Well talk about all of it tonight and then some starting with new cnn reporting on concerns among people close to the president about what he might do next. Cnns jim acosta joins us now with the very latest. Jim. Reporter yeah. What is the latest on how President Trump wants to handle the Senate Impeachment trial . Reporter john, ive been talking to my sources. Weve all been talking to our sources over here at the white house all day long. The latest is that it sounds as though the president is coming around to this idea advanced by Senate Republicans that a lengthy trial filled with witnesses is just too dangerous to his political future. You know, hes gone through this impeachment process, and as painful has it has been and as much as he wants to be exonerated and as much as, yes, he wants to bring in witnesses, he wants the whistleblower, he wants hunter biden and so on, Mitch Mcconnell, lindsey graham, his allies in the senate have impressed upon him and his top aides over here, people like pat cipollone, the white house counsel, that thats too dangerous a road to go down. It sounds as though tonight the president is listening. The question is whether or not hes preparing to leave joint base andrews in just a few moments to head to maralago for the holidays. The question is what happens when he gets to maralago because as we know hell be meeting with friends, confidants, longtime outside advisers and so on. The donald trump that emerges from that period of time may be different than the one right now. But for right now it sounds as though he is listening to these words of caution coming out of the republicans in the senate. Yeah, because people in the senate dont necessarily want Mick Mulvaney or john bolton there because who knows what theyll testify to. The president can get himself worked up into a lather down at maralago. Is the public posture, whats being said outside, the same thing as whats being said behind closed door . Reporter the public posture is the president is not distracted by this, that hes focused on the work and so on. Bologna. The president is obsessed with his impeachment. He is fixated on this. He is angered by this. His own daughter, ivanka trump, conceded to cbs in an interview earlier today that hes angry about all of this. And so, yes, i mean the president is looking for some kind of vindication at the end of this process. The problem for the president is he is not going to remove this stain from his legacy. He is not going to unimpeach himself, and that is why republicans, his allies in the senate and so on, have been trying to say, listen, just get through the senate trial process, and you still have a chance and a good chance according to a lot of his allies and confidants in getting reelected. That is where his allies and his advisers are hoping he will focus his energy on as we head into the new year. But no question about it, john. One of the things weve noticed all week long talking to our sources, talking to officials inside the white house and people who speak to the president is that he is unnerved by this. This is embedded in his skin, and he knows that history has rendered a very painful judgment, and it is one that is going to be attached to his name, you know, in the history books from here on out. The question is how it all affects him and affects his psyche moving forward, and i think at this point hes trying to listen to these advisers saying be cautious. You can make matters worse for yourself if you try to push this too far, john. Jim acosta at the white house, thanks so much for being with us. More now on the maneuvering between the house and senate, pelosi and mcconnell, and of course the president. Joining us, a juror when and if it comes to that. Senator richard blumenthal, member of the Judiciary Committee and a democrat from connecticut. Thank you so much for being with us. Will there be a senate trial . There will be a senate trial. It is required by the constitution. The issue of when the articles of impeachment will be sent to the senate is a decision for nancy pelosi to make and very understandably she wants some assurance that it will be full and fair, not the sham and charade that Mitch Mcconnell is apparently going to give the president. And whats striking about the report that youve just heard, excellent reporting by jim acosta, is the assumption by the president that he can set the terms of his own trial. And that assumption is well warranted by Mitch Mcconnell saying hes going to take his cue from the white house. He has said theres no chance that the president will be removed, and he in effect is making himself and his republican colleagues complicit in the coverup, the denial of documents and witnesses that are necessary for a full, fair proceeding, and thats why we are insisting that there be some agreement on those documents and witnesses before, not during the trial. Youre insisting, but what if Mitch Mcconnell does not agree . Would you support House Speaker nancy pelosi holding on to the articles of impeachment indefinitely . No one wants an indefinite delay. Neither i nor, i believe, nancy pelosi. There will be a trial. But there is a court of appeals to this proceeding. Its the electorate, the court of public opinion. And right now the numbers in your own polls are absolutely staggering. 71 of the American People want documents and witnesses as they would in any trial. More than 60 of republicans. So my colleagues are going to be going home these next two weeks, and theyre going to be hearing, in effect, those numbers. And i believe theyre going to have to think not only about the judgment of history but about their constituents judgments, and i really feel they will be complicit in the continuing threat to our democracy, our Democratic Institutions if they fail to provide a full, fair hearing. Have you heard from your colleague Susan Collins or Senator Cory Gardner or mitt romney, some of these republicans who might be incl e inclined to push for witnesses . Do you have any indication that they would side with democrats in calling for a trial with witnesses . Theres no question, john, and that is the question of the day, that they are contemplating seriously and considering how this trial has to be conducted. Mitch mcconnell is nothing without his enablers. He needs those 51 votes, and ive been talking to anywhere from five to ten of my colleagues directly or indirectly who are seriously considering how they will be haunted by this decision if they deny a full, fair trial. And ill just be very blunt. Theres a saying that courage is contagious, and so is cowardice. They need to step forward, and i hope that theyll be hearing from their constituents over these next couple weeks. But so far and i have to let you go here. So far you havent seen any sign that one of them will step forward and say they will want witnesses, have you . I have seen signs that one or more will step forward. I hope that courage will be contagious. Ive talked directly to a number who are seriously considering, without committing, that they will ask that there be witnesses and documents. And remember, john, one last point. The witnesses that we have asked to testify have direct knowledge. They have the information and evidence that republicans themselves have said they want to hear. These witnesses and documents were sought by the house. As a prosecutor, i would say right now the evidence is overwhelming. Id rest my case. But the American People deserve to hear these witnesses and documents. Senator richard blumenthal, hope you have a wonderful new year. Thank you so much for being with us. Same to you. Thank you. More on what is next. Were joined now by senior political analyst david gergen and a bona fide impeachment expert, jeffrey engel, founding director of the center for president ial history at methodist university. With Speaker Pelosi and Mitch Mcconnell, you really do have two of the preeminent masters of congressional strategy. They are at the top of the top historically speaking. How do you think this ends . Its not clear. Youre absolutely right about these two veterans. Theyre both wily, and very strategic and tough. They do not give in easily, and youve seen that this past week. Mitch mcconnell hasnt been moved at all, and nancy pelosi is hanging right in there. Both of them have a lot of support in their caucuses. How this ends, listen, i do think theres legitimacy to what nancy pelosi is trying to do, certainly in the short term, its to shine a light on the unfairness of the people on the democratic side who have never been given access to documents, who have never been able to interview the key witnesses, that this should not be resolved without those people coming forward. I think they have a very good claim on that. I also think its important for nancy pelosi to know what the process is going to be because as someone pointed out to me today, a good lawyer pointed out to me today, if there are going to be witnesses, you want managers on the democratic side who are good at crossexamination. If on the other hand there are not going to be witnesses, then you want lawyers who can make powerful arguments because the oral argument becomes everything. So thats one reason for waiting. But in the long run, i think this has to come to a conclusion. I do not think the democrats can stand out there for week after week. Theyre going to look too cute, and the country is going to want to wrap this up. I do think theyve sacrificed if theyre not careful, sacrificed some of the high ground. They do have a couple weeks over the holidays where there wont be as much pressure. A couple of weeks to take a breath. You know, step back and take a breath. Jeffrey, one of the things weve learned over the last few weeks and months is how few words are actually in the constitution about how all of this is supposed to be done precisely. Just hypothetically speaking, what if nancy pelosi holds on to the articles of impeachment and doesnt transmit them to the senate . What happens then . Nothing. Nothing happens, which is to say we live in this perpetual limbo of knowing the president of the United States has been impeached. Weve all actually seen it with our own eyes on two articles, but it would not move anywhere and wed have this political albatross hanging over our heads for at least the next eight, nine months until the election. I think theres a real sense in which Neither Party wants to have this discussion going forward. The question is if were going to have to rip the bandaid one way or another, knowing the numbers really suggest that donald trump is going to be not convicted at this point, the question is which direction do you rip . Do you want one that actually shows the American People what a full trial looks like, or do you want one that gets over quickly knowing that the end result is going to be the same . Of course there have been witnesses before. Andrew johns Andrew Johnsons impeachment trial, bill clintons impeachment trial. The precedent is there, but that doesnt always matter in these situations. David, the president of the United States on his way to maralago. As weve noted before, he can get himself worked up down there. What do you think happens to him over these next two weeks as he stares this in the face . Terrific question. I think its exactly the right question to pursue. Listen, in the nixon case and in the clinton case, the past two cases of impeachment or impeachment proceedings, the proceedings brought an end to the controversy. Richard nixon left office, and we opened a new chapter in american history. And bill clinton essentially was very contrite. You know, he went back to work, and that ended the clinton thing. In this case, i think donald trump is going to emerge very differently from nixon and clinton. Hes not going to be contrite. Hes not going to take responsibility. I think hes going to be embittered. Hes going to be embittered for the rest of the time he is in office, and that makes it more difficult. But i also think that if he comes out of this, you know, feeling vindicated, hes going to be emboldened, and hes going to be doing things and saying go away, im going to do what the hell i like right now. That might be more dangerous. That brings me to my last question for you, professor, which is that he is the first impeached president to run for reelection. Any sense of how it will play into it . Will it even be an issue ten months from now . Personally i think its actually not going to be an issue. I think we have to remember the American People are most likely going to make their decision on who the next president will be or whether trump gets a second term based on things that happened in september and particularly october. But this really does, i think, cast a real shadow over the entire election in both directions. If i could drill down for a second into the question of witnesses, which is clearly one thats going to be coming up as the Senate Debates what the rules should be. Theres a real fundamental difference between the witnesses that appeared in the clinton case and the witnesses that were talking about here because in the clinton case, everyone agreed upon the fact and they were really there just to present the case to the senators in dramatic fashion whereas in this case we dont know what all the facts are. So those witnesses are there to discover information, not just to present a case. Jeffrey engel, david gergen, fascinating situation we find ourselves in. Thank you so much for being with us tonight. Thank you, john. Have a wonderful holiday. Next, a rare dissenting voice in the president s base calls for the president s removal from office. That, the backlash to it including from the president to himself, and what it says about the president s political standing. And later, new reporting on just how influential Vladimir Putin may have been on the president s thinking about ukraine and all that its led up to. That and more when 360 continues. With advil, you have power over pain, so the whole world looks different. The unbeatable strength of advil. What pain . Too shabby too much i can rent this . For that price . Absolutely. Its just right book your just right rental at thrifty. Com. Ladies and gentlemen mini is a different ikind of car. T for a different kind of drive. Ladies and gentlemen for the drive to create a new kind of family car, that became a new kind of race car. For the drive to rebel, zag. For the drive thats inside you. And inside us. Thats the drive under the hood of every mini. Because every mini is. For the drive. A president who abuses power. And obstructs justice. The impeachment of donald j. Trump. He was supposed to protect our constitution. Not trample on it by asking Foreign Countries to undermine our democracy for his personal political gain. Trump broke his oath to america. Members of the house and senate must now do their constitutional duty. If you agree, sign our petition at need to impeach. Com need to impeach is responsible for the content of this advertising. We need a solution. Ut their phones down. Introducing. Smartdogs. The first dogs trained to train humans. Stopping drivers from liking. Selfieing. And whatever this is. Available to the public. Never. Smartdogs are not the answer. But geico has a simple tip. Turn on do not disturb while driving mode. Brought to you by geico. Asbut when your team is always dealing with device setups, app updates, and support calls. You can never seem to get anywhere. Thats why Dell Technologies created unified workspace, powered by vmware. A revolutionary solution that lets you deploy, manage, support and secure all your devices from the cloud. So you can stop going in circles, and start moving forward. President trump spent the day not turning the other cheek. He lashed out several times at a magazine, which isnt exactly unusual for him except it wasnt Time Magazine he was targeting for putting someone else on the cover, for instance. It was christianity today, which is read by his white evangelical base, for calling for his removal from office. Editor in chief mark galli writes, quote, to use an old cliche, its time to call a spade a spade, to say that no matter how many hands we win in this political poker game, were playing with a stacked deck of gross immorality and ethical incompetence. Galli also writes, his twitter feed alone with its habitual string of miss characterizations, lies and slanders is the near perfect example of a human being who is morally lost and confused. And as if on cue, the president responded. Quote, a farleft magazine or very progressive as some would call it, which has been doing poorly and hasnt been involved with the billy graham family for many years, christianity today knows nothing about reading a perfect transcript of a routine phone call and would rather have a radical left nonbelieve, who wants to take your religion and your guns, than donald trump as your president. By e. T. , the president meant c. T. , but, hey, he was rolling. This afternoon, the president picked up with this. I guess the magazine christianity today is looking for Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders, or those of the socialist communist bent to guard their religion. How about sleepy joe . The fact is no president has ever done what i have done for evangelicals or religion itself. Big name leaders are circling the wagon, all speaking out in defense of the president and denouncing the magazine. Mark galli joins me now. Mark, you have had one heck of a day. We spoke this morning. I actually had the pleasure of reading you the president s first attack on you. There have been many more as the day has gone on. What do you make of his response and the reaction . Well, im just trying to do my part so he doesnt talk about the failed cnn network, so i hope youll appreciate my work here. Why do you think no, seriously why do you think you got under his skin so much . Well, i think because he imagines that c. T. Magazine is attempting to speak for all evangelicals. One of the things hes mistaken about is what c. T. Magazine is and who its read by. So, for example, it is not a leftist magazine by any stretch of the imagination. Its a center magazine, center left, and the editor in chief happens to be center right. Its not a political magazine. Its a religious magazine. He was acting like we had a political vendetta against him. You know, the whole point of the editorial was to raise the level of conversation above the political fray to try to talk about that in moral and ethical terms, terms like a magazine like christianity today knows something about. No, we dont enter the political fray when we dont have to. But every once in a while when the situation is grave and we think we need to speak out, we do so. But were by far and away not a political magazine. And were also, just to be clear, were not a magazine of the evangelical right. The people on the far evangelical right who are very much protrump, they dont either us either. We dont get rid by the evangelical far left or the evangelical far right. As i said, were centrist. So he may be worried that we will influence the far right. I dont imagine that thats going to happen. But i do think one thing is clearly happening is that im encouraging readers in our orbit and around our orbit because they have vaguely sensed some of the things ive said in the editorial and theyre glad theres someone in the Public Square saying them. And it was the ukraine situation. It was the actions that have led to his impeachment that pushed you over the line to call for his removal. Why . What about that do you find to be, as you say, not apolitical but immoral . Well, first of all, this is a cumulative effect of his presidency, and at some point and up to this point, the argument by the evangelical right, many of my good friends who are sincere believers and this is how they make their political judgment. They say, youve got to balance things. On the one hand, trump is strongly working for religious freedom, especially for christians overseas. Hes strongly prolife, and the justices hes appointed. We can put up with or ignore his crazy tweets and his immoral actions because on balance, were getting someone whos doing some good in the United States as far as we can tell. For me, the impeachment hearings made that argument no longer valid in this respect. I mean the mueller investigation, i found very confusing. Im not a political animal, and i had a hard time following what exactly was going on half the time. The impeachment hearings, it became Crystal Clear very quickly that donald trump, president of the United States, had used his authority to influence the leader a foreign nation to harass and harangue the president s political opponents. Thats a violation of the constitution. As such, thats immoral because the president of the United States has vowed to uphold the constitution. So that kind of clear instance i mean there have been a lot of allegations about how the president uses his authority, and a lot of them are credible, but theyre not just unambiguous. This one was unambiguous to me, and i felt that that turned me from a person who said was sympathetic to the balance argument to the one that said it no longer applies. Mark galli, youve created quite a discussion today. I know its been a very busy and long day for you. We appreciate you being with us and we wish you a merry christmas. Thank you very much. Same to you. The Washington Post says that President Trumps Conspiracy Theory that ukraine somehow interfered in the 2016 election came from a unique source russian president Vladimir Putin. That when 360 continues. I use rakuten to get cash back instore and online. I just go to shop online with rakuten and i get cash back. I love using rakuten during the holidays, because i can get the sale and i can get cash back. All the stores are having sales, they are doing extra cash back, theres coupons. Its just deals on top of deals. Youre stacking your savings. Im definitely going to use rakuten for my holiday shopping, i got a lot of family, so i might as well get some cash back. And its so easy and the best way to start off the new year. Rack it up with rakuten, sign up today to get cash back on everything you buy. I looitaly avel. Yaaaaass. With the united explorer card, i get rewarded wherever i go. Going out for a bite. Rewarded going new places. Rewarded anytime. Rewarded getting more for getting away. Rewarded learn more at the explorer card dot com. And get. Rewarded verizons important to us because we facetime with her grandparents all the time. announcer when you have the best network, you wanna give the best network. Feliz navidad announcer this holiday, you can gift americas most Reliable Network and the latest iphone. I would probably give it to her grandparents so they can take tons of photos. My mom is amazing. If i got her one of these for christmas, shed be freaking out. announcer and now buy the latest iphone and get iphone 11 on us. Plus, get 400 when you switch. With plans starting at just 35. shrieks yeah, exciting. announcer happy holidays from the network that gives you more. Janie, come here. Check this out. Let me see. She looks. Kind of like me. Yeah. Thats because its your grandma when she was your age. Oh wow. Thats. Thats amazing. Oh and she was on the debate team. Yeah, thats probably why youre the debate queen. Mmhmm. Ill take that. Look at that smile. I have the same dimples as her. Yeah. The same placements and everything. Unbelievable. The same placements and everything. Here, it all starts withello hi . How can i help . A data plan for everyone. Everyone . Everyone. Lets send to everyone wifi up there . Uhh. Sure, why not . Howd he get out . a camera might figure it out. That was easy glad i could help. At xfinity, were here to make life simple. Easy. Awesome. So come ask, shop, discover at your local xfinity store today. And i like to question your im yoevery move. N law. Like this left turn. Its the next one. You always drive this slow . How did you make someone i love . That must be why youre always so late. I do not speed. And thats saving me cash with drivewise. My son, he did say that you were the safe option. And thats the nicest thing you ever said to me. So get allstate. Stop bossing. Where good drivers save 40 for avoiding mayhem, like me. This is my sons favorite color, you should try it. Now save even more with new lower rates. If youre looking for the source of the president s obsession with ukraine, new reporting in the Washington Post points to Vladimir Putin. Putin told me is how a former senior official says the president put it. Some perspective now from retired Army Lieutenant colonel ralph peters, a strategic analyst and author. Colonel peters, the fact that the president believes this Conspiracy Theory about ukraine, not really surprising. But if its true that one of the reasons he believes it so strongly is because putin told him it was true, putin told him so, whats your reaction to that . Putin knows what hes doing. Putin was an agent handler for the kgb. He is trained in identifying peoples vulnerabilities, their weak spots. And trump is the perfect victim, the perfect recruit as it were. You have somebody who has had financial problems, has interesting taste in women, has an ego thats easily played to, that craves praise. And so putin undoubtedly has been able to work him just brilliantly because if youre in the intelligence world or the espionage game, the best the best victim is somebody who wants to be a victim. The best victim is somebody who wants to be a victim. In other words, in somebody, you know, who is just susceptible. We hear a great deal, john, about trump wont listen to the facts. Wont is the wrong word. The correct word is cant. He cannot once trump has settled on a line of thought, an idea, a concept, whatever you want to call it, once he has committed himself to something, he has no reverse gear. And so its just impossible for him to admit hes wrong about anything. And you also hear about how he doesnt like intelligence briefings. They have to be dumbed down. He doesnt listen to the briefers. Again its a question of cant. Trump and weve all run into these people in our lives. Trump has to be the smartest person in the room. And suddenly in washington where hes dealing with genuine subject matter experts, people who have committed their entire lives to studying russia or china or whatever, hes so far out of his depth that he just cant bear it. This is a guy with an eggshell ego and, again, back to putin, putin knew exactly how to play it. Any thoughts about why hes so deferential to putin . Well, im the minority that Still Believes there probably are embarrassing tapes, certainly financial issues. But, again, he wants to believe what putin tells him. And theres a fundamental issue here where in the beginning of trumps campaign, when nobody thought he had a chance, no serious people in washington or in the academic world would bother with him. So he gets tied in with people like steve bannon and Paul Manafort and, got help us, mike flynn, an old akwancquaintance mine, all of whom were soft on russia. So trump who was never interested in foreign policy, trumps view of the world was shaped by the likes of manafort and bannon and others. And so he committed to this line of thought that, you know, russia is not so bad. Russia should be our ally. Putin gets a bad rap. The ukrainians are the villains here. And he just cannot go back from there. It is interesting, colonel, that talking about the president s allies, that they are all in on some of his ukraine theories given that they might be directly tied to Vladimir Putin. Yeah, indeed. Theres that, but also trump surrounding himself with thirdraters. Again, he has to be the big cheese. He has to be the smartest guy in the room. So if you look at the people who have been around him, with a few notable exceptions that didnt last very long, they are people who arent expert in anything except a bit of wheeling and dealing, people who embarrass the country every time they open their mouths. But at the end of the day, the reason all of this really matters, why its not just, well, ukraine wasnt perfect or whatever, it matters because next year we have a president ial election. Vladimir putin is going to pull out all the stops. Youre going to see wideranging and often innovative russian strategies, and the russians want trump reelected. Colonel peters, some sobering notions. Thanks so much for your time. Have a happy holiday. Thank you. You too. Up next, how wine caves became a hot campaign topic. Tmobile is lighting up 5g nationwide. While some 5g signals go only blocks, tmobile 5g goes miles. Beyond the big cities to the small towns. To the people. Now, millions of americans can have access to 5g on tmobile. And this is just the beginning. Tmobile, the first and only nationwide 5g network. Do your asthma symptoms ever hold you back . About 50 of people with severe asthma have too many cells called eosinophils in their lungs. Eosinophils are a key cause of severe asthma. Fasenra is designed to target and remove these cells. Fasenra is an addon injection for people 12 and up with asthma driven by eosinophils. Fasenra is not a rescue medicine or for other eosinophilic conditions. Fasenra is proven to help prevent severe asthma attacks, improve breathing, and can lower oral steroid use. Fasenra may cause allergic reactions. Get help right away if you have swelling of your face, mouth, and tongue, or trouble breathing. Dont stop your asthma treatments unless your doctor tells you to. Tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection or your asthma worsens. Headache and sore throat may occur. Havent you missed enough . Ask an asthma specialist about fasenra. If you cant afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help. With the Iowa Caucuses only weeks away, just seven candidat candidates made the cut for last nights debate. The topic of wine caves came up. Senator warren calling out Pete Buttigieg for a lavish fundraiser at a california winery. So the mayor just recently had a fundraiser that was held in a wine cave full of crystals and served 900 a bottle wine. Um, think about who comes to that. He had promised that every fundraiser he would do would be opendoor, but this one was closeddoor. You know, according to forrest magazine, im literally the only person on this stage who is not a millionaire or a billionaire. So if this is important. This is the problem with issuing purity tests you cannot yourself pass. [ applause ] if i pledge if i pledge never to be in the company of a Progressive Democratic donor, i couldnt be up here. Senator, your net worth is 100 times mine. Joining me now for their take on this, cnn contributor, New York Times oped columnist frank bruni, and cnn senior political analyst and usa today columnist kirsten powers. Frank, the piece you wrote in the New York Times this morning, the first line says does the road to the wine house run through a wine cave . I mean that was the big, big moment or the big argument at the debate was Pete Buttigieg having held a fundraiser at a wine cave in napa valley, and Elizabeth Warren, who is sort of the purity candidate, is saying that shouldnt be permissible. You shouldnt be hitting up billionaires to win the democratic primary or to win the presidency. Pete buttigieg was making the argument, you dont disarm when youre about to face donald trump. You take every ally you can get. You take money where you can get it. Thats a kind of bigger debate than just cabernet and cash. What struck me because im not sure this is the issue is going to decide the democratic primary, was the way they both went at it. You note this in your piece too. They were both at the top of their game in that exchange. If you liked Pete Buttigieg, you liked him doubly in that exchange because he was under fire and this 37yearold mayor of an indiana city was cool as a cucumber. If you liked Elizabeth Warren already, you liked her triply. And joe biden was sitting there watching the whole thing, kirsten. He has not been seen as having had strong debate performances at least by the political professionals until last night, but a lot of people look at last night and say, this was a different joe biden. What did you see there . Yeah. I think that he, in the past, has been criticized for being perhaps too rambling or not seeming enough on his game. And last night he was pretty much gaffefree. Also there often have been gafz gaffes in the other debates. So i think he was seen as gaffefree and strong and on his game. It couldnt have come at a better time, right . This is when people are just starting to focus. Hes still leading the polls. Hes not leading in iowa, but hes leading in the national polls, and i think this is the perfect time for him to be turning in a really good performance. Did he have that look and feel of a frontrunner, do you think . Yeah. Yeah, i think so. And i think that this is and i think the fact that hes been, you know, also so obviously and he took time to point this out you know, the person that donald trump seems to be concerned enough about that he would do the things that he did that led to impeachment, right . So that also sort of builds up his position as the frontrunner by saying, like, look, trump is so concerned about me that he would actually, you know, get himself in this kind of trouble over me. Frank, i know because we were talking about it in makeup, you think that joe biden had a strong debate performance as well. Who else do you think was a winner . I think Amy Klobuchar had a great night. I dont know if it will matter for her but she made the case and repeated it that shes someone who was won elections in the kind of state, in the kind of area that handed trump the presidency three years ago, four years ago. I think she was good with that. I think andrew yang had a good night for andrew yang. But, again, hes so far back, i dont think its going to be candidacy change. Yit only matters so much. It only matters so much if youre outside that top four because that top four has been so distant from the rest and so firmly ensconce. I think the most meaningful night was joe bidens. Hes been a frontrunner almost consistently since he announced his candidacy in april. Yet we in the media have had a tendency to treat him as a hallucinatory frontrunner. Its all going to disappear as soon as you touch it or get too close of it because he has so many gaffes, because so much is based on name recognition. I think its time to accept that joe biden could very well be the nominee, and if you were a person making a conservative bet and putting money on someone, youd probably put it on him. The polls have been fairly consistent. The new cnn poll shows joe biden up at the top, Bernie Sanders doing very strong lly as well. But in the head to head matchups with President Trump, theres been some slippage. Biden is still leading outside the margin of error, sanders barely. Why do you think that is . Also in the poll, the numbers for what people think of the economy are incredibly high, historically high. And also in terms of how they feel the economy is going to be in the future. So people are not just positive about how the economy is doing now, but theyre actually very optimistic about the future. Those two things would always mean that the president s Approval Rating should go up. I would ask why isnt his Approval Rating higher with an economy like that . With an economy like that, you normally would be seeing sort of stratospheric approval numbers and hes certainly not getting that. He shouldnt be at least in these matchups, and its still a pretty tight race. I mean were talking about still within four or five points, even the people who have lost ground against him. Kirsten powers, frank bruni, great to have you here. Have a lovely holiday. You too. Still ahead, how a Mining Company secretly collaborated with a governor to lobby the white house all at the expense of one of the countrys most beautiful and valuable wild habitats. chime shaq magenta . I hate cartridges not magenta not magenta. Im not going back to the store. Magenta cartridges are so. buzzer vo the epson ecotank. No more cartridges. It comes with an incredible amount of ink that can save you a lot of frustration. The epson ecotank. Just fill and chill. Available at. A president who abuses power. And obstructs justice. The impeachment of donald j. Trump. He was supposed to protect our constitution. Not trample on it by asking Foreign Countries to undermine our democracy for his personal political gain. Trump broke his oath to america. Members of the house and senate must now do their constitutional duty. If you agree, sign our petition at need to impeach. Com need to impeach is responsible for the content of this advertising. Skip to the good part with alkaseltzer plus. Now with 25 more concentrated power. Nothing works faster for powerful cold relief. Oh, what a relief it is so fast lets check in with chris to see what hes working on for cuomo prime time at the top of the hour. C squared, what have you got . J. B. , my man. We have some exclusive reporting about the money trail we got some exclusive reporting about the money trail leading from one at least of Rudy Giulianis associates through the ukraine gambit. We have a piece tonight from drew griffin. We have vicky ward with pickup reporting on where parnas got his money, what kind of oligarch, where did he get it. My case on this show is giuliani may not have been a subject of having done something wrong but used by people, which could be just as dangerous. I would be remiss if i did not say i love you and i wish you and your family the best for the holy days. You are a model journalist and a model man. I am proud to call you a friend. Youre a gift every day. Happy holidays. You can unwrap me any time you want, chris. Thank you very much. Ooh, naughty. See you in a few minutes. Exclusive new details in a story weve been following for months, a story of natural beauty, corporate money and the question of political influence. Verizons important to us because we facetime with her grandparents all the time. announcer when you have the best network, you wanna give the best network. Feliz navidad announcer this holiday, you can gift americas most Reliable Network and the latest iphone. I would probably give it to her grandparents so they can take tons of photos. My mom is amazing. If i got her one of these for christmas, shed be freaking out. announcer and now buy the latest iphone and get iphone 11 on us. Plus, get 400 when you switch. With plans starting at just 35. shrieks yeah, exciting. announcer happy holidays from the network that gives you more. The ones that make a truebeen difference in peoples lives. And mikes won them, which is important right this minute, because if he could beat americas biggest gun lobby, helping pass background check laws and defeat nra backed politicians across this country, beat big coal, helping shut down hundreds of polluting plants and beat big tobacco, helping pass laws to save the next generation from addiction. All against big odds you can beat him. Im Mike Bloomberg and i approve this message. Im Mike Bloomberg and i approve this message. I am all about livi g joyfully. Hello. The united explorer card hooks me up. Getting more for getting away. Rewarded going new places and tasting new flavors. Rewarded traveling lighter. Rewarded. Haha, boom getting settled. Rewarded. Learn more at the explorer card dot com. And get. Rewarded its a story that 360 has been investigating and reporting on, the battle over plans to build a copper or gold mines in one of alaskas most pristine settings. Alaskas governor not only has embraced talking points written by the company wanting to build that mine, hes also sent them practically word for word to officials in the Trump Administration. Reporter when the Trump Administrations epa removed the protections on this pristine part of alaska last summer, locals and environmentalists were shocked. The company that wants to build a copper and gold mine here was overjoyed. Documents obtained by cnn reveal the pebble mine company was secretly coaching Alaska Governor mike dunn levys office in how to influence the Trump Administration to make a decision in the companys favor. In email after email pebble provides the Governors Office with ghostwritten letters, talking points for communications with the epa, with the Vice President s office and to a potential investor in the mine. Joel reynolds, with the Natural ResourcesDefense Council says governor dunn leavy essentially became a lobbyist for the mine. These are the type of activities a company typically pays somebody on their staff to do. In this case theyre working directly with the governor and his staff to accomplish the goals of the company. Most striking of all, this april 26th letter sent by the governor to the army corps of engineers, asking the corps to end a Public Comment period on an environmental study. Pebbles staff wrote it first, here is pebbles ghostwritten letter for the governor, right next to the letter the governor actually sent to the army corps. Compared side by side, the highlighted sections show the letters are nearly identical. Reynolds, who represents one of many environmental groups suing to stop the mine, is appalled. Essentially the governor has become a puppet for pebble. The documents include two other companies, letters from the governor that appear to have been copied and pasted from language provided by pebble. Pebble even dictated the talking point for the governors staff to use in a meeting with the Environmental Protection agency. When cnn asked for comment, even their responses were similar, with pebble saying its not unusual for interested parties to suggest language to elected officials and the Governors Office saying it is common practice for an administration to request briefing materials on a specific project. Pebbles communication happened at a crucial time. They were desperate to protect one of the worlds last and largest spawning area. The company was so confident it was going to happen. The day before the governor met with President Trump aboard air force i, it sent the Governors Office this draft press release, which hailed the decision by the Environmental Protection agency in advance, though pebble says it did not receive any information about a pending epa decision. The governor did meet with the president and they did discuss mining and the epa did make an announcement on june 26th, but not entirely to remove the Environmental Protection. And in furious emails, a pebble official tells the governors aide the epa announcements sends the market a screaming message that epa may still kill the project and that pebble cant raise the money it needs. In announcement was worse than doing nothing. Pebble asks for immediate intervention, a president ial tweet or try to get the epa to reverse position, reminding the governors staff in another email, the epas lack of cooperation contradicts everything they were promised last week by the president. The very next day, epa trump appointees reversed course, told its top staff in seattle the withdrawal of protections is a now a done deal, one official told cnn, we were told to get out of the way and just make it happen. A month later the epa made that secret decision official, giving the Mining Company the win it needed. In response alaskas governor, john, didnt answer a single question, only giving us a statement saying he supports mining but the ceo of pebble mine, tom collier, met with us personally to stress two things. First, that he and his company had no advanced knowledge of any decisions made by the epa and, second, that in his view it is fairly normal to have communications with the governor, even to the point of writing draft letters for the governor to edit and sign. John . Common. Is that so . Drew griffin, thank you very much for that. The news continues. Well hand it over to chris for cuomo prime time. Welcome to prime time. We have an exclusive tonight, new intelligence on that arrested giuliani associate tied to an oligarch who is tied to putin. There is a troubling money trail revealed. Another question. Is pelosi right to hold back the articles of impeachment or is it going to back fire on the democrats . Hold on, it aint the holy days yet. Lets get after it. All ri