We are going through the procedure of determining the regulations regarding yes regarding your remark, Dear Colleague ivana orestivna, in accordance with the regulations, i take measures for the presence of deputies in this hall and once again remind that the issue of appointing members of the Accounting Chamber is a very important function of the Verkhovna Rada of ukraine and i ask my colleagues to take a responsible approach to the next 45 minutes of their parliamentary life to spend it in the session hall or in other places where they consider it necessary. The head of the Budget Committee roksolana andriivna podlaz is invited to the report, three minutes, please. Thank you, dear Oleksandr Serhiyovych, dear peoples deputies and colleagues, we fought hard to consider this issue today at the meeting, but it is really important in accordance with the legislative requirements in connection with the increase in the composition of the Accounting Chamber which took place several years ago from 9 00 a. M. To 1 p. M. For members of the Accounting Chamber, the committee on budget issues announced a competitive exercise of vacant positions for members of the Accounting Chamber until 40 candidates submitted documents to the committee, two of them refused further participation in the competition, therefore, 38 candidates are accepted for further participation in the competition , materials related to the candidates were timely posted on the websites of the Verkhovna Rada and the Budget Committee, you can familiarize yourself with all the candidates online, interviews were held in the committee with the candidates and received the results of a special check for all candidates, the decision of the committee with detailed information about the competition events has been provided to you and is also posted online in particular, the collar, but we have the decision of the committee, in particular the first the Budget Committee approved the committees conclusions regarding each of the 38 candidates for the vacant positions of members of the Accounting Chamber, as well as the oriented regulation of the Verkhovna Radas consideration of this issue. At the same time not added information about candidates you at the same time added information about candidates defined a no sorry not added information about candidates defined in article 205 of the regulations of the Verkhovna Rada , as the relevant documents are posted on the websites of the Verkhovna Rada and the committee. Thank you for your attention. Dear colleagues, lets vote. Thank you. Oksana andriivna. This is for speeches from the parliamentary factions of the groups, speeches from the tribune for two minutes, please , please, please, please, please, please, please, please, koltunovych Oleksandr Serhiyovych , platform for life and peace, please pass on the word nestoroshchuk, please Dear Colleagues this it is really our responsibility, because we have to contribute to the most Effective Work of the body, which is not coincidentally called the chamber under the Verkhovna Rada of ukraine, and i hope that now we will not waste time and will vote as soon as possible, and i want to appeal to my colleagues that we will do everything to ensure that their wishes the procedure for consideration of previous draft laws was taken into account , unfortunately, it was not enough 226 i ask everyone to join the vote as soon as possible. Please pavlovich Dear Colleagues, in november 2019, you and i adopted a law that increased the composition of the chamber of accounts from 9 to 13 members, in january 2020 , a corresponding competition was announced less than two months after that, the covid pandemic began another two years later probably a largescale war , was it expedient in these conditions to increase the staff of top managers of the highest state audit body by 4 units, would it lead to an improvement in the quality of the work of the chamber, the answer is unequivocal no , the best practice of the work of the highest bodies the audit of the world shows that an increase in the number of members of a collegial body does not lead to an improvement in the results of their work, and isolated cases where there are more members in europe than now in ukraine are justified by the broader powers of these institutions and the performance of judicial functions. In february of this year, the European Commission published a report on ukraine in which noted the low quality of the audit work of conducting inspections and not audits, the minimal impact of the recommendation of the Accounting Chamber to europe under the leadership of the previous chairman, we were integrated only at the level of salaries of the chairman and members of the chamber, therefore our efforts to reform the Accounting Chamber should now be directed not at increasing the number of members, but at institutional independence, transparency, accountability , the ability to introduce International Audit standards into the work of this body, for this, in close cooperation with worldclass state auditors by sigma experts in icd by the best enzio, we are finalizing the preparation of the new version of the law, the Accounting Chamber summarizes despite the fact that among among the applicants there are really powerful professional candidates. Today we do not have the right to increase the number of members, because these are additional members, please, it is volodymyrs voice. Dear colleagues, today the new minister of defense has already openly said that he will submit proposals to increase the Defense Budget , because we still need more than 200 billion by the end of the year at that time, we see a lot of abuses due to the inefficient use of state funds, we as the Verkhovna Rada have a special body which is actually our arm which performs a control function which has to control the effective use of funds , it is now very important to increase the capacity of this body , we and International Partners are telling us about it, we were told about it at the meeting of the joint Budget Committee of the European Parliament and the Verkhovna Rada. We need a meeting, accordingly, this is the capacity. This is what they say to us and we understand here , colleagues. I urge everyone, lets speed up this work on increasing the capacity, i understand there are some old contests, we must really think already in the new paradigm to redeclare the contests and think about how to work so that our Accounting Chamber becomes the body that will allow us to use funds more effectively, accordingly , to direct more funds to security and defense measures thank you colleagues thank you, please oleksiyovych a no, we need zhanina , please, European Solidarity , give me two minutes, too, please, cynically, now tell me about your socalled mistake about increasing the number of members of the Accounting Chamber from nine to 1 p. M. And in fact you then professed a very selfinterested moment, the goal you then set before yourself was to dilute the votes that the chairman of the Accounting Chamber, who is not disadvantageous to you, could get, to create conditions for him under which you would influence the work of this body, well, i dont understand you are talking about the independence of the body. Yes, you are doing it now in order for another institution to become dependent exclusively on you. Well, i just dont have the strength to tolerate this cynical lie that you tell all the time here from this podium. I only agree with the fact that even you dont read the conclusions of the Accounting Chamber, i read every report, i write about it, you write about it in every section, i ask for explanations of what they meant, no Law Enforcement agency has reacted in any way to the huge number of comments they give to their reports because you dont give them a command to these Law Enforcement agencies. As soon as you give a face to the report of this Accounting Chamber, everyone will be held responsible. Stop cheating. Literally all the institutions have already been destroyed. The antimonopoly Committee Fund state property reached the Accounting Chamber sydova thank you, lets move on to speeches from peoples deputies, please sign up for speeches of up to 2 minutes for a speech of only four minutes, please laba mykhailo mykhailovych luga of the people i have laba yes yes good afternoon friends so the work of the Accounting Chamber is now an important aspect for our state today and during the two days of the parliaments work. Strengthening the work of the Accounting Chamber. Just today, this is another component of the transparency of the work of the budget of ukraine and our International Partners, so today an important step is to decide to support and move forward. Thank you, please. I wanted to talk about how today the Verkhovna Rada has simply lost its subjectivity. Look today we are making a decision on the appointment of the minister of defense , a key decision, a key position where the president the president the president nominated us. He didnt even find time to come to the Verkhovna Rada to present the candidacy. Well, its simple, elementary respect for the parliament and the voters who elected us here. Today we elected the head of the antimonopoly committee, who was nominated by the government. Even the Prime Minister doesnt come here anymore. Earlier, when at least three people came there, i dont know sanchez , the Prime Minister of other countries , he comes out of respect, although myhal doesnt need everything today. This is, to put it mildly, not the most interesting Prime Minister in the world, but he doesnt go anymore well, complete disrespect, they elected the head of the antimonopoly committee today , the Prime Minister of denmark spoke here well, maybe someone will come here, the president , the Prime Minister, there is not even a speaker left us friends of the speaker of the parliament and thats gone, he went abroad and on a business trip. Well, its clear. Yes, who can, and i dont understand then. And what are we doing here with you, and now there are about 40 deputies in the session halls. We continue with you the consideration of the Accounting Chamber , the key issue of 40 deputies and you know if we dont respect ourselves, if we dont respect ourselves, then who will respect us, we have turned into a very bad amateur choir. Ropes that sing songs and hymns, when someone comes to us here, we will soon leave with a loaf of bread. Our role with you friends well, its a shame, its the parliament of ukraine, we proved it, the only thing is that i wouldnt disrespect the tradition of singing the National Anthem in general. I think its important for peoples deputies and for the country, and all the guests who come are very surprised and respect there is no such thing in any parliament in the world. Well, in fact, no parliament in the world is the parliament of a warring country, please. Yaroslav ivanovich zheleznyak voice. I think that the answer to what we are doing here should be given by the head of the Budget Committee of roksolana under vlasov. Please pass on her word. Laska roksolana andriivna, one minute you have yaroslav ivanovych Dear Colleagues, please, i thought, i suggest going to the vote, the question is clear and everyone has read the summaries of our candidates , they have made up their minds, we can vote thank you, lets proceed to the rating voting in alphabetical order for each candidate separately regarding the end shufrych nestori ivanovych its good if one minute has not ended and from the place thank you mr. Oleksandr lets do it for the sake of justice we are now in place and we are fulfilling our duties whoever thinks that he a and there will be a vote today regarding the absence of the president today, well, we must be honest, everyone knows that the secretary of state of the united states, mr. Blinking, came to ukraine and the president of ukraine is involved in these therefore he could not attend the events presented by the minister of defense, he was introduced by a representative of the Verkhovna Rada of ukraine , there is no need to speculate and pedal where it is not pedaled, thank you for your attention to the head of the Verkhovna Rada. Of the g7 speakers in tokyo and this is the first time in history that the speakers of the Verkhovna Rada, it is the second time at these events, are taking part in such highlevel gatherings, so i think this should also be respected, please european the solidarity of arturov bogdanovich gerasim, one minute, you can turn on the red one, please, because its an infinite time. Dear colleagues, you know , i wanted to draw attention to two points. He despises himself, this leads to the fact that the president did not come today, that the Prime Minister came today, that very often the representatives of the government are not present. It happens in many other situations, there is no need to talk about the war, there is no need for the war. Not everything is written. The cabinet of ministers should fix it at the level of law so that the payments to the families of the victims are protected, my colleagues. You know what i want to address to the monomajority , at least to those who are now in the hall. Please read the bills that are being brought to the hall. Because when what do they tell you about this . Lets protect the payments to the dead. Lets do it at the level of the law. And you dont support it. I have only two things, two points, to be more precise, its already red. You determine as for his support, lets start alphabetically boyko ruslan volodymyrovych i ask you to vote for 23 crows Vitaly Volodymyrovych by factions thank you crow vitaliy oleksandrovych i ask you to vote for 25 by factions viktoriya yuriivna hanushchak for 32 by factions please show me thank you gorbach margarita leonidivna i ask you to vote for 24 by factions gradil andrii ivanovich i ask you to vote for 32 by factions hrytsenko oksana ivanivna i ask you to vote for 23 by factions grinenko olena oleksiivna i ask you to vote for 25 by factions dmytrenko gennadiy vasyliovych i ask you to vote for 24 by factions please show zamlinskyi rostyslav teodoziyovych, please vote this is the same one from english for 32 by fractions please show ivan dmytro valeriyovych, please vote for 24 kanzurak viktor vasyliovych, please vote for 18 kerychyna natalya sergiyivna, please vote for 21 krylo olegovich klymenko, please vote for 23 klyuchka Serhiy Serhiyovych , please vote for 22 Tetyana Volodymyrivna krechkova, please vote for 19 kuyan, iryna anatolyivna, please vote for 26 Vasyl Ivanovych lemishovsky, please vote for 20 Viktor Mykolayovych mazyarchuk, please vote 43 he has the best chances so far. Andrii valentinovych, please vote for 15 we have voted for half of the list. Markov vitaly ivanovych, please vote for 16 naumova Olena Oleksandrivna please vote for 22 no need natalya petrivna please vote for 29 islander serhii ernestovych please vote for 20 good but nothing and how many islands once again rain olenichenko stepan volodymyrovych please vote for 24 pogorelov yury serhiyovych please vote for 19 humility yuliya gennadiivna please vote for 21 yuriy denisovych rodionov, please vote for 19 Oleksandr Dmytrovych skopych, please vote for 20 lydiya stanislavivna stavska, please vote for liliya 29, svitlana evgenivna strastratienko i ask you to vote for 22 tolstanov mykhailo kostiantynovich i ask you to vote for 51 ugrin ivan bohdanovich i ask you to vote for 19 khristofor v denysa ihorovich i ask you to vote for 19 chhugunna hryhoriy yakovych i ask you to vote for