joe biden -- based on what the promise during the presidential campaign. remember back on the campaign, barack obama got involved. after behind the scenes with joe, he forced pete buttigieg outcome of global out, because they were afraid that someone like socialist bernie was going to get the rights. so they forced all these people out because joe was the guy, but joe changed what happen. he went from being moderate joe to say and look at my thick we can actually be progressive. bernie flipped and said he may be the most progressive president peer the whole squad left behind joe biden. but they didn't do that with manchin. i think what you are looking at right now is the political confidence of joe biden used to be joe manchin. and now he's trying to pretend like josh when he really was the one that changed. i think the voters see this and i think this is why the biden agenda is dead, because he never really had it. >> dana: where do we go from