I think that sauls judaism, thats really we went to israel. I think he forced himself to get away from some of the intellectual development and that he had felt necessary to make himself into a great writer, and returned in a more personal and probable way to his own judaism. But did he attend temple . No. Getting of the bible . You bet. Do you think that his later writing different because of this when he talked itself judaism . Yes. He just force himself the reawaken himself that was something already inside them, deeply ingrained inside and. He successfully kept at a distance i believe, and i also a book where he says he felt that being an immigrant, a jew from chicago was to provincial. When he felt he needed to go, go to paris, you know, he went, you know. I mean, thats the short answer. Greg, wha want to thank you. It was a wonderful discussion. Urging people to get the book. You will be available to sign them . I think someone will take me to the signing room. We continue the discussion at the table. Thanks very much everyone