resolution. joining me now it's dr. jay bhattacharya, stanford school of medicine professor. doctor, thank you so much for joining us. i'm telling you, the messaging coming out of this white house, i cannot keep up with how -- one side it's the winter of death, the other side is don't panic, and then you have dr. fauci. i cannot make heads or tails of it, it is an absolute, total mess. >> let's look on the bright side. president biden is saying don't panic. that is the right messaging. there is no cause for panic and actually there hasn't been any cause for panic at all during the epidemic. there's been cause for concern, there's been cause for working carefully, looking at the data and adopting policies that make sense. but panic has not ever productive and i'm glad to hear joe biden call for that. the same time, you have dr. fauci still pushing vaccine passports for flights. you know third of minorities aren't vaccinated. the poor working-class people,