San francisco has a similar case boulders appeared on sidewalks in september. They were eventually removed. This is right out of a superhero movie, the la tb is officers with kevlar shooting raps which throw 8foot cards at suspects, up to 25 feet away to tingle them up without requiring more violent force, the lapd joined several other departments across the country trying out the new tools. Recent Winter Weather highlighting wisconsin towns ban on snowball throwing anywhere on public property which means school your snowball fights are illegal. The town, errors and stones and other missiles, citing public safety. They ticketed someone for throwing a snowball. A supporter of Marijuana LegalizationWillie Nelson is giving up weed. He has credit marijuana but he says he has got to quit because of breathing issues. danny pet care aint easy. 12 hours . 20 dogs . Wheres your belly rubs . After a day of chasing dogs you shouldnt have to chase down payments. vo send invoices and accept payments to get paid twice as fast. danny its time to get yours vo quickbooks. Backing you. For a limited time, get a outb4course meal your holidays even better starting at 15. 99. Treat yourself to the perfect gift today, because the aussie 4course wont last long and now, get a 10 gift with every 50 in gift cards. Shannon one of washingtons most quotable lawmakers, senator john kennedy, an shannon one of washingtons quote of the lawmakers senator john kennedy getting criticism for statement about whether ukraine entered. Interviewed in the election. Are you concerned that you have been duped . A mild rebuke of john kennedy for his recent televised claims that ukraine interfered in the 2016 election to hurt donald trump claims the democrats they have been debunked. That is a Conspiracy Theory put out, promulgated by Vladimir Putin. To deflect attention away from russias interference in an election. There is nuanced disagreement about that. Former National Security staff revealed a whole acknowledged some had spoken negatively about donald trump which he claimed the ukrainian collusion story on russia. Official narrative that has perpetrated by the Russian Security service themselves. On monday chairman richard burr told nbc, quote, every elected official in ukraine was for Hillary Clinton, the ukraine collusion narrative first surfaced in 2017. Politico reported, quote, ukrainian officials tried to help Hillary Clinton to undermine trump by publicly questioning his fitness for office, since then series that ukraine hacked into dnc servers and a forensics examination of the servers may still be in ukraines hands of all been disproven, still unproven is the role of alexandra cho lupo. The contract of the Democratic National committee worked with ukrainian officials to collect dirt on the trump campaign. In 2016 she contacted the fbi claiming she had been hacked in a statesponsored cyber attack while working with the dnc. Agents interviewed her and took images of her laptop and cell phone. That republicans grassley and ron johnson wrote the fbi two weeks ago demanding to see by u. Alexandra is one of the witnesses chairman adam schiff refused to call. If impeachment moves to the senate she may be calling the theory of ukrainian collusion may be proven or not. Thank you. As democrats push forward with the next phase of their impeachment push tomorrow with House Judiciary Committee hearing featuring constitutional law scholars comparisons with former president nixon are ramping up again. The only thing we can say is that it is not so much that the situation is different in terms of next ands conduct or trumps conduct but we have seen something far more serious than a thirdrate burglary, beyond anything nixon did. Constitutional law professor jonathan turley, one of the witnesses tomorrow so those words by adam schiff to the constitutional challenge for the house tweeting there is still disagreement of what this is, whatever this is it is not nixonian at least not yet. Attorney general Jeff Sessions, good to have you back with us, senator, i will call you. Good to be with you. What you make of this . We will hear from law professors who will talk about the constitutional issues, founders intense, what they meant for impeachment but today the house until chairman adam schiff prepared a report for the house judiciary, said this about the president s action. Is of Congress Allows a president who so fully and blanket the abstract of the work of Congress Even involving an impeachment investigation into the president s own misconduct and we are begging for more of the same. Congress has a duty to step up and protect the office of the presidency, the balance of power and the president will continue to do things that he assesses is unseemly at best a dont stop it. He has become obsessed with this, democrats have gotten so fired up, amped up that they are not objective anymore. Jonathan turley said this will be the narrowest base for an impeachment in our history. Kenneth starr who prosecuted clinton said nowhere close to an impeachable offense, that is what i believe so i think the danger is, the danger is congress will overreach, set a precedent for too really bringing impeachment charges was what of republicans are the majority and dont like the president . Will he start impeachment proceedings obstructing the ability of this government to be run . One thing i learned is attorney general, it is hard to run this government and these kind of things district every leader every day and take them from the responsibilities the American People want to see them do. Shannon you experience things differently than the American People did when it comes to these allegations regarding the 2016 election. What do you make of the beatings, senator kennedy is taking by saying, not dismissing that russia was involved but saying it is possible ukraine was. Politico says a Republicancontrolled SenateIntelligence Committee thoroughly investigated this. That ukraine worked to aid Hillary Clinton. According people with direct knowledge, no evidence that ukraine waged a topdown interference campaign to come to the kremlins efforts to help trump when. Im not sure how relevant that is except to say it does appear leaders in the ukraine did what they could to cooperate with the Clinton Campaign to have her win the election. That much appears to be undisputed. I would say what we need to focus on is is there a basis in this phone call to justify the removal of the president of the United States. I dont think it is close. Democrats dont either but on the other side they say this is a clear case, in an article what do they do in the senate . Such an open and shut case, what do they talk about to do how different do you think it will be if this goes to a senate trial in the white House Republicans have more of a seat at the table when it comes to calling witnesses . Hard to say for sure but the rules of the senate are specific about how an impeachment must move forward rapidly and how it is to be done. Certain things are in dispute or could be argued differently like motions to dismiss in those kind of things that might occur but it would be a shame to have the Senate Sitting in the chamber going through weeks of an impeachment process that could take as much is eight weeks. This would be a real disruption for the government of the United States. I think it is historically important they state, democrats state why this is justified and my hope is, my pleased to them is dont do it, dont start this path with insufficient charges of impeachment that disrupt the country when they are not justified. Shannon one of the jurors on the senate is Kamala Harris, she wont be on the campaign trail anymore, can you talk about that . She claims one of the great achievement was to stand up to Jeff Sessions, brett kavanaugh, william barr and donald trump. She is 04, all four Still Standing and she is out. Shannon you are on it and we will watch the return to the senate. Thanks for dropping in. As protesters are gunned down in the streets donald trump issues a clear warning to iran next. Shannon une grouping iran after hundreds are killed in the day the list political unrest in decades. The world is watching and now iran is admitting to killing protesters calling them rioters. Richardson has more. Reporter iran has admitted to killing protesters was government officials call them writers and claimed they were armed and taking hostages. Amnesty International Since evidence Shows Security forces shooting at unarmed protesters and 208 have been killed, likely more. People protesting in iran are going through tough period, have supported them from the beginning. Reporter two weeks ago iranians demonstrated against increases in gasoline prices. Today donald trump would not answer when asked what the United States should do. I am not saying right now. Reporter iranians have protested before. A decade ago millions demonstrated questionable election results. I hope we dont make the same mistake we made in the green revolution. We need to speak out and communicate with those seeking change in their government. Reporter the administration has sanctioned iran demanding it stop funding melissas and police hostages. Families of some of the americans imprisoned in iran met with senators to push them to do more to free their relatives. Also requesting more from the United NationsSecurity Council to pressure iran. Some of the president s critics say he is at least partially to blame for what is unfolding in iran. His supporters call that insane. What does our panel thing . Richard goodstein and host of the next revolution on fox news steve hilton, welcome to you both. Lets start here. In an opinion piece, current us policies are hurting the cause the iranian people are fighting for while failing to achieve any strategic objectives. If the with pursued policies aimed at creating a Better Future for the iranian people they may have the added benefit of producing less dangerous Government Policies than those we saw under the mantra of maximum pressure. Im with the people blaming donald trump for what is going on is insane. Of course it is true the trump policy, getting out of the nuclear deal and putting sanctions in place are putting pressure on the regime and they are lashing out in the brutal way we have come to expect but the simple answer to this is the regime can change course. It can stop being a terror regime that funds unrest and terror around the region in the world and join in the community of nations. That is the answer, you cant blame donald trump for trying to get that point. Shannon i get the european governments are about the Iran Nuclear Deal but now is the time to get past hurt feelings. These fanatics are shooting protesters in the streets. The regime lacks legitimacy. No more deals. What do you think . Iran is a bad actor period. Anyone who comes on this network and says otherwise should be ashamed of themselves was i agree with what steve said about iran joining the community of nations. That is exactly why president obama did come through with the iran deal because that was away to engage them rather than to stiff on them. Because of the sanctions the iranian people are not able to get cancer drugs, that basic commodities. Our official policy as we are opposed to the iranian government but support the iranian people, the iranian people are the ones who are hurting. We will end up with iran being like north korea. They will have nukes they didnt have before. Heather how many of this goes to mismanagement by the leaders in iran . Billions in unmarked cash. That doesnt seem like that trickle down to the people who are suffering. They certainly got back money that was held in abeyance after the iranian revolution in 1979. A lot of money came back to iran. Im not blaming donald trump for the fact that the iranians are shooting people in the streets, that is shameful. All i am saying is engagement, which was the obama approach is something we didnt give a try to and we are seeing the consequences. Im not sure this is a good outcome. The fact that iran now can proceed with developing Nuclear Weapons and is enriching uranium, they are not very far. No one is cheering for this but iranian leaders made the decision that got us to this point but i want to ask you about nato, the president is making headlines getting into a dustup with the manual macron and tomorrow he will call out Angela Merkel and others who are not stepping up to the 2 gdp requirements. I think hes quite right to call out germany and the other nato allies for their failure to fund nato properly. He has had a huge impact through doing that, we have seen a huge increase in funding for other countries, 130 billion, the narrow general secretary giving trump express a credit for that but he needs to call out nato allies for the real danger that they unlike donald trump are continuing to suck up to china, inviting china, our number one strategic rival to build their infrastructure in europe, communications and technology infrastructure. That is a huge threat for the security of all of nato. He should be calling them out for that as well. The 130 billion nato countries are kicking in started in 2014, not since donald trump became president but good that it is increasing. The problem is european leaders on cyber security, russia is a problem, interfering with elections in france, russia is a problem, killing people on their soil, russia did that in england. What happened in syria where russia is teaming with enemies of europe, that is where donald trump seems to be aligning himself with Vladimir Putin on each of those things, he invited interference in our own campaign. It was president macron the other week who said nato should make Vladimir Putin it ally, not donald trump. He did say that but in each of the things i identified is where europeans take issue. We all aspire to the fact that one day putin will become someone who is not a former kgb guy who means well. That will not happen. Shannon this administration has been tougher on russia than the last couple administrations. Mostwatched, most trusted, most grateful you spent the evening with us, shannon bream. Isis fighters coming from europe. A great politician. That is one of the greatest nonanswers i ever heard. Heather it is wednesday, december 4th. Happening on the east coast, donald trump arriving for a celebration of the 70th anniversary. The french president front and center on the world stage, live in london with a Fiery Exchange ahead of another busy day for the president