resolved, what's next for these cases? here now to discuss former nypd inspector paul morrow criminal defense attorney mark and crime scene analysis cheryl. thanks so much for join the program paul you've been covering this from the very beginning let's get your reaction to the end because i have to tell you i thought that the defense put up a good fight. but we're learning from testimony from the jury now that this is all over -- they weren't buying any of it. >> no they weren't and you know i think really we can point to one dispositive moment in the trial, i mean, there were many. but i think the real linchpin was the fact that yeah we all know he was a liar he admitted to being a liar lied to his family law partners but remember this lj during the trial the inception of the trial his defense was alleging that he was nowhere near the scene that the timeline was going to favor him because of his visit to his