Well to resolve the problem. To a very free society we have freedom of speech freedom of journalists and so long live in on some very not. As far as democracy in this is an extremely complicated subject which we have to field a constitutional refined and yes no i think that entity capable. I mean. Please that doubt. Also coming up since were on the subject of trust they are all democrats and they all want to be the next u. S. President last night in a televised debate they all were agreed on the one person not to be trusted. In pietschmann is the way that we establish that this man will not be permitted to break the law over and over without consequences this president and i agree with bernie senator sanders is the most corrupt president in modern history and i think all of our history. Well to our viewers on p. B. S. In the United States and all around the world welcome we begin the day with the woman they do not trust the woman is hong kongs chief carrie lamb they refers to the protesters in hong kong who have become a nonstop nightmare for lamp on the prodemocracy demonstrators they would tell you that kerry lamb is not exactly the definition of a dream for them either well that mutual disaffection and distrust have been on view for all the world to see for almost half a year now protesters are demanding democratic reforms and a stop to beijings authoritarian creep within the territory despite a recent crackdown by police and a ban on face masks the protesters refused to go away or to be silenced today was no different. A hostile reception for kerry land const chief executive had come to deliver a speech but as fellow no mike has heckled and she could make it started. I think all white all no make has no place remained silent for years anyone who does not stay silent we will be asked to leave the chamber. Under a jungle in 5 seating poco im going to uncle. Prodemocracy lawmakers projected the slogan here the 5 demands not one less than the chambers walls these include universal suffrage and an independent inquiry into Police Violence during demonstrations. When carolan didnt address any of these demands she was shouted down forcing her to abandon her speech she wanted to live at her address 5 video length. No make it tanya chan is one of her moms most vocal critics she later told t w that the chief executives time is up well absolutely absolutely i dont think she can still get her call call and and after all this muddles we can clearly see her incapability and so i think that thats very 1st step all to go forward to go forward its her its for her to resign as soon as possible. As night fell get small cause for anger jimmy sham a prominent protest organizer was left bleeding in the streets after at least 4 men reportedly attacked him with ham as. He supposed to say the assault was politically motivated they have found to carry on their prayers hest. Well to trust or to rust and that is the question many here in germany say that the country is facing as it begins rolling out its 5 g. Network now 5 g. Technology it allows internet speeds a 1000 times faster than what we have today it will make the internet of things a reality autonomous altos will be possible radically everything could change but not everyone is convinced for the better in order to roll out 5 g. Immediately germany will not be able to avoid doing business with the chinese tech giant who way it is the Global Leader in 5 g. Equipment and germanys ally the United States have considered who are away a potential Security Threat its equipment a possible trojan horse concealing state espionage the us australia and japan they have blacklisted who away this is what secretary of state mont pompei i said earlier this year during a visit right here in berlin. Weve been pretty clear about how we view the risks connected to while away in 5 g. 8 or structured infrastructure the internet the future must have western values imbedded within it theres a 2nd mission which is to make sure that we have to get our friends about these risks as well that we talk to them plainly openly theyll make their own sovereign decisions. Who way has repeatedly rejected accusations that it could become an arm of beijing but chinas National Security laws they are very clear about the role of Chinese Companies in assisting the communist party on demand german chancellor Angela Merkel she is certainly aware of all of this yet she has decided not to exclude who are away from the 5 g. Bidding process not to follow intelligence advice from the u. S. Now that is unusual for america and it is risky so what is it about who awaits products that could become weaponized we have this report tonight from serbia where they can talk from experience. This camera is one of more than 1000 on the streets of the serbian capital belgrade the 5 g. Software which connects them is able to identify and track individuals local authorities argue the system created by Chinese Telecommunications giant one way helps reduce crime in the city of 2000000 but critics say the system is not well suited to that task. Monitoring the entire population and to every single point in time. When it comes to conduct this petty crime and then i. Think wed be doing surveillance in general. Statistics studies show its only against crimes critics say this violence can be used to trail political opponents making them vulnerable to retribution serbias police are accused of leaking footage of protests to progovernment tabloid media to identify and intimidate demonstrators. Weve had very bad experiences with the treatment of the citizens data by the state bodies and primarily security structures even Sensitive Data such as health and welfare or party or Union Affiliation this data has been brutally abused on several occasions and used against the regime critics or opponents although thats a criminal act and punishable by law. Although beijing has been forging closer ties with belgrade including joint Police Patrols way denies accusations of chinese spying and says the technology is simply to make cities safer. Are for more tonight at the big table by thorsten better hes cofounder and director of the Global Public policy institute here in berlin person its good to have you back on this so i want to show our viewers the text from germanys new. Guidelines on 5 g. Because this is the part thats really raising some eyebrows and see if we can pull that up and show our viewers it remains to provide assurance of the trustworthiness of the supplier the Commission Company shall obtain a comprehensive declaration from them the declaration must relate to all components and where appropriate functionalities relevant to security as well as providing complete information on the supplier now thats a lot of contract language for saying basically you have to certify that your trust worthy is that good enough when were talking about something is important as 5 g. Networks for a company or a country is certainly not good enough this is Critical Infrastructure has grave National Security and technological sovereignty indications and now what the German Government in this Draft Guidelines has agreed on is that huawei just needs to self declare that its trustworthy and then it gets allowed to provide up to 2 thirds of the german 55 g. Network thats not at all taking these security concerns seriously that are not just raised by the u. S. And australia by the way the German Intelligence Services see it that way the German Interior Ministry sees it that way the German Foreign office has grave concerns about this their Big Industrial policy considerations because the european suppliers that have excellent technology. Ericsson and not nokia find themselves in an unfair competition with huawei and need to be supported but chancellor merkel out of fear of retribution would get us a little side of it that she wants to allow huawei in although she i think understands the security risks that are associated with if there were a different relationship to the United States right now if there were a different president do you think that miracles decision would be different you know i dont think it would be different because. What shes afraid of retaliation retribution by the Chinese Government we have the German Government against German Companies and our companies. And theyre in to the China Business the verde pendent up to 3040 percent of their revenue is dependent on the market in china and i think Anglo American has decided that maybe compounded by trump and the volatility has injected is certainly a factor but i do think its just the fear of retribution thats informing her but were talking about the profit sources for companies for German Companies that profits which is outside of the country in china but 5 g. That were talking about security inside the country i mean those are 2 theyre not of course theyre not related. Ones much i would assume that for her the security of the country should be much more important than the profits would hope so but i think she sells out the longer term security implications that will materialize in 4 or 5 years only to her worries about short term potential economic wrists today who weighs Top Executive in europe published a letter about 5 g. In europe in this segment called our attention lets pull that up it reads europe is open and inclusive and it is this openness and inclusive of the which allows us to Work Together effectively we understand each others points of view and reconcile each others interests this exchange of ideas will move us Forward Together that. Because coming from a Chinese Company its beyond comical because 1st of all its a very proud partner of the party state and its in the repression in. Other provinces in china it supports their civilians and repression operad is there and does so proudly and in addition. Is of course beholden to the Chinese Government and ultimately under its control if push comes to shove then to say that they share the European Values of the rule of law and openness. Its a sales pitch but a sales pitch that for me is beyond comical and take a look at this other part of the letter its also. Interesting to say the least it reads the 1st Industrial Revolution was forged in europe out of industry the 2nd and 3rd Industrial Revolutions were led by america through mass production and digitalisation now he says i think it is only fitting that the 4th Industrial Revolution should begin see europe at the forefront. That is also that thats not realistic 1st of all but does he mean europe with china exactly europe with using technology and i think the party state has made it very clear that they want to be the leaders of what he calls the 4th revolution they have made in china 2025 and they want to be the Artificial Intelligence leader in 2030 so we in germany these were just Draft Guidelines that were british so its important and they were drafted by a minor Cybersecurity Agency in the german system because merkel wanted to have it out of the hands of professionals and parliamentarians and out of the broader political process delegated down delegated down in to a lower administrative level and right now its up to parliamentarians there quite a few german members of parliament who are very concerned about the mistake were making with these guidelines and parliament can just take things into their own hands and pass a law that would actually take our security concerns seriously our technological sovereignty concerns and also the industrial policy concerns that are associated with this monumental decision that i think we shouldnt delegate to a minor agency if it stays this way will be interesting to see how washington reacts to it either way though not just washington is also a question of european unity because were this is very much on their minds a common standard within the European Union poland has been very critical francis is critical and if the biggest european country just sells it out itself out to china it. Sends a terrible signal for somebody with a Global Public policy institute thorson as always we appreciate your time and your insights thank you thank you. U. S. Foreign policy it was one of the main points up for debate last night the stage was crowded as 12. Democratic president ial candidates faced off on Live Television there was almost unanimous condemnation of President Trumps decision to withdraw all u. S. Forces from Northern Syria and there was a unified front of attacks launched at Elizabeth Warren who could very well eclipse joe biden and become the party front runner. As they took to their podiums the democratic president ial candidates appeared to be united at least on one thing all 12 say they want to see President Donald Trump impeached. And pietschmann is the way that we establish that this man will not be permitted to break the law over and over without consequences former Vice President joe biden was asked during the debate about his and his sons dealings in ukraine one of the issues at the center of the trump impeachment probe president my son did nothing wrong i did nothing wrong i carried out the policy of the United States government in rooting out corruption in ukraine gaiden and Elizabeth Warren are seen as the favorites of the democratic race war and challenging died in as the front runner found herself increasingly its hocked the candidates also criticized President Trumps decision to withdraw u. S. Troops from syria treat being fired on by a shot by assads people and the president states if those if those isis folks escape from the prisons or in the lonely go to europe would affect the democratic when i will take on President Trump who is seeking reelection in november 2020. 4 will the United Kingdom begin leaving the European Union on october 31st we will know the answer to that sometime tonight and use chief works in negotiator Michel Barnier said today that High Pressure last minute because she must produce a result by the end of today tomorrow is the start of a summit of e. U. Leaders and will be the final opportunity for the European Union to discuss and say yes or no to a breaks a deal to keep in mind that deal would that have to be passed by the u. K. Parliament as well here is what the irish Prime Minister said today about those talks. We have a pathway to possible deal but there are issues still to be fully resolved it has to work for the people of ireland it means avoiding a hard border between north and south thats always been the governments primary objective ensuring that the all island economy can continue to develop and the north side cooperation as invasion by the good friday agreement can resume and just as important to protect the Single Market its integrity and our place in it those are our objectives and this is always been about achieving those objectives and i am confident they can be achieved. All right im happy to welcome the night here at the big table 2 brothers matthew and michael yule did i get the last name right you to believe they are linked which means alter their linguist their polyglots their citizens of Global Britain is well gentlemen welcome to the show you called our attention because you are advertising yourselves as as twins who speak many languages how many languages do you speak fluently 1st of all fluently so were really as if you know like oh Mother Tongue of the tongues then 10 and weve learned over 25 languages and are constantly looking to learn more can you name the languages really fast that you speak fluently did you like doing this irish heber french spanish german orgies italian danish french. All right so you are poly what brits yes did you vote for brooks it absolutely you know is the only language you would never want to lend his device in his home for this point unless there is a language to break to do that and no one is getting the apparently votes of i mean how do you explain what has happened and is happening in your home country think is about to like to say as something to do with being an island but then i saw in shows everybody else that thats not the thats not so they were also high fives as well and island is very very well within the within the e. U. And is a very active partner. Its quite badly and sometimes to figure out why and brags is happening the white house is about to happen and i think sometimes this island mentality does play a role in that we run a very well those were votes 31 which is a school locally we had 2 on on available to us friends im german that is no longer the case its right that its been changed students in the u. K. Are no longer required to learn a Foreign Language right it was a disaster you know what i mean i agree with you but tell me what you think its a disaster i think this is disaster in many of the many reasons. We both teach. On a regular basis we both weve taught children and adults. Unfold language is a very. Probably the biggest part of our lives shows simply that language is just that isnt important and language is in my in our opinion the most important thing there is actually without language we wouldnt be able to communicate and therefore i would say britain in this sense is sending this clear signal to the rest of the world if not you know to the rest of europe because britain is your whether it likes whether it thinks it is or it isnt was it isnt it will continue to be your and its sending a signal that we dont need that and i think if anything we need more language learning more language to doing more communication more than ever why arent there more people like you in the u. K. Saying these things i think there are i think theres a very sizeable minority that thinks that i think however coming from in perspective its not only something that we find in england or in britain per se you also find in the states in australia its almost as if we have this like to think you have a genetic gene that makes those unable to learn a language the curse of the english being the lingua franca of the world all right we dont have to learn the other way around really if we think that we took 40 percent at least of our own language from other languages and made it what it is which is a brilliant language just like any other languages but yeah our language is so international. To say that we would like to you i mean when i look at your story you 2 are i say youre the the brakes it british irony in card 8 i mean if you consider that i mean your lets say your polyglots your european brits you live in a time when breaks it is promised with Global Britain but its being delivered in dimensions that look like Little Britain absolutely i mean i see that from the outside i see that yeah what about at home though how do you how do you think people are pushed perceive what theyre being told. I think is does a very important very important interesting question because if a many people have none for those that actually voted for a good deal of people now thats that that they were lied to join the company. Then theres been enough evidence to show the has been the case especially with the fall the states have all the alarming figure is in regard to the n. H. S. And that has now been said by some politicians i was not the case again goes to show how important languages are extra in telling the truth how important it is to tell the truth do you consider yourselves to be europeans. You consider yourselves to be more european then British English i mean what is it is there a hierarchy i think its just. Wealth immediately so i think its a very nice happy medium. South and not only british but i and also european and american i think to be all 3 i think you can fit all 3 i mean in our case because we come from a british irish family i think for us its very we are very british were also very irish and we were extremely your opinion and i see no contradiction in that was some of the i think its a wonderful thing you know i think the whole the whole development is fascinating and you also come from a country that once you know had an empire that the sun did not. All right its amazing that you came from an island that was able to reach around the world and now its pulling back almost like a turtle it in its shill do you think it is going to happen and i hope it doesnt the events of the last few years is still make it clear the corn. As it stands right now. Is it is a tough one to call and if it does happen do you think that it will be reversed i would very much like you to be and i think its a quite a good theres very few things give you a Little Britain thats the feeling i have generally at the moment concerning all of this and i would like it to be reversed and i would like the i would say majority actually of people that did back then it was 4050 to. 52 percent against for i think were already hopefully in a situation where the majority that are against briggs and i would like. To go. Time matthew michael. Steele im going to say feel and. See and thank you guys. The date of the conversation of course as you know continues on. On twitter and you can probably have t. V. Maybe well put that on the screen for you there you go they wake up every member whatever happens between now and then tomorrow is another day well see that everybody. We leave digital traces. Everywhere over time. And they are always on our on line trail companies how careers dinner mine are in. Because for them our data is literally a coal mine. Made in germany next on t. W. Enter the conflict zone. Lies in populism uprising in venezuela hong kong protests for exit blocking. The world is in crisis mode just this week weve lost track of the key interviews of the season the point is that people wants to change they imply the whole thing to me on channel there is no discernible and you. Look so. Insistent teetotal. Literature invites us to see people in particular. To see how it sounds as the kids finds growing up. My objective is to show. You the 3 books on youtube. After the fall of the berlin wall nov 9th on do you w. Name place of residence date of email address mobile phone number credit card number Security Code its mind boggling the amount of personal information you have to share when shopping online and we just go along with it the internet and privacy give me your data our topic today on mate