there are always winners and losers. and with our partners which v.w. has across the whole world i interned to be the winner. within a few years v.w. was again making a profit that laid the cornerstone for his reputation as a visionary car executive when v.w. acquired porsche was already a group chairman the merger was a long time ambition of his the father of 12 children believed v.w. and porsche belongs together. that in 2015 p.s. found himself in a power struggle with v.w. then c.e.o. martin venter corn it was a struggle ph lost and he resigned an abrupt end to a storied career. monica jones joining us now in the studio good morning monica monica p.s. was it was truly a giant in the world of course what made him such unique car executive what as you