Transcripts For CNNW CNN Newsroom With Poppy Harlow And Jim Sciutto 20191126

Absolute immunity from compelled congressional process simply does not exist. But mcgahn wont be sworn in yet. Hell wait to testify while the case is appealed as the doj just did. May go all the way to the Supreme Court. Meanwhile, the Supreme Court handed down a temporary win for the white house in another case blocking congress from seeing the president s tax returns for now. But the court is fasttracking the case asking both sides to make their best arguments for why the court should weigh in on the tax return fight in this term. Cnns Kaitlan Collins has been covering this story and joins us now here from new york. So first, on the white house strategy as it relates to this loss or temporary loss on mcgahns testimony. Its a pretty big rebuke to what their strategy had been. Theyd been maintaining since mcgahn, which this is dating back to mueller testimony, is essentially these people do not have to go. They had this absolute immunity. And if you read this 120page ruling you see what this federal judge thinks of that. And we knew that they were skeptical of this argument that the white house had been making about how essentially everyone was protected by this. But what you see in this is just how far it goes because this is much broader than just the former white house attorney. And whether or not he can go before congress. But it goes into National Security officials as well which is essentially youre reading former National Security adviser john bolton who is making the argument that his case is different from mcgahns because he was so involved on these National Security issues. The judge said, no, that is not the situation there. You cannot get this widespread, you know, pointblank ruling about whether or not someone can testify. Thats on the mcgahn issue, it relates to witnesses appearing before congress. You have the tax issue now. And the Supreme Court putting a stay, but not really tipping its hand as to whether where its going to decide in this case but it does say, you know, at least its giving both sides an opportunity to make the case the Supreme Court should weigh in on this. The question is how long does that win last. This is something thats longterm because essentially with this ruling, with this state, they are inviting them to make a fullthroated argument. What are they going to say about this and where does it go from there. It says theyre pretty unclear about how this is going to end up. To be clear, part of the white house strategy, is it not, is delay. Yes. To push it out. Push these witnesses beyond being able to testify in the impeachment inquiry that they may have already won that battle and on taxes trying to push it, well, hopefully beyond the election or at least thats what theyre counting on with the mcgahn situation. Yes, it could have these farranging implications for people like Mick Mulvaney and john bolton. They are counting on the fact its not going to affect them now and could help them later on. We saw this before. The white house had been looking at that Harriet Miers coase, th counsel to george w. Bush. It was decided in 2008. The feeling was, well, its 2008. Thats the strategy theyve been counting on now. They knew this could be coming. Kaitlan collins, thanks very much. Joining me to discuss, shan wu, defense attorney and former federal prosecutor and ron brownstein, Senior Editor for the atlantic and cnn political analyst. A lot of cases to go through here. Lets go on the mcgahn case. This is key. Doj is going to appeal. Not clear yet, i believe, whether theyre going to ask for a stay, but probable theyll ask for a stay here. What is likely to happen next . Thats exactly right. I think its key whether theyll ask for a stay or not. It makes sense they would ask for the stay. So really what happens next, jim, is its going to theyre going to lose on this argument of absolute immunity. Its been widely expected as kaitlan was reporting. In myers case, the judge rejected this blanket assertion. Its going to end up with mcgahn in a witness chair but then its still going to go question by question. He may try a little bit more, or the white house may try more on some questions and then theyll revert to executive privilege. So its the long way to go in terms of litigation, but importantly, this legal ruling is a big help for the democrats obstruction argument. But, ron, as you know, this is all about timing here because part of the white house strategy, as i was discuss with kaitlan, is push these witnesses out so they cant be a factor in the impeachment inquiry. On that note, particularly because the democrats have a piece of this as well. They have an aggressive timeline. Theyll not fight it out in the courts. On that point, regardless of how the courts decide, hasnt the Trump Administration effectively won on keeping these witnesses out of the impeachment inquiry . They have, no question. And like many things in american life, this is ultimately going to be decided by john roberts. You know how john roberts feels the morning it comes to him because the pattern of decisions on a wide variety of issues is at the four other republican appointed justices are going to give the administration a lot of leeway. Their posture has been deference, much like the republicans in congress towards what the Trump Administration wants. I do think there is the potential this could be relevant for the 2020 election more than for impeachment. You know, if you look at the tax case, it is the court takes it, they could delay it until next june but if they decide if they conclude he must release the tax returns, that will be available to congress at that point. Potentially the same with his testimony but its not on a track to influence whether the house votes to impeach. And on Something Like that, the cnn poll showing support remaining at about half the country is probably more relevant. Okay. Lets go to the other case which is about the president s taxes. Supreme Court Granted a stay in effect. Says its going to decide on this or at least asking both sides to present arguments as to why it should be decided and decide quickly. Where do you see this going . Where do you see the court leaning on this issue and where is the legal precedent on whether congress should have access because you read the law. It says the House Oversight Committee Shall have the right to do so. Shan, is the law clear . Well, theres not really legal precedent on the president s taxes being released. Its been my view, im still going to stick with it, im not sure that the Supreme Court is going to take it. They are asking for both sides to give their best reasons for why they need to take it and take it fast. But ultimately, i am not sure which way theyre going to come out on it because its a step removed from him. Its not hes being personally subpoenaed to produce these. It does go into the question of whether his socalled immunity from process meaning you cant charge him or indict him while hes in office goes to this question about whether a third party can get his taxes or whether the fact theyre being subpoenaed automatically means hes being pulled into a criminal process. So theres a lot of stuff to slice and dice there. And i dont know that theyre going to want to jump into what were thinking of, of must the president release his taxes. Theres a lot of nuances they can cut away on that. Ron, as you know, john roberts is very protective of the Supreme Courts position to the extent that it still exists today as a nonpartisan body here. There are going to be a lot of tests to that, will there not, in the next seven to eight months . And as shan was talking, thats what i was thinking. The controlling dynamic here may be john roberts how far does john roberts desire to have the court not seen as a partisan institution extend. He broke on the census case when the administration was trying to change the rules in the senate and said in a way that would likely reduce the count of nonwhite americans. On the other hand they backed the muslum ban and looks like theyll support the administration ending daca. If they dont take the case, well probably learn that ultimately, it was roberts desire not to be seen as reflexively protecting the president. Okay, ron brownstein, hold your thought. We have some breaking news out of washington just now. The white house, we learning, is on lockdown due to a security threat. Possibly related to an aircraft in restricted air space. We have our joe johns inside the white house in the Briefing Room on the phone because the white house is on lockdown. Actually, no, hes on camera. Tell us what were learning. We do know that there has been an air defense event, if you will. An aircraft that has somehow strayed into restricted air space, which has created a situation certainly around the white house and perhaps up at the capitol as well where air defense measures have been put into effect. Here at the white house, were on lockdown. Everybody is being kept inside. The United States secret service, uniformed officers and others patrolling outside with the full armed gear. And were waiting for authorities to give us an all clear sign. This information about this air defense condition reported by Barbara Starr at the pentagon and Suzanne Malveaux on capitol hill. We here at the white house first heard of this during a brief news conference, a briefing here with kellyanne conway. Last question was about an evacuation at the capitol which i dont believe has been confirmed. However, what we do know is that there has been this situation involving an aircraft that has entered restricted air space. Joe, hold that thought there. Often security authorities will act with an abundance of caution. We have Barbara Starr at the pentagon coming up live now. Barbara learning from defense officials that this aircraft not known to be hostile at this time. Barbara, tell us what youre hearing. Jim, a defense official has just told us they do not believe at this time this unidentified aircraft is hostile. But nonetheless, washington is always sensitive to these issues and they immediately engage in their standard procedures. So often what happens is there are military aircraft in the National Capital region on standby at all times and they go up and look at what this aircraft may be doing. They look for tail number so they can identify it. They try and signal the aircraft that it is in restricted air space and it must turn around and leave immediately. They can do this, the military pilots, by essentially maneuvering their own aircraft, waving their wings at the unidentified aircraft, flashing lights, signaling, trying to reach them by radio communications. Everything they can to ensure whatever pilot may be up there, civilian pilot knows they are in the wrong place. And they must turn around immediately. What we do know is a highlevel interagency Conference Call under way at this time. They are monitoring the situation trying to identify the aircraft. And trying to find out exactly what is going on. Okay. So theres a lot of concern but pretty standard protocols at this time, jim. Were learning and can report this now that military aircraft have scrambled to respond. And we should note and you know this well, a lot of this is the legacy of 9 11. These protocols are in place to operate out of an abundance of caution so they can react quickly. When you say its not known that the plane is hostile at this time. Are you saying defense officials have made a judgment its not hostile or they do not know that there is hostile intent . What our understanding is right now, and, of course, this can change, is right now they appear to have no information that would indicate it is hostile. Most of the time in these incidents, they are small, private planes, civilian pilots who essentially get mixed up about where the restricted air space is. They may not have read the latest bulletins from the faa, and these small planes often just simply wander in, frankly, to restricted air space. Even if they may be trying to test the boundaries of it, even if its maybe deliberate, they dont see hostile intent but thats exactly why the u. S. Military scrambles aircraft and sends them up there to have a look at this, trying to identify exactly whats happening. As we learned on 9 11, if they arent up in the air quickly, they cant react. The planes on that day were up too late. We have news coming out of the white house. Well bring joe johns back. I understand the lockdown on the white house has now been lifted . Thats right. The lockdown has been lifted. People are being allowed back out on the grounds freely, and starting to get back to normal here. Obviously, as you said, abundance of caution. I know back during the Ronald Reagan funeral, there was an evacuation of the u. S. Capitol. And another lockdown because of a plane flying into restricted airspace. If i remember, that was the governor of kentucky whose pilot had strayed too far into restricted air space. Abundance of caution, and its looking pretty good here from the capitol. Okay. There you have it. Momentary, for minutes, concern at the white house but now that lockdown is lifted. Again, this appears to be a case of an abundance of caution. Weve seen cases like this before where pilots make a mistake. They dont know where the restricted air space is around washington. They find themselves inside it. We should feel comfortable knowing the military is able to notice this and react very quickly. We do have Suzanne Malveaux on the hill where there was also for a moment concern there. And i believe the possibility of a lockdown. But are you hearing similarly there, suzanne, that the threat is gone now . Yes, jim, we got the all clear probably about five minutes ago from a u. S. Capitol police source. Were on the third floor of the capitol on the senate side in the russell building. We were able to go out into the balcony and see for ourselves that constitution avenue was closed for a time, about 30 minutes or so. Closed to traffic right outside of the building. There was also a helicopter that was hovering above the court area in front of the Supreme Court. But according to our u. S. Capitol police source, what was happening was that they were what they call an air condition, as you know, aircraft that was in the area that they could not communicate with. It had violated the air space around this area, very sensitive. And so it was a code orange is what im told. The codes go from green at normal, yellow, monitoring the situation, orange, a heightened state of alert. Red is when we would have evacuated. There was no evacuation here. There was no shelter in place. We were inside the building. So they allowed us to stay, but they were preventing people from coming inside of the capitol. And thats what happens when its a code orange. We were just told 5, 10 minutes ago it had gone back to a code yellow and has since cleared. The headline there, the all clear at the capitol. All clear at the white house. This appears to have been a false alarm, but, again, we should feel comfortable knowing that they react very quickly to aircraft like this who stray into air space where they should not be. Shows how quickly they can respond in the event of a genuine threat. The headline there, the lockdown now lifted on the white house and capitol hill. Well bring you more information as we have it. Conspiracy, obstruction of Justice Campaign finance violations, money laundering. Investigators are looking into all of this in their investigation of Rudy Giuliani and his associates. And hes not going quietly. The fired former Navy Secretary Richard Spencer speaking out after a stunning twist in the case of a navy s. E. A. L. Accused of war crimes. His message to the president , ahead. Plus, they spent 36 years in prison for a murder they did not commit. Today, three baltimore men walking free. Hear from them just ahead. As a more secure diaper closure. There were babies involved. And they werent saying much. Thats what we do at 3m, we listen to people, even those who dont have a voice. We are people helping people. It also has the highest growth in manufacturing jobs in the us. Its a competition for the talent. Employees need more than just a paycheck. You definitely want to take advantage of all the benefits you can get. 2 3 of employees said that the workplace is an important source for personal savings and protection solutions. The workplace should be a source of financial security. Keeping your people happy is what keeps your people. Thats Financial Wellness. Put your employees on a path to Financial Wellness with prudential. The holidays are here and so is tmobiles newest, most powerful signal. And we want to keep you connected to those you love, with the new iphone 11. So tmobile is giving you an iphone 11 on us for each new line of unlimited. For yourself, or up to a family of four. Keep your family connected, and hurry into tmobile today, to get up to four iphone 11s on us. Only at tmobile. Its the kay black friday event. Save up to 60 on black friday specials like this threepiece diamond set, under onehundred dollars or this diamond ring, under twothousand dollars every best gift ever. Begins with kay. A lot will happen in your life. Wrinkles just wont. Neutrogena® rapid wrinkle repairs dermproven retinol works so fast, it takes only one week to reveal younger looking skin. Neutrogena® hi dad. No. Edont try to get up. Hi, im julie, a right at home caregiver. And if id been caring for toms dad, i would have noticed some dizziness that could lead to balance issues. Thats because im trained to report any changes in behavior, no matter how small, so tom could have peace of mind. Well be right there. We have to go. Hey, tom. You should try right at home. Theyre great for us. The right care. Right at home. Federal prosecutors are looking at a wide range of charges for associates of Rudy Giuliani. Subpoenas undicate the charges of money laundering, conspiracy, Campaign Finance violations are under consideration. This is all part of the federal investigation into giulianis consulting firm. At this time giuliani says hes not heard himself from prosecutors. He denies any wrongdoing. Joined by kara. So these charges, do they relate purely to his associates, fruman and parnas or might they include giuliani as well . Weve seen a subpoena sent to one possible witness. In the subpoena theyre asking for information about this persons communications with lev parnas and igor fruman but also any connections with giuliani and his firm giuliani partners. Theyre specifically asking about any actual or potential payments or any agreements that may have been done with giuliani or his firm. That indicates theres an interest specifically in any business dealings. And as we know giuliani was paid half a Million Dollars by a company set up by lev parnas. You can see that prosecutors are trying to better understand the relationship between these men and any money flows that may have existed between the men. Concern here is that his partners fruman and parnas might flip on him to protect themselves but might then provide information thats useful to prosecutors against giuliani. Is that a genuine concern now . I think it is. Weve seen from lev parnas be outspoken, that he wants to tell his story. Hes made overtures to the impeachment investigators saying hed be willing to provide information. There are reports theyve turned over documents, audio recordings, other details. So lev parnas Team Definitely is making this overture that he wants to tell his story. We dont know how much he has. We dont know what is corroborated. So we dont know how good of a witness he is. Theres an indication from him he wants to. Igor frumans team has been quiet. They could also be doing things behind the scenes but not telegraphing it. Its hard to know at this point where this is going to shake out. Another story, i understand cnn has learned that david pecker, the head of the national enquirer, close friend of the prrkts spoke with the distriman district attorneys office. Theyre investigating the hush money payments made to silence the two women who alleged affairs with the president. There was the federal investigation. Now the Manhattan Das Office is looking to see if any state laws were violated in the process of those payments. So they interviewed david pecker last month. David pecker is a longtime friend of the president s. Hes done these catch and kill deals. He was involved in the payments to these two women either directly or indirectly. He has a lot of knowledge about what the strategy was. So prosecutors have met with him at the end of october. They are expected to meet with him again. He did have a Cooperation Agreement with the federal prosecutor. So this is a relationship where we do see, you know, the tables have turned. A longtime friend and protector of the president. Now hes cooperating with this investigation. That should be a worry to the president. Kara, thanks. We have shan wu back to help put this into context. As a lawyer, if you have a subpoena that asks about communications with giuliani, does that indicate as a prosecutor that you suspect giuliani committed crimes here . Well, if i was the prosecutor making a statement, i wouldnt use the word i suspect him quote unquote but he is certainly what they call a subject of the investigation. Thats kind of one category down from being the target. Thats going to give him small comfort that hes not named at this point because hes unquestionably a subject. Also from a prosecutors standpoint, he should be worried that they havent talked to him yet. Hes putting it out there. They havent contacted me yet. Well, investigations, prosecutions work their way in from the outside down to the inside. If hes at the center, theyre not going to talk to him until theyve talked to everybody else. So all those things are kind of warning signs for mayor giuliani. Now, when mayor giuliani says that he has insurance, youve heard that comment. Is he saying he believes the president will pardon him . Is that your read . That could be the read. He may also mean that he has information that could be damaging to the president or that he has information that hes certain will basically clear him of any wrongdoing. And its probably that latter, that hes implying with that. And giuliani likes to place a lot of emphasis on the idea that hes a zealous advocate. His defense names many people as his clients and so his problem here is if these folks, if parnas was his client as hes said at some point, he has no privilege there because that privilege is parnas privilege, not his. So his client wants to help the client themselves and roll over on giuliani, he cant do anything to prevent that. Shan wu, its going to be an interesting case to follow. Thanks very much. Theres turmoil, hard questions in the pentagon. Fired Navy Secretary Richard Spencer may be out of a job but hes noout of things to say about what really happened in the case of the navy s. E. A. L. Eddie gallagher and his concerns about the president s involvement. Well have more. And were moments from the opening bell on wall street. The markets look to start the trading day flat after the dow, nasdaq and s p 500 all closed at record highs once again. Plus weve just learned treasure secretary Steve Mnuchin had a phone call hours with the chinese vice premier. The u. S. china trade war. Does this mean theyre making progress . Well have more. At leaf blowers. You should be mad your neighbor always wants to hang out. And you should be mad your smart fridge is unnecessarily complicated. Make ice. Making ice. But youre not mad because you have e trade which isnt complicated. Their tools make trading quicker and simpler so you can take on the markets with confidence. Dont get mad get e trade and start Trading Commission free today. D and you wrapped your arms aaround me for days after being a part of millions of love stories. At kay, weve learned the most important love story. Will always be your own. Every yes. Oh my gosh, yes. Begins with kay. Get zero down special financing with the kay jewelers Long Live Love credit card. Too many afterparties. New neutrogena® bright boost with dullnessfighting neoglucosamine. Boosts cell turnover by 10 times for instantly brighter skin. Bright boost neutrogena®. You may have gingivitis. When you brush, and the clock could be ticking towards bad breath, receding gums, and possibly. Tooth loss. Help turn back the clock on gingivitis with parodontax. Leave bleeding gums behind. Parodontax. Experience the power of sanctuary at the lincoln wish list sales event. Sign and drive off in a new lincoln with zero down, zero due at signing, and a complimentary first months payment. Wthats why xfinity hasu made taking your internetself. And tv with you a breeze. Really . Yup. You can transfer your Service Online in about a minute. You can do that . Yeah. And with twohour Service Appointment windows, its all on your schedule. Awesome. So while moving may still come with its share of headaches. No kidding. Were doing all we can to make moving simple, easy, awesome. Go to xfinity. Com moving to get started. Fired Navy Secretary spencer is defending his actions in the case of s. E. A. L. Eddie gallagher. He posed for a photo with a dead isis fighter. President trump repeatedly intervened in the case, pardoning gallagher as well as reversing the demotion. Spencer does not agree in very strong terms with the president s repeated intervention. What message does that send to the troops . Well, what message does it send . That you can get away with things. We have to have good order and discipline. Its the backbone of what we do. I dont think he understands the full definition of a war fighter. A war fighter is a profession of arms and a profession of arms has standards. Joining me is cnn pentagon correspondent Barbara Starr. You hear spencer there in strong terms. Thats a sentiment thats not confined to the former navy secreta secretary. What is the reaction to the end result of this case . Well, i think that, you know, there is it is fair to say that there is some dismay about all of it. An awful lot of Senior Leaders here in the pentagon would like to put this behind them and move forward rather tharnn, as they say, concentrating on the fate of one single military person, eddie gallagher. They do understand what the Navy Secretary is saying about a good order in discipline. That is something they are concerned about that this case does not alter that fundamental foundation of the u. S. Military. But there is also concern that spencer went outside the box. That he went to the president behind the pentagons back to try and cut a deal on all of this to preserve gallaghers s. E. A. L. Status. Have a little more of a listen to what spencer has to say and what defense secretary mark espers response to the situation is. I will take the bad on me for not letting him know i did that. But he was completely informed as to this because his chief of staff was briefed on it. Secretary spencer broke these rules. Thats lost my trust in confidence. Contrary to the narrative that some have put forward in the meedia, this is not about eddie gallagher. Its about secretary spencer and the chain of command. Now even this morning, top officials at the pentagon are disputing spencers account and saying neither the defense secretary or his chief of staff knew that spencer was going to the white house to try and precook a deal that would have preserved gallaghers s. E. A. L. Status. That would have been the impartial review would have been anything but. Thats key there because what spencer has said is that, okay, yes, esper was traveling overseas. I didnt speak directly with him about this contact with the white house but i did keep his chief of staff in the loop. The pentagon is saying thats not true . The pentagon is saying the chief of staff did not know the specifics of what spencer was proposing that would have been the deal where they would have had an impartial review of gallagher, but ahead of time there would have been an agreement that his s. E. A. L. Status still would have been preserved. They didnt know thats what spencer was proposing. A lot of conflicting comments and versions of this. Barbara starr from the pentagon, thanks very much. Theres stunning testimony from 12 witnesses over two weeks. Did the impeachment hearings move the needle for voters . New cnn polls out this morning. Well break those numbers down. Be powerful. Be the diamond you are. Find dazzling deals on diamonds and more. The zales black friday sale. Get 3050 off everything, including this stunning 7carat diamond bracelet. Exclusively at zales, the diamond store. Including this stunning 7carat diamond bracelet. For powerful relief from cold and flu symptoms without a prescription, try theraflu multisymptom. Theraflu dissolves in seconds, so its ready to work before your first sip, and absorbs quickly to target and attack 8 cold and flu symptoms fast. Try theraflu. Im max, i was diagnosed with aplastic anemia and if i didnt find a donor, i probably wouldnt be here right now. Be the match uses the power of the Cisco Network to match donors with patients faster than ever, saving lives like maxs. Me and dylan are dna twins. Dylans like my brother. Cisco. The bridge to possible. only tylenol® rapid release gels have laser drilled holes. They release medicine fast, for fast pain relief. Tylenol®. Hi, my name is sam davis and im going to tell you about exciting plans available to anyone with medicare. Many plans provide broad coverage and still may save you money on monthly premiums and Prescription Drugs. With original medicare, youre covered for hospital stays and Doctor Office visits, but you have to meet a deductible for each and then youre still responsible for 20 of the cost. Next, lets look at a Medicare Supplement plan. As you can see, they cover the same things as original medicare and they also cover your medicare deductibles and coinsurance. But they often have higher monthly premiums and no Prescription Drug coverage. Now, lets take a look at humanas Medicare Advantage plans. With a humana medicare plan, hospital stays, Doctor Office visits and medicare deductibles are covered. And, of course, most humana Medicare Advantage plans include Prescription Drug coverage. In fact, in 2018, humana Medicare Advantage Prescription Drug plan members saved an estimated 7400, on average, on their prescription costs. Most humana Medicare Advantage plans help you stay active and keep fit by including a Silver Sneakers Fitness Program at no extra cost. And, you may be able to save on dental and vision expenses, because coverage is now included with most humana Medicare Advantage plans. You get all this coverage for as low as a zero dollar monthly plan premium in many areas. And your doctor and hospital may already be a part of humanas large network. If you want the facts, call right now for the free decision guide from humana. There is no obligation, so call the number on your screen right now to see if your doctor is in our network; to find out if you can save on your prescriptions and to get our free decision guide. Licensed humana sales agents are standing by, so call now. A lot will happen in your life. Wrinkles just wont. Neutrogena® rapid wrinkle repairs dermproven retinol works so fast, it takes only one week to reveal younger looking skin. Neutrogena® some democrats have claimed the last two weeks of public impeachment hearings were convincing in their case against the president. Do voters agree . What do the polls show . 50 of americans say the president should be impeached and removed from office. However, that number is the same as in october before those public hearings began. With me now, cnn politics reporter and cillizza. They were placing a lot of faith in public hearings to move the poll. According to cnns poll, they havent. Did those hearings go how you wanted them to . They would say not in our wildest dreams did we think Gordon Sondland would say, yes, there was a quid pro quo. That those hearings went better than they could have imagined. So i would say democrats would have been much happier if those numbers moved up five or ten points but id also caution that we, people like you and i are following this extremely closely. The average person is gearing up for thanksgiving, looking ahead to christmas. And so i think theres an element to which we have to take a big cleansing breath and think to yourself, its possible that this will take a little bit longer to seep into the body politic, the average voter and then give it two, three, four weeks and see where were at. Theres also signs out there that folks are running out of patience. Lets look at independents and republicans here. Independents, of course, key group here that their support for impeachment is down actually from october by three points. Within the margin of error. And we should note, among republicans, up to 10 . Only 10 but, heck, 10 of republicans think the president or republicans should be impeached and removed from office. So i hear your point there, but were also entering a period now where you may not get any new information. Unless the courts force key witnesses to testify. Thats exactly right. I would look at those numbers among independents, republicans, democrats, a little bit as statistical noise. Theyre up a little, down a little. But to reiterate and to your point, democrats, if you asked democrats last friday, do they think that what happened over the last week and then the two days before that, do they think that will move the needle in terms of Public Opinion on impeachment . They would say 100 , yes. So that is absolutely true. All i am suggesting is, lets not assume that right afterward everyone is fully aware of it. To your point, though, youre right. Theres not likely we dont have another set of public impeachment hearings scheduled. So whats the points that have been made have been made. Its not clear if it will be revisited. And to your point, if you look at the figures going back a few months, it was 36 a few weeks ago. Its been on the rise. Its up to 50 now. Does it move higher . Chris cillizza, always great to have you on. Republican senator john kennedy is now walking back, reversing comments he made supporting a debunct Conspiracy Theory that claims ukraine meddled in the elections. Was it russia or ukraine . I dont know. Neither do you nor do any of us. The entire Intelligence Community says it was russia. Right. But it could also be ukraine. Well, republicans, as you may have noticed, have used that Conspiracy Theory as justification for President Trump withholding military aid to ukraine saying he had cause to investigate that interference. Last night after facing serious backlash even from some of his republican counterparts, the louisiana senator reversed his answer here on cnn. Chris is right. I was wrong. The only evidence i have, and i think its overwhelming, is that it was russia who tried to hack the dnc computer. Ive seen no indication that ukraine tried to do it. Although kennedy himself walked back that part about ukraine hacking the dnc server, he says he Still Believes ukraine could have meddled in the election. Weve heard that from a number of other republicans. Intelligence officials have concluded conspiracy theories pushed by President Trump and several republican lawmakers are part of a Russian Campaign that this is russian prop ganda to in effect shift blame for 2016 election interference away from moscow onto others just to raise questions to muddy the water. You heard fiona hill testify to that very much so under oath just last week. Well stay on that story. Another story were following this morning, three men from baltimore are walking free after spending 36 years in prison for a crime they did not commit. Youll hear from them coming up. May your holidays glow bright and all your dreams take flight. Lease the c 300 sedan for just 399 a month at the mercedesbenz winter event. Hurry in today. It also has the highest growth in manufacturing jobs in the us. Its a competition for the talent. Employees need more than just a paycheck. You definitely want to take advantage of all the benefits you can get. 2 3 of employees said that the workplace is an important source for personal savings and protection solutions. The workplace should be a source of financial security. Keeping your people happy is what keeps your people. Thats Financial Wellness. Put your employees on a path to Financial Wellness with prudential. Its the kay black friday event. Save up to 60 on black friday specials like this threepiece diamond set, under onehundred dollars or this diamond ring, under twothousand dollars every best gift ever. Begins with kay. The holidays are here and so is tmobiles newest, most powerful signal. And we want to keep you connected to those you love, with the new iphone 11. So tmobile is giving you an iphone 11 on us for each new line of unlimited. For yourself, or up to a family of four. Keep your family connected, and hurry into tmobile today, to get up to four iphone 11s on us. Only at tmobile. You wanna see something thatamazing . Ing. Go to hilton instead of a travel site and youll experience a whole new range of emotions like. The relaxing feeling of knowing youre getting the best price. Thesell work. The utter delight of free wifi. Oh man this is the best part. Isnt that you . Yeah. And the magic power of unlocking your room with your phone. I can read minds too. Really . Book at hilton. Com. If you find a lower rate, we match it and give you 25 off that stay. Expect better. Expect hilton. Thanksgiving travelers, i know you may have been worried about this a historic winter storm will well be right back havoc for tense of millions of people this holiday week. Live look on your left there, as heavy snow wallops the rockies. You can see the cars getting buried there, dicey conditions threaten travel plans from california to michigan. Airports like denver, an important hub for a lot of flights cnn is in denver, hundreds of flights are cancelled. Tell us if travelers will see any relief in the next couple of days . Reporter in the next couple of days, jim, nearly 500 flights cancelled. This is a travel nightmare two days before thanksgiving. We are in downtown denver. Take a look at these conditions. The state Capital Building behind me, you can barely see it. Several inches of snow on the ground already. Theyre predicting about 12to18 inches of snow. This is just the metro area. Up north in the foothills of the mountain, 15 to 30 inches predicted. Wind gusts up to 45 miles an hour. That creates for some very dangerous conditions. The National Weather service telling folks to try to stay off the road because some parts of colorado will be completely impassable if you dont have to get in the car. Dont do it. Its sim mr. I too dangerous. Colorado, of course, can handle this because of the holiday season, its making stuff a lot more difficult for folks trying to get home to see their families, for the airport, specifically, its the wind thats the major concern. They got a lot of equipment on the ground in order to be able to clear those runways. The wind is a big concern. Thats why people are being told to try to come one alternate plans. Major airlines are offering waivers for today so people can rebook for free and get home, im one of those people trying to get home to new york tomorrow. I dont know if i will be able to get. Unof the many watching the snowstorms as it unfolds. I wish you luck. I wish all those travelers luck as well. Lucie kavanaugh, thank you so much. Three men were wrongfully convicted and spent 30 years in prison. The men were teenagers sentenced to life if prison. Cnns britain joins me now, what was the key . One of these men filed an information request upon the his own behalf, which is just incredible i think and really that put hands on this exculpatory everyday in the case the judge sealed decades ago. That was the key to his and two other mens freedom. Lets go back to 1983. The three men were convicted of killing a teenager for his Georgetown University basketball jack. The smoking fun was a similar jacket found in chestnuts bedroom. It didnt though have gun or bloodshot res document his mom had a receipt for the jacket. Still the men were put behind bars. More everyday has since come to light with that filing. The men were interviewed and interrogated by police, parents rather, witnesses as well, potential witnesses of the crime were interviewed as a group and told to get their stories straight according to chestnuts lawyer. He identified another suspect was kept from the defense during the trial. So all of this was brought to the attention of the bolt mar integrity unit, which was looking at old convictions. They sat them down and threw those charges out, after 36 years behind bars, the men are now free. I am free and the people around me you see me here will help pe get through all this. They never stopped fighting for me. And ive never stopped fighting. This is the first time i have been able hug my son in about 20some years. This is wonderful. God bless and god is good all the time. Not sometime but all the time. There is no current law in maryland to xen compensate those wrongfully convicted. The state Attorney Says she will advocate and the men were arrested on thanksgiving day ripped from their families. This thanksgiving gym family is where they will spend. It makes you so happy at the same time. Its a clear misjustice. How about the prosecutors . Will they face kwejs consequences . The state attorney, the suspect i was referring to also died and we actually tried to track down the lead version and we havent gotten any calls back. It really is so frustrating, but good that they get to be home. 36 years later, thanks, very much. The department of justice is filing paper to appeal, this after a federal judge says the former White House Counsel Don Mcgahn must fly to testify in the impeachment inquiry. We will talk about the next steps. Thats coming up. Now in one pot, and with tendercrisp technology, you can cook foods that are crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. The ninja foodi Pressure Cooker, the Pressure Cooker that crisps. loud fan noise children playing Music Building experience the power of sanctuary at the lincoln wish list sales event. Sign and drive off in a new lincoln with zero down, zero due at signing, and a complimentary first months payment. Its the kay black friday event. Save up to 60 on black friday specials like this threepiece diamond set, under onehundred dollars or this diamond ring, under twothousand dollars every best gift ever. Begins with kay. Good morning, im jim scuitto, poppy harlow has the day off the. This morning they are hitting the pause button while they appeal to a higher court to have don mcgahn testify. The house agreed to a 7day delay. The judgeul