i mentioned this to jeanine pirro. the jump has thrown out sarah palin's case against "the new york times," which said they had defamed her but suggesting her pac had something to do with the shooting and killing of six people including injuring of gabby giffords. >> sarah palin won this in the court of public a opinion, a lot of damaging material came out about this editorial accusing of of political incitement in a mass shooting and has not make "the new york times" look good. it's always been the case that it would be difficult for the former governor to win this suit because she's a public figure and there's a supreme court standard about proving malice. and why the judge would send the case to the jury and said she's not proven the case as a matter of law. apparently what we've been told, allowing the jury to continue to