conservative side -- >> sean: let's see, oh, about 8 minutes. go ahead. >> somebody on the conservative side should get a pool together to buy her in econ 101 textbook. public goods are generally understood to be, when you were talking about economics and government not excludable things. the military, things you cannot prevent people from accessing, the court system. what she has done is somebody told her this buzzword, of course. maybe she picked it up somewhere and she went after it. now she is including things like well, what about a free higher education? that is a public good. no, it is not. it is a private good that may generate some public externalities. but if i have to pay for my neighbors kids college education, even if my neighbor makes the same thing i make, then that is not a public good. as a matter of fact, it is the opposite of a public good. it is silly less than first grade economic analysis. we are only like idiots clap for, because they have never