About to begin speaking at a rally. Its in cincinnati. Its his first since the racist send her pack chant about an american congresswoman broke out. Now, tonight, the president seeming to suggest he may let it happen again. In cincinnati at your rally tonight are you prepared to tell your supporters to stop if they begin chanting something problematic . I dont know whats going to happen. I cant tell you whether or not theyre going to do that chant. If they do the chant well have to see what happens. Will you stop them, sir do you think. I dont know you can stop people. I dont know that you can. He doesnt know if you can stop them . Well, except he can. Because he the only reason they even said such a thing, send her back was because he tweeted it. Remember, why dont they go back and help fix the totally crime infested places from which they came . Right. So when the crowd at last months rally seized his words and kmanted send her back about the american congresswoman he tweeted about, he claimed he knew how to stop them and in fact he said he did stop them. Mr. President if i may, when your supporters last night chanted send her back why didnt you stop them . Why didnt you ask them to stop saying that . Well, number one i think i it. I started speaking very quickly. It really was a loud i disagree with it by the way. But it was quite a chant. And i felt a little bit badly about it. But i will say this, i did and i started speaking very quickly. Well, except of course he didnt start speaking quickly. He didnt try to stop them. He stood there for 13 seconds. Watch. Omar has a history of launching vicious antisemitic screeds. [ chanting ]. He can speak more quickly than that. He looked around, took it all in. Only again speaking once the chant died down. Now the president now claims he he disagrees with the chant that its offensive. Of course it came from his tweet. If he does disagree, why would he say he doesnt know if he can stop it . Well see what happens . Thats blatantly encouraging them to do it again. Because of course lets be clear. When he was asked will do when they chant, he said what the congressman representing cincinnati he said i hope the president silences the crowd and tell tell them dont do its not helpful its not right. But thats not what President Trump said when asked about it. He encouragedpeople them. Well see but if if happens President Trump has a ka chance to do the right thing to stop it. Following the lead of another republican running for president. I cant trust obama. I have read about him. And he is not he is not he is a he is an arab. He is not no, mom, no, maam. No . Sno, maam. No, he is a decent family man, citizen that i just happen to have disagreements with on fundamental issues. And thats what this campaign is all about. He is not. Thank you. Abbey phillips is outfront live outside the white house. Abby, the president did not go that way this afternoon. Will he do the right thing if it happens tonight. Well find out in a few short minutes, erin. But President Trump seemed to make it clear that he may not be able to stop the chants from starting. But he might be unwilling to stop them once they have. And this is exactly the thing that many republicans were afraid of, that this chant, in sentiment might be engrained in the tweets, becoming part of a typical trump rally and that the president might decide to just let it go. President trump has not since that first disavowal repeated his repeated disavowal of the chant. He continues to praise supporters saying in response to the questions from reporters today that the message he has for his supporters at the rally tonight are that he loves them and they love him. He did not say that this is something he would want repeated at his rally. And already you are hearing a message from donald trump junior, for example, who spoke just before the president earlier today at the rally in cincinnati, a message that everyone is using racism against the president and his supporters. So that is something that the campaign does want to use in this context, saying this is all Political Correctness gone amok. But the question is will President Trump allow this to happen again creating more heartburn for his party as they felt this really did cross the line, erin. Abbey, thank you very much. I want to go to congressman donald payne junior, a member of the congressional black caucus. And on set tonight. Thank you for your time. You heard what President Trump was asked on the way to cincinnati if they chant send her back what do you do . He said i dont know you can stop people. Well see. Didnt say it was wrong. There is no place for this sort of thing. Thats not what he said. Can the president stop them. Well thanks for having me, first of all. And you know, just as you played the clip of the senator when obama was asked called an arab. An arab. He corrected her directly. The president could step in and say that its not right. But he has no interest in doing that. Stoking the racial divide in in country. He has made it okay for this type of thing to go on. Its unconscionable. You know, last time as he said i jumped in quickly, of course he looked around 13 seconds. The chants died down. He continued his speech. Why do you think he allows it . Well, injury its who he is. And it plays to his base. And he just cannot help himself. It is unfortunate, but the president of the United States is a racist and a bigot. And its just its a sad time in this country to have the leader of the free world act in this manner. Look, you have taken a stand. You said you support impeachment inquiry. I want to say people might hear you say he is a racist and bigot you thought that way for a while. Did you not publicly come out oh until after the mueller hearing. After that you came out. Moments ago your fellow congressman pete aguilar is onboard. You are almost there. 117 out of 235. You only need one more vote to have the majority of the caucus behind the impeachment do you know anymore democrats ready to get onboard. Not to my knowledge for me we are back in our districts right now. It could happen any day. We are at the tipping point. Do you believe you have the momentum. I believe so, yes. Speaker pelosi has dismissed the idea of impeachment, right. Here she is in june when asked about what happens when your caucus is there . Here is the exchange with our manu raju. If the majority of the caucus wants to go forward with impeachment inquiry would you go for it. Its not even close in our caucus. That was june 11th. Tonight we are one vote away. Right. Youre not close. Youre there. Today she was asked about it. And here is what happened. Speaker pelosi, your reaction to a majority of your caucus supporting impeachment inquiry . She seemed didnt want to talk about it. Seemed to say she would have a statement soon. Of course we dont have one. Does she need to back the impeachment proceedings as soon as the majority of democrats are onboard . Does she have any other ground to wait. Speaker pelosi is trying to make sure that the it is the will of the american people. I believe in discussions with her that has been one of her main interests. There have been many of us and many of my colleagues that have wanted to go prior to this. But miss pelosi has a lot of things she has to take into consideration in doing this. And one of the main her main interests is making sure that its the will of the person people. You want her to get there but youre not saying once we get the one vote we better there or im livid youre not in that camp. No, no. Okay. Look. Last night as we talk about the topic of race and the president s rally about to begin. Joe biden pointed out the diversity in the democratic primary field opinion it is diverse. He played off trump telling people to leave High Pressure send her become. Here is joe biden. Mr. President , this is america. And we are strong and great because of in diversity, mr. President. [ applause ] not in spite of it, mr. President. So, mr. President , lets get something straight. We love it. We are not leaving it. We are here to stay and were certainly not going to leave it to you. I know congressman pairn you support cory booker for president. Youve known him a long time from new jersey. You worked with him. What do you make of joe biden delivering that message . Well, i have been a great supporter of the Vice President , and im not surprised. He is a man of great integrity and has been helpful and has worked with Diverse Communities throughout throughout his time in the public service. So im not surprised. But he is not your guy. No im with senator booker right now. It would be a a great opportunity for the senator to be the president of the United States. And i support him wholeheartedly at this time. All right. Congressman payne, i appreciate your time thank you very much. Thank you. And outfront next former Vice President joe biden misspeaks again and again and again. If you agree with me, go to joe 30330 and hematocrit me this this fight thank you very much. Is that a problem for someone who is now trying to convince voters that age is not an issue . Plus charlamagne the god, the radio host every democratic candidate for president sits down with who he says was the clear winner last. And the democrats turn on the most pfrp didactic. Former president obama. Why . Free wifi. And the price match guarantee. So with hilton there is no catch. Yeah the only catch is im never leaving. No im serious, i live here now. Book at hilton. Com and get the hilton price match guarantee. Did you know you can save money by using dish soap to clean grease on more than dishes . Try dawn ultra. Dawn is for more than just dishes. With 3x more grease cleaning power per drop, it tackles tough grease on a variety of surfaces. Try dawn ultra. [ alarm sound ] [ alarhello. D ] what is happening . What is all of this . Move everybody get out of here whyd they kidnap bunch of normal folk like us . Theres no escape. You have no idea what youre up against. [ screaming ] our mission is to provide complete, balanced nutrition for strength and energy whoohoo greattasting ensure. With nine grams of protein and twentysix vitamins and minerals. Ensure, for strength and energy. And you eat right. Mostly. And minerals. You make time. When you can. But sometimes life gets in the way, and that stubborn fat just wont go away. Coolsculpting takes you further. A nonsurgical treatment that targets, freezes, and eliminates treated fat cells, for good. Discuss coolsculpting with your doctor. Some common sideeffects include temporary numbness, discomfort, and swelling. Dont imagine results, see them. Coolsculpting, take yourself further. Upbeat musieverything was so fresh in the beginning. [sniff] dramatic music but that plug quickly faded. Upbeat music luckily theres febreze plug. It cleans away odors and freshens for 1200 hours. [deep inhale] breathe happy with febreze plug. Dealing with Psoriatic Arthritis pain was so frustrating. My skin. It was embarrassing. My joints. They hurt. The pain and swelling. The tenderness. The psoriasis. I had to find something that worked on all of this. I found cosentyx. Now, watch me. Real people with active Psoriatic Arthritis are getting real relief with cosentyx. Its a different kind of targeted biologic. Cosentyx treats more than just the joint pain of Psoriatic Arthritis. It even helps stop further joint damage. Dont use if youre allergic to cosentyx. Before starting, get checked for tuberculosis. An increased risk of infections and lowered ability to fight them may occur. Tell your doctor about an infection or symptoms. If your inflammatory bowel disease symptoms develop or worsen, or if youve had a vaccine or plan to. Serious allergic reactions may occur. I got real relief. I got clearer skin and feel better. Now, watch me. Get real relief with cosentyx. New ton, President Trump slamming senator Kamala Harris performance at last nights democratic debate and offering a pack handed compliment to the former Vice President joe biden. I think biden did okay. He came through. He came limping through, as i say about sleepy joe. He limped right through it but he got through it. He really did. I think he was okay. I think kamala had a bad night last night, i would say. Outfront now National Affairs correspondent for the nation joan walsh and former chair of the dnc ed rendle, a joe biden supporter. Governor rendle you heard President Trump. Kamala harris had a bad night at the debate and joe biden came limping through, as i say about sleepy joe. He limped right through it. Is that how you see it . Well, i think he did better than limp through. I think he appeared strong and in command of the facts. He did a good job defending his position. Did a good job pointing out differences in his position and some of the other candidates. I think overall he had a very strong performance. Kamala harris, you cant judge her by her first debate performance because she did terrifically well in that debate. She didnt do nearly as well in this debate. But kamala hair sis a force to be reckoned with, no question about that. Kamala hair sis a bright, intelligent dynamic person. And she didnt have as good a debate as she did in number one. But so i would disagree slightly with the president. But i cant believe that im actually thinking he did a good analysis. Well, he seems to be reflective of what a lot of people people say. Limping through juror joe biding. No, absolutely not. Vice President Biden had a better night than in miami last month for sure. He had rusch patches. I would say senator harris did not have the same kind of night she had. But the second half was much stroirng stronger but i dont think the governor or the frrm Vice President care at all what donald trump says. I dont think democrats should be baited into react whag he thinks of our debates because it doesnt matter. There is a real conversation out there, though. Lets be honest about joe wide biden, right . And whether you well did he do last night and as well as he needed to no where was the bar sfl governor rendle where multiple instances where joe biden misspoke. You say command of the facts. But there were moments a big awkward to watch. Here a few examples. Four more years of donald trump will go down as an aberration, hard to overcome the damage he has done but we can overcome it. Eight more years of donald trump will change america in a fundamental way. If you agree with me, go to joe 30330 and help me in in fight. I mean im not trying to make light of it government but eight more years would change america in the fundamental way because the president cant serve three terms. Change the constitution. Right. I mean, he is trying to show that age is not an issue here. And its not relevant. Do moments like that hurt . No, no one is taking an isolated moment out of context. Theyre going to view the overall performance. En and overall it was strong. Erin youre probably to remember Ronald Reagans debate against walter monthdale. You know i watched it. I dont remember all of it but i watched it with my parents i remember watching youre right i wouldnt have been able to judge . The way you are now. Right. He seemed completely incoherent. You really were deeply troubled because in a 60, 907ensecond presentation he seemed to lose track of everything. He went on to win i think 49 states. So people we the 4,000 of you who make our living out of politics we seem to isolate the facts and give them emphasis. The average voter doesnt. I believe joe bidens lead in the polls will be as strong if not stronger than before the debate. To that point, joan, biden had loud applause multiple times during the debate. We have some technical issues so i cant play it. We dont have the sound bite. But there were several when Kirstin Gillibrand wrote an oped opposed working mothers. He is like what are you talking about . You were there with me. And my my deceased wife worked. And my wife he got a lot of applause. And there were many moments he seemed ready. Right. You know, i had a different reaction to to some of that, erin. I think that one of the issues for the Vice President and i would say this to senator harris as well, is not being defensive. I know its tough. We know its tough backup you know when he said to senator gillibrand, you went to Syracuse University with me. And youve praised me. We worked together. You said i you came with me im wonderful and passionate about the concern for working women turned it back on her. But, you know, he has done this several times. He did this with senator harris, you know, she knew beau. He personalizes thing that puts him off his game. He needs to understand he got in the race kind of late. All these people think they should be president , not him. Its not personal. Theyve been friends, will be friends again. And there is a tone sometimes that he takes that i think sounds a little bit like entitlement. And it also injury puts him off his game. So, governor let me ask you, because, you know, im curious because you have known him a long time what you think is happening in a couple of the moments. You know, we know this is a guy every story i hear about him, governor is about how we gave joe biden four minutes and 31 minutes later. Literally thats of an exact quote from somewhere. The guy doesnt want to be quiet. Its part of what defines him. Yet in the first debate there were a lot of moments like this that got attention. And let me just play it. With kamala hair zblies i agree everybody wants no, no my is up. Im sorry. Of course governor he grot criticized was he scared . Did he not know what he wanted to say what was the problem. Last niem everybody is running over the time and the moderators cut them in. Joe biden he handled it slightly differently but let me play what happened. If the 160 Million People who have it say they like their employer insurance they should have a right to have it. If they dont they can buy into the biden plan which is obama care. Thank you, Vice President thank you. And they buy the gold plan and theyre not going to pay anyway. Thank you, Vice President. If you cross the border, illegally you should be able to be sent back its a cranium. Its a crime. Its not one that in fact. Thank you, mr. Vice president. Governor what was that he didnt try to talk over finish his thought he almost seemed relieved to be told to be quiet. What do you think happened there. I think he is a polite human being. Look, a trait not found in many of us politicians. Joan, what do you think . I think perhaps he has been warned that he is too gerlous. Talks too much and maybe he is selfcorrecting. I dont know a couple of times it seemed like he ran out of steam. He should not look like he is running out of steam or answers. He is really he has to take up all his time. Take up space in the room and so i dont think it looks good for whatever the reason. Well see what will happen. Joan. Quick final word, governor. He did take up all his time. He just stopped when told to stop. He actually stopped when someone asked him to stop. Shocking. Lets drum him out. Right, right. He did what people asked him. Im not saying drum him out im just saying finish the sentence. There was something strange about it but maybe he was being overly polite. Its possible. Thank you very much. And next Kamala Harris defending her record after being accuse of jailing people for minor overs. Marijuana offenses. Despite this. Have you ever smoked . I have. Okay. Like. And inhaled i did inhale. It was a long time ago. But, yes. I know you have to the man conducting the interview charlamagne the god is my guest. Plus dems critical of president obama at last nights debate. Today its a very different story. And there is a real question as to why when you look at the polls can dems have it both ways . Nt formula recommended by the National Eye Institute to help reduce the risk of moderate to advanced amd progression. Man because its my sunset, its how i see my life. Its my vision. Preservision. [woof] here, hello starts with hi mple. How can i help . A data plan for everyone. Everyone . Everyone. Lets send to everyone [ camera clicking ] wifi up there . Ahhh. Sure, why not . Howd he get out . a camera might figure it out. That was easy glad i could help. At xfinity, were here to make life simple. Easy. Awesome. So come ask, shop, discover at your xfinity store today. Outfront tonight, senator Kamala Harris on defense after her performance in last nights debate. Maybe if i could have had three minutes instead of 60 sections o seconds or 30 seconds where or 15 seconds if i could have done it differently that would have been my choice. Harris on her heels after coming under attack by Tulsi Gabbard. Senator harris says she is proud of her record as a prosecutor and scheel be a prosecutor president but im deeply concerned about this record. There are too many examples to cite but she put over 1500 people in jail for marijuana violations and laughed about it when asked if she ever moekd marijuana. All right. That exchange, the one about laughing about it that gabbard refers to came from an appearance harris made on the popular radio show the Breakfast Club hosted by my next guest charlamagne the god, a must stop on the campaign trail. Here is the moment. Have you ever smoked . I have. Okay. And inhale. I ininhale. You did did inhale. It was a long time ago but yes. I know you have to dsh zbloosh outfront now charlamagne the god. And i know we played that moment before. It was an important moment. You talked about how genuine she seemed. And now obviously you were talking about legalizing marijuana during the exchange. Congresswoman gabbard put forth the people she put behind bars for marijuana. What did you make of the moment in the debate last night. I didnt think it was a genuine moment simply because if you want to attack senator harris for i guess cribbing to putting people in jail for drugs then why wouldnt you attack joe biden too . If you your purpose was to combat somebody for the war on drugs, i mean, the author of the 94 criminal backup bill and 88 crack laws was sitting in front of you it was low hanging fruit to go after senator harris but everybody should be questioned on the record. The debate ended. She came on cnn and did an interview. She then was talking about the moment with gabbard. Here is what happened, charlamagne. Did you expect that from Tulsi Gabbard . Had you had interaction about that in the past . And how do you think it went . Well, i mean, listen, i this is going to sound immodest but im obviously a top tier candidate. So i did expect i would be on the stage and take hits tonight because there are a lot of people trying to make the stage. For a lot of them its do or zplie li is. Especially when people are at zero or 1 or whatever she might be at. Okay. Does that swagger help or hurt her charlamagne. Its the truth. She is a top tier candidate. You know her. You know joe bidenen on the stage were the big guns. Everybody was coming up against them. Aiming. And gabbard i cant pronounce her gabbard. She is at zero . You like the swagger. Its the truth. Not immodest. She should have had the swagger because she was terrible on the stage last night. Is she still your favorite. Yeah, she is still my favorite simply because our current president is a criminal and who better to go up against a criminal than a prosecutor, donald trump needs to be prosecuted. I want to ask you about a candidate we have had on the show. Cory booker. Yes. You snow him well from new jersey, the senator. I asked you before which candidate was the least comfortable talking about race in all the conversations you had with him. You said without hesitation cory booker. You told me we want to know exactly what type of agenda you have for africanamericans and you said he wasnt prepared to answer. Did he change your mind at all. Cory booker won the debate last night if you ask me. I thought he did great. He brought up things ive been waiting for people to question. I wanted people to question joe biden on the the tough on crime stance. Yeah. I wanted people to talk about the russian interference we know exists Robert Mueller talked about in the report, that the Senate Intel Committee talked about. Im private citizen that has to vote next year. I want a fair vehicles. That was a moment when cory booker connected those, race and russia. Here he is. Look, this is one of the times where were not staring at the truth and calling it out. And this is a case for the democratic party, the truth will set usfree. We lost the state of michigan because everybody from republicans to russians were targeting the suppression of africanamerican voters. We need to say that. What was it about that moment. I love that simply because last week i watched you know Robert Mueller say that there was russian interference. I watched the Senate Intel Committee say there was russian entertains. I watched Mitch Mcconnell block the Election Security bill after getting the information. If that doesnt tell us the administration is in cahoots with russia what will . Me as a citizen having to vote, i want to make sure its fair and balanced election. He linked it to the africanamerican vote. Two nights of debates with the democrats. None bringing it up. Shouldnt that be a pressing issue. We dont know if its a Fair Election in 2020. So coming into the debate you were critical of joe biden. Up up. You have been direct about that with the crime bill. Criminal justice reform. And its impact on black americans. I dont want if you saw that poll but a recent poll had 26 when you look at the 53 of black voters the who have decided who theyre vetth for say joe biden. 53 . Sanders is the next closest at 8 . Then Kamala Harris at 7 Elizabeth Warren at 4. And 2 for cory booker. Broism is real. Like i said. People are not educated to joe bidens record. And people can change and unlearn. I want everybody to keem in mind last night month the state your name he called cory booker the president. Im sorry future president. Because he thinks all black politicians look alike. Nobody paid that no attention. Joe biden why cant he admit hey i made mistakes did some things wrong i want to correct those things going forward. You come out of this saying joe biden is not getting there. Umhum. Cory booker wins. Umhum but you are still as of now. I just think that. Backing harris. I think the democrats as a collective are famg america. And the reason i think they are failing america is because they are not being honest like cory booker said. We have a crisis in the white house. We have a president that seems like he has the facist agenda to me. Thats what i think. And i think if we continue on this path democracy as we know it is going to be dead because it looks like the fight is fixed. He has the department of justice on your side. You have the senate, the supreme court. You got the National Intelligence now and its like and the russians in 2020 . Im not going to feel comfortable until some type of Election Security bill is passed and i know the fight is not fixed in 2020. Anded i dont understand why people arent making a big deal of this especially the democrats. Charlamagne the god. Thank you. Thank you. And outfront next, the most popular democrat. How does attacking president obamas legacy help the 2020 candidates . And jeanne moos on how the candidates are cashing in on their one liners . I knew that when i wrote the damn bill. If you have moderate to severe psoriasis, Little Things can be a big deal. Thats why theres otezla. Otezla is not a cream. Its a pill that treats plaque psoriasis differently. With otezla, 75 clearer skin is achievable. Dont use if youre allergic to otezla. It may cause severe diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting. Otezla is associated with an increased risk of depression. Tell your doctor if you have a history of depression or suicidal thoughts or if these feelings develop. Some people taking otezla reported weight loss. Your doctor should monitor your weight and may stop treatment. Upper respiratory tract infection and headache may occur. Tell your doctor about your medicines, and if youre pregnant or planning to be. Otezla. Show more of you. [ alarm sound ] [ alarhello. D ] what is happening . What is all of this . Move everybody get out of here whyd they kidnap bunch of normal folk like us . Theres no escape. You have no idea what youre up against. [ screaming ] bills back needed a afvacation from his vacation. An amusement park. So he stepped on the dr. Scholls kiosk. It recommends our best custom fit orthotic to relieve foot, knee, or lower back pain. So you can move more. Dr. Scholls. Born to move. [fa mers bell] burke a rock and wreck. Seen it. Covered it. At farmers insurance, we know a thing or two because weve seen a thing or two. We are farmers. Bumpadum, bumbumbumbum tonight joe biden standing up for president obamas legacy after the democratic debates. I must tell you i was a little surprised at how much incoming there was about barak, about the president m. Im proud of the job he did. I dont think there is anything he has to apologize for. The thing is, some of the Democratic Candidates actually a whole lot are using obamas record on immigration, specifically the deportations, the 3 Million People he deported over two terms to hit his Vice President joe biden. Did you say those deportations were a good idea . Or did you go to the president and say this is a mistake we shouldnt do it which one. Mr. President , it looks like one of us has learned the lessons of the past and one of us hasnt. Mr. President , you cant have it both ways. You invoke president obama more than anybody in the campaign. You cant do it when its convenient and then dodge it when its not. Outfront now Patrick Healy our political analyst and New York Times politics editor and gloria our chief political analyst. Thanks to both. Joe biden tide himself closely to obama. If anything people sometimes criticize him for that refers to him as barak, not the president. He is making a bet on that. Could this hurt him when some of obamas policies which are now seen as positively rightwing by some running for president go unthe microscope. The reality is that joe biden is running as Barack ObamasVice President , if he hadnt been Barack Obamas for eight years he wouldnt have the support with a lot of the older voters, with some to many africanamerican voters. That service, those eight years are core to who he is. He has a story to tell about this vice presidency that is very different than what some of the democrats running against him want to talk about. They want to appeal to Younger Voters and liberals looking at eight years of obama and saw a lot of moderation. They were happy for obamacare but want to go further now. They look at the deportations. I want not trump light but a prolog to what trump is doing now. And theyre not happy with what all of what that record says. So he is going to keep taking the incoming fire. But i think for at least right now for the older voters, africanamericans, what joe biden did today in saying, i cant believe they are going after barak, that works for him. Gloria, look, president obama is popular. Very. When you look at the full democratic base, his his average Approval Rating among democrats cheh he left office was 83 . Is that all . And it might have gone higher right because you are talking about democrats who have been living in the era of trump. I mean, going after him, smart move. Look, i think in the end its a mistake for democrats. I think that right now what theyre trying to do is differentiate themselves. They have to figure out a way to say this is how im different from joe biden. You saw julian castro. He is running on obama you have to go to its kind of logic. Health care, obamacare and immigration. Right. But i also believe biden could have had better answers on immigration in particular. He could say well who are the people lets look at this. Whats the context of this . Who are the people that we deported . We deported serious criminals. We deported people who had just come across the border so we could send them back, didnt have to put them in cages. Selectively enforced the law. This is why he did it and how. And defend what you did. But instead he said well im not telling you what i talked to the president about and. Its such a good point. He could have said we werent putting children in cages. Were werent doing. Exactly. What the president is doing at the border right now. And instead he found himself this went to a broader problem. You know, the nimbleness of surviving a debate these days waents on display. Lets talk about in because biden you mentioned this he refused to answer a question from mayor de blasio which maybe he should have refused because de blasio was not moderator but like a new yorker he got in there and through his elbows around. And look, about deportation under president obama. De blasio comes straight at joe biden. And joe biden did not defend obama. He seemed to throw him under the bus . Can i just play this moment . I was Vice President im not the the president. I keep my recommendations to him in private unlike you i expect you would go ahead and say whatever was said privately with him. Thats not what i do. It it felt like a big bus. Yeah, that was not a good moment. Every time Barack Obamas name should have come up at the debate, you know, joe biden if he was, you know more of a nimble debater would have pivoted back to the closeness of the relationship to eight years together to what they did for america. And it was strange because instead of he is getting himself in a ground war with bill de blasio. Answering his question. The answer was it wasnt me it was him is what it sounds like. Right. Gloria, it wasnt just he implied i might have had the currently popular point of view. But i dont know what that guy did. Im not telling you. He then said, you know, this isnt what i do. I dont tell anybody what i talk about with president obama except thats not true. Right. He has many times discussed openly conversations he had with president obama about osamma bin laden like this. I get to be the last guy to be with the president. Walked up toorpds the residence, the office. And i knew where he was going to go. I always he looked at me again. Follow your indistinct mr. President. As we walked out of the room and walked upstairs. I told him my opinion. I thought he should go but follow his own instincts. He just didnt have an answer. So thats what he said. You know, to de blasio. He didnt want to defend the policy which he defended for eight years because he knew that he is talking to a Different Group of people, that the base of the marketic party has shifted. So instead he said, well, you know im not talking about that. Thats not really an answer in a debate. And we know that barack obama probably couldnt win in this primary if he were standing for the policies he stood for then. Joe biden could have said you you are the mayor of the new york not the moderated ert you dont ask the questions. I stand by barack obama there was a way to just he didnt do it. Here is what he did for eight years. You know what we did eight years. Ill tell you. He should be doing that and maybe he will now. I got to give gloria credit i literally punched herer her in the face she didnt flinch. I did not flinch. Thank you both and Kamala Harris record as a prosecutor a major selling point on the campaign trail. Tonight under scrutiny. Plus jeanne moos and now joe bidens gaffe is paying off for cory booker, as only jeanne can tell it. When i was diagnosed with breast cancer, there was no hesitation, i went straight to ctca. After my mastectomy, it was maddening because i felt part of my identity was being taken away. When youre able to restore what cancers taken away, you see that transformation firsthand knowing that she had options that she could choose, helped restore hope. My team made me feel like a whole person again. Cancer Treatment Centers of america. Appointments available now. Cancer Treatment Centers of america. When you start with a better thats no way to treat a dog. You can do no wrong. Where did you learn that . The internet. Yeah . Mmm with no artificial preservatives or added nitrates or nitrites, its all for the love of hot dogs. Who used expedia to book the Vacation Rental which led to the discovery that sometimes a little down time can lift you right up. Expedia. Everything you need to go. I felt i couldnt be at my best for my family. In only 8 weeks with mavyret, i was cured and left those doubts behind. I faced reminders of my hep c every day. But in only 8 weeks with mavyret, i was cured. Even hanging with friends i worried about my hep c. But in only 8 weeks with mavyret, i was cured. Mavyret is the only 8week cure for all common types of hep c. Before starting mavyret your doctor will test if youve had hepatitis b which may flare up and cause serious liver problems during and after treatment. Tell your doctor if youve had hepatitis b, a liver or kidney transplant, other liver problems, hiv1, or other medical conditions, and all medicines you take including herbal supplements. Dont take mavyret with atazanavir or rifampin, or if youve had certain liver problems. Common side effects include headache and tiredness. With hep c behind me, i feel free. Fearless. And theres no looking back, because i am cured. Talk to your doctor about mavyret. At tmobile, for 40 line for four lines, its all included for the whole family. Like unlimited with netflix on us. And now with each new line, get one of our latest smartphones included. 40 line for four lines and smartphones are included for the whole family. Tonight Kamala Harris is trying to fight back, defending her time as a prosecutor and as the attorney general of california. After her record faced a series of attacks last night, kwang la is out front. Reporter this former prosecutor defending her past. People want to know the commander in chief has actually been in the business of prioritizing their safety. Ive done that my entire career. They absolutely want Public Safety so im not going to shy away from that record at all. Senator Kamala Harris. Reporter her career as a prosecutor is her central pitch to voters. What we need is someone who is going to be on that debate stage with donald trump and defeat him by being able to prosecute the case against four more years reporter an opening for attack against Tulsi Gabbard. Im deeply concerned about this record. Reporter serving up a slew of attacks, gabbard zeroed in on one part of harriss record as San Franciscos district attorney. She fought to keep the bail system in place that impacts poor people in the worst kind of way. I am Kamala Harris reporter it is true. In 2004 harris advocated for higher bail amounts for gunrelated crimes. She had just been elected district attorney. May 2004 audio first recorded by website free beacon captures harris talking about her priorities, mainly increasing those arrested for bail on par with nearby counties. Were going to change the bail schedule in San Francisco. People come to San Francisco to commit crimes because its cheaper toe do it. You know, we have to do something about that. Well, welcome. Reporter the Harris Campaign says as a prosecutor she acted to protect the public from rising gun crimes, the job of district attorney. Fast forward 15 years, a new job, a new time, new priorities. I tell you what, shes the best. Reporter now a california senator, she introduced Bipartisan Legislation to change the cash bail system, citing its disproportionate impact on the poor and people of color. Harris struck back at gabbards attack. There were certainly inaccuracies about my record. Theres no question about that, and, you know, from a person who has been an apologist for assad, who is by all accounts a murderer of his own people, an accusation by someone who refuses to call him a war criminal. Reporter gabbard did, indeed, meet with Bashar Alassad in 2017 in a private meeting and then this is some context here, this is when assad had already used chemical weapons on his own people. At a cnn town hall last march, gabbard declined to call him a war criminal, and then, erin, it was only after she was pressed repeatedly on cnn after the debate that she said she would not dispute the fact that assad is, indeed, a murderer and a torturer. Erin . Thank you very much. Up front next, jeannie, on the one liners that stole so much of the show at the democratic debates. The first thing im going to do when im president is im going to clorox the oval office. R longestlasting aa battery goes to. cymbal crash energizer ultimate lithium. Guinness World Records title holder for longestlasting aa battery. [ alarm sound ] [ alarhello. D ] what is happening . What is all of this . Move everybody get out of here whyd they kidnap bunch of normal folk like us . Theres no escape. You have no idea what youre up against. [ screaming ] thats ensure max protein, with high protein and 1 gram sugar. Its a situp, banana bend at the waist im tryin keep it up. Youll get there. Whoahoahoa 30 grams of protein, and one gram of sugar. Ensure max protein. We like drip coffee, layovers and waiting on hold. What we dont like is relying on fancy technology for help. Snail mail we were invited to a y2k party. Uh, didnt that happen, like, 20 years ago . Oh, look, karolyn, weve got a mathematician on our hands check it out now you can schedule a callback or reschedule an appointment, even on nights and weekends. Todays xfinity service. Simple. Easy. Awesome. Id rather not. Heres jeanne moos. Reporter this is a salute to debate one liners, starting with the one that launched a thousand clorox jugs, oval office strength. The first thing im going to do when im president is im going to clorox the oval office. Reporter it inspired mopping by everyone from mr. Clean to spongebob, though critics suggested, why dont you start by using clorox on your friends . Showing senator gillibrand posing with bill clinton and harvey weinstein. Now, the senator didnt dream up that clorox zinger on the spot. Its a line shes used before. Then polished. E egged on by voters. Whats the first thing youll do when you get in the white house . Clorox myself. Reporter she honed the line in new hampshire. After i clorox the oval office. Clorox the commander in bleach. Reporter others are cleaning up with their one liners. Kamala harris talked about being bussed. And that little girl was me. Reporter the campaign started selling that little girl tshirts. When Bernie Sanders got feisty i wrote the damn bill. Reporter the Campaign Author i wrote the damn bill. Arguing with ryan you dont have to yell. Reporter ryan started plugging you dont have to yell stickers. Koolaid clinched the promotion. Youre dipping in the koolaid and you dont even know the flavor. You know whats cool about being black . You can makeup phrases and white people dont know its real. Reporter when joe biden really did call rival cory booker. Future president here he endorsed my presidency already. Reporter hes selling stickers future president because one liners stuck. Careful with the clorox. We ended up with a spill that made a splash. Jeanne moos. I hope they had better luck cleaning the oval office than we did. Cnn, new york. Oh, no, i hope we can expense that, jeannie. Thanks for joining us. Anderson starts now. Good evening. Democratic president ial candidates Marian Williamson and Kirsten Gillibrand join us tonight. We begin with growing concerns trumper republicans in the wake of the cnn debates in detroit. The candidates they say are risking their general election chances by taking on one another and tarnishing Barack Obamas legacy instead of focusing on defeating President Trump. President obama s after all, an expresident with 65 in independents. This is democrats and republicans giving democrats advice echoing president obama who warned about this before the Campaign Even got going at a town