Welcome to everybody. Should workers everywhere love it . I think they should. Workers everywhere do love it. Look at some of the numbers. 74 of americans want to be in right to work states. When you talk about workers themselves, percentage point lower unemployment in righttowork states and 2012 editorial in wall street journal said the last ten years previous to that, righttowork compensation had gone up four times that, states that were not righttowork. Look at michigan when you had the righttowork, how many people dropped out of unions . Americans want a choice. When tafthartly came in 1947 which meant you had to be part of a union to work at a place, that made those illegal. It went from 6. 6 in private enterprise. 93. 4 businesses think unions are inefficient and harm business. I go with the majority. These go to private companies and say its illegal to have all your workers in a union. We see the decline in unions led to a depression in wages. People are going back to work. The new jobs numbers this week are showing us we are at a 5. 5 unemployment. Wages are flat. We see that correlation as there is a decline, wages are not going up. Unions bargain on behalf of everyone, not just the people in their union. The numbers do tell a different story dont they . Im scratching my head, with all due respect to emily. I dont understand where she is getting her numbers. In almost every metric righttowork states are outperforming nonrighttowork states. Employment rates are growing much faster than the states that dont have righttowork. Per capita income once you adjust for cost of living, its much higher. Union membership in righttowork states is dropping dramatically. Across the board incomes are up, employment is up. What more could you work from a law . This is benefitting workers across the board. I think every state will have righttowork because it makes economic sense. These numbers are right. A state is poaching jobs from another state. Imagine one state didnt have to do the Clean Air Act a lot of factories would move there because they could be dirty and create jobs there for a nation as a whole its not as obvious the benefits having a situation. Wages are going to go lower without unions. They are artificialry raising wages. If you want low Unemployment Rate and low wages, unions are bad. Melissa, go after it. Thats ridiculous. Its like you cant do math. If you look at the data, the reason wages are lower right now because since 2007 the only jobs we added have been at the very high end and at the mcdonalds level. We lost all the middle class jobs. The manufacturing jobs where the unions were because they went overseas because of the control. You talk about unions driving up wages, no they have driven all those jobs out of the country. Youre crazy. Emily, what do you think . Specifically on the middle class manufacturing jobs the same period we had this many months in a row of job growth in the mid 90s to early 2000. In that period we lost a couple hundred thousand manufacturing jobs as opposed to these past five years we gained 800,000 manufacturing jobs. Thats not true. Since 2007 we lost all the middle class jobs. If you look at the data from the bureau labor statistics, we are negative on job creation in that group. Why didnt scott walker support it up until a couple of weeks ago . Scott walker has gone up against the unions for years now. And won. Gary b. What does that mean to wisconsin . I think now wisconsin is going to join the other states that are seeing continued economic revival. Jonas pointed out one fact i would like to take issue with. In states that have right to work, personal income is growing 12 more than in states that dont have righttowork. Maybe we are looking at a different set of facts. I cant see any economic benefit to not doing it. I agree with one point he made as the states have righttowork, people will migrate to those states if every state does it, well all be back to square one. Everyones economic level will have risen. Jonas, response . The wages are better because they are moving jobs, companies are saying that is a state i can operate in. That is a good thing for that state. Employees in that state. I bet theres income losses where the jobs are leaving from and going to that state. For the whole country its not as obvious the benefits. Again, i think you would have lower unemployment without unions. The opposite of what goes on in europe. To all these jobs going away because of unions abroad that is a separate issue. Most auto jobs are unionized abroad. We are not losing those jobs to germany. They get all kinds of unions in japan and germany. A lot of trucking jobs are not going abroad. They still have to truck stuff. What you are creating is higher unemployment in a higher artificial wages union in america. The facts are the facts. You can talk about ideas talk about what you want personally your ideology. Wall street journal did an editorial. 2012 they said the last ten years righttowork states compensation increased four times that of not righttowork states. I dont understand how to say that any more clearly. The pay was a full percentage point lower. People are going to get out of unions. Youve seen it over and over. Americaned shut have the choice to get into unions or choice to get out of unions. Thats what the bottom line is. It is supposed to be about choice. This is an idea that is totally antiquated and out of its time. Who on this panel has been part of a union . I have. You are forced to join, you are forced to pay deuce. It wasnt something that made sense to me. I wasnt allowed to work in the work place unless i paid this group of people that was supposedly bargaining on my behalf. I didnt agree with what they were doing. I was forced to pay them. Felt like the mafia. Felt like i was shaken down. Is this the same situation . Yeah. To me i was forced to pay. They didnt do anything for me. Everybody be quiet please. I want to get emily in for a second. Union membership has plummeted over the last decade. Arent workers voting . It has. In illinois when there are these Public Private partnerships which are less clear, they are no longer able to be unionized. Its declining for a couple of reasons. Also our economy just looks very different. Jobs are coming through in all sorts of new ways. We are not necessarily training people for them. We are still living off a couple of benefits of unions like bargaining and health insurance, but we need new models across the board. John, last word. Dropped out of Screen Actors Guild because i was in a tv show and years later they tried to get my video game money for me. Thats why people drop out of unions. I paid in for no reason. People understand that. Brad pitts job is not going to china any time soon. Okay. Im sorry, weve got to go, guys. Thanks. Cavuto on business 20 minutes from now. First illegals now tax hikes . Now the next executive action from the white house could hit everyones house. You want real proof we will never get entitlements under control . We cant even fake getting them under control. Ill explain. See you soon. Thanks. We cant wait. Up here first, released from gitmo and rejoining terror. The brandnew intel report that may prove we need to keep gitmo open at all costs. At ally bank no branches equals great rates. Its a fact. Kind of like mute buttons equal danger. That sound good . Not being on this phone call sounds good. Its not muted. Was that you jason . It was geoffrey it was jason. It couldve been brenda. At ally bank no branches equals great rates. Its a fact. Kind of like shopping hungry equals overshopping. Vocal opposer of vladimir putin. You think the report on dozens of americans who hooked up with islamic militants returning to the u. S. Is scary . How about released gitmo detainees getting back in the game . Our top intel guys saying 185 released gitmo guys are getting back in the terror fight. John, you say this is why closing gitmo is too costly on so many measures. It is. As our friend tracy burns said a couple of weeks ago, if they are not going to rot in hell, let them rot in jail. I dont care about closing guantanamo bay, but they need to be housed somewhere. That is our facility. You say theyve been down there so long they are ineffective. Nelson mandela was in prison 27 years and came out for good and ran a country. Camp boco gave us the leadership of isis. These guys are there for a reason. They are not there for parking tickets. There is no reason to let them out because your political ideology about guantanamo bay. Why close gitmo if there is proof they are going back to the fight . The biggest reason to close it is it actually does have more harm than good. There are currently 129 die tanstan detainees in gitmo. But the people being recruited is so many more than that. It is so costly. What . I dont understand that. They talk about the fact that we have this and hold them. If we have them and have the proof, we should bring them on to american soil and charge them. We have to decide what we are doing here. The same day we are flying sortees, lets decide whether we are going after these people and trying to kill them or releasing them back to the battlefield . Pick a side. Pick a policy and stick to it. Every time you let somebody out of any prison a certain percentage are going back to whatever got them back in prison. We dont put everybody in jail to negate that totally. Forget the morality of running a police state. These are young people in this prison. To keep them in there for life, that is 50 million a head for life. Are they going to each do 50 million in damage . That seems unlikely. You can put an ankle bracelet on them. There has to be a way to mitigate that damage to society. 50 million perfect person to for life will bankrupt us. These are not criminals. They are terrorists and they are going back to try to kill us. Exactly. We have it down in cuba. If we move it here, the point is im in favor of the idea of gitmo. Look this is not just some criminal out there that did a smashandgrab and we are letting it in and he does a carjacking. This is equivalent of mass murders out there could they cost 50 million in damage . Yes. They bombed the world trade center, for crying out loud. As to emilys argument on its a recruiting tool. I dont get that. Are you saying there are terrorists out there saying i dont know if i want to be a terrorist. They have gitmo . Yeah. Sign me up. That doesnt make any sense at all. These people out there hate the United States whether they are at gitmo or its club med down there. Thanks, guys. Thats got to be the last word. Cashin in over an hour from now. What do you have coming up . Forget what she is emailing its what Hillary Clinton is saying about your money that will shock you. Is Legal Marijuana making america more dangerous and violent . See you at 11 30. Well be watching. Up here first obamacare is here to stay. Obamacare may be here to stay, but subsidies may not be. Why that could be supremely painful to your health care premium. The future of the market is never clear. But at t. Rowe price we can help guide your retirement savings. Our experience is one reason 100 of our Retirement Funds beat their 10year lipper averages. So wherever your longterm goals take you we can help you feel confident. Request a prospectus or summary prospectus with investment information, risks, fees and expenses to read and consider carefully before investing. Call us or your advisor. T. Rowe price. Invest with confidence. Im almost done. [ male announcer ] now you can pay your bill. Manage your appointments. [ dog barks ]. And check your connection status. Anytime, anywhere. [ dog growls ] oh. So youre protesting . Okay. [ male announcer ] introducing xfinity my account. Available on any device. Americans bracing for a Supreme Court decision on Health Care Law subsidies that some say could mean severe price spikes for everyone. Gary b. , if the justices strike it down price is going up . Absolutely. The whole essence is to boil down obamacare into one thing. Its a tax on everyone that cant afford to pay. So the people like myself, if you will have to pay. Ive seen my premiums gone up 30 . If everyone chips in, well be able to pay for the 30 million or so uninsured. Even with obamacare right now, 30 million uninsured. Its clearly working, if you will. Emily, youve been out there protesting. Why . This law, the impact of this case are huge. There are 36 states that have federal marketplaces, which means they did not set up their own. They are getting the subsidies. That is the question in this case. If the justices rule against the government and say they can no longer get subsidies in these federal marketplaces this will create the death spiral people were so concerned about obamacare that has not come to fruition. It will if justices rule against obamacare. Does that make sense to you . Its your money either way. You are talking about if you take the subsidies away, everybodys Health Care Premiums will spike through the roof. Where do you think the money comes from . The exact same people, your tax dollars. There isnt a money tree in washington where this money is miraculously coming out of the sky. Its hardworking peoples money either way paying for people who couldnt afford insurance before because they use a lot of insurance out of the system. They use a lot of health care because they are already ill or not working. We are all paying for everyone else to have insurance. Emily is right. It is the key component of it. Its unclear what will happen because if the government mandated you go to college and subsidized everybody who couldnt afford to, removing that subsidy isnt going to make tuition go up. It will go down because there is less artificial demand for insurance. Thats one thing to think about. Another thing, the people that are going to get the subsidies, this is an economic show so well talk about are the poor people who dont have jobs to pay for it. Any insurance executive will tell you off the record those people are not very healthy. They are more likely to smoke, be overweight have diabetes and a whole host of conditions they are not looking to pay for. I dont know what the effect will be on the other tears of people paying insurance. Other pieces mate stay in place like a mandate. Ive got to get john in. Subsidies cover as much as 89 of the premium. Try taking away something youve given to somebody for free. Thats why we have a hard time dealing with entitlements. This will be a mess. I dont know how bad a mess but the Supreme Court this is a political court. They rule along ideological lines. They rule according to their political leanings. They are going to do what they think is best politically. Im not sure what that is. Well know soon. Thank you for joining us. Personal spending may be down, but spending to pamper our pets is soaring. Just ask our bulls and bears mascot. There he is ramon. You, my friend are a master of diversification. Who would have thought three cheese lasagna would go with chocolate cake and ceviche . The same guy who thought that small caps and bond funds would go with a merging markets. Its a masterpiece. Thanks. Clearly you are type e. You made it phil. Welcome home. Now whats our strategy with the fondue . Diversifying your portfolio . E trade gives you the tools and resources to get it right. Are you type e . Predictions. I predict well see this picture every time someone complains about the billions this winter is costing consumers. This is why there are delays and cancellations to avoid this. Airlines have been hit because of what melissa is talking about. I own american airlines. I think its a good seasonal buy. Up 10 by spring. I dont like it right now. What do you like . I like apple. Two reasons. More on the apple watch. Added to the dow its up 30 by the end of the year. Jonas . Too much apple these days. Your prediction . Im not the only one lavishing money on my pets. Up over 4 . Dog spending is going crazy. Idex up 15 a year. They do blood tests. Love the dog not sure about the owner. Our ratings are going up. Neil is next. Get ready for the executive order to end all executive orders. Some people are interpreting this that you left the door open to the president raising taxes by executive action. Is that possible . What i will leave open is always the president s ability to use his executive authority to move the country in the right direction. Did you hear that . Because i did. Im neil cavuto. Not so earnest suggesting the president is open to raising taxes through executive action. It works for illegal immigration, right . If you cant run a tax hike through congress,