California. Thousands are gathering, you can see these live pictures, to mourn the victims. Six students murdered during a killing rampage friday night at the university of california santa barbara. Janet napolitano, the uc president and former secretary of Homeland Security is going to be speaking, along with the father of chris martinez. He was Elliot Rodgers final victim, shot, murdered at a deli. In the random horror, the five other victims included rodgers two roommates and a friend who was just visiting. Police say rodgers stabbed them to death in their apartment. From there the 22yearold got into his bmw. He drove only two blocks to a Sorority House and murdered two more women. Then he drove to a deli, where this Surveillance Video captures the barrage of bullets that killed martinez. Rodger kept driving and shooting at random people before police say he took his own life. And investigators say rodgers murder rampage was a twisted attempt to get revenge against people he say had rejected him. His frustrations were detailed in youtube videos like the one youre looking at right now, and a 137page manifesto. Kyung lah is out front in goleta, california, where the memorial is taking place. We can see all the students behind you, kyung. I know there are many thousands coming there tonight. The cassity for this stadium, erin, is 17,000. It looks like theyre going to hit it. It seems like the entire university is here, the entire town. And this is just a snapshot of how this has affected everyone who goes here, the schools, the university, the people who live here. They say they are grieving. They need this so they can try to put the pieces back together. They have also come to hear chris martinezs father, who has a potent message to share with this crowd, as well as everyone in this country. Who would have dreamed that this could have happened to us. Reporter not to my child, thought richard martinez. His son, chris, just 20 years old, a ucsb english major went to the iv deli mart when bullets flew into the store. No one thinks its going to happen to their child. I would never have thought chris would die in this way. How would i know . How would i think of that . No one would think that, that your child would die at 20 in front of a deli. Reporter what could a father do . He did this. Our son Christopher Martinez and six others are dead. It was an extraordinary moment when you walked into the news conference. They talk about gun rights. What about chriss right to live . Reporter very unexpected. Why did you do that . Because i realized that people are only going to be interested in this for a short time. And to honor the memory of my son, im determined to take advantage of the limited amount of time that we have to talk about this. Reporter and what he wants to talk about is how we got here. Another gunshot wound by the iv deli mart. Code 3. Reporter investigators say the gunman suffered from a Mental Health issue, yet he still owned semiautomatic handguns and hundreds of rounds. All purchased legally, to the frustration of this father, a veteran and former gunowner. I cant tell you how angry i am. Its just awful. And no parent should have to go through this. No parent, to have a kid die because in this kind of a situation, what has changed . Have we learned nothing . Reporter learned nothing from newtown, he says. 20 children and six adults shot and killed at sandy hook elementary in connecticut. President obama pushed for tougher federal gun control laws, expanded background checks. But that failed in the Senate Despite overwhelming public support. I think the vast majority of people in this country favor some type of reasonable gun control. But every time somebody mentions gun control, they get this strong reaction from a small vocal minority and the politicians cave. Every time. Reporter he says it will probably happen again this time, but this father wants washington to hear this. Where is the leadership . Where in the frigging politicians that will stand up and say we need to do this. Were going to do something. Those gutless bastards have done nothing, and my son died because of it. Its outrageous, absolutely outrageous. Reporter and its not just gun rights that mr. Martinez is talking about. He says this is as much about Mental Health and the lack of this countrys ability to take care of those who need help. Erin . Kyung lah, thank you very much. And that stadium fits 17,000. You see the students walking in now. They suspect it will be completely full tonight. Elliot rodgers history of Mental Health was not a secret. His parents were frantically searching for their son after receiving the chilling manifesto and seeing this youtube video. Tomorrow is the day of retribution, the day in which i will have my revenge against humanity. Outfront cnn legal analyst paul callan and mel robbins and dr. Guardier. You just saw that video. This is a young man, his mother saw some of his disturbing videos this spring in april, end of april, just a month ago, called police. They went to his apartment. He convinced them it was a misunderstanding. Is this something is that could have been prevented, or are these things that some people do, and most of the time they dont turn into anything . Well, first of all, the cops did not. And im not pointing fingers. But they didnt connect the dots, that there were previous contacts with the police officers. So if in fact they had known about the two previous con techs when they went do to do the welfare check, then they would have put it all together and said wait a minute, there is something not right here. Secondly, what we see in many states, there are not laws that state that you have to have a Mental Health expert go along with Law Enforcement to do this check. So here is a situation where you had Law Enforcement who really were not experts in any way in Mental Health, and therefore could have easily been fooled. So do you think, paul, this could have been prevented, given what he is saying . This is not the first time that police have been called . I dont think it could have been presented. The talk for instance about gun control. Gun control wouldnt have stopped it. No. The gun was legally obtained. And he killed three of his victims with a knife. He is the kind of kid who would have used gasoline probably to douse the Sorority House. He ran somebody over with his car. Its not about gun control. In terms of Mental Health availability, he is a rich kid. His parents could have gotten a psychiatrist for him. In fact, he had a therapist. They could afford to give him a hospital bed. So its not about providing Mental Health for the disturbed. But nobody came in, mel, and said this hits that bar. Yes. And thats the problem, erin. Youre nailing it and saying exactly what everybody at home is thinking, which is what do you mean . You have a kid that rants on like this and the cops show up a month before and they dont take him into custody . Part of the problem is the two prior times that the police were with this kid had nothing to do with Mental Illness or any concern. Scuffles with the roommates. Second, youve got a system in place, and you see that father. Its heartwrenching. And he is talking about guns. And i think the problem is the laws around Mental Health. We have a system in this country where the mentally ill have selfdetermination. They get to determine what happens to them. So the police show up. Theyre told by a professional Mental Health worker, theyre told by the parents that this kid is threatening violence and he is threatening suicide. That there is a youtube video. They dont see the youtube video. They have credible account from the parents. Hold on. The parents were never told those things. Thats not true. Specifically. Im talking about the april 30th visit. They total the police. Let me finish for a second. If the cops knew that, then the cops are wrong and they had an obligation to lock him up. Let me tell you this. 20 of the American Public suffers from some kind of Mental Illness. 26 . 26 . All right. So mel robbins wants to create some type of a police state where were going to lock up everybody who is saying things that we dont like this. Is a very, very hard decision. This is a difficult decision. I want a different standard. I represent psychiatrists in these cases. And theyre tormented in these cases because sometimes even when he has admitted to a hospital, then a psychiatrist has to say do we keep him indefinitely, or can we send him holme to a stable home environment . You dont get to put someone in for 72 hours. Ive talked to the mother of a child who has threatened to kill her and siblings. Right. And the child wanted to have more care, and they continually release them. They send them home after the 72hour hold. Its not designed to work with it well. We know most of the Psychiatric Hospital beds are gone now. Insurance doesnt want to pay for Mental Health. So this kid wouldnt have done this, it sounds like youre saying, okay, fine, maybe there have would have been a 72hour delay. But it would happen. A 72hour hold, if they said look, lets take him to a hospital, which is what they should have done. Already treated by a therapist. He is already in therapy. But he wasnt taking his medications. Thats a major issue. Number one, they may not admit him because he has to be a danger to himself or others. He was clearly a danger to himself or others, but they couldnt see it. Yes. And secondly that. Discharge him. Once they discharge him, he he is back out there again. Thats why many psychiatrists and psychologists will not just say get someone hospitalized because theyre talking dangerously, because theyll lose that patient. Theyll lose the patient. There are two cases when people talk this way, nothing happens. No, it doesnt. Lets just be realistic. Is. How can you . You have no place to send them. I was looking at the stats here. In 1955, we had x number of beds available in psychiatric facilities. Do you know we only have one of the five beds that were available in 1955. There is no place to send these people in the united states. Okay. So if the police in a well check, so theyre showing up to see about the wellbeing, if they had the authority to be able as part of that check to look around the house, to check out the cell phone so now youre going eliminate search warrants . Yes, yes. [ overlapping dialog ] you lock up anybody thats not true, paul. Dont put words in my mouth. If a parent says we think our kid is crazy, we think he is going to hurt someone, there is a youtube video, we better do something about this. Lets get him checked in the hospital. Instead, they said not only was he okay, but he was a wonderful, beautiful person. They got duped. They got duped. Because of the standards. Its not the cops. Its not the cops. The cops are not at fault here. Please, we do want everybodys feedback on this and what you think should have happened. Outfront next, months after flight 370 vanished, the raw satellite data. Finally it has been released. Will it bring us any closer to actually finding the plane . We are going to talk to inmarsat. They are coming outfront tonight. Plus, a bizarre political scandal in mississippi. The man called the next ted cruz tonight fighting for his political life. And a controversial new weight loss study has people reconsidering soda. Is diet soda really good for you . Humans. Even when we cross our ts and dot our is, we still run into problems. Namely, other humans. Which is why at Liberty Mutual insurance, auto policies come with new car replacement and accident forgiveness if you qualify. See what else comes standard at libertymutual. Com. Liberty mutual insurance. Responsibility. Whats your policy . The numbers are impressive. Over 400,000 new private sector jobs. Making new york state number two in the nation in new private sector job creation. With 10 Regional Development strategies to fit your business needs. And now its even better because theyve introduced startup new york. With the state creating dozens of taxfree zones where businesses pay no taxes for ten years. Become the next business to discover the new new york. [ male announcer ] see if your business qualifies. Ugh. Heartburn. Did someone say burn . Try alka seltzer reliefchews. They work just as fast and are proven to taste better than tums smoothies assorted fruit. Mmm. Amazing. Yeah, i get that a lot. Alka seltzer heartburn reliefchews. Enjoy the relief. Abe get in punch it let quicken loans help you save your money. With a mortgage thats engineered to amaze thanks, g. It really made the difference between a morning around the house and getting a little exercise. Unlike the bargain brand, depend gives you new fitflex®, our best protection. Its a smooth and comfortable fit with more lycra strands. Get your free sample at depend. Com. At this hour, polls are about to close in a high profile congressional primary race in texas. Thanks to the backing of senator ted cruz, the tea party is expected to seize victory. But its a very different story in mississippi, where Chris Mcdaniel, who is often called the next ted cruz was supposed to sail to victory, be the tea partys best hope of bringing down an incumbent in the gop. But now his campaign is wrapped up in a downright bizarre scandal. Dana bash is outfront with the story. Reporter a conservative blogger is in jail, arrested for breaking into this mississippi nursing home to photograph u. S. Senatored that cochrans ailing wife, suffering from dementia. Its the worst. Reporter in gnaw ad, cochrans Campaign Points fingers at his gop challenger, Chris Mcdaniel. Posting video of senatored that cochrans wife in a nursing home . Had enough . Reporter and it gets even deeper in the mississippi mud. Cochran supporters argue the reason the blogger took his wifes picture was to feed questions about cochrane and longtime aide kay webber, who has traveled extensively with the senator on the taxpayer dime. Cochran calls it part of her job and suggestions of anything untoward sexist. This republican primary was supposed to be about the struggle of ideas within the gop. Chris mcdaniel. Reporter a young tea partybacked upstart challenging a fellow republican for being out of touch and too entrenched in washington after 36 years in the senate. Now Chris Mcdaniel is fending off questions about whether his campaign had anything to do with photographing his opponents sick wife. Our campaign had absolutely no connection to that whatsoever. Reporter you personally, when did you find out about the breakin . Were going focus on his record right now. God bless the tea party. Reporter mcdaniel would like to be the senates next ted cruz, stick to principle, compromise be damned. I am not going to washington, d. C. To be a member of the cocktail circuit or to make back room deals. Im going up there to fight and defend the constitution. Reporter talk to mississippi republicans and democrats who say come on,ed that cochran has been there a long time, but he is a good public servant. I say one fight senator cochran has put out against barack obama. Name one time he has raised his voice in defense of conservatism. Reporter for the Tea Party Movement after a string of primary losses this year, mcdaniel has been their great hope, the best chance of toppling a republican, especially after this cochran stumble. The tea party, you know, is something that i dont really know a lot about. Reporter millions of dollars pouring into mississippi against cochran come from a whos who of Tea Party Groups nationwide. Mcdaniel says he is a lifelong republican. Reporter but like other republican incumbents, this year cochran and his allies are fighting back, painting mcdaniel as extreme and inconsistent. After four decades in washington, cochran has loyal supporters like this democratic mayor. Youre a democrat. Yes. Reporter and youre supporting senator cochran . Yes. Reporter why is that . One is that i understand politics, and i understand what is needed in a state. And he is what we need in washington, d. C. To stay as long as he wants to stay. Reporter at this point, cochran is trying to avoid unforced errors, going to headscratching extremes to avoid talking to us. We tried to catch cochran after this event. But when an aide came out and saw us, they did a bait and switch. The car they told us cochran was getting in screeched away without him, while he snuck out another door to a different car, leaving reporters like us in the dust, unable to talk to the senator. Dana, this story is incredible on every level, including that. Going to those lengths to dodge you . I dont think im that scary, do you . Look, this is all about making sure there are no forced errors. It is do no harm that is the most important thing pour the cochran campaign. Thats why he isnt talking to anybody at this point. The gop primary a week away from today. I can see in that interview you did with mcdaniel why they would call him the next ted cruz. But obviously, trying to this whole link possibly to taking pictures of senator cochrans wife in a hospice is distasteful at best. Does mcdaniel still have a shot at winning . When i talked to him today he says they feel confident, they feel good. But i have to say that republican sources who i think are pretty good in washington who are fighting really hard for cochran insist that he is going to survive. He is going to stay in the senate. And they are really hoping that happens for a lot of reasons. But they hope this deals another blow to the tea party. Well see a week from today, though. Thank you very much, dana bash in biloxi, mississippi tonight. And still to come, a shocking new weight loss study. Well tell you which beverage researcher says will help you lose weight. Its kind of miraculous. And the white house responding after blowing the cover of a top cia agent. [ male announcer ] this is kevin. To prove to you that aleve is the better choice for him, hes agreed to give it up. Thats today . [ male announcer ] well be with him all day as he goes back to taking tylenol. I was okay, but after lunch my knee started to hurt again. And now ive got to take more pills. Yup. Another pill stop. Can i get my aleve back yet . For my pain, i want my aleve. [ male announcer ] look for the easyopen red arthritis cap. I missed you, too. Ou. Hi buddy. Mom awesome dad i missed you. Oh. Daddy. Chevrolet and its dealers proudly support military appreciation month. With the industrys best military purchase program, for all that have served. Sweets become salaries. An oven heats up a community la cocina, a small kitchen that kickstarts the careers of 41 entrepreneurs. They bring the talent. We help fund the tools. Its a small way we help thats been huge for the community. Little by little we can do a lot. Because. Small is huge. Visit www. Wellsfargo. Com to see how big small can be. When we arrived at our hotel in new york, the porter was so incredibly careful careless with our bags. And the room they gave us, it was beautiful. A broom closet. But the best part, worst part, was the shower. My wife drying herself with the egyptian cotton towels, shower curtain defined that whole vacation for her. Dont just visit new york. Visit tripadvisor new york. With millions of reviews, a visit to tripadvisor makes any destination better. Could mean less waiting for things like security backups and file downloads youd take that test, right . Well, what are you waiting for . You could literally be done with the test by now. Now you could have done it twice. This is awkward. Check your speed. See how fast your internet can be. Switch now and add voice and tv for 34. 90. Comcast business built for business. So its called diet soda for a reason. But here is the question. If you drink diet coke, whatever your thing of choice, diet canada dry, will you lose weight . New Research Claims you will. According to a article, diet drinkers lost more weight than people who drink water. Do the claims add up . Outfront tonight samantha cassidy. She is a registered dietitian. If you are a quote unquote water drinker, you could have been drinking other things like juices or regular soda that may have, you know, made you not lose as much weight. I know there are questions here about the study overall. What do you think about the bottom line . I think the bottom line, i would trust it. I mean, these people were on a caloriecontrolled diet. So both groups were told to cut calories. And over the course of 12 weeks, both groups lost weight. The diet soda drinkers lost a little bit more weight. All right. So i guess this gets to the question, is it a tool to help you . I know people go to mcdonalds and say well, im going get a big mac and fries, but im getting a diet coke. And people roll their eyes and say really . To me its a few hundred calories less. Absolutely. Thats what you have to think about. If youre somebody who drinks sugarsweetened beverages every day, then drinking a diet soda is absolutely going to be better for you. When you look at the longterm benefits of diet soda drinking, you know, the results arent as clear. Some studies show people gained more weight over time. Some studies linked diet sodas to poor health outcomes. So you have to look at the overall quality of the diet. Does diet soda, ive also heard people say, well, it makes you hungrier. Even though its diet, you end up eating more and gaining more weight. Other people saying, no because it tastes sweet, i dont want that cookie. What do you think . Does it actually make you eat more to drink a diet soda . The results arent clear here either. Some studies do suggest when you drink something sweet, your brain expects a calorie payoff. Maybe youre digging into the cookie jar, looking for those calories. Other studies say this study found that the diet soda drinkers were less hungry and felt more satisfied with their sweet tooth. So, again, its more about what works for you. And also, about the quality of your overall diet, and what else are you eating and drinking. I think i just end up eating more sweet soda, then you have the hersheys bar. Thank you very much. Appreciate it. Outfront next, breaking news. President obama announcing an end to the war in afghanistan. But some say it is a monumental mistake. Plus, new developments in the search for flight 370. The raw satellite data. Ive said we got it. Finally, we have it, literally. I dont know if you can see this . There are so many numbers on this page. Guess what . Inmarsat, the Vice President of inmarsat is outfront to talk about it. Marge you know, theres a more enjoyable way to get your fiber. Try phillips fiber good gummies. Theyre delicious, and an excellent source of fiber to help support regularity. Wife mmmm husband these are good marge the tasty side of fiber. From phillips. Narrator these are the skater kid whoa narrator that got torture tested by teenagers and cried out for help. From the surprised designers. Who came to the rescue with a brilliant fix male designer i love it narrator which created thousands of new customers for the tennis shoes that got torture tested by teenagers. The internet of everything is changing manufacturing. Is your Network Ready . Ben well, that was close you aint lying let quicken loans help you save your money. With a mortgage thats engineered to amaze but when we put something in the ground, feed it, and care for it, dont we grow something more . We grow big celebrations, and personal victories. We grow new beginnings, and better endings. Grand gestures, and perfect quiet. We grow escape, bragging rights, happier happy hours. So lets gro something greater with miraclegro. What will you grow . Share your story at miraclegro. Com. What will you grow . Trwith secure wifie for your business. It also comes with public wifi for your customers. Not so with internet from the phone company. I would email the phone company to inquire as to why they have shortchanged these customers. But that would require wifi. Switch to comcast Business Internet and get two Wifi Networks included. Comcast business built for business. Breaking news. President obama announcing the end of americas longest war. The president s latest attempt to end the Afghanistan War includes keeping 9,800 troops on the ground next year, and pulling all but a thousand out of the country by 2016. The bottom line is its time to turn the page on more than a decade in which so much of our Foreign Policy was focused on the wars in afghanistan and iraq. I think americans have learned its harder to end wars than it is to begin them. Barbara starr is outfront from the pentagon. Barbara, he has been trying to do this for a while. But this comes as al qaeda is resurgent in other parts of the world. How will this affect americas fight against terror. Good evening. Look at it this way. If u. S. Troops are out of afghanistan, what about pakistan just across the border which by still by all accounts may be decimated, but is the heartland of the al qaeda movement. What if u. S. Intelligence sees a Training Camp or they want to go after operatives with a drone strike, or Pakistans Nuclear weapons fall into the wrong hands . The u. S. No longler have a base of operations in two years out of afghanistan. This is going to lead to a lot of intelligence questions, how do you take up the slack, where do you base other troops, where do you base drones. How do you keep gathering intelligence what is going on on that border. Because the bottom line, erin, is if those Afghan Security forces cannot control the border, cannot control their side of the border, the real risk is that the tallahassee and al qaeda come back into afghanistan. Right. And everything is right back where it started. I know being there about 18 months ago, thats what everyone was saying was their fear. They thought that would happen. Barbara starr, thank you very much. And i want to bring now into the conversation republican congressman peter king. Great to have you with us as always, sir. Do you think the president is doing the right thing . I would say partly. I think its the right thing for him to maintain forces there. I think its important for him to try to get a status of forces agreement. Having said that, i think it was a very big mistake for him to be giving a timeline saying half of the troops will be out by the end of next year and the remaining troops out by the end of 2016. That just gives the enemy the opportunity to plan their strategy. They can either lay back, or they can move forward. It gives them tupper hand in determining what to do. Also, the number of troops he has, that he is going to allow to stay there, i dont know if thats sufficient enough. In fact, i doubt it is for us to carry out our intelligence activities outside of bagram and outside of the kabul area. Interesting, though, when you say it may not be sufficient enough. You are someone who shed sedona a couple years ago boko haram should be designated a terrorist organization. But there was so much focus on iraq and afghanistan that that didnt happen. People didnt know what was happening in libya and malli and other places. Wouldnt this liberate the administration to focus on other areas. He could have named boko haram a terrorist organization whether or not we were in afghanistan. And also, the reality is we cant always pick and choose. Thats what bothers me about the president s statement. Its sort of condescending, saying americans are learning its harder to get out of war than it is to get in. The fact is we were attacked and thats why we were there. And the fact is also that 3 4 of the casualties came when president obama was the president. And his policy then when he had the surge back in 2009. Again, he announced a deadline at that time. And that also gave the enemy the opportunity to prepare for that. Congressman, i want to ask you about this cia story, which has so many people in shock that the white house ordering a review now of who in the administration inadvertently released the name of the station chief in kabul to reporters last week ahead of the president s visit there is an email that went to reporters who is going to be there. And guess what, that person is named by name and title. How much damage was done and should someone lose their job . I believe so. This to me is an unpardonable error. Listen, im sure it was a mistake. Whoever made the mistake in the first place, its inexcusable. Secondly, that it went through so many hands. This is not something that went out, you know, on twitter or it was a mistake. This is something they had a chance to look at and look at again. And they still allowed it to be out there. To me its unforgivablunforgiva. This is tremendous harm. That person will have to be taken out of afghanistan, the station chief. And this is elementary. Everyone knows from the day you arrive in congress, never mind the white house, you know that no one is ever to know the identification of a station chief in any country, never mind afghanistan. So youre saying someone should lose their job. And i just have to ask you this before we go. Breaking news here. The u. S. State department, reporting is advising americans to depart libya immediately. They have a new warning citing unpredictable and unstable political situation. Here we are and no one has been held accountable at all for the death and murder of four american citizens. Will anyone ever be . They certainly should be. And im hoping that the investigation is going to lead to that. There has to be accountability. Four americans died. The Administration Lied about it from the very first minute. First over all, we pretty much know who did it and we even know the whereabouts of some of them. The fact is no action has been taken. Unforgivable. Thank you very much, congressman king. Well appreciate your time. Thank you. Months after flight 370 vanished, the raw satellite information has finally been released, except for some columns that dont have Material Information have been removed. So is this everything . Does it confirm the missing plane is in the southern indian ocean . Inmarsat, outfront next. And the music video that is taking the internet by storm. Jeanne moos and the otters. Ups is a global company, but most of our employees live in the same communities that we serve. People here know that our operations have an impact locally. Were using more natural gas vehicles than ever before. The trucks are reliable, thats good for business. But they also reduce emissions, and thats good for everyone. It makes me feel very good about the future of our company. [ shutter clicks ] hi there [ laughs ] im flo i know im going to get you your rental car. This is so ridiculous. Were going to manage your entire repair process from paperwork to pickup, okay, little tiny baby . Your car is ready, and your repairs are guaranteed for as long as you own it. The Progressive Service center a real place, where we really manage your claim from start to finish. Really. Easy as easy can be bye ugh. Heartburn. Did someone say burn . Try alka seltzer reliefchews. They work just as fast and are proven to taste better than tums smoothies assorted fruit. Mmm. Amazing. Yeah, i get that a lot. Alka seltzer heartburn reliefchews. Enjoy the relief. Mayo . Corn dogs . You are so outta here aah [ female announcer ] the complete balanced nutrition of greattasting ensure. 24 vitamins and minerals, antioxidants, and 9 grams of protein. [ bottle ] ensure®. Nutrition in charge™. Sixties, the spaceage, the beatles and more. Dont miss the premier of the 60s. It starts thursday at 9 00 p. M. Today the noticing for the search for Malaysia Airlines finally released. Everything that happened pretakeoff, everything that happened post takeoff. Finally made public after family members first requested the information whether its going to determine whether searchers are looking in the right place. Is this it . Can we definitively look at these columns and interpret them to find out where the plane is . Tom foreman is in washington to begin our coverage. And inmarsats Vice President is going to join me shortly. Tom, first all these columns here of pretakeoff and post takeoff, what is in the 47 pages . What is in it first of all, erin is exactly what you said, what the families had been wanting, 47 pages of raw satellite date that that inmarsat used to track this plane after it disappeared. These numbers were used to measure the way that a ground station sent a message up to a satellite up above the indian ocean, which in turn relayed that message over to the plane, electronically asking are you there and how the plane responded. And these 14 numbers in particular allow us for the first time to see the planes movement long after every other tracking source had lost it. Each one of these lines across here represents one of those electronic handshakes between the satellite and the plane. And you can see, if you look over here how those numbers get bigger each hour. Look at that. Steadily moving up. What does that mean . It means the transmission time between the plane and the satellite is getting bigger, which means the satellite is getting further away from the plane. That means the plane is moving this way. And these planes over here, these numbers over here, by using the doppler effect help give us a better sense of the direction the plane was actually moving. You combine all of this with the known capabilities of this aircraft, and that is how you produce this map that everyone has talked about so much, the idea that inmarsats analysis is that the plane had to go somewhere like this, and it had to wind up somewhere down here. Erin . So tom, they kept saying there was an arc, but the arc went all the way up into the north right to kazakhstan and other places. Sure. It sounds like what youre saying from the data that exists here, and again, we have the data, not the calculations, it would seem from what were given you could determine yes, indeed, its where they say it is. There. Are a lot of details that other physicists and other mathematicians would still like to have and would still like to talk over before theyre completely convinced. But by and large they say this does at least fit what could work. Important to bear in mind in all of this, erin, as precise as this sounds, when you read a related report released by the australians, you get the idea that this job remains incredibly huge. And here is just one example. Based on all of this math, they admit you could still be six miles off in either direction on the math alone, in addition to which the plane itself could drift after that last contact easily 23, 24 miles, all in it adds up to about 60 miles side oside in terms of where this plane could be, even if you knew precisely when it went down. And we dont know that. The search area remains very, very big and still full of a lot of uncertainty. Tom foreman, thank you very much. I want to go to chris mclaughlin, the Vice President for inmarsat. Good to talk to you again, sir. So let me start off by getting straight to the main criticism, right. Ive got all of these pages here. The frustration that people have today is all right, were glad we have this data. But what about the calculations, the way that you put the data together to get to the conclusion that the plane is in the southern indian ocean. Would you share that also, the calculations . Erin, i think our ceo said earlier today on cnn he would be very happy to share the model. The issue is that the data belongs to the malaysians. What we have released in conjunction is the inmarsat data. Obviously they have other information from boeing, from other parties as well involved in the hunt for this aircraft. But at inmarsat, we want to be completely transparent. So im understanding what youre saying. Youre saying the calculations werent your calculations, they could be boeings or someone elses . Or youre saying they were yours, but youre going let the malaysians make the decision on whether or not to release them . Well, the calculations in the first instance to create the model were ours. And we gave those within ten days of the aircraft going missing, as you know. The submission goes into the air accident investigation board, who the uk is representative on the search, on the inquiry. We are only a Technical Contributor to that. Within that inquiry, other parties also contribute, like boeing, like rollsroyce, and like the radar information as well. So were one part in the whole. And we have contributed our bit. So one of the family members we have spoken to frequently on this show, sarah bajc, the American Partner of philip wood says the data still isnt complete. On day one, i want to emphasize what we have what the malaysians released. But they note that some columns that have no Material Information have been removed from the tables. So can i ask you of the 47 pages, how much about do we have . Since you gave them everything, and theyre only giving us some of what you gave them, how much are we missing . Well, in the actual data itself, what you see are sheet after sheet of binary ones and 0s. What you have there in the summary information is an interpretation of those binary 1s and 0s which run to about a 7ing me bit file. Its an interpretation based on the data, based on the best information that we can portray. You shouldnt read anything into any gaps in the data. This is a very good will and focused way that were trying to communicate the best impression of what we think happened. And i know, chris, that as you say, the best impression of what happened. And part of you im sure is frightened may not be the right word. But the burden of all of this is on you and on inmarsat. Everyone has based all this analysis on all of you. Are you still 82 days since this plane went down and we havent seen a piece of debris, are you still as confident as we were when we spoke earlier on yes, im well, erin, besides the inmarsats model there have been four other groups involved in this from aib, through boeing, and other matter, looking at the data and coming up with their own conclusions. In addition, we have looked at successful flights from the north and south, so yes, to a high degree of probability we are certain that our data is right. What we want tell you is the sharp distance. Im sorry, say again . What we cant tell you is the exact distance because the handshakes dont have that data on them. We hope the airlines will conclude that. Well, thank you very much, joining me now, arthur rosenberg, yes, we dont have all the data but he is still as confident as he was. It is very interesting, you go back a week, inmarsat pointed a finger at malaysia, malaysia yeah, they were both fighting about the data. The bottom line here is i believe we have lost sight on what the whole exercise was about, which was to give some gravitas to the families in the absence of physical wreckage, which we dont have today. What i heard today was very important. The ceo said we will come clean with basically the underlying data, the analysis well, that is what he said now. But again, malaysia just why not just put it out there so that these families can know . And they absolutely should. Malaysia went to being transparen transparent to back back to being opaque again, and in a case like this where there is no physical damage, these people, the public, theyre entitled to see the most important piece of information where this plane is. And when you go through this data and as tom explained what it was, the timing offsets, the words that dont mean very much to us out there that basically determine the distance and the time, do you think there is enough data here to conclude where it is . Well o as an engineer. Well, i have spoken to a couple of experts who say that the data that was prootsed was actually very good. But theyre also saying between the gaps and the underlying data, which was used there are 17 pages of data before take off and 22 after take off. Obviously, seven or hours after, before it is only an hour. I am not an expert but is that strange . Well, common sense would tell you there are reams of a lot more information. On the flight itself. Absolutely, i think inmarsat was clear about that. They cherry picked a lot of this information. But the piece that tom did just before there are really only seven key times in the analysis, which gives us the arc, the approximate location, i call it the doppler fingerprint that compares it to other triple 7s, that information was not provided either. They say if it were here it would match this exactly. That would be helpful. Incredibly helpful. All right, arthur rosenberg, thank you very much. And still, what happens when you give a companion to a group of otter . Jeanne moos is on the case. O any happy and healthy. Thats why im so excited about these new milkbone brushing chews. Whoa, im not the only one. Its a brilliant new way to take care of his teeth. Clinically proven as effective as brushing. Ok, here you go. Have you ever seen a dog brush his own teeth . The twist and nub design cleans all the way down to the gum line, even reaching the back teeth. They taste like a treat, but they clean like a toothbrush. Nothing says you care like a milkbone brushing chew. [ barks ] to prove to you that aleve is the better choice for him, hes agreed to give it up. Thats today . [ male announcer ] well be with him all day as he goes back to taking tylenol. I was okay, but after lunch my knee started to hurt again. And now ive got to take more pills. Yup. Another pill stop. Can i get my aleve back yet . For my pain, i want my aleve. [ male announcer ] look for the easyopen red arthritis cap. The numbers are impressive. Over 400,000 new private sector jobs. Making new york state number two in the nation in new private sector job creation. With 10 Regional Development strategies to fit your business needs. And now its even better because theyve introduced startup new york. With the state creating dozens of taxfree zones where businesses pay no taxes for ten years. Become the next business to discover the new new york. [ male announcer ] see if your business qualifies. There are so many music videos on youtube, but one in particular is really getting everybodys juices going, probably because the musicians are just so wild. For more, we turn to jeanne moos. Reporter liberace, theyre not. But when it comes to animal videos there is nothing hotter than these oatters at the zoo. These asian species, every few weeks, keepers set up the keyboard just outside the otter enclosure to provide a little sound enrichment. So of course they got a little excited. And whoa, it makes a noise when i touch it. Reporter or when the bears blow on a harmonica. The bears love to suck up insecond secretaries, even blowing through a fire hose, the otters keyboard has to stay inside the enclosure so they dont rip it out. Does he or she have a name . Rutabega. Reporter with two hands . Two hands. Reporter possibly the most famous critter to ever play the keyboard has a new video out. Actually it is the performance for the cat performing 96 tears. The original cat, named fatso is long dead. An artist dressed her up in a tshirt and manipulated her paws. But at least lila both plays and accompanies herself. And chocko the pug plays on command. Maybe they should consider a orchestra, jeanne moos, cnn. I dont know what it was about the otters, it was great to see. Anyway, they would ruin it if they went in their cage, that is why they saw it on the other side. And coming up, the 60s, the decade that changed the world, free love, civil rights, the 1960s reshaped americas lives in ways that affect us all today. Be sure to watch for the premiere at 9 00 eastern right here on cnn. And we are watching the vigil in santa barbara, california, where thousands of students right now are gathering to hear among others the father of the young boy who was shot at a deli. Just went to a deli and he was shot and murdered. Tonight, we have a special investigation inside the mind of a killer. Is a child born to become a killer or is that something that is made . Tomorrow, our coverage of that continues. And right now, Anderson Cooper has more on the vigil on ac360 starting right now. Good evening, it is the end of the day of mourning at the university of california, santa barbara, thousands coming together at the campus, the soccer stadium and at other campuses around the state. People may not ever know what happened on friday. But that is not so important tonight. That honoring a lost friends life matters more or supporting a wounded classmate. Comforting a neighbor, showing up just to prove that there are far more good people in the world than gunmen. Which is why our focus tonight will not be on the one who killed six people before he killed himself friday, it will be on the lives taken. None